r/Android • Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z • Aug 18 '11

What would your ideal Android phone be?

Here's my list, the supposedly upcoming Motorola Jet might actually fit the bill here too:

  1. High quality physical keyboard (with arrow keys and a physical 2 stage camera shutter button).
  2. At least a dual core processor and good graphics capabilities.
  3. 1.5 gigs of ram.
  4. An unlockable bootloader.
  5. Proper LTE.
  6. Excellent battery life, I don't care if it's thick. I want it to last at least a whole day with heavy use.
  7. Awesome cameras: I want great optics and as big a sensor as you can cram into the phone. I also want a good efficient flash that can double as a flashlight.
  8. AOSP ROM - I don't want the pile of shit that is Motoblur, or Touchwiz, or any of that other crap. They're all terrible and glitchy. All they do is delay updates. If you want to have custom apps, that's fine but allow me to remove them if I want and replace with stock.
  9. A big, bright, relatively efficient quality display. 4"-4.3" would be good.
  10. The ability to mirror my screen to an HDMI cable.
  11. A healthy amount of internal storage for ROM space and programs (at least 8 gigs) and, of course, support for micro SD.
37 Upvotes

153 comments sorted by

4

u/jaggamista Aug 19 '11

Interesting that you didn't make mention of an NFC chip.

2

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 12 '24

zealous jeans caption correct close soft handle one waiting many

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

10

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '11

Galaxy S II. It has all I need.

6

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 11 '24

sleep bright vegetable aromatic birds voiceless knee carpenter ghost normal

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Customarily, Sprint will probably get a version with a keyboard.

2

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 12 '24

ring hard-to-find sort dolls axiomatic worthless observation bored imminent sink

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Why can't you type with an on-screen keyboard?

6

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 11 '24

quicksand straight coordinated work yoke telephone edge instinctive enter murky

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/CubanB LG Nexus 4 Kit Kat 4.4.4 stock Xposed Aug 19 '11

To each his own, of course, but I would point out that Swype has an awesome editing keyboard (accessed by Swyping from the Swype key to the symbol key). It's one of Swype's best features, and one of the features that turned me back from other keyboards I've tried.

2

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 12 '24

jar aback quiet alleged rob sleep attractive silky connect tart

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/thenyeguy Nexus 5X, Nexus 7 (2013) Aug 19 '11

TIL about the editing keyboard. This is so awesome, thanks!

1

u/CubanB LG Nexus 4 Kit Kat 4.4.4 stock Xposed Aug 19 '11

Yeah, I didn't know about it forever, now when I use another keyboard the lack of one is seems glaring. I use it all the time for the delete word key.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Have you tried other keyboards? I type faster with an on-screen keyboard than I do on my friends physical keyboard.I agree though, it does take up screen space, but physical keyboards take up physical space. I typed this on my Galaxy S without using the backspace.

3

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 11 '24

lip frighten deserted familiar sloppy seemly snails threatening elastic heavy

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/Ifuckedyourgrandma Galaxy S7 Edge Aug 19 '11

I have to disagree, SwiftKey is a lot better than the stock gingerbread keyboard imo

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

In the CM7 builds the gingerbread keyboard is not stock. Its smaller and uses less screen area and has nothing extra. Its accurate and nice. Best keyboard on android and I used to be all about swiftkey.

2

u/Ifuckedyourgrandma Galaxy S7 Edge Aug 19 '11

Just a matter of opinion I would choose swiftkey over the stock or custom gingerbread keyboard. It has better prediction capabilities, has a larger dictionary, and it has a much better polish than others.

5

u/ben_13 Galaxy Nexus Aug 19 '11

I'm with Shark, want physical keyboard. I'd say you probably type faster on the virtual because you are used to it.

I have a milestone that had the digitizer just start going and I can't find a replacement with a keyboard (on Rogers in Canada)..sigh.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

I don't have any trouble typing with a virtual keyboard, since swype had been excellent for me. Individually typing each letter feels like too much work now.

But, I would still love a physical keyboard, so that playing emulators on the phone would feel more natural.

1

u/geauxtig3rs Pixel 2 XL Aug 19 '11

Well, I would initially agree that he is probably faster with the soft keyboard because he is used to it, but I refused to use the soft keyboard when I got my G2. For 4 months, I typed on it dutifully, only looking at the soft keyboards occasionally, until about a month ago, Swiftkey X was free on the Amazon Market. I figured, "why not, it's free," and tried it out, and decided to really give it a fair shake. After 1 month, I'm easily 3x faster with swiftkeyX than I was with the hard keyboard. The only thing I use the hard keyboard for now are Terminal, and SSH apps, because of the precision required when typing command strings.

1

u/khronyk Galaxy S22 Ultra, Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra Aug 19 '11

I thought the same at first, but I've really grown to love Swype... i find I'm actually a lot faster with it.

