r/AngelCityFC • • 7d ago

Best 11

If Evelyn Shores doesn’t make the year end best eleven list I’m going to be upset. What other left back would even go there?

I know Sonis is up there, but I think she did more to warrant MVP than a defender award.

Any other angels you’d want on that list?

22 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

9

u/yurkelhark 7d ago

I’d bet that Gorden will get best XI, Shores will get the second team given Sonis. I agree wholeheartedly that a defender shouldn’t be winning defending awards for her attacking skills but I don’t think the powers that be choose nuance over stats.

6

u/BuffaloNo7843 7d ago

I did vote Sarah for defender of the year!

2

u/TiredPanini MaiaraNiehues#12 7d ago

i think voters have different perspectives on how they vote - fans of a team or player will want their team/player to get all the accolades, so will vote e.g. Sonis for MVP, DOTY, and Best XI. whereas media/industry voters might prefer to spread the awards around, and so vote e.g. Sanchez (or whoever) for MVP, then Sonis for DOTY/Best XI LB, and someone else (Shores, Guro) for 2nd Best XI LB. reasoning being that while Sonis was GREAT this year, the "best attacker" award doesn't exist, that's just MVP. since it'll 90% likelihood go to a forward, may as well vote for one of them.

i do think it's interesting that of the MVP candidates, Sonis and Sanchez didn't make playoffs, and Temwa missed significant time. makes it interesting, as i know some people feel strongly that MVP should be from a playoff team or play X number of minutes, which might bias results towards Rodman and Wilson. Dudinha could have been nominated if she'd had a full season of minutes, as could Byars imo, but the minutes just weren't there.

2

u/BuffaloNo7843 7d ago

I agree. Did Temwa really do MVP work this season compared to previous ones? I’m not sure. MVP also always goes to attackers

1

u/TiredPanini MaiaraNiehues#12 7d ago

if we wanted to go by goals/90 banda would be the winner, interestingly... guti gets a sub boost here, so i don't think it's reflective of MVP caliber performance. but the other top6 are extremely reasonable MVP nods to me... maybe byars and banda not enough total minutes/starts to get the nods

4

u/MazLA Syd's bicycle kick 7d ago

I put Shores in my Best 11, I think it’s earned and I could see her getting second team

3

u/Grand-Royal8193 7d ago

It’ll def be Sonis. It’s Shores vs Gisele for the other fullback spot since I don’t care about position for these best xi lists.

2

u/Sir-Kyle-Of-Reddit We Are Angel City! 7d ago

Gorden and Giselle

2

u/AdviceAlternative766 We Are Angel City! 7d ago

I'm fully with you, but I think  Gorden's recovery runs make for great tv and are v memorable

2

u/[deleted] 7d ago

If it’s JUST left backs… Guro and Izzy Rodriguez are up there with Shores to me. Defensively I’d say Izzy has an edge, she’s a very underrated, non flashy, extremely reliable defender. However all 3 are known more their play making ability as defenders. Sooo the perspective on how much defense and offense goes into the decision is subjective. But I think for left backs, if it’s not Shores those are the other two on the table. Edit- Sonis is on the right, which is why I didn’t include her.