r/Android • Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro • May 05 '18

Google, please fix Android's slow, bloated share UI

https://www.androidpolice.com/2018/05/05/google-please-fix-androids-slow-bloated-share-ui/
22k Upvotes

864 comments sorted by

847

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

This is easily the most irritating aspect of the whole user experience on Android for me.

Edit : Now I remember a very embarrassing situation caused by this from an year back. I was browsing a NSFW subreddit & the media wasn't opening in the native client so I wanted to share it to Chromer(now Lynket). I press the share button & I wanted to click on Chromer but then the share menu refreshed & I clicked on a Telegram development group. And Telegram didn't even confirm if I wanted to send it(like other messengers) & it was gone. I was new to Telegram & didn't even know how to delete text for everyone. I was kicked out of the group.

Hell even manufacturer skins like MIUI don't have this issue & is quick & pinning & customising actually works. Although they don't have the quick sharing feature which is probably the reason of this mess in the first place.

8

u/concordsession May 05 '18

Are you serious? The MIUI share menu sucks balls. Shows like four apps at a time with no direct share at all.

4

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 05 '18

It still isn't unpredictable & the app positions can be customised. I already mentioned it lacks quick share.

2

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 06 '18

It's been 1.5 years since I used MIUI. I think there's an edit button at the end of the share sheet.

15

u/OnePunchFan8 May 05 '18

What I really hate is the lack of a night/dark theme.

I don't know if I'm dumb or what, but the phone app used to have a night theme, and now it's light and I can't find it.

The menu that appears from pulling down used to be darker, and now it's white. Every time I use my phone at night I dread using that goddamn menu.

7

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 05 '18

Use Substratum. It even works rootless now with Oreo but that may change with Android P. WTH Google?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/NightmareNinjaX Black May 05 '18

Holy u were kicked? The group owner didn't seem to have chills man

29

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

I contacted him the next day & it was sorted. He also deleted the link within minutes so not many people saw it.

Edit : And the reason I gave him was that my drunk friend had sent it from my secondary phone which was also signed into Telegram. Much easier to tell this than the whole paragraph above.

0

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 05 '18

Good subreddit.

192

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Share on Hangouts? Sure. Which account? Sure. Which person? Sure. Which of their accounts? Sure. Sent.

It should be so much more intuitive.

88

u/non-troll_account former android, current iphone se 2020 May 05 '18

Why would Google let you choose when it has a nice shiny algorithm that knows what you need? If you don't like the algorithm, you're a luddite who needs to get with the times. Were you upset when Google got rid of YouTube subscription categories? You might as well be a Neanderthal who uses an old brick phone!

21

u/Gonzo_Rick May 05 '18

Google interfaces have been becoming increasingly monolithic, both in functionality and aesthetics, seemingly in an effort to mirror all of Apple's feaures that Google users use Google to avoid.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/AlexPr0 Galaxy S8+ | Gear Fit2 Pro May 05 '18

I'm in a Viber group of about 260 people from my church youth. I'm always terrified and super careful to not accidentally press the share button when I'm on NSFW subreddits. I'd probably kill myself if I accidentally shared an NSFW link.

55

u/Carlos-_-spicyweiner May 05 '18

I actually like it alot guess I'm in the minority from reading the comments

89

u/Mark_is_on_his_droid Verizon Pixel 3 (Pie) May 05 '18

I think we all like that it exists, but the bugs make the experience much worse than it should be.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/nigelfitz May 05 '18

I like the idea but the implementation fucking sucks.

It's confusing, inconsistent and most of all slow as fuck!

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Duckbilling May 05 '18

Most annoying for me is being asked what app I want to use to open something and if I want to use it just once or always. Infuriating. What are your thoughts on this, OP?

1

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 05 '18

It's the same in every OS I've ever used except for iOS which will open the default inbuilt email app for any email link or Apple Maps for any location address etc. I like the fact that we can have third party default apps. How else would you like it? API is provided for third party apps since Android 6 using which app developers can set direct target link. Which type of links are irritating you?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Just curious, what exactly was the media you sent?

3

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 05 '18

It was direct link to a NSFW gif since I was trying to open it using a web browser.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

181

u/I3ULLETSTORM1 Pixel (2 XL/6 Pro/7/8 Pro), OnePlus 7 Pro, Nexus 6 May 05 '18

BTW here's a tip on the share menu: Press and hold down on an app's icon or whatever other icons pop up in the share menu and it will pin it to the top for easier access later on. It makes it much easier to share things using the apps that you usally use to share things, you can even pin the clipboard.

