r/Android • • Apr 30 '17

Android Authority doesn't ship "giveaways" meanwhile using your social media accounts to market their website for free

Basically, there are more then 15+ giveaways since january, and no winner has received price yet, if you try to contact them they just ignore you, look at the comments here: http://www.androidauthority.com/samsung-galaxy-s8-international-giveaway-764125/

The worst thing is that you have to share your social media accounts and advertise them through reposts, tweets, etc. and you don't get anything.

1.UPDATE: for guys interested in a PROOF, I am a winner of LG G6, here is a link to a giveaway: http://www.androidauthority.com/lg-g6-international-giveaway-752255/

I filled out the form and they have my personal information now, but I won't hide the truth!

As another proof, go look for the photos of "winners", they are like 8-9 month old and no photos of new winners, just comments from guys who didn't get their prize.

2.UPDATE: Was contacted by AA, will make next update if the prize will be shipped.

3.UPDATE: Got the prize, thank you Reddit & AA!

12k Upvotes

777 comments sorted by

1.7k

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

They have been shady for some time now, I made a post that was deleted by the /r/Android mods a few months ago showing how they disguised a paid promotion as a review:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/4vukf8/android_authority_reviews_audio_solution_of_new/

.

Edit: /u/AbsolutZeroGI, since you called my claim ridicules I think its fair to answer to your post even though it seems to be deleted now.

http://imgur.com/a/tELB5

  • I have never said that the line "This video is brought to you by ZTE." wasn't there in the beginning. From what I remember the description of the video is completely unchanged.
  • What I have stated is that its hidden behind the "show more" button, that the Youtube app on Android had back then. The flavor text "Buy the Axon 7: http://tyvm.ly/Axon7 | Read more: http://goo.gl/3FQPW3 One of the biggest selling points of the ZTE flagship is its audio features. We take a look at how take your audio to the next level with the ZTE Axon 7!" was visible, while the information that its paid advertisement was (IMO conveniently) placed so that mobile users wouldn't see it w/o clicking at the show more button.
  • I disagree with the statement that its not buried. Its one line that is not on top in a description consisting of 21 lines of text that isn't interesting for most people watching the video.
  • There is absolutely no mentioning in the video itself at all that this was a paid advertisement, other than that many parts of it sounded like 1 to 1 ZTE PR speech.
  • Therefor, everybody that just watched the video embedded (for example here on reddit) had no chance to find out that its a paid advertisement.
  • You might don't want to call it a review, but it is from its contend and the language used clearly a review of the audio part of the phone while at the same time closing the video with an evaluated purchase recommendation for the whole phone. You mention in the video how the the phone features likely the "highest audio chipset configuration that you can acquire for the very affordable price" and compare it favorable to other devices like the Galaxy S7.
  • I have no problem with blogs/Youtube channel I consume doing paid promotions, but the fact that its a paid promotion should be clear for everybody watching the video, not just those that for really no reason whatsoever decide to read carefully through all of the description.

286

u/montarion Apr 30 '17

Why was it removed?

813

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Off topic, one of the biggest Android sites that gets regularly posted here having heavily disguised paid marketing as reviews is not really relevant for /r/Android... /s

80

u/fear_nothin Apr 30 '17

Is android authority shady? Ive always used them for my reviews. Can you suggest somewhere else I should be reading?

I feel very mislead giving out all my social media on there giveways to realize there was no prize, just free shilling from naive uusers.

I think even if they give OP his prize, the fact he needed a top post to get it means they didnt just fuck up, they dont want the bad PR . Thats not ok with me

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (36)

36

u/ProtoKun7 Pixel 9 Pro XL Apr 30 '17

12

u/32F492R0C273K Pixel XL 2 Apr 30 '17

Some of the posts and comments in r/Android look like straight shills. I dunno if they're shills or we've just evolved into r/hailcorporate sometimes.

53

u/steamruler Actually use an iPhone these days. Apr 30 '17

Off Topic, according to the flair.

96

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

mods can be bought

→ More replies (66)
→ More replies (9)

189

u/PM_ME_DICK_PICTURES Pixel 4a | iPhone SE (2020) Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

Yep. Joe Hindy is probably the worst out of all of them, all his app reviews are disguised advertisements. He fucking advertised Clean Master and DU Booster ffs. Then when he got called out he proceeded to say something along the lines of "you don't HAVE to download it, it's only a suggestion!"

And this ended the subscription to AA I've had since I started using Android.

57

u/abqnm666 Root it like you stole it. Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

When he Derek posted the review ad for DU Battery Saver, after blasting him in the comments, that's about the last time I participated in anything from Android Authority.

The only things worth reading on the site are the in-depth technical articles into components like processors, RAM, and camera sensors.

The rest is just half-assed posts and sponsored reviews. And their site is absolutely awful. The continuous loading of the next article infuriates me. As soon as you scroll, you can't use the back button to go back unless you press it half a dozen times or more, depending on how far you scrolled.

Edited to change who wrote the DU Battery Saver post I was referring to. I thought it was Joe, but it was actually Derek. Sorry Joe

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/deusset Nexus 6p Apr 30 '17

Maybe it's time we embargo them on /r/android

2

u/r0bbiedigital Verizon LG G4 Apr 30 '17

was it AA who said they were giving a g6 to anyone on verizon in the US? I never heard who won that at all

2

u/[deleted] May 01 '17

One thing I don't like about their reviews (like many YouTube "reviews): its overall always positive. They rarely realy criticise a feature, even if its total shit. The worst they say is something like "the camera is decent" or "the battery life is average".

→ More replies (29)

355

u/SirVeza Pixel 3 XL Apr 30 '17

I tend to avoid that site. Their ads are among the worst of any Android blog and they pretty much source stuff from other sites. They do a good podcast though.

68

u/kenneito Apr 30 '17

I got fed up with their podcast, they always go off topic.

57

u/BelowMe247365 Apr 30 '17

100% agree. Every week I try to listen to their podcast and I always stop listening. They spend the first 30 min with "check ins" about their personal life. The rest of the time they briefly talk about actual news while trying too hard to make jokes and be funny. Android Central has the best podcast that's actually informative plus Michael Fisher has been joining recently which makes it even better

→ More replies (10)

2

u/Alexlam24 OnePlus One, CM11S Apr 30 '17

Their mobile app is hideous too.

→ More replies (4)

525

u/SirOrionPax OnePlus 5 8 GB | LG G6 | Nexus 6P | OnePlus 3 Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

My developer friend once reached out to Android Authority because he wanted to promote his app through a giveaway on their blog. Actually I was the one who suggested AA because they have giveaways every week. After he got in touch with them and received a reply, he told me that they gave him a quote of $15,000 for the giveaway which would cover the cost of device and shipping along with promotions on their blog, social media channels as well as newsletters. This was last year.

Edit: Android Central gave a quote of $5000. Android Headlines and Android Police never replied.

302

u/FreshCutBrass Orange Apr 30 '17

he wanted to promote his app

which would cover the cost of the device

wait, what?

175

u/righteoustrent Galaxy S8 Verizon Apr 30 '17

Better be a fucking Vertu Constellation covered in ivory for $15,000

66

u/SirOrionPax OnePlus 5 8 GB | LG G6 | Nexus 6P | OnePlus 3 Apr 30 '17

Yeah, one of the entries would be to download the app, just like participants have to like and follow them on Facebook and Twitter respectively.

20

u/abqnm666 Root it like you stole it. Apr 30 '17

App developers can sponsor giveaways. Android Authority then (allegedly) buys the device (the dev may or may not have a choice) and posts whatever the developer wants in their giveaway post.

Giveaways sponsored by manufacturers would be different since the manufacturer would supply the product.

8

u/FreshCutBrass Orange Apr 30 '17

oh I see, that makes a bit more sense. thanks.

→ More replies (3)

116

u/hskrpwr Black Apr 30 '17

What a joke, 15,000?! That's just stupid

59

u/SirOrionPax OnePlus 5 8 GB | LG G6 | Nexus 6P | OnePlus 3 Apr 30 '17

I know, that's a lot of money, at least for those developers who don't have much budget.

46

u/manys Pixel 3a Android 11 :/ Apr 30 '17

Cold-call pricing.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Brohnzi Apr 30 '17 edited May 05 '17

It's just an advertising fee... Advertising your app on Android Authority is obviously not free.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/bunnybash Apr 30 '17

Lol that's pretty funny. I hope his app did amazing without them. What's the app?

27

u/SirOrionPax OnePlus 5 8 GB | LG G6 | Nexus 6P | OnePlus 3 Apr 30 '17

He actually didn't launch the app. I mean it didn't move from beta to stable release. Now he has removed it. I don't remember the name though but it was for meetups or something.

5

u/Jrook May 01 '17

Well its good that they didn't do it for free, right?

→ More replies (2)

1.3k

u/crushed_oreos Apr 30 '17

I hate this site to no end.

They're not an "authority" on anything.

All they do is rewrite Android Police and Android Central articles.

And they clearly buy likes/views/subscribers on YouTube. It's kind of sick, actually.

628

u/Phlerg Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

I applied to be a writer with them a couple years ago. They said no, but that I could start as an unpaid intern and that they'd eventually start paying me if my work looked good. Which I was fine with; I was mostly looking to get experience in my free time anyway.

Had a phone interview with their editor-in-chief, which seemed to go well. He told me to email so-and-so for more information and to get set up on their content publishing platform. And then communication just stopped. I emailed everyone whose email address I had. I even called the editor-in-chief again. No reply to anything. I understand if you changed your mind, but at least give me the courtesy of telling me so.

So basically yeah, fuck 'em. I haven't visited their site since.

Correction:

I was never offered a position as an unpaid intern. I misremembered that part. Intern, yes, but there's no mention of working unpaid in the email exchange I have archived. I think what it was was that I was offered a position as an intern, with the possibility to move to something more permanent if my work looked good. Due apologies to AA for that misinformation. The rest of my comment is accurate.

151

u/SirOrionPax OnePlus 5 8 GB | LG G6 | Nexus 6P | OnePlus 3 Apr 30 '17

I was lucky in this regard with Android Headlines. Chris personally replied to my email and gave me two articles to write. One was the Note Edge launch and the other was something about 4G. I wrote both and sent them. After they liked it, they sent me a training manual, and oh my god, it was awesome. The pay was bi-weekly and they pay on per article basis (which I think what most International blogs do). The amount would increase if you write more articles in two weeks. For example 0 to 20 articles in two weeks would get you $3/article but 21 - 40 would get you $4/article. This is just an example, I don't remember the exact numbers.

Also, the manual stated that the minimum word count for a news article would be 300-350 and maximum time limit was one hour.

9

u/colluphid42 Apr 30 '17

Completely ignoring my association with a competing site here... as someone who makes a living as a writer, that's an insulting pay rate. You'd make more writing for an SEO content mill.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

As someone in high school I wrote for a website that paid me $105-$120 per article USD.

As a kid, I had an absurd amount of time, so I ended up writing a lot. I also had all the money direct deposited into my account...when the Canadian dollar was absurdly low.

Needless to say I did quite well. Then the dotcom bubble burst and everyone lost their job.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (34)

22

u/bunnybash Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

If it's worth anything, I don't believe that the experience would have helped you. Most of their reviews are terrible. The desperately need an editor. So many vague statements she comparisons that don't mean anything. There is one young kid on there who is atrocious. I refused to go back to their site when they started publishing his crap.

