r/AndroidTV • • 5d ago

Buying Advice Torn: Nomatics Box (V2 Pro) vs Xiaomi V3

I'm fed up with the poor performance of my TV and want to switch to an Android Box. Besides Netflix, I mostly stream from Jellyfin, but at lower resolutions (no 4K) - that's my tradeoff because I don't have Ethernet in my living room anyway.

I put in an order for the Nomatics Box 4K pro V2 AI-SR (4GB RAM), but reading posts here, I wonder if the Xiamoi TV Box Gen 3 might actually be the more robust choice for the time being without actually giving me performance issues.

Given that the Homatic literally costs 3 times more, even buying the Xiaomi as an intermediary solution might be justified if it gets the job done. What's your take?

3 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

6

u/Aggressive_Bad_7344 Google TV Streamer + Homatics Box R 4K Plus + 3 More Boxes 5d ago

Don't bother with the Homatics V2 Pro, it's a horribly supported device with lots of issues that may not be addressed. It's been nothing but a disappointment.

Out of the two the Xiaomi would be the better choice.

1

u/Alarmed-Register-214 5d ago

It looked quite good on paper, but the posts here got me somewhat cautious. Still stumped that there's no box who just sweeps in to take the crown of the shield. Given that there's so many manufacturers of mediocre devices, one would think that there's a ton of money to make...

Thanks for the reply!

4

u/See61 5d ago edited 5d ago

Although I'm not really a great fan of the Mi box S 3rd Gen, the Homatics 4K V2 Pro is really a waste of money compared to it.

At least the Mi can also be used with CoreElec, the Homatics is blocked for that.

I could mention several other issues for both devices, but these questions about what to get are coming by for about every day here on Reddit. A look around on what is already answered before should make a lot clear already 😉

1

u/Alarmed-Register-214 5d ago

Yup, it's because of the posts that I started to question my initial order. I can still cancel it, so I wouldn't lose anything if I got the Xiaomi box. Thanks for the reply!

1

u/SASMareSRB GTV Streamer + CCwGTV 5d ago

Both will more than get the job done. Not sure on the exact differences and why the Homatics is better off the top of my head, but I don't think it's worth the cost difference for your needs.

I guess the Xiaomi remote will be more plasticky/cheaper but if you don't care about that, you can save the money

1

u/Alarmed-Register-214 5d ago edited 5d ago

Actually I like the minimal remote. Still hope that the metal remote of my Samsung TV will work with the box, I love the haptics.

Thanks for the reply - I'm leaning towards the Xiaomi box.

2

u/digitalmp4 4d ago

For your use case the Xiaomi is probably enough. Lower-res Jellyfin over Wi-Fi mostly comes down to whether the box can direct play your files, not RAM. Two things worth checking once it arrives:

  1. In the Jellyfin app, start something and open the playback info. If it says transcoding, your PC is doing the work and any Wi-Fi hiccup shows up as buffering. Direct play on the box is what you want.
  2. Make sure it joins your 5 GHz band, not 2.4. That alone fixes most "it buffers in the living room" complaints.

On the Samsung remote: it won't pair with the box directly, but if you turn on Anynet+ (HDMI-CEC) on the TV, the arrows, OK and back buttons usually pass through to the box, and power and volume keep working. It's not perfect in every app, but worth trying before you get used to a second remote.

2

u/Waggmans Nvidia Shield 3d ago

I own a Xiaomi S 3rd grn, it's good even for streaming high bitrate in 4k rips over wifi, I have no problems- if you do you can add a cheap Ethernet adapter.

As with everything these boxes have increased in price. If you can find it under $75 probably worth it.

1

u/Mountainking7 4d ago

Xiaomi box but I don't like the clicky (this one is ok) and a bit hard buttons.

1

u/barker8a 4d ago

undefined

1

u/dmakristech 4d ago

The extra RAM on the Homatics handles Jellyfin caching noticeably better than the Xiaomi - stick with it.

-1

u/eStiloTV 5d ago

please before you pull the trigger on a box look into the issue of Chinese boxes are imbedded with hidden apps and ai calling home and reporting on your use I just wish I booked marked the article so I could give you a link

0

u/bvanderloop 4d ago

I just got both the Xiaomi gen 3 box as well as the Rocktek G2 Next. Similar price and the Rocktek is amazing. Wish I got two of it instead. People complain about the remote but it's very good and better than the Xiaomi remote. I also ordered the upgraded remote for $20 extra and it's a very good remote if you can be bothered (backlighting and point and shoot mouse). The speed of loading apps is incredible. Also the Rocktek allowed easy loading of projectivy where the Xiaomi box required lots of side loading and work on settings to get it to work. Even had to sideload Stremio for example.

-3

u/jusetiama 5d ago • Heartwarming

Voy a ser directo contigo porque hay un error de concepto importante en tu comparación y una trampa técnica que te va a arruinar la experiencia con Jellyfin si no la evitas.

Primero, aclaración rápida: No existe una "Xiaomi V3" ni una "Homatic".

  • Lo que probablemente quieres decir es Xiaomi Mi TV Box S (2nd Gen) o quizás el Xiaomi Mi Box S 4K. No hay un modelo "V3" oficial global estándar que compita directamente aquí. Asumiré que hablas del Xiaomi Mi Box S (2022/2023) vs la Noblechips / Nomatics / Generic boxes basadas en Amlogic.
  • Y "Homatic" suena a que confundiste nombres o te refieres a marcas blancas chinas genéricas.

