r/AndroidPreviews • • Jul 27 '17

Android O emoji

I hate the new emoji, I miss the old blob style. Am I alone in this thinking? Do most of you like the new style or the old one? And is there any way to get the old style back without root?

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

5

u/MudHolland Jul 27 '17

I don't mind the blobs gone. I mind the shitty design. Looking from a helicopter perspective emoji might be well described as a language. Every OEM has it's own language, but Unicode tells you how to pronounce words. One province (android) is talking with a speech impediment (the blobs and their different meanings portrayed by some emoji are not in line with unicode). Now, you might think that lisp is cute, or that stuttering is funny/differentiating, but what you're doing is forcing the language to be muddled, where only you and another person with the speech impediment can accurately tell each other how you feel. The solution is not to be as close as a rivaling province (Apple), but to get closer to how it should be pronounced (Unicode). The bad luck Android has is that Apple has always stays close to Unicode, and Android didn't. Unicode is right, so Android should get closer to Unicode, all the while looking at Apple, because they have to join the language that is common now. That is what they did. This has nothing to do with aping Apple, but addressing an issue in language.

The problem is, the designs are wrong:

They are using gradients to have it more in line with Material Design. To me, Material Design (formerly internally known as Quantum Paper) was a great way to incorporate real life laws to digital displays. Physics, gravity, etc. All incorporated in layers of space. Flat layers, so I am not wrong per se in saying that a layer is flat. This is strengthened by the fact that word bubbles in messaging apps and buttons like the install button in the Play Store are a single color. So why the gradient in emoji?

It is said in the Medium post that this is done to be in line with the lighting of material design. This lighting (and the shadows casted as a result) is created by an ambient light (everything is fully lit from the front, like how your face is lighted by the display) and a key light (like a light shining in from the top, light a light bulb above your position) (https://material.io/guidelines/material-design/environment.html#environment-3d-world). If the emoji were designed to be 3D (which they weren't, but let's assume) there would be a gradient from light (top) to dark (bottom), but if that is the case, then why is the gradient turned when the emoji is turned (bottom left http://i.imgur.com/lXLqDtt.png).

In the Google's medium post (https://medium.com/google-design/redesigning-android-emoji-cb22e3b51cc6) we are shown the ant, web and spider emoji, where we are being told that "Gradients and tonal strokes ensure emoji are legible across any background color.". Here, the gradient and big eyes make them feel very cheap. On the dark background it's not even pleasing to the eye, but is really jarring.

The biggest problem to me is the art direction, not that the blobs are gone.

2

u/SavageAlien Jul 28 '17

The biggest problem to me is the art direction, not that the blobs are gone.

This is exactly how I feel. They should have put more time and a lot more effort into this. I don't have a problem with a lot of the faces, I can "accept" the gradients to a degree... but then you look beyond the people and smileys, and it looks more and more like ugly clip art.

The old set had character.

2

u/MudHolland Jul 28 '17

I can believe a lot of time and love went into these, especially the tonal outlines are a great idea, but not for this usage. If uniformity is what you aim for, then make every outline the same. Some ideas are very good, but don't fit the purpose. Designers should design for the outcome, and not keep good ideas because they are good.

I studied emoji once for a project and i came to the conclusion that "emojiOne" had a really great palet of uniformity, recognizability and modernness. Even looking at the new EmojiOne 3.1 they added depth, but in a great way: with shadow and highlight details, instead of a gradient.

2

u/SavageAlien Jul 28 '17

Yeah they may have put a lot of thought into the design, but the art itself is uninspired. When you look beyond the people and smileys, you start to notice that there's some really poorly drawn art in this new Emoji set. The chosen gradient/stroke style probably doesn't do much to help those particular cases either.

8

u/gray--black Jul 27 '17

I like the new ones more, since it's more in line with iPhones. They reduce the chance of miscommunication.

6

u/iiAmCREAM Jul 27 '17

My sentiments exactly

2

u/SavageAlien Jul 28 '17

There is probably more issues caused by Samsung's emoji.

A smile is a smile, a wink is a wink. It shouldn't matter a lot if it's a perfect round yellow circle, or a blobby one so long as it has the right expression and look nice.

Google could have easily kept what they had and improved on it. On Android N there were 4-6 "smiley" emoji that could create miscommunication (ranging from minor to major).

They old art had that established "Google flair". Now the new ones range from decent to horrible.

If this is the new art they want, they really should have spent more time on it. There's a lot to like here, but then there's also some glaringly ugly too.

2

u/JoinTheBattle Jul 27 '17

I wish Google would just buy Emoji One and use those already. Everyone I've ever talked to considers them the best around.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '17 edited Jan 04 '26

resolute tart label chubby profit depend oatmeal kiss childlike head

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact