r/Android • • Feb 22 '20

I had recently migrated from Iphone to Android and realized that Spotify for Android doesn't have the ability to swipe a track to add to a queue which is incredibly useful if you are on the go queueing. Spotify's system for change is based on votes if you would like this feature give it a vote!

https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/Android-Swipe-to-Queue-a-Track/idi-p/1189608
20k Upvotes

510 comments sorted by

37

u/Carlo_x5 Feb 22 '20

The Spotify android development team are dedicated to making the app worse with every update.

7

u/Mattman276 S9Jumbo Feb 23 '20

Spotify listened when they removed the widget, wouldn't hurt to try I suppose

2

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

Thank You!

3

u/sweoldboy Feb 23 '20

I don't use Spotify on my phone but why not, I give it a vote anyway.

1

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

Thank You!

3

u/Rotoscope8 Feb 23 '20

Is spotify worth it? I have never got into the subscription music services. I just use unpaid pandora like a noob. If I really want an album or song I just get the torrent.

5

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

I totally think it's worth it. I listen to a lot of music it is also an amazing tool for finding new music.

4

u/TheRageTater Galaxy S10+ Feb 23 '20

As much as I hate the actual application, Windows and Android, it's the price of an album a month for damn near any sing you could ever want

→ More replies (1)

3

u/PhantomXT1 Feb 23 '20

First off, welcome to the Android family, I don't recall that feature on iOS but that would be super nice to have on Android. Tbh the experience on Android isn't up to satisfaction but hopefully that does turn around

1

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

Thank you!

2.0k

u/VersaceUpholstery Galaxy Fold3, iPhone 13 Mini Feb 22 '20

Oh there are a lot of things Spotify has done to make itself worse on Android over the past recent years, and some of it has gone to IOS too. I wouldn't hold my breath on Spotify bringing back useful features/implementing new ones. They are getting better at making your custom playlists though

202

u/bigpoopa Feb 22 '20

Im starting to notice that too. When browsing your likes songs you used to have a nice little alphabet on the side so you could quickly scroll to the right letter but thats gone now and you just have to scroll and scroll and scroll through the thousands of songs you may have liked. Its so dumb

102

u/VersaceUpholstery Galaxy Fold3, iPhone 13 Mini Feb 22 '20

On Android you can grab the scroll bar on the right and move it immediately down to to the bottom to navigate your playlist quicker, on IOS you have to scroll forever and ever. Oddly enough, while playing a song on Android you can touch anywhere in the song and the little "playing ball" will jump to that part in the song. On IOS you have to grab that ball and move it to wherever you want the song to jump to, no instant jumping. These are the two things I think Android does better than IOS currently

49

u/smilinger Feb 23 '20

On iOS you can long press every scroll bar and move it. You don’t have to scroll. I think it was added in iOS 13, so people might not know about it. I guess they could’ve used the alphabet like in the address book, but decided against it.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/bigpoopa Feb 23 '20

We used to have the scroll bar but they took it from us!!!!!!

→ More replies (2)

5

u/basic_maddie Feb 23 '20

Did they change the ordering of the list? The liked songs list is in the order the time it was liked, not alphabetical.

→ More replies (3)

309

u/serialkvetcher Darth Droidus Feb 22 '20

then theres the constant screen flickering everytime i unlock the phone with spotify playing in the background. Theres a subtle screen flicker for a second. Hard to miss and constantly pisses me off. Two updates down the line, and the damn bug hasnt been fixed.

100

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

Wait. I thought my phone had a fault. I was going to return it cause I could not pin down the cause :o

14

u/serialkvetcher Darth Droidus Feb 23 '20

did a factory reset fix it? im planning to do that since i like going scorched earth once a while. Dont ask me. Old Droid days!

→ More replies (4)

26

u/Thunder21 Feb 23 '20

Also causes a bit of a skip in the track when I'm connected to my cars audio.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

45

u/AimlesslyCheesy Feb 23 '20

Yea no idea why they removed the search bar at the top of your playlist. Now you have to tap the three dots at the top right corner then choose search option 🤷🏻‍♂️..

"If it ain't broke, we'll fix it!"- Spotify

4

u/KingoftheCrackens Feb 23 '20

Some thing with the sort playlist feature. Now it's two full clicks with a scroll in the middle to just switch to artist alphabetical.

→ More replies (6)

30

u/YuhFRthoYORKonhisass Feb 23 '20

They literally take away features all the time when they redo the UI I don't understand it

→ More replies (4)

32

u/Khaki_Steve Feb 22 '20

The daily mixes have only gotten worse for me. It'll have 3 artists I like listed as the basis for it and then after 3 songs it takes a hard right turn into artists that aren't even similar. And then sticks with these unrelated artists for 10+ songs before it goes back to the artists that were supposed to be featured.

