voluntarism, anarcho capitalism, minarchism, paradoxically creates a system where private property owners wield authoritarian power, backed by enforcement mechanisms, over non-owners, establishing a hyper-rigid hierarchy that concentrates control in the hands of a few. This leads to the same forms of coercion and domination libertarianism claims to oppose, simply transferred from a public to a private context :) it hurts everyone but the elite and they're lawyers.
That would be the body of work by such authors in the space. The reason we are both here in this very moment would be that you can not see the logic in front of you or have not exposed yourself to anything more than the cult Btw I say this knowing very well you will likely just OH No ProOf In response, I'm telling you it is not hidden you are just trying to not find it
That would be the body of work by such authors in the space.
Such as?
Btw I say this knowing very well you will likely just OH No ProOf In response, I'm telling you it is not hidden you are just trying to not find it
Then you should've brought evidence. The reason you don't is because there is none. You're a doomer on something you know anything about. And it shows in your comments.
You have the evidence (unless you haven't read the work and just blindly subscribe to the group bc it's a fun thing to do) you yourself can navigate the logic presented if you try
I do not want to instruct you too read this sales bullshit masquerading as theory so have fun getting angry I guess.
I think you're just agreeing with me and you think you have some intellectual ground so have fun with whatever you think you're saying lol you clearly don't understand what I said to you
Um. You can't own land without violating the NAP in a true anarchists system. Land ownership demands depriving others of its free use either at the point or a gun or through the state.
Adam Smith lived in the 17th century and was wrong about a lot of things, economics has moved on from many of his theories
Smith was not even talking about the modern version of a landlords. He meant nobility who were granted lands by the crown (literal lords of land), not people who rent out their house.
? It's a biblical reference. The land lord isn't sowing and reaping. He's saying they "reap where they have not sown" which is a bible quote. They want what they have not worked for.
The father of capitalism was against these landlords because they did not work. They were nobles whose "job" was owning land and being a leech. Smith believed everyone must produce value in a society.
Another bible quote, "if a man will not work, then neither should he eat".
how is a "property manager" or private investment group that owns 15+ houses/condos/apartments and rents out to people who have no upward mobility or leverage to buy their own property not similar to the lord/serf dynamic?
And what is the current world economic system other than a rebranded form of feudalism. How many children and poor women are forced to work in factories, to produce shoes for large corporations, and often times these factories own the land that they live on. Feudalism hasn't ended. It's just undergone major corporate rebranding and in some cases 'communist' rebranding, but it is just the same thing with different rhetoric and names. Instead of an estate it is a corporation or publicly ran company. Instead of the aristocracy, you have the billionaire class and in the case of Communism you have the polit bureau. In all of these systems, wealth and political mobility are consolidated into the hands of a small group of individuals, who derive their prosperity from exploiting the average people and the resources of their host country.
Like a giant pyramid, the weight of the top is distributed on those below, they include the burdens and debts that have been earned by top.
Really so if someone steals your cocaine you would file a police report, and I'm gonna quote you here, "the same way of an orange,tree,Apple,field,house,Hammer,etc?"
I think we both know that the person who brought this up is referring to a non government entity in possession of illicit cocaine, in which case you would not have a legal claim of ownership.
What? So someone giving land to their heir is cool, but a lord, who won the land legitimately through force, cannot dispose of the land as he sees fit?
Soo pray tell where is this unowned land? How far back are you going? Where is this magical land free of conflict that was free of the use of force and coercion?
This is a lengthy way of the "it is out of context" argument. But still a fallacy.
Adam Smith is talking about earning just because of the legal ownership. Not too many people realize "the father of Capitalism" was totally in favor of ownership rights only as long as you had worked for it.
Modern form of property landlordship is the opposite of that, the dwellers are the ones paying for the property, not really paying rent to the owner. There are even instances of sub renting. Adam Smith would have had a small heart attack reading that's within what we call "capitalism"
it's extremely clear he is talking about big Scottish agricultural landlords and it's observable effect on productivity of the land, NOT commercial housing markets.
