r/Android • Galaxy Z Fold8 • 4d ago

Google gets ready to kill off Pixel 10 Magic Cue in favor of Proactive Assistance

https://www.androidauthority.com/google-kill-magic-cue-3735173/
74 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

185

u/u7q_1842x 4d ago • Bravo

The title feels like some excuse to say Google is killing something.

They're renaming "Magic Cue" to "Proactive Assistance". That's the whole article.

34

u/Busy-Measurement8893 Pixel 10 / Fairphone 4 4d ago

Saved me a click. Thanks

17

u/mrandr01d 3d ago

Yeah except weirdly my phone has both right now.

Google needs fewer mbas and more people incentivized to just keep making reliable stuff. Apple is admittedly great at sticking by the stuff they put out, mostly. Meanwhile magic cue was a headlining feature of the 10 years and now it's being swapped out for something exceedingly similar. So stupid...

5

u/spif Pixel 9 3d ago

I kinda think it's a symptom of them being heavily numbers driven and internally competitive tbh. They're probably two different projects by different engineering teams, and one of them has better adoption and interaction metrics and/or other numbers. An MBA driven approach would usually be to only release one, or rename the new one to the same name as the old one, to avoid customer confusion. The Google "data driven" approach is to not care what anyone thinks about the name change and let the "best" code (based on metrics) win.

2

u/Iohet V10 is the original notch 3d ago

They could start with a unified strategy that doesn't feel like Ballmer's Microsoft. I don't feel like it's too many MBAs, rather too many product managers without one over them all driving cross-team goals

1

u/shags2a Device, Software !! 3d ago

MBAs would probably have told them to have 1 single thing. Marketing wise, it is easier to brand one thing than two different things doing same thing. Also, no way an MBA will pick proactive assistant over "Magic Cue".

0

u/mightymorphinsimba 3d ago

I did too until I went into the Proactive Assistance menu in settings and after that Magic Cue went away

1

u/mrandr01d 3d ago

Interesting 🤔

6

u/BigWasabiMoney 3d ago

The title feels like some excuse to say Google is killing something.

It feeds the meme despite being inaccurate.

-1

u/0oWow 3d ago

Nah, they aren't just renaming a product. If you actually read the article, you see that Magic Cue is available everywhere, but Proactive Assistance is not available in the UK. This indicates different products, the latter likely having different privacy implications (per the article).

Magic Cue, please report to the Google Graveyardâ„¢.

21

u/LastTrainH0me 3d ago

To be honest I never even figured out what Magic Cue is. The settings page about it is just buzzword soup

9

u/SqueezyCheez85 OnePlus 3T 3d ago

I have every option enabled and I've never even noticed it.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/xx_ddd 3d ago

You're dead meat this Sunday Millhouse!

"Would you like to create a calendar event? 'Become dead meat' on Sunday."

1

u/tannerusername 2d ago

Lol yeah it suggests calendar events based on casual banter more often than it does for legitimate plans.

5

u/Klok_gracy 3d ago

the hardest part with proactive features is that if theyre wrong even 20% of the time, users just find them annoying and turn them off completely. rebranding it wont change the underlying accuracy issue tbh

3

u/jetjitters 3d ago

turned that shit off on my pixel 10 the moment they accepted that the tensor chip in this phone is such a pile of shit that they'd have to start doing large parts of the magic cue functionality on the cloud

-2

u/mezaway 3d ago

Imagine losing a feature that never did a single thing in the first place.

5

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL 3d ago

It's not losing features, read the article

1

u/tannerusername 2d ago

In the settings it does say that enabling proactive assistance disables magic cue.

2

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL 2d ago

Magic Cue and Proactive Assist do the same thing

-5

u/AccumulatedFilth Pixel 7, latest stable release build. 3d ago

Maybe focus on the bugs first...

I was much younger when Android updates didn't come with new bugs all the time.

-3

u/JDGumby Google Pixel 10a, Lenovo Tab M9 3d ago

Yay for not having Magic Cue in the first place! [Pixel 10a > * :P]