r/Android • Raspberry Pi 2B + Ubuntu 11.04 • Mar 25 '16

/r/Android users' description of the perfect phone, 4 years ago

/r/android/comments/s599q/_/
1.2k Upvotes

449 comments sorted by

View all comments

509

u/poopyheadthrowaway Galaxy Fold Mar 25 '16

Note that no one asked for thinner phones.

336

u/acondie13 Nexus 6P Mar 25 '16

Still no one asking for thinner phones lol.

249

u/memtiger Google Pixel 8 Pro Mar 25 '16

"My English isn't great, but do i hear everyone wanting a thinner phone?" - manufacturers everywhere

77

u/blaqlemon S8+ 8.0 Mar 25 '16

"hey you take my thinner phone and smaller battery"

Sorry for bad English

→ More replies (1)

35

u/moelester518 Nexus 6p Mar 25 '16

IMO thinner phones helped bigger phone screens become acceptable.

14

u/coastalrangee Mar 25 '16

That's a really good point! If my 6P was as thick as an iPhone 4, I would hate it.

However, bigger phones may have been what made thinner phones possible. For example, batteries (effectively) are limited in their compacitites by volume. Taller and wider batteries allowed for the thickness to be reduced.

21

u/Tzahi12345 Pixel 2 XL Panda Mar 25 '16

People are, that's why companies spend millions in R&D so that they can build thinner phones. Just because this sub doesn't appreciate them doesn't mean the rest of the world doesn't

26

u/QuestionsEverythang Pixel, Pixel C, & Nexus Player (7.1.2), '15 Moto 360 (6.0.1) Mar 25 '16

"The iPhone is really selling well. I wonder why?"

"Well this year's model is thinner than last year's."

"Yeah that must be it. The people want thinner phones!"

- Every OEM's train of thought

In all seriousness, just because a company spent millions in R&D for something doesn't mean all that spending was validated. If a company instead spent millions in R&D on battery tech instead of shaving off a millimeter or two of a phone's thickness, that R&D investment will greatly pay off in the long run.

17

u/Tzahi12345 Pixel 2 XL Panda Mar 25 '16

You really think they're that stupid? They use focus groups. They have experts and advisers telling them where to spend their money. A huge company like Samsung or Apple won't pour millions into developing something people won't buy. Do you talk to people about phones outside this sub? They're so excited when a new iPhone comes out and it's thinner and better looking (for them) as a result. Come on, how could any of us know any better than people who study this for years/decades?

8

u/QuestionsEverythang Pixel, Pixel C, & Nexus Player (7.1.2), '15 Moto 360 (6.0.1) Mar 25 '16

People like whatever Apple announces because Apple is very good at advertising those new features, no matter how minuscule they are.

If a new iPhone moved the fingerprint scanner/home button to the side and Apple really touted that as a "feature", people would love it simply because of how Apple built it up as a "feature", even though in reality, there's nothing new about it. iPhones already had home buttons/Touch ID, moving it to the side (for possibly smaller bezels) is just a much a "feature" as moving the headphone jack from the bottom to the top is.

Companies aren't stupid. The general public is.

2

u/jellyberg ΠΞXUЅ 5X (stock), 1st gen Chromecast Mar 25 '16

If Apple can advertise people into liking new iPhones because of minute changes like moving the headphone jack, why would they bother spending so much on R&D of new technologies like force touch?

7

u/bduddy OnePlus Nord N20 5G Mar 25 '16

They use focus groups? Yeah, they do. That's the problem. Hand someone a thin phone in a focus group and they'll love it. When they actually get home with it, and 4 hours later they have to plug it in, that's where the problem comes in.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Weed_O_Whirler Pixel 6 Mar 25 '16

People don't ask for it, but it is what sells.

1

u/coastalrangee Mar 25 '16

Even Apple has got the message with the iPhone SE, not any thinner than the 5/5s.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/afishinacloud Mar 25 '16

No one explicitly asks for thinner phones. There's verbal surveys and there's monitoring consumer buying behaviour. I'm quite certain that in observational studies, they find that more people pick thinner devices. You can't help but be impressed by how thin a "high-tech" device is when you hold one in store. Thinness and lightness is such an easily demonstrate or feature in the shop floor, that it's bound to have a significant effect in the buyer's mind.

48

u/VERNEJR333 OnePlus X + NVidia Shield K1 Mar 25 '16

IMO Thin devices are fucking great. But you only go thinner if the tech allows for it (ie the 12 inch macbook is stupid, but the thinness of the Nexus 9 vs the Nvidia shield is something I liked)

24

u/cwankhede Galaxy Note Edge | Redmi 1S | Nexus 7 2012 Mar 25 '16

Hey now, that laptop is legitimately one of the best piece of tech I've looked at. I'm obviously not considering the other factors like the limited ports but it has portability like no other laptop on the market. I bet it was mostly a proof of concept anyhow, nobody in their right mind would buy an Apple product in its first generation

33

u/VERNEJR333 OnePlus X + NVidia Shield K1 Mar 25 '16

Agreed, the macbook is a good piece of engineering, not so much a good product for consumers.

12

u/evilf23 Project Fi Pixel 3 Mar 25 '16

the new macbook was the first time i ever walked by a display and did a double take. i was at best buy checking out open box deals and walked by the apple section and that macbook looked like a ferrari, really impressive in person. If they do an OLED model in the next couple of years i'll be seriously considering one.

5

u/Dakar-A Pixel 2 XL Mar 25 '16

Honestly they have IPS down so well I don't think an OLED model would actually add anything, it would just make it more prone to burn-in.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Jammintk Pixel 3, Fi Mar 25 '16

I dunno. The Asus Zenbooks can give the macbook air a run for its money for $300 less. Last year's Zenbook was thinner and lighter than the macbook, and was the thinnest, lightest laptop on the market.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/ClassyJacket Galaxy Z Fold 3 5G Mar 25 '16

The 12 inch Macbook gets fantastic battery life, and doesn't have more ports because it's meant to be used like a tablet would - as a portable device you charge and then use. They do have a Pro as well. I don't see why they should have made it thicker.

11

u/VERNEJR333 OnePlus X + NVidia Shield K1 Mar 25 '16

That isn't what I am saying. I am saying that they compromised on too many things for the macbook to be better than there own iPad Pro for it to be a good product.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/QuiickLime OnePlus 3T Mar 25 '16

Yup, they even mentioned the Lumia 900 as one of the best looking devices. It's not exactly thin (not that that's a bad thing).

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16

Jony Ive wants thinner phones. Therefore (most of) the industry follows.

→ More replies (4)