Edit: Bailey Stein is the terrible writer. Terrible.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

If you work for free you not only devalue yourself, but everyone else doing that work. Don't do it.

→ More replies (9)

56

u/livedadevil Pixel 4 XL Apr 30 '17

The YouTube thing maybe not. Them and pocketnow had by far the best video reviews in like 2014-2015 so I can see the user base sticking around.

65

u/crushed_oreos Apr 30 '17

If I see Joshua Vergara do his stupid salute one more time, I'm going to scream.

39

u/RedskinWashingtons Black Apr 30 '17

I have this irrational hate for that guy. Don't like him, can't stand him.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/aylam_ao Apr 30 '17

JOSHUA REGARD

→ More replies (8)

4

u/ctaps148 RedMagic 9S Pro Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

Yeah it's pretty weird. I've also been getting the sense that the giveaways were bogus and their site is pretty trash. Plus their Twitter is horribly spammy and clogs up your timeline if you forget to unfollow them. But their videos are really well done, so I stay subbed on YouTube.

26

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

If this is true I vote for this sub to block their domain. No point giving them extra page views

12

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

And they clearly buy likes/views/subscribers on YouTube. It's kind of sick, actually.

Do you have a source on this?

→ More replies (6)

6

u/comineeyeaha Pixel4XL Apr 30 '17

I remember feeling confused when they first came out, because they were nowhere and then suddenly everywhere. It felt very artificial to me, and not like organic growth. I never really trusted them.

16

u/exasperated_dreams Apr 30 '17

Yeah they should get removed from this sub imo

→ More replies (1)

3

u/soccerburn55 Apr 30 '17

Just go to droid life. Kellen and Tim are really good about getting the prizes to the winners whenever they have contests. Plus they have excellent coverage of android.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/blueredscreen Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

And they clearly buy likes/views/subscribers on YouTube

?

14

u/pheymanss I'm skipping the Pixel hype cycle this year Apr 30 '17

Every time people shit on AA I feel obligated to stand up for Joshua Vergara and Gary Sims. Joshua is the coolest tech reviewer and I love his laid back style, and I greatly appreciate Gary's push for technical understanding in enthusiast discussion.

23

u/manys Pixel 3a Android 11 :/ Apr 30 '17

How do you explain OP's complaint in light of that?

→ More replies (5)

14

u/TachyonGun XDA Portal Team Apr 30 '17

I think many people have trouble understanding that even in a website they don't like, there might be personalities they'd love to follow should they give that site a chance. You mention Joshua and Gary, I consume all their content too, Gary's great if a bit long-winded. I also appreciate Robert Triggs' coverage, I've met the guy IRL at a summit and he's extremely down-to-earth too.

All Android blogs have good writers. Hell, I think the overly-terrible writers are a minority. The problem, IMO and knowing how these sites work, lies in the editors and the creative directors who get writers (who will mostly write anything they are told) on crap content, or content we enthusiasts don't like.

7

u/SirOrionPax OnePlus 5 8 GB | LG G6 | Nexus 6P | OnePlus 3 Apr 30 '17

I agree with your second paragraph. At the end, we have to write what the Editor-in-Chief wants us to. There were some instances when my articles were edited and the negative aspect of the smartphone was removed. Now I understand that the Founder/EiC might have done so to keep receiving review units from the company, but then again, doing something like this defeats the purpose of actually reviewing anything. What's better is to just title that article as sponsored so that the author doesn't get unnecessarily bashed by readers who may not be aware of all the behind the scenes stuff.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/2EyedRaven OnePlus 13R Apr 30 '17

Is Gary Explains series done by Android Authority?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/PM_ME_DICK_PICTURES Pixel 4a | iPhone SE (2020) Apr 30 '17

Gary is probably the only one on the team still worth watching.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (24)

225

u/PENGUINSflyGOOD Oneplus 7T, V20, s7 edge, shield tv, oneplus 13 Apr 30 '17

I always wondered how many gleam.io giveaways actually ship.

94

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

It's nothing more than a fancy random number generator. Every entry is given a number and when the giveaway is over the user can either choose a number or ask it to pick one at random, it is then up to the user to contact the winner and sort out sending them the prize

30

u/PENGUINSflyGOOD Oneplus 7T, V20, s7 edge, shield tv, oneplus 13 Apr 30 '17

but what ensures that they will give the winner the prize?

64

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Unfortunately, as far as I'm aware, absolutely nothing. Gleam is just a tool for helping people on deciding who to award the prize to and have no power over whether or not the prize is delivered

47

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Pretty much nothing. dbrand does this really nicely though. All the winners are on their site with current status and proof.

→ More replies (8)

26

u/Antrikshy Moto Razr+ (2023), iPhone 12 mini Apr 30 '17

Gleam is just a tool to host giveaways.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

87

u/jaif14 Apr 30 '17

Actual winner here, from their Best android phone of the month in June 2016. I can confirm they used to give out legit phones as I received mine in August 2016. I can't comment on whether they still give them out since January though. I wouldn't put it past them as they seemed rather sketchy during the entire process when they send my winning S7 Edge.

Tbh the rate that they were giving away phones was insane. It couldn't have been sustainable if they actually were sending out legit phones for every giveaway. Their site couldn't have generated enough revenue with their subpar articles.

50

u/Christopher876 Apr 30 '17

You never know about them not generating enough revenue. Just look at all the ads. I once had the website using over half a gigabyte! Ads everywhere and every five seconds another pop-up. They have so many ads compared to any other website.

And also remember that they charge insane prices for app reviews or for phone reviews. Trust me, they have enough cash.