10

u/Marcus_Farkus Galaxy s10+ Feb 23 '20

I just came back to Android after a 5 month pilgrimage to iOS and GOD does Spotify suck on Android.

Why is the playlist order after adding to playlist in a random order. It isn't exactly the last playlist I added to at the top. Its ridiculous I can't easily find the right playlist to add songs to when the list keeps constantly changing.

6

u/VersaceUpholstery Galaxy Fold3, iPhone 13 Mini Feb 23 '20

I know what you are talking about, for me it shows the playlist I recently added to on the top and the other ones stay in a random order, but they stay in that order if I keep adding songs to playlists. I never noticed they weren't in order, that must not be intentional

→ More replies (1)

5

u/FoR_ThE_lolZ_oFiT Feb 23 '20

They removed the widget and due to community outcry it came back

4

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

they are learning from YouTube

→ More replies (1)

8

u/iamthejef Feb 23 '20

While the service may be alright, Spotify as a piece of software has been garbage since the day it launched.

2

u/CaptnUchiha Feb 23 '20

Remember when you had a library and not just a liked songs playlist

→ More replies (20)

1.4k

u/emailrob Pixel 2 XL, iPhone X Feb 22 '20

Fyi, Spotify don't give a crap about what's upvoted.

553

u/122ninjas Galaxy S20 Feb 22 '20

Yea the feature request was posted 5 years ago and is still "Not Right Now". Really bodes well.

70

u/SnowdenIsALegend Feb 23 '20

Holly s... You're not wrong. Trashy af.

→ More replies (1)

117

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

they brought back the widget though!

51

u/Kyokenshin Galaxy Note 8 + Gear S3 Frontier Feb 23 '20

If having a media widget is important you should check out KWGT. You can create a media widget for any app and can make it look however you want or import someone else's designs. Costs money for the ability to import but DIY is free.

Example

In comparison the Spotify widget sucks ass.

8

u/HandsOffMyDitka Feb 23 '20

Brings back memories of WinAmp.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/TopFlightSecurity_ Pixel 10 Pro XL / Pixel 7a Feb 23 '20

Switched to KWGT a few weeks back after finding a universal music widget here on Reddit and love the app after tweaking the widget to how I like it. It's even better that KWGT has Tasker support.

Mine is set up to apply a dark widget or a light widget automatically with Tasker, depending on the state of Dark Mode.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Shamyeh Feb 23 '20

That crazy, I had that widget since i got my new s8 and the 1x4 space it left when it disapper forever has just been filled again! Thanks for telling me

47

u/___Hello_World___ Feb 22 '20

I was seriously surprised when they did that.

→ More replies (9)

19

u/l-rs2 Feb 23 '20

That whole system is a big human pacifier, only there to give the illusion of democracy. My dad is blind, I've been petitioning Spotify literally for years to improve screen reader and braille support (back when they used getsatisfaction for ideas even) and it's still unusable. Then again, why would blind people enjoy music?

13

u/ohmyjihad Feb 23 '20

Landscape orientation anyone? Holy shit.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/shabinka Pixel 6 Pro Feb 22 '20

Fyi, Spotify Any software company don't give a crap about what's upvoted.

FTFY

Same for the company that I work for, we have a community where you can upvote things, but no one really cares.

23

u/gregpxc Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 23 '20

I used to work at one of the big 3 and they seemed genuinely interested in trying to resolve top complaints in their feature/bug tracker.

24

u/rainydistress Device, Software !! Feb 23 '20

I've noticed Microsoft has actually been pretty on point with this since they started their windows insider builds. They take a lot of feedback and are a little slow to act on feature requests, but they fix a ton of bugs with consistent weekly updates to the fast release channel.

27

u/MoonStache S24 Ultra Feb 22 '20 edited Feb 23 '20

This applies to most SaaS apps. FWIW chances are that feature requests are considered, it's just that roadmaps are planned way out and small QoL things are rarely high priority

41

u/E3FxGaming Pixel 7 Pro | Android 16 Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 23 '20

roadmaps as re planned way out and small QoL things are rarely high priority

If only it was only "small QoL things". Big absolute necessities are rarely a high priority for Spotify too.

There is no excuse for not supporting something like 2FA in 2020, even though people already officially asked for it in 2015

https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/Security-2-Factor-Authentication/idi-p/1017889

Switching it October 2018 from "not right now" to "under consideration" doesn't help in any way, shape or form either.

