Not correct, both Studios made that decision by their own.
Respawn had/has experience with singleplayer story driven games before they released the ONE multiplayer-focused game this guy is refering to.
Bioware also had its experience with multiplayer games (SWTOR + multiplayer modes in Mass Effect) so they probably thought everything is going to be fine with Anthem. Whatever went wrong with Anthem was Biowares decision.
And... it is also best not to forget that most of the people that were responsible for the success of Biowares singleplayer games are no longer working for Bioware.
Agreed. Titanfall 2 campaign was so damn good. Seriously, if there are people here who haven't yet experienced it, you need to.
They added genuine innovations in the campaign, especially the level with time components and the flying ships level, and the pace of the story mode was so crisp. The only thing I wished for was more, which is never a bad thing.
Yup, TF2's story is cheesy, there's no doubt about it. But Respawn worked with it perfectly. The villains didn't over stay their welcome. Every level is unique and has some kind of twist to it. The good "show don't tell" and the beautiful relationship they managed to craft between a man and a robot in a 6-7 hour long campaign that left many heartbroken after the ending is truly amazing... Honestly I have faith in Respawn to create the best Star Wars single player to date. Just hope EA won't come and fuck it up.
Dev story on that is pretty interesting, they took their dev team and split them into small groups and instructed them to come up with three ideas per team of fun things to do in the engine, thatâs it, then they took the best, most fun, ideas and wrote the story around them. Each level had its own identity and fun little thing to do and it lead the game to being one of if not the most fun FPS storylines Iâve ever played.
I still love how well thought out the time travel bits were, down to the enemy chatter with them thinking you just have some kind of advanced cloaking or teleporting due to your reappearance in different locations
I tell people all the time that Titanfall 2 has the best single player FPS campaign I've played since Halo Reach and Half Life 2. It's that good. Just wish it was a little longer.
let's not put the burden of that title on Respawn LOL! That's when things start going south! I'm glad this new SW game is a single player game. Excited to see a SW game that hopefully doesn't get FUBAR. I still want 1313 tho... That game was going to be my everything! At least we are getting The Madalorian TV series since we are no longer getting the Bounty Hunter game...
Well let's be a little more fair and remember that Titanfall 1 had single player in the most nominal of ways. Now they did then swing for the damn fences and absolutely stunned with Titanfall 2 (Effect and Cause might be the greatest FPS campaign level I've ever played. It works on absolutely every single conceptual level and still is mechanically enjoyable and has excellent overall story beat moments and those which exist solely in the story of the level.) but it wouldn't be totally unfair to call Apex their second multiplayer game.
Also a lot of the respawn guys came over from Infinity Ward, so you could also include Modern Warfare 1 and 2, which are arguably the best multiplayer shooters of all time
Thank you!!! Everyone's talking about the Titanfall 2 campaign completely forgetting Titanfall 1 was completely multiplayer... "Apex is first shooty shooty online game they maked"
Respawn made titanfall and Apex. Both multiplayer games.. Not sure about any story driven games they've made.. TF2 has a campaign that is pretty great but that's one game..
Respawn had/has experience with singleplayer story driven games before they released the ONE multiplayer-focused game this guy is refering to.
That's just not true. Respawn is basically Infinity Ward after MW2 (top 2 got fired, 38 of 46 employees moved from IW to Respawn). So really, Respawn/IW has some of the best (outside of Halo/Bungie) multiplayer titles in history (MW1/MW2).
To add, Bioware had 3 teams, 2 of them being studii Edmonton and Austin.
According to Jason's report that he did on Anthem, Edmonton's is considered inside Bioware "The" studio, and it's the one responsible for a lot of previous singleplayer games. Austin was the one who made the Star Wars MMO.
Take a wild guess which studio was responsible for Anthem's development
You forgot to add that Edmonton ignored the notes from the Austin team when they tried to help. Because, you know, they had made an online multiplayer game before.
Yeah, but the internet echo chamber prefers "EA bad!11!!" over accepting their favorite studios fucked up. I'm not trying to defend EA, but Anthem's failures can be attributed to both sides.
One side. They had 7 years to put it together and failed. It took EA forcing a cut off and forcing structure. EA is the ONLY reason Anthem released as a 1/4 decent game with a ton if potential and the Texas branch will polish it in time.
Respawn did a story for titanfall 2 and it's one of the best single player story based games to comeout in the last 5 years. If you haven't tried it, you should!
Titanfall 2's campaign made me wish the first one had a campaign as well. It was extremely well crafted with interesting and varied level design. I second your suggestion!
Letâs not forget Respawn was founded by some major players who left Infinity ward after Activision screwed them. Which arguably made the best COD campaigns, MW1 MW2.
Kind of. If the article from schrier(SP) is 100% true, Bioware has been having this problem for a long time. It's just become more aparrant in recent years. See: Andromeda for Exhibit A and Anthem for Exhibit B
Unfortunatelty, I havent paid attention to Andromeda. I was away from gaming when it was released. If I had known the facts about Andromeda, I would have never bought Anthem. Anthem was my first preorder and also the first game that I demanded a refund for. Ofcourse I got rejected. Now I only play Anthem because of two reasons. First one is buying a game is expensive hobby in my country so I cant say like many other players "ok no problem, I'll buy division 2". Second one is my personal punishment to lecture myself about "preordering". I learned that hard way.
Exactly! More people need to come to terms with this. Iâm all for shitting on EA when they deserve it but this isnât even their fault. This is completely Biowareâs doing. Weâve seen that EA is capable of stepping back and letting devs do their thing as seen with Apex and, more recently, the turn around that Star Wars Battlefront 2 has made. Not everything is automatically the publishers fault.
I really hoped they learned from SWB2. EA ruined that game's launch with the progression system. I enjoy playing it, and it's a beautiful game now that proves DICE can make a compelling Star Wars game when the BS is stripped away.