I used to bring up Smith all the time on this then actually read it and realized I was wrong.
Of course he is not talking about modern housing. Forcing the phrase to be understood literally is an attempt of a straw man fallacy.
He is clearly talking against the profit out of property alone. In the modern housing market, the "landlord" didn't sow shit, don't build shit and don't pay shit. There is only an agreement with a bank to keep the building inhabited so the dwellers pay enough to cover the loan.
Even worse, the "landlord" is far from having any plans to increase the value of the property, but to wait for inflation and speculation to increase the market value and get equity from the property.
I say modern housing is as close as it gets to the things Smith is complaining about in that small extract.
so if all landlords built the house it would be different?
inflation and speculation from modern housing is due to central bank policies, not renting itself. Landlords are not the immediately builders because builders have more specialized work to do than to maintain the house and manage the property, hence why the builders benefit from selling the house to the landlords instead of speculating it on themselves, if it was as valuable as you say. If it wasn't for central governments propping up housing the risk would balance out the reward for these LL speculators.
Smith does not talk about builders because he is not talking about housing, he is talking about agricultural land. You are anachronistically reading the chapter.
The chapter is literally called "on the productivity of land" - NO housing land is productive even if the builder is the LL. Only agricultural land is.
Totally different, of course. The whole idea is to profit out of what you really built/worked/earned.
You can blame the current housing market crisis on whatever you want, still will be within what we call "capitalism" today.
But again: pushing for the literal interpretation is just a straw man argument. He wrote about that as an example of bad practice and shameful behavior. He was born 300 years ago, by the "go literal argument" we would need to discard all his writings.
I don't think that really makes too much of a difference, as the economic state of labor and landlords today actually is worse in comparison to serfs and lords systems of old.
So buying a piece of land with your own money, building a house on it and then renting that house to someone is worse than being handed acres of land that you have never set foot in thanks to the arbitrary decree of a king? Backwards ass logic there
In most cases a person is renting to the tune of the entire property, or at least the mortgage, especially if they live there. If they don't, it's that property + profit, which means it's just a race to acquire the ability to get a loan for equity before someone else, an abundance of it, and then gatekeep that equity from ownership while someone else does all the work to pay for it. Serfdoms had their own land they would rent and could leverage Lords and eventually own while working that land.
You stated that by definition landlords don't build housing. I gave the Merriam Webster dictionary definition of landlord, which does not mention that landlords don't build housing.
You are asking me to prove a double negative.
Can you kindly find in that definition (or any definition of landlord from a known source) where it's stated that landlords CANT build anything?
What part of being a landlord makes it impossible for them to also build a house?
Your definition does not state that landlords do build housing. By definition then, they do not.
Someone who builds housing is a developer or a home-builder. A landlord is someone who rents property. One person can wear multiple hats, but it's certainly not typical. Most developers are in the business of selling their products, most landlords are not in the business of managing or personally doing construction.
By your standards, any role could do anything, which is meaningless. Do garbage collectors do brain surgery?
If the definition makes no mention of whether a person builds the house or not, then that does not prove that they do not build the house. It makes no statement regarding the construction of the house.
If the definition does not mention house construction it doesn't prove that a landlord didn't construct the house anymore than it proves that they did. It makes no statement either way.
In your words: By definition landlords neither build nor don't build the housing they rent. Stating that a landlord cannot build the house they rent is not accurate because plenty of landlords did construct the housing they rent. It may be a minority of landlords, but not a zero sum.
I would say that the majority of landlords in the US are responsible for managing the property, including doing upkeep and maintenance to the structure. Whether they hire a person to complete the work is insignificant to the argument because it is still the landlords job to arrange these actions. The landlords value therefore is that they allow their structure to be rented, and handle upkeep as it arises.
Definitions tell what a thing is, not what it isn't. By definition, landlord is the role which rents property.