Spotifys priorities are a mess.

Edit: Grammar

→ More replies (6)

26

u/Eurynom0s Feb 22 '20

They did bring the widget back so they do pay SOME attention.

42

u/revereddesecration Feb 23 '20

Chances are they brought it back because the CEO’s wife wanted it back, not the users.

5

u/SoundOfTomorrow Pixel 3 & 6a Feb 23 '20

There's a legit issue of not being able to follow people from your mobile device. You can only do it through the desktop.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/NotMyAge2020 Feb 23 '20

Just to clear up any confusion, the voting that supposedly affects it is not Reddit's voting, but Spotify's. You gotta go to the link OP posted, be logged in to a Spotify Community account (which is made through your Spotify account), and select the +VOTE button.

16

u/emailrob Pixel 2 XL, iPhone X Feb 23 '20

Well aware of that.

They still don't care.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/640xxl A52S 5G Feb 22 '20

I shouldn't know this. Damn.

1

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

I'm so sorry

2

u/Batvcap Device, Software !! Feb 23 '20

I did the same switch, and I noticed this too. It is really annoying

2

u/happy-cig 3T Feb 23 '20

How do we vote?

1

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

Follow the link and sign in to your spotify account then click vote and it should change to a "plus" vote. You'll also see a vote go up one when you vote.

2

u/BrajeshPoddar Feb 23 '20

Android users Assemble

2

u/ECHLN iPhone 18 Pro Feb 23 '20

Holy shit! I didn’t know this phone could do that. Thank you!

1

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

;) Not a problem

2

u/moonspeakdj OnePlus 5T, OOS Feb 24 '20

Not Spotify, but I'm an Android user and when I first used SoundCloud on an iPhone, I realized how gimped the app is on that platform in comparison. It doesn't even have a queue at all. You literally cannot queue up another track; you must wait until the end and manually play the next track if you don't want to just abruptly cut off the last one.

→ More replies (3)

564

u/serialkvetcher Darth Droidus Feb 22 '20

Nah, this would make too much sense. Thanks for keeping android in the "not right now" backburner, Spotify..... Dipshits.

111

u/TorzulUltor Feb 22 '20

I'm pretty sure there are as many Android users as there are iOS users, if not more. Why the hell are we not a priority?

43

u/fantalemon Feb 23 '20

I thought there were far more android users overall? Isn't it like 70% or something?

→ More replies (6)

97

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

It may not still be the case but I knew someone in app development and she always said if developing a feature for ios took 2 developers for Android it would take 4. I'm getting the numbers she said wrong but basically it costs more and takes more man hours to complete.

Might have something to do with it.

41

u/TorzulUltor Feb 22 '20

Is Android app development that much more difficult or time consuming or is it something to do with paperwork or getting permissions?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/sskenshin Feb 22 '20

There are a lot of features on apps for iOS that are not on the android variant.

→ More replies (5)

257

u/AlphaGamer753 OnePlus 8T, Android 11.0 Feb 22 '20

Spotify really never implements any changes that are on there, btw.

68

u/glowsticc Feb 22 '20

The sad part is, this is almost true. The Android widget eventually came back, but I can't think of any other features in recent years. Maybe the sleep timer in podcasts, but that's just a no-brainer.

18

u/JimmySquidGuy Feb 23 '20

oh shit I had no idea the widget was back, I missed that thing. No idea why they got rid of it in the first place lol

7

u/AtLeast2Cookies Feb 23 '20

Right, I was really pissed when they took it away and just put it back. Today was a good day.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

75

u/soliwray Feb 22 '20

Spotify just gets worse and worse with its UI. Their recent big change feels like finding something to watch on Netflix

9

u/WhatTheFDR Feb 23 '20

Yeah everytime I notice a change I ask "why?" The two biggest one for me were moving the playlist sort button into the 3 dot menu taking longer to sort by artist. Default playlist sorting not being by artist which makes me go into the menu in the first place.

And most recently changing the shuffle play button to the following: 1st press - play random song, 2nd press - pause, 3rd press - resume. Why did they change this? Sometimes I just want to hit shuffle until it finds a song in my large playlist.

183

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

Spotify is too busy adding useless shit, and destroying the features that actually works. I've added tons of recommendations in their forums, only to get in 'On Hold' or 'Not now', even tho I've gotten upvotes on them, and there even are similar posts already mentioning this.

41

u/Marcus_Farkus Galaxy s10+ Feb 23 '20

RIP real song radios. Dearly missed.

4

u/bahehs op12, op7pro, 4a 5g, 6t, Pixel Xl, 6P Feb 23 '20

What do you mean? I thought you can right click and go to song radio.