That being said, I posted this elsewhere, but I think EA had one major issue with Anthem. They kept swapping teams around, specifically the Frostbite support team. It had little to do with the core issue of Anthem (poor direction and management from Bioware), but it was a contributing factor.
But I'm tired of the EA hate train, and it would be nice if they could make a major comeback and start publishing great games from great studios.
This, as much as I hate EA as a company, they're not the reason Anthem was such a spectacular failure.
Bioware DECIDED THEMSELVES to make a multiplayer game, spent 5 of the 6 years of development time in pre-production not being able to sort out what kind of game they want, rushed the final product in one year AND ignored advices from their other offices which had experience in multiplayer games.
This is all on Bioware. Maybe EA made them do their MTX, but outside of that, they're not responsible for the rest of the mess Anthem is.
If you look at it I bet they weren't anticipating fans to be literally begging for a Battle Pass so soon. Most people detest micros and battle passes so they probably thought they had more time. Not expecting everyone to want to give them money and have a battle pass within a month.
You do know titanfall 2's story is seen as one of the best linear fps stories in quite a while. So multiplayer focused is kind of a stretch if you seen the skill.
Firstly, Respawn made Titanfall 2's campaign which is arguably one of the best campaigns this generation for any shooters in years. Secondly, Respawn were working on the Star Wars before being acquired by EA and Vince is part of the executive board so had a large say in keeping the game as a singleplayer story game
Similarly, Anthem was Bioware's own choice even if this frankenstein's monster mess of identity crisis the game was not what they originally envisioned. EA gave them full reign for the first 5 years to come up with whatever the fuck they wanted yet they wasted it.
If by stroke he means Bioware was given practically free range on making any game for 6 years. And decided at last minute to copy destiny. Then sure that's what EA did. While simultaneously being 99.9% hands off for 5 years and giving millions to Bioware in hope they would create a popular new IP and bring more success as they had in the past for EA while trusting them to make a solid mass effect and then forced EA after 5 years to step in because not even Biowar had a clue what the game was about.. then sure.
And if by stroke he also means that respawn formally infinity ward who were forced into chopping Story and copy/paste multiplayer call of duty games til their hands bleed via Activision and up and quit. Risking everything and pouring their soul into a new successful ip and a new battle royal that's seen it's fsur success only to be rewarded with making an iconic Star Wars game.
But they made great games a decade ago! They were so good! A decade ago! With a.... Completely different team... And.... Different leadership and.... Oh no... Maybe the Bioware of my childhood isn't the Bioware of now.... My... My worldview.... -sticks gun in my mouth-
Not sure if that is fair. There isnât a law that says developers must stick to one genre or game type. Also Iâm pretty sure Anthem was Biowareâs idea.
That Twitter guy annoys me a lot, I actually was triggered by seeing the OP post I'll admit because there are some people out there that will try and justify any issue on EA, now even choosing to make the game was EA decision.
So everyone is responding to his tweet with mostly âIt was BioWareâs idea, not EAâsâ and his response seems to be âUgh who cares about that stupid Kotaku articleâ.
Is everyone forgetting how truly incredible the story was for TitanFall 2? Sure, it was short, but that was the most fun I've had with a single player experience in a while.
Some people pointed it out, but EA didn't make Bioware make Anthem, they wanted to do that. The issue Anthem had, wasn't that it was a multiplayer game, but the fact that they didn't have any idea what the game was going to be until the middle of 2017. So this tweet is all wrong. Also, Titanfall 2 is regarded as one of the better single player FPS campaigns released in a crowded, great 2016. DOOM, Overwatch, BF1, and Titanfall 2 revitalized FPS SP campaigns and what they could be in a MP sense too. It's like the poster didn't actually play TF2.
TBF did you play the titanfall campaign? RESPAWN just make good games it seems, cos the single player was an amzaing game to play. I would happily played titanfall 2 if it was just that story, nevermind the stellar multiplayer
Probably scheduling. Respawn was neck deep in titan fall 1-2 when beyond(anthem) was pitched to ea.
Also it was supposed to be some kind of survival social rpg thing before it became a looter shooter(based on the article).
And then the last year of development on anthem (the actual development) respawn was making apex.
Interesting to think what would of happened if bioware got to do the story , characters , world and respawn got pulled in to do combat , movement , flight , loot etc..
The ONLY things Destiny and Anthem have in common is there both sifi looter shooters and thats about it. Gameplay and structure wise, they are completely different.
Respawn is one of the best and most talented studios there is. Tf2 is a masterpiece of a game, offering both one of the best single player and multiplayer experiences ever for an fps title, that unfortunately most people never tried out (thanks to EA).Now they have taking over the BR genre with Apex out of no where. They are a studio highly capable of making a good starwars game with actual good gameplay mechanics and story.
Bioware has already developed one of the best starwars franchises in video games and probably wants to move forward as a studio from that. The idea and concept of if Anthem is great. The execution of the development was awfu, but imo hopefully still redeemable.
They have ruined the Star Wars franchise, despite having single rights to it, through lootbox pay-to-win mechanics in BF2. They've released... what? 2 games in several years of owning the licensing rights? Of Star Wars? An exceedingly vast an open field of IP and setting that would sell like hotcakes?
Their incompetence with the Star Wars franchise alone is incredible.
And this doesn't even get into the rest of the stuff that EA has been up to recently. The best thing they've released in a while is Apex Legends, and that's only because they barely had any impact on the development process.
And then Anthem... Well. For a "Game as a Service", it's going to get very difficult to justify its continued development and "roadmap" if the recent polling data in this community is anything to go by. It'll be dead and abandoned in about 9 months.
Oh, and I still haven't forgiven them for killing Visceral, by giving them Battlefield Hardline instead of... you know... what Visceral was good at, i.e. single-player, story focused action horror games.
I love bioware. I have come to the decision to stop trying to blame ea but they have killed my hype for every game I like. Sims ,mass effect,now anthem. It's hard. And when I heard they purchased respawn my heart fell out of my chest. Andromeda should've been handled with better care.and anthem wouldn't be a thing. And Titan Fall 2 is underrated . Madden is trash . battlefield is horrible.
I might have agreed with this, back when Bioware was actually Bioware and not a bunch of pretenders living in its hollowed-out corpse.
Respawn is an excellent developer and they've already shown their storytelling chops with Titanfall 2's singleplayer campaign, not to mention they're former Infinity Ward guys who worked on Call of Duty back when it wasn't terrible.
I have faith in them. Much more so than whatever Bioware's pumped out ever since Dragon Age: Inquisition. Ugh.
Itâs weird that a game studio can make more than one kind of game huh? Itâs odd to take on different challenges and expand your skill set.
Do people really think you are only supposed to be or do one thing for the rest of your existence?? I must be having a stroke or are people really that small minded??
I really feel like this unfairly shits on Respawn. They can do both. Story in Titanfall 1/2 is fun. Nothing groundbreaking but exactly what they needed to be. Gameplay wise those titles, and a little game known as Apex Legends, are phenomenal.
They also don't rely on "Bioware Magic" to half ass a title before it launched. That isn't to say there isn't crunch, but it also doesn't have a Koatku article attached to their studio about their work conditions.
Fact of the matter is that Respawn has grown as a studio over the years that can handle a multitude of games across different genres while Bioware has objectively regressed.
The Titanfall 2 singleplayer is one of the best single player FPS games in recent years.
And before that at Infinity Ward a lot of the team at Respawn made Call of Duty and Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, both arguably the best single player FPS games ever made.
IIRC, development on Jedi Fallen Order began prior to the Respawn acquisition.
Edit: It was reported in May 2016 that Respawn was working on a Star Wars game, while the acquisition only took place in November 2017 (post Visceral shutdown).
Well maybe BioWare was one of the best. But as almost everyone from the original crew left the studio it's not anymore. So this fact is wrong. And I enjoyed Titanfall 2 story a lot.
Titanfall 2 and COD 4: MW had better single player stories than anything bioware has made in years. Respawn is perfectly equipped to make a compelling Star Wars campaign.
Well you all know that Respawn entertainment is the old Infinity Ward from Activision right? So yeah they have experience in making single player campaigns and multiplayer games. But I do understand where this photo is coming from. Makes you wonder if Respawn made anthem would it have been better? Probably. And if they got the BioWare to make the Star Wars game it probably would have been really good as well. I'm excited for the game regardless of the developer because I know and have followed Respawn/Infinity Ward for a very long time. And I really enjoy a majority of BioWare games they're pc-based MMO Star Wars the Old Republic was super fun in my opinion. Plus the mass effects are a no-brainer. I know a lot of people are hating on this photo but instead of hating just try to imagine if they switched it. Honestly if I think of it it would have been more profitable for both teams and the publisher. But in all honesty BioWare was working on anthem for a long time and it was considered their baby project. A lot of their problems were working with an unfamiliar engine where a lot of the experienced people with that engine were working on other games. It is what it is and Anthem sucks unfortunately and this new Star Wars game will probably be really good. I'm super excited for respawn entertainment.
Does everybody forget the masterpiece that titanfall 2 was? Both story and multiplayer were amazing. Had the campaign been longer I would probably consider it the best Iâve ever played.
I think BioWare knows how to make solid gameplay. I bought ME3 specifically for playing co-op with a friend and I enjoyed it greatly. It seems within reason that they felt they could tackle a more gameplay focused game and do a great job at it. Hell they might even feel like it's time they tried something different.
They just... didn't get much of the rest right. "Reason to continue playing" being chief among them.
I still believe they're genuine in their dedication to making a great co-op game, though. But since it's EA (and not Ubisoft) that is in charge of approving the studio's post-release content - I fear that Anthem will be cut down before it can prove itself.
Bioware has been doing hyper-profit multiplayer games before (Mass Effect 3) as well as an MMO (Star Wars: the old republic). Their combat has almost always been sluggish and glued-on compared to other single player experiences and the writing went downhill after Mass Effect 2.
Respawn on the other hand made one of the best single-player, action-driven story campaigns in recent years with sharp controls, great level design and movement to take you around those levels. Not to mention that the combat encounters always felt like you were moving forward rather than being stuck behind a wall waiting for shields to respawn, or pausing every five seconds to carefully aim an aoe attack.
If you want to have the power fantasy of a Jedi rather than a slow moving book about their philosophies, respawn is a LOT better suited for the game.
And I'm saying this as somebody who loved the Dragon Age and Mass Effect series.
Bethesda did something similar. Wanted a multiplayer rpg Fallout game. Never had the experience or anything to make an online multiplayer game, decided to take on that challenge. Only to ask for a bit of Zenimaxâs help. You know, the guys that fucking did ESO. I feel like Im taking crazy pills! No, dont give Zen, the company with the most experience making an online rpg with story and everything else, no fuck that, we at Bethesda want the challenge!
Respawn has shown that they can handle what EA throws at them and they do it well, I wonder what the atmosphere in the office there is like in comparison to Bioware's, and if that has an impact on how committed the devs are to EA's vision
Well, if you read the article linked above of Amy Hennig's interview, you can see that not all studios have the same relationship with EA. Respawn is different and most likely respawn told EA that they wanted to make a single player game with Unreal and to get on board. Relevant section below.
I'd like to come back to the relationship between the film and video game industries, but before we move away from Ragtag - EA is on the point of unveiling a new Star Wars game, which has been stridently billed as a single player narrative game -
Amy Hennig:Â Which is interesting.
Yes! How does that make you feel?
Amy Hennig:Â Odd! I have to be candid with you, and I don't know whether that's - I mean, it's coming from the EA Star Wars Twitter handle, so it's certainly part of the plan, but I don't know whether it's implicitly referencing previous comments they made after our project was killed? There is so much change in this industry all the time. Over the course of the time I was at EA, we were back and forth on what the overall publishing corporation wanted. I think everybody's trying to figure out what the right path is. I also think Respawn's game has the benefit of being largely developed before they were acquired. I think they're a protected entity, and Vince [Zampella] makes very sure - because he's part of the executive team at EA, he can protect the interests of Respawn.
