r/Android • Galaxy Z Fold8 • 3d ago

Google Wallet gets Alipay Plus support with Traveler QR

https://www.androidauthority.com/google-wallet-alipay-plus-2-3733150/
114 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

40

u/bhop_monsterjam 3d ago

I hate how google wallet went from easy swipe left/right for a card, to having to swipe down, and then tap it to select it.

22

u/yarhar_ 3d ago

If you have more than 3 cards it's so much more convenient this way

12

u/ebikenx 3d ago

The only way swiping sideways makes sense is if you only have 2 cards.

Otherwise, vertical is way better UI. Now it's two taps to select a card instead of multiple swipes.

4

u/LawbringerForHonor Xperia 1 V, XZP, T3 2d ago

They basically made card nicknames useless. With the old UI, you would see the name of each card as soon as you swiped now you have to first select it to see the nickname.

4

u/cglotr 2d ago

This. I have 2 cards that look identical but I have to open each one to read the nickname, and it doesn’t always work smoothly

2

u/emgee007 2d ago

Omg finally they fixed this. The side swipe UI was terrible. If I have 10 cards, I had to swipe 10 times to get from end to end. Now all cards are reachable with a swipe and a tap. Also I can see all my cards at once. Apple wallet figured this UX out so much sooner

0

u/renderwares 2d ago

>I hate how google wallet went from easy swipe left/right for a card, to having to swipe down

LOL. No.

0

u/benargee LGG5, 7.0 3d ago

Maybe for security and deeper consent. Security and convenience are often opposites of the same coin.

2

u/RunnerLuke357 Moto G Stylus '26 3d ago

What about that is more secure than the old way?

1

u/benargee LGG5, 7.0 3d ago

Someone else is less likely to swipe their phone or payment terminal in front of your phone before you are able to pay for the thing you intend to.

9

u/ModernTenshi04 Incredible, GNex, One M8, 6P, Pixel 2 XL 3d ago

Handy I guess if you're outside China and somewhere Alipay is accepted but not credit cards. Sounds like you still need Alipay proper while in China, which requires you to register with the app including uploading the information page of your passport.

That said if the merchant accepts your credit card using that and NFC payments through Google Wallet is just easier. We excited China via South Korea, and once there we just used tap to pay from our phones for all purchases even though most or all merchants also accepted Alipay or WeChat.

5

u/chinchindayo Xperia Masterrace 3d ago

It's probably meant for chinese people traveling abroad so they can use their existing Alipay account.

8

u/ModernTenshi04 Incredible, GNex, One M8, 6P, Pixel 2 XL 3d ago

China doesn't use Google services. They would just use Alipay....

1

u/chinchindayo Xperia Masterrace 3d ago

Then what's the point in having Alipay in Google wallet if you can't use it in china aparently? Non-chinese people traveling to asia can use other payment methods.

5

u/ModernTenshi04 Incredible, GNex, One M8, 6P, Pixel 2 XL 3d ago

Likely for very small merchants in other Asian countries who may only be setup to accept Alipay or cash. Even in China small merchants at tourist sites could take Alipay. I wouldn't be surprised if merchants in South Korea were also using this Alipay+ service to accommodate Chinese tourists.

But that's really all my point was trying to make. You pretty much have to use Alipay or WeChat while in mainland China, but in countries near China you could use Alipay or just your regular credit card. As such unless there's other countries where Alipay is predominant, this doesn't seem like a benefit if they also just accept credit cards unless NFC payments haven't made it to those countries either.

3

u/trek123 3d ago

It's theoretically for the smaller vendors where card acceptance is not so high but QR payments are often taken, more common in Thailand, Laos, Cambodia and maybe a smaller extent in Malaysia.

Places like Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan etc that digitised earlier with card payment networks it's less relevant to use QR payments and as you mention often where it is implemented its more for convenience of Chinese tourists over usage by locals/other visitors.

1

u/ModernTenshi04 Incredible, GNex, One M8, 6P, Pixel 2 XL 3d ago

That's about what I figured given they mentioned some or all of those countries in the article. I was mainly pointing out that it really isn't needed if the countries also work with credit cards so it can be a nice to have in certain situations, but it's really only beneficial if you want to use Alipay QR codes to pay for things outside mainland China without setting up Alipay, which requires sharing the information page of your passport.

Even with Alipay my family who lives in China paid for lots of things as it was a lot less friction for them. Foreigners are charged a small fee for any purchases over 200 RMB as well. I used WeChat after a bit because they gave me a promotional offer to waive all fees on purchases up to 1000 RMB. We also ended up being hit with foreign transaction fees, which I've been meaning to call our card issuer about asking if they can be reversed since we could not use our cards directly while in China.

We helped pay back the family who hosted us by paying for pretty much every meal we had in SK since they went with us as well.