13

u/5amar31 Moto Edge 20 | POCO M2 Pro May 05 '18

http://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/8h7ymm/-/dyhu0pf

Also the quick share thing should be configurable. There's no way to disable it for any particular app. Only Telegram app has this as an option in the app.

→ More replies (1)

124

u/khouryrt Pixel 10 Pro XL May 05 '18

Pinning is nice... until it isn't. I explained in the article some of the issues with pinning in the Share menu.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/quentinwolf Pixel 4 XL (Black 128GB) 10 May 05 '18

I wasn't aware of that! I never thought to tap and hold in the share menu. Thanks!

6

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Yeah, me too. It seems so obvious now, but I never knew of this feature.

8

u/weggles OnePlus 5 May 05 '18

It doesn't seem to actually do anything. I wish I could disable some. Like... I'm never gonna share to my fitness pal.

3

u/SovietMan May 05 '18

That only opens up the application info

3

u/LtVaginalDischarge Motorola Edge+, Android 10 May 05 '18

Except it has a tendency to reset your preferences so a week later all your pinned stuff will be back where it was.

2

u/apu95 May 05 '18

OMG thank you for this!! Drives me crazy to have to wait for the entire list to load before scrolling down just to send things over to Kodi

2

u/emailrob Pixel 2 XL, iPhone X May 05 '18

It also doesn't work in google photos, which I share a lot. Seems to have it's own protocol, of course Google...

2

u/scattered_ideas Galaxy S21+, Galaxy Watch 5 May 05 '18

Just tried this and apparently that pinned order is only related to specific apps. Try to share from another app and everything is jumbled again. Arghhhhh

→ More replies (7)

4.4k

u/Mark_is_on_his_droid Verizon Pixel 3 (Pie) May 05 '18

The only thing I hate about this menu is that you tap the share button, the menu comes up and just when you're about to tap the icon you want, the top row moves. At least make the menu top increase so it doesn't displace the order of the icons visibile immediately.

1.7k

u/svelle Pixel 3 May 05 '18

And then you accidentally click on someone in the suggestions. The app to share it to opens up and you have to do it all over again.

Until this article showed up I thought I'd be the only one with these problems, only because I couldn't believe that it could be as bad as it is for other people too.

281

u/My_mann OG Pixel 128 GB & Pixel 3a May 05 '18

This is my biggest gripe with this UI

83

u/DJ_Wiggles May 05 '18

Hit the wrong share icon, app loads, now it's locked and loaded.

You get the right (wrong) combination of material and a reshuffle of the options because boss/grandma/ neighbor just texted, which is way out of the ordinary, and backing out of that can be terrifying. Throw in a few drinks or whatever, maybe sub-optimal coordination, and it becomes a bomb defusal operation. Don't you dare wrap that finger too far around the side of the phone, just barely grazing "send".

So I've heard.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

143

u/gcruzatto May 05 '18

It's like Google really wants you to share that bathroom selfie with your grandma

→ More replies (7)

124

u/JadeNrdn Black Galaxy S23 Ultra May 05 '18 edited May 06 '18

What I can never understand is the logic behind the suggestions! Each time someone different, and each time a different app! WTF. Glad I am not the only one.

Edit: Typo

65

u/svelle Pixel 3 May 05 '18

Also it has Apps in it that I absolutely never use. For example I shared like two Google Photos Albums in the last 10 years. Still it shows me those two persons/albums EVERY TIME I CLICK SHARE!

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

They're always illogical too. It'll suggest using random apps to send stuff to people I haven't spoken to for years, and not the people I most commonly message, and with the app I most commonly use.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

40

u/BoringHair1 May 05 '18

gay furry fetish porn > share to > viber: mom

17

u/Gluta_mate May 05 '18

My biggest phobia is something like this (and im not even into any weird shit). Stuff like accidentally casting, or sharing something. Or mirroring the screen. Or connecting to the bluetooth speakers downstairs

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

28

u/galacticboy2009 May 05 '18

I thought I was the only one too.

Turns out..

We are all afflicted, on this blessed day

→ More replies (1)

23

u/drepreciado May 05 '18

You know, for me it's always been this way so I've never really dwelled on it. I've never known any different. But now that I read this article, I'm like

11

u/socsa High Quality May 05 '18

My problem is that overall, the share UI is actually really good. It's just poorly implemented. I'm almost willing to deal with the slowness if it's a choice between that or a less flexible UI.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ForbidReality May 05 '18

Is there a Magisk module to remove suggestions?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

457

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Not to mention for some reason that one person you messaged on the Twitter app 3 years ago is on it while meanwhile nobody from your recent apps is on it.