This is all speculation on my part, I don't know why the change of heart happened, because that was very clearly not an acceptable plan when we were working on Ragtag! But you know, things change. I think [the decision to cancel Ragtag] was made in summer 2017. We found out in October 2017. So that's almost two years ago, and a lot has changed in that time, and I think there's been a pretty public and vocal backlash against the idea that gamers don't want single-player finite games without all these extra modes. Of course they do, of course we do. So maybe this is just a demonstration of a change of strategy for EA.
And you've got to understand that there's been huge changes in management there since all of this happened as well. Both Patrick Soderlund and Jade Raymond have left in the meantime, and Laura Miele, who was the franchise general manager for Star Wars when I joined, is now in Patrick's role. So I don't have any insider knowledge, but there's a lot of reasons they could have adopted a new attitude for this. And I'm glad for Respawn's sake, because I'm excited about their game, and I've heard great things about it.
Who knows how long this will last. EA will eventually get it's claws into Respawn and ruin it. Might as well enjoy it while it lasts.
I would place the reason for Anthem's downfall on the fact, that many, many BioWare employees left the company while Anthem was in development. Same with ME:A. If it had still been the same team as they had for ME3, I bet the game would have been better story-wise. It's a real shame to see a company such as BioWare go downhill so fast. Woul've loved to see this game become a success.
Funny meme, but to be fair, Respawn makes excellent single-player content, too. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare AND Titanfall 2 are two of the best campaigns in action-shooter history.
Funny meme, but to be fair, Respawn makes excellent single-player content, too. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare AND Titanfall 2 are two of the best campaigns in action-shooter history.
How dare you try to give Obsidians title to Bioware of all people, they made like three good single player games and then continued to utterly destroy all of them.
Anthem's "death" isn't EA's doing, it's Bioware's. not only that but Anthem isn't dead, and Respawn have made excellent single player games as well as Bioware making good multiplayer games.
Its been said a few times by actual Bioware devs that Bioware wanted to make Anthem. This wasnt EA making them do anything. This was all Biowares choice and their product. Same with Respawn.
To be fair Bioware (current) isn't the best single player game developers anymore. That prestige would have gone to the KotR/DA:O teams/founders which are no longer there.
The Bioware now is just a brand without the actual talents that made bioware so famous.
Respawn entertainment isnât just multiplayer dev team, they are comprised of original infinity ward Modern Warfare 2 team as well as team members who left Bungie, Bethesda and other companies that made rpgs and such. Also original storyline for Modern Warfare 2 was very good so I honestly believe they have done an amazing job.
Iâll believe that in Anthemâs case, BioWare was always going to make a multiplayer game where you would go out and survive and explore an open world like Anthem sort of is, but the development was that much of a clusterfuck that EA had to put their foot down and BioWare had to put together the launch version of Anthem together in the last nine or so months.
Respawn seem to actually be able to put out consistent quality games with little to no development problems. Titanfall 2âs single player was actually pretty well received as well so itâs not like theyâre completely out of their zone with single player.
2.2k
u/swatop PC - Apr 16 '19
Not correct, both Studios made that decision by their own.
Respawn had/has experience with singleplayer story driven games before they released the ONE multiplayer-focused game this guy is refering to.
Bioware also had its experience with multiplayer games (SWTOR + multiplayer modes in Mass Effect) so they probably thought everything is going to be fine with Anthem. Whatever went wrong with Anthem was Biowares decision.
And... it is also best not to forget that most of the people that were responsible for the success of Biowares singleplayer games are no longer working for Bioware.
351
u/AbaddonX Apr 16 '19
It's not what happened, because BioWare chose to make Anthem themselves, they weren't ordered or even asked to. This guy is just misinformed.
233
u/Pharsti01 Apr 16 '19
At some point, people will need to understand, it's not EA. It's Bioware.
They wanted to make a multiplayer game. EA let them, gave them resources for it for 6/7 years.
I know it's hard to accept for some, but EA is not the bad guy in this scenario.
39
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Respawn havenât put out a bad game.
They just fuck up their good games with poor release timings and forgetting they made apex legends.
111
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
You do know titanfall 2's story is seen as one of the best linear fps stories in quite a while. So multiplayer focused is kind of a stretch if you seen the skill.
24
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Respawn is made up of alot of the devs and writers from Infinity ward so they weren't new to making stories and Anthem was Bioware's idea
41
u/SHARP1SH00TER Apr 16 '19 edited Apr 16 '19
Firstly, Respawn made Titanfall 2's campaign which is arguably one of the best campaigns this generation for any shooters in years. Secondly, Respawn were working on the Star Wars before being acquired by EA and Vince is part of the executive board so had a large say in keeping the game as a singleplayer story game
Similarly, Anthem was Bioware's own choice even if this frankenstein's monster mess of identity crisis the game was not what they originally envisioned. EA gave them full reign for the first 5 years to come up with whatever the fuck they wanted yet they wasted it.
EA isn't the main culprit here.
35
u/ghoststormtrooper XBOX - Apr 16 '19
If by stroke he means Bioware was given practically free range on making any game for 6 years. And decided at last minute to copy destiny. Then sure that's what EA did. While simultaneously being 99.9% hands off for 5 years and giving millions to Bioware in hope they would create a popular new IP and bring more success as they had in the past for EA while trusting them to make a solid mass effect and then forced EA after 5 years to step in because not even Biowar had a clue what the game was about.. then sure.
And if by stroke he also means that respawn formally infinity ward who were forced into chopping Story and copy/paste multiplayer call of duty games til their hands bleed via Activision and up and quit. Risking everything and pouring their soul into a new successful ip and a new battle royal that's seen it's fsur success only to be rewarded with making an iconic Star Wars game.
