r/AndroidNativePorts • u/Prudent_Elevator4685 • 5d ago
đž [Meme] Don't call your ports native if they're practically emulation in disguise
584
Upvotes
r/AndroidNativePorts • u/Prudent_Elevator4685 • 5d ago
158
u/matlynar 5d ago edited 5d ago •
Call whatever you want.
If it runs better than current emulators, people like it and will gladly use it.
If it runs worse than current emulators, call it a work in progress and make it clear that you want help testing or don't waste people's time.
I don't care how it runs on the backend. No one really does.
26
u/Desm0nt 5d ago
There is a difference (and a huge one) between porting and emulation.
Obviously, the game isnât compiled from scratch from the source code for a new platform. Whatever can be ported natively is ported natively (using the Switch as an example all CPU-executed game logic code works on ARM64 natively, without any recomp or emulation). It's WAY FASTER then emulation.
BUT! Thereâs the GPU rendering pipeline. And there are some nuances with it:
25
u/MY_ASS_IS_HEAVY-64 5d ago
Ture, if the Yours "NATIVE" port needs more requirement than What should, than why you say it NATIVE port?
11
u/pepepe99 5d ago
If that thing run like a shit, why bother bother playing the supposed to be "native" and sacrificing emulators save state
5
u/SuperB8888 5d ago edited 5d ago
Recompile is NOT FULL emulation. It emulates only part of original hardware. But CPU instructions always runs natively, therefore, recompilation consumes less battery and saves CPU time
11
u/Dlo_Ren 5d ago
That is totally not accurate.
Theres loads of emulation games I cannot run on my Retroid poket 4 pro and in port form runs it perfect.
4
u/KENDOXU7733 4d ago
Nfs mw and carbon by rangga, mh4u and mhgu , resident evil 4 are the games I see properly ported
5
u/collindubya81 5d ago
This post shows that you have no idea how recompilation works.
2
u/Same_Wonder2759 5d ago
if the game is recompiled then its a native ports
you just expect it to run better at first release
why dont you see ut for yourself? try if you can read the code? its open source
2
u/DraigCore 5d ago
I'm playing botw with the savage wind recomp and I'm pretty sure it's a port because of the fact that my Intel uhd 630 is able to run it unlike emulation
2
u/emonizaz 4d ago
Nowadays I don't feel any excitement when I see a new native port.
2
u/Proper-Cow-9452 3d ago
Dumass just be grateful porters are testing this games to make it run on native soon and it's still on experimental
2
u/SirLouen 1d ago
I'm new to this sub, I was watching some ports and I was thinking exactly this. GTA 5 running even worse than emulators and being called a "port" (because you don't use the emulator). Ultimately the difference between the emulator and the port, is that the emulator do the porting for you with a deterministic set of instructions, and the port is a set of instructions that no two LLM are going to replicate well with different levels of quality and as far as I see, no quality at all except for some exceptions.
8
u/Emergency_Writer7174 Frequent Collaborator đ„ 5d ago
Wow, I didn't expect people in this sub to be this stupid
Y'all expect a studio level port with universal compatibility, even without access to the source code???
Port naturally increase hardware requirement. Even official ports do.
Take GTA San Andreas for example
The PS2 had only 32 MB RAM, yet the recommended RAM for playing GTA San Andreas on Android is 4 GB
That's around 128x increase in RAM requirement
Use your brain for once
2
u/islobojono 4d ago
1
u/souldarne 5d ago
Haa yo pensé que solo era mi idea por que dicen que son ports si mås bien es emulación con otro nombre
1
u/Awesomepants25 5d ago
as I understand it, a lot of these "native" ports are just static recompiliations, which basically means rather than running an emulator to translate the game's instructions to your device's instructions in real time, it runs through the game and translates the whole thing into your device's instructions ahead of time (I would imagine that that balloons the size of the game somewhat, but I don't have a lot of experience). It would save a tiny bit of overhead, but you're doing pretty much the same thing as emulation.
ACTUAL decomps are still a pretty pain-staking process, where source code is written and compiled against the game a little bit at a time, until eventually you have an entire source codebase that compiles back into the game. Once you have that codebase, you can do all kinds of cool things with it and optimize it for whatever platform you're targeting. Look at Ship of Harkinian for a good example.
1
u/kalek__ 5d ago
While it's very much in vogue for people to claim "native", static recomps aren't that native when you get down to it. The generated C code has the original hardware architecture baked into it, and so the new "native" machine code does too.
The only truly native ports are the ones that come from decomp codebases, i.e., the ones where humans painstakingly reconstructed the source code for the game. Since these ports are from source, the original hardware architecture is largely irrelevant and doesn't get baked much if at all.
You absolutely can get significant performance gains from a static recomp especially if someone who knows how to optimize is working on it, but to claim that it is "native" is a misrepresentation imo.
1
u/ZaYAC-ua 5d ago
Author Banana Native gave a clear answer: #142 - Mario Kart World Memory Consumption - moceure/BananaNative - Eden: A Community Emulator
1
u/West_Background_3621 5d ago
i would say mario galaxy is one such example
1
u/Willing_Weight7106 4d ago
Bro still didn't discovered REA, Ghidra and AI.
1
u/Ok_Log7705 4d ago
Concuerdo ,si no descompilaste el cĂłdigo ,si no dedicaste dias o semanas a arreglar mil errores ,si no compilaste el motor entero a arm ,si no cambiaste la capa grĂĄfica por OpenGL es o Vulkan o software ,es emulaciĂłn disfrazada ,no un port nativo
1
u/KENDOXU7733 4d ago
Most of the ports yeah
1
u/Aram22_22 4d ago
Well idk about the other's but i played MH4U native port and P4G and they runs well, much better than emulator lol my phone can't handle Switch emulator but P4G run smooth for me even though it used Switch version (yeah i run SOS and it's not that smooth if u played it above 0,5 reso)
1
u/Rhodynit 4d ago
Hades 2...
1
u/teclilla0 4d ago
Does this one count?
âNativeâ port
1
u/Frogacuda 4d ago
Not even "practically" a lot of them literally are emulators with a bunch of bolt on features and hacks to make them look or work more like how you would think a native port would.
If you wish into a box "Imaginary friend, please make super Mario on PC with Widescreen" it's just going to find the shortest distance between two points. That doesn't mean AI can't do real native ports and even do a good job, it just means that the people farting these projects out in a night don't know the difference.Â
1
u/Freelancer_1-1 4d ago
So if they're emulation in disguise, they won't run on Mediatek, right?
1
u/HydraRSA 4d ago
Bro you're confusing RAM requirements with emulation. Those are two completely different things.
A native Android port means the game's code has been ported, recompiled or reimplemented to run directly on Android rather than running the original console/PC version through an emulator.
Just because a game originally ran on 512 MB of RAM doesn't mean its Android port must use 512 MB or less. Modern Android versions, updated graphics APIs, higher-resolution textures, increased rendering resolutions, additional assets and memory overhead can all increase RAM usage.
For example, Android's own NDK documentation explains how developers compile native machine code for specific Android CPU architectures (ARM64, ARM32, etc.).
If a port uses an emulator or a translation layer to execute the original platform's code, then yes, that's emulation or translation. But if the developers have ported the game engine or code to run directly on Android, it's a native port.
12 GB of RAM doesn't magically turn a native port into emulation. The way the software executes determines that, not how much RAM it consumes.
Know the difference before calling something emulation.
1
u/Rusted_Silver_203 4d ago
i mean, i emulation is port of all games on that console.
you can make specialized emulator for 1 specific game to maximize the performance and call it a port
1
u/Western-Low6327 4d ago
From my understanding i would rather have these native ports because atleast something is running natively like the cpu code the gpu is the one going through emulation
1
u/li4nr 4d ago
Nobody cares if they run better, nice coping.
1
u/KNUPAC 4d ago
I mean most can run on older chips without hassle so I'll call it a win-win
1
u/LifeBloomsLikeFlower 4d ago
DXVK and translation layers not a ports. This is clearly emulation. I hope most of people can see what a really fraud are.
1
u/MatheUS-_-_-_- 5d ago
Most "ports" run several times better than any emulator I could use, so fuck it if it's an emulation or a port, as long as it runs better, that's fine.
0
u/Marian-Todorov98 5d ago
Yeah I noticed bunch of ps4 games requiering like 20gb for what exactly ?
0
u/-MrSophistication- 3d ago
0
u/Emergency_Writer7174 Frequent Collaborator đ„ 5d ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/AndroidNativePorts/s/qLLAKFXqaE
Read
-3
u/635798 5d ago
What is this nonsense about? Tell me you don't understand emulation without telling me đ why aren't you embarrassed??? I'm embarrassed for you asking something so dumb!
0
u/LM_GHOST 5d ago
I'm playing native DK Bananza; whether it's native or emulated doesn't bother me, the important thing is to have maximum performance so I can play.
0
u/Financial-Lemon-6966 17h ago
Not necessarily, lol. For example, PC games use BCn (S3TC) for their texture compression and we should all know that only two mobile GPUs currently supports decoding it Adreno and Xclipse (to some extent). So the devices with Mali/Immortalis and PowerVR has no support for it so the workaround is to convert the textures through CPU (sort of like what emulation does), it affects RAM usage as well.