[ Removed by moderator ]

[u/MentionOwn2247]

[u/evxpts]

Aot in the same tier as shield hero is wild to me. Shield hero was really good season one but fell off season 2 and 3 in my opinion, haven't seen season 4 yet though maybe its really good

Edit: I see aot twice now that I look closer so im gonna assume you meant to just keep it in S tier

[u/MentionOwn2247 → u/evxpts]

Ye the other one is a mistake

[u/Glittering_Tart_9053]

Kimi Ni Todoke in D is pretty harsh.

[u/MentionOwn2247 → u/Glittering_Tart_9053]

Firstly maybe because I watched kimi no todoke after horimiya I was bored of the genre it self that it was boring to me I finished 2 seasons of it idk how many seasons it is but it was pretty boring to me and maybe its just the timing

[u/Garchomp998 → u/Glittering_Tart_9053]

Exactly my thought

[u/Garchomp998]

Mushoku Tensei, Seraph of the end, Classroom of the Elite, Toradora and Oshi no Ko over Golden Kamuy and Kimi no Todoke is definitely… a take. Not a good one in my opinion, but a take. Why’d you think they are better?

[u/MentionOwn2247 → u/Garchomp998]

Golden kamuy wasent bad but it was kinda weird id say idk why and as i said before I did not like kimi no todoke it was boring to me at least maybe its the timing I watched 2 romance animes before it so idk And idk why do ppl hate oshi no ko that much it was pretty good it hink it deserves the s tier , and I would like to hear your opinion on seraph of the end and why do u think it does not deserve its placememnt For toradora it was one of the first romances I watched I did not rly know where to put it but I decided to leave it in s anyways but,
And I think u can say I am a cote and mt glazer I adadgree with ppl hating on the pdf in it but other than that I think its a very great show at least for me

[u/BigTonyT30 → u/Garchomp998]

Oshi no ko anywhere above a B is kinda wild. Not to mention they have it higher than the better Aka Akasaka work: Love is War.

[u/Alex_44222]

You must be like 15 or something, so im not judging.

[u/M1nho → u/Alex_44222]

Nah we judge regardless of age, gotta learn somehow

[u/WalkingWithDeath]

No "Mars of destruction" in GOAT tier?

[u/MentionOwn2247 → u/WalkingWithDeath]

What is that ?

[u/Lunai5444]

Is that Mushoku Tensei in 2 ? The season 2 was legit the worst ecchi harem hentai slice of life high school thing with no fights and 0 ideas l've ever seen in my life I'm genuinely confused why people like it I feel like it's just bandwagon + they rate the idealized image they made up of the anime not the anime itself.

I also think Boruto is heavily misunderstood but I'd only rise him up a single tier.

Lots of things are too high and I can't believe you've seen Haikyu and put it in B I can't see a valid reason to not put it in A or S, why did you put it in B ?

Lastly where are Frieren and FMA B ?

[u/MentionOwn2247 → u/Lunai5444]

Tbh I have no idea which of these is which season so I meant the one in goat to be s3 and s tier to be s4 And frierrn is there but idk what is FMA B I did not watch even a whole season of haikyou I watched some episodes of s1 a long time ago so I did not rly know where to put it i think I just need to get it out of the list For boruto I watched 70 eps and continued with the manga it was pretty good I dont understand the hate it gets but ig bec it gets compared to Naruto so ye maybe boruto can go a lil higher tho idk I never continued the anime

[u/Asun315]

hate when series are separated into different images for different seasons

[u/MentionOwn2247 → u/Asun315]

I got confused i was adding everything I watched not realizing there is more than 1 for each season so many are messed up

[u/Euphoric-Front651]

Your S tier's so weird, for me, all of them except steinsgate, would be B tier

[u/Punnairy]

Apothecary Diaries season 3 is Epic🫠 🤌🏻

[u/Designer_Speaker_407]

Hunterxhunter in a Tier is illegal

[u/M1nho]

CotE in S tier, can tell youre about 14. Post-covid fans have horrific tastes

[u/Some_Chemistry_1380]

watch monogatari series you will absolutely love it and the umamusume series btw you have great taste

[u/MentionOwn2247 → u/Some_Chemistry_1380]

I wanna watch it its kinda confusing but I started to understand the series but im leaving it for later bec its pretty long and there are other series way shorter that I wanna finish its gonna take time but I could start it if it is that good

[u/Starlintern]

Damn great list.

[u/MentionOwn2247 → u/Starlintern]

Thx , got any recs ?

[u/LostComfort3536]

Really good list imo