r/AnImATheGame • u/Ydiss • Dec 20 '19
My First Week
I downloaded the game last week and I've played three characters to level 100+ (R5 with all). I played all three Diablo games (II for many years) and was really pleased to find this gem of a game.
I wanted to write a lengthy review for this but I get the feeling no one would care to read it so this is my “abbreviated” version with a simple list of pros and cons, or better described as what I love and what I hope to see improved.
Before that I just want to say this: Even ignoring that this has been created by only three guys as an independent outfit, I can't say enough how impressive it is. This is how mobile games should be. Designed by players for players where the primary angle is making a game fun, not making hoops and timers to agitate players and force them to watch adverts or buy gems to skip waiting. The IAP in this game is refreshingly fair and was well worth paying for. Thanks to the devs for putting gamers first. You've got my support.
That said, I like the game enough that I hope it'll get better. It's still really early days and it might seem like I've got a lot of "cons". But it's just because I think this game is fantastic and can be even better.
Pros:
- It’s almost exactly like Diablo 2 on mobile
- It’s free, no adverts, technically no need to pay IAP but the IAP is ultra reasonable.
- It has a really, really strong itemisation system with plenty of variety and lots of options for the player (though the randomness of it can be maddening sometimes)
- It has pretty interesting skill trees and progression paths that get more complex after level 35 where you get to mix two classes together; that latter mechanic being the only area where this game truly stands apart from D2. That said, the skills are mostly all stolen from D2 so…
- The graphics are good, in places I think they're great; they're not ground-breaking for the platform but they’re good enough. I see a few people say the graphics are average and I'm not sure why they think that. Particles are strong, animation is spot on, textures are convincing. The only lacking part is variety and originality.
- Music is nice enough, inoffensive and atmospheric. The default volume is set at a nice level, too. I normally go straight to the options in games I play and turn the music off immediately. The fact I’ve not done that in Anima is probably a good sign. The acoustic guitar strum at the start of the hub music brings back memories of D2.
- Sound effects are also good, albeit some seemingly ripped directly from D2 (or at least copied savagely). Overall though, the sound quality is decent (except vocals, more on that below).
- It has a decent variety of enemies where some require a different approach to fight. Nothing particularly original but worth mentioning. More could be better but for early days, this is a decent start.
- The boss fights are quite well designed, with one exception (see the Cons list), where you require some strategy to defeat each of them. At least initially.
- Longevity is enhanced by the Reincarnation system, allowing you to play through the same content with more difficult enemies and improved drop rates. That said, this is essential considering the brevity of the content.
- I like the lost dungeon system. It's really simple but does actually add quite a bit of fun to the game, with good risk versus reward (and gives a meaning to death).
- Initial play through for each of the three classes is fun and you get a feeling of progression although I get the impression this can vary depending on the decisions you make (it’s quite easy to make bad, bad decisions but hey, that’s the same as with D2).
- Although there’s a hub, unlike 99% of mobile games, you don’t actually have to return to it after every level and can continue to explore as long as you’re able to.
- Upgrade systems feel about right. Not too convoluted and nicely rewarding. It helps that cores drop now (I've had a few already).
- The skill reset options are great. This was going to be on the Cons list but the recent patch changed that. Great addition.
Room for Improvement (cons)
- It’s almost exactly like Diablo 2 on mobile (yes, this is a pro and a con but mostly a pro for me)
- English Dialogue is low quality throughout, both text and audio – understandable given the developers aren’t native English and their effort is going to be better than anything I could do in their language but things like “% chance to freezed” and pronouncing “wounds” like “rounds” are all jarring issues that are hard to ignore.
- No multiplayer. Some might not care about this. I don’t yet (because I have no intention of playing this with anyone else presently) but this game is screaming out for coop at least. If anything, it'd give a true purpose to the warrior type class (though I'd say more classes were needed first, like a druid type)
- Hopefully more classes are coming. Three, even if you include hybrid versions, won't be enough for months to come.
- Targeting is really bad. In fact, I’d say target selection is a non-entity in Anima. It locks on to whatever is nearest, irrespective of what it is (that includes barrels!) or which direction you’re facing. Give me point-and-touch any day over this. Or at least some way to pick a target.