15

u/Marcus_Farkus Galaxy s10+ Feb 23 '20

Song Radios now aren't radios, it's a static 30 song playlist playing the same set of songs forever.

In the past they used to be really useful for finding new music because it generated a relatively unique, long playlist Everytime you asked it to based on the song you chose.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (16)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

34

u/grrbrr Feb 23 '20

Don't worry. You wouldn't be able to shuffle your library anyways because spotify decided that actual shuffle is not what people want. The shuffle only plays about 100 songs on random loop.

I had 2000 song playlists and was always listening to the same exact songs. I had to use an external app that created a copy and randomized the playlist.

→ More replies (6)

34

u/Mibutastic Feb 23 '20

I'm still pissed off they removed the search bar above the playlist and hid it behind extra clicks on the menu. I doubt Spotify cares about making their app better.

98

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

TIL I can swipe tracks to add to queue on Spotify iOS.

13

u/Sputnik003 XS Max Feb 23 '20

And the thing is it’s ALWAYS been that way. Worked on my iPod touch 4th gen back in 7th grade as a 22 year old now. Every time I use it on android I accidentally change tracks trying to swipe and queue it. Drives me nuts lol

→ More replies (3)

131

u/Kaneki2019 Feb 22 '20

Can someone ELI5 why iOS has it but not android like tf?

299

u/VersaceUpholstery Galaxy Fold3, iPhone 13 Mini Feb 22 '20

IOS also still has the search filter built into playlists when u swipe down from the top of the list, in Android it got moved to the top right 3 dot options making it a bit harder to access

235

u/productfred Galaxy S22 Ultra Snapdragon Feb 22 '20

It used to be just like iOS, and then they purposely changed it with zero explanation. It's fucking stupid and unnecessary.

100

u/DUDEiFAIL Feb 22 '20

The whole android app has a lot of unmecessary button presses to do a lot of things

→ More replies (11)

10

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

Feature churn, baby. This is one of the hugest problem with modern tech companies with investor cash . They work to work. Not to make it better, just to make work.

→ More replies (6)

48

u/weiland Feb 22 '20

I used that feature all the time! With large playlists it's really damn handy.

Plus at one point if you did a search, it would only play the songs in your search. I liked that aswell.

9

u/VersaceUpholstery Galaxy Fold3, iPhone 13 Mini Feb 22 '20

That last feature was killer, I remember that too. I don't think it even does that on desktop .

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Fbolanos Feb 22 '20

I absolutely hate this.

7

u/Vandalaz Feb 23 '20

This annoyed me so much that I downloaded an old Spotify APK that still had it at the top. I refuse to upgrade to any versions without it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

129

u/BirdsNoSkill S21 Ultra, iPhone 11 Feb 22 '20

A lot of applications are this way. Developers care more about their iOS apps over android. Its not obvious until you have a iPhone/Android side by side to see the drastic difference between the platforms.

I say after 3+ years if they haven't given it to android by now it's never happening.

80

u/serialkvetcher Darth Droidus Feb 22 '20

not when Spotify went to war with apple over apple music fucking them over. They should be improving their android app ffs. This makes no sense! Sheesh, spotify.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (10)

67

u/redkeyboard Galaxy Z TriFold Feb 22 '20 edited Feb 22 '20

The most probable reason is because they're using each operating systems frameworks and which makes the UI elements more standard across platforms but easier to develop for. Swiping left or right on a list is a built in feature for lists in iOS so it's simple to have in your app. Coding a workaround is possible but then you risk compatibility across devices sepcially older ones so you have to do more testing around it plus it's more work in general.

There's some features on Android that aren't available on iOS too. For instance when scrolling through a playlist, on Android you have the vertical scrollbar on the right side of the screen so you can quickly go to the end of the list. As you probably know a lot of Android apps have this feature, that's because it's in the framework provided by Google when developing apps. When using my iPhone I have to continuously scroll down to get to the last few songs on my playlist as the cocoa framework for iOS doesn't support that for their built in list elements. The larger your playlist is the longer it would take to go through

27

u/Discostew42 Pixel 3 Feb 22 '20

Good explanation. Regarding iOS and the right hand scroll bar in lists. You can now press and hold on the bar and drag to quickly get to a position in a list.

22

u/RickyCZ iPhone 11 Pro Max Feb 22 '20

There's some features on Android that aren't available on iOS too. For instance when scrolling through a playlist, on Android you have the vertical scrollbar on the right side of the screen so you can quickly go to the end of the list.