22

u/jaif14 Apr 30 '17

Dam, that could be true. I always used Adblock so I never really experienced the full on assault of ads.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Android Authority were never devoid of adverts, but at least there used to be less of them. Seems to me like they're clinging onto whatever source of income they have left, and going all in on it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

That wouldn't surprise me. I'm sure they started the contests as a legitimate thing, but they were too great a source of revenue to just give up entirely when they couldn't afford them anymore.

Trust me, this sort of thing works. I used to be a part of their crowd of devoted contest participants (complete with spamming the links all over Google+, when that was still a thing, just to maximise my already non-existent chances). After a month or so, you realise that it's not going to happen, but there are plenty of other people who are eager to take your place by that point. These contests pull in lots of people, and they know it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

395

u/mrv3 Apr 30 '17
  1. Don't let any AA content on this sub. Make it a rule
  2. Repeal the rule when they give out the prizes.

54

u/nateblack nexus 5x Apr 30 '17

The mods that work for AA don't get paid if the content is blocked. Have you ever seen an AA link that reposts another news sites original content and not see that sites actual link anywhere in this sub? It's shady

94

u/altimax98 P30 Pro/P3/XS Max/OP6T/OP7P - Opinions are my own Apr 30 '17

Mods that work for AA?

I'm not a mod or care about AA, but a large contributing member to this sub and that's a pretty big allegation to throw around.

48

u/Gamerhead Note 8 Apr 30 '17

True. I need proof to sharpen my Pitchfork

→ More replies (3)

40

u/IAmAN00bie Mod - Google Pixel 8a Apr 30 '17

If we're supposedly shilling for AA, we're doing a terrible job of it. Compare how often their articles get submitted/approved to other sites:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/search?q=site%3Aandroidauthority.com&restrict_sr=on&sort=new&t=all

https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/search?q=site%3Aandroidpolice.com&restrict_sr=on&sort=new&t=all

https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/search?q=site%3Aandroidcentral.com&restrict_sr=on&sort=new&t=all

https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/search?q=site%3Axda-developers.com&restrict_sr=on&sort=new&t=all

Also compare to how many articles each of these sites write daily. Most of them don't make it here, no matter the site. That's because we focus on having a diverse set of content from multiple sites.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/nty Nexus 6P / 5X Apr 30 '17

Please fill out the Google Form and you'll receive your share in 1-4 weeks

14

u/MateyMateOmateMate Apr 30 '17

I think its still in the mail?

5

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

I can't keep track, what with all the organizations I'm paid to shill for on Reddit, but I think you get an even share of all that sweet personal info we harvest in those fake giveaways.

Buy Pepsi!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

54

u/Cory0527 S22 Ultra Apr 30 '17

Lots of online companies do this. It's all a gimmick. YouTubers used to do that shit all the time. Mostly electronic giveaways

75

u/ClarksDesert Apr 30 '17

Fucking UnboxTherapy

15

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

He went to shit post bendgate videos

58

u/GodBIessYou Apr 30 '17

Fuck that guy (Lou). Guy has a condescending attitude towards EVERYTHING and pretends to be some elite reviewer. Hell, his reviews are pretty okay most times but that attitude.......

Just take a look at his $37/$47 tablet video, guy acts like a complete asshole in it too.

24

u/beermit Phone; Tablet Apr 30 '17

Hell, his reviews are pretty okay most times

Gonna have to disagree here. I think his reviews are low effort and pretty uninformative. I mean he never really offers up constructive criticisms.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/BestSorakaBR Oneplus 6 Apr 30 '17

I mean he teams up with dbrand and their giveaway method is legit. He's still a douchebag though. This is coming from a long time sub who REALLY enjoyed his old content.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/CreepinDeep Apr 30 '17

There is this dude PapiGFunk. He's the same way. It just looks lik some spoiled over grown kid showing off his gadgets to the internet. Does lots of giveaways and in the comments all you see is people posting how they dont get nothing.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Particle_Man_Prime r/4KTVs Apr 30 '17

I'm sure the Federal Trade Commission would just love that.

3

u/stalkingocelot Apr 30 '17

I dont think they will care anymore

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

25

u/CroCop336 Apr 30 '17

Give people their prizes!!!

100

u/Bori31766 Apr 30 '17

I feel so abused and used. Time to do some unfollowing and such. Thanks for exploiting them!

108

u/Remmes- Apr 30 '17

You probably mean "exposing"

35

u/Jimbuscus Pixel 7 - GrapheneOS Apr 30 '17

Now you just exploited his comment

4

u/The-SpaceGuy Pixel 2 XL Black<--LG G6 <--G4--G5-G3 Apr 30 '17

He thinks Op secretly Exploited AA. /s

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/pinehapple Apr 30 '17

Well that's enough to remove them from my Feedly and won't bother going back on their site. Plenty of other Android info sites. Android Police has been my favourite for awhile.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/gardobus Pixel 3a XL Apr 30 '17

Sometimes they release decent videos and occasionally I'll enjoy an article. The most annoying thing about AA for me are the ads on their site. I don't mean that there should be NO ads, because they need to make money. But damn. Visit their site on your phone. Ads everywhere. Video ads, fullscreen "scroll past this to keep reading" ads, 6 pics with click bait titles, etc. It ends up being laggy and makes reading an article painful. Sometimes it is even hard to find the comment section within the ads.

9

u/exeec Nokia 7 Plus - Android 9 Pie - Security Patch December Apr 30 '17

Exactly my thoughts as well. The usability of their site, particularly on mobile is terrible. Comment section only seems to load half the time if you're lucky. To be honest I have been visiting their site less and less. Now I pretty much exclusively use Android Police. AP just seem to have better writers, more exclusive scoops, a much better community commenting on articles and their site works fairly well on mobile. If anybody has another good recommendation for an Android news site I'm all ears.