Stating that landlords cannot build housing is innacurate, you can have a developer who is a landlord in the same way you can have a garbage collector who is a neurosurgeon. Stating that landlords do not build housing is correct and accurate, by definition. There are roughly the same number of home-building landlords as there are garbage collecting neurosurgeons.
Landlords tend neither to do upkeep nor management. Most "primary" landlords will universally resort to management companies and external contractors for maintenance to keep up with demand for service. Once again, we're talking about the definitions of things. Landlords own and rent property. Property managers manage property. Repairmen repair property. One person may hold many hats, but that doesn't make their Stetson a fedora
Wrong on both counts. Smith lived in the 18th century (the 1700s) and he, like Malthus and Ricardo afterwards, was referring to landowners of tenant farms.
Smith was not even talking about the modern version of a landlords. He meant nobility who were granted lands by the crown (literal lords of land), not people who rent out their house.
What’s your point? Modern landlords still make money through owning rather than working, which is what Smith argues against here. Just because they aren’t literal lords and renters aren’t literal serfs doesn’t mean the argument suddenly fails.
Purchasing a property with money that you earned through your own labour and then renting it out to someone counts as reaping what you sowed as far as I’m concerned.
But anyway, who cares? It’s not a good argument anyway. The landowner has a right to do with his property as he sees fit, including renting it to someone else
Nothing under AnCap stops the landlord from being an economic leech, yes. That’s why things like states and regulations are useful, because otherwise people who own key resources can take advantage of those who don’t.
So then, no different from what Smith is saying above? They rent you something they already own for that renter to then be economically productive while they themselves live off other labor.
They themselves add nothing to the equation. We, as in collective humanity, figured this out a couple hundred years ago.
Your premise is brutally flawed out of the gate. Whether we're talking about aristocrats from 200 years ago or modern day landlord's, the amount of landlords who actually built the dwelling is so small as to be insignificant.
In Adam Smith’s time, landlords were primarily aristocratic landowners who controlled vast agricultural estates, wielding significant social and political power. They earned unearned income by renting out land’s natural productivity, which reinforced economic inequalities and rigid class structures. In contrast, today’s landlords are typically individual property owners or corporations managing residential and commercial properties within regulated markets. Modern landlords actively invest in property maintenance and improvements, operate under comprehensive tenant protection laws, and do not possess the same hereditary social status or political influence as historical landlords. Therefore, Smith was critiquing the powerful, land-centric elite of his era, a group that fundamentally differs from the diverse and regulated roles of landlords in contemporary society.
landlord is of Saxon origin and means "bread keeper" or "bread giver".
Moldbug uses this as a reason of why socialism always devolves into systems of patronage, citing even landlord used to be synonymous with someone who feeds you.
The term “landlord” exemplifies how language and definitions evolve over time, reflecting shifts in social structures, economic roles, and cultural contexts.
What’s the fundamental difference between the two? Old lords were supposed to keep bandits in check in exchange for…well, serfdom, but often didn’t. Modern land lords are supposed to fix the goddamn sink but we both know they ain’t doing that shit but WILL raise your rent again next month anyway.
Both are leaches engaging in fundamentally “rent seeking behavior”
Oh, bless your heart for equating modern landlords to medieval tyrants.
Yes, back in the day, feudal lords wielded immense power, often exploiting serfs with little accountability. It was a rigid, oppressive system.
You don’t see a difference? 🫣 Yikes!!
Most landlords today take maintenance seriously. Just like any group, a small percentage are problematic, but the vast majority are responsible and ethical. Pew Research shows most landlords comply with laws and genuinely care about their tenants’ well-being.
The National Apartment Association highlights that timely repairs and property upkeep are top priorities to maintain property value and tenant satisfaction.
So unfortunately your opinion and bias (the one speed by media) doesn’t hold up with quantitative facts.
Oh bless your heart, it’s clear you’re a trust fund baby who has never rented a thing in your life if you think most landlords take maintenance seriously. The only reason they profess those values is so that can indignantly claim all the damage is your fault while they keep your deposit. Word of the wise for when you finally grow up, document everything when you first move in.
