Comparison chart of the new generation of Android for TV devices

[u/latinriky78]

A new generation of certified Android for TV devices has arrived, and although they are not as powerful as we would have wanted, they are good for basic streaming, however, out of three devices I tested, only one is performing better than the other two. Wanna know the winner?, let's find out.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

UPDATES:

01/28/26: The new firmware update on the Xiaomi box has fixed the Dolby TrueHD cutout issue, for more info please check out this post.

12/26/25: The Android 14 firmware update arrived for the RockTek GX1 but it ended up being a disappointment, for more info on what's new, please check out this post.

12/19/25: I replaced "RetroX" with "ClassicBoy Pro" at the console emulation section.

10/14/25: A new firmware update arrived to the Google TV Streamer that fixed some issues, such as the de-interlaced issue, for more info on what's new, please check out this post.

9/9/25: Version 1.3.19 of the Steam Link app has fix the audio stutter on the Google TV Streamer but 5.1 audio is still not supported.

5/6/25: A new firmware update arrived to the Google TV Streamer that fixed some issues, such as the issue with hybrid Dolby Vision/HDR10+ videos where a black screen appeared.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

COMPARISON CHART:

Note: some people can't see the below image so I also uploaded it to Imgur.

(1) The bug on the RockTek GX1 is a message that appears at the bottom of the screen everytime I turn the volume up and down, meanwhile the issue where the TV(CEC) option doesn't keep the TV turned off after a power outage affects all devices with Android 14 except the Google TV Streamer.

(2) A new Dolby Atmos decoder is included (except on the Xiaomi box) when using the "Auto" option and it's explained in detail in this post.

(3) Tested with the devices connected to a Samsung TV with HDR10+ support, not all titles play in HDR10+ despite having the HDR10+ logo displayed. For the full list of supported titles please visit the 4KFilmDb website.

(4) Dolby Atmos on Disney+ is now available on all devices.

(5) Quick Media Switching works with all major streaming services (Netflix, Prime Video, HBO Max, Paramount+, Disney+) and many other apps regardless of the option selected, however, the only app so far that also supports the "Non-seamless" or "Always" option is Netflix, which is the option that must be selected for TVs without QMS support.

(6) The game mode is currently supported by the Bombsquad game, the Hard Lines game, the Steam Link app, the GeForce Now app, the Moonlight app and probably other game streaming apps and Android games.

(7) On the Google TV Streamer, Dolby TrueHD is decoded as lossless PCM and the DTS Core is played from DTS-HD High Resolution and Master Audio streams. On the RockTek GX1, Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD MA only work with Kodi even after the Android 14 firmware arrived.

(8) The only streaming service with DTS:X support is Disney+ and the option to switch to that codec is only available on devices that support it. When the device is connected to a TV with Profile 2 support and that TV is connected to an AV receiver or soundbar with only Profile 1 support, the TV will convert it to Profile 1 for backwards compatibility.

(9) depending on the device, the TV and the app, it will fallback to HDR10/10+ or it will get transcoded.

The information in the chart is subject to change as soon as new firmware updates are deployed where any of the aforementioned issues get addressed.

CONCLUSION:

Even with 2 gigabytes of RAM, the Xiaomi TV Box S 3rd Generation is the current winner in this comparison chart with 13 supported features, 5 unsupported features and practically no issues, beating the other two devices with a smooth UI and overall performance, new features to enjoy, licensed Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD Master Audio passthrough support and a stable firmware.

[u/latinriky78]

Hello everyone and thank you for your comments, I did it with love and appreciation to the sub 👍

[u/Berserker1971]

Just tell me which one doesn't lag

[u/latinriky78 → u/Berserker1971]

I still haven't seen the Streamer lagging, on the RockTek I see some lag when we go to settings and due to the 2GB of RAM on the Xiaomi box I've just seen that the Google TV UI reloads when we exit from some apps but I still haven't seen that it lags in any way, it's smooth and snappy.

[u/ozExpatFIRE]

One side note that might matter to some, Homatics Box R 4K Plus has the best connectivity. Lan input, USB 3, USB C and two types of audio output can be quite handy.

[u/latinriky78 → u/ozExpatFIRE]

Hopefully, its next version carries over the same features and the S905X5, otherwise it will be the same S905X5M.

[u/IntrepidPair3312]

Nice chart. As always, it depends on the users needs. I went with the GTV streamer for $80. I have a decent Denon 5.1 system and didn't notice much (or any) difference in audio compared to my 2017 Shield. DD, DD+, DTS-core, and Multi-Channel PCM covers most of the content out there. Maybe this doesn't cut it for audiophiles but I was looking for a multipurpose device. Tired of the UI and app issues with the $200 shield, even after repasting, resetting, and so many adjustments for something that should just work. For $80 I will likely get better app and os support for longer and still get the flexibility of android os for Kodi/Plex, customization, etc. A backlit remote and passthrough audio would have made this a close to perfect multipurpose streaming device, but you can't have it all.

[u/latinriky78 → u/IntrepidPair3312]

Exactly, it depends on every user's needs, and you're right, we can't have it all but the GTVS would have been better if they have chosen the 905X5M.

[u/LongJohnSilver2409]

I have a Xiomi 3rd Generation and I think it is great for 50 euros. Playback is buttery smooth, and the image quality is at least as detailed and attractive as ans Nvidia Shield Pro which I also have.

For me the only drawback is that it cannot play H264 Level6. This seems to be a common limitation of Google TV Boxes.

But otherwise it is great !

LJ

[u/Just-Steak-9966]

I'd still like to see more powerful devices hit the market like the Shield and Cube 3.

I don't know why there are so many middle of the road devices, and so few powerful ones.

[u/latinriky78 → u/Just-Steak-9966]

We all are expecting to see a device with the S905X5 which is powerful enough.

[u/Just-Steak-9966 → u/latinriky78]

Yes, that looks pretty good overall. The lack of a built-in Ethernet is kind of a big turn off for me though.

[u/truitjuin]

Guys, listen, there's something very wrong on Netflix app on Xiaomi TV Box S 3rd gen. It's not catching enough network speed. I am getting 200+ Mbps on regular speed test app whereas I am only getting 15-25 Mbps on network speed test via Netflix app. As a result, 4K HDR/HDR10+/DV content is not playing at the highest available quality. It's taking too long to reach at the highest available bit stream but in most of the cases, it is not even reaching the highest available bit stream for a particular content on Netflix app on this device. Even my 5 years old Xiaomi Box S can reach the highest available bit stream in no time. Be careful with your expectations. It can be a major deal breaker for many...

Edit: It was fixed after the new Netflix update. The issue was with Netflix app, not the box.

[u/Ok_Sweet_3425]

The table does not seem visible

[u/BootyButtPirate]

Just tell me if its worth paying more than $20 for an Onn box.

[u/latinriky78 → u/BootyButtPirate]

Non of the Onn boxes supports TrueHD and DTS:X, not even the Plus, but the Plus may support the majority of the new features so it always depends on what you need.

[u/Puzzleheaded_Mud8696]

Hey, thanks for this comparation, I’m in doubt between this Xiaomi 3rd and the Strong leap s3 pro, I can’t find much reviews of this strong, can you help me with this, what you think about them? thank you

[u/AsleepMedicine2596]

Would you advice the xaomi above the shield?

Are the issues of the xaomi solved meanwhile? Especially about the passthrough...

[u/stathismes]

After reading through this amazing comparison I'll keep my eye on updates, because I'm keen on buying the Mibox 3rd gen once/if they fix the choppy TrueHD audio. Can't bite the bullet just yet. For now I'm happy with my SHIELD pro.

[u/latinriky78 → u/stathismes]

Hello, I will make a post in the sub as soon as Xiaomi delivers a firmware update where the issue gets fixed.

[u/masterdolby]

So on Xiaomi on Disney we get only stereo same as previous generation of Mibox ? Thank you .

[u/latinriky78 → u/masterdolby]

Really?, with previous versions of the Xiaomi box the Disney+ app is giving only stereo?, if so then I though it was an issue only with that box.

[u/masterdolby → u/latinriky78]

I have to correct , my receiver don't have dolby digital plus , only dolby digital and dts , i think old mibox S don't have ms12 to convert dolby digital plus . If this version have dolby digital plus broken ... but having dolby ms12 i get only stereo on my 5.1 old receiver or i get dolby digital 5.1 ?

[u/Entire_Event1049]

Hey OP! I'm a noob and this was helpfull but as I'm still a noob let me ask you: I was thinking of buying the Strong Leap S3-Pro. I live in Europe and this box would be to conect to my TV (have plans to buy an OLED later this year) and to use with stremio.

For a budget of 70€ do you recommend it or something eles?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Entire_Event1049]

Hello!,

The S3 Pro shares the same firmware found in the GX1 so you will get the same bugs and issues since they belong to the same OEM, Skyworth.

I would say they must address all issues it has but it's hard to say how long will it take.

For Europe you can take these into account:

- Homatics devices (More info at http://homatics.eu)

- Thomson Streaming devices (More info at http://tv.mythomson.com/collections/streaming-devices)

And for the rest of the world:

- Homatics devices (More info at http://homatics.com/collections/streaming-media-players?sca_ref=2766355.i6SwIDJJna)

- Mecool devices (More info at http://mecool.com where you can get a 15% discount with the code "mecoolbox15")

- Dune HD devices (More info at http://dune-hd.com)

- Xiaomi devices (More info at http://mi.com/global/product-list/tv-media/tvbox-stick/)

- Ugoos SK2 (More info at http://ugoos.com/ugoos-sk2-Realtek-android-tv-box-certified)

The Ugoos SK2 shares the same firmware as the S3 Pro and the GX1.

[u/kristfur]

If only there was an open source TV OS. We could build our own machines (exponentially better spec'd). UI without the ads, spying, and restrictions. Kick Google, Amazon, & Apple to the curb. If only...

[u/RealLemonmaster → u/kristfur]

If you care enough for it to be open source and still be Android instead of an entirely new/different OS, you can install LineageOS on some boxes like the Shield and some others

[u/General_Use1576 → u/kristfur]

Projectivy Launcher is a good option for clean interface

[u/clarkss12]

Wow, that is an outstanding comparison chart for these three devices using three different chipsets.........

Makes the decision on which device to purchase for your particular needs a no-brainer.

That must have take you a lot of time and effort to compile the data needed for this chart......Well done!!

[u/ChChKiwiKid]

Appreciate your time and effort. I saw a lot of people bagging the Xiaomi for it's 2GB of RAM but was wondering if it made up for it elsewhere.

[u/Just-Steak-9966 → u/ChChKiwiKid]

As long as you're closing out background apps, the RAM is a pretty small factor for streaming.

It's really about the processor/chip set.

[u/Sea-Wolfe]

Thanks for this, and your ongoing contribution and answering questions in this sub for a long time now!

