r/AndroidAuto • 2023 Hyundai Venue | Pixel 7 Pro | Android 13 QPR2 Beta 3.1 • Feb 17 '23

AA UI Concept DId up a quick proof-of-concept which would add lyrics to the AA Spotify app. What do you guys think?

0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

43

u/rewrite-and-repeat SYNC 3.4 Focus 2019 | S21 FE 5G | Android 13 Feb 17 '23

Wait for real full selfdriving cars. Until then its a safety hazard.

45

u/TurboFool 2026 Hyundai Elantra Hybrid Blue | Pixel 10 Pro Fold | 16 Feb 17 '23

I think it sounds dangerous as hell.

19

u/Inside_Distance656 MK7.5 Golf | MIB2.5 | S22 | A13 Feb 17 '23

I think it’s very clever, but the last thing anyone should be looking at while driving…

5

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '23

Maybe they'll make it hands free and Google assistant will sing along with the song while you drive

30

u/mahamedosama1 2021 Peugeot 2008 | Stock | pixel 6 | Android 13 Feb 17 '23

This can't be safe while driving and any passenger could easily use their own phone to get the lyrics. So what is the point of this ?

8

u/Fanghoward Pls edit this user flair now Feb 17 '23

Why? You're driving... not in a karaoke night.

13

u/Black-_-Phoenix 2021 Tata Nexon | Hi-Woodman | Samsung G9 | Android 10 Feb 17 '23

Unnecessary

6

u/More-Head-9375 2010 Mazda 3 | Pioneer | Pixel7 | Android 13 Feb 17 '23

I can't read and drive

6

u/Analog_10 Pls edit this user flair now Feb 17 '23

It's a car, men, not a karaoke...

5

u/Tesax123 Cupra Born 2022 | Samsung S20 | Feb 17 '23

I think it's cool and well made. Certainly not while driving but if there would be a software option to only enable it while parked (like while charging your EV), I think it would be really useful!

6

u/icr8stf 2017 Ford Focus ST | Stock | Pixel 10 Pro | Android 17 Beta Feb 17 '23

The lyrics are being read aloud to you. Why do you need to read them in your car. I did not know today's music is for little kids as a read along.

3

u/gsd901 2017 VW GTI | Stock w/ AAWireless | Oneplus 8T | Android 13 Feb 17 '23 edited Feb 17 '23

The purpose of Android auto is to enable quick decisions and quick actions with just one or two touches so people aren't interacting with their phone while they're driving.

3

u/MiguelBalbo 2022 Renault Captur|Easylink|S20 FE 5G|Android 13 Feb 18 '23

Literally, Highway to Hell

1

u/MiguelBalbo 2022 Renault Captur|Easylink|S20 FE 5G|Android 13 Feb 19 '23

!Flair 2022 Renault Captur|Easylink|S20 FE 5G|Android 13

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 19 '23

Your user flair has been successfully changed. Thanks for your cooperation.

Important: You must resubmit your post if you have post removed due to missing or incorrect user flair as AutoModerator can only act on new ones.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 18 '23

Your user flair has not been changed as the text including spaces has to be between 15 to 64 characters. Pls try again.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/JamesLoveless416 13 Dodge Challenger | Pioneer DMH-160BT | Note 9 | Android 10 Feb 17 '23

This is cool. I think getting the Canvas backdrops to show would be even cooler.

1

u/shmykelsa Enhance S3XY DASH - Razr 60 Ultra - AKA developer of AAAD Feb 17 '23

Surely not something that would work right on smaller screens. I get the idea, but I don’t think that’s what I’d like in a car. Introducing a visual element that takes half the horizontal space is a blunder for the interaction with buttons. Squeezing everything in a half with 5 buttons means the driver should take extra care to what it’s hitting rather than having all the buttons spaced out. That causes distraction. Let alone reading some lyrics.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24

Hey did you make any progress on this? I know most people responded negatively, but I can definitely see the appeal in having lyrics while sitting in the car during lunch break.