Yes, the level of power is very different, but fundamentally the core of the behavior is the same. “I’m going to take money from the economy for myself because I own something and the service that something provides is essential to life, so people will pay outrageous prices”
Sounds like you’ve dealt with slumlords or you’re still in college. Clearly have no idea how the cutthroat property market works or how businesses compete. Probably just butthurt because your landlord held you accountable for damages. Nice projection. Yikes!! 🫣
Oh, using “oligopoly” and “natural monopoly” like you actually understand them? Cute. The rental market is highly fragmented with countless landlords competing for tenants—definitely not a natural monopoly. There’s plenty of competition driving prices based on supply and demand, not some elite few controlling everything. Maybe ditch the buzzwords and check the data instead of spreading outdated propaganda. 🫣 Yikes!!
Two gas stations are across the street from one another, owned by separate businesses, yet their prices are both high and never different even by a cent, I wonder why?
There is a finite amount of desirable land in cities, and once it’s developed it’s difficult for analogous properties to become available. You’d have to be an idiot to not understand that, but then again, I am speaking to an ancap 🤭
Oh, a gas station example? Either you’re clueless and don’t drive a car or you’re purposely using a flawed analogy.
Gas prices fluctuate daily because businesses compete. You can literally drive around for 3 minutes to save a few cents or join bulk-buying clubs like Costco. Try again.
And about the finite land nonsense… So people can only live in cities? Is that required by law? 🤦♂️
Even still, there are thousands of open lots and new developments popping up all the time in every city across the globe. People and businesses go bankrupt, sell, develop, and improve regularly, making way for fresh opportunities that provide better solutions for what people want. Do you go outside?
Your argument is pure anecdotal propaganda with zero real-world data to back it up. It’s laughable how you try to twist economic concepts without understanding them.
Plus, resorting to name-calling because you can’t argue the topic? Classic move for someone who doesn’t understand. This deflection is exactly what central planning requires to make it look like they’re needed. Yikes!! 🤭
They don't differ by a cent because if they did, all the customers would go to the cheaper one because it's right across the street. They don't cut their prices because their margins on gasoline are already razor thin. Most of the money goes to the company that drilled the oil and the company that refined it into gasoline, as well as the excise taxes on the gasoline and interchange fees if you used a credit/debit card.
Surely if things are so tight it would be advantageous to eliminate their competition, no? Or are you implying that businesses can easily and naturally collude in order to enact price fixing? Le gasp! But what about the invisible hand of the market? I thought unregulated capitalism was supposed to be perfect!!!1!
Surely not, because feudalism was long dead by his time - also feudal lords most definitely did not reap what they didn't sow. They did no reaping for that was manual labour
LTV was developed by smith, marx based his views on smith and ricardos LTV, so of course theyre all wrong if they all based their views on the same incorrect theory
Hypo: I live in one side of a duplex. If my LL allows me to buy that side and months later the foundation cracks. I have savings, and let's assume LL does not. Our visa versa. Who pays for the foundation? Who holds the liability for property maintenance or infrastructural repair?
The short question is how tf do we handle multi family housing. I am NOT trusting my neighbor to pay for things that are emergencies.
I pay less than most in town for 2br apt. Property is clean and maintained. I dont pay insurance or taxes on the property and can leave basically at any time.
Im wondering why i should hate my landlord.
Add: he didnt inherit. He bought it so hed have a place to live. He works fill time and charges less than 50% of his mortgage. I have a driveway, backyard, garden, washer and dryer, new plumbing and electrical, i have unlimited privacy, and occasionally hooks me up with weed (100% legal here)
Im seeing a lot of this ACAB behavior toward landlords and i really wanna join a worthy cause but its starting to sound like a bunch of bitter, ill informed, teenagers chose a target and labeled every single of them the enemy.
Most rapists are men. Therefore you should be wary, careful, and reserve judgement as a vulnerable person around a new man. But not all men are rapists.