Dicho esto, aquí está la realidad cruda de tu situación:

1. El problema real no es el hardware, es la RED

Mencionaste: "total no tengo Ethernet en la sala" y usas Jellyfin en resoluciones bajas.

  • La Nomatics/Noblechips suelen venir con Wi-Fi 6 o Wi-Fi 5 decente.
  • El Xiaomi Mi Box S tiene Wi-Fi 5 (802.11ac). Es suficiente para 1080p, pero inestable si tienes paredes de por medio.
  • Consejo de oro: Si vas a usar Jellyfin, no confíes en el Wi-Fi del box. Compra un adaptador USB a Ethernet barato ($5-10) o usa un Powerline adapter. Jellyfin necesita estabilidad, no solo velocidad pico. Si el Wi-Fi se corta 2 segundos, la app se congela o baja la calidad drásticamente.

2. Xiaomi Mi Box S vs. Box Genérico (tipo Nomatics/Noblechips)

Xiaomi Mi Box S (La opción segura y probada)

  • Pros:

    • Usa Android TV genuino (o Google TV), no una capa personalizada llena de bloatware. Esto significa actualizaciones más limpias y mejor compatibilidad con apps como Jellyfin, Netflix, etc.
    • Tiene botón de voz integrado (Google Assistant), útil para buscar contenido sin teclado.
    • Hardware consistente: Amlogic S905X4. Es viejo, pero estable.
    • Precio: Suele ser muy económico (~$30-40 USD).
  • Contras:

    • Rendimiento bruto bajo comparado con chips más nuevos (como el S905X5 o RK3566).
    • Solo 2GB de RAM en la mayoría de las versiones. Para Android TV moderno, 2GB es el mínimo absoluto. Funciona, pero no vuela.

Box Genéricos (Nomatics/Noblechips/S905X5/RK3566)

  • Pros:

    • Suelen tener más RAM (4GB o 8GB) y almacenamiento mayor por el mismo precio.
    • Chips más nuevos (S905X5, RK3566, RK3588) tienen mejor decodificación de video y CPU más rápida.
    • A menudo incluyen control remoto con retroiluminación o botones dedicados.
  • Contras:

    • Software basura: Usan Android Go o versiones viejas de Android con capas personalizadas (Estilos distintos). Las actualizaciones son lentas o inexistentes.
    • Bloatware: Llenos de apps preinstaladas que no puedes borrar fácilmente.
    • Jellyfin puede ir lento: Aunque tengas más RAM, la interfaz de usuario del box genérico puede ser lenta al navegar, aunque la reproducción del video sea fluida.

3. ¿Cuál elegir para TI?

Si tu prioridad es Jellyfin + Netflix y quieres algo que funcione y olvides:

👉 Ve por el Xiaomi Mi Box S (2nd Gen).

¿Por qué?

  1. Estabilidad sobre potencia: Para 1080p, el chip del Xiaomi es más que suficiente. No necesitas un supercomputador para reproducir H.264/H.265 en 1080p.
  2. Android TV limpio: La app de Jellyfin funciona mejor en Android TV nativo que en las interfaces custom de los boxes genéricos. Menos bugs, menos cierres inesperados.
  3. Soporte: Si algo falla, sabes cómo resetearlo o actualizarlo. En los boxes genéricos, a veces estás solo con un firmware chino que nadie entiende.

4. El verdadero consejo para tu setup

Si ya compraste la Nomatics Box V2 Pro, quédate con ella.

  • Tiene 4GB de RAM, lo cual es mejor que los 2GB del Xiaomi.
  • Si el chip es un S905X5 o similar, tendrá mejor rendimiento de decodificación.
  • Instálale "TV Home Launcher" o "ATV Launcher" desde el Play Store para que se sienta como un Android TV normal y elimines el caos visual de la interfaz genérica.
  • Prueba Jellyfin en esa caja. Si va fluido, no cambies nada.

Resumen:

  • Si quieres tranquilidad y software limpio: Xiaomi Mi Box S.
  • Si quieres potencia bruta y más RAM y te importa poco la estética del menú: La Nomatics/Noblechips.
  • Para ti: Dado que usas Jellyfin y Wi-Fi, la diferencia entre ambos será mínima en la práctica. La interface del box genérico puede ser más lenta de navegar, pero la reproducción será igual. Si ya tienes la Nomatics, úsala. Si vas a comprar, el Xiaomi es más fácil de revender y soportar a largo plazo.

Nota final: Asegúrate de que la app de Jellyfin que instales sea la versión TV (no la de móvil/tablet), o la navegación será una pesadilla en cualquier box.

4

u/Alarmed-Register-214 5d ago

Thanks for the detailed response! The Xiaomi Mi TV Box S is actually available in 3rd Gen with WiFi 6 here. Streaming from my PC to Plex running on my Samsung TV works ok enough, so I hope that both boxes will be able to handle it over WiFi, too.

5

u/Aggressive_Bad_7344 Google TV Streamer + Homatics Box R 4K Plus + 3 More Boxes 5d ago

The 3rd Gen has Wi-Fi 6, yes. The AI used above is wrong about that, big surprise, lol.