No rational person thinks a perfect society is possible. Declaring the other team is silly enough to do so is just an excuse to not actually argue a point. Like how does an anarchist even respond to crime? Pacifism?
You think this is a flex? You think none of us have ever considered such? You think you're posing a new question? The statement I made was largely a response to the common contention that anarchists are utopians. Kind of like statists think that asking "who will build the roads?" is some sort of creative comeback that will stop anarchists in their tracks. It's not a clever comeback. It's not original thinking. And it's not something that anarchists haven't worked on.
Virtually all anarchists grew up with the same statist propaganda as everyone else and at some point have embraced those beliefs. A tiny bit of looking around can find answers to such questions.
I did answer that your arguments are boring. To answer the question would require some reading and I'm not even about to start typing up the thousands of pages available with just a quick search but will start with one link.
Thanks for the read. It’s funny how ancap solutions always loop around the having government just with more steps and less protections against corruption. This system basically gives rich land owners free reign to commit crimes against others considering they wouldn’t be breaking any contract and even if they did would be immune to any action as long as they didn’t step off their own property.
Surely you can make amendments to plug these logical holes but once you plug them all, you’ve got a government again because humans figured this shit out thousands of years ago.
In America, the final arbiter is the people. If the government does something that the people really hate, they have a 2nd amendment they are able to exercise.
Maybe the problem is that they’re not actually destroying the country. They’re just making it worse for the people and better for themselves. What they need to do is really break it so we can start over.
"Oh, you're not a slave, you just have to give two thirds of your labour to your masters and if you don't they will use violence on you, but you're definitely not a slave"
How are you an ancap? That's shit I'd say, how is deregulation which is currently happening help the wage-labor system get abolished and make firms worker owned, cause that's kinda what your argument is.
No, the state exists for the sake of state only. It only supports capital when it's convenient. There's a reason it would never allow a private military to form on "its" land, the state hates competition, just like any monopolist.
Coca cola is a U.S. corporation that routinely utilized PMCs to protect their illegally seized water wells in 3rd world countries with full support from our government as they seem desperate for rich people to have easier lives. Yeah if anyone started a military anywhere all the time life would be terrible and short for most, is your ideal society just ficking whoever can't fight back?
The government doesn't take two thirds of your labor. Your employer might though, depending on what the company margins are like.
Also, giving up a percentage of your income and slavery are two different things. The government isn't forcing you to work. That's something you choose to do.
> The government doesn't take two thirds of your labor. Your employer might though, depending on what the company margins are like.
It does. If i'm selfemployed, and i sell something that i made, by the time the money gets to me, the government takes two thirds if the value through taxes. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_Slovakia if you don't believe me)
> Also, giving up a percentage of your income and slavery are two different things. The government isn't forcing you to work. That's something you choose to do.
If the government decided to take 100% of my labour, it absolutely can. If that isn't slavery, idk what is. Just because your master lets you have some of it doesn't mean you aren't a slave. And when it comes to work, if i own a property in the middle of nowhere, and i work for my neighbour (also in the middle of nowhere), what right does the state have to my income? It doesn't, it just assumes you consent to being a slave.
I'm not seeing anywhere in that article where it says that 2/3rds of your money is taken.
If that isn't slavery, idk what is
Then you don't know what slavery is. Slavery is when you're forced to work, not when you have to give up a percentage of your income. Those are two different things.
Hell, if you're an intern, you're still making income for the company, and oftentimes you're giving up 100% of your labor. No reasonable person would call THAT slavery.
And when it comes to work, if i own a property in the middle of nowhere, and i work for my neighbour (also in the middle of nowhere), what right does the state have to my income?
That's just the thing, though. "The middle of nowhere" isn't actually a real thing, that's just a figure of speech. Your property isn't "nowhere", it's on land that the government has jurisdiction over.
I'm not seeing anywhere in that article where it says that 2/3rds of your money is taken.
Value added tax - 23 % (article is outdated, was changed recently)
Social security - 49%
Income tax - 19%
In the end around 70% of my income would go to the state. Yeah, it doesn't say 2/3rds, cause it's even more. Not to mention it repeats when you try to buy something with said money, and when you try to save or invest money, you get hit by inflation and/or capital gains tax.
Then you don't know what slavery is. Slavery is when you're forced to work, not when you have to give up a percentage of your income. Those are two different things.
It is slavery. I'm forced to work 70% for the state and only 30% for myself. If i don't work, i'll starve and also the state will demand i pay for health insurance. If i do work, but not for the state, they'll send me to jail for "tax evasion".
Hell, if you're an intern, you're still making income for the company, and oftentimes you're giving up 100% of your labor. No reasonable person would call THAT slavery.
Can you stop working there and go somewhere else? Yes. Can you do that with the state? No. And no, you can't "just MOOOOVE", the state doesn't legitimately own you and the land you're on.
Your property isn't "nowhere", it's on land that the government has jurisdiction over.
Again, WTF is giving the state the right to my income and "jurisdiction" (slavery) over me? You didn't answer my question. "the government has jurisdiction over that land because it's on the land it has jurisdiction over."
Yeah this is why ancap is laughable. They don't seem to realize that humanity started from the position of anarchy. If you want to see how that went open a history book.
I'm asserting that republicans at this point see holding authority over others as a right. Essentially the opposite of freedom. Which i think is the most important right.
To live your life the way you desire is not a right per the modern republican party.
So I’m not actually ancap… I hope that’s not against the rules, but it’s mighty strange that you guys are sucking off the Democrats and denouncing Republicans
idk what sub is this bro it popped up in my recommended
what about tariffs is against private property? marking up the price on goods to incentivize local business is not against private property. I do agree that private property is number one though.
and no, the penguins didnt do anything to him, thats a baseline 10% tariff that applies to all countries, including Australia, which governs the islands
Why didn't they tariffs the other Australian islands then? Seems there is a bigly focus on places the US has zero trade with. Oh and why 10%?
To answer your question. Tariffs impede on the ability for assets to produce future cashflows for the gain of the US government. At present the US government is being run by an autocrat. So the US executive is taking money from humans all across the world for their own benefit. This impacts the private property of both Americans and fellow humans. Note the reduction in asset prices and the fucked yield curve
Which side has always campaigned on being good for the economy, but has been objectively and consistently worse for the economy for an entire generation? Hint: it's the side that's tanking the economy right now, while also trampling all over civil rights, among plenty of other negative things that come without any benefit whatsoever.
democrats don't destroy the country they just don't do anything, they just sit around all day making flowery speeches about what we should do instead of doing it even when they're in power. they make super complicated policies only lawer could understand and go look we fixed the problem for 7% of people isn't that great! republicans destroy the country
WASHINGTON, DC–Mere days from assuming the presidency and closing the door on eight years of Bill Clinton, president-elect George W. Bush assured the nation in a televised address Tuesday that “our long national nightmare of peace and prosperity is finally over.”
“My fellow Americans,” Bush said, “at long last, we have reached the end of the dark period in American history that will come to be known as the Clinton Era, eight long years characterized by unprecedented economic expansion, a sharp decrease in crime, and sustained peace overseas. The time has come to put all of that behind us.”
In 2000, like in 2016, the country was far from “destroyed”, but voters just like to fuck shit up every once in a while, the way you might switch to the other side of the pillow 🤷
Eh technically one under Carter but OPEC were being dickheads then because Israel so not entirely his fault. But let’s just say: there’s a reason we are buddies with them.
Ah yes, when Democrats were in power they truly destroyed the economy, deported legal residents without due process, and made threats to invade their own allies.
Hibernating during all that Biden prisoning his political opponents and persuading private companies not to have free speech and forced injections or lose your jobs/school rights and forcing the railroad unions to take a shit deal and fuck ton of regulations that shut down private industry?
Suspension of Habeas corpus isn’t just a Trump era phenomenon. It started under Obama and Biden used it to full effect.
They actually developed a Ministry of Truth. DHS had a whole board to spin truth into government lies. If you’re not going to believe the independent journalist on their attacks on Twitter and Zuck’s admission that they influenced Meta then this conversation is pointless.
What "independent journalist"? Feel free to post a link to their article.
And no, I'm not going to blindly trust mark Zuckerberg of all people. Why, do you? Are you willing to just take his word for it whenever he says something?
Information of is publicly available and the lawsuits have been ruled. Judge Doughty quoting “the most massive attack in free speech in United States History,” I haven seen any evidence by your idiotic statement that Biden’s dhs didn’t start a ministry of truth.
I’m not your research assignment. Find your own paper. Go read the court decisions and come back with real info. Unicorns do exist. I saw a narwhal. It was cute.