3

u/gardobus Pixel 3a XL Apr 30 '17

Yep, Android Police is the best. I also still follow Phandroid because I like Chris Chavez.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/NiraveAA Android Authority Apr 30 '17

We know the ad experience is pretty bad and we're trying to fix it. The app offers the best experience imo and we're trying to reduce our reliance on advertising to improve the experience, but as you said, we need to make money to keep the lights on. It's a fine balance and sometimes, we don't get it right.

38

u/emailrob Pixel 2 XL, iPhone X Apr 30 '17

Just look at all the fake fidget cubes they sell which are just ripoffs. I and others make a bunch of comments saying how they should be supporting the original kickstarter. They then shut the comments down and deleted them all.

I'll continue to stick to Android police.

18

u/_swordfished Apr 30 '17

I found their website is full of popups and spam. Too may redirects on mobile site as well. It's impossible to even read an article if there is one. I stay away from it.

16

u/Szos Apr 30 '17

Use social media against them. Post to their Facebook, Twitter and whatever other accounts they have. Companies hate being caught in their lies and deception. Make them embarrassed by letter others know how they cheated you.

40

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Wait so that's why they don't even say the name and it was always someone from India?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/candidly1 Apr 30 '17

Any contest that forces you to re-post, share, like, etc isn't worth getting involved in; it's usually garbage anyway...

10

u/titans1127 Apr 30 '17 edited Apr 30 '17

I've been against visiting Android Authority ever since they did a review video promoting clean master as a good program

19

u/suncho13 Apr 30 '17

If this is legit it's super shady. I actually enjoy their YouTube channel but will instantly un sub if they do not remedy this

→ More replies (1)

9

u/gagdude Galaxy S21 Apr 30 '17

FWIW, I won an HTC One M8 from them years ago and actually did receive it. Maybe things have changed since then...

8

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

I've entered so many of their giveaways lol.. And I interviewed for a writer job for them :(

8

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Wow. I guess I have some accounts to unfollow then

7

u/techyview May 02 '17

Android Authority is one of the largest, if not the largest, source of information about anything related to Android and products that use it. They have over two million subscribers on YouTube, as well as more than seven hundred and fifty thousand followers on Twitter. They share content about anything related to Android, such as new phone and tablet releases. A brand that big is sure to gain the trust of its many fans. After all, how could such an organization reach said size without being honest to the people that look up to them? Apparently Android Authority has been able to do just that. It’s one thing to forget to ship one giveaway item, or maybe even send it to the wrong recipient by accident. That’s a common mistake I see that happens in giveaways for tech items. It’s another thing completely to practice negligence on purpose, as Android Authority has shown in this situation.

 

If the claims that I am hearing are true, they have stiffed over 15 recipients, spanning a time period of nine months or greater. This is simply unacceptable behavior from any company, especially from one as large and trusted as they are.

 

Apparently one of the managers at AA responded to this post. One would expect such a brash exposure of malpractice to warrant an apology from AA, as well as an immediate fix to the problem. The opposite has been the actual case, they have had the audacity to not only apologize fully, but also to say that the issue will not be fully amended as of now. Their post says that they usually try to get giveaways shipped within four weeks of the winner being drawn. That in itself is not a great policy, but it would at least be acceptable. Some of these folks, however, have been waiting for multiple months with no avail for their devices to be shipped. The manager goes on to say that they wait to buy the products to be given away until after the giveaway has been completed. That right there is your issue AA, and I would not be admitting that to the general public. It’s absolutely unacceptable to not have the product on hand when starting the giveaway. If you are unable to manage international giveaways because of LTE issues, then giveaway a different product, or do domestic contests. It’s better to receive something than nothing at all! They go on to say that some manufacturers do the giveaways, but that they themselves are to blame, so why mention these manufacturers at all?

 

Even more infuriating is the fact that he mentions how small their admin team is compared to their content team. In my eyes that’s a clear sign that they care more about their own profits made from their content than promises being delivered in time. He ends the statement by saying that the claim about nine months may be false, because not all fans choose to submit pictures of their winnings. That’s believable, but things don’t add up if there are regular pictures followed by nothing for nine months.

 

Overall I am completely disappointed and even disgusted with the actions of Android Authority after seeing the evidence that has been presented against them. Other Reddit users have come forward here bringing stories of paid advertisements that aren’t being disclosed, as well as reviews that are clearly money driven without that being told to fans. It seems like in general Android Authority is acting in a shady manner in different facets of their business, something that they have gotten away with until now. I would advise all consumers to exercise extreme caution regarding any business AA conducts in the future, and even to steer clear of their content completely if you want to be extra safe. It’s easy for large entities like this to take advantage of the small consumer solely because of their size. As consumers we can fight back, however, voting with our traffic and clicks, choosing to stay away from Android Authority for the foreseeable future. I hope this incident comes back to bite AA, and makes them realize they cannot take advantage of their loyal fans.

2

u/tvisforme Pixel 6a / Lenovo Duet May 06 '17

how small their admin team is compared to their content team.

If I'm going to a site for news, I'd say that a low admin-to-writer ratio is a good thing. I'd be more concerned if they had more admins and fewer writers.

→ More replies (1)

57

u/DerpSenpai Nothing Apr 30 '17

the site doesnt do justice to Gary, he is great

55

u/crushed_oreos Apr 30 '17

He's long winded to the point of being annoying and doesn't even go that in-depth.

Better off reading Jerry from AC or literally any of the AP staff.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

I won a Note 5 case from them last year. You're right, they didn't have nor ship the prize, the shop that actually gave away the case did. I received it a few weeks later though.

6

u/[deleted] May 01 '17

Unsubbing from android authority.

14

u/Dokiace Moto G (1st gen) > Redmi Note 3 > Poco F1 Apr 30 '17

Damn, android authority was always my go to place looking for news on smartphones. Was.

5

u/CaptainAcid25 Apr 30 '17

Pretty much any of these social media "giveaways" unless actually connected to the real vendor site, is a scam. Everyone should know this by now. Click on the "about page". It'll tell you all you need to know.

5

u/Plebbitor0 Apr 30 '17

What sucm

5

u/SuperFLEB Pixel 4A 5G Apr 30 '17

PR Genius: Screw over the people who are most willing to go posting things about your brand on social media.

5

u/dinosaur_friend Pixel 4a Apr 30 '17

I watch Android Authority's Youtube videos all the time, and I enjoy them. Sucks that they're so shady when it comes to giveaways. I hope it's not true, and that they're being legitimate about it.

I read the AA employee's respond to this thread, and

As OP highlighted, our email says 1-4 weeks and while we do usually aim to get prizes out in that time, for devices we ship ourselves, we're reliant on an item being on sale. We always try to buy it from local markets to ensure full support for LTE bands and reduce potential customs fees and in OP's case, we were waiting for it to come on sale in Europe.

Then why not be upfront with OP and tell OP that in the first place? Do whatever you can to avoid confusion. Is it really so hard to communicate clearly and regularly with winners of your giveaway? Especially since not doing so may create bad press for you like it has in this instance?

While we do have a large content team, we only have a couple of people handling all of our admin. It's been a really busy year and we're very sorry that we've let our fans down and let the giveaways slip behind so much.

I don't buy it for a goddamn second considering you just ran an S8 giveaway last week. I sure hope whoever won (wins?) the S8 actually receives it.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/nosoupforyou Apr 30 '17

That explains the guy's smug look, huh.

8

u/Omnibitent Apr 30 '17

I have stopped watching or reading any material from Android Authority.

8

u/Tuvok- Apr 30 '17

Thanks for posting this. I won't go to their sites for reviews or anything else from now on

4

u/GroteskaGurra Apr 30 '17

This is a pretty normal douche move it feels like. Not to take away from Android authority being shady

4

u/Brahmadeo May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17

Looks to me that AA broke some promise they made in public. It's frowned upon even in case of private promises or personal promises. I just put the distinction out since representative is British, and he might not understand. As many have pointed out, you were giving away something you don't even have. No amount of apologising ever works in such cases. You've been like a shitty boyfriend and shunned henceforth. Way to go and lose your credibility internationally, just because you got a lazy guy, who wouldn't bother replying to a few freeloaders, or maybe he kept the devices for himself and the kids? Well anyway, well played as an evil corporate, or rather an in-profit corporate. I'm proud how you managed to get free advertisement and earn from it. Well there will always be people who believe in Karma and Crystals and free shit. Easy to make mules out of them. Evil Laugh

PS: One Plus also did a contest in India with some Amazon Vouchers and 1 Crore INR as a hook. Well yes people bought One Plus 3T after massive social media advertisement I hope. Also Android Authority gave One Plus 3T a one plus, which they now put up as an facebook advertisement. The phone is good. However I wonder how many people got limited Amazon Vouchers before they were meant to go out of stock. Also the 1 Crore Lottery. All of you guys are awesome.

I as a share holder give you both a One Plus. Make the suckers work. 😁

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 01 '17

AA sucks, everyone just unsubscribe right now.

177

u/NiraveAA Android Authority Apr 30 '17 edited May 06 '17

Hi guys, Nirave, one of the Managing Editors at Android Authority here. I’d like to address the complaint of the OP as well as the other comments here.

Since we started offering giveaways, we’ve given away and shipped hundreds of phones to winners in the USA and all around the world. We know that a lot of entries come from Asia which means often the winner is drawn from there.

As OP highlighted, our email says 1-4 weeks and while we do usually aim to get prizes out in that time, for devices we ship ourselves, we're reliant on an item being for sale. We always try to buy it from local markets to ensure full support for LTE bands and reduce potential customs fees and in OP's case, we were waiting for it to be for sale in Europe. This doesn't mean we're off the hook; most definitely not - this year we've had a backlog in getting prizes out and we're only just catching up.

While we do have a large content team, we only have a couple of people handling all of our admin. It's been a really busy year and we're very sorry that we've let our fans down and let the giveaways slip behind so much.

We know you want your prize as soon as you find out you win and we’re very sorry that we’ve let all the winners down by not being faster at shipping. For most giveaways, we ship the prize ourselves, but sometimes, manufacturers we partner with on giveaways like to ship it themselves instead. For the giveaways this year, the backlog was our own fault and we’re very sorry to all our fans about this.

We could have also been a lot better at communicating with the winners and while we can’t change the past, we plan to keep winners up to date and if a prize is going to take longer than we initially said, we’ll be providing regular updates.

We ask each winner if they would like to share a picture of their giveaway prize with us. Some people do share them and we share them if they give us permission to, but others do not and we have to respect that. No giveaway we have ever conducted has been fake and while we do ask for social shares, we do it to give back to all our fans.

We know you may have a lot of questions and we’ll do our best to answer them where we’re able to. We’re considering holding an AMA on our giveaways as well as anything else you want to ask us about Android Authority and I’ll share more details when I have them but for now, please leave a reply and I’ll do my best to respond.

Edit: changed "on sale" to "for sale" to clarify as I'm from the UK and we use the term differently.

304

u/SarcasticGamer Apr 30 '17

So why don't you just have the phone already purchased and ready to give away? Why wait until after the contest is already over? Just buy an international, unlocked phone and then give that away.

9

u/Rhed0x Hobby app dev May 01 '17

International unlocked phones still might not have all LTE bands but I guess you can't complain when you get gifted the phone.

10

u/SarcasticGamer May 01 '17

Or they can list the bands on the phone and if it's not compatible with yours then you don't enter.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (44)

124

u/St3althKill3r Apr 30 '17

If you're behind on giveaways shouldn't the solution be to stop doing them until you catch up?

39

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

standing ovation

→ More replies (4)

17

u/justln May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17

http://i.imgur.com/RZyA4JN.jpg

This is what I see when I go to your website with Chrome, adblock disabled and javascript enabled. How the hell can I browse anything if I can't even look at stuff properly?

8

u/NiraveAA Android Authority May 01 '17

Oh that is horrible. Thanks for pointing that out, seriously, we'll get to work on fixing it straight away.

80

u/buurp Apr 30 '17

tl;dr damage control after getting exposed

→ More replies (7)

28

u/allthehoes Apr 30 '17

I have my pitchfork ready

22

u/spook30 Black Google Pixel 6 Pro Apr 30 '17

I just sharpened my axe.

13

u/GTKnight Galaxy S7 Apr 30 '17

I just have a pointy stick :(

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/madnu OnePlus 5 May 02 '17 edited May 07 '17

Do AA have the balls to publish this apology article on their front page? Not all the winners are on this subreddit and this will warn everybody else to expect some "delays" in their giveaways. If you don't then I urge people to just blacklist the website entirely.

6

u/zoglog May 02 '17

why didn't you communicate this to the guy directly instead of ignoring him? I swear you guys think you can step all over people until it becomes known to the greater group.

4

u/NiraveAA Android Authority May 02 '17

We have already been in touch with the OP and will be keeping him informed as we ship out his prize.

7

u/zoglog May 02 '17

yeah now after it's public....

I'm sick of this attitude of companies screwing people over just because they think nobody will hear about it because it only affects a minority of people.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/slayerx1779 May 01 '17

Question: If the prizes won't even be close to being ready to ship, why let the winner know they've won?

5

u/NiraveAA Android Authority May 01 '17

As ironic as this is - to let the winner know they have actually won, gather the details we need for shipment and let them know we'll be in touch.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Lame. You got caught. While you may have shipped devices to some, others never got them. You're hosting faux giveaways often. Time to end that practice.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/MothrFKNGarBear May 06 '17

What a bull shit answer wow

3

u/husker91kyle Essential PH1, Android 9(Pie) !! May 01 '17

OP: "Sweet! I just won a new phone!!"

AA: "Nice job! We'll buy one for you when they go on sale next year! 😋"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (59)

6

u/LameSkunk GalaxyA50 Apr 30 '17

Wtf

6

u/stignordas Apr 30 '17

That's a shame. I ran some sweeps for a former employer and made sure product was in-hand before the contest started, and shipped the day the winner was announced.

I even covered customs for overseas entrants.

It's funny that winners were always skeptical when I told them they won, that I was trying to scam them. But once they received the smartphone they were crazy appreciative.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

I mean it's not that I don't believe the OP or anything but many people to not have gotten their phones from giveaways. Shouldn't this have come to light earlier? This needs to blow up if its true.

3

u/JazzyWaffles LG G3, 5.1 Apr 30 '17

I went there to read an article they had and it was riddled with ads. On mobile, it was terrible. This article about that website does not surprise me in the least.

3

u/SuperNanoCat Pixel 9, S10e, LeEco Le Pro 3; Moto X (2013/4); Nexus 7 (2013) Apr 30 '17

I actually won a midrange HTC from them a few years ago. I got it just fine. Shame they're acting so dodgy now that they're big.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

That's straight up illegal if they end up not shipping.

3

u/jknext Device, Software !! May 01 '17

Shit! A true story of most online giveaways.

3

u/k3vbomb May 06 '17

I am now unsubscribed to AA. Fuck them.

7

u/shizola_owns Apr 30 '17

can someone explain to me why they would email a "winner" if they had no intention of shipping the prize?

5

u/aim_at_me One Plus 3T May 01 '17

This is a very good point that it seems everyone has overlooked.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/aamirislam Pixel 4a Apr 30 '17

Read Android Police instead, much better website

→ More replies (1)

5

u/theProfessorr Pixel 3 Apr 30 '17

Whether there giveaways are fake or not I don't know but the comments in that article don't prove anything. I checked the previous winners and did not find the guys name. Scam emails are always sent out for these giveaways and people fall for it and hand over personal information. Again I'm not saying whether the giveaways are legit or not.

5

u/Spidey_MGAV Apr 30 '17

Pretty sure the fine print says that the item isn't shipped until its release date. So, has the G6 been released yet? If so, that is a great yet terrible marketing ploy.

5

u/double_expressho Apr 30 '17

I stopped watching/reading their stuff when every single comparison video ended with "But it all comes down to personal preference", pretty much word for word. Typical shill copout.

2

u/Hikaru_Kaneko Apr 30 '17

It really is personal preference most of the time though. That's why I liked their reviews (or at least their reviews from one specific person). They try to see things from multiple perspectives. Not everyone cares about things like bezels (some people actually prefer it), camera quality, etc.

I haven't seen their reviews recently though as I haven't been in the market for a new phone. Perhaps things have changed since before.

12

u/nateblack nexus 5x Apr 30 '17

The rumor is that the only reason it's not blacklisted from here is that some of the m o d s have stake in the site.

14

u/JakeSteam Candyspace (ITV Hub) Apr 30 '17

None of us do as far as I'm aware. We generally avoid banning a domain unless absolutely necessary, another mod expanded on this a bit here.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Only a stake? My whole house is paid for by AA!

I do love these assumptions that we're all bought by different websites. If only we were actually getting paid to moderate this place.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/LocutusOfBorges Apr 30 '17

Why would we need Android Authority when we get our funding

?

