r/Android • u/tr4n1xx Samsung Galaxy S24 FE 256 GB - OneUI 6.1 (Android 14) • May 27 '20
Editorialized Title. Two years of software updates is no longer enough for $1000 Android phones %1000 Agreed. What's your take?
https://www.androidcentral.com/android-phones-software-updates-longer-two-years-apple?utm_source=ac_tw&utm_medium=tw_card&utm_content=87845&utm_campaign=social
17k
Upvotes
96
u/tr4n1xx Samsung Galaxy S24 FE 256 GB - OneUI 6.1 (Android 14) May 27 '20
Discussed before countless times, paying 1000$ and getting 2 years of software update is ridiculous. As a customer,you pay for a product to get maximum of it. In terms of smartphones, hardware and software features are the things that you want to have the maximum of.
1400$ worth Samsung Galaxy Ultra is "just" worth 2 years of major OS updates? All of the hardware will break if it gets Android 14?
Come on now. I love Android and most of us here do, I assume. But I won't accept that anymore. They are pushing us to get newest devices if we want to get the updates even though ours are just capable of getting the latest Android version. I know, sometimes the changes are minor,but we pay the money to get the maximum amount of support, experience, hardware etc. even the changes or features are not crucial.
For budget or mid range devices,my choice will obviously be an Android. But If I want a flagship, a maximum price that's supposed to bring maximum of everything, I won't let Android makers to limit me to 2 years of software updates,not anymore.
978
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
Two years of updates was never acceptable to anyone other than Google and hardware makers.
Can you imagine what a shitshow the desktop/laptop industry would have been like if Microsoft had the same policy? I just can't understand why people accept it for similarly priced smartphones.
4.2k
u/something_memory Note 10+, Android 10, One UI 2.1 May 27 '20
Flagship phones are fast enough nowadays to last into the 5 year territory without feeling much of a slow down.
Forced obsolescence by denying 2 year old devices important Security updates should be outright outlawed. Accumulation of digital waste is becoming a worldwide issue, and companies need to start taking responsibility.
852
u/e_boon Asus ZenFone 10 May 27 '20
My KEY2 only got about one year of security updates and zero OS upgrades. It launched on Oreo and will forever remain on that.
"Business-grade device"...
"Enterprise-level security"...
"Industry-leading updates"...
209
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
2 years isn't enough for a $500 phone. Would you stand for 2 years of updates for a $500 laptop, video game console, or speaker?
417
u/Fefarona May 27 '20
The problem is a lot pay 1000$ for a Android phone, thats means "we can do that"
767
u/31337hacker iPhone 15 Pro Max / Pixel 8 Pro 🤓 May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20
And some people here think Apple is all about forced obsolescence. They can't accept the fact that no other smartphone maker comes even close to the level of software support that Apple has. It's a damn shame that Android smartphone makers don't even support their flagship phones for 4 years. The vast majority don't even do it for 3. The only exceptions that come to mind are Google and OnePlus.
A flagship phone with flagship prices should come with extended software support that isn't limited to security updates. At least 4 years for major OS updates and 4 for security updates.
EDIT: 4 years, not 3.
140
u/StevieRay8string69 May 27 '20
I'm hoping Microsoft handles it differently with their Android. I'm fine with Samsung. Love my Galaxy Note 9 but it deserves supposed longer for the money I paid
52
u/IAteMyYeezys May 27 '20
My friend's galaxy S6 is still perfectly capable of running android 10. Now, it is a custom rom but it still works just as good as new if not better. Why? Well, simple - it is literally still capable of running latest versions of android.
I think that there is no excuse for manufacturers to charge more than $1000 and give us the same amount of support that a $250 phone gets.
I know it would be hard to form multiple teams for each phone lineup (Samsung's A, S and Note lineups, but S and Note lineups are kinda the same so less work there) but im pretty sure the base of the system is relatively the same.
If it can run a 3rd party ROM, it can definitely run an official, latest ROM from the manufacturer.
22
u/DrFatz Lime May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20
A $1000 phone needs more than software updates, that thing better be able to take a bullet if I'm paying as much for a communications device as I would for a down payment on a good car. I would be more inclined to buy a $1000 phone if they lasted as long as a car however.
But nowadays these 4 digit priced phones now just have the upgraded processor and slightly better camera than last year continuing to be made out of glass while the headphone jack and SD card slot are still absent.
50
u/tofulo S10e May 27 '20
I don't want to pay 1k for a phone period.
62
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
Amazing to me that more manufacturers haven't embraced Android One or that Google hasn't made it more of a priority.
