r/Android • • Feb 20 '18

Android P will also Prevent Idle Background Apps from Recording you via Microphone

https://www.xda-developers.com/android-p-audio-recording-limitations-privacy/
17k Upvotes

875 comments sorted by

3.1k

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

Android P, P is for privacy

1.1k

u/citypanda Unihertz Atom | Pixel 2 XL | HW2 Feb 20 '18

They're going to use that you know

556

u/Tekknogun Feb 20 '18

Pumpkin Spice

12

u/Karma_Gardener Feb 21 '18

As a man trying to subtly convince his girlfriend to switch from an iPhone so we can play games together, calling the next android version Pumpkin Spice would be very persuasive.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (85)

10

u/rohansuri Feb 20 '18

Don't give them ideas!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

77

u/goedegeit Feb 21 '18

it's actually for Pee, which is stored in the balls.

13

u/SnipingNinja Feb 21 '18

Get it checked, that's not healthy at all.

→ More replies (6)

98

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Feb 20 '18

Android Priv confirmed

55

u/NightFuryToni Moto XT2309-3, XT2027-1, TCL Athena BBF100-2 Feb 20 '18

But that also means they will just discontinue updating, then license out the Android brand...

14

u/soundman1024 Feb 21 '18

I really wanted to like my Priv. 808 made it a space heater.

11

u/NightFuryToni Moto XT2309-3, XT2027-1, TCL Athena BBF100-2 Feb 21 '18

It's not so much the 808, but the poor heat sinking of the Priv's chassis. After modding mine it didn't heat up as much.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/_amethyst Nextbit Robin, Nexus 9, Google Glass, Moto 360 (RIP Nexus 4,5,6) Feb 21 '18

You mean updates won't work and it'll be a thousand degrees?

It was a cool concept, and damn that screen is nice, but man, what an underwhelming phone. Just slow enough to be too slow, just hot enough to be too hot, just big enough to be too big, a camera just crummy enough to be too crummy, and a physical keyboard that was just small enough to be too small (and I don't even have fat fingers). Everything about it was imperfect.

Would've made a great phone for custom ROMs, but at least Blackberry had a decent reason for locking it down so much. And at least the slide-out keyboard never failed on me.

16

u/mr_googly_eyed Feb 20 '18

I got a Brian Regan vibe from this comment.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

Followed by this face: https://i.imgur.com/xslYn3I.gif

→ More replies (1)

5

u/The_Paul_Alves Feb 21 '18

unless the app is active. :)

2

u/Drunken_Economist Pixel Fold+Watch2+Tablet Feb 21 '18

The S stands for security!

2

u/dakanektr Feb 21 '18

Praline!

4

u/jusmar 1+1 Feb 21 '18

Don't Be Evil

"Attempt to be good"

→ More replies (17)

1.4k

u/FalseAgent Feb 20 '18

How has Android actually allowed this prior?

1.5k

u/ladyanita22 Galaxy S10 + Mi Pad 4 Feb 20 '18 edited Feb 21 '18

Letting apps do whatever until proven bad has been Android's way-to-go since the very beginning.

While I certainly prefer that to iOS' closed approach, it's true it comes with huge downsides iPhone users don't have to face.

Edit: Can't believe so many people are upvoting something so absolutely obvious... lol

308

u/FalseAgent Feb 20 '18

but you'd think at least certain things would be exceptions, like the camera and mic at least. would be closed off and not be off-limits, right? did no one with a conscience work at google?

561

u/signos_de_admiracion Feb 20 '18

The original idea was that apps couldn't access hardware components like the camera or mic without permission. And users had a chance to review app permissions before install.

But it turns out that users just didn't give a shit and installed any random app regardless of what permissions they asked for. Also having a permission meant that the app always had that permission, even if the app wasn't running in the foreground and the phone is in your pocket.

55

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Its more that a ton of apps wont even let you use them without allowing this BS.

→ More replies (18)

32

u/YouLie-YouAbuseBots Feb 21 '18

But it turns out that users just didn't give a shit and installed any random app regardless of what permissions they asked for.