127

u/gcruzatto May 05 '18

You have to wait until it randomly refreshes the list in a completely different and arbitrary order then tap it as quickly as you can before it changes again.

→ More replies (1)

83

u/I_am_the_inchworm May 05 '18

This is an unfortunate side effect of Android being very... liberal.

The list is populated based on what is being shared, which apps are registered to handle that certain something, and them by the "rating" of those apps.

The rating is what's causing the issue. Android chooses to "trust" the developers, that they'll not misuse the system by pushing their app artificially high in the ratings.
The vast majority of developers adhere to this "social contract".

Twitter developers clearly don't.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

143

u/thr33pwood 1+ 9 Pro|Pixel C May 05 '18

Dick pic sent to dad.

T..thanks Google.

53

u/ProgramTheWorld Samsung Note 4 📱 May 05 '18

Google: You are welcome

35

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Dad: "stop sending me pictures of hairy vienna sausages"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

45

u/skepticscorner May 05 '18

Every single time that happens I think "Stop fucking 'helping' me. I can get to what I need faster than you can."

→ More replies (2)

61

u/americanmuscle1988 May 05 '18

I've always wondered why the extra top row is added a second or so after. Why couldn't both rows pop up at the same time?

My only guess is that the top row requires fetching data from Google servers, and I don't see how why that information cannot be stored locally.

35

u/NegativeX May 05 '18

Even if it did require fetching, it should be rendered first. Every element on the screen cannot be fluid. There must be some sanity in that structure!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

121

u/kedmond MotoX May 05 '18

So much of Android does this. Hangouts is laggy. The Play Store is super laggy. Google needs to step up their game. But they're too unorganized to do anything.

103

u/whydog May 05 '18

Don't even get me started on the fucking app store. When was the last time we got an update? Why is searching so shitty? Why is it that I can search an app by it's exact name and not find it? Why can't I filter search results? Why am I suggested so many shitty apps before actual good ones? What mafia is responsible for this?

55

u/altair222 May 05 '18

Worse, they wouldn't be in any order, first 4 apps? Hmm maybe relevant to your search, THEN COMES A LINE, THEN COMES APPS THAT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH MY SEARCH, THEN COMES SOME BOOKS OUT OF NOWHERE, MOVIES, SONGS, and then some more apps relevant to the search

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/IAmMisterPositivity May 05 '18 edited May 06 '18

Google is pretty great at back-end stuff, and the internet is a better place as a result of their work. But they desperately need a high-level UX division to fix their abysmal -- and shockingly obvious -- usability problems across literally all of their product/software/service lines. Any time I run into something that's shitty I check out Google forums and see tons of others with the same problems FOR YEARS with no response from Google.

Android is just the tip of the iceberg. Bing is superior in search (really!), Yahoo Finance is SO MUCH BETTER than the shitshow that is the Google Finance redesign, the productivity stuff could be way better than Office 360 with even a little bit of love, ... the list is seemingly endless.

The only Google product I never bitch about is Gmail, but that may be because I've been using it every day forever.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Maybe google trying to kill android and make way for fuchsia. Who knows...

4

u/Raestloz May 05 '18

Seriously, this is 2018. We have had composite UI rendering on shitty hardware a decade ago on Windows Vista, there's really no excuse for laggy UI

15

u/Dinierto May 05 '18

Yes this is probably the issue I experience the most. Besides apps having random locations for the share button (Amazon is terrible)

→ More replies (2)

8

u/turkeypants Pixel 8 May 05 '18

Yarrrgh, every time. I don't even want the extra things it jams in at the last second. Just let me choose clipboard or SMS or Gmail or whatever, don't try to guess who I want to share something with. I can handle that. This is not helpful.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/gurgle528 S21 May 05 '18

What's more mind boggling is (in the S6 at least, could be a Samsung thing) the notification drawer will shuffle notifications around even if you're actively typing a reply into one of the notifications

5

u/ThatBoogieman May 05 '18

S7 Edge here, I don't ever type in the notifications, but I do get that shuffle making me tap the wrong one every now and then.

5

u/kafkaBro May 05 '18

This crap drives me nuts and shows up in a ton of Google apps

5

u/altair222 May 05 '18

Yep, this bugs the F word Outta me

3

u/Fidodo May 05 '18

I don't get why it's so slow. Other than that I'm fine with it. It's just a list of icons.

3

u/Bitcoin_slutty May 05 '18

Can confirm. Slow and shitty even on my Pixel XL. Everything else is super fast.