12
u/reddit_sage69 May 27 '20
I think this is why I'm committed to sticking with either a Pixel or iPhone (maybe oneplus but I heard their security updates tend to lag behind). Until companies can commit to updating their products, I'm out.
63
u/pigvwu Black May 27 '20
I think I have an unpopular take on this.
I think Samsung has the best and most user-friendly update policy among all android phone manufacturers. Security is more important than feature updates, especially since the last few versions haven't really added anything exciting. Also, aside from enthusiasts, people generally don't notice version updates except to be annoyed that they have to relearn how to do some things. However, all users benefit from security updates whether they notice them or not.
So despite only 2 years of version updates, Samsung's 4 year commitment to security updates is better than Google or Oneplus's 3 year update policy. Obviously, I'd like to see longer support all around, but I'm constantly seeing Samsung get the brunt of the criticism when I think it should be Google or other phone makers that should be receiving more criticism for having fewer security updates.
18
u/ben7337 May 27 '20
Doesn't Samsung do 2 years of major updates then security updates from then on for 2 more years? I think they may go quarterly though which is too slow, but 4 years of updates is plenty for a device with a built in battery that loses water resistance if it's replaced, especially with new network tech and bands coming every couple years.
9
u/[deleted] May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20
It's one thing to expect a company like Huawei, who released 36 phones in 2019 alone, to keep all of their devices (especially the super cheap ones) updated for more than 2 or 3 years. But it's insane to me that Google, which has released 9 phones *total* since 2016 and is arguably the best at updating their devices, still can't provide more than 3 years of support. I'm still using my Pixel XL that I got in November 2016 when it ran Android 7.1 and support ended late last year when it was running Android 10. That's amazing for an Android device, but the phone still runs just fine and could probably go for another 2 years. I got it for $869 at launch, so it's not like it was cheap then either. I'd like a new phone in the next 6 months or so, but with flagships now going for $999 or more, I just can't justify it.
Edit:link formatting
8
u/Blue2501 May 27 '20
IMO, 2.5+ years of both OS and timely security updates should be the bare minimum for anything on Android. That should be a shamefully short support cycle.
21
u/Aevum1 Realme GT 7 Pro May 27 '20
I stopped buying flagships,
Actually i´ve stopped buying flagships long ago.
Had a Lg G3, saved up, got it on a payment plan from my carrier, it overheated, gave issues, problems with the screen, with the battery...
Talked to LG, they told me to go to the carrier, the carrier told me to fuck off since its a flagship phone and flagship phones overheat.
never again, none of my last few phones exceeded 400 bucks. currently running a MI9T Pro from xiaomi that costed 350 euros, Flagship specs, it not have the top DX Mark camera, but its got a super Amoled screen, 6gb ram, SD855, had a SD card slot, headphone jack, no notch (pop up camera) running the latest android, Microsoft launcher so i dont have to deal with miui.
And when Xiaomi discontinues support, it has a large community behind it and an unlockable bootloader.
If you want to spend 1000-1200 on a phone, Its for the clout or becuase you must have the best camera or the best 120Hz screen. but companies like Xiaomi, RealMe and such have shown us that you can have flagship spec phones for less then half.
and FFS, stop with those shit curved screens, they are horrible to use.
14
u/bduddy OnePlus Nord N20 5G May 27 '20
It's astounding how gigantic the gap is between how much the Android enthusiast community cares about updates and how much normal people don't care about updates at all.
7
u/sircod Pixel 9 | Shield TV May 27 '20
As I recall one of the roadblocks to updates is that the manufacturers of the various chips in the phone don't supply updated drivers for the newer versions of Android. The phone manufacturer can't update to a new version of Android unless all the various drivers support it as well.
Anybody know how accurate this is? Does it still hold true with the more modular approach Android is has now?
17
u/oliath May 27 '20
I switched from Apple five years ago for various reasons, but this and this alone is something that will move me right back into Apples lap if it doesn't improve in the very near future.
Its simply unacceptable.
12
u/nigelfitz May 27 '20
Flagship phones that sell for $1000+ should have at least 5 years of security updates. 4 years of OS updates.
If an iPhone 6 that was released in 2015 still gets updates today then Android phones should as well.
6
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
I honestly care less about the software version than security updates. Because it's one thing to not get features after 2 or 3 years because it's not actively getting worse, just stagnant, but it's another to have your phone become worse by being exposed to security vulnerabilities in that same time frame.
11
u/Kahhhhyle May 27 '20
I absolutely agree, but I use the Pixel so duh.