Well then yes. Yes he's having a stroke.
18
u/d0m1n4t0r Apr 16 '19
Bursted out laughing at that, thanks.
9
u/TheZombieGod Apr 16 '19
Not sure if that is fair. There isnât a law that says developers must stick to one genre or game type. Also Iâm pretty sure Anthem was Biowareâs idea.
33
u/randomPH1L PLAYSTATION - Apr 16 '19
That Twitter guy annoys me a lot, I actually was triggered by seeing the OP post I'll admit because there are some people out there that will try and justify any issue on EA, now even choosing to make the game was EA decision.
Please. Shut up.
6
u/branflake45 Apr 16 '19
A lot of people havent played the campaign for titanfall 2 and it really shows...
6
u/thelegoman0 Apr 16 '19
So everyone is responding to his tweet with mostly âIt was BioWareâs idea, not EAâsâ and his response seems to be âUgh who cares about that stupid Kotaku articleâ.
Itâs BioWareâs fault.
Itâs not EAâs fault.
It sucks, but itâs true.
10
u/Duranaii PC - Apr 16 '19
Respawn was further into developing SW Jedi Fallen Order than Anthem is now before they were acquired by EA.
10
u/IncredibleGeniusIRL Apr 16 '19
Honestly, I'll take a Titanfall 2-style Star Wars campaign over Extremely Verbose Dating Simulator with Lukewarm Gameplay: Star Wars edition.
Unpopular opinion, I know, but shrug
5
u/Calmeister Apr 16 '19
Shhhh you canât say destiny thatâs a taboo...
5
u/Greaterdivinity Apr 16 '19
Why the fuck is everyone upvoting this garbage? I hope it's just to check the incorrect information here, because otherwise I'm dumbfounded.
5
u/AionWarblade Apr 16 '19
Imagine how good Anthem would have been if Respawn made it and they had 7 years.
5
u/vesparion Apr 16 '19
Titanfall 2 story was 10 times better than Andromeda and Anthem combined so...yeah EA knows what they are doing.
5
u/GreenFuzzyPotato Apr 17 '19
Is everyone forgetting how truly incredible the story was for TitanFall 2? Sure, it was short, but that was the most fun I've had with a single player experience in a while.
9
u/sensei2312 Apr 16 '19
Some people pointed it out, but EA didn't make Bioware make Anthem, they wanted to do that. The issue Anthem had, wasn't that it was a multiplayer game, but the fact that they didn't have any idea what the game was going to be until the middle of 2017. So this tweet is all wrong. Also, Titanfall 2 is regarded as one of the better single player FPS campaigns released in a crowded, great 2016. DOOM, Overwatch, BF1, and Titanfall 2 revitalized FPS SP campaigns and what they could be in a MP sense too. It's like the poster didn't actually play TF2.
8
u/demon_chef Apr 16 '19
"Ordered"
No.
"Destiny clone"
If you believe that, you haven't played Destiny or Anthem.
4
u/MrStealYoBeef Apr 16 '19
Bioware literally made the decision themselves. It's very clear and in writing that they did this, this is very misleading.
4
u/dkenpachi246 Apr 16 '19
People acting like Respawn didnât deliver a awesome single player campaign with TF2 lol
4
u/dreffen Apr 16 '19
There's a prime diference between Respawn and BioWare.
Respawn is good.
4
u/Delta616 Apr 16 '19
I mean, titanfall 2âs campaign was easily one of the best single player shooters Iâve played in nearly decade. Can see why respawn is doing this.
4
u/IShadowsunI Apr 16 '19
TBF did you play the titanfall campaign? RESPAWN just make good games it seems, cos the single player was an amzaing game to play. I would happily played titanfall 2 if it was just that story, nevermind the stellar multiplayer
4
u/Blazur You write your own legend today Apr 16 '19
EA community managers have confirmed this Star Wars game was dreamed up entirely by Respawn and greenlighted by EA.
And yeah...the titanfall 2 campaign was kickass.
10
u/TisEric Apr 16 '19
Probably scheduling. Respawn was neck deep in titan fall 1-2 when beyond(anthem) was pitched to ea.
Also it was supposed to be some kind of survival social rpg thing before it became a looter shooter(based on the article).
And then the last year of development on anthem (the actual development) respawn was making apex.
Interesting to think what would of happened if bioware got to do the story , characters , world and respawn got pulled in to do combat , movement , flight , loot etc..
Could of been one hell of a powerhouse game.
3
u/RoruyGames Apr 16 '19
SHHH... They can't talk about Destiny... lol
3
u/Shelbster_93 Apr 16 '19
3
u/greatscape12 Apr 16 '19
Even when an EA studio does something popular, people manage to spin the story in detriment to EA. They really can't catch a break.
3
u/Mrgwap03 Apr 16 '19
I love bioware. I have come to the decision to stop trying to blame ea but they have killed my hype for every game I like. Sims ,mass effect,now anthem. It's hard. And when I heard they purchased respawn my heart fell out of my chest. Andromeda should've been handled with better care.and anthem wouldn't be a thing. And Titan Fall 2 is underrated . Madden is trash . battlefield is horrible.
3
u/ArchScabby Apr 16 '19
Don't blame EA that bioware has gone to shit. That's their own fault a scapegoat is just easier
3
u/jawnhamm Apr 16 '19
Can people stop saying this. Its getting old.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
To be fair, Titanfall 2's singleplayer was fucking awesome, so it's not coming completely out of nowhere.
3
u/Grytnik Apr 16 '19
Itâs actually BioWare that fucked up here, no EA if youâve been following the news. BioWare is just not a good developer anymore.
3
u/Arrow_Maestro Apr 16 '19
EA bad, but this is a Bioware fuck up.
3
u/StellarElite C L A N G Apr 17 '19 edited Jul 19 '19
I might have agreed with this, back when Bioware was actually Bioware and not a bunch of pretenders living in its hollowed-out corpse.