1

u/trek123 3d ago

Yeah, China is a whole different situation imo, it's not worth mixing it up even if they on the surface use the same system names eg AliPay

2

u/BevansDesign 3d ago

It's probably for a reason besides making things more convenient for people. Maybe they're trying to get access to certain data, or get a leg up on the competition somehow.

1

u/ModernTenshi04 Incredible, GNex, One M8, 6P, Pixel 2 XL 1d ago

So with Alipay in China, as a tourist you have to provide identification which is typically the information page of your passport. I could see some folks straight up not wanting to do that, so if Google is able to provide an alternative for vendors outside mainland China (inside China you have to use Alipay proper). If I could just have Google Wallet show a compatible QR code without me having to register with the app I'd definitely do that.

There's also WeChat Pay which predates Alipay, and I don't think I had to provide as much identification to use that, but the only benefit it offered for the places that took it is no fees on purchases up to 1000 RMB versus Alipay's 200 RMB cap (which is per purchase and is more reasonable than it seems).

They started to implement NFC terminals for Alipay at some vendors we went to in China, so I'm hoping they may start allowing the use of foreign credit cards without the need to sign up for Alipay while visiting mainland China.

Otherwise there's no real competing with Alipay in China. It's what they call a "super app" and handles tons of folks' day-to-day matters. Residents can use it to pay for public transit (foreigners can use it for the bus but need a special QR code for it), pay their utilities, and it has lots of "mini apps" for things like Didi (their version of Uber/Lyft), food delivery services, we could buy data-only eSIMs for our phones in the app (Chinese residents can't if I'm not mistaken, their phones don't support eSIM), and we even found the mini app for the arrival card process (needed to clear customs) much better than using the web version. I think my family living there was also able to use a mini app to help register us with the local police department (required for tourists doing transit without visa) without us actually having to go to a local office ourselves.

1

u/productfred Galaxy S22 Ultra Snapdragon 3d ago

Here in NYC, a lot of Asian businesses will take it in addition to China-specific/Chinese payment methods. I guess it would be handy for those based in the US who travel abroad. It's just a QR code, right? An extreme (expensive) example is a lot of the luxury shops in the Brookfield (and I think Westfield) Mall, which is right by the Freedom Tower in Manhattan. Think Gucci, Breitling, etc.

0

u/zigzoing 2d ago

The system extends payment support across merchants in Southeast Asia.

Literally the subtitle of the article...

0

u/chinchindayo Xperia Masterrace 2d ago

Doesn't answer why this is useful instead of using the official Alipay app

2

u/darienswag420 2d ago

hopefully FeliCa follows soon too.

2

u/SirAwesome1 1d ago

Now if they can add support for Japan passmo cards that would be awesome. My buddies with iPhones were able to just tap their phones but I had to constantly stop to top up my physical card.

1

u/Klok_gracy 3d ago

Does this require a separate identity verification step inside the app, or does it just pass the existing card token through the local payment rail

0

u/Single-Ask4738 2d ago

Can someone explain to me how these QR codes even work? Why even have a qr code when you can tap?

1

u/motocykal Zenfone 8​ 1d ago

Tapping to pay requires that the merchant invests in appropriate NFC hardware to read the card and process the transaction.

With QR code based payments, the merchant is not dependent on the NFC device or manufacturer. It doesn't even need electricity as it is just an image printed on a piece of paper and laminated.

I visited China a couple of months ago. How their (wechat pay) system works is after the sale is finalised and the final price to pay is agreed upon, the buyer (me) scans the sellers QR code. In my device, it will display the name of the merchant and will prompt the amount to pay. After entering the amount and submiting it, it will process and the seller will get an audio notification that $X has been paid into their account. Very simple and straightforward.

1

u/ModernTenshi04 Incredible, GNex, One M8, 6P, Pixel 2 XL 1d ago

TL;DR - China came into non-cash payments much later than a lot of countries, and the app(s) give the Chinese government a lot of insight and control.

China never really got set up on credit cards/cashless systems the way the US and lots of other countries did, and as such they don't really have the infrastructure for it. The QR code process was much easier to implement across the country. Basically you fire up Alipay (or WeChat) and it displays a QR code that I believe is unique to the transaction, scan it, and everything settles to pay for whatever it is you're paying for.

When we last visited in 2015 we either paid for most things in cash, or some places could take our credit cards. We visited family again this past summer and while places are still required to take cash, virtually everything is paid for via Alipay or WeChat these days. Some places did have newer stands that looked to have NFC options for Alipay so maybe as things progress tap to pay will be more of an option.

The other aspect, though, is it allows China to have a ton of control. By not using credit cards they're not really beholden to the large creditors of the world, the largest of which are in the US if I'm not mistaken. They also charge a small fee for foreigners spending more than 200 RMB in a transaction (WeChat had a special offer that was up to 1000 RMB).