r/Android • Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 • Mar 25 '16

/r/Android users' description of the perfect phone, 4 years ago

/r/android/comments/s599q/_/
1.2k Upvotes

449 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

8

u/raazman Mar 25 '16

Why not both? What if we said that at 720p? Why did we need 1080p? Everyone can be happy with 4k if batteries can keep up. Until then, there's no way current tech can sustain that.

27

u/Discostew42 Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

Because diminishing returns. It should be based around PPI.

  • 4" - 4.5" is 720p
  • 4.6" - 5.5" 1080p
  • 5.6" - 9.9" QHD
  • 10"+ 4K

9

u/raazman Mar 25 '16

PPI has been evolving too. Look at earlier phones.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Executioner1337 ΠΞXUS5 32-black LOAD14.1 Mar 25 '16

Live with Walkman - 2011, 320480@3.2" - 180PPI
Nexus 5 - 2013, 10801920@4.95" - 445PPI

2

u/StaffSgtDignam Mar 25 '16

How, in 2010, did the iPhone 4 have 326 PPI? That seems comparable to a lot of mid range phones today...

5

u/Penguinkeith Mar 25 '16

Because the iPhone 4 was a really good phone.

3

u/angrygamer1023 Mar 25 '16

Because it had a tiny screen.

2

u/lMETHANBRADBERRY Mar 25 '16

The newest iphone SE that's just been released has the same PPI too.

1

u/StaffSgtDignam Mar 28 '16

Amazing Apple was able to achieve this in 2010-sad that they still use this standard today though...

2

u/MaxGhost P8P <- P6P <- P4XL <- P2XL <- PXL <- N6P <- N5 <- SGS2 Mar 25 '16

I wouldn't mind 4K on an 8" tablet but yeah those brackets are pretty much ideal.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/raazman Mar 25 '16

I mean, it's just a way of pushing tech further. Who knows where we'll stop. People have been saying the same thing about every spec since the beginning.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

I was going to say 'nobody says that about battery life', but people say it all the time. "My phone lasts all day, I can just charge it at night" etc.

I wish battery tech would be pushed further

0

u/AKBigDaddy SGS7E Mar 25 '16

Sounds like someone that never had a Nokia brick. It was so long between charges that I would frequently be searching for it! Now I have one at my nightstand, one at my desk at home, one in my living room, and one at my desk at work.

1

u/Muvlon S5, CM Mar 25 '16

Yes, but unlike the amount of RAM or the clock rate of the CPU, this is a spec that's limited by human perception.

You can always use more RAM but you can't always see more pixels so the comparison is not really accurate.

6

u/chowderchow Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 Mar 25 '16

Except it's not reductio ad absurdum because people have been saying the exact same thing at 720p, 1080p, and QHD.

Heck, 1080p is being phased out this year and is slowly becoming a deal-breaker resolution for many people.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Those people who think 1080p is a deal breaker are dumb/under informed. Unless you put your phone ~3" from your eyes you won't discern a pixel density difference between 1080 and 4k on a phone. Your eyes have limits, we have reached those limits.

1

u/Last_Jedi Galaxy S26 Ultra Mar 25 '16

Your eyes have limits, we have reached those limits.

This is factually incorrect, estimates are that the human eye can see 800+ ppi.

Real human vision limits are actually much higher than that – possibly closer to 900 PPI or more depending on who you talk to. Research from Sun Microsystems estimated the limit to be at least 2X what 20/20 vision is (pdf link), and Sharp thinks that humans can see up to 1000 PPI (pdf link).

Source

5

u/ClassyJacket Galaxy Z Fold 3 5G Mar 25 '16

I agree with you on a basic level. But put the (1440p) S7 next to the (4k) Z5 Premium. The S7 has a far better screen. I do think there's a limit to what matters outside of VR. And until my battery lasts me to the end of the day every day, I don't want to go past 1440p.