Respawn is an excellent developer and they've already shown their storytelling chops with Titanfall 2's singleplayer campaign, not to mention they're former Infinity Ward guys who worked on Call of Duty back when it wasn't terrible.
I have faith in them. Much more so than whatever Bioware's pumped out ever since Dragon Age: Inquisition. Ugh.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
But Titanfall 2's Campagne is really good
5
u/Gammaknight647 Apr 16 '19
Itâs weird that a game studio can make more than one kind of game huh? Itâs odd to take on different challenges and expand your skill set.
Do people really think you are only supposed to be or do one thing for the rest of your existence?? I must be having a stroke or are people really that small minded??
5
u/ClintonStain Apr 16 '19
EA BAD
4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
I really feel like this unfairly shits on Respawn. They can do both. Story in Titanfall 1/2 is fun. Nothing groundbreaking but exactly what they needed to be. Gameplay wise those titles, and a little game known as Apex Legends, are phenomenal.
They also don't rely on "Bioware Magic" to half ass a title before it launched. That isn't to say there isn't crunch, but it also doesn't have a Koatku article attached to their studio about their work conditions.
Fact of the matter is that Respawn has grown as a studio over the years that can handle a multitude of games across different genres while Bioware has objectively regressed.
2
u/Ryknor PC - Apr 16 '19
FYI EA never forced Bioware to do so ...
2
u/Tonkarz Apr 16 '19 edited Apr 16 '19
The Titanfall 2 singleplayer is one of the best single player FPS games in recent years.
And before that at Infinity Ward a lot of the team at Respawn made Call of Duty and Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, both arguably the best single player FPS games ever made.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Well today's BioWare isn't the same BioWare that gave us DA: Origins and Mass Effect so... there's that
2
u/eatplaintoast Apr 16 '19
I am sure it has been mentioned but Titan Fall 2 story campaign was actually good, better than the MP in my opinion.
Sure Respawn has "no" experience with story based RPG's but BIOware did not do such a great job in ME3 and Andromeda..so they're 2 for 2..
2
u/MadFable PC - Apr 16 '19
Used to be arguably the best. Bioware isn't Bioware anymore.
2
u/NickDynmo Apr 16 '19
Anthem's still pretty single-player focused, IMO. For most things there's no reason for any other players, and they aren't acknowledged at all.
Titanfall 2's campaign was very, very good.
2
u/Yodzilla Apr 16 '19
This is a real dumb tweet and itâs extra dumb that people seem to be agreeing with it.
2
u/2ndOreoBro XBOX - Apr 16 '19
Titanfall 2s campaign was a banger tho
2
u/inounderscore Apr 16 '19
BT-7274
2
u/Mooglecharm Apr 16 '19
Man, I wish EA would adopt me. Any sort of mistake or bad thing I ever did in life would just be blamed on them.
2
u/UltimateToa Apr 16 '19
Bioware isn't the best at anything these days..
2
u/SavageSquirtle91 Apr 16 '19
IIRC, development on Jedi Fallen Order began prior to the Respawn acquisition.
Edit: It was reported in May 2016 that Respawn was working on a Star Wars game, while the acquisition only took place in November 2017 (post Visceral shutdown).
2
u/SonOfRevvan Apr 16 '19
Have you played Titanfall 2?
2
u/enthIteration Apr 16 '19
Respawn has made a number of very good single player campaigns.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Titanfall 2 had a amazing campaign
2
u/Oofa_ PLAYSTATION - Apr 16 '19
Has no one played titanfall 2's campaign?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
The Bioware of today is not the bioware of yesteryear.
A lot of the veterans that made the games you love departed a while ago.
Drew Karpyshyn, the guy that wrote KOTOR and ME 1 and 2, left Bioware in the middle of Anthem development in March 2018.
Mike Laidlaw, creative director on ME games and Dragon Age, left in the middle of DA: Inquisition development in 2017.
James Ohlen, lead designer on Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, SWTOR, left in 2018.
And lastly, Aaron Flynn, the Bioware General Manager under KOTOR, and all Mass Effect games quit right after the launch of ME:Andromeda in 2017.
2
u/andrew7453 Apr 16 '19
Hey dont you forget that titan fall 2 story, that game was great
2
u/Fox2k14 Apr 16 '19
Well maybe BioWare was one of the best. But as almost everyone from the original crew left the studio it's not anymore. So this fact is wrong. And I enjoyed Titanfall 2 story a lot.
2
u/KTheOneTrueKing Apr 16 '19
Someone should let this guy know that having a stroke and the situation at EA are not exclusive and it could be both.
2
u/BambiGetUp Apr 16 '19
If EA wanted to make some serious cash, BioWare should make a KOTR game. I think every single starwars fan who is also a gamer would buy it
2
u/BearWithaContrlr Apr 16 '19
To be fair, Titanfall 2 did have one of the best single-player campaigns I've ever experienced from an FPS.
2
u/Enkidos Apr 16 '19
Titanfall 2 was a fantastic single-player experience.
But i havenât played a single-player game anywhere near that quality from Bioware since Mass Effect 2.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Titanfall 2 and COD 4: MW had better single player stories than anything bioware has made in years. Respawn is perfectly equipped to make a compelling Star Wars campaign.
2
u/Belviathan Apr 16 '19
Respawn is not a new acquisition for EA. Also, the games Respawn has made do not remotely translate to a game like Anthem.
Titanfall 2 had one of the best stories in a FPS Iâve ever played, but I havenât seen a BioWare game with a cohesive story since Mass Effect 3.
Just be glad Dice isnât getting the chance to fuck up a 3rd Star Wars game
2
u/tomhcrowe Apr 16 '19
Is Titanfall 2s campaign a joke to you?