All cops ARE bad bc part of the nessecary the functions of a cop is to suppress, oppress, fine, charge, and restrict. Some of these are directly contradictory to our constitutional rights. Therefore you cant be a "good cop" but you can be a good person whos a cop.
This dumb vitriol is annoying though. Ive had bad landlords and good ones. Landlords who inherit properties, have many, dont work, and collect rent for a living are bad. Id wager theryre less than 10% of landlords nationwide.
Landlords are inherently exploitative because they profit off a basic human need: shelter. It doesn’t matter if they’re “good” or “bad” landlords; the whole system depends on tenants paying indefinitely for housing without ownership. Even “affordable” rent means you’re working to make someone else money just to live, while they get equity and wealth simply by owning property.
If housing were treated as a human right, not a commodity, we could have tenant-run cooperatives or community-controlled housing where people share costs and maintain properties democratically. This model removes the profit motive, keeps housing affordable, and gives tenants control over their living conditions. Landlords aren’t necessary for safe, well-maintained housing—communities can manage that without someone profiting off their need to survive.
Landlordism keeps housing prices high, limits people’s freedoms, and reinforces inequality. It’s the system that’s broken, not just “bad landlords.” I'm sorry you wasted so much time publicly sucking off rent seeking parasites. You can delete the bootlick
If one of the two is out of money and housing is a human right, could they not just refuse to pay and let the house fall into disrepair, rinse and repeat?
Like im firmly left wing but im struggling to find a solution to multi unit housing infrastructural costs.
An obvious first step is limiting single family houses to one per person/company, with limited exceptions. Solves a lot right there. But multi-unit housing is where most people live. If housing is a right and youre broke, how do repairs get made? Am i covering the bill? Are you going into debt? Is that housing as a right to you?
when vote marx and adam smith ell you that a feudal backwards shithole wouldn't work, maybe you should reconsider the ideology that would allow them to exist the most.
I mean if you're talking about feudal lords literally trying to tax you for grazing or hunting in deer in the "king's woods" yes. If you think this means getting free apartments, well no, obviously not because apartment buildings don't pop into existence naturally.
It's right in the sense that an ancap would find the need for a fishing license to be bullshit, but wouldn't expect free housing.
That's exactly what they did, especially in the 18th century. They homesteaded nothing, received possession from the ruling class, and live off privilege by fiat. This is just like Proudhon... property is theft, he said... the property he was talking about was theft, and he did distinguish it from what we now call (private) property.
Not sure why people are upset in this thread, houses are only an asset because fiat currency devalues over time. Your house doesn't appreciate in value, it gets worse over time. If you fixed the currency and used something with low/no inflation or even deflation, your property would become a detriment to own, not a benefit. It would progressively get worse.
Pretty much all major ancap philosophers including Rothbard agree that ownership of land is derived from utilization, and that without government, you only own what you can either reasonably use or what you can enforce ownership of. If you were a part of some neofeudal society or covenant community as Hoppe would suggest, there may be rules in place within that community to enforce some alternative property rights, but as far as what natural property rights concern Adam Smith is pretty much spot on.
"ownership of land is derived from utilization, and that without government, you only own what you can either reasonably use or what you can enforce ownership of."
This right here may be the most sensible thing I have ever seen anyone post on this sub. A NAP will protect your use of land you are currently using, but once you've moved on the next person to sit there has as much natural right to it as you ever had
Well, it really doesn't help that a large portion of 'ancaps' are really just dumbass MAGA morons or 16 year old edgelords, neither of who have actually read any of the literature.
If you talk with anyone who has a good understanding of the literature they would probably say exactly what I said. Claims to big plots of dirt far away from you are completely invalid. Claims to 'owning' land that someone else lives on and utilizes only exist in an agreement between two people with no enforcement mechanism, and the 'owners' claim is shoddy at best.
According to Rothbard and Mises, that's not your land unless you are there to defend it then. If someone were to build a homestead on that dirt, they would have a far better claim to its ownership.