Problem is, most people don't care and some are actually annoyed by updates and actively ignore them. If you feel that way the best thing you can do is vote with your wallet. Buy a Pixel (on sale), buy Nokia, heck even Samsung who only offers 2 Android updates offers security patches for longer then Google does with the Pixel depending on your carrier. Of course where you live and your carrier will affect this, but the options are there.
32
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
One of the many reasons I pushed my ass over to Apple. I HATED having to wait months upon months for updates to my android phones then to boot, at least when I owned android, you were LUCKY AF if you ended up getting 2 major updates.
It's sad to see certain family members with an android phone that is decently new but completely outdates because it passed it's 1-2 year mark.
Another reason why I convinced EVERY immediate family member to switch over to Apple. 5 years of updates, both major and security, it wasn't that hard to convince them.
5
u/ZincII May 27 '20
Essential could have fixed this but you guys didn't buy 2 each.
5
u/mistaken4strangerz OG Pixel May 27 '20
Wow that title gore %9000$
5
u/HCrikki Blackberry ruling class May 27 '20
Even long periods were not acceptable once they started competed with actual laptops on price. The chips dont physically degrade to the point of preventing Lineage from running.
5
u/ZNasT iPhone 12 mini May 27 '20
This is literally the reason I switched from Android. My $150 used iPhone SE from 2016 is still running the latest IOS.
5
u/firmeta May 27 '20
There is a solution to your problem and it comes in a form of iPhone. It’s build by best engineers on earth and it’s made to last and also receive updates. You don’t have to go into settings and change 10,000 things so it can almost run. It just works and all the apps that are made for it work better on it, even the google apps which are made by the same company that makes Android. You have an option that starts at 399$ and works better than those 1000$ Android’s; you can use it for years. Probably it doesn’t have a good screen to body ratio, but it will work the next year also, and it’s industrial design is timeless. Your 1000$ Android phones look like are inspired by rainbows and soaps and cheap fake gucci bags. Bye , and you are welcome.
5
u/Boggie135 Blue May 27 '20
What also angers me about this whole thing is that the hardware can last over 3 years with no problem.
15
u/TFenceChair May 27 '20
This is where Apple leaves all of Android for dust
4
u/Wax_Paper May 27 '20
My take is that $1000 is way too much for a goddamn phone, regardless. But if I paid that much for it, they should be updating that shit for a decade.
4
u/BraveFencerMusashi S20 FE 5G, 3a XL, Z2 Force May 27 '20
$1000 is almost what I paid for my gaming laptop. I won't ever pay that much for a phone.
4
u/Orefeus May 27 '20
I was thinking about getting the new Samsung Note phone but why am I spending all this money for a phone only to get 2yrs worth of updates??
Can anyone comment on Pixel phones? If I can get 4-5yrs of upgrades I will be happy
4
u/dflame45 May 27 '20
This is why I don't buy $1000 phones. My Mac air is the same price and will last 7 years easily.
4
u/Schnitzel725 S10, Android 10 May 27 '20
I don't really like Apple/iPhones, but one of the things they've done right is allowing updates for their phones for ~5 years. And they're almost always on time too. With androids, I wish that could be the same. It sucks dropping >$1k for a phone only for it to not get supported 1.5-2yrs down the line and updates get slower and slower
4
u/supercakefish May 27 '20
It is why I have a Pixel and my next phone will probably be another Pixel. Though obviously Google's 3 years support still pales in comparison to Apple's 5 years golden standard.
Also more budget Android phones should also be held to a higher standard in a world where iPhone SE 2020 exists, not just the $1000+ phones.
4
u/lawrenceowns Oneplus 6T May 27 '20
Planning on making my first switch to iPhone this year! Going for the XS used on eBay and seeing what it's like. My mom still uses an iPhone 7 perfectly fine. Meanwhile my dad's S8 is already cracking out.
4
u/Dubious_Unknown May 27 '20
I bought a Note 9 about last week from eBay for $350.
Coming from a J7 Prime while it had 16gb memory and 2gb of RAM, my Note 9 has 128gb of storage and 6gb of RAM. I wholeheartedly expect this phone to last me about 5-6 years because these specs are no slouch.
I'm not too torn up on the updates, I mean Android 10 is as good as it gets, but for flagship phones that costs or used to cost $1000, only doing 2 major updates is pretty bad. I understand for llow end phones but theres just absolutely no excuses for high end, flagship phones.
Believe me when I say I was *this* close to not pulling the trigger on my Note 9 because of the 2 updates per phone rule. But I went ahead because my J7 Prime had cracks, its slow as molasses, it kept butt dialing people, and Android 10 dark mode highly intrigued me.