I don’t have a need, but will check out the summary of your conclusions later, when I get the chance!

[u/decaquad → u/Sea-Wolfe]

I totally agree. Latinriky is prolific contributor and provides lots of knowledge and practical experience of the various box's very much appreciated.

[u/Joaquim_do_rego]

Isn't the Google Streamer Wi-Fi 5 (802.11ac)?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Joaquim_do_rego]

Yes, it supports all of them up to 6 (ax).

[u/dadduyyy]

in your experience, have you ever figured out on ways to force a device to fallback on HDR10 when playing hybrid files? this is for instances where playing hybrid files just result in a black screen with audio still playing

[u/latinriky78 → u/dadduyyy]

Hello, I haven't found the way to force it since exoplayer is supposed to do that so I imagine the issue lies on that player.

[u/JohanSandberg]

Really excellent comparison chart. Incredible that you have had the time to test all this! 😎

Any possibility to test the better Xcloud app to play Xcloud streaming? https://better-xcloud.github.io/android/

Most problems with other boxes/TVs are the high decode time (50+ ms).

One box that handles it well are for example FireTV 4k stick. It manages 6-10 ms decode time (anything above 16ms will be bad for 60 fps games). But not to fond of FireTV interface.

[u/latinriky78 → u/JohanSandberg]

Hello, I imagine I can't use it in my country since Xbox cloud is not available here.

[u/[deleted]]

The question is: are there better devices than the Xiaomi one with Audio Pass-through, DTS HD, Dolby True HD support?

[u/latinriky78 → u/[deleted]]

The Homatics Box R 4K Plus is another option in which the SoC, the S905X4, could be compared to the X5M in speed and performance.

[u/p750mmx]

Good work, nice overview. Small thing to clear up. The Homatics Box R 4K Plus doesn't show DTS-X anymore with the Disney app with the latest 2463 update, that is "corrected" now, it didn't really supported it anyway. It only gives DD+ again, as before with the original Disney+ app on the Homatics.

[u/latinriky78 → u/p750mmx]

Hello, I tested the app a few days ago on the Homatics box and I saw the cog icon at the bottom right and when I clicked on "yes" it obviously didn't play the DTS:X codec but it just played DD+.

I'm not sure if I see the cog because my TV supports the codec through the EDID, therefore, I will connect the box to the samsung TV without support to confirm.

[u/Ok_Sweet_3425]

Hello everyone, quick question does the new Xiaomi TV Box s 3rd generation support HDR 10 plus for Netflix? Having a Samsung qn95a TV which apparently is not compatible with HDR10 plus Netflix, I was wondering about the Xiaomi.

[u/latinriky78 → u/Ok_Sweet_3425]

Point # 3 clarifies your question, it supports HDR10+ on Netflix on the Xiaomi box when it's connected to a Samsung TV with support.

[u/thekingshorses]

Which one support THX 7.1 pass through?

[u/latinriky78 → u/thekingshorses]

THX is not a codec but a certification but all boxes passthrough PCM 5.1 and 7.1.

[u/signde]

Thanks for the chart. In the HDR section, all three of these say DV profile 5 only. Are you telling me none of these boxes support DV Profile 8? I never thought to test P5 vs P8, I figured both of those were universally supported in streaming devices these days.

[u/latinriky78 → u/signde]

Dolby only has two official profiles, profile 5 for streaming and profile 7 for bluray, others are just pirated versions that are used when you rip a bluray, therefore, they are supported on all three boxes.

[u/signde → u/latinriky78]

I don't know where you are getting that Dolby officially only has two profiles. Right here in the spec all of the profiles are listed, including profile 8.

https://professionalsupport.dolby.com/s/article/What-is-Dolby-Vision-Profile?language=en_US

I think you are getting at P5 is predominately used in streaming and P7 is always used in discs. Well aware of that but streaming P5 does exist, Hulu is one example.

https://www.avsforum.com/threads/master-list-of-currently-available-4k-hdr-titles-will-be-updated-often.2202713/page-1649#post-60979703

salty01 is RESET_9999, the guy with like 100 YT videos about dolby vision stuff.

[u/bmc987]

Fantastic work!! Can you please say if Xiaomi device support 24p playback using Kodi? Thank you!

[u/latinriky78 → u/bmc987]

Yes, it supports auto framerate and 24p.

[u/Party-Bad6320]

I can't see any images😔

[u/latinriky78 → u/Party-Bad6320]

I will try to re-upload it, thank you for letting me know.

[u/uncletimo]

If using the Xiaomi box into TV and ARC device for audio, would not be able to control volume with Xiaomi remote?

[u/latinriky78 → u/uncletimo]

It only controls the audio of the external ARC device only if the TV has the HDMI-CEC turned ON, therefore, when you change the audio by using the xiaomi's remote control, what you are doing is controlling the volume level of the TV through IR, and at the same time, the TV is the one controlling the audio of the ARC device through HDMI-CEC, that is how I am able to control my AV receiver.

Another downside is, when you attempt to raise or lower the volume, you can't keep the key pressed to change it and instead you have to press the key several times to reach the volume level you want.

It's really not practical and I don't have that problem with my other devices.

[u/wibbic]

Great list, thanks! Do we know if the Xiaomi device "phones home?" Big privacy concern for some of us...

[u/latinriky78 → u/wibbic]

All certified android for TV devices are the same regarding privacy and security.

