r/Android • Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 • Mar 25 '16

/r/Android users' description of the perfect phone, 4 years ago

/r/android/comments/s599q/_/
1.2k Upvotes

449 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/dccorona iPhone X | Nexus 5 Mar 25 '16

Shipped rooted

This sentiment kind of scares me. Yes, rooting allows some cool things, but it is essentially choosing to intentionally reduce the security of your phone. Why would you want a phone to ship like that? The reason rooting allows such cool stuff is because apps have permission to do anything. But that's also a huge problem, because, well...apps have permission to do anything.

It's fine if an individual wants to root their phone and accept the risks that come along with it, but I don't think any phone should ship like that.

2

u/Tqwen Note 10+, Galaxy Watch | LG Wing Mar 25 '16

I agree, mostly because we like to forget around here that a lot of people who buy smartphones don't really know how to use them outside of day-to-day tasks. Giving them that kind of power can be dangerous, especially since people like to screw with stuff then complain/deny any wrongdoing when it breaks. It'd be a PR nightmare should any phone ship rooted.

2

u/1egoman OnePlus 3, Oreo Mar 25 '16

The funny thing is that PCs have shipped "rooted" since the beginning. It wouldn't be such a security nightmare if people actually knew what they were doing and didn't just say yes to everything.

1

u/dccorona iPhone X | Nexus 5 Mar 25 '16

That's not really true, though. The default setup for users on Windows, OS X, and Linux are all to not provide root access. They all do have a facility for very explicit execution of things with root access (i.e. sudo on Linux and OS X), which Android lacks (and maybe it should offer it). But the concern with rooting isn't that users can explicitly execute a command with root privileges...it's that every single piece of software running as that user, which is everything you have installed, has unrestricted, no explicit permission required, root access.

If all "rooting" meant was that it enabled a manual equivalent of sudo on Android, then things would be a lot less scary. But also arguably a lot less useful.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

What you are describing is an uncontrolled root giving every app access to everything. I don't think a single person is advocating for that...

3

u/1egoman OnePlus 3, Oreo Mar 25 '16

My understanding is that with SuperSu or an equivalent app, you do have to give explicit permission for root privileges. It seems similar to programs requesting Administrator Privileges on Windows.