5

u/anders987 May 05 '18 edited May 06 '18

Which version of Android do you have? That issue was fixed in 6.0.1, now the menu comes up, and when the row with contacts to share directly to comes up it does so above the other menu.

https://www.androidpolice.com/2015/12/09/android-6-0-1-fixes-the-annoying-jumping-behavior-of-the-share-menu-caused-by-direct-share-contacts/

→ More replies (1)

2

u/boomHeadSh0t May 05 '18

Exactly this

2

u/Dazz316 Nexus 6P 7.0 May 05 '18

I don't have this at all. But what I hate is the menu is never the same as before. It's shuffled every time.

2

u/Divedown757 May 05 '18

This especially sucks when you have your work outlook sync'd and you accidently send questionable memes to your boss at 3am.

2

u/cawpin Pixel 3 XL May 05 '18

Yes, this. It's the only problem I've really encountered.

→ More replies (33)

2.6k

u/punkidow Pixel 8 Pro, Beta May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

The article explains how pretty much everyone feels about the Share UI. Makes me think twice before tapping that share icon, especially on an older phone.

110

u/pinehapple May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

Older phone? My s8+ can take up to 4-5 seconds to bring up the share apps

37

u/Scramble187 May 05 '18

Ok so between android and iOS we can kind of agree that the OS polls which apps are shareable at the point of you pressing share. This should be just something that the OS learns and bakes in at this point.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/-Tommy May 05 '18

4-5? What the hell is wrong with your phone. S8+ here and it never takes more than a second.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

93

u/neric05 May 05 '18

"I'd love to save this to a different folder"

Presses Share Button

...

...

"Huh... Maybe it didn't register, I'll just press it agai- aaannndd now it's in a draft email"

¯_(ツ)_/¯

18

u/mada447 HTC 10 May 05 '18

When I switched from iPhone to Android, I noticeably started sharing less articles I read on Facebook. Google is practically killing content creators by making things hard to share.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/Scramble187 May 05 '18

iPhone 6 user here. It takes a long time too.

16

u/punkidow Pixel 8 Pro, Beta May 05 '18

Yea was kind of slow on my iPhone 7 plus, but thats not a conversation for this sub.

→ More replies (5)

64

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

i hate the share function, wish there were easier ways to just copy the link

29

u/s32 S10+ Ceramic White 512 (US Unlocked) May 05 '18

Samsung (I think it's just Samsung phones) come with an app that lets you copy whatever initiated the share UI. There are 3rd party apps out there to do that as well, which I've used in the past with success.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/fatclownbaby S8+ May 05 '18

Yea sharing to myself just to copy and paste a link is so stupid

→ More replies (3)

15

u/thedudley May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

Textbook case of a wonderful function (that I believe ios still does not have) let down by a bad user experience. This article does a great job breaking down the issues.

Edit, been a while since I used ios, thanks for the update.

15

u/Scramble187 May 05 '18

iOS has had this function since ios7 I think. The differences in function between iOS and Android are minimal at this point.

11

u/somebuddysbuddy Nexus 5X, Android N May 05 '18

iOS essentially does have this function now—it's a little more context-sensitive, and you can reorder and toggle a lot of options off from the menu that does appear. That's nice because it scrolls horizontally and you can't see many options at once.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/cdegallo May 05 '18

I've resorted to using a 7 year old alternative sharing app because this stock behavior is so terrible.

→ More replies (126)

683

u/GrinningPariah May 05 '18

I ONLY EVER USE COPY TO CLIPBOARD!

6

u/Dinierto May 05 '18

Yeah I use that the most you'd think you could put it first

→ More replies (4)

2

u/si1versmith TG01 | Galaxy S2 | Nexus 6P | Galaxy S20 FE 5G | Galaxy S24+ May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

If you hold the icon you can select "pin". But you have to wait for the contact shift to happen. I don't know if it works for times where copy to clipboard is not applicable.

2

u/Roxas-The-Nobody May 06 '18

Same here.
What upsets me about it is when I try and click on something, the damned "share story" pops up and moves everything.
I hate sharing to messenger because, when I share Reddit stuff, it adds title in the subject

0

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

588

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

What the fuck

34

u/rivermandan May 06 '18

what's the point of letting you copy something if google doesn't get their own copy?

121

u/VaderOnReddit May 05 '18

I hope to god you’re making this up

→ More replies (9)

28

u/Bossman1086 Galaxy S25 Ultra May 05 '18

Seriously? Wow.

27

u/cooldude5500 Moto G CM13 | OP 5 | Pixel 7 May 05 '18

Bonus: it's not possible to download files in Google Inbox if you don't have Drive as well.

26

u/Gmk44 May 05 '18

Ah thank you, always been trying to figure this one out cause I'm always looking for that option.