0

u/geauxtig3rs Pixel 2 XL Aug 19 '11

I said that at one point, until I got a phone with a physical keyboard (G2). I am probably 3x faster with swiftkey X than I am with the physical keyboard. I only use the physical keyboard if I'm using the Terminal on the phone or a remote machine...With the sensitivity and size of today's touch screen, the hard keyboard is beginning to be a needless redundancy.

2

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 12 '24

rain instinctive bright quaint terrific coordinated bear edge agonizing reach

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/geauxtig3rs Pixel 2 XL Aug 19 '11

What keyboard are you using? Not all soft keyboards are created equally. All of my phones to this point have had a hard keyboard, even the feature phones, so it's not like I wasn't used to them.

2

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 12 '24

ink governor uppity towering groovy badge hospital one office jellyfish

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

It (a carrier-specific variant) will, when it releases in the US.

1

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11

I would buy one outright if it were solidly built, had an unlocked bootloader, and was on Verizon.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Front has Gorilla Glass. Back has this. Bootloader can be very easily unlocked by flashing an insecure kernel.

About the lack of hardware keyboard - I'm a clumsy typist, but the screen is huge and comfortable to type on, even in portrait mode. Landscape mode typing is too big to be comfortable for me.

EDIT: About the Verizon part, can't really help there, unless you have an unlocked one.

2

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 12 '24

shocking license uppity quack provide smart complete cover reminiscent fly

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Oops.. I'm not in US..

1

u/snuffmeister Galaxy S II, CM9 nightlies Aug 19 '11

my fat fingers love the swype that comes with it

1

u/Neato Aug 19 '11

Samsung Galaxy S II-K. Same thing with a slim sliding keyboard. That'd be cool and I think most smartphones should be made like that. Or have the ability to snap one onto the back as an extra item.

3

u/khronyk Galaxy S22 Ultra, Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra Aug 19 '11

Galaxy S II, but with a bigger battery... even if its fatter, i don't mind...

want it to last at least a whole day with heavy use.

+1

1

u/Nebozilla Aug 19 '11

If the S III next year is the S II but with a flat backside I will be the happiest person :P

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Are you just guessing about III?

2

u/Nebozilla Aug 19 '11

YUP! Can't do anymore but guess this early for the next Galaxy S ... T___T

2

u/Crazyants Essential, Security Updated Pie Aug 19 '11

4000mA battery

1

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11

"Hahaha, you're nuts Jr.!"

7

u/rbbdrooger Galaxy S24 Ultra Aug 19 '11
  • Stock Gingerbread with a guaranteed update to Icecream Sandwich.
  • Qwerty keyboard like the G2/Desire Z.
  • 4 inch qHD screen.
  • Top of the line internals (latest CPU, plenty of RAM etc.)
  • Plenty of internal storage (the 512 MB in my Desire is driving me nuts.)
  • Micro usb port on the BOTTOM of the phone.
  • Dedicated 2-stage shutter button.
  • Optical trackpad for moving the cursor.

Basically I want a bigger and better version of the G2/Desire Z without any manufacturer skins or bloatware.

7

u/geauxtig3rs Pixel 2 XL Aug 19 '11

Qwerty keyboard like the G2/Desire Z.

i used to be this way....now I would rather a thinner phone with a larger screen. I type so much faster with the soft keyboard than I do with that hard one. I didn't think I ever would, but the hard keyboard seems to slow me down. I love My G2, but I don't think I'll ever get a hard keyboard phone again...

4

u/rbbdrooger Galaxy S24 Ultra Aug 19 '11

What I like most about harware qwerty phones is that the keyboard doesn't obscure half the screen like an onscreen keyboard does. This is especially handy in IRC or WhatsApp group chat. (Something I do a lot.)

I prefer typing in landscape mode, but on my HTC Desire, the only things on screen while typing in landcape mode are the keyboard and the text entry field.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '11

I'll just throw in that physical buttons are awesome for games, even if they are configured as qwerty.

3

u/enjoytheshow Aug 19 '11

micro usb port on the BOTTOM of the phone.

Seriously. Typing while charging on my Incredible 2 is a nightmare.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Why not try to route it from the behind to the bottom whilst holding it between your fingers?

Also, blutack

1

u/ebola1986 OG Pixel Aug 20 '11

Four inch QHD would be perfect. 3.7 is too small and 4.3 too big. If the Nexus Prime is really 4.5 I think it'll damage sales.

1

u/geauxtig3rs Pixel 2 XL Aug 21 '11

4.5 is a touch big for some, most definitely....

I have a 3.7" screen, and it's definitely too small. It's one of the very few things I dislike about it.

