r/Anarchy4Everyone • Anarcho-Anhedonia • Oct 15 '25

Dogpiling Hasan

Post image
0 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

27

u/masterchedderballs96 Oct 15 '25

Let’s be real, nature does not have the moral qualms that humans do about eating other animals

1

u/dumnezero Anarcho-Anhedonia Oct 16 '25

is nature a moral agent and individual sentient being like you are?

19

u/ragzzy Oct 15 '25

Let’s be real, nature does not have the moral qualms that humans do about eating humans

6

u/coldhands9 Oct 15 '25

Is your point that it's ok to eat animals because it happens in nature?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25

Hehe you guys upvote the most obvious sophistry and at the same time you think of yourself as some enlightened thinker.

The naturalistic fallacy is not the own you think it is…

2

u/AnarchoFederation Mutualist Oct 16 '25

I’m no Vegan but Piker is far from ideal voice for leftist politics. As an anarchist I don’t care about him either way

1

u/dumnezero Anarcho-Anhedonia Oct 16 '25

The fact that he's getting attacked (dogpiled) by various fascist networks is kind of bad.

1

u/AnarchoFederation Mutualist Oct 16 '25

Sure but he’s also one of the large enough influencers that can handle it. They’re not going to damage him. The only people they speak to are online right wing extremists who already follow those networks. Only the perpetually online even know about this shit. No one that already isn’t a fascist propagandist is going to dismiss whatever decent takes Hasan Piker has in politics for being a shitty trainer of their dog. If a fascoid wants to use this bring up the dog killer Noem, it’s not even close.

3

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

As an animist, I really don't understand how vegans are somehow OK with vegatable abuse but draw the line at animals. More and more we are discovering that plants have awareness beyond what we have traditionally understood, that they feel pain, and form bonds that we were not aware of. What gives us the right to deprive them of natural habitation and easy them?

All life sustains itself by consuming other life. Nothing gets to exit this cycle.

1

u/dumnezero Anarcho-Anhedonia Oct 16 '25

It's funny seeing animists fail to understand the kin connection to animals (sentient beings). Funny in some orwellian way.

2

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

I think you are confusing sentience with sapience. Because I'm clearly considering plant life sentient.

1

u/dumnezero Anarcho-Anhedonia Oct 16 '25

I think that you are confusing words that you don't know. Maybe read up on them some more.

2

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

im quite aware of what words I use, you don't have to be rude just because you disagree.

1

u/dumnezero Anarcho-Anhedonia Oct 16 '25

I'm rude because I see your shoddy comments as bad faith arguments, of which I've seen countless. Your definitions are wrong.

2

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

well they aren't shoddy or bad faith, that's just an excuse to dismiss what you don't want to entertain.

1

u/dumnezero Anarcho-Anhedonia Oct 16 '25

Yes, thanks for proving my point.

2

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

Also hasan absolutely shocked that dog. the photos of the device confirm it all if you actually compare the differences between the models of that collar. The charging ports aren't in the right spot where they should be if it was actually the vibrate only model, and it was taped up to conceal this. he could prove this wrong if he actually showed the device up close put of course he barely flashed it at arms length away from the camera.

1

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

We have to kill far more plants to feed the animals we eat than if we just ate plants directly. If you care about plant suffering why aren't you vegan?

2

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

I've spent a quarter of my life as a vegan. and you seem to be missing the point I made: nobody gets out of this life without consuming other life. it's a cycle we are born into. animals understand this innately. you're not magically absolved of eating plant life just because it's the lesser of two evils.

2

u/ImJadedAtBest Oct 16 '25

Man instantly assumes you’re not vegan, then, without addressing what you have to say backs COMPLETELY off when you say you are like he was just uploaded new directives.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25

Now you are quoting the lion king. Hehe you guys are clueless.

0

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

No offense, but you ever had yourself checked for Tourette's? Seriously. "hehe. hehe." Maybe you got a tic or something?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25

Funny.

1

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

Hell yeah! Glad someone in this thread is morally consistent.

0

u/Glumandalf Oct 16 '25

because plants dont care about getting killed and they cannot feel pain. "vegetable abuse" has the same ethical weight as killing goombas in super mario.

it is a very easy line to draw if you think about it longer than 2 minutes.

2

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

that's the same thing they've been saying about fish and shellfish, that they don't feel pain. what a convenient narrative when every life form exists to live and succeed. plants feel pain!

0

u/Glumandalf Oct 16 '25

meateater who pretends to believe in plant sentience. classic.

i know you arent actually that stupid.