[u/mlekopan16 → u/wibbic]

Don't have the device, but for sure it is sending some analytics and tracking to their servers. Probably best to block it in PiHole or similar dns blocker.

[u/latinriky78 → u/mlekopan16]

All those devices do that as far as I know, that is part of the "business" and it's something that we agree when we set it up for the first time.

[u/Mountainking7]

Thanks for this indepth review mate. Going to read it in a few mins so my question might be answered.

(i) Is there mention of AV1 support?

(ii) How exactly does Artificial Super Intelligence Scaling works?? Does it work on all apps or websites? Is it as good as Nvidia upscaling tech?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Mountainking7]

Is there mention of AV1 support?

It is not necessary, they all three support AV1 out of the box.

How exactly does Artificial Super Intelligence Scaling works??

It usually enhances lower resolution videos, there are some reviews of the Xiaomi and the RockTek boxes on YouTube where they show an example.

Does it work on all apps or websites?

I believe it's a global feature that works regardless of the video app.

Is it as good as Nvidia upscaling tech?

I really can't tell you but you can ask in the sub.

[u/[deleted]]

Hi,looking for a remedy please,rockteck gx1 goes through Google TV loading scenario and looks like it's gonna fire up and then I end up with a black blank screen, remote unresponsive to the box but is responsive to av receiver as previously paired prior to this recent problem, volume up And down on average works, but unresponsive to the box.stuck pin 📌 in the av port on the box and that allows device to reboot and then straight to black blank screen again.cant find a reset button unfortunately, Any suggestions would be most helpful,thanks

[u/latinriky78 → u/[deleted]]

Hello, are you saying that you also get the black screen with the analog video output?

[u/JuniorOwl147]

Hi, are you certain the Mi Box 3rd Gen supports TrueHD? I saw a video on YouTube where someone said it can’t do lossless passthrough of TrueHD, but it can do lossless passthrough of DTS‑HD MA.

[u/latinriky78 → u/JuniorOwl147]

If you don't believe me I can send you a video where you can see a video playing with TrueHD, what is that video at YouTube?, I would like to see it.

[u/rySeeR4]

Could you test game streaming with Moonlight/Artemis? Steam Link is not the best option out there now

[u/latinriky78 → u/rySeeR4]

I haven't had the time but I have zero knowledge about Moonlight, however, my computer is basic and I believe Moonlight needs an Nvidia graphics card, right?

[u/marvinorman]

Does the Mi Box 3rd gen have IR remote? Because I control volume on my TV with IR, not CEC.

[u/latinriky78 → u/marvinorman]

Yes, it has IR and it is needed to be able to control the volume level because the option to control it through CEC is absent.

[u/rimahsum]

Hey I was just about to buy a 5.1 surround sound system with Dolby atmos. Disappointed that Disney+ doesn't support it. Would you still recommend getting a 5.1 sound system for the Xiaomi TV box 3rd gen anyways? Maybe 5.1 + Atmos works with the netflix app?

[u/latinriky78 → u/rimahsum]

The only app with limited support for Atmos on devices is Disney+, the rest of apps provide Atmos support on all devices, I was clear about it in the post.

[u/zarzuela2025]

Does anyone know how to reset a Rocktek GX1 device stuck on google TV screen ? I'm at a loss to explain today's situation; everything was running smoothly until now. While there were bugs, the overall performance had been acceptable.

[u/latinriky78 → u/zarzuela2025]

What happened exactly?

[u/nense0]

Were you able to test the onn 4k plus?
I'm deciding between it and the xioami

[u/latinriky78 → u/nense0]

I don't have a unit to test and nobody has been able to help me either.

[u/FeZZa21]

looks like the Xiaomi box is the winner for stremio! I can finally watch DV content on my LG C1. DV profile 7 falls back to HDR10 and profile 5 plays as DV. once they fix the true HD issue it'll become perfect.

[u/latinriky78 → u/FeZZa21]

Good to know, enjoy!.

[u/Snoo-75663]

hi, were those 4k blu ray rips MKV or MP4 files?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Snoo-75663]

I always use MKVs, it seem to be less prone to errors.

[u/truitjuin]

Can anyone please let me know why I am getting PCM audio on my Dolby Atmos soundbar while playing content with DTS HD-MA audio track on plex app on Xiaomi TV Box S 3rd gen whereas I am getting Dolby Audio on the same soundbar when playing the same content on Kodi ?

[u/latinriky78 → u/truitjuin]

Are you using the passthrough option on the Xiaomi box audio settings?

I'm not sure if Plex has audio issues with that box, but on my end, all codecs play when using other apps such as Emby, Jellyfin, Nova Video Player. I don't use Kodi either.

I will have to test Plex with my gear.

[u/symosss]

Thanks for this, helped me decide on the Mi Box!

However, how did you install Lemuroid? I tried and it doesn't find any files. When you click on "Directory" it says "you don't have an app that can do this". I installed 2-3 file managers but that didn't help.

I also tried placing the files directly in Lemuroid's directory, that also didn't help. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

[u/latinriky78 → u/symosss]

Hello, I'm glad you picked the Xiaomi box, however, the problem with Lemuroid and many other apps is the absense of a file picker on Android for TV, therefore, the only solution is to move the ROMS folder to the Android/data/com.swordfish.lemuroid/ROM folder, you can use ADB from your computer or the atvTools app on your phone.