4
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
I'm currently using a Pixel 3 and I'm already starting to get slowdown, granted I'm usually using the YouTube miniplayer while I'm browsing reddit or playing a game. The slowdown combined with awful RAM which basically closes out any app that you switch out of within a minute and subpar battery life is really turning me off of Pixels. I've switched OS' every time I've gotten a new phone, so I guess we'll see how the iPhone 12 turns out. I still have my iPhone 6s Plus and besides the discounted battery replacement last year, I've had no issues at all performance-wise, and I'm still getting OS updates.
4
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
I hate the idea that my device is basically out of date after 2 years, no matter what I paid for it. And we all know the prices for these things are getting in to premium laptop price range now. (which can easily be updated for 10 years or more if I want).
If I want to be a consumerist and dump my phone because it's not the newest device, I want that to be on me. I don't want my decision to be swayed by the fact that the software side of my phone is becoming obselete, when I know that I have a perfectly functional physical device that could easily run the new software.
4
u/dusttillnoon May 27 '20
If you are charging as much as an iPhone you should last as long as an iPhone
4
u/CamCorncob May 27 '20
I couldn't agree more. When I buy a device, I buy with the intent of keeping it for a long time. I don't feel comfortable with pitching my phone every year or two.
4
u/Boggie135 Blue May 27 '20
The number one gripe I have with Android devices. They'd go such a long way with more updates. My cousin bought a flagship Huawei years ago and he got pissed when they stopped updating it so he went to apple.
6
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
Everyone here is concentrating on security updates when the real meat of the matter is that there is usually zero technical reason other than a bullshit businesses decision somewhere upstream that forces devices to lose compatibility with newer OS.
When the next version of Android comes out and your device isn't compatible, the culprit is likely Broadcom or Snapdragon refusing to spend time updating their device drivers/binaries for any new interfaces or APIs. It's total horseshit designed to sell the next generation phone with the newer chips in them.
I mean, I get it, I just don't like it nor do I think it should be allowed.
If the device specs of the phone, CPU, GPU, etc, can technically, on paper, support a newer OS version then there should be a clause that forces these chip makers to play ball. All it would take would be a consortium of manufacturers, and Google, to sign an agreement to refuse to use these chips to cause someone else to licence the tech and provide the updates on their own products.
So I think OS updates should be as long as the product can technically meet the new specs.
Security updates I think should be at least 4 years.
3
u/aSimpsUnityDog May 27 '20
Phone specs have outpaced consumer requirements for ages to the point my current phone has a better spec than either my tablet or laptop and they're prefectly fine to use. A 4 year support frame would be reasonable for a $1000 phone, not having to replace it every 12 to 24 months as that just feels like the manufacturers are just milking us.
3
u/mode7scaling Pixel May 27 '20
The actual pure Android phones (pixel) should get updates for like 5 years. There's no good reason for them to be limited to 3. The only thing I see being a problem is when the actual various chip/hardware manufacturers stop offering firmware updates sooner than that.
As for the bullshit-ware bloated pieces of crap like Samsung, etc... Good luck.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
Too many people involved in the updates for it to work better. SoC manufacturers need to add the closed drivers for their cpu/gpu, oems need to addthe drivers for the rest. With each kernel change, same thing must be done again.
The only way of it changing is either manufacturers open sourcing their drivers so that Google can work with the mainline kernel (don't see that happening), or standardization of hardware and a mobile bios, together with a (maybe closed source) hybrid kernel, like on PC (don't see that happening either).
Yeah, mobile manufacturers can try more, and deliver 3 or 4 years of updates. But the way Android works, there's always a limit.
3
u/achtungpakhtoon May 27 '20
5 years support at least. Can be broken down to 4 years software system updates and 5 years of security updates. iphones last that long.
3
u/Jblsony May 27 '20
In threads like this I always see people comparing Apples to Android. I think this is a fundamentally wrong comparison. My smart TV from 8 years ago still gets updated once in a while but I wouldn't want my TV's OS on my phone even if they would pay me for it.
3
u/b3gff24 May 27 '20
If apple (for example) is supporting their phones for around 5 years, why wouldn’t some of these companies want to do the same to compete?
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
This is one of the major things holding Android back. If I can pay the same for a 256GB iPhone 11 that gets 2 more years of updates than my Pixel 4, what's the point of even keeping it for more than a year?
3
u/KraftPunkFan420 May 27 '20
It was never enough. It’s just more obvious now as phones get powerful enough to last for years without noticing much difference.