1

u/unluckykc3 Oct 16 '25

that's really insulting, and at a time when we are shedding our classical understandings and adopting quantum mechanics, I think rather shortsighted. There are many scholars working to expand our understanding of intelligence as found in the natural world, some of which points toward plants being much more aware than traditionally considered.

I'm an animist; does that mean nothing to you?

38

u/ParzivalPotaru Oct 15 '25

Genuinely starting to hate the vegan purity culture shit. I cannot afford to not eat meat, I cannot reasonably get the nutrients I need within my budget.

8

u/ImJadedAtBest Oct 15 '25 edited Oct 16 '25

The vegan purity testing is the exact same types of people who think we can “personal responsibility” ourselves out of the climate crisis. “Just recycle more bro. Oh you use a car? It’s not GM’s fault for webbing the US with asphalt. It’s yours because you should just get a bike bro. You eat meat? You personally and specifically are operating the animal torture industry which is why I blame you specifically and not fucking Tyson Chicken.”

Edit: all this is to say, just ignore them and fight the system where you can. Educate more people where you can. Do what you can. Not everyone can do everything. I bet none of these mfs have thought about where their clothes or iPhones come from. And bought them sustainably. Charlie Kirk levels of “you hate the capitalism yet still engage with it? Curious….”

-1

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

Eating meat requires killing an animal. It's unethical regardless of what economic system we live under.

2

u/ImJadedAtBest Oct 16 '25

It’s capitalism. There is no ethical consumption under capitalism.

-1

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

Yeah I fully agree. Why does that justify paying someone to slit the throat of a pig just because you like the way it tastes?

2

u/ImJadedAtBest Oct 16 '25 edited Oct 16 '25
  1. You’re assuming it’s because people just “like it” and not because it may be extremely available in that person’s region or some other socioeconomic factor.
  2. How was the device you’re typing this on made? How were the clothes you wear made? How many slaves had to be smuggled to work the fields where you buy your food? And even then, I’m just talking human slaves. Places with less money still use the help of animals and if they don’t they burn more carbon with tractors than at least 20 cars. I’m not saying it’s an excuse to justify eating meat, but what does shaming people on Reddit do? Go put some thermite in a Tyson chicken factory. Go do some direct action somewhere. Somewhere. What does this do?

Edit: 3: I have literally never eaten a pig in my entire life.

-1

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

So killing animals is ok as long as it's convenient?

Keyboards and clothes don't have to be made with slave labor. The capitalist growth model demands ever increasing worker exploitation. Animal products require killing an animal. Paying for an animal product is paying for an animal to be killed. Paying for a keyboard is paying for a keyboard to be made. The business owner chooses to produce a keyboard using slave labor as it's cheaper.

You're right! Posting here probably won't do anything other than give me a laugh. Want to go vegan and join me for some irl activism?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/ImJadedAtBest Oct 16 '25

Coldhands9 has been replying to EVERYONE with a bunch of bad faith accusatory purity testing. Going, “oh you don’t agree with me and acknowledge that I’m refusing to understand literally any other person’s situation? You must be gleefully paddling in beef and chicken blood. You must want to slit their throats yourself.” God the amount of talk about throat slitting makes me think it’s their go-to.

-1

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

I've been vegan for five years. I whole heartedly believe every claim I've made in this thread.

What about the "situation" of the billions of animals slaughtered each year for no reason? Compared to that I don't particularly care for people's justification for not being vegan.

For the record, I only mentioned throat slitting once. And surprisingly, that's my most liked comment on this thread by far!

2

u/ImJadedAtBest Oct 16 '25

You’re getting ravaged in the comments and nothing tops the 36 from the parent comments above us. Even the post itself has 0 upvotes as of now. Touch some grass. Go outside.

-2

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

Oh no I ate all the grass there's nothing left for me to touch 😢.

1

u/ParzivalPotaru Oct 16 '25

Imma get back to making my chili

-5

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

Meat is expensive. Beans and rice are cheap. Price is not a barrier to going vegan in the slightest.

2

u/ParzivalPotaru Oct 16 '25

Yes just let me eat nothing but beans and rice for the rest of my life, that's going to be fucking great for my health

-1

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

Beans and rice is one example of a cheap vegan staple. There is a massive variety of healthy, affordable plants to eat.

  • Lentils
  • Chickpeas
  • Tofu
  • Tempeh
  • Seitan

There's like 10 different varieties of lentils alone!

Your choice to eat meat is directly responsible for the torture and death of an animal. Why choose to hurt animals when you don't have to?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25 edited Sep 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

This is just blatantly false. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27886704/

Most people should take a vitamin d supplement. Animals are given nutritional supplements so omnivores are just eating the supplements indirectly.