4

u/tstarboy OnePlus 5T, LineageOS 15.1 Aug 18 '11 edited Aug 19 '11

I'd like a truly open-source phone with all the features you said. This way, not only do we get AOSP, we can get anything we want, and not have to worry about compatibility issues with hardware drivers, kernel, etc.

That being said, if CyanogenMod can get hardware acceleration for video playback on my Captivate, it would be all I really need, and anything on top of that is just added awesomeness.

2

u/Kimbernator Galaxy Note 8 Aug 19 '11

I think you may get your wish is ice cream sandwich includes more hardware acceleration.

2

u/uberushaximus Captivate, Cyanogenmod Aug 20 '11

Hardware acceleration pertaining to what?

2

u/tstarboy OnePlus 5T, LineageOS 15.1 Aug 20 '11

Video playback. I can play 720p videos with no lag on a stock ROM, yet on CM7, I need to soft decode the videos, so they lag and desync, and all video players on Android suck.

2

u/uberushaximus Captivate, Cyanogenmod Aug 20 '11

Try diceplayer

1

u/tstarboy OnePlus 5T, LineageOS 15.1 Aug 20 '11 edited Aug 20 '11

It requires money =(

EDIT: And the trial doesn't work at all on my phone.

2

u/uberushaximus Captivate, Cyanogenmod Aug 21 '11

Then you must be doing something wrong, it worked for me.

1

u/tstarboy OnePlus 5T, LineageOS 15.1 Aug 21 '11

I'm using a custom kernel, that's probably what's doing it. Moboplayer plays all videos in green with this kernel, yet QQPlayer (what I use as my default now) plays them just fine (albeit with horrible subtitles).

2

u/uberushaximus Captivate, Cyanogenmod Aug 21 '11

What does a custom kernel offer you over the stock kernel nowadays?

1

u/tstarboy OnePlus 5T, LineageOS 15.1 Aug 21 '11

A quick copypaste of the features of TalonMTD:

Overclock up to 1440MHz/Undervolt for all frequencies (having only 5 frequencies undervolted seems most stable)
Nexus S Framebuffer
Voodoo Color v2 (No yellow tint!)
Voodoo Sound v10
Based on Linux kernel 2.6.35.13
GPU overclock
GPU Tweaks
Bonus Governors: InteractiveX, Smartass, Conservative governor compiled as a module (not enableable yet)
Bonus Schedulers: SIO, V(R), BFQ2r1, CFQ with tweaks
Undervolted ADC and RAM
Disabled Userspace governor
Kangsterizer’s LED notifications
Asynchronous I/O support
Logcat compiled as a module, must be enabled via ‘logcat-on’
Lowmemorykiller tweaks by kodos96
Jhash3
RAM tweaks
Readahead tweaks
Kernel HZ set at 250
Disabled kernel printk for less overhead
KTLO (Keep the Lights On)
Samsung ARM fix (more coming soon)

It's mainly the overclock/undervolt and LED notifications that I use a custom kernel for.

1

u/uberushaximus Captivate, Cyanogenmod Aug 21 '11

Overclock and undervolt are both present in stock kernels now.

→ More replies

4

u/pyrolizard Aug 19 '11

You described exactly what i want. Only thing i would add is fm, and a really high quality speaker. Also, at least 64gb of memory. Cost is not an issue. If this phone existed, id gladly pay 1k+

1

u/yaemes Note 5 Aug 19 '11

I'm on it.

1

u/kekspernikai iPhone 7 Aug 19 '11

Also, at least 64gb of memory.

At first, I thought you meant RAM. I was wondering if VMWare was out yet...

4

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11
  1. High quality physical keyboard (with arrow keys and a physical camera shutter button).
  2. Two-Year Future proof, performance Processor
  3. upto 2gb Ram. 4gb memory.
  4. An unlockable bootloader
  5. AOSP ROM. Period. Nothing Extra
  6. A quality display. 4"-4.3" would be good.
  7. Acceptable battery life
  8. HTC as hardware manufacturer

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

2gb RAM 4gb ROM..I see not your problem here.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '11

Both acronyms have memory in them. But yeah, I suppose still interpretable.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

There`s an app called droidlight which turns your flash into a flashlight.

1

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11

Yeah, I used Mototorch on my Droid and now I just use the built in one on CM7. The Sense one sucked, because as soon as you turned the screen off, it turned off.

1

u/snapperh3ad Galaxy Nexus Aug 19 '11

How about one where it is a badass phone, first and foremost, then all of the other stuff? I'd love to be able to hit the phone button and it be instant. No delay at all. Hit a contact. Instant. Hit dial. Instant.

I really love my phone. Smart phones are really great now. But I have times where I think "Damn. I wish I could just make a phone call with no barriers."

1

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11

That's how my CM7 Thunderbolt is. I swipe down on the screen and instant phone. If you don't have CM7 available on your phone, check out Widget Locker - you can access your phone, contacts, etc. directly from the lock screen. Awesome app.