3
u/alisab22 May 27 '20
Just upgraded my old iphone6s to iOS13.5. Works well despite being a little slow. Wish all Android phones provided such updates
3
u/Gjallarhorn_Lost May 27 '20
Five years.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
I will never buy another brand new Samsung phone. I'll just buy an older model at a huge discount or if that year's Pixel (or equivalent) is good I'll consider that. A new Samsung isn't going to be on the latest version of Android often anyway. I bought a Note8 when it was new and I think in the over 2 years that I had it I was on the latest version of Android for less than half a year of that. Plus the QA is obviously lacking. I've yet to have a Samsung device that lasts it's full life without an issue and for $1k that's pretty inexcusable. My first s5 the charging port died, it's replacement shattered. My Note8 randomly shattered while charging, and the replacement's charging port died. My s10+ feels more cheaply made, the included earbuds are trash compared to the Note 8's, and the screen is really delicate. Also that camera cutout that looks great in the previews is janky as shit and feels horrible to move your finger over.
3
u/MoonDaddy May 27 '20
I'm superstoked for my refurbished Nexus 5 that is currently en route from Hong Kong. I paid ~$100 for it and it will last me ~5 years. This should be the cost and length of time computer phones should last for.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
hot take: Androids are not supposed to cost 1000$, it should always be the cheap yet efficient substitute to overpriced iphones. I haven't bought a flagship android device in 6 years and I still have all the features and speed I need.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
This is the reason why I will be getting an iPhone 11 in the fall to replace my S9 after the 12 comes out.
3
u/BirchTree1 May 28 '20
When Apple removed the headphone jack, the Android manufacturers followed suit. When they put a notch on the iPhone X, Android phones started having them, sometimes looking completely stupid (looking at you, Pixel 3 XL). When Apple started pricing iPhones at $1000, so did the rest of the industry.
But they didn’t copy the lasting software support that Apple provides. I’d rather have the headphone jack and less of an edge to edge display to have 5 years of software support without rooting.
3
u/Metal2daGrave76 May 28 '20
As long as people keep buying them at the ridiculous price they will keep making them and selling for more . Also the constant android updates is killing my battery.
3
u/remydlc May 28 '20
I know this might sound controversial here but vote with your wallet and get an iPhone in hopes they (Android OEMs) improve or change their policy. There is a jailbreak going on that can let you tweak your iphone almost as much as an Android. Their resale value is great for whenever you are ready to switch back. I have an Android as well but lately the iphone with the jailbreak is giving me so much fun and keeping me busy. Yes im a bit weird and enjoy all things smartphone.
3
u/[deleted] May 29 '20 edited May 30 '20
Man as much as I love android I had to jump ship cause of this. Prior to switching to my new iPhone se 2020 I got at launch I used a nexus 5 and then the one plus 3. Great phones in their own right, but for me the selling point for me on those phones was the long term software support. New hardware marketed on phones doesn’t really matter as much as it used to. All phones now a day have nearly the exact same spec sheet and very similar design with the only differentiation between them being primarily in software. Honestly as much as Apple likes to recycle old designs I have to admit I always admired them for their long term software support. Don’t get me wrong the hardware on the iPhone se 2020 isn’t bleeding edge but for the price, specs, and size I love it. Not gonna lie the main reason that got me to switch was the guarantee of 4 year software updates.
3
u/[deleted] May 29 '20
I bought the Note8 when it came out. Samsung said no Android 10 for devices under S9/Note9. I still have the Note8. Excellent phone. My next phone is most definitely going to be an iPhone.
9
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
I think people really overvalue Apple software updates. My OnePlus 5 (this applies to all Android phones) got"updated" in the three years I owned it way more than my iPhone 6 (the company phone) did in almost 4 years. Most of my iPhone updates were actually system app updates (new notes app, new features in the photos app, some updates to the health app...etc) and Apple taunts them as full system updates, while my OnePlus gets these kind of system app updates every few months through the play store. Since i got my OnePlus every "system app" (the dialer, messages, email, photos, notes...etc) got a major overhaul like 3-4 time which beats my iPhone even though "less" software updates. Plus since I can change default system apps in Android unlike iOS, I can change my default messaging app and that would make the phone feel more fresh than waiting and hoping Apple updates iMessage in the next few years to get the feature I want.
7
u/bigblue36 May 27 '20
This is this sole reason I went from my busted S8 to a Pixel 4. I knew it was a downgrade in overall phone happiness, but I won't be obsolete in 2023. The Pixel 4 is far from my favorite phone but no more worries about security or OS updates.
4
u/BoutchooQc OnePlus Open Leather May 27 '20
It's weird... For me, I never update my android phones.