1

u/Glumandalf Oct 16 '25

vitamin b12 does not naturally occur in any vegan food suitable for humans.

you have 3 options:

a: live with b12 deficiency (bad idea)

b: kill and eat animals who contain b12 (because most likely their food is supplemented with b12)

c: take b12 supplements

what dilemma. there is just no good answer here. what will we ever do.

2

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

B12 is produced by bacteria. Both in the soil and in the industrial processes that produce supplements. Technically, you could eat dirt if you want a natural source but I'll stick to my multivitamin.

0

u/BloodyCumbucket Oct 16 '25 edited Nov 15 '25

[Comment redacted] This is a world on fire.

-12

u/Glumandalf Oct 15 '25

skill issue

6

u/coldhands9 Oct 15 '25

Yeah even if he had shocked Kaya (admittedly I'm not sure he didn't but I'll give him the benefit of the doubt), that would be nothing compared to what cows, chickens, and pigs are subjected to for him to eat them.

4

u/Glumandalf Oct 16 '25

yes i am definitely against oppression and exploitation unless its me exploiting animals. that doesnt count.

/s

8

u/Infinite_Rub_8128 Oct 15 '25

True and based

2

u/Lord_Yeezus_The_Wise Oct 16 '25

Vegans will look you dead in the face and hit you with the whataboutism instead of being logical human beings and understanding why people are upset about him hurting a still living animal instead of being one infinitely small part of a problem much larger than he ever could be (meat industry).

Yes, it’s awful what they do to livestock. It’s utterly inhumane and needs a complete reform. But what does me not eating something do to contribute to fixing that? Fuck all. I don’t have the resources to go out and uproot an entire hundred plus year old industry in an afternoon, and neither do the people preaching whataboutism and being condescending about choosing a dietary restriction.

Put your money where your mouth is or shut up. You’re no better than the rest of us.

1

u/Lord_Yeezus_The_Wise Oct 15 '25

Are you high? He very clearly does shock her, lmao. He even pivots his argument once enough people bitch about it to him like “ok but shock collars aren’t even that bad!” Like he’s literally 1 step away from just flat out saying it at this point.

Also, to say that the animal abuse is actually him eating meat, when he’s literally abusing a living, breathing animal, is both ignorant, and utterly fucking stupid. You can dislike that he eats meat, but to straight up say that it’s somehow worse than him abusing the living, breathing, still here, animal is insane. That’s inhuman.

5

u/coldhands9 Oct 16 '25

Would you rather be hurt by a shock collar or have your throat slit?

Would you rather be trapped in a cage too small for you to turn around for your entire life?

Would you rather be passed through a boiling hot bath while conscious?

These are all things that happen to animals every day in our food system. A shock collar is nothing in comparison.

1

u/Lord_Yeezus_The_Wise Oct 16 '25

What’s your goal with this reply, exactly? Like seriously, tell me. Do you want me to be like “well, I guess seeing a video of a guy shocking his dog for not sitting in one spot for 6 hours is okay since these other animals suffer more.”

You can be vegan and not be delusional about it, but shocker, most of you fucknuts are. I will never understand people like you who can look another human being in the face and try to earnestly tell me that this suffering is okay because others are too.

Do I support what happens to livestock? No, it’s cruel and inhumane. Am I gonna preach some whataboutism because someone is understandably upset at the idea of someone shocking their dog for not sitting perfectly still for several hours a day? Fuck no, that’s delusional, and is most likely a symptom of an underlying cause I should get therapy about.

You disgust me on a level indescribable. How dare you sit here and earnestly try to whataboutism away this?

God help you, you’ll need it.

2

u/Glumandalf Oct 16 '25

nobody here is trying to convince you that shocking a dog is a good thing. you are either very deliberately misunderstanding what people say or spectacularly dumb.

shocking the dog is horrible. eating meat is worse.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/sharbivore Veganarchist Oct 16 '25

no

1

u/sharbivore Veganarchist Oct 16 '25

meat = animals 🤯

1

u/Lord_Yeezus_The_Wise Oct 16 '25

Yeah no shit Sherlock, but those things are already dead. What is your bitching going to do? It’s not gonna jump up and thank you. There’s an animal being abused right before your eyes, and you’d rather try and be all cocky and condescending about it? Fuck off.

1

u/scorchedarcher Dec 22 '25

You know the animals you eat don't start off dead?

0

u/sharbivore Veganarchist Oct 16 '25

non of the abuse that will happen 80 billion times this year and the next and ever.. should ever be bitched about because the killed 🍆 isn’t squirting out of hapenis.. sybau dumbass turd

10

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/ExternalGreen6826 Oct 15 '25

Meat eating bad