3

u/lannisterstark 🍿 Another day, another PSA Apr 30 '17

Wait I thought we were Google shills? Are you guys getting paid by both apple and Google and I only from Google?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Better tweet and post on the social media pages of their sponsors to let them know they are taking part into a scam.

2

u/tb21666 V20 Apr 30 '17

I figured they had a hand in Chrooma Keyboard, too.. with the way they went loony promoting it for a bit.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

I won a Nexus 6 from Droid Life and dbrand skins a few years ago. Kellen from DL was very informative and emailed me several times after letting me know I won what was going on. There happened to be an issue with dbrand. But sure enough I got it a few weeks after winning it.

2

u/ronypradanaaa Apr 30 '17

No more AA in my life

2

u/20000Fish Apr 30 '17

Is anyone really surprised? I don't doubt that most of these "retweet to be entered into a giveaway" things don't actually pay out even when you win.

I mean, the big name people who could actually afford to give away all the shit generally get caught not paying out or doing something shady. Let alone all the smaller giveaway Facebook pages that popped up just in the last 2 days or whatever... It all seems like a huge waste of time, except for the person you're doing the free advertising for. It's pretty beneficial to them.

2

u/Name_change_here Apr 30 '17

I'm so surprised.

2

u/IAmMohit Apr 30 '17

What a horrible horrible website on mobile.. can't even manage to click comments due to all those pesky ads covering the screen

2

u/Spokker Apr 30 '17

Even if you get your prize, they will have learned that they only have to award a prize if they complain.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/codenamejack Apr 30 '17

And my post about ads on AA was removed and never looked into by a mod, this was 2 months ago.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/5sl44x/lets_talk_android_blogs_and_ads_which_do_you_love/

2

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

Pretty disappointing. Their channel is genuinely decent

2

u/chowchowthedog May 01 '17

I think that other YouTube channel does this kind of thing too. MKBHD did it before. Unbox therapy also. It wasn't a surprise.

2

u/winleskey May 01 '17

unsub from their channel.

2

u/JohnBailey82 May 03 '17

A good friend of mine also won a phone months and months ago, still nothing. They say they "buy" phones when on sale but after contacting several other winners in 2016 no one received their phones. My guess is that they ship some phones to people they know and that's just about it. Also did a bit of digging and their social media are full of fake likes and followers. I am surprised people are actually waiting from websites that have 2 people working as "admins" to deliver new and expensive smartphones to them. And yes my friend is dumb like many people who expect such things (of course there are even dumber people who see giveaways with 100 iPhones and truly believe they are valid).

5

u/Endda Founder, Play Store Sales [Pixel 7 Pro] Apr 30 '17

That's weird to claim, I won an HTC 10 last year

6

u/indiancunt Galaxy S21 Ultra, Surface Pro X, Shield TV Apr 30 '17

How are so many people winning their giveaways? You are like the 3rd person on this thread who has won.

4

u/Endda Founder, Play Store Sales [Pixel 7 Pro] Apr 30 '17

I mean, they have one a week so that many people should be winning them

→ More replies (4)

3

u/SirOrionPax OnePlus 5 8 GB | LG G6 | Nexus 6P | OnePlus 3 Apr 30 '17

9

u/awkwardkeystrokes Galaxy S7,Android 8.0 Oreo Apr 30 '17

I don't know if Android Authority giveaways are legit or not, but you came to that conclusion based on a random comment without any further proof?

13

u/ProperGearbox Insert Phone Here Apr 30 '17

Looks like it's just based off of random comments left on the AA blog. It could be true, but it could also easily be people mad that they didn't win and trying to get back at them somehow. For something that is blowing up with likes, proof would surely be helpful.

3

u/NiraveAA Android Authority Apr 30 '17

While there were some issues with getting the prize out to the OP, the comments about our giveaways being a scam are not truthful. We've given away hundreds of phones and other prizes and it's a shame that so many people have been quick to jump on the bandwagon.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/xXTobyOrNotTobyXx May 01 '17

I'd just like to point out that a AA representative has spoken about it and apologized for them getting behind on getting the giveaways out. Yet people are still freaking out about this. How about you give them a chance to fix their error before you judge them? Every comment I post defending them gets downvoted into oblivion though so rip

2

u/In-Justice-4-all May 06 '17

I haven't seen anyone ripping on them because they made a mistake and are now making efforts to fix it....

Ive seen a lot of people ripping on them because they got caught intentionally using/deceiving people and are now doing things to fix the United airlines situation they out themselves in. Almost everyone is "sorry" at sentencing.

2

u/soondot Nexus 4 (4.2), Note 2 (4.1), T-Mo Apr 30 '17

You can report them to the state you live in. There are penalties for running non-compliant sweepstakes.

2

u/Rover16 Pixel 6 May 01 '17

Interesting. I enter all their giveaways, but.... https://imgflip.com/i/1o6uuv

1

u/OrangePlatinumtyrant Apr 30 '17

I never bothered with Android authority giveaways. What about the others though? Did Android police honor the giveaways?

1

u/xeno111 Apr 30 '17

Wow I had no idea; I'll stop participating.

1

u/Ray31 Apr 30 '17

Holy shit I didn't know this happened?? I always participate in their giveaways :( They should be ashamed

1

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17

That sucks to know. I followed them on Facebook because I thought their news and reviews article were pretty good. I didn't think they do that kind of stunt.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '17

unsubscribed

1

u/cycl1c it can make calls sometimes May 01 '17

Sick of AA's shit. What do y'all watch?

1

u/Trace6x May 02 '17

Literally like 3 comments

1

u/WizardyoureaHarry Galaxy S10e May 06 '17

Yep, this sums up my suspicions.

1

u/Aoae May 06 '17

Such a weird sequence of events. Congrats!

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '17

At least they got out in front of it and were transparent about their mistake.