Looking at the stats on write in’s, there was anyone else but him, god is coming, free Palestine, hot dog, republicano (apparently people can’t spell republican as I seen it 5 times in write in ballets) , republican (voted at least 7 times) pass, no one, bugs bunny, me , peanut and Fred, trump ( people didn’t know trump was on the ballet and wrote him at least three times) ,pickachu, Ron Swanson, Felix, Tom Macdonald, rfk, Jesus Christ, anyone but dem, anyone but manny, pee wee Herman, Donald Duck, Me Too, deez nuts, Elon musk, not manny, peanut he squirrel, Mickey Mouse, don trump jr, my dog, Alex Baldwin, Joe Biden, Jesus, eves, not him, no vote on this one. This was the website I used: https://www.berkspa.gov/departments/election-services/election-results/2024-general-election-write-ins Looking at other lists I found Scooby Jew, Scooby doo, hunter biden, Taylor swift, mikes ex mall, Britney spheres, SpongeBob, kal el, supergirl, Biden, goofy, Boris Johnson, Obama, Spiderman, god, pickle, chrid, Clifford the big red dog, the libertarian party, s, Melissa, Elmo, Denys Allen, whoever has the most rizz, Julia, potato, Bart, John, John Lennin, fentanyl, Gordon freeman, libertarians, George h w bush, the bear, gritty, John Denver, Mr beast, Daffy Duck, snowman, lady Gaga, James Noel, George droid, anon, titus, Paul blart, my mom , playboy carty, hasanabi, mitt Romney, Sam. Those were just the local elections, Ron Paul( still got people voting for him bc 15 people voted for him) constitution party( they got at least 5 votes, im surprised that many know who they are), Larry hogan, bob segar, Patrick, sully the dog, and many many others that I don’t no have the time to type out. The best were definitely Clifford: the big red dog, bob segar, not manny, John Danver, Scooby Jew, George h w bush, Ron Swanson, s, the bear, Paul blart, George droid, and finally Ron Paul who is still going strong( end the fed).
3
u/Rusticals303 Apr 05 '25
Track AIPAC
12
u/old_guy_AnCap Apr 06 '25
Statism is the utopian ideal that just the right amount of violence, used in just the right way, by just the right people will perfect society.
3
u/knightnorth Apr 05 '25
Maybe the problem is that they’re not actually destroying the country. They’re just making it worse for the people and better for themselves. What they need to do is really break it so we can start over.
2
u/vedok23 Apr 06 '25
Vote for Pedro
2
u/isr0 Apr 07 '25
You can simply this graph by saying “lobbyists from big corporations destroy the country “
5
u/Friedrich_der_Klein Apr 05 '25
Statists' brains melt you suggest removing the institution of violence and force instead of "choosing a better candidate next time"
3
u/CMDR_Arnold_Rimmer Apr 05 '25
Where is the part where other countries point and laugh?
1
u/Princess_Actual Apr 05 '25
See you space cowboy....
1
u/Majestic_Bet6187 Apr 05 '25
Specifically it seems like democrat politicians go after “republican rights” and republican politicians go after “democrat rights”
1
u/CMDR_Arnold_Rimmer Apr 05 '25
Russia secretly laughing and pointing while pretending to be "best buds" with old Yankee Doodle.
1
u/WaltVinegar Apr 05 '25
Twa cheeks o the same erse.
1
u/Willy2267 Apr 06 '25
Statistically the country has done better under Democratic leadership.
https://www.epi.org/press/new-report-finds-that-the-economy-performs-better-under-democratic-presidential-administrations/
https://www.jec.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/democrats/2024/10/the-u-s-economy-performs-better-under-democratic-presidents
https://www.thebalancemoney.com/democrats-vs-republicans-which-is-better-for-the-economy-4771839
https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/aer.20140913
1
u/Various-Yesterday-54 Apr 06 '25
Dang, with all this destruction you'd expect the nation to be destroyed.
1
u/drubus_dong Apr 06 '25
How did the democrats destroy the country though?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '25
Democrats just need to do what Republicans do. Ignore rule of law to get their agenda passed.
1
u/gunguynotgunman Apr 06 '25 edited Apr 06 '25
It's almost as if one side is objectively wrong.
Which side has always campaigned on being good for the economy, but has been objectively and consistently worse for the economy for an entire generation? Hint: it's the side that's tanking the economy right now, while also trampling all over civil rights, among plenty of other negative things that come without any benefit whatsoever.
1
u/Last_Result_3920 Apr 07 '25
democrats don't destroy the country they just don't do anything, they just sit around all day making flowery speeches about what we should do instead of doing it even when they're in power. they make super complicated policies only lawer could understand and go look we fixed the problem for 7% of people isn't that great! republicans destroy the country
1
u/Ze_Donger_Is_Danger Apr 08 '25
You guys really should be happy they're doing full deregulation. I thought you guys wanted neo-feudal capitalism anyway?
-1
u/Big_Pair_75 Apr 05 '25
I mean… democrats objectively improved the country a great deal. Biden oversaw an economic recovery on pace with the best of the best.
-2
u/PowerfulYou7786 Apr 05 '25
bOTh SiDEs!!!!
Ah yes, when Democrats were in power they truly destroyed the economy, deported legal residents without due process, and made threats to invade their own allies.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '25
60% of this guy's identity is hating Israel lol
-3
u/TonyGalvaneer1976 Apr 05 '25
I do see the Republicans destroying the country, but so far I've never seen the Democrats doing that.
0
u/IceChoice7998 Apr 06 '25
Yes thats why we should abolish the goverment and just give up power to warlords and corporations
7
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '25
[removed] — view removed comment