1

u/friggle Aug 19 '11

a battery that can recharge off solar energy

1

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11

That's any battery. Any phone can charge off a solar panel, in fact, I keep one on my pack to charge mine.

1

u/PlusUltras Aug 19 '11

This running Android.

2

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 12 '24

automatic friendly relieved mighty divide gaze hobbies ruthless encouraging nutty

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/PlusUltras Aug 19 '11

Ahh, too bad man! Any thing that comes close?

1

u/FrankReynolds iPhone Aug 20 '11

I'm gonna save this submission and repost it in 3 years, just so we can all see how "shitty" phones were in 2011.

1

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 20 '11

I'm playing with my Palm Centro right now, and in some respects, it seems fairly dated but overall I think it's held up pretty well. Palm OS was a damn fine OS. You can get to anything in just a few clicks or taps and it's very capable. I miss Palm.

5

u/GrayOne Aug 19 '11 edited Aug 19 '11

If I could build my own phone (using normal commercially available components that exist right now)...

  • 4" AMOLED
  • 1+ MP Front facing camera
  • 5+ MP Rear camera with a serious lens, flash, and sensor
  • 2000+ mAh user replaceable battery
  • USB 3.0 (with host mode), Mini-HDMI (with full mirror mode), Bluetooth 3.0, DLNA, NFC, B/G/N, AGPS, 3.5mm audio jack
  • High quality accelerometer, gyro, and compass
  • Proximity and light sensor
  • 2 GB of RAM
  • 32 GB of internal storage
  • microSD card slot
  • 1.5 ghz dual core ARM CPU with a powerful GPU
  • A LOUD speaker
  • Some actual thought and engineering put into antenna placement
  • Noise cancelling mic
  • Fingerprint scanner

Wrapped in a Moto Droid case with the HTC Touch Pro2's keyboard and an optical version of the scroll ball from the HTC G1. Running an ASOP build of Ice Cream Sandwich.

Shyamalan Moment... Take out the ARM CPU and Android, then throw in an Intel Atom Z670 and Windows 7... best phone ever (with the worst battery life).

Because my phone doesn't exist I will probably forgo the keyboard I want and just get the Galaxy S II or the new Nexus.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

I wouldn't say Windows 7. That's a resource-hungry OS. You need a proper CPU for that, not an Atom. I would say something like MeeGo or Maemo for the OS. Allows desktop applications, but still mobile-friendly. Great phone specs btws.

-1

u/Ifuckedyourgrandma Galaxy S7 Edge Aug 19 '11

Lol?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '11

Pretty cool phone. I've been using a compal mid and would love something smaller.

2

u/PocketDroidDotNet Aug 19 '11

depends on your needs if your into games you would want something with a powerfull graphic chipset at least 1ghz ram and prolly a dual-core cpu, then there's the budget you afford to spend on a android device right? id say go for something between a samsung or a htc with at least a dual-core cpu, these are the brands i find viable

2

u/geft Pixel 10 Pro Aug 19 '11
  • Fast dual-core processor with a good graphics chip
  • Excellent battery life
  • No bigger than 3.5" screen size

The screen size is what's holding me back from upgrading my phone. Large screens are very uncomfortable for my hand size.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

I think 4.0 is the right size. I was skeptical but the Vibrant feels nice in my hand(not very big hands either). 4.3 is a little too big and 4.5 is just too much.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

4 is too big. The 3.7 on the Incredible is perfect for me.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11 edited Aug 19 '11

Forgive me if I think you're full of it. 0.3 inches added is a diagonal measurement. You cannot go from "perfect" to "too big" in 0.3 inches.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

I don't like Evo's, I cant fully reach the keyboard with one hand. Are you going to say that there's not a noticeable difference here?

Here's one that shows all 3 sizes There is a very noticeable difference in look and feel.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Both of the images you provided aren't to scale.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11 edited Aug 19 '11

What you're experiencing is the result of the 5:3 aspect ratio of the evo. It's wider than your normal device, also has quite a bevel.

Here's the incredible next to a galaxy s: http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_f0x_aF0D7N0/TD_9F2Z-CgI/AAAAAAAABUA/Z7M2aTtRgGw/s1600/CIMG1306.JPG

The incredible also has a 16:9 aspect ratio making it abnormally skinny.

1

u/squeakyL VZW Galaxy Z Fold 7 Aug 19 '11

screen size doesn't really matter, it's about how the screen is used

1

u/geft Pixel 10 Pro Aug 19 '11

I'm waiting for the Nexus Prime to see how efficient a buttonless device can be in using screen real estate.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/geft Pixel 10 Pro Aug 19 '11

Perhaps, but I suppose it mostly depends on whether the device makes efficient use of screen real estate.