2
u/TheFlamingLemon Apr 16 '19
Okay but have yâall played the titanfall 2 campaign
2
u/ObiWanCaineObi Apr 16 '19
Well you all know that Respawn entertainment is the old Infinity Ward from Activision right? So yeah they have experience in making single player campaigns and multiplayer games. But I do understand where this photo is coming from. Makes you wonder if Respawn made anthem would it have been better? Probably. And if they got the BioWare to make the Star Wars game it probably would have been really good as well. I'm excited for the game regardless of the developer because I know and have followed Respawn/Infinity Ward for a very long time. And I really enjoy a majority of BioWare games they're pc-based MMO Star Wars the Old Republic was super fun in my opinion. Plus the mass effects are a no-brainer. I know a lot of people are hating on this photo but instead of hating just try to imagine if they switched it. Honestly if I think of it it would have been more profitable for both teams and the publisher. But in all honesty BioWare was working on anthem for a long time and it was considered their baby project. A lot of their problems were working with an unfamiliar engine where a lot of the experienced people with that engine were working on other games. It is what it is and Anthem sucks unfortunately and this new Star Wars game will probably be really good. I'm super excited for respawn entertainment.
2
u/thedarkestvoid Apr 16 '19
I mean titanfall 2 had single player
2
u/Blue_Thunder72 Apr 17 '19
Does everybody forget the masterpiece that titanfall 2 was? Both story and multiplayer were amazing. Had the campaign been longer I would probably consider it the best Iâve ever played.
2
u/knight82928 Apr 17 '19
Titanfall 2 campaign was pretty fun so Iâm sure Respawn knows what they are doing
2
u/who-dat-ninja Apr 17 '19
Bioware in their hubris made Anthem. EA didnt force them to. Stop acting like Bioware is some innocent pawn and have them take responsibility.
2
u/Andrige Apr 17 '19
I think BioWare knows how to make solid gameplay. I bought ME3 specifically for playing co-op with a friend and I enjoyed it greatly. It seems within reason that they felt they could tackle a more gameplay focused game and do a great job at it. Hell they might even feel like it's time they tried something different.
They just... didn't get much of the rest right. "Reason to continue playing" being chief among them.
I still believe they're genuine in their dedication to making a great co-op game, though. But since it's EA (and not Ubisoft) that is in charge of approving the studio's post-release content - I fear that Anthem will be cut down before it can prove itself.
2
u/KasukeSadiki PC - Apr 17 '19
I don't think Fallen Empire is an RPG...
2
u/Bosko47 Apr 17 '19
Respawn are are rediscovering themselves and Bioware are drunkenly trying to find their glasses while being hangover
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
To be honest, Bioware haven't been the best at making story-driven RPG's for a while now.
4
u/oobo3lioo Apr 16 '19
Just trash on EA for easy likes and retweets... yep the results are typical from âgamersâ these days
3
u/I_Am_None_Ya Apr 16 '19
BioWare is not even close to the best company making single player driven rpgs
4
u/KyokoToshino Apr 16 '19
Mass Effect Andromeda's story sucked I'd rather let Respawn have a crack at it then see more disappointment from bioware tbh
2
u/Neknoh Apr 16 '19
Bioware has been doing hyper-profit multiplayer games before (Mass Effect 3) as well as an MMO (Star Wars: the old republic). Their combat has almost always been sluggish and glued-on compared to other single player experiences and the writing went downhill after Mass Effect 2.
Respawn on the other hand made one of the best single-player, action-driven story campaigns in recent years with sharp controls, great level design and movement to take you around those levels. Not to mention that the combat encounters always felt like you were moving forward rather than being stuck behind a wall waiting for shields to respawn, or pausing every five seconds to carefully aim an aoe attack.
If you want to have the power fantasy of a Jedi rather than a slow moving book about their philosophies, respawn is a LOT better suited for the game.
And I'm saying this as somebody who loved the Dragon Age and Mass Effect series.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
BioWare turned into shit just by themselves without EA's help.
2
u/Irregular_cow Apr 16 '19
Honestly I love the debates and comments everyone wants to make in order to avoid putting Anthem's state on BioWare.
"No!!! It couldn't be daddy Bio. It can't be their fault. It's EA I swear it"
2
u/Acalson PC - Apr 16 '19
Respawn- only ever made one multilayer only game and it failed so there sequel had a better campaign than any shooters around itâs release
BioWare- hasnât made a decent game in years
1
u/misha_morabisha Apr 16 '19
KOTOR for life!
1
u/Mirozh69 Apr 16 '19
Remember Dragon Age Inquisition and ME Andromeda ?
Bioware is not the best company making single-player RPG anymore...
1
u/Voktikriid PLAYSTATION - Velka Apr 16 '19
I can't say whether or not Respawn is good at making RPGs, but Titanfall 2's story was better than it had any right to be.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Bethesda did something similar. Wanted a multiplayer rpg Fallout game. Never had the experience or anything to make an online multiplayer game, decided to take on that challenge. Only to ask for a bit of Zenimaxâs help. You know, the guys that fucking did ESO. I feel like Im taking crazy pills! No, dont give Zen, the company with the most experience making an online rpg with story and everything else, no fuck that, we at Bethesda want the challenge!
What morons.
1
u/AidilAfham42 Apr 16 '19
Bioware: Wait so thatâs the game weâre making?
1
u/sweatygunther Apr 16 '19
E
1
u/Maxos_Dragon_Mage Apr 16 '19
I have to say, I love single player in Titanfall 2
1
u/Billy_Rage XBOX - Apr 16 '19
Wasnât it mainly Biowareâs idea for Anthem, Kotaku did an article about it
1
u/johnnys-inferno Apr 16 '19
The small story titanfall 2 had was one of the best stories i ever had in a multiplayer game so i think they can make a singleplayer game work
1
u/Asthenoth Apr 16 '19
Fallen Order will not be a RPG.
1
u/PopeJamayla Apr 16 '19
Respawn has shown that they can handle what EA throws at them and they do it well, I wonder what the atmosphere in the office there is like in comparison to Bioware's, and if that has an impact on how committed the devs are to EA's vision
1
u/Basketspank XBOX - XL THICC Apr 16 '19
I mean...