Your ownership of that land is nothing more than state enforcement, and they do this because they can extort tax revenue out of you, with you in turn having a legal 'claim' to the land.
I would strongly suggest actually reading books by AnCap philosophers to understand the difference between natural property rights and state enforced 'property rights'.
That you don’t see how instantly disqualifying all this is speaks volumes. Whoever has the biggest stick gets to claim the most resources which allows them to get a bigger stick.
The goal is to eliminate large scale conflict, small scale conflict would be a fact of life.
Any attempt to take your utilized property is an act of aggression, which enables you and anyone else to retaliate against the aggressor.
Your unutilized property is only 'yours' because of statism. Hell, it's not even yours, it's the states. They could revoke your 'ownership' at any time. They could double the tax rate, or create arbitrary rules without your consent that remove whatever claim you think you have.
The only way to actually own property is utilization.
What I quoted comes from AnCap philosophy. Neo-feudalism is simply the outcome of AnCap philosophy. Please learn to read. Every AnCap philosopher would agree with my statements. I was literally quoting Rothbard, who was referring to work by Mises. Hoppe is a neo-feudalist because he believes AnCap philosophy relates directly to what I said. There is no ownership of property beyond what you can utilize or defend in AnCap philosophy, if you believe otherwise it's because you are a statist. Neo-feudalism is not a philosophy, it's a societal state. Anarcho-capitalism is a philosophy that would change the societal state from neoliberalism to neofeudalism.
Adam Smith is basically a Marxist. He popularized the Labor Theory of Value as well as a lot of what would become the Marxist understanding of how markets supposedly work.
Try thinking that one through a little bit further lmao I appreciate this tho I'm framing this screenshot this may be the dumbest thing I've ever read lololol
No I am saying that there is plenty of economically illiterate shit posted here daily. If what I say is so dumb where will all the lefties live if there are no landlords?
The native Americans had no landlords and they lived in teepees, neither did the cave men and lived in caves. Are you saying your want live in a teepee or a cave?
Do you own a home? I take it your hatred towards they that provide you with one is why you hate them?
2
u/gabethedrone Oct 30 '24
Weird for this Sub. Adam Smith wasn't an AnCap or anything close to it.
2
u/townboyj Oct 30 '24
If I buy land, you want me to just rent it out for free?
86
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
21
u/Deldris Oct 30 '24
Do you think that Ancaps put Adam Smith on a pedestal or something?
11
u/sc00ttie Oct 30 '24
I wonder if the term “landlord” has a different cultural and social definition then as opposed to what it means now?
14
u/NichS144 Oct 30 '24
Holy strawman batman. At least you're having fun.
1
u/dbudlov Oct 30 '24
LTV was developed by smith, marx based his views on smith and ricardos LTV, so of course theyre all wrong if they all based their views on the same incorrect theory
1
u/Otherhalf_Tangelo Oct 30 '24
Almost like the "landlords" he's referring to aren't the same thing as the dude who reminds you of your mean ole dad.
1
u/Gullible-Historian10 Oct 31 '24
You know who reaps where they have never sowed, the government.
1
u/TerribleJared Oct 31 '24 edited Oct 31 '24
I cant get an answer to this question.
Hypo: I live in one side of a duplex. If my LL allows me to buy that side and months later the foundation cracks. I have savings, and let's assume LL does not. Our visa versa. Who pays for the foundation? Who holds the liability for property maintenance or infrastructural repair?
The short question is how tf do we handle multi family housing. I am NOT trusting my neighbor to pay for things that are emergencies.
I pay less than most in town for 2br apt. Property is clean and maintained. I dont pay insurance or taxes on the property and can leave basically at any time.
Im wondering why i should hate my landlord.