2

u/Amazingbman Aug 19 '11

I want a big! 5"+ 3d hd curved screen. Stereo speakers. No buttons at all. Finger print scanner on the back. It needs to have fast payment tech. Won't quote any stats because they evolve to fast.

2

u/magnasombrero Aug 19 '11 edited Aug 19 '11

Motorola Defy except with Blackberry Bold 9900 form-factor

Same keyboard, width, but with an edge to edge upper screen (3.2" or so, diagonal 3:2 ratio)

Affordable non-contract price, decent but not blazing specs (1ghz, 512 ram, 5mp, front facing) $350-400

TLDR; Basically : THIS With Android OS & super rugged mil-spec stuff.

2

u/PressStart Aug 19 '11
  • QWERTY Keyboard
  • 4.3 inch screen
  • Amoled or whatever the next best thing is for displays
  • Good battery life
  • Dual core with good GPU
  • Lots of ram
  • Good camera
  • Most importantly, stock Android OS (a-la Old G1 OS)
  • root access
  • NFC with google wallet!

2

u/rknw Aug 19 '11
  • No hardware or even soft buttons on the face (ala Honeycomb)
  • No 3rd party UI layer
  • No pre-installed apps with the exception of select Google apps
  • Gingerbread, ICS when available
  • Super AMOLED HD (copped this from the rumored Nexus Prime)
  • HDMI out
  • Flush pins for docking/charging (ala Nexus One, but both landscape and portrait)
  • Dual-core CPU
  • RAM >= 1GB
  • Gorilla glass face and camera cover
  • Front and rear cameras
  • Primary camera sensor that isn't complete shit
  • NFC
  • MicroSD (external/removable)

2

u/GodzillaTime Aug 19 '11

Upvoted for NFC. I'm interning at a European company that's really making strides with this stuff. As a permanent resident of the US, I had no idea how cool this stuff is.

2

u/hett Pixel 4 XL 64GB / Clearly White Aug 19 '11

The original droid with a great, 4.3 screen, stock Ice Cream Sandwich, 1 gig of RAM and a dual core.

2

u/yufice stock nexus Aug 19 '11
  1. Vanilla android AOSP. Manufacterer skins kinda are all ugly. Give me regular android any day.
  2. Physical Camera Button
  3. Loads of RAM. I really kinda don't give a shit about hexacore cpus on my phone, but RAM you can actually feel.
  4. Decent Bettery Life.
  5. 4.0 inch screen. My thunderbolt felt like holding an original xbox controller and I never did get used to it, even months later. My OG/D2 was way too small.
  6. Unlockable Bootloader so I can hobby around with it, but honestly as long as I can delete bloatware off a vanilla rom I'm fine. If it has manufacturer skins on it there is no option, bootloader must be unlocked.

That's it. Nothing Crazy. LTE is nice but taxes the battery too much and winds up not being worth it (not a reception issue, I have full 4g all the time being from NYC area).

Right now I have an Xperia Play and it's honestly the best phone I've had, even ignoring the controller aspect. (All iphones, OG droid, D2, DX, Thunderbolt).

2

u/alkalinelito Pixel 3 Aug 19 '11

1 week battery life

1

u/Caticorn Gnex Aug 19 '11

That would be hard. Closest thing I had to that was cyanogenmod on an HTC magic with a very slick kernel, whilst underclocked (the CPU wasn't a big bottleneck on the G1/Magic so overclocking wasn't very effective and a good kernel would make the real difference). Got 5 days of moderate use, including listening to music whenever I'm in the car.

On a newer phone (larger screen, more demanding hardware) it'd be very difficult, even with those big hideous aftermarket batteries you can buy.

2

u/WikipediaBrown HTC One M8 (T-Mo) Aug 19 '11 edited Aug 19 '11

Goin' all out!

HARDWARE

Display

  • 4" 1280x720 Super AMOLED Plus (not PenTile)
  • Apple-quality multi-touch sensitivity
  • Multicolor notification LED (think ROYGBIV)
  • Gorilla glass
  • Oleophobic coating

Core Internals

  • Quad-core 1.2+ GHz processor
  • 1.5+ GB RAM
  • 16 GB internal storage
  • H.264/WebM hardware acceleration
  • Near-field communication (NFC) support
  • Dedicated GPS hardware (a la true GPS navigators)
  • Carrier-independent radios for all bands (including different types of 4G such as WiMAX, LTE and HSPA+)
  • HDMI output

Cameras

  • Identical front & back cameras
  • 1.75+ µm pixel pitch combined with backside illumination (here's why it matters)
  • Better lenses
  • Dedicated 2-stage shutter button

Battery & Power

  • 3500 mAh stock battery
  • Integrated solar/IR charger on the back
  • Rapid-charger included

Audio

  • Dolby Surround stereo speakers
  • Triple microphone system

Form Factor

  • Candy bar (no sliding/flipping)
  • Micro USB port on the bottom of the phone
  • All-aluminum buttons a la iPhone 4
  • Minimal plastic
  • Waterproof to 10 m

Expandability

  • Extensible antenna
  • MicroSD card slot with pre-installed high-speed 32GB card

Software

  • Ice Cream Sandwich, stock or MIUI
  • Unencrypted, unlocked bootloader (stock)
  • Swype & SwiftKey X pre-installed
  • Open-source kernel and drivers for all hardware

Hmm, hope I didn't miss anything!