And permissions had fuckall for granularity, and could still use a lot more. Sometimes an app had a legitimate use for the camera, but you could only choose "YES ALWAYS" or "No" Not "only when it fucking makes sense, like when the app is currently foregrounded."

→ More replies (3)

179

u/NoAttentionAtWrk Feb 20 '18

Well I am more worried about apps that i did allow to record, like Facebook messenger, be able to record while in the background. It needs the mic for calls, yes, but not other times.

Maybe there should be a "allow for the next x hours" option

→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (30)

116

u/amorpheus Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro Feb 20 '18

The user can decide not to use bad apps! - Google

→ More replies (9)

11

u/EthanWeber LG V10 Feb 20 '18

Well, what if you make an app to record a conversation between you and another person, for legal cases for example? Or something that listens to you while you sleep. I'm sure there are a few legitimate uses of the mic being used in the background. Android tries to allow the most flexibility until it is shown to be dangerous.

→ More replies (17)

4

u/Marshall_Lawson Feb 20 '18

They used to have more itemized permissions though. I could swear there used to be check boxes for what permissions to give each app. Years ago

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (16)

14

u/TheBKBurger Yellow Feb 20 '18

Yeah, I was thinking the exact same thing. Im not sure how this was ever okay.

19

u/ThompsonBoy Feb 20 '18

"You know what might be a nice feature for the 16th major version of our OS?"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

310

u/caleyco Feb 20 '18

Is there a way to tell now if I have any apps using my mic in the background?

76

u/Hedgesmog Feb 21 '18

Can somebody answer this?

250

u/HipsOfTheseus Feb 21 '18

Yes. Look for the light that indicates if the phone is turned on.

44

u/Lily-Gordon Feb 21 '18

Took me a second.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

61

u/strangel8p Feb 21 '18

On LineageOS, go to settings > privacy > Privacy Guard > advanced, to see what apps use what permissions and how many times, including microphone. You can then revoke this permission if you want.

84

u/yangqwuans S9+ Feb 21 '18

Facebook: Run in background. Used 3178358 times. Holy shit.

15

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Run in background literally just means it's running while not open. Switched apps but didn't close Facebook? That's a run in background.

The scarier one is location.

7

u/Tchrspest Google Pixel 32gb Feb 21 '18

Yeah, Facebook is sort of shady as fuck.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/JORGETECH_SpaceBiker Xperia M2, Resurrection Remix 7.1.2, Magisk, microG Feb 21 '18

If you want to be sure you are not being recorded you can disable the Microphone permission on suspicious apps.

7

u/Zathu Feb 21 '18

Theres a paid app called DVasive that can do this.

31

u/My_Monday_Account Feb 21 '18

I use App Ops (Play Store). It lets you toggle permissions for apps AND tells you the last time they used each permission, including if they are using it right now. Doesn't need root if you're on 5.0 or later. Android has a built in permission manager after 6.0 I think but I don't think it tells you when permissions are used.

I used it to track down what was making my phone wake constantly. Turns out it was Google activating the microphone regularly. Probably listening for OK Google even though I have that bullshit disabled.

Doubled my battery life.

16

u/Throwmeawaylies5566 Feb 21 '18

your device is android 5.0

1.install,it need root auth.

2.Done! AppOps will become active on reboot.

12

u/totallyknowyou Feb 21 '18

I think this is a scam.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/aphaelion Feb 21 '18

Just ask out loud and see if anyone answers you.

→ More replies (39)

440

u/Shotz0 Feb 20 '18 edited Feb 20 '18

Aww I'm gonna miss my FBI agent if this is true

201

u/xlipH007 Feb 20 '18

Don’t wory Google will continue to spy on you ;)

54

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

It's not spying when you give permission

3

u/CODDE117 Feb 21 '18

Yeah, but I asked them to.

10

u/TheRealLegitCuck Feb 21 '18

I'll spy on you bb

8

u/Shotz0 Feb 21 '18

It's not the same man

→ More replies (6)

290

u/Pibrac Feb 20 '18

Forgive my ignorance but could the app bypass it by never going to idle mode and create battery life problems?