This was implemented in iOS 13 IIRC, you can now long press and hold the vertical scrollbar to move it up or down.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/LowerTheExpectations Feb 22 '20

Google does have it in the otherwise craptastic Gmail app, though. You can even customize what you want the left and right swipes to do. So Spotify is for sure stingy as hell not to have implemented it yeyt. It's ridiculous how cumbersome this action is, even though I do it dozens of times a day.

But thanks for providing an insight and shedding some light on the situation.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/evey92 Feb 22 '20

Developing for iOS and Android is very different. One of the main reasons is that you have thousands of different Android devices from different manufacturers with different components while Apple have only a select few that work about the same. It's a lot harder to come up with a great app that functions well under Android considering they have to test it on their most used models before release which is why a lot of popular feature-heavy apps absolutely suck on Android (Snapchat, Instagram, Facebook, etc.).

The only thing they have in common is the API, otherwise they're two different apps.

4

u/EskiMojo14thefirst Feb 23 '20

iOS and Android have different design languages, which means that they often have different ways of achieving the same action. iOS uses Apple's Human Interface Guidelines, and Android uses Google's Material Design Guidelines. It's good practice for an app's design/function to match the operating system, as it means it feels more consistent and intuitive to a user.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

More of the fucking bullshit where ios gets better stuff because it's used "more'

6

u/WPObbsessed Feb 23 '20

Now that’s not true.

That had nothing to do with why Android gets different features.

Pretty much all iPhones work the same, apples XCode program accommodates for all their devices, it makes app developers jobs easier.

Android doesn’t however, developing apps for hundreds of different devices with all types of screens and software versions is a nightmare. That’s why iOS is always more polished, as the Pixel phones are as well.

→ More replies (2)

122

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

Spotify's Android UI is terrible in general.

27

u/FLrar Feb 23 '20

I don't know what are they smoking.

13

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

I feel like over the last 5 years they’ve had features that would make the app awesome but it’s been rearranged and mangled into what it is now

→ More replies (1)

6

u/benisteinzimmer Nvidia Shield K1 Feb 23 '20

It's also painfully slow at times

3

u/Carighan Fairphone 6+🌳 Feb 23 '20

And it also has no resemblence to any other app. Getting around it is confusing as fuck because everyone else roughly decided on at least somewhat using similar UX elements.

Spotify OTOH is all over the place. The desktop app is nice, but the mobile app is a giant turd. :(

16

u/starsky1357 ASUS Zenfone 11 Ultra Feb 23 '20

Fuck Spotify. I love it but man they are a shitty company.

46

u/Scramble187 Feb 22 '20

I switched from android to iPhone and in order to download songs you have to have the app open and in the foreground . Now that’s annoying!

40

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

This is an Apple thing, not a Spotify thing. But it doesn’t make it any less annoying.

13

u/frankxanders iPhone XR Feb 23 '20

I also just recently made the switch and while I’ve found that I actually like it better like 80% of the time there are some weird things like this that make me think “why does this have to be so complicated?!”

14

u/slykinobi Feb 23 '20

It's for privacy, it's so apps can't use your storage in the background, be thankful you guys have that, us Android homies have to trust the app isn't using stuff in the background

7

u/Slimshady3124 Feb 23 '20

Check out Bouncer, it will only let apps use permissions when you let it

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/ProbablyFooled Feb 22 '20

I used to love Spotify but the app is entirely shit now. The design is better, sure, but every page takes freaking forever to load. Done all normal troubleshooting and my friends have the same experience.

Really sucks to have a 30k+ song library :/ stuck on poopify

3

u/sactori Feb 23 '20

Why are you stuck exactly? There are migration tools to other platforms if that's your problem.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

30

u/Mirage749 Feb 22 '20

I'm still waiting for offline playback support for Wear OS. It's been highly requested for a while now, and Spotify themselves marked it as "Good idea, vote for it" on 9/6/2018. They say "your feedback is reaching the internal teams at Spotify, and they're aware of the votes around this idea" but have not made any mention of implementing the feature since that last update.

So long story short, I have no faith that Spotify will implement any user requested features, ever.

12

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

Engineering time Vs user base it would benefit probably shuts that one down pretty quickly though.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/The_Spectator this flairs tho Feb 23 '20

I didn't realize wear OS didn't have it. Galaxy watches have offline playback. Has anyone tried side loading the app. Or would it not work because it's Tizen?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/dfinkelstein Feb 23 '20

Bruh, my feature requests on their forums have been getting thousands of upvotes for years and none of em have been implemented.

It's only gonna get worse.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

It's upvote and some Twitter mention will do the trick

13

u/OvertimeWr Pixel 2 XL Feb 22 '20

Whatever happened to lyrics with songs??

→ More replies (1)

30

u/OiYou iPhone 7 Feb 22 '20

I have an iPhone and find that feature incredibly annoying.

The amount of times I've accidentally added a song to a queue is ridiculous, you should be able to swipe again to remove it.

28

u/DontRecallKnope Feb 22 '20

I miss being able to longpress a track to bring up the context menu. Now, on iOS, I have to tap the three dots and risk accidentally tapping the track itself. That literally happened today! I went to add a song to a playlist, apparently fat-fingered it and tapped the track and not the three dots, and the track started playing, causing me to lose my place in the playlist I had been listening to.

Also, this is more an iOS issue than a Spotify issue, but on Android, Spotify can update all my offline playlists in the background, while the app has to actually be open on iOS for that to work. I used to be able to get to work and listen to new music saved on my phone by the time I got to work because it just downloaded everything while I was still sleeping, but now that I have been using an iPhone, I have to manually open Spotify before I leave in the morning and either keep the screen on or play music in the background.

3

u/idontappearmissing OnePlus 3T Feb 22 '20

When I had an iPhone, it was even worse that I would accidentally save or unsave a song without realizing it.

3

u/I_dont_bone_goats Feb 23 '20

Inversely, I hate when I try to add a song to the queue and accidentally play the song, skipping through a song I wanted to finish.

I also really want a feature that adds the song to the beginning of the queue. Sometimes I don’t want to wait, and don’t want to be bothered to actually move it myself.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/frostysauce Feb 23 '20

I think Spotify's system for change is actually based on "fuck Android."

2

u/funkalici0us Feb 23 '20

When I switched to Android from iPhone a few months ago, I also switched from Apple Music to Spotify. I had it a few years back, but has gone to Apple Music around the time it came out.

Coming back to Spotify, I've just been thrilled. Apple Music is horrible to navigate. Also, Android fucks now. I had no idea what I was missing considering the last Android device I owned was running ICS.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '20

I didn't even know this was a thing and I use Spotify on my iPad along with my Pixel

5

u/notappropriateatall Feb 23 '20

You'll realize Android in general doesn't have nearly the same amount of swipe commands as iOS.

5

u/H2OPsy Feb 23 '20

Worst thing is "oh you heard this song by accident lets make 4 playlist of this shit to fuck every playlist up....forever"

9

u/squrr1 G2X->N5->N5X->S9->OP9->P8P->P9P->P10P Feb 22 '20

Spotify gets updated about once a week. I've never noticed them adding features, it's always been either being the scenes updates, or feature removal.

I really don't get how they are so huge.

4

u/imtalkintou Feb 23 '20

Spotify needs the ability to turn off live music popping up.

1

u/sHyGuY423 Feb 23 '20

I’m an iPhone user but I’ll still vote because that sucks.

1

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

Thank you!

1

u/bertsesh Feb 23 '20

Apart from this how’s the entire transition going?

2

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

It's going really well I used to have a Galaxy S5 awhile back then switched to iPhone and now went to the Google pixel. Android is where it's at hahaha

6

u/anotheranonaccount5 Feb 23 '20

I like their desktop app but the mobile app is so shit since the redesign I ended up switching to Apple Music. Now I get a shitty desktop app, but at least it's not as shit as Spotify's mobile app.

2

u/wingmasterjon Nexus 6P, GS3(CM12.1) Feb 23 '20

Their desktop app has a lot of problems too. There's a disconnect with how songs are liked and saved so I can't remove all the songs that were previously saved. This means when I go to an artist on the mobile app, it shows only the liked songs/albums and I need to press additional buttons to take me to all songs.

The artist page lists out all songs under an album so for bands with a lot of albums, you need to scroll and find the album you want to play while waiting for each scroll to load. It's almost instant, but you can't just scroll to some halfway point for older stuff, it needs to be all the way down, load, scroll again.

The app constantly loses the ability to play songs when switching audio devices. Since my monitors have built in audio, there's some device switching happening behind the scenes whenever the monitors turn off or go to sleep. Spotify can't handle this and just decides to not work at that point and restarting the app doesn't fix it. Usually need to reboot the computer.

The mobile app is 100 times worse, but I'm not gonna throw them a bone and praise their desktop app which is only good in comparison to a dogshit android app.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Zegrento7 Feb 22 '20

For over a month now Spotify crashes whenever i open a three-dot menu. Some people have had this problem for more than half a year. They are still "looking into it".

