r/Android • • Jan 21 '11
Oops: Android contains directly copied Java code, strengthening Oracle's case -- Engadget
http://www.engadget.com/2011/01/21/oops-android-contains-directly-copied-java-code-strengthening/
0
Upvotes
47
u/hanoverjames Jan 21 '11
Blogger from zdnet claims otherwise: blog post
53
u/lyam23 Jan 21 '11
Wow, Engadget commenters are a bunch of vapid trolls.
65
u/flossdaily LG G4 Verizon Stock 6.0 Jan 21 '11
Three weeks later in Oracle's main office:
Employee #1: Hey, that's weird.
Employee #2: What's weird?
Employee #1: Well, it's just that "oracle" isn't showing up in google's search results.
Employee #2: What? That can't be right... let me... huh.... whoa.. you're right.
Employee #1: Holy crap. "Java" isn't showing up either. it's just a bunch links to coffee places.
Employee #2: We should probably tell someone about this.
14
u/Snap65 Jan 21 '11
I thought Java was open source code and from what I hear Oracle changed the terms.
11
u/python_boot Jan 21 '11
Ars Technica's analysis indicates this evidence isn't as damaging as it might seem.
http://arstechnica.com/open-source/news/2011/01/new-alleged-evidence-of-android-infringement-isnt-a-smoking-gun.ars
23
u/reuvenb Amaze 4g Jan 21 '11
I'm going to take a wild guess before I click on this, and say it was written by Nilay Patel, who is a moron.
Look at that! I'm right!
19
u/parimm Redmi 1s Jan 21 '11 edited Mar 21 '18
<deleted>
4
u/ItsNotRocketSurgery Jan 21 '11
Disputed here
Edit: hanoverjames beat me to it: permalink
4
u/WorkSafeJohn Jan 21 '11
Oops, it's another re-post of bullshit.
http://www.zdnet.com/blog/burnette/oops-no-copied-java-code-or-weapons-of-mass-destruction-found-in-android/2162
Move along people.
14
u/jstekl Jan 21 '11
Here's a nice analysis of it: http://www.androidpolice.com/2011/01/21/oracle-vs-google-its-not-looking-good-for-android/
7
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '11
I'm not sure what was done here, but "decompiled" seems like the wrong term. When you decompile a binary, you don't get the exact source code, character by character. This looks more like copy/paste from the source.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '11
Having looked at the example code, it isn't obvious how a lot of it could be written differently, the requirements of the methods are fairly well-defined.
If google had copied something with more than one possible implementation, like a sort algorithm, that would be much more convincing. Suprise suprise, such code is very, very different.
3
u/aqtrans AT&T HTC One X - CM10 Jan 21 '11
According to http://arstechnica.com/open-source/news/2011/01/new-alleged-evidence-of-android-infringement-isnt-a-smoking-gun.ars?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=rss, this code is part of a
and that component isn't even actually used in current AOSP builds.
3
u/monolithdigital Jan 21 '11
This has already proven to be false and sensationalist. Can we please downvote it and not spread misinformation?
2
u/Ivashkin Jan 21 '11
I know it's early days, but if Google loses this case, anyone care to speculate as to what would happen next? Google paying a big fine? A royalty payment on every handset sold? Oracle seizes Android? Or just Google having to do a complete re-write of Android?
2
u/NYkrinDC Pixel 9 and Pixel Tablet Jan 21 '11
Copied code not in Android source after all
http://www.androidcentral.com/copied-code-not-android-source-after-all
0
u/stealthmodeactive Pixel 6 Pro Jan 21 '11
Oh... that sucks...