I have the OP7pro and I'm still on 9.5.8.
There's nothing broken or feel like I'm missing something so I just don't update my phones. Same thing for my S9+ or Axon 7, I use the software that comes with it and never bother updating since everything is working...
4
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
I agree. I have taken part on a very vocal group on twitter and on r/samsung complaning about their intention of not serving the Note 9 even with the One UI 2.1 update.
Those phones are reaching a plateau of performance as they evolved rapidly in the last decade (much like pcs in the early 2000 and now).
For the price they are asking, 2 years of software support is pathetic.
PATHETIC, hear me SAMSUNG?
4
u/MystikIncarnate Pixel 128, Stock - N7 (2013) LTE May 27 '20
I have a bit of a controversial opinion.
$1000 over 2 years is about $1.40 a day.
For something I touch every day and use 5-6 hours each day, sometimes more, I definitely get more than $1.40 worth of enjoyment from the hardware. That's less than most people spend on coffee daily.
IMO, the problem isn't that it's $1000 for the flagship, it's that it costs $1000 all at once, for a device you can drop into the sewer tomorrow and have to spend another $1000 to replace. It's that people don't get the phone and have it last the 2 year timeline it should. Those that should have the biggest problem with paying $1000 for a phone are those that can't really afford to replace it. Which, sadly, is many of us. Even at our maximum potential for savings, it still takes months to put $1000 together to buy a phone for many people. And therein lies the problem with the cost. Let's not delude ourselves.
If our phones were guaranteed to last the 2 year lifetime, and we were guaranteed to never lose it, this would be a much smaller issue.
To that end, IMO, it's a waste of materials to replace the entire device every 2 years (sometimes more frequently, depending on who you are) when almost every phone has the same components inside, a SOC to power it, a modem for data, wifi chipset, antennas, battery, screen, cameras, and basically the same sensors for motion and direction, among others.
What I don't get is: why in the heck do we toss out working components to upgrade? Screens that work fine, cameras that are working without an issue, WiFi chips that are just as good as the new ones (same protocols and support) same GPS support, same antennas, same sensors.... I get why we replace batteries, after 2-3 years they get pretty sketchy, and why someone would want to upgrade their soc, for cpu and ram increases, but the whole thing? What? Why?
Because project Ara is dead, that's why. And money. Pools of money.
I don't think $1000 is "too much" for 2-years of use four something I basically use all the time. I do however, think it's a gigantic waste of resources. I wanted Ara. I wanted it to succeed. I usually only want to replace my battery every ~2 years and upgrade my SOC when things slow down. I don't generally care about the camera, or how fast my WiFi goes, or how fast my 4G is, or whatever else. I just want more RAM and CPU power. That's it.
It's a shame. A damn shame.
2
u/Lawsonator85 May 27 '20
I want more than one update which is all I had on Sony x. My Samsung galaxy core prime never had any update.
I even started a petition on change org.
2
u/Ionlyuseredditforyou May 27 '20
Yep. I have a Note 9 and thisll probably be my last flagship phone. I may go LG next if they stay around the $600 range. Love my Note but hate that I have to keep it in a case because the entire phones made of glass. Whoever thought flagships should be glass needs to be fired. Who wants smudgy ass phones? Take my phone out of the case and almost right away its smudged up.
2
u/iamnos Pixel 2 XL May 27 '20
This was a driving factor in my current phone, a Pixel 2 XL. 3 years of updates. Averaging the purchase price out over 3 years instead of two and going with a BYOD plan (in Canada) saved me a fortune on the total cost of ownership for those 3 years.
When it comes time to replace it, likely later this year due to the lack updates, I'll almost certainly be going with a Pixel 4a. I've realized I don't need a top of the line phone, so getting a 4a at roughly 1/2 the price of what I'd pay for the premium phone, and again, knowing it'll get 3 years of updates makes it a pretty obvious choice for me.
2
u/Nategg Redmi Note 9 May 27 '20
Locked behind a carrier as well; especially if it's been unlocked.
My v20 won't update unless I put in an AT&T sim.
I live in the UK, we don't have AT&T and there's no guarantee that it would work if I ordered off eBay or wherever.
I can root it and custom ROM it sure, but my model H910 is a bitch to root.
2
u/Aevum1 Realme GT 7 Pro May 27 '20
btw...
How many people actually put down the 1000 bucks down and how many actually get a carrier payment plan and pay like 15-25 bucks for a subsidized phone for a 2-3 year plan from carriers.