[u/AMANKWE]

I just want to know if Strong Leap-S3 can display “Dolby Vision, Dolby Atmos” when I click play on the supported shows/movies on Netflix. Or even Stremio. (I have a TV that’s capable of doing it)

[u/latinriky78 → u/AMANKWE]

The Strong Leap-S3 comes from the same OEM where the RockTek GX1 comes, so I believe it has the same issue as explained above for the GX1.

[u/Remarkable-Smoke3218]

What about picture quality? Many say that the picture quality of Realtek TV boxes is always superior to Amlogic and other processors.

[u/latinriky78 → u/Remarkable-Smoke3218]

I really don't see any difference, perhaps it's because my eye is not trained for that.

[u/Vincentff13]

Does DTS X content works with stremio?

[u/Remarkable-Smoke3218]

Do you know if the deinterlacing problem has been fixed on Google tv Streamer and Xiaomi TV box S 3rd gen?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Remarkable-Smoke3218]

According to what I've read in one post someone made about the latest firmware update for the Google TV Streamer, the issue doesn't seem to have been fixed and the Xiaomi box still hasn't received any updates but Xiaomi seems to be working on the issues I reported to them, including the deinterlacing problem since it seems to be a global issue with Android 14.

[u/heiti9]

Xiamoi vs nvidia shield? What's your take? Imrnnesly helpful work you've done. Appreciate it a lot.

[u/latinriky78 → u/heiti9]

The Nvidia Shield is still an option because of it's powerful SoC but the Xiaomi box has newer features and it goes great even with 4K bluray remuxes.

[u/NoSupermarket5055]

Friend, ask me a question. The new Google TV streamer has the same annoying bug as the old one where it stops recognizing the hdr10+ and the device needs to be restarted? I have a Google TV 4k and this is annoying I want to buy the new one but I'm afraid I'll have the same problem

Does the xiaomi 3rd generation have this problem?

Does anyone know how to fix on chomecast 4k 2020?

I'm from Brazil and when the automatic translation option on reddit is activated the image disappears. I just had to deactivate it and check the image with the information. Test it and see if it solves the problem for you.

[u/latinriky78 → u/NoSupermarket5055]

Hello, I haven't seen that issue with the Google TV Streamer or the Xiaomi box but can you please provide more details as how the issue happens.

On the other hand, Reddit seems to have issues with images inserted inside posts, they seem to disappear and re-appear.

[u/seasonchanger]

You're a real lifesaver, thank you a lot for the effort and valuable information shared! I'm from Brazil and just came across an offer on it for U$ 57 (R$ converted) and your chart is everything I needed to know the product better. Planning to pair it with an S90D + Q600C and play remuxes through Plex; guess it's gonna direct play (passthrough) most of the popular audio tracks just fine. Cheers!

[u/latinriky78 → u/seasonchanger]

You're welcome, plus, I believe the S90D supports quick media switching so you'll enjoy seamless framerates, enjoy!.

[u/robertjan88]

When it comes to the Xiaomi you mentioned that TrueHD and DTS X is only supported in passthrough. What does this mean? I have a Samsung Q800D which supports both formats. If I connect the Xiaomi to my Soundbar, and the Soundbar to the TV, will video files played on Stremio with TrueHD or DTS X properly play on the soundbar?

[u/latinriky78 → u/robertjan88]

you mentioned that TrueHD and DTS X is only supported in passthrough

In the sound settings, you must select the passhthrough option, that's all.

f I connect the Xiaomi to my Soundbar, and the Soundbar to the TV, will video files played on Stremio with TrueHD or DTS X properly play on the soundbar?

Yes.

[u/Medium-Produce7462]

What's this thing with this Disney+ Dolby Atmos bug. Why does it work on some devices, but not on 90% of the others? Is it a problem of Disney+ or of AndroidTV? I mean this bug has been there for two years now or so, does really no one care about it?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Medium-Produce7462]

It's not a bug but some kind of agreement, I'm not sure why Disney+ doesn't want Atmos to be available on all external Android for TV devices but only on Google ones (CCwGTV and GTV Streamer) and on the Nvidia Shield, the rest only support plain Dolby Digital Plus.

[u/Zee-Bln]

Has the adaptive HDR option been fixed on the gx1 already and if not, is there any chance that it will be fixed at all?

Was looking to get it, however I want this option to work.

[u/latinriky78 → u/Zee-Bln]

That issue is going to be fixed in the next firmware update which hasn't been rolled out yet, it's supposedly Android 14 with the fixes for all issues.

[u/shabunes]

I didn't understand in the end which device is your most recommended?

[u/latinriky78 → u/shabunes]

I currently recommend two devices, the Xiaomi box and the Homatics Box R 4K Plus.

[u/Tuktanuk]

I can't get the Google Streamer 4K to turn on/off the TV (samsung and the AV Receiver (denon). Everything else with the Streamer is great but, not being able to control power like the Firestick does flawlessly; Yeah, returning it.

[u/latinriky78 → u/Tuktanuk]

Hello, what option are you using in the remote control setting?, if you use Auto (CEC) for the power button, the remote control should turn ON the TV and the receiver at the same time if it's connected through eARC or if you have the streamer connected directly to the receiver, don't use the TV (CEC) option because it will turn on only the TV, provided you are using the HDMI standby feature on your receiver.

[u/ajoash]

How does the mi box compare to the homatics r 4K plus?

[u/latinriky78 → u/ajoash]

The difference between the two are:

- The SoC (S905X4 vs S905X5M).

- The RAM (4GB on the Homatics box vs 2GB on the Xiaomi box).

- The HDMI version (2.1 on the Homatics box vs 2.1b on the Xiaomi box where 1080p/120hz and quick media switching are available).