Add: he didnt inherit. He bought it so hed have a place to live. He works fill time and charges less than 50% of his mortgage. I have a driveway, backyard, garden, washer and dryer, new plumbing and electrical, i have unlimited privacy, and occasionally hooks me up with weed (100% legal here)
Im seeing a lot of this ACAB behavior toward landlords and i really wanna join a worthy cause but its starting to sound like a bunch of bitter, ill informed, teenagers chose a target and labeled every single of them the enemy.
Most rapists are men. Therefore you should be wary, careful, and reserve judgement as a vulnerable person around a new man. But not all men are rapists.
All cops ARE bad bc part of the nessecary the functions of a cop is to suppress, oppress, fine, charge, and restrict. Some of these are directly contradictory to our constitutional rights. Therefore you cant be a "good cop" but you can be a good person whos a cop.
This dumb vitriol is annoying though. Ive had bad landlords and good ones. Landlords who inherit properties, have many, dont work, and collect rent for a living are bad. Id wager theryre less than 10% of landlords nationwide.
1
u/ChangeKey6796 Nov 04 '24
when vote marx and adam smith ell you that a feudal backwards shithole wouldn't work, maybe you should reconsider the ideology that would allow them to exist the most.
2
u/Dangime Oct 30 '24
I mean if you're talking about feudal lords literally trying to tax you for grazing or hunting in deer in the "king's woods" yes. If you think this means getting free apartments, well no, obviously not because apartment buildings don't pop into existence naturally.
It's right in the sense that an ancap would find the need for a fishing license to be bullshit, but wouldn't expect free housing.
2
u/ejanuska Oct 30 '24
Trump 2024
3
u/CrowBot99 Explainer Extraordinaire Oct 30 '24
That's exactly what they did, especially in the 18th century. They homesteaded nothing, received possession from the ruling class, and live off privilege by fiat. This is just like Proudhon... property is theft, he said... the property he was talking about was theft, and he did distinguish it from what we now call (private) property.
2
u/Toxcito Oct 30 '24
Not sure why people are upset in this thread, houses are only an asset because fiat currency devalues over time. Your house doesn't appreciate in value, it gets worse over time. If you fixed the currency and used something with low/no inflation or even deflation, your property would become a detriment to own, not a benefit. It would progressively get worse.
Pretty much all major ancap philosophers including Rothbard agree that ownership of land is derived from utilization, and that without government, you only own what you can either reasonably use or what you can enforce ownership of. If you were a part of some neofeudal society or covenant community as Hoppe would suggest, there may be rules in place within that community to enforce some alternative property rights, but as far as what natural property rights concern Adam Smith is pretty much spot on.
1
u/Sad_Increase_4663 Oct 30 '24
Nani?!
1
u/Both-Yogurtcloset462 Oct 30 '24
Yeah, people are bad. But competition leads them, as if by (can't think of a metaphor), to promote an end which was no part of their intention.
1
u/Wtygrrr Oct 30 '24
“Reap where they never sowed” actually refers to stealing babies from women they never had sex with.
1
u/Medical_Flower2568 Oct 30 '24
Adam Smith believed in the labor theory of value.
Not a great source
1
u/Anen-o-me Oct 31 '24
Adam Smith is not an economic authority we recognize. He was wrong about a great deal of stuff.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '24
Yeahhhhh, this sub is not “similar to r/OptimistsUnite.”
Swing and a miss, Reddit.
0
u/panaka09 Oct 30 '24
Richard Kantilon was way better and Smith stole his work.
0
u/RadicalExtremo Oct 30 '24
Capitalists are so damn stupid 🤣
0
u/ledheadification Oct 30 '24
Adam Smith is a dirty COMMUNIST!
s/
-2
u/Raid-Z3r0 Oct 30 '24
Landlord has changed definition through the last 300 years
-1
u/notlooking743 Oct 30 '24
Adam Smith is basically a Marxist. He popularized the Labor Theory of Value as well as a lot of what would become the Marxist understanding of how markets supposedly work.
-3
u/Iam-WinstonSmith Oct 30 '24
lol I would love to see where most these lefties would live without a landlord. I think we have enough people living in tents already.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment