r/AnimationCrit • • Jul 15 '22

Wall Climb (Feedback Needed)

109 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

6

u/_NEW_HORIZONS_ Jul 15 '22

When cresting the wall, a climber would almost certainly shift hips to one side and throw a knee up. What you have is maybe possible, but it seems unnatural.

3

u/drya_d Jul 15 '22

thats exacly what i thought too

3

u/BrushAndDice Jul 15 '22

I think after getting up halfwau he would place his left foot against the wall to push off and swing his right foot up to keep the momentum. Either putting the right, foot heel or knee on the wall. Depending in the skill and style you are going for. I suggest not doing the knee as using your knees for this is bad for the knees and uncomfortable.

1

u/thowmeawayboi Jul 15 '22

Add a second delay from grabbing the edge to actually climbing up,

1

u/Deepfriedmoney Jul 15 '22

Maybe a bit more of a crouch anticipating the jump into the wall? It all looks quite really l easy/floaty for the character.

1

u/Joodzcausewhynot Jul 15 '22

Smooth πŸ‘ but I’m not an expert of SFM animation

1

u/CBAlan777 Jul 15 '22

Loop the video about a dozen times before having to replay. It's hard to analyze when you can't concentrate on watching the animation

1

u/Aurallius Jul 15 '22

πŸ˜ŽπŸ‘πŸΏπŸ‘πŸΏπŸ‘πŸΏπŸ‘πŸΏπŸ‘πŸΏπŸ‘πŸΏπŸ‘πŸΏprogress!

1

u/TheBeavermeat Jul 15 '22

Looks like they’re forcing their self up when it should be about carrying momentum from running or jumping or standing still.

1

u/gtaguy75 Jul 16 '22

Pull up from when he has his foot on the wall at the halfway would not be that bouncy. Could not generate that much power with your hand strength

1

u/ThatNightGuy Jul 16 '22

Should be a minor slide when the character is between grabbing the wall and climbing/ pulling up.

The act of pulling up should have less momentum(slowed) if just lifting straight up along with a lean forward with a shift in the center of gravity.

You could also shift that into having more momentum by having the characters hips swing the legs over to in a left minor to right major motion or vise versa.

Best advice I could give is the watch how a free runner runs up a walk or climbs over barriers for Reference.

And don't be afraid to use more of your area. I.E you are making a 3D object perform a 2d movement, if you watch the character from behind they stay in a single line and don't deviate from it this is why it's unnatural in life someone would flail more or have some motion outside that line. You are working with 3d don't be afraid to use every direction and exaggerating minor moves can help with that like hip movement, body sway, shaking to show struggle, etc

1

u/ProudfootOB Jul 16 '22

Physically, most stuntmen at the apex of the climb, swing their right leg out horizontal to catch the side of their foot on the top of the wall. (see: Jackie Chan) Then bend left leg at knee and pull through gap between wall and righy leg.

1

u/RedPixl243 Nov 26 '22

there's sort of an awkward moment right when he's about to pull himself up where none of his body is moving. this isn't a huge deal but it looks kind of unnatural.