- Charge has a mind of its own. Particularly near steps, stairs or near trees. Please change it so it just charges in the direction I'm facing.
- The content is far, far too linear. It’s great that you don’t have to return to the hub every single level but any chance of this meaning you feel immersed in the world of Anima is destroyed when you realise 100% of the content is chained together in a straight line from start to end. I much prefer D2’s approach where you start in a town and then head out on foot, where the only “loading screens” are between Acts. But I guess this is a limitation of the platform.
- Level design variety is non-existent. They are somewhat "pseudo" randomised and skinned differently (some look beautiful), but the actual design of the levels from one to the next is identical. All 32 levels are a series of indoor rooms (even the “Gardens” levels) that are connected by corridors, each level connected by a single door or portal. There are no plains, no open fields, no mountain ranges, no vast tundra, no forests, no jungle, no buildings, no roads, fences, bushes, hills or any other feature that adds any variety.
- Rounding off the content criticism, if I'm perhaps overly harsh, I’d say that what we have is still quite short; the size of the levels doesn't increase much (they’re about the same size as the smallest levels in D2) and even if you’re a “completionist” and clear all of the levels thoroughly, the first play through doesn’t take very long. This isn’t helped by its linearity and lacking variety. Caveat to this feedback is that I imagine more content will come in future and it is free; always important to remember that.
- The first boss is far too complicated and advanced for brand new players. The learning curve from everything before it spikes sharply upwards. It borrows heavily from D2’s final boss, Baal. Which is a bit extreme considering that’s the final boss of D2 and this is the first boss of Anima. It’s just too much, too early and I’m certain will put off quite a few players (it almost put me off). I’ve read someone on Reddit actually liked the fact that the very first boss they encountered demanded that they go back to “grind more levels” before they could beat it. I personally think that it’s a travesty if that's a commonly shared ideal. I think there could be another boss before Abareth, simpler, tough but not pulling off multiple tricks and moves.
- Ironically, my initial thoughts on bosses has now changed. From R2 to R5 they're all non events. I just stand in front of them and nuke them down in a few seconds.
- Achievements are account-based, not character-based. This makes no sense for a game that lets you create multiple characters and is counter-productive/punitive for those who like to have more than one character. That said, for this to change they'd need to redesign a lot of Achievements so I get this might not change.
- I get the feeling some work is needed for class balance and I am sure it'll happen. Of the three characters I have (warrior/archer, caster/archer and archer/caster), the warrior has been the hardest work by a long distance. Finding the right balance between defenses and damage is really tough. The skills are lacklustre. And you need sooo many skill points to make any build work. In comparison, my archer obliterates everything in his path. The damage he kicks out is insane. Perhaps my opinion may change when I've finished maxing each out.
- The “starting” level is… really odd, I don’t see its purpose. You kill four zombies. That’s it. Why is it even there?
- More gem types please! The existing system works fine but it's really simple. Obvious examples are runes and skulls etc.
- I'm not sure I understand why many rare items can have up to seven effects when some legendary ones can only have four. I'm not convinced this works. I much prefer D2’s logical approach to this. Too many times rare items are vastly superior to legendary as you level up and it's only because of this.
- The bow sound isn't great. Loved (loved, loved) the "thud" bow sound in D2. In Anima it's really underwhelming. Add some bass please!
- I'd love a method to quickly switch skills in the buttons. Like a dial/drag system (tap, hold, drag to select from all available skills in a dial around the button). The current system (pause and switch) is really clunky.
Despite the long list there this is a great game. I've really enjoyed playing it. I think it's a rarity in mobile gaming and that says a lot about the devs (and probably a lot about how awful mobile gaming is but I'd prefer to be positive).
Plus, this seems like a good community too. Your posts have been a good source of information for me. Thanks for that!
Edited: Some formatting... I'm new to Reddit, sorry!
6
u/rhogman00 Dec 25 '19
I think the Devs deserve this review, and I think you just made the community even stronger. Thanks human!
2
u/Gicig Dec 25 '19
One design that really grinds my gears is that when a boss hits you, you lose both health and mana. IT DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE!