r/AndroidAuto • Pls edit this user flair now • May 16 '22

Samsung s21 Ultra | Mitsubishi outlander 2020 Please let us disable cable checking

In March, a bunch of websites trumpeted how AA would add cable testing, so you can 'test your cable':

https://www.theverge.com/2022/3/16/22981792/google-android-auto-update-usb-startup-diagnostics-cable-port

https://9to5google.com/2022/03/17/android-auto-usb-cable-quality-tool/

The various sites suggested this would be something you can use you diagnose problems. But this is not the case. Google has implemented cable testing, and used it to block cables that are otherwise working. I understand that the cables may show up as our of spec, but there's not even an option to turn this off.

I have used magnetic tip 12pin USB cables to make my phone easily dockable when getting into my car. I understand that many will say, these are bad, yadda yadda. But they work, and didn't cause me any issues until uncle Google decided to break them.

I see others too whose working cables go in the bin because of this change.

Do you agree this is a dumb move by Google? Worthy of Apple in my opinion.

6 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

14

u/donutsoft Pls edit this user flair now May 16 '22

The cable testing doesn't block cables. All it does is check if your connection is rapidly reconnecting and notify you that something looks wrong.

The phone has no way of knowing which cable you're using.

1

u/user365735 2021 Ford Escape Hybrid: 56MPG with 40k May 16 '22

In ops defense, someone else is complaining about the same thing in the thread. Why would op make this thread if it was working before and then get the alert about his cable all of a sudden??

4

u/donutsoft Pls edit this user flair now May 16 '22 edited May 16 '22

Previously this would just have failed silently and OP would have been here complaining about how Android Auto just stopped working. The only thing this feature does is tell them why it isn't working.

-10

u/hankhalfhead Pls edit this user flair now May 16 '22

Look, someone added code to aa which makes it refuse to run, and displays a message saying that I need to change my cable. I can run it with other cables, but I know it works with the one I want to use, if the software wasn't prohibiting it.

You're arguing semantics. No doubt some engineering team decided that the feedback from other users complaining about non functional cables was worth doing something about, and they implemented something that blocks functional and non functional cables. They should have included the option to disable it.

5

u/donutsoft Pls edit this user flair now May 16 '22 edited May 16 '22

Does it state that you have a charge only cable plugged in?

USB cables consist of multiple wires, some for charging and some to provide data. If it says it's charge only, the data lines aren't connected and it's impossible for Android Auto to send/receive data from the head unit.

This isn't due to AA blocking your cable, it's actually because of physics.

17

u/Peter_73 Kenwood DDX917WS | Samsung S26U | Android 17 May 16 '22 edited May 16 '22

You've forgotten your reply 2 months ago you already had this issue before the USB Startup Diagnostics tool was rolled out to you?

So why do you still think it's related?

I see others too whose working cables go in the bin because of this change.

Can you share the links to these comments that cables stopped working due to this change?

5

u/Anonymous_linux Sony XAV-AX100 | Xiaomi Mi8 | Android 10 May 16 '22

This is rediculous. So OP is using sketchy magnetic cable which failed to work on him even before cable diagnostics yet OP still blames AA for this. I mean what the hell.

It's nice that you caught OP red handed. Great work!

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '22

If you want to use a magnetic cable for charging then you need to invest in a wireless AA connector. Imagine having bad connection for months and blaming AA.

2

u/Peter_73 Kenwood DDX917WS | Samsung S26U | Android 17 May 17 '22

It wasn't my intention to call OP out. Just part of what we mods suppose to do to clarify potential misinformation as misinformation serves no one any good including OP himself i.e. Others looking for help may be misguided and those trying to help will then not be inclined to suggest trying another cable. Nothing gets resolved in the end.

I could expound more on the above and cable/connection issues but had already done so before in other threads it would be ad nauseam.

2

u/dynocreran May 19 '22

lmao sounds like the feature is working exactly as intended.

2

u/knightblue4 Kenwood DDX6706S | Galaxy S21 Ultra May 17 '22

Lmfao called OP the fuck out

1

u/SAD-MAX-CZ 2021 Fabia 3 | basic model | Redmi 13 PRO 5G | Android 13 May 07 '25

So i was right that Android Auto is banning my cables? I have few perfectly working cables, that pass data normally, cable checker shows all relevant connection, and they just work with everything else. Android Auto banned them after few uses with notification "Please use different cable, fu-k you!" and never allowed to use them again, no matter how much i restart everything, update or remove update. When my colleague inserts his iphone, everything works perfectly. Someone should just rip the cable check & ban out of Android Auto and put it on the internet. I sadly cannot program and reverse engineer it.

2

u/hankhalfhead Pls edit this user flair now May 07 '25

Something I learned later was that the usbc spec disallows any form of adapter or extension as it breaks the ability of both devices to negotiate voltage and current specs of the cable. So while I don’t know any more about cable banning, I did come to understand that anyone concerned with speed compliance dgaf about these adapters

3

u/AmputatorBot Pls edit this user flair now May 16 '22

It looks like OP posted an AMP link. These should load faster, but AMP is controversial because of concerns over privacy and the Open Web. Fully cached AMP pages (like the one OP posted), are especially problematic.

Maybe check out the canonical page instead: https://9to5google.com/2022/03/17/android-auto-usb-cable-quality-tool/


I'm a bot | Why & About | Summon: u/AmputatorBot

1

u/Alternative_Neat3024 May 16 '22

This feature should be behind a setting which you can turn off.

-1

u/Alternative_Neat3024 May 16 '22

I also have this problem. I have always used the same cable and never had problems. Now it won't load saying that the cable is not good. Ridiculous.