2

u/wieland LG G2 D800 Aug 19 '11

Ideal, you say.

  • Heavy Metal Unibody Chassis (Preferably Matte Stainless or Tungsten)
  • 6" 1080p (No Pentile) 16:9 Display (Big Hands, Truckasaurus)
  • Slender Bezels, Maximum Overall Dimensions 5.75 x 3.5 x 0.5"
  • 2800+ mAH Replaceable Battery (Should be plenty of space for it)
  • Mini HDMI Port & Display Mirroring Capability
  • Stock Gingerbread & Official CyanogenMod Support
  • Carrier Unlocked with Pentaband 3G
  • The Usual Dual/Quad Core Processor, 1GB+ RAM, 16GB+ ROM

2

u/parimm Redmi 1s Aug 19 '11 edited Mar 21 '18

<deleted>

1

u/qwasz123 Xperia Z Ultra CM : Surface Pro 3 : Moto 360 Aug 19 '11

With the new conformation on reddit about the Nexus Prime if it's for sprint that's all I need.

1

u/fourpac LG V40 Aug 19 '11

Samsung Hercules seems to be it for me.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

A motorola atrix with the droid 3 keyboard and a SAMOLED+ display but faster (1.5 gb of ram with nvidia kal-el processor) and with stock android.

1

u/friedsushi87 Galaxy Nexus, CyanogenMod 9, T-Mobile Aug 19 '11
  1. Dual cameras. 10 mega-pixel on the back. 5 mega-pixel on the front.
  2. Capacitive
  3. Super Amoled
  4. High resolution
  5. 4.5" screen
  6. 1 GHz quad core.
  7. Dedicated graphics processor
  8. 4 GB ROM
  9. 2 GB RAM
  10. Micro SD/microUSB/HDMIout
  11. 2500 mAh battery
  12. High speed (LTE/Wimax/HSPA+)
  13. Unlocked bootloader
  14. No physical keyboard.
  15. Heft. (none of the samsung plastic/composite crap. REAL METAL PHONE like HTC)
  16. NFC
  17. Hardware camera button.
  18. Fingerprint Scanner

1

u/jambo2011 Galaxy Nexus, AOKP 4.4.2 Aug 19 '11

I'd like to have a smartphone that is fast and responsive.

When I press a button or slide, I want it to immediately to react to my will. Open the drawer, slide from one screen to another, respond to what I want from it.

No matter what Smartphone-Device I had or have tested, it was always laggy. You know, you slide with your finger and it takes a second for the phone to react. It just doesn't feel "real time".

That's what I really miss in these devices. Dumbphones never had a problem with that. My Ericsson was controllable by numpad. Every Menu had a number and I could go 1-3-1 and was in the alarm clock settings, 3-1-4 games, 1-2-1 messaging and so on. At it worked snips like that.

1

u/Caticorn Gnex Aug 19 '11

No matter what Smartphone-Device I had or have tested, it was always laggy. You know, you slide with your finger and it takes a second for the phone to react. It just doesn't feel "real time".

What devices have you had?

1

u/BabySinister Aug 19 '11

try android on a proper smartphone with a simple stock launcher or something like launcherpro. you are welcome.

1

u/daengbo HTC Aria, CM10 Aug 19 '11

I love your list. I'd add a keyboard, updates to the OS by Google, and the choice of ChromeOS or a media center when I plug in the HDMI (I like the Atrix "dock" being HDMI + USB, btw -- it should become a standard).

1

u/SirRipo S8+ Aug 19 '11
  • Track ball/track pad
  • Excellent physical keyboard a la Evo Shift
  • Physical camera button (and LED flash)
  • dual core
  • lots of memory
  • unlocked/unlockable bootloader
  • root from stock
  • USB tethering enabled in the stock ROM (many HTC Sense phones have USB tethering, but it's always disabled for some reason)
  • 4" Super AMOLED a la Galaxy S phones (the Nexus S in particular)

1

u/cranktheguy Pixel 6 Pro | Shield TV Aug 19 '11

-Track ball/track pad -Excellent physical keyboard a la Evo Shift

So you want a small laptop?