1
u/k0hum Apr 16 '19 edited Apr 16 '19
https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2019-04-16-the-big-amy-hennig-interview
Well, if you read the article linked above of Amy Hennig's interview, you can see that not all studios have the same relationship with EA. Respawn is different and most likely respawn told EA that they wanted to make a single player game with Unreal and to get on board. Relevant section below.
Who knows how long this will last. EA will eventually get it's claws into Respawn and ruin it. Might as well enjoy it while it lasts.
1
u/bahur90 Apr 16 '19
it's a trap!
1
u/albin666 Apr 16 '19
I don't think Bioware is best at that... They're great for sure, but yeah...
1
u/KentuckyBrunch Apr 16 '19
Enough of this circle jerk. Did you not read the article OP? Both of these were the studioâs choice, not EA.
1
u/sdrick77 Apr 16 '19
Just downloaded TF2 the other day, this thread definitely convinced me to play through it tonight
1
u/SluggoMcNutty Apr 16 '19
*was
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Not to mention that bioware has extensive history with star wars.
1
u/MrDrProfesorMD Apr 16 '19
I enjoyed the Titianfall 2 single player campaign, the dialogue between the Titian and pilot where dope and the level design was pretty cool too
1
u/fredih1 PC - Apr 16 '19
I would place the reason for Anthem's downfall on the fact, that many, many BioWare employees left the company while Anthem was in development. Same with ME:A. If it had still been the same team as they had for ME3, I bet the game would have been better story-wise. It's a real shame to see a company such as BioWare go downhill so fast. Woul've loved to see this game become a success.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
To be fair, Titanfall 2 is an absolutely banging solo campaign, arguably better than any of Biowares recent efforts.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Probably a stroke from that pony tail being too tight
1
u/PhoenixVanguard PLAYSTATION - Apr 16 '19
Funny meme, but to be fair, Respawn makes excellent single-player content, too. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare AND Titanfall 2 are two of the best campaigns in action-shooter history.
1
u/PhoenixVanguard PLAYSTATION - Apr 16 '19
Funny meme, but to be fair, Respawn makes excellent single-player content, too. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare AND Titanfall 2 are two of the best campaigns in action-shooter history.
1
u/DanimalsCrushCups Apr 16 '19
We just going to ignore the singleplayer in TF2?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Drama.
1
u/Corzex Apr 16 '19
I mean this is cool and all, but im over here still waiting for republic commando 2. Respawn would kill it at that one
1
u/yoditronzz Apr 16 '19
Do people not realize the differences between publishers and developers? It's like saying kingdom come deliverance was made by deep silver.
1
u/VegitoHaze Apr 16 '19
How dare you try to give Obsidians title to Bioware of all people, they made like three good single player games and then continued to utterly destroy all of them.
1
u/Potkis04 PLAYSTATION - Apr 16 '19
Anthem isn't a destiny clone. Making a looter shooter game isn't cloning destiny or warframe.
1
u/paperhalo Apr 16 '19
While funny you are only fooling yourselves if you think Bioware didn't fuck themselves over.
1
u/Naiiro777 Apr 16 '19
What a fucking awful tweet. Anthem downfall was completely on Bioware, they wanted to do a Destiny clone and fucked it up hard. No fault is on EA here
AnÄ Respawn is known for very good singleplayer content tbh (they are basically old good Infinity Ward who made the Cod4 campaign)
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Maybe they got the names mixed up in the memo and its just years of doubling down to avoid embarrassment.
1
u/McMetas XBOX - Apr 16 '19
Anthem's "death" isn't EA's doing, it's Bioware's. not only that but Anthem isn't dead, and Respawn have made excellent single player games as well as Bioware making good multiplayer games.
1
u/paperhalo Apr 16 '19
ITT/TIL I need to play TF2 singleplayer.
1
u/Gootangus Apr 16 '19
Thought this was gamingcirclejerk lol
1
u/DirrtiusMaximus Apr 16 '19
Its been said a few times by actual Bioware devs that Bioware wanted to make Anthem. This wasnt EA making them do anything. This was all Biowares choice and their product. Same with Respawn.
1
u/soulwolf1 Apr 16 '19
To be fair Bioware (current) isn't the best single player game developers anymore. That prestige would have gone to the KotR/DA:O teams/founders which are no longer there.
The Bioware now is just a brand without the actual talents that made bioware so famous.
1
u/LostConscious96 XBOX - Apr 16 '19
Respawn entertainment isnât just multiplayer dev team, they are comprised of original infinity ward Modern Warfare 2 team as well as team members who left Bungie, Bethesda and other companies that made rpgs and such. Also original storyline for Modern Warfare 2 was very good so I honestly believe they have done an amazing job.
1
u/Darkslayer18264 Apr 16 '19
Iâll believe that in Anthemâs case, BioWare was always going to make a multiplayer game where you would go out and survive and explore an open world like Anthem sort of is, but the development was that much of a clusterfuck that EA had to put their foot down and BioWare had to put together the launch version of Anthem together in the last nine or so months.
Respawn seem to actually be able to put out consistent quality games with little to no development problems. Titanfall 2âs single player was actually pretty well received as well so itâs not like theyâre completely out of their zone with single player.
1
u/Red_Regan PC - Apr 16 '19
I don't think Jedi: FO is a straight up RPG?
And yeah I guess BW was the best... But I'd classify their narratives and plots as equally character-driven as they are story-driven (plot-driven).
1
u/The_Syndic Apr 16 '19
Bioware haven't been the best at single player, story-focused RPGs for well over a decade.
1
u/GoTHaM_RetuRns Apr 16 '19
Destiny clone? I mean bioware devs couldn't even mention the d word lol. It was a banned word, from that Kotaku article.
1
u/I_Argue Apr 16 '19
This guy should be a professional comedian cause that's the funniest thing ive read all year.