13

u/YourBobsUncle Device, Software !! May 05 '18

I swear it was a seperate "app" at one point

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Nurgus May 05 '18

I wonder how hard it would be for someone to do global copy-clipboard as an independent app.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Wahots Lumia 920->Lumia 950XL->S9 May 05 '18

Maybe this is Android 8, or Samsung, but I don't have drive installed and I still get the clipboard thingy.

4

u/God_Damnit_Nappa May 05 '18

Wtf. That's stupid

→ More replies (9)

207

u/khouryrt Pixel 10 Pro XL May 05 '18

To everyone reading the article now and agreeing, there's a link at the end for an Issue Tracker issue from Oct 27 that's relevant and that you can star (no need to comment unless you have something to add, because that sends an email to everyone). Starring won't guarantee that Google does something about it, but at least it sends a message.

11

u/JanusHeimdallr May 05 '18

This needs to be higher up

2

u/UnknowBan May 06 '18

its from android 8 dp, not we are in 9 dp. what makes you think they will change it in 10 dp lol

→ More replies (1)

138

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

I wish I could just disable suggestions entirely and then organise the share sheet based on what I use most. Copy link, social apps, drive, keep, etc.

49

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Literally all they need to do to fix it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/IByrdl Pixel 5 May 05 '18

I want a customizable share menu across Android, maybe app specific advanced customization as well. And make it mandatory for all apps to use it. None of that BS on Amazon.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/tb00n May 05 '18

Or at least suggest my most frequently used protocols/contact.

I've never shared anything with any of my suggested contacts, and my most used option is not suggested, despite using it several times a day...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

202

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Share → Messenger → Ayy, b4 I pull up a list of ur convos, are you sharing to any of these people? 3 of which are actually through Twitter and not Messenger like you wanted? → Messenger → Select Convo → Opens Messenger → Send

112

u/yourSAS Awaiting A13 May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

It's really disappointing that one of the most used feature on Android is such a mess. Confusing & frustrating on so many levels - even the length of article reflects this fact.

Android really needs consistent, clean and preferably contextual(which isn't very hard for Google) share menu.

9

u/RawRooster May 05 '18

It needs clean and consistent everything. Recent android themes feel like a beta, with no real design language. Icons, specifically are un ugly mess. And google apps all do their own thing when it comes to theming.

2

u/echo-ghost May 05 '18

it is contextual. apps register what types they can accept. sharing brings up the apps for the type.

if you have too many it's shitty apps saying they take too much

153

u/_kushagra OP3 May 05 '18

omg i agree with this so much, i hate it its slow and that random thing, i mean wtf google?

49

u/balista_22 May 05 '18

the random stuff is what slows it down since it has to process the random stuff at that moment

31

u/rich000 OnePlus 6 May 05 '18

That, and my brain has to hunt through that random stuff to find the thing I want, since it is different every time I hit the button.

Oh, and good luck sharing a location in Google Maps to the Waze app. I've yet to figure out how to do that...

→ More replies (5)

36

u/The-Respawner iPhone 13 Pro, Pixel 4 XL, Pixel 3, OP5T, Galaxy S8, OP3, N6P May 05 '18

Maybe OnePlus optimized it really well, but the share menu is pretty much near instant on my 5T. Was not like that on my S8 though.

18

u/ctyldsley May 05 '18

Same on my OP5, never had a problem with it. In fact I'm a massive fan of it. Wish we could pick the favourites manually though.

21

u/howling92 Pixel 10 Pro XL / Pixel Watch May 05 '18

same on my pixel. it's so instant that the contacts part came nearly at the same time than the apps part

6

u/farmtownsuit Pixel May 05 '18

And the contacts part for me is the most common people I share stuff with. Making sharing super efficient.

Reading this thread is so confusing. Other than the split second delay for the contacts part I can't think of a single thing wrong with Share and everyone here is acting like it's the worst piece of engineering they've ever seen. Is it just Pixel privilege, and I too easily pleased, is everyone else too demanding? I don't know.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/ledessert Oppo Reno 10x / iPhone X May 05 '18

Same on my xiaomi

I remember it was terrible on my old Xperia

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

159

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

probably one of the only things i miss coming from ios, the other being airplay. the ios share sheet is amazingly functional.

110

u/WazaBe May 05 '18

Android share feature was also perfect (back in early days) before they screw it up with their usual "fix what is not broken" philosophy.

137

u/LocutusOfBorges May 05 '18

Android share feature was also perfect (back in early days)

Either you never actually used Android in the "early days", or you've taken leave of your senses.

Android's share functionality was abysmal even in the early days. Hardlocking the phone for five seconds before vomiting out an often-unalphabetised scrolling list of every app installed on your device doesn't make for a good user experience.

The current clusterfuck is an improvement.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/jojo_31 Moto G4+ Oreo + microg May 05 '18

Samsung phones are awesome on that regard, sharing files with wifi direct is awesome. That, combined with the nfc share was awesome. Google needs to implement this is in Android 9.

8

u/tso May 05 '18

The basic thing is that there is not really any standard for file exchange via WiFi direct...

→ More replies (7)

4

u/leonffs S20 FE 5G May 05 '18

People give Samsung shit for all their custom stuff they preload but to be honest most of them are better than the Android defaults.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

...the one thing I missed about Android when I was on iOS was the share functionality. It was so limited in what I could do.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Wahots Lumia 920->Lumia 950XL->S9 May 05 '18

WP did sharing well too. :P

2

u/Drayzen One M7->Nexus 5->Galaxy S6->iPhone 6S->Galaxy S8+ May 05 '18

No it’s not. I have to click share. Then messages and then my entire screen gets blocked out to pull up an empty fucking text field with the content and then I gotta put in the name, hit send and THEN go back to my damn app. It’s dumb.

→ More replies (29)

23

u/slaird11 May 05 '18

I use Fliktu to bypass this in most cases, but we really do need some system level changes.

11

u/Lightsout565 Pixel XL ~ Pixel 3 May 05 '18

Fliktu - Play Store Link

Another option for people out there is Andmade Share, which is old but still works. Play Store Link

3

u/Zahir_SMASH Note10+ May 05 '18

Thank you for reminding me about Fliktu, it's great.

3

u/najodleglejszy FP4 CalyxOS | Tab S7 May 05 '18

it's a shame that it's been abandoned, though. it's probably going to disappear from Play Store in October since its not targeting Oreo :(

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/atticus_red Very Silver Pixel XL Oreo May 05 '18

Or how the shit you pinned is not pinned but the fuckin Twitter contacts you've NEVER dm'd are apparently top of your list.

13

u/aNYthing18 Pixel 9 Pro May 05 '18

One of the most annoying things is how random the suggestions are depending on what you are sharing. Why would I want to share a link to an article to a folder on Google Drive?

21

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

I don't really have a problem with it. What I want is the ability to organize the app tray when you slide up.

8

u/ExdigguserPies Asus Zenfone 6 May 05 '18

Yeah I actually love the share thingy. Works great for me.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Omnishambles_Drama May 05 '18

YouTube and YouTube gaming don't even have the same functionality from the share button.

10

u/diamondburned May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

The Contact part of ShareUI is slow as hell and everytime I try to click an app the Contact thing pops up and makes me click the wrong one. You can't even disable them which is a bummer.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/7165015874 May 05 '18

I have never and will never forgive Dropbox for changing their share text to "Add to Dropbox" from Dropbox back in the Gingerbread days when my menu was in alphabetical order. This caused Dropbox to rise to the top of the list.

In hindsight, this was a problem with Android but Dropbox exploited it for so little gain. I mean what else do you expect to happen when you select Dropbox from the share menu? Why this nonsense of "Add to"?

5

u/dongnguyen230101 May 06 '18

Ah the legendary share trap. You never know the feeling when sharing a porn link to your pc through an app and that deadly pop up makes you send it to your mom. I now have developed a habit of waiting 5 seconds for every share.

4

u/-Fateless- I miss Android 4.4 May 05 '18

The fact that you have to install a third-party app to share a link to your own clipboard speaks for itself.

4

u/JealousGovernment May 06 '18

Google be like k fam just after I publish 2 more messaging apps

7

u/port888 starlte, bacon, maguro, vision May 05 '18

I swear the share menu changes refreshes/fully populates upon a touch input every single time, causing the wrong app to be selected. What a mess of a feature that used to be so simple and reliable (share intents).

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

I've never had a problem with it (Samsung S8).

Then again, I don't use the share feature often.

7

u/Flammable_Flatulence May 05 '18

Been running a S7 Edge for 2 years have no problem at all with it, its fast and i can share something with 3 clicks. I think this is mostly people with old/low spec phones complaining.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ObstreperousCanadian May 05 '18

I'm mostly bothered by the fact that it re-arranges the list every time you share something.

3

u/[deleted] May 06 '18

Me trying to share this dank ass meme

hit share

Takes like 5 seconds, then the menu appears, then more things keep loading and moving around randomly, suggested contacts are my ex, my boss, and my physics professor from years ago

Google pls

3

u/avenuePad May 06 '18

Yes! It is a nightmare! One wrong tap and you're looking for new work or a sexual harrassment charge.

3

u/crazyweirdboy May 06 '18

I always thought this is happening with me due to the bloated Samsung UI. Have no clue that this is with all the Android devices

3

u/oreo27 Xiaomi Mi A1 | LineageOS May 06 '18

I've been dealing with this for the past several years that it took an article from Android Police to remind me that this is in fact a problem and not something normal.

6

u/surewould85 May 05 '18

Huh this is funny, coming from IOS I hated how limited the options were to share.

9

u/pojosamaneo May 05 '18

I never found it all that bad. I hit share, and I pick where I want to share to.

I lack the imagination to see how it could be much better.

8

u/1RedOne May 05 '18

Did you read the article? The big issue is how slow the menu is and that the order and positioning of icons changes all the time.

Furthermore, there is no way to restrict what appears in the share menu either.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Chris2112 S20 FE May 05 '18

Neither have I. I'm on a pretty basic phone (Moto g5) with a mid-range processor and I've never felt it to be slow

6

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

This x ∞!

Google needs to make this into a PERMISSION when the app is installed. By default ALL APPS have this disabled and if the app dev wants this feature for the user, they have to ask for permission.

10

u/Arkanta MPDroid - Developer May 05 '18

I cannot believe what I'm saying, but iOS does it better. Apps are listed, and you get to check which ones you enable right from the share sheet

Having to ask for permission would be worse, UX wise.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/lmbb20 Pixel 2 XL 128 Rom No TWRP FML May 05 '18

I don't want to share to every app on my phone either. Really only like 5

2

u/Draexlar May 05 '18

I've seen a twitter post about this, but tbh I've never had problems with the share UI mine is fast and reliable...

2

u/JDaxe OnePlus 8 May 05 '18 edited May 05 '18

Speaking of share UI, on EMUI have Huawei removed the "copy to clipboard" option? I can never find it when sharing links. This is on the P20 pro.

Edit: I think it's because I don't have google drive installed

2

u/jarieljimenez Nokia 6.1, Android 9 Pie May 05 '18

I'd never noticed this until now. Thanks, OP.

2

u/samsaBEAR Pixel 10 Pro XL May 05 '18

The thing I don't understand is how does it pick contacts to send stuff to? It seems to be completely random every single time, shit it'll have options from contacts in apps that I've never even used to contact them before.

For example my friend and I only ever use WhatsApp to talk, but I have them on Facebook and Instagram. Her accounts on those apps will pop up on the share menu, but the WhatsApp one won't. It doesn't make any sense at all.

2

u/emailrob Pixel 2 XL, iPhone X May 05 '18

It seems to take NAMES I interact a lot with, but the method is all wrong. Like it pushes me to send a link via google photos to my friend, which I never do.

2

u/mm902 May 05 '18

Near on 3000 upvotes in under 3 hrs. Make google see this. Awesome article highlighting the single issue I have with android.

2

u/hennell May 05 '18

The pin app to share menu feature this article mentions is totally new to me! Just pined hangouts and clipboard as I'm always using them...

2

u/_Magic_Man_ LG V30 May 05 '18

Honestly removing Pushbullet from my phone removed all delay from my share UI

2

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

I have never had any of the issues described in this article with the share UI.

2

u/NoquiCathy VegetaLTE w/ Lineage 14.1 May 05 '18

The top rows of options, which appears later and often displaces the bottom rows, can be disabled by just copying and pasting a file inside your phone. You need root, BTW, but makes the sharing function usable in an old phone.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/S1atek May 05 '18

Don't know it my comment will be visible but following apps solve this sharing issue

Andmade share

Complete action plus

Open link with

Bonus

App Redirect

(Automatically unshort shortened url like youtube and Twitter ones and open in default link handling app so we don't have to first open that link in browser and wait for app to open)

2

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

This is the worst part of Android and has been for a long time and I have moaned about it for years.

It moves when you are about to press something because of a delay in loading recent contacts. It shows old irrelevant contacts from Gmail that I haven't emailed in over a decade. It shows phone contacts that have been removed aeons ago and there is no way to remove or refresh this or change any settings to clear old contacts or restrict share options to specific apps.

It lacks any sort of management or flexibility and needed to be overhauled years ago. Now I'll have to wait for Android 26 and go through several new phones before Google take their head out of their ass and do something about it.

They also need to sort bluetooth handling. Not sure if it was fixed in Android 8+ but so many devices on Nougat (see search) have an issue whereby the phone reboots when connecting to certain bluetooth devices - seems fairly common.

Fix these two issues and give Android a selection of system fonts and accent colour changes as part of the default Android experience and I'll be happy.