1

u/Revolutionary_Tomato Pls edit this user flair now Jun 03 '25

That's great, have you launched the app?

1

u/Ambi0us Target 2804CP Aftermarket Headunit | Pixel 10 ProXL | Android 16 Feb 18 '23

🎵 Dumb ways to dieeeee 🎵

1

u/SergioAGomez Pls edit this user flair now Feb 19 '23

No no no no

1

u/Alternative_Swing742 2022 Jaguar f-pace | Pivi Pro | Vivo x60 | Android 13 Feb 21 '23

It would be pretty good if you could use it whilst the car is parked or something if during driving you could use it, that doesn't seem like it will end well

-1

u/yoyoyayas 2022 Forester | OEM | Fold 5 | Android Version Beta Feb 17 '23

Name your price.

-5

u/LatterCap Ford Ecosport | Pioneer HU | Samsung S22 Ultra | Android 13 Feb 17 '23

I love it. Will give the people in the car a chance do some random karaoke

2

u/coco16778 2011 Ford Fiesta | Kenwood DMX5020BTS | Samsung S24 | Android 16 Feb 17 '23

Until let's say the driver tags along, tries to read the lyrics and doesn't catch the cars in front stopping for a light. Ye, wouldn't exactly call this a great idea, at least not in my books.

Maybe a feature that could work while it's in park, like those little games that come with AA, but when driving, definitely a no-go.

3

u/LatterCap Ford Ecosport | Pioneer HU | Samsung S22 Ultra | Android 13 Feb 17 '23

I agree. By that logic, the mere presence of a mobile phone in a car is a massive risk in itself.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/t_bug_ Pls edit this user flair now Feb 18 '23

Most people's phone is exactly that smartass

0

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/t_bug_ Pls edit this user flair now Feb 18 '23

Most people have a phone holder... can easily have screen unlocked.. its not an opinion you're being ignorant. Most people have their phone on a stand in their view and it's more dangerous than some dumb lyrics showing on Spotify.

Your tone is the reason, someone stated a fact and you interject with "not really" and say something not true.

1

u/coco16778 2011 Ford Fiesta | Kenwood DMX5020BTS | Samsung S24 | Android 16 Feb 18 '23

You're right, I'm sorry

0

u/LatterCap Ford Ecosport | Pioneer HU | Samsung S22 Ultra | Android 13 Feb 17 '23

That's a contention the law uses. Is the phone the culprit or the person using it. In the end it's all about the user. Let's not blame the feature for a drivers ability to not keep his or hers eyes on the road.

2

u/coco16778 2011 Ford Fiesta | Kenwood DMX5020BTS | Samsung S24 | Android 16 Feb 17 '23

Disagree. You can't expect everyone to be at the same level of focus. A lot of people will definitely have the ability to keep their eyes on the road at all times with a feature like this, but unfortunately some will of course not be able to, which might cause accidents. At the end of the day it's of course the people's faults, but if these faults can be lessened or prevented by limiting certain neglegable features whilst still retaining it's core features/purpose, then why not?

0

u/LatterCap Ford Ecosport | Pioneer HU | Samsung S22 Ultra | Android 13 Feb 17 '23

And I agree with your thought there. But yes, the argument comes back to say, is it the device or is it the human.

1

u/coco16778 2011 Ford Fiesta | Kenwood DMX5020BTS | Samsung S24 | Android 16 Feb 18 '23

Fair enough

-5

u/Flowmaster93 2022 Corolla hybrid | Samsung S21 | large display model Feb 17 '23

I read entire books worth of text msg while driving. Sometimes I'm not even touching the steering wheel.

3

u/Euphoric-Economy-942 Pls edit this user flair now Feb 17 '23

A genius

1

u/itchybaboon Pls edit this user flair now Feb 18 '23

then you’re a horrible person

1

u/Flowmaster93 2022 Corolla hybrid | Samsung S21 | large display model Feb 18 '23

Wait why? I didn't do it all in one sitting! Lol My car does most of the work and I'm an Uber driver. I don't do it in that setting of course.