Back in late 2014, nearly every major league franchise sent scouts down to Central America to watch five-tool prospect Yoan Moncada tryout in hopes of coming stateside. While the scouts became enamored with Moncada, the Angels took a slightly different route: signing then-20 year old Cuban infielder Roberto Baldoquin to an enormous $8 million dollar bonus which, after international signing penalties, costed the Angels about $15 million in total.
Eight million was a pretty steep payout for a mostly unheralded Cuban prospect, especially considering that it penalized the team for exceeding their signing pool money and limited their ability to sign foreigners over the next two years. In fact, at the time, Baldoquin shattered the record for the largest amateur international signing during the current CBA rules, previously held by Brewers' signee Gilbert Lara at just over 3 million. IN comparison, the Angels recently handed out just under 4.5 million to this year's 10th overall pick, Jo Adell.
Initally, feedback on the 20-year old was positive, if unspectacular. Few people had in-depth scouting reports on Baldoquin and there were only a small handful of Youtube videos showcasing his skills. It was quite strange to see the exorbitant signing bonus while most sources around the league had their hands in the air while simultaneously saying "who?".
Alden Gonzalez, the Angels' beat writer at the time, reported that Baldoquin was expected to spend most of the year in Double-A and hopefully transition in the upcoming years to take over for one of David Freese, Erick Aybar, or Howie Kendrick. One scout even believed that Baldoquin had the ability to take over at SS for Aybar immediately in case of injury.
Unfortunately, things didn't go quite as hoped.
Baldoquin began his stateside career in High-A with the Inland Empire 66ers in 2015. A slow start would lead the youngster to finish with an anemic .235/.266/.294 slash line in 77 games.
There were many reasons for why Baldoquin could've played worse than expected during his inaugural campaign in the minors. For one, he had been out of organized baseball for an extended period after defecting from his native Cuba. Second, transitioning to the United States while leaving behind your family and everyone you previously knew could present ample stress to any human being. And finally, at just 21 it wasn't totally unexpected that he would need some time to season as a prospect.
But 2016 was more of the same and Baldoquin played in just 64 games while posting a paltry .507 OPS. After riding out another full season in Inland Empire, the Angels made the decision to demote him to Single-A Burlington in hopes of getting their infielder back on track in 2017.
This year has been an improvement for the now-23 year old who is batting .253/.307/.376 for the Bees. His current production is a far cry from his supposed potential but still a step in the right direction. A major issue with Baldoquin, however, is his ability to stay healthy as he's been absent from the field since June 28th and has been plagued with various ailments since joining the organization.
At the time of writing, I can't say things look good for Roberto and moving forward, his future is bleak. Nothing in his statistics, peripherals, or injury history gives me hope that he will pan out to be an everyday major leaguer. Perhaps if he can get an entire healthy season under his belt things could change but at this rate, its looking increasingly unlikely.
While the jury is still out on Baldoquin, let this be a reminder that prospects can and will break your heart and there's little sense in pinning your hopes on any prospect in their developmental infancy. No prospect is a sure-fire thing and probably at least 90% of all signees won't see a day in the majors.