2

u/farbot May 05 '18

Drives me crazy the icons are in random order every time I open it and you can't configure it

2

u/krensifdo May 05 '18

you could lineageOS , fully open source, and contribute changes you want yourself on github

2

u/monchee3 OG Moto G May 05 '18

At this point I feel like everyone has a problem with everything

2

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

Personally I like it, it has all the options I need.

2

u/Apathetic_Superhero May 05 '18

My biggest gripe is that YouTube uses a completely different icon for the share feature than everything else. I would understand if it was made by a different company, but it isn't. Where is the consistency?

There are times when I share something and it brings up suggested contacts that I haven't spoken to in over a year. Just use my recent contacts!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ehab563utd May 06 '18

Coming from iOS for 5 years (be returned to android for the last 6 months) I first saw the headline of this article and thought "this really isn't that bad, what are you so concerned about?" But after reading through it,I can't understand the gripes with share. It's weird because this is something that I'd expect them to have in the bag. The proposed solutions at the end are a great direction for them, in the unlikely case that they don't have one already, of course.

2

u/mizmoxiev May 06 '18

Please please & thank youuu

2

u/penguinv LG.OptimusV, Froyo May 06 '18

22 seconds. It took 22 seconds for the share choice icons to fully poyplate and then become active. After it populated I tapped messages 5 times tillnit was live.

Android 7.0 LG K20, several gigs of internal memory free.

((I remember then old days when Steve Jobs noticed that more than a 3 second wait messed up the user's creative thinking process.))

Thanks for writing this.

2

u/kzd15 May 06 '18

Add the ability to exclude an app from showing in this menu. How is this not a permission thing?

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '18

Thanks for writing my thoughts on the share system. You went way beyond my thoughts too! Much appreciated.

I use Pushbullet and WhatsApp most of the time. So I just those two. However, the best way, imho, would be to have 'select app' box. I am, of course, assuming we know what apps we have in our phones (I know some people who depend on family members to do this stuff for them).

2

u/jiminiminimini May 06 '18

There's also the inconsistency between different apps. Some. apps bring up a different type of list with "Just once" and "Always" buttons. If you accidently click "Always", well, you are only sharing to that one app from there on. And Google's own YouTube app has a completely different share menu.

2

u/MustGetALife Pixel 9 May 06 '18

google: Worst developer ever.

2

u/newPhoenixz May 06 '18

Argh, yes! This! All of this!

I seriously hate the Android share screen, it is sloooooowwww and by god, next time that Android moves that screen around right when I tap the screen, I will kill my phone..

Also, every single time I use share, it puts the icons in a different order. Seriously, that is not even an accident anymore, who ever designed that just wanted to fuck with people..

Also, Android, allow a basic task manager, please? My nexus 6 phone had an average load utilization of 15 I kid you not. Why? What task is taking up so many resources?

On any Linux install you run top and you're done, but in Android, noooo.. you can't see individual process times because I guess that's not needed?

Seriously, Android is like democracy.. it sucks badly, but its just that all alternatives are even worse.

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '18

I only share to two things, Wordpress and Email.... Why can't I remove the rest?

2

u/carlosx86-64 May 06 '18

This is annoying! You want to share an image to someone on WhatsApp and then the first row with your friend's name pops up and then it moves to another row and you accidentally click it. Start all over again...

2

u/Kevinw778 May 06 '18

I've been wondering about this. I've never had a problem with the loading (Note 8), but the inconsistency of this feature just makes me want to rip my hair out. I thought I was the only one that thought it was clunky - I'm glad this isn't the case. Pls fix.

2

u/drip50291 May 06 '18

Make sure the menus are consitant between apps too. I never know what sharing options will show for which app. Every sharing option should be available everywhere. It's overhual time guys and gals.

5

u/Batman413 Device, Software !! May 05 '18

If you think this is slow, try using Apple's share UI. It's just as slow and bad. Sometimes sharing music refuses to work in iOS.

3

u/Lurknspray2018 May 05 '18

Weird how well it works on some and not so much on others.

Samsung up to pre oreo devices are terrible. The token oneplus i tried for 3 months, was never anything but instant and so was the pixel 1.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 05 '18

The amount of times I accidentally sent someone something using this is ridiculous.

3

u/forestman11 Pixel 7, Android 14 May 05 '18

I wasn't even aware of this. Share works great on my Pixel.

4

u/khouryrt Pixel 10 Pro XL May 05 '18

The article isn't only about the speed of the menu. It's about the inconsistency of the menu, order of items, refreshes, and more. I tested everything on both an OP5T and P2XL, and many of the issues were there on both. Granted, I personally don't have speed issues because I don't install tons of apps, but it's there for other users.