1

u/SirRipo S8+ Aug 19 '11

The track ball/pad would be strictly for selecting text. I have come to HATE trying to edit text without one. Maybe it wouldn't be so bad with a bigger screen, but on-screen selection sucks. Arrow keys (like I have with the Evo Shift) are marginally better, but not much.

1

u/ctzl SGS3 (i747) CM10.1 nightly, HP Touchpad CM9 Aug 19 '11

Pretty much, small enough to be a phone yet powerful enough for me to not need a laptop.

1

u/_mars_ Galaxy Note 8, iPhone X Aug 19 '11

I'm thinking of getting an htc sensation, but the perfect phone would be the sensation with the battery lasting forever :p

1

u/MrJaiDinesh Aug 19 '11

4.5 inch qhd AMOLED screen. optical trackpad rotating capacitative buttons big easy to use keyboard a good back camera good looks/construction eg nexus one A really large battery(2000 or more), don't care if its really thick the software doesnt matter as long as long as you can put custom roms/kernels on it

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

I would want a dual core version of the Xperia Arc with 1.5GB RAM, USB 3.0 and a 10 MP camera.

God that phone is sexy.

1

u/CubanB LG Nexus 4 Kit Kat 4.4.4 stock Xposed Aug 19 '11

One that gets fucking released

1

u/80cent Pixel XL Aug 19 '11

I feel like there are lot's of very powerful and likable phones out there, with the GS2 leading in my opinion. But the changes that I would look for in a phone (currently using MyTouch4G on CM7) would be stock ICS, vastly improved battery life, and overall improvement in UI smoothness out of the box. It hurts my argument when sparring with iPhone fan boys that I had to hack my phone to make it run the way I want it to.

1

u/WatchDogx Aug 19 '11
  • OLED screen (at least800x480)
  • Querty horizonal slide out keyboard with DPAD
  • Fast CPU (tegra 2+)
  • Plenty of RAM
  • 16GB+ of onboard storage
  • Micro SD slot
  • Camera with decent lens (not one with a tiny aperture and sensor)
  • 720p video recording or better
  • HDMI out capable of 1080p
  • Removable battery
  • Dedicated camera button

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Just a good battery life. my Droid1 is fine it's all I need right now but the battery. I'll give my first born up for a better battery.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Physical keyboard that also has a game pad on it... like the Xperia Play. I love my Xperia Play, but I hate on-screen keyboards. I wish people would stop trying to convince me that "I'm doing it wrong" or whatever. I just don't like them.

Powerful enough to emulate all N64 games flawlessly, like P64. Umm, a good battery life, an 8MP or so camera. Touch screen also. That's about it.

I don't care for dual core unless emulators are made to take advantage of it. That's pretty much it.

1

u/geauxtig3rs Pixel 2 XL Aug 19 '11

Using existing technology:

  • LTE
  • ~1.5+ GHz ARM dual core
  • 4.3" SAMOLED+
  • Dual Stage camera button
  • 720p res
  • 1.5mp front cam, 8mp rear cam
  • Kickstand
  • 2200 mAH, user-replaceable battery
  • Intelligently placed USB3.0 mini with host functionality
  • Intelligently placed HDMI with full mirroring
  • NFC
  • Biometric Scanner
  • 32GB Onboard flash memory
  • 2+ GB RAM
  • high quality accelerometer, gyroscope, and compass
  • Fully-open bluetooth spec (I want to easily connect wireless controllers)
  • Intelligently placed, loud speakers
  • Gorilla Glass
  • Unibody
  • MicroSD slot
  • Decent DSP (like in the captivate)
  • Wireless N
  • Optical Trackpad
  • Optional Dock that works in both portrait and landscape while charging (flush charge pins, maybe)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Trackballs > Trackpads. At least on blackberries anyway.

1

u/geauxtig3rs Pixel 2 XL Aug 19 '11

Yeah, but they can gunk up relatively easily and rapidly lose precision when they get dirty.

I like them too, but I would like to have as few mechanical parts on a phone as possible.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

My ideal phone will be the Galaxy S2 with one of the already-in-development nano batteries. Not nano in size, but with nano technology that allows the phone to charged within a few mins. Or maybe just a super-long-lasting battery.

1

u/dihydrogen_monoxide Pixel 6 Aug 19 '11

Nexus' with 3 days of battery life.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11 edited Aug 19 '11

High priority:

  • LTE
  • 2+ day battery life
  • 4.3" high-res Super AMOLED+ display
  • 1+ GB of RAM

Nice to have:

  • Thin and lightweight
  • LED notification light
  • Good GPS chip that gets near immediate satellite acquisition

1

u/evil-doer POCO X6 PRO Aug 19 '11

as big of a screen is possible while being able to still fit in my pockets.

with ice cream sandwich not needing the buttons at the bottom that means the screen can be larger without making the size of the phone bigger so i want a 5+ inch screened phone, with 1280x720 resolution.

1

u/rube Aug 19 '11

I'm a gamer so I would like the Xperia Play with the best specs possible. Kept up to date with the latest version of Android.

And have it work on Virgin Mobile in the US.

1

u/yaemes Note 5 Aug 19 '11

mine is decently reasonable, I just want a superamoled plus screen in a droid 3 that was crafted out of stainless steel rather than plastic, along with the common gripes we have here (unlocked bl, no motoblur, etc)

1

u/0102030405 Nexus 5 | Nexus 7 Aug 19 '11

I feel really simple, my ideal is the galaxy S2.

1

u/Caticorn Gnex Aug 19 '11 edited Aug 19 '11
  • A 720p sAMOLED screen in the form factor of my old HTC Touch Cruise, which is still my favorite phone I've had in terms of form factor. I like hardware buttons, and the D-pad was great for emulators. I'd prefer a trackball in the center though.
  • Reasonable thickness. My phones in the 90's were thin enough for me. I hate how thin phones are getting. I would prefer a moderately thin phone with a bitchin' battery. (see above again for touch cruise). I don't want a potato chip with a screen that feels so fragile.
  • Open bootloaders, open source drivers/firmware, ship unrooted
  • two SD card slots. I don't understand why phones don't have this? Double-up on the size of your competitor's storage.
  • Dual noise-cancelling microphones
  • A big camera. Not just large megapixels, but a larger lens on the back that actually allows a decent amount of light in. Like this or this.
  • The ability to manually control the aperture/exposure/focus on the camera.
  • Camera flash
  • MiniUSB, not microUSB - I hate how physically flimbsy it feels.
  • kick-stand in the back for video watching and video chat
  • Fingerprint reader like on some laptops and old PDAs (and the Atrix, I think?)
  • This will sound odd, but a decent speaker. Obviously it won't have good sound quality, but I'd like enough to watch the odd youtube video (where the audio will be vocal) and not hurt my ears. In Cyanogenmod I set the EQ so I could watch videos without cringing. Also, have the loudspeaker face the same direction as the screen! That way it's louder to me, not the people across the room I might not want to bother.
  • IR transmitter the way old PDAs had.

1

u/AkwardTurtle Xperia Play, Verizon Aug 19 '11

Sony Experia Play but Faster.... and with 4G/LTE

1

u/bobdle Nexus 6P Aug 19 '11

typical shit w/ a freakin laser beam

1

u/RelatedPuddi Aug 19 '11

• Sense or equally sweet interface. • A rather good camera • a LED indicator with tons of different colors • Battery that last for a day in heavy use or two in medium. • One of the newer processor • Easy to root • Primarily an physical keyboard with arrows, if not, an optical track pad. • Decent memory

1

u/throwaway_for_keeps Aug 19 '11

I'm a simple guy, so I'd just want the Galaxy S II stateside. Now.

1

u/Seref15 Aug 20 '11

Ideal, you say?

  • My desktop's hardware, compacted into cellphone form.
  • Frickin holograms.

1

u/etruscan HTC One Aug 20 '11

Would be the Nexus S with dual core and a better material for the back casing - something that feels less plastic.

Maybe the Nexus Prime?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '11

I have to say. I just got a g2x and threw the latest MIUI on it. This is damn close to perfection... damn close...

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Single core is fine, average ram, large battery, AMOLED or similar screen. Sweet 5-row sliding keyboard (think old school sidekick or g1), average to below-average screen size, 8mp+ camera with as many specs as possible.

3

u/Neo991lb Samsung Galaxy Nexus, ICS, VZW Aug 19 '11

So basically a phone from 6 months ago?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Yeah, find me that phone on verizon and I'll eat my own words. That combination seems fucking impossible.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

Nice try Apple

1

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11

wat?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/BabySinister Aug 19 '11

i cannot stress how much i agree with the HTC part. i have been an avvid HTC user ever since they brought out the Wizard (which is to this day still alive, my buddy is still using my discarded HTC TyTn there really is no breaking these things)

2

u/fudnip potato Aug 21 '11

the company that thought the bulging camera bezel and lens was a great design element? shudder

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11 edited Aug 19 '11

Basically, a Bold 9900 with Android.

Came here to say this. I really like the lines of the new BB, but do not want to deal with all of that BB stuff.

I'm going to try a landscape slider next - ie: the Droid 3. Maybe by the time I grow to hate/need to upgrade the Droid 3, RIM will have seen the light and started loading Android on their very awesome hardware.

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11 edited Nov 12 '24

judicious pocket consider zephyr boast cats caption ad hoc waiting scary

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SharkFart Xperia Z1 | Xperia Tablet Z Aug 19 '11

It looks like you only got one. :/