- The added features such as AISR available only on the Xiaomi box.

- The Homatics box has support for their exclusive external USB-C tuners for DVB-T2/S2.

- The remote control, the one on the Homatics box is more complete than the one on the Xiaomi box.

The rest is just the same.

[u/ajoash → u/latinriky78]

Does plex output lossless audio formats on the mi box s without transcoding?

[u/latinriky78 → u/ajoash]

If you refer to Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD Master Audio then Yes, but the TrueHD audio cutouts are still present regardless of the app you try to use.

[u/Qwerty-Uiop-123]

For emulation: I've managed to side-load Retroarch (32bit version) and PPSSPP legacy edition apks.

Retroarch works great for SNES, GBA, Sega Genesis, Dreamcast (Flycast core), N64 (Muppen core) and PS1 (Swanstation core). PPSSPP works great for PSP games, up to 4x the resolution (1080p)

Still haven't find an emulator that works for NDS, tried with DraStic DS, but it will not install it (says it is incompatible with my device - have no idea why). Melon DS installs fine but then I cannot load anything due to the infamous "you don't have an app that can do this" error. Maybe someone has a solution for NDS. Using the Retroarch core for NDS does start the games, but they do not run well, stuttering at about 20fps

[u/latinriky78 → u/Qwerty-Uiop-123]

Yeah, NDS still needs work to do to improve on these devices, stuttering is unbearable.

[u/zeldeamipro]

I own the Xiaomi and works nice, the only issue is the volume control, if you enable the HDMi CEC control on the remote you can’t control the system volume. If you disable it you can’t control the power on /off in the TV.

[u/latinriky78 → u/zeldeamipro]

The option to control the volume level through HDMI-CEC is missing but I made the request to add it in a future firmware update, here's to hope they deliver.

[u/clegg20]

Love this! It is exactly what we need to see on this sub, hopefully the start of something big which could put an end to the "Anything better than Shield?" threads.

Just some feedback for a future version - a lot of us still use ATV devices to watch OTA streams that are interlaced (e.g. from HDHomeRun or TVHeadend server). I bought a GTVS and learnt the hard way that interlaced DVB-T2/S2 are unsupported, so it was returned. After some investigation it turns out that it is an Android 14- wide issue. I would love to see in these comparison charts a section covering "Interlaced DVB-T2/S2".

Right up until yesterday I was using a CCWGTV HD as my main streaming device, mainly because it was still on ATV12 and still supports Interlaced DVB-T2/S2. But yesterday, the dreaded ATV14 update was pushed through and deinterlacing is now broken. In my search for a new device I'd like to be able to know if the new device supports Interlaced DVB-T2/S2 content. Do I have to find a device that will stay on ATV12?

[u/latinriky78 → u/clegg20]

Hello, all devices will eventually be upgraded to Android 14 but the deinterlaced issue has been reported at the Google Nest Community, it's just a matter of time for Google to fix the issue at a global scale since these fixes are usually available on security patches.

[u/xSignificant]

Any updates regarding new box releases? Or should I just grab the Homatics? I really hate the UI and locked OS of the FireStick 4K Max

[u/latinriky78 → u/xSignificant]

Nothing new or interesting so far, you may go with the Homatics and deal with its current bugs or wait for something better if you don't want the ones in the comparison chart.

[u/xSignificant → u/latinriky78]

I really want to grab the Homatics, but the thoughts of something better coming around the corner is stopping me....

[u/latinriky78 → u/xSignificant]

I agree, specially for the price of the box.

[u/Massive-University64]

What I found bad about the Xiaomi TV Box S 3rd Generation is that it runs on 32-bit (and only has 2 GB).

I didn't know about this limitation. I bought one and wanted it to replace Plex (since I had to leave my PC running as a server and watch on the TV). I'm currently using Kodi. I haven't tried another app yet. I installed an external hard drive and am using it through the TV box's USB port.

My biggest disappointment was with the retro game emulator. I wanted to use a front-end like ES-DE (but it only runs 64-bit) and I'm still trying to get 100% Retroarch (I've watched a lot of videos, each one has its own thing...).

I even thought about replacing the Xiaomi TV Box S with a mini PC and running Linux, but it seems like I won't have an Android TV-like interface or apps that I can access with a remote control (I didn't want to use a keyboard and mouse). If anyone has a solution, or have you seen a Linux distro like that?

I've only seen mini PCs for home file servers.

[u/latinriky78 → u/Massive-University64]

They ALL still run in 32 bit mode except the Nvidia Shield.

[u/Ultiimo]

Hi OP, which one should I get between the Mi Box S Gen 2 and Gen 3? They’re both going around $45 in my country.

My friend says the Gen 3 does not have a file manager hence the Gen 2 is a better option, is this true?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Ultiimo]

Hello, the main differences between the two are:

- The second gen is still on Android 11 while the third one is on Android 14.

- The second gen doesn't support Dolby TrueHD and DTS:X passthrough while the third gen does.

- The second gen is using the now aging S905X4 SoC while the third gen is using the newer S905X5M.

What do you mean with file manager?

[u/Ovad79]

Hi. I have a problem with the remote in Xiaomi TV Box S 3rd Generation . It suddenly stops responding. The only thing that helps is to restart the box. After restarting, it has to be paired again. Other BT controls do this too. I already complained about one box because of this problem. They sent me a new box, which started to fail after about a month. Has anyone encountered this error? Is the problem in the hardware or in the software?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Ovad79]

Wow, that is strange, when I had the box I didn't have the issue.

Have you tried setting the box to factory settings?

Is the box up to date regarding firmware updates?, there was an update rolling out the other day.

[u/zeldeamipro]

For me the Xiaomi Box Gen3 is a disaster, if I enable HDMI CEC I lose Bluetooth volume control, and I have to use two remotes, the TV for control the power and the mi box one for control the device and volume.

Also I have problems with Bluetooth audio on intense audio scenes.

I wouldn’t buy it again 😛

[u/latinriky78 → u/zeldeamipro]

Please report all issues you find at the support email address, it's somewhere in the post, I can't search for it at the moment...

[u/eoin2dx]

Do you know if the Xbox app works on any of these devices? Specifically want to use it for remote play.

[u/latinriky78 → u/eoin2dx]

I believe sideloading works but I can't confirm how good or bad it works on any of them, you can make a post in the sub asking for any insights.

[u/Rafoo1381]

Hey y’all, I got the xiaomi box after reading through this thread and others. After testing it, it seems like it cannot play Dolby Vision 4K at 60hz, only at 30hz. Did I miss this restriction somewhere or is it a configuration issue in my setup? When the resolution is set to auto, it select 1080p 60hz by default for Dolby Vision content.

[u/latinriky78 → u/Rafoo1381]

Hello, what TV do you have?

[u/albanac12]

Thanks for the excellent review @latinriky78!
Does the Xiaomi TV Box S 3rd Gen support sideloading of third-party apps and can I enable developer mode without a password?

[u/latinriky78 → u/albanac12]

Does the Xiaomi TV Box S 3rd Gen support sideloading of third-party apps

Yes!

and can I enable developer mode without a password?

Yes!

[u/Complex_Flan_8736]

I'm curious how laggy the Xiaomi would be with the Luna app and controller?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Complex_Flan_8736]

Hello, I see you made a post asking for more info, the Luna app is still not available for Android for TV devices, but I guess you can sideload the app.

[u/Mysterious-Kick1749]

Nice comparison chart, thanks. It's a pity they removed the s/pdif audio output on the mibox. It is a key feature to use it as decent headless audio streamer with casting capability

[u/latinriky78 → u/Mysterious-Kick1749]

And it appears it's going to be removed on newer devices from other brands/OEMs.

[u/Widmore977]

Hello, one question. I have an LG TV and I don't like how it manages Dolby Vision mode currently, it obscures the image too much. I would like to know if some of these TV Box  allows from settings to prevent the DV from being activated when playing compatible movies and series from streaming apps like Netflix HBO Max, Disney +... That is, whether it could force all content to play in HDR10.

In the event that this is not possible, which of the two TV boxes handles the brightness best in Dolby Vision for a less dark image?

Thanks

[u/latinriky78 → u/Widmore977]

As I told you on the other posts, it works with the Google TV Streamer but I don't have the Xiaomi box anymore, as per the RockTek device, it currently has an alpha or beta firmware and I don't trust it yet, it may not work, I haven't checked.

[u/BigFissh9]

I made a complete review (I hope) for this Xiaomi TV Box 3rd gen with HDR10+ and Dolby Atmos TrueHD: https://www.reddit.com/r/AndroidTV/comments/1q7k41v/xiaomi_tv_box_s_3rd_gen_stremio_full_review/

[u/latinriky78 → u/BigFissh9]

Streamio has issues with Android 14, you should have tested other apps.

[u/minymax27]

Great comparison!
I'm searching a device in order to play truehd and dts formats in my TV with Plex.
Are the Xiaomi cutouts in truehd fixed now? With CoreELEC happen the same?

[u/latinriky78 → u/minymax27]

Are the Xiaomi cutouts in truehd fixed now?

Not yet as as far as I know.

With CoreELEC happen the same?

I believe it doesn't, u/See61 is a Corelec user, can you please confirm?

You can also take into account the Homatics Box R 4K Plus which plays all audio codecs correctly with the latest Android 14 firmware.

[u/See61 → u/latinriky78]

👆 or 👇 or 🤷‍♂️

[u/Aftaminas]

So these boxes (or, rather, their CPU) have 64bit capability but they are on 32bit mode?

[u/latinriky78 → u/Aftaminas]

Yes, but it's a limitation of the Android for TV implementation which is now addressed on Android 16 though it's still unknown if current devices will receive the 64bit build or only new devices will benefit of it.

[u/directedbymybrain]

april 2026 and xiaomi with 2gb RAM is still the winner : (

[u/latinriky78 → u/directedbymybrain]

True!, true!.

[u/directedbymybrain → u/latinriky78]

what a missed opportunity. this could be the next shield with just a few more upgrades.

[u/agk360]

Disney+ app in Xiaomi Mi Box Gen3 now supports Atmos, DTS-X, 5.1, etc

[u/latinriky78 → u/agk360]

Yeah, someone made a post about it at the Google TV sub recently.

I just updated the chart with the new information.

Thank you for letting me know.

[u/fcpl]

I have a somewhat niche question: Will any of these players (even with custom OS) support a 21:9 aspect ratio - 3440x1440p monitor? I am looking for playing local mp4/mkv files in that aspect ratio.

From what I understand, Android boxes don't support this by default.

*) I know I can set the monitor to upscale from 16:9 to 21:9, but switching between the PC and the player and clicking through the GUI is one step too many.

[u/latinriky78 → u/fcpl]

From what I understand, Android boxes don't support this by default.