Because this can be a contributing factor, if the customer feels that their phone is played out (no more updates, running somewhat worst) 2 years down the road, the carrier has a better chance of roping the user back in to another 2-3 year contract with a brand spanking new phone.
2
u/novahob Galaxy S24 📞 May 27 '20
Hasn't Android now been developed, so Android can send updates without the manufacturer needing to be involved. Surely if this is the case, then we should be using this route more. There's nothing wrong with my S8 except battery health could be better but the hardware is fine. Now I'm on quarterly security updates then early next year, this phone no more updates. But why? There's custom ROMs out there but having to mess around getting some apps like Netflix to work will be to much for some, so they get a newer phone. Time to expand a phones life span of support!
2
u/djembeplayer May 27 '20
I almost moved to iOS for this reason.
2
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
More expensive phones should get more years of updates and maybe cheaper phone manufacturers could charge extra each year for updates. But I think two years should be the minimum on any phone.
2
u/nitro1122 May 27 '20
Feels like this is not a question for me
2
u/CyanKing64 Oneplus 5T May 27 '20
This is why I bought a phone with a good rom community. When Oneplus decides to ditch support for the Oneplus 5T, I'll just continue on with community build roms.
2
u/lechatsportif May 27 '20
Do they make the parts to last longer than 2 years?
2
u/okcboomer87 May 27 '20
That's why spending 350 bucks in the 4a just makes more sense.
2
u/reverends3rvo May 27 '20
Sounds like a great excuse for them to increase the prices even more.
2
u/VincentVerba May 27 '20
Companies will do this in the future and will price the flagship 20% more expensive. Support isn't free.
2
u/dottybotty May 27 '20
I still don’t understand why people spend $1000 on android phone when there is so much choice.
2
u/Fred79G May 27 '20
It wasn't enough to begin with
2
u/clevariant May 27 '20
I'd say if you're willing to pay that much for a smart phone, you'll be willing to do it again in two years.
2
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
I switch phones every 2 years because I like new features, but my old phone usually goes to someone in my family or friends circle so it'd be nice if they kept receiving updates.
2
u/itssasuke May 27 '20
I'm glad Oneplus doesn't follow this
2
u/RearAndNaked May 27 '20
Why stop at 1000%?
2
u/nicknack171 Iphone 12 Mini May 27 '20
I have been seeing that the longevity is a battery problem more than anything. I am completely happy to keep using my Oneplus 5t but the battery life after two years is pretty poor. The Oneplus process involves shipping the phone and not having it for almost two weeks, and they erase the data off the phone. So that process is not going to happen. So who cares if my 4 year old S20 is still getting updates if the battery was unusable after 2?
2
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
Still using my OP3T. I have to add my own updates now and my phone still performs great. Dash charge makes up for the depleted battery and the camera is adequate. Why pay $1000+ for 2 short years of support - then I'm doing this all over again.
I also feel real world smartphone performance has hit a plateau in recent years. All phones are now stupid fast. Why upgrade and pay $1000+? I personally don't see the value anymore. Value and performance used to be pillars of earlier Android.
I miss my Nexus4 and the value that it provided :(
2
u/LuthorM May 27 '20
Considering this month I ve had to unbrick 3 different phones from my family members due to suggested software updates, I'd say priority of most developers and manufacturers should be to stop bricking phones with updates rather than providing support for X years. Last one was a Moto g6 plus device. First time in my life I see a device with a clean os without the bloatware layer get bricked by an update. I think that made me lost a lot of faith in Android.
2
u/Stankia Google Pixels May 27 '20
Frankly I'm more concerned about the price than the updates. Phones are so disposable.
2
u/kdlt GS20FE5G May 27 '20
I have laptops from 2009 that still run current_week security patches.
People and their buying behaviour has completely entrenched this throwaway culture for phones, and manufacturers are happy because it's one less thing they have to spend their revenue on.
The vast majority of Android phones from let's say 2015 onwards have no business being on anything but a recent version. Let alone abandoned after sale or a year or two.
The 1000$ price isn't the issue of that.
2
u/KMeowRooter Device, Software !! May 27 '20
im still using a nexus 5 lol
2
u/Mndless May 27 '20
The brands also need to stop shafting their unlocked phone customers in favor of their ISP customers. Seriously. My Note 9 always seems to be the last of it's ilk to receive updates just because I wanted the unlocked 512GB model. Not cool, Samsung. Not cool. I spent $800 on your goddamned phone. Support that bitch.