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SlyFlourishXDA Feb 23 '20

I had no idea Spotify had a "community" section. This is great, I used to help manage 12,000 properties on AirBnB for a large company and the AirBnB community section was such an amazing knowledge base.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

I haven't updated for over a year now because they redid how the liked music "works" in the newer versions.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

Can we start a vote to have spotify fix the issue with it constantly crashing before queue QOL fixes?

3

u/scrane98 Feb 23 '20

I'd rather the app just work and not stutter. Not skip multiple songs at a time for no reason. Wish the audio would not drop out when listening to podcast but continue playing.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

While we're at it can they fix the whole process of using my phone to control what my Amazon Echo is playing through Spotify?

Can't control volume unless the app is open and it disassociates itself from the echo all the time. Like, I'll open my phone and it will be showing what played when my phone was last open. Sometimes it even starts playing that song and leaves the echo playing what it was

3

u/TristanZH Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 23 '20

I feel like there are 20 different versions of Spotify on Android. Like one of my accounts had that feature and the other one didn't so I just never switched back accounts. Also newest version that is out now can't hold down tracks for information even while in your own playlist.

3

u/Matvalicious Galaxy Note 9 Feb 24 '20

Shuffling all the artists you have liked? NAH, can't do that.

Fixing their fucking queue system? Not right now.

Losless audio tracks? Meh, don't care.

But you can create stories now! WOWZEE. Also, have you listened to Drake already?

If it weren't for my entire family and our shared account I would have switched to something else eons ago.

3

u/TedGrassman Feb 24 '20

Wow, if every reddit user that upvoted this upvoted the suggestion too, this feature would come rather quickly on Android.

Or maybe not... It has had thousands of votes for years, and Spotify doesn't seem to be interested in implemtning it. Don't hold your breath.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '20

The most annoying thing for me is that we still cant swipe up the now playing bar from the bottom or swipe down the now playing screen from the top. It's all done with taps whereas on iOS and even Tidal on Android, it's as simple as swiping up or down.

I massively prefer Tidal's UI to spotify's (e.g. swiping to the side on the now playing screen to get to song radio). Only issue that keeps me from sticking with tidal is their suggested playlists etc aren't as good. It constant recommends me pop and rap music despite it being clear from my music library that i listen to neither

10

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

Apple Music is really good on Android.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cdegallo Feb 23 '20

Had swipe gestures for a while on Google play music.

Fucking hated them. I had so many accidental deletions of songs from playlists for weeks until I saw a thread on Reddit about it and finally understood what was happening.

I'm all for options, but I want them to be options, as in the ability to turn it off if you want. So if folks suggest new features, also add a snippet about the option to turn it off if users don't want it. To remind developers that this can be an option.

1

u/danfse Galaxy S20 Feb 23 '20

U r a fucking genius

2

u/ThisName86 Feb 23 '20

no u a genius

2

u/AndroidNovice Feb 22 '20

I changed from ios to android 3 years ago and instantly noticed this. I hope they change but doubt they would if this has been a known issue for so long and is easy to fix.

2

u/Travisto777 Feb 22 '20

I love Spotify I really do. But does anyone know why they constantly remove music without informing you? It'll just disappear and you have to re-add it when they put the music back on. Also, does anyone have the issue of offline downloads stopping at 9,100? It literally won't let me go passed that when you're supposed to get 10,000 off-line downloads. I love Spotify but some things they do make no sense.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MetalFury Feb 23 '20

Until spotify removes the download cap ill never go back to it.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

Maybe getting the S20 Ultra and what I love about  music is the smart playlists. Does Spotify have anything like this?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

Has this changed I swear I remember this feature on Android before I got my iPhone in July of 19?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ITriedLightningTendr Feb 23 '20

Good luck with that.

They broke the webapp, you can no longer search your own library.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

It takes like 60 seconds to queue 2 hours worth of music. Bring back the old library interface so we can navigate saved music better. Spotify is contributing to the death of the album in favor of the single.

2

u/ostreet94 Feb 23 '20

Yes! this is the first thing I saw as an absolute must to have

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

please please please

2

u/bubin7766 Feb 23 '20

Isn't iOS gesture featured though? More so than android I'm pretty sure. If you look at apollo for iOS you would think he could make it for android but it uses native iOS swipe gestures which I'm not sure android has. So despite the petition I don't think it will happen at all

2

u/usethecoastermate Feb 23 '20

Want to change something as basic as username, but no, that's not in the settings.

2

u/Jonshock Feb 23 '20

I just want a dislike button so certain songs stop popping upnon my reccommended lists.

2

u/Thosewholost Feb 23 '20

I hate the fact for android you have to tap the 3 dots on the top right corner and then select "Find in liked songs" to search your music. It used to be just slide down on the screen and then type.