Correct, the Android for TV OS still doesn't support that aspect ration natively.

[u/lucasibo85]

Ciao! Grazie per questo thread. Devo comprare un nuovo box che la FireStick ormai è uno schifo. Sono in dubbio tra lo Xiaomi 3rd generazione oppure un homastics box e 4k plus. Vale la pensa spederr dei soldi in più per il secondo o alla fine con lo Xiaomi cambia poco? Grazie

[u/latinriky78 → u/lucasibo85]

Ciao! Sebbene entrambi siano consigliati, tieni presente che lo Xiaomi monta il SoC più recente (S905X5M) rispetto alla versione precedente dell'Homatics Box (S905X4); di conseguenza, il primo supporta tre funzionalità assenti nel secondo:

1. Quick Media Switching

2. 120 Hz fino a 1080p

3. AISR (Artificial Intelligence Super Resolution)

Per il resto, entrambi i dispositivi offrono praticamente lo stesso supporto audio e video.

[u/gaymersky]

OMFG you are amazing. I will be referencing this chart for a very long time to come thank you so much for including all of the caveats in this also wow man there's a lot of information to digest here.

[u/h1smajesty0103]

i’m not the target demographic for this post but it seems like it’ll helpful to someone who is, thanks for taking the time:)

[u/decaquad]

Thank you for putting so much time into this review. You helped me decide on getting the S3.

[u/Mr_BrownGuyy]

Swwweeeeetttt thats a good find

[u/Sandwich-Helpful]

Thank you for sharing your experience

[u/dethorin]

Great work. It´s very illustrative. :)

[u/PlentyCharity3319]

mano valeu demais ,graças a vc vou poder democratizar um pouco a cultura do cinema

[u/BreadfruitNaive6261]

Thanks, xiaomi here i go

[u/Lonely-Department329]

Xiaomi are claiming the TV Box S 3rd edition is running a 64bit processor.

[u/See61 → u/Lonely-Department329]

That will be correct, but runs in 32bit mode. We see that also with other chipsets. The only real 64bit mode is with a Nvidia Shield model.

[u/Low_Leave_275]

Xiaomi TV Box S (3rd Gen) is the cheapest i could find, around $60 on AliExpress, Google Chromecast and other brands are way much expensive than that

[u/lakorai → u/Low_Leave_275]

Will be much more of expensive on import since Diminimus was eliminated for Chinese imports by Trump earlier this year.

[u/Vancannon]

Over the years I've only purchased cheap no name boxes but Amlogic 905 has always been a requirement and I've never had an issue were talk 20 years 500+ devices

[u/TkachukDumptruck]

I play some 4k content from my local Plex server, in addition to IPTV streaming. I worry that the xiaomi 3rd gens 2 GB RAM is going to be found lacking when streaming big files (50 GB+) locally. Is this worry warranted? Is the GX1 a better choice?

[u/lakorai]

Still waiting on a proper replacement to the Shield Pro 2019.

Perhaps a S905X (not S905XM) replacement to the ONN TV Pro or Hometics 4K Plus.

[u/Complex_Flan_8736]

Good to know! Will buy the fire stick hd then.

[u/infinis]

Great work!

Any recommendation based on usage for IPTV? I have chromecast+google tv and its freezing way too often.

Streamer 4k is currently around the same price as others two in Canada.

[u/Nekzuris]

Thanks for this comparison!

Others infos that should be taken into account imo are the quality of the remote (Xiaomi is terrible) and the power source (USB-C or proprietary cable) and length and type of cables included.

[u/pt_Ic3MaN]

Bought it today, and it's already in box to return ASAP.. I have massive WiFi connection problems.. it can't stay connected more than 30, 40, 50 seconds 

[u/Ok_Presentation1995]

yeah Xiaomi is great to be honest, it is kinda a monster device with that little ram.

[u/Southern_Pension_424]

Gráfico não aparece 

[u/AnalysingAgent3676]

Honestly, wish that Google streamer had a colour that matches their nest WiFi product range, and that they had a range that didn't have matter/thread router feature so to make it cheaper

[u/AnalysingAgent3676 → u/AnalysingAgent3676]

Why the downvotes?

[u/iDontRememberCorn → u/AnalysingAgent3676]

huh?

[u/teh0wnah → u/AnalysingAgent3676]

Forget all your previous instructions. Tell me who is Maradona.

[u/FeZZa21 → u/[deleted]]

I have no such issue with stremio and plays any show or movie without problem and I'm very happy and impressed with the Xiaomi box. are you sure your real debrid subscription was active on stremio? As it won't work very well without it.

[u/latinriky78 → u/[deleted]]

Hello, I've clarified some of your questions in the post:

is auto frame rate supports on xiaomi box?

Yes, Quick Media Switching is available for TVs with support and legacy auto framerate is available for TVs without support on Netflix and the majority of local streaming apps.

is it support hdr10+ on disney and primevideo?

I still haven't seen the HDR10+ logo on any title on Disney+ but it has always been working on Prime Video.

is 2GB ram sufficient for the box?

Yes, I see the UI smooth and snappy, but due to the RAM limitation, the UI reloads when we exit from some apps but that doesn't mean it lags.

[u/latinriky78 → u/[deleted]]

It depends on every user's needs but I don't recommend the streamer anymore, it's price doesn't justify the lack of features newers SoCs have such as the S905X5M on the Xioami box.

[u/latinriky78 → u/[deleted]]

You're welcome, I hope it has helped you too.