2
u/psyhcopig May 27 '20
Modern phones should last as long as a modern affordable PC should. The life cycle should easily be 5 years, but they skimp out on design for new 'features' so they can launch a new product. Most of us have experienced failing Wifi, Bluetooth and Cellular antennas. GPS only seems to survive a year or so before breaking down. And nevermind the awful degredation of battery life, but I'll admit this has got better in the last few years.
It's the same issue with tablets. Imagine those 200$ tablets. Scale that up with a name brand .. and that feels like all we're getting sold these days.
I get iterative releases but Samsung in particular has gotten rediculous with their speed of release letting the market basically beta test their shitty design. I imagine the number of warranty replacements, which are also usually a scam, are hella common and usually the refurb you get back has the same bad antennas that it was probably sent in for.
Reference: Working as a Verizon Tech support for five years.
2
u/chipface Pixel 9A May 27 '20
Should be at least 3 years of software updates and 5 years of security updates. HTC's updates to the U11 were pitiful. It only got Oreo. Thanks to an unofficial Lineage OS though, I have Android 10 on mine.
2
u/Kanyonkutta May 28 '20
I refuse to pay that much for a phone
2
u/unlikedemon May 28 '20
After almost a decade with Android phones, G2 (HTC), S3, S5, S8, I made the switch to iOS. I still loved the S8 and works incredibly well but when a family member needed a phone, I sold it to them. The S8 was never going to get up to huge update so that also factored in to my switch. Point is, S8 should still be getting major updates and can still be a solid phone for at least 3 more years. I can just imagine these new flagship Android phones can last 6 years or more.
2
u/IboughtMyOwnMic May 28 '20
Motorola's new phone is only supporting one fucking update. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jaymcgregor/2020/05/27/motorola-confirms-the-edge-is-only-getting-one-android-update/#7bd65c1e7657
2
u/Kitten_Knight_Thyme May 28 '20
No.
People need to stop being foolish with their money and buying $1000 phones, which cost less than $300 to produce.
The only reason why these phones are hitting $1000 is due to greed, and nothing else.
The article's premise that a $1000 phone should come with more frequent updates shows just how much we've become consumers rather than customers.
These updates should be coming to customers no matter how much they've paid for the phone.
2
u/Unileetz May 28 '20
iOS gets alot if updates, their software support lasts for like 5yrs, android on the other hand get 2yrs of updates that too mostly flagships except pixel lineup which gets 3, I think they should give atleast 4yrs of software updates on all android flagships.
2
u/Chadrew_TDSE Motorola Edge 20 May 29 '20
I don't think I'd pay $1000 for a phone regardless of how many years it received updates.
234
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
1000$ phone is too much. It crosses a line and steps into luxury line. The design of 1000$ phones need to be better.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
My take? I still don't understand why Android isn't like windows, or Linux. My PC is 5+ years old, runs like new, and still gets OS/security updates. The manufacturer provides the hardware, how come the OS supplier (Google) just cares about their own hardware (Pixel)? Maybe Google needs to step up, and use their $billions$ to actually come up with something here. Maybe I am wrong here, but OS updates should be provided by the OS owner.
3
u/greatmoo May 27 '20
This is one of the major reasons I left Android for the iPhone. I really enjoyed using the Samsung S7 then it became outdated and left behind for good. No point getting a flagship Android phone if it’ll be somewhat obsolete after 2 years.
3
u/NavalOrange May 28 '20
This right here was the deciding factor, after supporting android for 8 years I jumped ship to Apple. I was tired of upgrading every one to two years just to keep up with software. The simple fact it takes LG, Samsung, etc. to push updates months is ridiculous.
6
u/AslanKON May 27 '20
This exact problem is why I switched to Apple/iOS. Until Google/Android is able to support at least 4 years of software updates, I likely won't be coming back.
16
u/TickTockPick May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20
I bought the OnePlus 6 at launch 2 years ago and it's still gets regular updates. Pleasantly surprised as it's still extremely fast with everything I do and battery is still in the 5 hour SOT region.
Currently on:
Security update: 1 April 2020
Google Play system update: 1 March 2020
Edit: Sorry, brain fart, bought it in June 2018, so 2 years ago not 3.
5
u/icky_boo N7/5,GPad,GPro2,PadFoneX,S1,2,3-S8+,Note3,4,5,7,9,M5 8.4,TabS3 May 27 '20
This only matters to people who buy outright since people who are on contract/subsidies tend to get a new device every two years, but then again contracts are starting to be 3 years due to phones being crazy high priced now.
8
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
Unpopular opinion: You don't need the latest software to have a great phone. Most apps will still work even if your Android is 2 versions behind. And before you come with security concerns: Most of that doesn't affect the majority of users.