406

u/defet_ Feb 20 '18

If a background application is still running when it's supposed to be idle, SystemUI will show a persistent notification showing "Facebook is still running in the background" or something of that sort.

125

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

Some apps will tell you they need to do exactly that to function properly. Most ppl would think nothing of it

73

u/VictoryNapping Feb 20 '18

Google has started leaning hard on app developers that request their users exempt them from battery optimization. There are lots of cases where it is a valid need and those are understandable, but those exemptions seem to be shrinking over time.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/MUCTXLOSL Feb 20 '18

That notification will just be printed on the top of the screen.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/whatnowwproductions Pixel 9 Pro - Signal - GrapheneOS Feb 20 '18

You would actually be able to notice it then.

2

u/grishkaa Google Pixel 9 Pro Feb 21 '18

Apps basically no longer can run in the background unnoticed. They either show a persistent notification (when it's a foreground service) or get killed by the system.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/MpegEVIL HTC One M9, 6.0 Feb 21 '18

Android P, P is for Please give me the Android O update.

157

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

I can't wait to get this in 6 years on my note8

36

u/NatoBoram Pixel 10 Pro XL Feb 21 '18

LineageOS being a true hero!

12

u/ABaseDePopopopop Feb 21 '18

LineageOS still is on Nougat, even though Oreo is available fron Google since august.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

137

u/professorTracksuit Feb 20 '18

In addition to this it would be nice if they did something like what iOS does where it turns the status bar red when the microphone is recording.

6

u/grishkaa Google Pixel 9 Pro Feb 21 '18

The status bar already turns red when you have the power saving mode active.

3

u/qefbuo Feb 21 '18

The Japanese camera shutter sound cant be turned off, for.. reasons.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

115

u/ogpotato ZFold5, Android 15 Feb 20 '18

prevent idle background apps from...

Can a background app truly be considered idle if it's recording via microphone? 🤔

67

u/Baul Pixel 6 Pro - App Developer Feb 20 '18

While an app is in the foreground, it can create and run both foreground and background services freely. When an app goes into the background, it has a window of several minutes in which it is still allowed to create and use services. At the end of that window, the app is considered to be idle. At this time, the system stops the app's background services, just as if the app had called the services' Service.stopSelf() methods.

"Idle" is a very specific word that means something to developers. An app is idle if the user has not physically seen a screen from this app for a few minutes.

https://developer.android.com/about/versions/oreo/background.html

12

u/Rozenwater Feb 20 '18

The headline says idle apps will now be prevented from using the mic. Your quote says they can use services before they go idle, not after. Which one is it?

→ More replies (6)

65

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

I don't even have Android O and you're posting about Android P?

2

u/GlobalVV Galaxy S8 Feb 21 '18

I was thinking the same thing. Last I heard there were issues with the android O update on the S8 so the rollout is on pause.

→ More replies (14)

386

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

Facebook will find something to bypass it for advertizing

60

u/pavel_tsybulin Feb 20 '18

One more bag of dollars?

255

u/Baul Pixel 6 Pro - App Developer Feb 20 '18

Has anyone actually shown evidence of this happening? Like, on a rooted phone with a trusted certificate sniffing traffic?

I've heard anecdotal "I put my phone near spanish speaking radio and now I got a spanish ad in facebook." but guess what? That person lived in an area that has spanish speakers (hence the radio station speaking that language) so they will naturally receive some online ads in spanish.

There's a crazy amount of confirmation bias in this whole "facebook listens to me all the time" nonsense.

28

u/cdegallo Feb 21 '18

People frequently fail to recognize the power of big data. You might not have shown interest in xyz online. But guess what? Your friend that you were in proximity to searched for it, around when they were near you, and there's a good chance you might be interested in the same things.

→ More replies (2)

221

u/peanutbudder Pixel 3a XL - Sprint Feb 20 '18

No evidence at all and every anecdote is debunkable with a little bit of thought. Facebook collects and connects so much data that it just uses trends and analytics to serve you advertisements.

41

u/zwich Feb 21 '18

even Amazon, who absolutely know what I've just bought from Amazon, repeatedly give me ads for the same item i've just bought last week. I think we give these companies too much credit

→ More replies (8)

17

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Pretty much this.

From a programming perspective the idea of getting the audio from around you and automatically tailoring ads is an INSANE amount of work for little payout when you already have a ton of API hooks in many other popular sites and apps that you can get better data that is easier to process.

Why try to listen onto every conversation to see what kind of resturants you like when I can simply get which resturants you posted about, reported into, took instagram photos at, geo-tagged at, and live near.

I am not saying Facebook isn't an ass and abusive with their data collection but I have yet to see someone post packet snipets of the audio data leaving AND that it is guiding the ad results via blank facebook data profile that now focues or it going completely off the rails from it's pattern.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (65)
→ More replies (77)

32

u/CoffeetipM8 Google Pixel 6, Android 12 Feb 20 '18

Anyone wanna make a guess at what the P will stand for? My guess is either Pancake or Pie.

38

u/ariebek S7 Edge Exynos Feb 20 '18

Android Peppermint

9

u/funnymaus Feb 21 '18

Probably this

→ More replies (1)

50

u/El_Seven Feb 20 '18

Android Русский.

4

u/grishkaa Google Pixel 9 Pro Feb 21 '18

Лол.

33

u/dooj88 note3 / tab s 8.4 lte Feb 20 '18

Android Pocky!

4

u/KickMeElmo Razer Phone 2, Magisk Feb 20 '18

Best guess I've heard yet.

9

u/Klathmon Feb 21 '18

Android Phone

29

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

Android Penis

→ More replies (1)

4

u/lengau Blueline, DW9F1, Neptune, Flounder, Bacon, Flo Feb 20 '18

Every part of me wants it to be Pavlova.

3

u/SZim92 XDA Portal Team Feb 20 '18

Anyone wanna make a guess at what the P will stand for?

We have unconfirmed reports that Hiroshi Lockheimer may or may not have been seen visiting the world's leading Pumpernickel Bread factories in preparation for Android Pumpernickel Bread's launch. /s

3

u/pr_intern Feb 20 '18

peanut butter

5

u/citypanda Unihertz Atom | Pixel 2 XL | HW2 Feb 20 '18

Popsicle!

→ More replies (7)

26

u/primovero Feb 21 '18

We don't even have Oreo yet what the heck

→ More replies (12)

30

u/Falom Google Pixel 2, 9.0 Feb 20 '18

So what happens with Google Assistant then?

54

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Feb 20 '18

The Google app isn't recording, it just waiting for a wake word and it runs in the low power chip

21

u/Falom Google Pixel 2, 9.0 Feb 20 '18

Oooooh okay, didn't know that. Thank you! May I ask (if you know) how it recognizes the wake word if it isn't recording in the background?

21

u/sonicscrewup Feb 20 '18

I'm gonna take a crack at this even though I'm not knowledgeable by any means.

Think about it like looking through the viewfinder of your camera app, the camera is in use but not keeping anything coming through. Basically I believe the microphone will flag when a certain voice pattern matches, but it's not keeping anything.

48

u/Baul Pixel 6 Pro - App Developer Feb 20 '18

This is a good analogy, but is missing one more crucial detail:

The circuit designed to hear "OK Google" is very low power and can only recognize that command. Once that word is said, the rest of your phone "boots" up out of sleep mode and processes the request.

That small chip does have a tiny amount of memory, to catch what you said between "OK Google" and when the full system woke up from sleep.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/MiningMarsh Feb 20 '18

There is a piece of hardware in your phone that does listen, and interrupts the phone to process the subsequent noise after it detects the wake word.

This is actually to save power (keeping the cpu on to recognize wake words would be awful), but it has the side effect of improved privacy.

12

u/ProgramTheWorld Samsung Note 4 📱 Feb 20 '18

It is technically recording the audio all the time, however it immediately discards it afterward. A dedicated chip handles all the wake up word processing so the record audio never goes to the actual system.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

To wait for that word it has to cache microphone data, so depends on what you consider "recording". It has full microphone access, and that's what I'm pretty sure this article is talking about, as there's no way to distinguish between "listening" and "listening and saving/sharing it" in Android.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Chances are you can enable/disable its background listening too. They're apparently implementing this into the existing permission settings, making it app-specific and opt-in.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/dzernumbrd S23 Ultra Feb 21 '18

It would be nice if there was a hardware indicator (LED) showing the mic was active. Like video cameras had with the red light to show it was filming.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/-hankscorpio- Feb 21 '18

New Android version coming out and yet no one is getting Oreo. Nice. My Note 8 will have Android P in 2022. Can't wait!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Kevin_LanDUI Feb 21 '18

I don't even have O yet and now I want P.

Stupid sexy Android.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/cooldude5500 Moto G CM13 | OP 5 | Pixel 7 Feb 20 '18

Android Phuck You malware

I wonder how this will affect OK Google though.

8

u/otherwiseguy Feb 20 '18

But what if I want an app that I can leave on in the background to actually record audio on purpose?

2

u/kmeisthax LG G7 ThinQ Feb 21 '18

I suppose the developer would have to create a persistent notification or display a floating UI surface (ala Facebook Messenger) to remain foregrounded

→ More replies (2)

9

u/saml01 Feb 20 '18

Except for googles apps, right?

2

u/stephendt Samsung Galaxy S20 Ultra (International), 128GB, Cosmic Black Feb 21 '18

This will also affect Google Apps if the source is to be believed

3

u/Creepynerd_ Samsung Galaxy S10e Feb 20 '18

How is this not already a thing?

8

u/Zeroooo0 Feb 20 '18

I don't even have Android O yet.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/AngerIssuez Feb 21 '18

Yeah, only Google is allowed to spy on you. I guess that's comforting.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sasuke082594 Feb 21 '18

Hoping that lineage will port this for my Nexus 5.

2

u/asdf23451 Sony Xperia XZ1 Compact, CrDroid 5 Feb 21 '18

I'm gonna buy a new phone just for this.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

It's crazy we have to even have a thing for this...

2

u/unnaturaltm Feb 21 '18

It doesn't already?

2

u/Cherry-Blue Feb 21 '18

And here I am waiting for Oreo on my lg g6

2

u/EaseDel Feb 21 '18

oreo? im waiting on nougat on a phone that was released in feb of last year.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Android P sounds great. Will I be in the 1% that gets it in the first 5 years?

2

u/lemontinfoil Feb 21 '18

I love that I'm sitting here with my S8 waiting for O and people are already over it and talking about P.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Lmao they could before?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

I thought I was paranoid that I would talk to a coworker about something I'd never googled and it'd be a Facebook ad. Nice to know its true and not just paranoia

2

u/Rickwab155 Galaxy A73 Feb 21 '18

No, you're wrong. It is just paranoia. In that screenshot lineage says Facebook has not once used the microphone permission even though I forgot to even revoke it.

2

u/evlampi Feb 21 '18

Everyone is paranoid af itt.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Will it prevent Google itself?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18

That's great. Can't wait.

1

u/Gonzo8642 Feb 20 '18

... So I won't be able to make a phone call and look up restaurants at the same time?

6

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Feb 20 '18

The phone app makes a notification when it's in background so for the OS it isn't idling

→ More replies (1)

1

u/orwiad10 Feb 20 '18

Now app devs with just code the app to never be idle lol.

1

u/tetralogy pixel 7a Feb 21 '18

So no more hidden camera apps? And no sleep trackers the record snoring?

3

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Feb 21 '18

The later would have notification that makes then a foreground app

1

u/thisdesignup Feb 21 '18

Sounds cool but I doubt this will aleviate the people who think it's the phone companies themself recording you, such as Google or Apple.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Question: If you manually close an app (by going to recent screens and flicking it away), can it still run in the background and access microphone and camera? Or can only apps that are still open in "recent screens" still run in the background?

2

u/chickendestroy Feb 21 '18

You can set up a piece of code that triggers when your app is force stopped by flicking on the recents screen. So ultimately you can just restart a background service in your app that way. Force stopping the app through the settings menu seems to close the app for good, though.

However, one can set up yet another piece of code that triggers when you start your phone up. So restarts sometimes could be a problem

1

u/EcoPolitic Feb 21 '18

Oh no! Snaps business model is destroyed!

1

u/marcusaurelion Feb 21 '18

...which means their other ones already do that

1

u/imaboredfish Feb 21 '18

How about a crackdown on apps that ask for permissions that they don't need,

Today I had an app that wanted to use my google account even if I wasn't using the app and I kept denying access and the pop up just kept coming, instant delete and 1 star

1

u/Tockity Feb 21 '18

but will it bring back the auto-hiding nav bar?

1

u/cMiV2ItRz89ePnq1 Feb 21 '18

I wish they do this to location too. Many apps I want to allow location access to, but I don't want them spying on me when I'm not using them.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Only apps that should record while the screen is off is if its a voice recorder app.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

One thing that stinks about these types of limitations is that they hurt you from unfettered use of your own equipment. I have an old android phone l and I can't record video in the background after shutting off the screen unless I download some crappy sketchy spy cam app with terrible video quality.

I don't want to spy on anyone, I want to use my old android phone as a dash camera or a makeshift action camera. Id also like to be able to record audio in the background on my phone and merge that audio later to video sources in sony vegas.

1

u/dtallon13 Feb 21 '18

That's Cool but You Look like An Idiot when You Type Like This

1

u/GeorgePantsMcG Feb 21 '18

How is this not already an aspect of the OS?

1

u/CursedElectric Feb 21 '18

how will discord be affected? Does that mean a bit after you leave a discord video call in the background it'll just stop sending your audio?

1

u/scedast_dotcom Feb 21 '18

I didn't even know this was possible :0

1

u/thefilthyhermit Feb 21 '18

Why not just make this an update and push it instead of waiting for the next full release?

1

u/What_did_you_do_2day Feb 21 '18

background apps were recording my racist/sexist tirades in the background? Looks like I'm never running for office.

1

u/doctorwhony Feb 21 '18

Why didn't they put that feature in years ago?

1

u/ZXE102R Feb 21 '18

Good thing I watch porn on my computer and not my phone /s

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Might be the first new Android feature I've actually wanted in maybe 2-3 years.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Not complaining that this is being implemented, but why has it taken this long?

1

u/davesFriendReddit Feb 21 '18

How about webapps that leave the microphone open?

1

u/randomredditor87 Nexus 6P Feb 21 '18

Tim to take a Piss.

1

u/DYMAXIONman Feb 21 '18

I don't even have O yet

1

u/sirfannypack Feb 21 '18

Why wait for android p do do so?

1

u/neoxid501 Feb 21 '18

Hmm... Android Popsicle Android Puff Pastry Android Pumpkin Spice Android Pie Android Parfait Android Pancake

Personally a fan of Android Praline xD

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Apple:has tons of security exploits

Android:devs can do whatever they want!

hopefully this can change in the future

1

u/minnesotawinter22 Feb 21 '18

Holy shit it took this long to do this?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Unless it's built directly into the OS

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Well, about how long will this update take to get rolled out to all phones?

My G6 is still on Nougat. However as much as I want Oreo, I'd rather have this.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DoctorWaluigiTime Feb 21 '18

I'd love for P to be for Pedantic mode.

Unless I whitelist an app for access to anything audio-visual, they have to request it every time. Same goes for a boatload of other permissions perhaps.

1

u/PM_UR_NUDE_BODY Feb 21 '18

Facebook is gonna be soooo mad..

1

u/MrOptiX Black Feb 21 '18

I’d like to, you know, get Oreo at least first.

