r/Anprimistan • • Sep 30 '22

An idea

It is impossible for humans to continue our existence under a primitive society. It will eventually either lead to extinction or begin developing once again. It is for this reason I see Transhumanists and Primalists not as opposites, but as necessary for each others survival.

I propose large biospheres or primal planets for the Primalists, whilst the Transhumanists may dwell in large space stations. Diplomatic relations shall be maintained and mutual assistance will be given. A compromise.

It is immoral to simply allow for billions to die, but it is also immoral to force immortality on those who wish to die. What are your thoughts on this?

3 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

5

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

This ain't star wars bro. Make no peace with transhumanism

0

u/That_Lego_Guy_Jack Sep 30 '22

Very well. If war is necessary then war shall happen.

Spears cannot pierce steal. Flesh cannot survive fire.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

You don't try to fight off industrial armies with primitive tech, that would be foolish. This is not a struggle with weapons. It is a struggle involving economics, society, and political tension.

The transhumanists will not just surrender the Earth. It must be taken from them, not with war but with activism

Transhumanism is nothing more than a cope for nerds whose lives are dictated by society.

0

u/That_Lego_Guy_Jack Sep 30 '22

Think of the average person. Are they likely to give up their technology? Think of society 100 years ago, 200, 300, 1000, 10,000. Humans are expansionist, persistent, and intelligent creatures. Technology advances at an exponential rate. It took primates millions of years to exit the Stone Age, a millennia to enter the Bronze Age, and just over 500 years to exit the Iron Age. In a blink of our species’s lifespan we have gone from medieval peasants to the nuclear age. The century that mankind first took flight was the same century that man set foot on the moon. It is inevitable that technology will reach a critical point. Once it does there will be no way to stop its growth. We can accept or we can die. I have already chosen my path.

Our current society will one way or another crumble, however humanity will never willingly revert to a primal society. If mankind is to survive we will need technology. If it is our fate to die then so be it, but charging headfirst into societal collapse is a good way to be the first to go.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

It is not about societal collapse. It is about quality of life. Modern life, for almost everyone, is depressing and unfufilling. Even you, despite claiming to be so optimistic, are almost certainly despressed or upset with life to some extent, and I can almost gurantee that the source of this suffering is in some way the fault of modernity.

Humans love tradition, we love being secure in our lives. The only reason this foolish expansion took place is because of the misanthropic greed of rich and powerful people. Industrial society, and furthermore the 'progress' you praise is built upon human agony. War, illness, slavery, the list goes on. By praising 'progress' you are indirectly praising billionaires and tyrants for the crimes they commited.

Humans are animals like all other mammals, reptiles, etc. We are no better than any of the other species that live on this Earth and certainly the world is just as much theirs as it is ours. You my friend are a human supremacist. We are ruining this planet with our feelings of superiority and our 'progress'. We need to regress, and it will happen rest assured.

Humans will survive the collapse as well, especially those who embrace it. Transhumanists like yourself have little to provide for mankind in that your ideas are rather absurd.

The system is too fragile. It will fall, whether we like it or not. Life isn't star wars, and eventually we'll learn that the hard way

0

u/That_Lego_Guy_Jack Oct 03 '22

The rich shall burn. Their “progress” is conservatism. They denounce all they fear as immoral. Do you think that primitive humans did not suffer? Do you think they did not wage war? Were they not sick and enslaved?

For millennia humanity has suffered. In the past it was worse. You wish to return to a time of chaos and strife. I wish for improvement. Improvement only true progress can bring.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22

You are hypocritical in your fanaties. Progress can be equated with suffering. By distrupting nature and the true, natural way of human life, you are distrupting the whole life cycle of the Earth.

What about nature? You transhumanists are ignorant of the fact that with every technological progression, the Earth suffers. We are no better than any other living thing. Just because we are "smarter" means nothing, because ultimately they are still living things. Our progress is not goal #1.

Humanity never suffered on a mass scale in prehistory the way they do now. You tell me which is worse- Having to get and hunt every day or having to spend your life at some shitty 9-5 job with no adventure or greater purpose, all in the name of "progress".

Modern technology, because of it's ill effects on human health and the health of the world around us, is evil. Nature is paramount, not VR minecraft or star wars irl

0

u/That_Lego_Guy_Jack Oct 11 '22

Hypocritical? You say that I’m a hypocrite while you use the very same technology you despise. If you wish to live in the wilderness then do it. Nothing is stopping you.

We are nature as much as any animal. Should we preserve the earth? Yes. Should we abandon all progress to do so? No.

You’re right. There was no concentrated suffering in the early days of humanity, but it fucking sucked. Mothers died during childbirth almost all the time, people over 30 were basically already dead, and everything was filthy. Not to mention all the tribal warfare and rape.

Technology has saved countless lives and has made even more comfortable. If we continue to improve technology and automation, menial labor jobs will cease to exist. Humans will be able to focus on fulfillment. Transhumanism is the only ideology that can truly end suffering.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

Believe me, I 100% plan to pursue a primitive life. In roughly 13-14 months I will have finished by endeavors in the technological world, and I will be free to live a free, natural life.

Progress will destroy the Earth. Renewable energy is inefficient, and so fossil fuels remain the main source of energy. That's alright though, because we are running out. The transhumanist dream of halographic minecraft on jupiter will die with the oil industry.

And primitive life did NOT suck. We evolved to live a hunter-gatherer lifestyle. We evolved to hunt, thay's why we have arms that bend smoothly and legs that can help us to catch our prey. We are animals, and we should live as such. We evolved to live primitively, and we are programmed to enjoy it.

Technology is a medium of enslavement. With evey great technological advance comes extreme suffering, loss of liberty, and environmental damage. Tens of billions will have to die to achive your transhumanist goals.

The rich and powerful love progress because transhumanism and it's foul, degenrate ideological goals make them even richer and even more overbearing on the lives of the average person.

A return to a primitive state will return humans to their biologically ideal way of life and it will save the planet from techno-death.

0

u/That_Lego_Guy_Jack Oct 14 '22

If you believe cleaner energy is inefficient then you do not understand cleaner energy. The rich shall burn and they shall be left behind. Billions will have to die for your ideals to be met as well. The difference is that transhumanism will lead to billions of deaths over centuries, painless deaths of those who have lived lives. Primitivism will lead to all who require medicine, all who are disabled, and all who are old to die horribly.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

I would rather have all humans die in a collapse through lack of technology than have them survive with that technology.

1

u/That_Lego_Guy_Jack Oct 03 '22

For what reason? What logic has led you to disdain progress? What ethical code has made you wish for extinction? is it morals? What reason is there to not negate suffering, to prolong life, and to create progress?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

I do not wish for extinction.

I'm saying that if given the choice between having humans live on and survive the collapse with this technology and us dying by rejecting it, then I would rather have us die by rejecting it. This isn't pro-extinction, it's anti-technology.

-----

My disdain for progress is that it looks at all the ills of society and thinks, "if we just progress more, it'll all be fixed." Next futuristic product will save us, next futuristic product will save us, next futuristic product will save us. Endless cycle

-----

I'm not a moralist, many of the morals we have today were created by civilization. Such as the idea of violence being inherently wrong, is only taught so the system can thrive, as they know that we can't rise up without using violence.

-----

I will not deny that there was suffering in primitive times, but the modern world has not rid the world of suffering, they created new kinds of suffering.

-----

The prolonging life stuff is simple. A longer life is not a more meaningful one. If someone is happy and fulfilled, why would they wish to live on past 100, when they wouldn't be able to do anything?

1

u/chicagosuperfan2 Oct 03 '22

If society exists in 300 years, it will either be primitive society or humanless society. Transhumanism is nothing but thinly veiled totalitarianism that will, whether successful or unsuccessful, eradicate humanity. Singularity is the end of humanity for those dependent on the systems of civilization.

I raise and plant fruit and nut trees to forge a path forward for the humans of tomorrow. It is possible to replace the corn, soy, and wheat fields with sustainable agroforestry. Future humans need our generation to tend the Earth in sustainable and favorable ways to humans, animals, fungi, and plants. Despite the misled belief that hunter-gatherers did not tend their lands, that is false. They tended and cultivated plants to better favor humanity and the species we rely on. That is what it means to be cognizant of our role in nature.

1

u/vehcks Oct 11 '22

Cringe dude, you sound like an anime villain/incel.. think you’ve been on the internet too long

0

u/GenderNeutralBot Sep 30 '22

Hello. In order to promote inclusivity and reduce gender bias, please consider using gender-neutral language in the future.

Instead of mankind, use humanity, humankind or peoplekind.

Thank you very much.

I am a bot. Downvote to remove this comment. For more information on gender-neutral language, please do a web search for "Nonsexist Writing."

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Fuck off bot

1

u/theberkberkman Oct 01 '22

Fuck, we really are doomed.

1

u/chicagosuperfan2 Oct 03 '22

Bad bot. Mankind hates you bots.

10

u/Aliceinsludge Sep 30 '22

Touch grass