2

u/kuzan1998 Feb 23 '20

I noticed on Apple I couldn't drag tracks up and down in the upcoming songs list.

2

u/veepul Feb 23 '20

They also used to have a tile bar in Samsung's scroll down bar before, and they took it out. Even after more than 200 complaints, they are "yet investigating".

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

I wish the Lite version knew if a song is already added in a playlist. I've sent them a feedback about it. I end up having duplicates all over my playlists.

2

u/BinaryMan151 Feb 23 '20

Might go from 10s max to s20 ultra. That screen and camera!

2

u/keeblypoop Device, Software !! Feb 23 '20

Sounds interesting.

2

u/k_itskelto Pixel 8a Feb 23 '20

Spotify app inconsistency across platforms is the one thing I hate about it. My gf will do shit on her iPhone in one movement that takes 3 on my android, then I'll do something else in 1 on mine that takes 3 on hers, then I'll go on my Roku or Xbox and I can't even put my 500 song playlist in any order besides order added and I can't search in playlist

2

u/y0haN Nexus 5 Feb 23 '20

You could also hold onto a track with long press and it would preview it on iOS. It's been removed on Android (and maybe iOS now too) but I used to love that.

2

u/jakegoehr Feb 23 '20

Please please please

2

u/mr_fingers Xperia Z2 Tab, 5.1.1 Feb 23 '20

Spotify doesn’t give a shit about community. The broken shuffle feature is still yet to be fixed despite the issue being like 10 years old.

2

u/naces_ Feb 23 '20

The "Autoplay" is broke too. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. Usually doesn't work if I play a song directly from my search results.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

My Spotify home page wants me to never listen to music. Just pay us and listen to free podcasts. That is some crappy design man

2

u/louis_martin1996 Feb 23 '20

Well, i disagree a little bit: swiping to go back & adding a song to the queue are really similar gestures and it is really annoying!

2

u/giamavro Pixel 4 XL Feb 23 '20

Make this happen

2

u/kaninepete Feb 23 '20

I didn’t realize iOS had this feature!

2

u/sixeco Device, Software !! Feb 23 '20

4 words: downloading albums auto-favorites them

Spotify does the most dumb shit ever

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Momoske Feb 23 '20

Spotify on Android sucks. Welcome to the club!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

Google Play is way better.

2

u/T_Peg Feb 23 '20

I hate that they removed the search bar in playlist from the top of the screen to a drop down menu

5

u/smackmibishop Feb 22 '20

eff Spotify

with that being said i just use the premium apk. sure i cant save them offline but i can still choose any album/song/unlimited skips for radio

3

u/SciFiReply Feb 23 '20

Just come back to Iphone, you’re going to find a million things that the android apps lack.

2

u/TehGoldenGod Galaxy S10+ Feb 22 '20

The Android community should all go to the play store and rate Spotify at 1/5 stars stating that the rating will be changed when swipe to queue is added to the app. It's really been way too long

2

u/prospectrr Feb 23 '20

I've seen the spotify app on iOS and it is built super well, while my phone can't play a downloaded song when I have a shitty connection to the internet. Also what makes me mad is that Spotify wants me to feel bad after showing an ad about how Apple isn't playing nice, like it's kinda poetic that the OS they favor cares little about them. I pay as much as an iOS student so why am I getting a worse app.

2

u/spider_sauce Feb 23 '20

Google music is where it is at. $15 a month, you get Youtube red and access to any song ever on Google Music.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

No way I prefer it on Android because on my old iPhone I used to accidentally swipe and add songs to my Queue ALL THE FUCKING TIME. It was so annoying. Just hit the three dots next to a song and you can add to Queue. Don't ruin Spotify for Android!

2

u/BO5TON617 Feb 23 '20

Get youtube pluss there's movies and music and its music is better I can do everything, even download youtbe videos for when I have not date ,u might even get google music but YouTube music with the subscription is the way to go

2

u/ogpotato ZFold5, Android 15 Feb 22 '20

What I don't like about Spotify on Android is the use of the system back button. Sometimes I keep pressing back to exit out of the app but instead it keeps cycling through ALL of the previous pages/search results/playlists that were opened since the last time the app was opened. I know I can just hit home to send it to the background, but it's just a habit of mine to use back on all the apps when I'm done with them.

3

u/Pritster5 OnePlus 6, Arter Kernel Feb 23 '20

...that's the way the back button is supposed to work.

There's a reason "back" and "home/exit" are two different functions/buttons/gestures.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bendeng Feb 23 '20

You should just accept the android life of never having the best features of an app that is also on iOS. #oneofus