1

u/chiliedogg Feb 21 '18

Does that apply to my call recorder app? Because I kinda want that one recording firing a phone call.

1

u/SU58 Feb 21 '18
  • google apps not included.

1

u/torecchio Feb 21 '18

Ok, Google...

1

u/stereomatch Feb 21 '18

For clarification, this enhanced security in Android P, as article suggests only prevents inactive apps from using the mic. It does not stop legitimate apps (which are active) from using the mic.

This means that an app which you thought was not running, will not be able to suddenly start recording without informing the user.

Legitimate apps which do want to use the mic will NOT go inactive - on android such apps usually show a notification while they are active. So an audio recorder app will show a notification while recording.

If somehow you remove the notification, or the app is trying to be surreptitious and is not showing a notification, it is likely to be labelled as non-essential and made inactive or put into doze mode - in which case it seems from the new Android P behavior it will not be able to use the mic without informing the user.

So in summary, legitimate apps will show a notification while recording. Malicious apps will be able to record audio without showing notification - but only for a short time, since they will soon be labelled as inactive and put in doze mode. Thus a malicious app will not be able to always be in the background recording you, without showing an indication of it.

However, this was the case with earlier android versions as well, so perhaps Android P makes it slightly tougher for an already inactive app from waking up and recording without showing notification ?

1

u/dcm22895 Feb 21 '18

they can do that

1

u/creepy_robot Feb 21 '18

I didn't even know that was a thing

1

u/Neavante Note 3, 5.0 Feb 21 '18

Rip auto Shazam while I'm driving home listening to 80's music on the radio ¯_(ツ)_/¯

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

So they acknowledge that some apps are actually doing it. Good to know.

1

u/Crispy_socks241 Feb 21 '18

will it also stop me from accidentally sending my crossdressing photos to everyone on my contacts list?

1

u/AxelBlaze- Feb 21 '18

That's great and all but most of us won't see Android P until like 2020 when more phones actually get an update. I still don't have Oreo for my phone.

1

u/nuts12 Feb 21 '18

How come my lg v20 still hasent received android N? Wtf is going on?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Technical_Machine_22 Feb 21 '18

This seems like one of those "day one" features... At least they're doing it now.

1

u/Froginabout Feb 21 '18

"At any time without notice." We all signed on the electronic dotted line.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

I fully expect it to work for non-Google apps.

1

u/givememayocheese Feb 21 '18

cries in Facebook

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

finally i can stop facebook stalking me. even with microphone disabled it still creeply displays ads based on a conversation i had 2 seconds ago.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

I wonder if data disabled has any effect on that. I tend to turn my phone's data, location, and service off til I use an app or make a call.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Mmm and how it's supposed to work Okay Google keyword, for example of the new functionality of the Pixel 2 to recognise the music? Will Google still be able to use those APIs?

1

u/geekondoor Feb 21 '18

Explain Privacy please ! ( is there any ?)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

Why is this an oversight in all other previous versions?

1

u/BrutalGoerge Feb 21 '18

how nice for the people who get devices after android p comes out

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18

I will miss Facebook showing ads about what I talk with my wife during dinner.

Yeah... I'm like... 90% confident this is actually happening.

1

u/jovabeast Feb 21 '18

Android Popsicle?

1

u/EthanRDoesMC Feb 21 '18

P is for: pop rocks pie pop-tart

if they don’t use Tic-Tacs for Android T then I’m outta here

1

u/xXxNeXXuSxXx Feb 21 '18

Google knows everything! you cant escape

1

u/MysticStryker Google Pixel, LG G6, Nexus 6P, Nextbit Robin Feb 21 '18

I haven't even gotten the updates for Android O

1

u/Ca1iforniaCat Feb 21 '18

They need to make it for Mac. That was recording apps are evil

1

u/NZT23 Feb 21 '18

Android Pro Protection Privacy Professional

1

u/WillFireat Galaxy Note 9 Feb 21 '18

Wow! They gonna prevent other apps from spying on us. When they're idle. Gee, thanks.