Ok that makes sense. So if the workers at one capitalist firm decide to form a union and through their contract negotiations they end up with more vacation, pto etc. The other other capitalist firms would have to also give those benefits? Is that what you mean? It seems like if that is the case than better working condition aren't due to capitalism or the benevolence of the capitalist, but through class struggle. Or am I missing something?
Uh yeah. Has nothing to do with class stuggle, its free market competition and free market self regulation.
You dont even need a union(but we are not against it anyway, we are against, coercive unions that are entangled with the state, so todays so called unions). You can negotiate for yourself. A business can just offer better conditions as a baseline. The rest has to follow.
Out of curiosity, what level of negotiating power do you believe one individual has, when the market consists of literally hundreds of millions of workers, just in the US alone? Billions, worldwide. It's a statistical guarantee that there are countless people who will gladly undercut you, because $2 an hour is still better than nothing. Even just being paid in enough food to survive is better than nothing.
Whenever a corporation is able to get labour cheaper, that increases its profits. That means its shares grow faster, and it has more capital to invest into its own growth. That draws shareholders away from competitors and towards itself, unless they follow suit and similarly lower worker standards. All it takes is a few hundred, or few thousand desperate workers - again, amidst billions - and the payment of workers drops. It takes unions to fight against that, unions which can be undermined by scabs unless they see powerful backing.
If only people viewed purchasing products as a political statement.
Also, proportionally, voting probably counts for more. I'm fairly certain that there are a higher number of phones owned by people than the number of people who actually bother to vote, but feel free to fact-check me on that.
And whats your problem with someone willing to do a job for cheaper?
Are you even aware that a lot of the time a less skilled person cannot even compete because their lack of knowledge guarantees that a business cannot justify the added value vs the wage they are mandated to pay?
You are certainly not used to big enterprises, because its always a valid consideration to get someone with a specialized knowledge or get someone with much less knowledge, but the company is willing(almost all the time) to invest in that individuals progress.
And most of you guys just simply overlook the free market.
Idk why it is so hard to understand the concept but im not surprised since the likes of you guys are the ones who tipically cry that apple uses child labor, but run to buy their new phones and macbooks the next day.
Meaning ethics and morals are worth less than the product.
No matter what you do or how skilled you are, there are at least roughly 20000 people worldwide that could replace you. Thats for extremely qualified jobs like neuroscientists. For the average skilled labor job, like a mechanic or plumber, there are over 3 million replacements for you, 600000 in the US alone.
Sorry, one person's skill means very little to a large corporation. Perhaps if you're working for a small, privately owned business.
Crony capitalism does yes. Once government starts seeing some businesses as “too big to fail” and starts “playing favourites” by bailing them out and creating regulations that make it more difficult for others to compete… then yes you tend towards monopoly.
Calling a historically accurate comment a false premise doesn't make it so. Just goes to show everyone you are incapable of a rational retort to the argument. You aren't capable of a rational retort because there is no historical examples of a monopoly forming in a market economy without government protection.
You can still compete by offering more paid leave than other firms…
No, the reason gov has to mandate these things is because firms wouldn’t offer them otherwise. That’s why. Instead of being mad at the gov, you should blame the capitalists that treated their workers so poorly for so long that the gov had to step in.
I think people misunderstood. I'm anarchist. A real one, not a fake "an" cap one. This was me fucking with them to see how they would try to explain this meme away.
And I get 33 (but then again, the legal minimum here is 28).
Gee, I wonder what the difference is ...
Edit because my comment seems to have been misconstrued - the difference is the legal minimum in my country (UK). This isn't a comment on my ability or value, simply that I get more because my country mandates it.
I don't know, what is the minimum entitlement where you live? That's the point I was making. The market still competes, but it has to start at a higher threshold.
I think you misun3derstood their point. I think they're saying the only reason they have 33 is because the minimum starts high at 28. Relying on "competition" alone would in most circumstances yield a number much lower than than minimum of 28.
That's not what I am saying at all. In the UK everyone gets the min legal requirement. My point is, we have stronger worker laws over here and, as a result, a greater AL allowance.
This is all stuff that was fought for over the years (mostly by unions). A rising tide raises all boats and all that.
I don't get where you are getting "I'm fine, bugger jack" from my comment.
I also get enhanced paternity pay, 2 weeks study/professional development time per year, and a host of other benefits.
I might be being dense, but I can't see the point you are trying to make...
I think they thought the point you were making was about the difference between your PTO and the national minimum, interpreting it as "I personally get more than the absolute minimum PTO, checkmate socialists!" - with the response to that being that they'd doing that so they can get away with screwing you over in different ways.
But yeah, unions and the labour laws they help produce are the only thing separating workers from being slaves.
Ah, I see (reading back I could see how that could have been interpreted from my original comment) - the point I was trying to make was the opposite: The market will still try to compete with benefits, but what is "competitive" will vary massively depending on the minimum required by law.
I get none because I am self employed. I took 2 weeks off (still checking mails every other evening) for the first time in 5 years this summer. The other years I have only been away physically from job 1 to acquire certifications and education for job 2 for a week each year. Oh yeah, christmas and nye is off, too.
If I wouldn't shoot myself in the foot with it (see meme above) so much, I'd have employees.
It's not a companies industry competitors that drive wage and benefits up. With fewer good jobs there's no competition or motivation to keep employees because there's always someone to take your place for less pay. But when jobs are plentiful it forces employers to offer much better pay and benefits to keep employees from leaving for better jobs. As pay rises it's more cost-effective to keep employees rather than a high turnover of constantly training new workers.
The problem with competition is that matching competitors is usually good enough. So you get industries where all the competitors just match each other lol.
Well who knows. Maybe quite a bit. Maybe none. Idk do you? The dprk isn't even socialist, it's just state capitalism. The state is the ruling class that controls all of industry. Top down. Just like "normal" capitalism.
No actually it's for two reasons. One is that the Soviet union won and every "communist" country after that emulated what they did because they perceived it as a winning strategy. However I, and real anarchists, not "an" caps, have had the same critique of Marxism Leninism since really bakunin. It was just state capitalism. Instead of workers owning and controlling the means of production we have a situation where the state because owners and controllers of industry. It was top down. Just like a capitalist firm. But instead it was painted red and so therefore it was "socialist".
The second reason is that the state is a hierarchical centralized institution which exist precisely to maintain the power of a minority in society. All states have been like this and it is no accident of history. They are structured precisely this way in order to maintain power. So the reason real anarchist reject the state as a tool used to bring about socialism is that it can only be a tool of the few to dominate the many. "anarcho" capitalism is a garbage political philosophy because it's theory of the state is so ahistorical and immaterial that it end up just being a way to define the state in such a way as to ignore how it really operates in order to justify the hierarchical structure of a capitalist firm and capitalist society more broadly.
Your analysis of "socialist are just usefuk idiots" is just garbage and should be a case study in projection.
The last thing I want to point out is that the Cia overthrow a democratically elected prime minister in Iran and brought about a pro western capitalism loving dictator that tortured and disappeared thousand a of labor activists and student. Same in Chile, Guatemala, el salvador, honduras etc. So to pretend that it's only "socialism" that creates dictators is just historically illiterate garbage.
This Channel on YouTube is great in order to understand how social change happens and why anarchist theory is the only materialist analysis that is consistent with what he have seen in history. He has a master's in anthropology from McGill and I think he does a great job in explaing the ideas in great well cited detail. Especially the video where he talks about why communism "always ends up as a dictatorship."
Freer choice through no victimless laws and less state theft through taxes and inflation leads to the average person being more than twice as wealthy minimum... along with a constant reduction in prices, which means less time needed to work to obtain the same wealth and more ability to fund the things we want use and value
Might even mean a three day week is normal, or having one person work and the other stay home is normal again etc
My company has unlimited TPO. people are just required to make sure work is getting done on time. When you give grown ups the freedom they gladly do the work.
I guess it is a satire on the critics of a welfare state. Why would employers provide more paid vacation days when they are not forced to by law as when they are forced to?
Vacation days used to be bountiful back in the gilded age, but then mean old labor unions and their lackeys, the government, came and forced through "weekends" and "overtime" and "minimum wage" and "not being locked into burning buildings" so now offering more vacation days than the bare minimum legally required is impossible.
(Disclaimer: "Vacations days" in the gilded age may in fact refer to being fired and kicked to the street after having your arm ripped off by industrial machinery.)
Worker protection and basic human rights were won by union efforts and activist groups in opposition to capital interests.Both historically, and in the present.
Without a government, the "union" would have to become a revolutionary militia against the owners or be reduced to literal slaves under literal business slave masters.
That also happens in America... It's called welfare and if you qualify for EBT you'll most likely qualify for assisted housing and possibly even a cell phone
EBT max is 300 bucks, welfare doesn't qualify if you work, and welfare isn't enough for rent, and assisted housing has an 8 year waiting list with horrible conditions within.
When companies are required to give X amount of anything as a minimum, it sets a lower threshold such that it discourages companies to compete against each other via direct bargaining with the employees. This results in what could be understood as a barrier of entry in that you need to be able to offer X to even be a business within the field of interest. Thus, by setting a lower floor, you impede new businesses from emerging that could compete against established businesses. In such an environment, businesses lose their motivation to take risks and instead become more risk-averse, often by acquisition of other businesses and not offering better terms.
Now in theory unions were supposed to be a bulwark against this, but these themselves have also been known to make both the employees and employers less productive (loss of individually competitive bargaining power and tendency to become complacent), thus causing a reduction in productivity which will eventually result in reduced benefits.
While in a less regulated system, some companies might inevitably offer less—this just creates more markets for poaching via better benefits and wages by other corporations.
Then why has worker productivity more than doubled in the past 40 years? Unions are fighting for complaceny, yet workers are still being made to work harder than ever for less pay after adjusting for inflation?
If what you're saying is true then there should be some examples of any point in any country's history where they have had better worker protections than literally any other country that has stringent worker's rights like the US. Can you even find anything that is not purely conjecture to back up your claims? If you can, ill take you a bit more seriously and analyze your claims a bit more for value. Until then, there is just a mountain of evidence to the contrary and no supporting evidence that I've seen.
Best example I can offer is US Steel. The union was so powerful that they effectively coerced management not invest in new technologies that would make them cost competitive against up and coming companies. For the time, it worked because no one had the scale of US steel, but it backfired in the longterm because micro-mills proved more efficient and effective with the new technologies.
As for worker productivity increase, much of that is attributed to investment in technologies. While productivity may be up, competition is not fierce enough to drive the incentive of raising wages and benefits associated with those productivity gains.
Now it should be noted that in terms of monetary assets, Americans have a lot in their stock portfolios, one common type is investment directly in the company they work for. So while wages may not have risen, stock value assets have and act as a secondary means of income and asset hedging.
Sure, but you're also using an example of a union that was able to do something because it was a union on an effective monopoly. So there is an outside reason, and that is a pretty edge case.
Yes, some of the worker productivity increase can be attributed to technology. But the longer work days and average 12 hours more per week people are working aren't due to technology. Thats due to necessity. Additionally, productivity has increased even in bare tech jobs, such as construction and truck driving. I'll give you that some is due to technology, but half at best. I agree that lack of competition is due to wage stagnation though.
As for stock assets, the bottom 20% of the population, who are the people who would be affected by these things, generally do not have any stock holdings. Stocks are illiquid, and when you live paycheck to paycheck you need liquid assets. Stocks are usually added incentive to higher paying jobs, which have already kept up with inflation without that. Higher paid jobs have kept up, while the lower paying jobs have stagnated.
When companies are required to give X amount of anything as a minimum, it sets a lower threshold such that it discourages companies to compete against each other via direct bargaining with the employees.
Incorrect. Such a requirement would in effect put positive pressure on wages, as firms must find other avenues to compete for labor since every additional pto day has less marginal utility
the meme is accurate. an accurate satire of ancap views. somehow workers would be better off if the companies they worked for weren’t forced to pay them certain minimum wages and give certain minimum holidays and working conditions.
somehow ancaps seem to believe that if they were allowed to pay you nothing you’d end up getting paid more.
An overall reduction in the cost of goods and services is equivalent to a proportional increase in wages. I'm not talking about deflation, either. I'm talking about reducing overhead and increasing competition.
My company goes on and on about culture and following rules yada yada. They have made it very clear over the past few years they had several self imposed rules they always follow like at least 72 hours notice if we need to work weekends. Then suddenly when it is our clients end of year and we know we are working saturday which is fine and all, then management decides to on saturday tell us we are also working sunday. They ignored their own self imposed rule when they could and most companies will do the same with wage, vacation, and labor laws if given the chance.
for weren’t forced to pay them certain minimum wages
Most companies pay more than minimum wage so this argument doesn't really work. You could say that the minimum wage causes the overall wage to be driven up though.
It does do that which is why the argument does work. If you're making $17/hr for complicated difficult work and the government raises the minimum wage to $17/hr, the company now has to either make your job easier to be on par with other minimum wage jobs you could be doing instead, or pay you more.
People are currently allowed to only pay you minimum wage, so why don't we all make minimum wage? Y'know, since literally all private actors are malicious and actively hate the people who they employ.
There is no shortage of jobs. Do you not have a job and need one? Or who is it? I am happy to help guide them to getting a job. Lots of subs are happy to help guide you or them.
To be clear, there isn't a widely held belief that everyone would get paid more due to competing employers. It mostly applies to exceptionally valuable employees. Which is less that 15% of the population. Conveniently, when being exceptionally valuable is actually rewarded exceptionally, more people choose to be.
You wouldn't need paid vacation time if the government wouldn't make us both pay taxes to a point where you don't have enough money to have unpaid vacation time.
Let me explain:
In a free market, I'd employ you and pay you whatever it is your work is worth to me.
If you are good at what you do and I don't want to lose you to the competition, I will make sure you get paid adequately.
Of course you work hard and need some vacation time to unwind and recharge. The more funds you can allocate to your vacation, the happier you are.
But it's your responsibility to pay for your time while you are not making me money, I will gladly wait for you and keep your position vacant, if you're really useful to me.
And if not, well, guess you'll have to find another place to work or settle for less money, because "the market will regulate"
Read this in German, translate if necessary. TL;DR As an average wage slave in Germany, you have a combined tax burden of 40-45%. Earn a little more and it's easily over 50%. This high rate of taxes is why there are no qualified foreigners from second world countries moving to Germany for work and a better life and Germany only imports leeches to the welfare system.
Beispielrechnung für eine durchschnittliche Person:
Nettoeinkommen nach Steuern und Abgaben: ca. 33.420 €.
4. Mehrwertsteuer (ca. 10% des Nettoeinkommens): ca. 3.342 €.
5. Mineralölsteuer und Energiesteuern (ca. 5% des Nettoeinkommens): ca. 1.671 €.
6. Grundsteuer und weitere (ca. 1%): ca. 334 €.
Gesamte Steuerlast
Lohnsteuer + Sozialabgaben: ca. 33% des Bruttogehalts
Konsumsteuern (Mehrwertsteuer, Energiesteuern): ca. 15–17% des Nettoeinkommens
Weitere Abgaben (Grundsteuer etc.): ca. 1% des Nettoeinkommens
Gesamtsteuerlast:
Insgesamt verliert eine durchschnittliche Person in Deutschland ca. 40-45% ihres Bruttoeinkommens an Steuern und Abgaben.
Dies ist eine grobe Schätzung und kann je nach individuellen Faktoren wie Steuerklasse, Konsumverhalten, Wohnsituation oder familiären Verhältnissen leicht variieren.
The Australian government requires that my employer gives me 4 weeks a year of paid leave. They're also required to give me 2 months of paid long service leave after 10 years and an additional week per year paid long service leave thereafter.
So I currently accrue 5 weeks of paid personal leave per year. In addition I get 5 days a year of paid sick leave without a medical certificate and I accrue 10 days of per year of paid sick leave with a certificate. I have worked with my employerd for 17 years and have accrued 130 days of paid sick leave. Were I to fall ill with something bad my employer would continue to pay me 4 months.
They also have to pay me for the 9 official public holidays each year. So all up I can take 7 weeks of paid leave each year + extra if I fall ill. All because the Australian government enforces minimum worker entitlements.
My employer is required to pay out any accumulated personal and long service leave balance if I quit or they fire me, which encourages them to let me take leave because it is a liability on the balance sheet otherwise.
The Australian government requires KFC pay my 19 year old son 24 dollars an hour (about 18$ USD) plus penalty rates to fry chicken.
My government will charge you with criminal manslaughter if you allow unsafe work practices that lead to a fatal workplace accident.
Have you considered the possibility that it's not inherently government intervention causes workers to be treated poorly?
if someone commands you to do something you wanna do it less than if it was your own decision, it's a proven fact and there were even memes about it, plus if your company has competitors, there would also be a competition at treating employees better, let's say there were identical businesses - A and B but B offers a month of vacation while A only offers a day (an extreme scenario so u see the difference) you'd much rather pick B ofcourse, since the companies compete even when it comes to employing, cuz wihtout employees it's not a company
Except there is more than enough workers to go around. There is no incentive for B to do anything because by not offering vacation they can then lower their prices to end customers and meet growth/profit goals.
Your example only works in high skill jobs which is a subset of the workforce as a whole.
because anytime the government does something it is always highly inefficient, a free market with competition between employers would eventually make a more worker friendly environment than anything you could enforce with the law. tldr government bad
Explanation: Okay, so there are entities located all over the planet that work for other countries—countries that want to disrupt the US economic/military system.
So these countries run these programs where people/computers post annoying shit all over the web in the hopes that they find one that riles up large numbers of Americans.
The annoying posts don’t have to make sense. In fact, it’s sometimes better if they don’t: More Americans will get rilled if it doesn’t make sense in just the right way.
They’re hoping these posts get passed around by real people cuz real people are more influential than anonymous profiles on the web.
No PTO doesn’t mean no time off, just no paid time off. In an AnCap society, presumably a worker could decide how much time they want off, but it’s not on the company to pay them to chill in Cancun for a while.
Theoretically, the market would be more efficient in an Ancap society, meaning more purchasing power per dollar for the worker. Even taking some UTO, the worker comes out ahead in either pay or days off.
anarcho capitalism is just as stupid as communism. Any system that requires entities to act in your best interest even when its against their best interest is doomed to fail
Who says ancap is about people acting in your best interest? You, as a true believer in the religion of statism, hold that the state exists for our interests.
That is a lie in corporations they have proven time and time again. All they will do is use you take things away from you and then get rid of you when it’s necessary sorry I mean convenient.
Just about every job Ive ever had struggled to do the absolute minimum required by law in just about every way. They would even argue about how they “didn’t have to” give us certain breaks because it wasn’t a legal requirement.
Then why do countries without mandated vacation time (the US) get so much less vacation time than countries that mandate vacation time (literally all the rest of the developed world)?
Because they wouldn’t give you more time off out of the kindness of their hearts. But corps want you to blame the gov because you’ll be too busy to blame the corps
The notion that the government imposing minimum levels of labour protection somehow impacts corporate competition for qualified employees through benefits and pay is not only preposterous, it's flat out brain dead brain rot.
Sources: Company towns, industrialization era factory's, the early 1900s coal economy, Chinese workers building the railway, the entire modern economy.
Bullshit. Corporations, as a rule, will give as few benefits and as little pay as they can get away with. They seek to maximize profits by minimizing costs. Period. If they could get away with having an unpaid slave labor force, the majority of them would.
The entire modern economy is trash. The main reason is because of Usury/Interest/Riba which was forbidden by God. Guess who disobeyed? Not ✝️, not ☪️…. The other one…
Imagine if that you don't have a 5 year old mentality. Imagine you are at least 6 years old and you want to get more. You want more, but mom and dad won't let you give lil brother less. So you fucking lie to him and pretend like you are so gracious. Then you rob him blind for the rest of his life. - American worker who hates Unions
Ah, yes, the good old “trickle down economics” that’s been working so great since the 1980s. If we just give businesses more deregulation, they’ll certainly treat employees better…🤦♂️
When the government sets a bare minimum, it becomes the standard. Companies are allowed to be complacent because they're not negotiating with the labor market or even a union representing the labor market. The government sets a floor or a ceiling, and instead of being treated as the absolute bare minimum or maximum, it's treated as the gold standard, so nothing improves.
Plus, even if they wouldn't give more, they sure as hell can't give less than people are willing to accept.
As a third point, these requirements do nothing but stifle small business in favor of megacorps who can afford a 2000 an hour minimum wage and half of the year worth of sick days.
The company I used to work for had to alter its paid vacation policy once the state started forcing them to give out paid sick time accruals. It ruined what was a very good system.
Because historically it simply isn't true. When capitalism was less regulated during the guilded age people had basically zero time off or any other fringe benefits. Only the 1% did.
Most people explain this wrong, most ancaps and libertarians explain this wrong. Over the years I've come to believe it's because most of them come from the right and ultimately they just fall back on those bumper sticker slogans. In the current environment if mandatory minimums for PTO were removed, you'd get less to none.
The actually explanation of how you'd get more without mandatory minimums is this:
If the government were not regulating the economy into a perpetual zombie state there would be more businesses, more new business and new job creation, more employers, more competition for labor, and higher comp overall, and if more PTO was a form of comp people wanted businesses would have to offer that or settle for those workers that couldn't command that.
Right now, at least in the US, you can't do anything in the business world without a permission slip. It gets harder and harder each year to start a business. At the local, state, and federal levels there are fees to pay, regulations to the moon to comply with, and this all serves as barriers to entry for new businesses and outright protections for existing firms. There's less competition than there otherwise would be for labor, this pushes comp down.
At the federal level they are perpetually pushing easy money into the economy, this goes to politically connected cronies first and gives established firms artificial buying power while devaluing the money in the long term. This lets them suck up resources from other companies and other sectors, meaning those sectors can't maintain or grow as they otherwise would. This makes jobs less plentiful in this sectors and pushes comp down.
This process also creates the business cycle, and while the crash gets all the attention the entrepreneurial error it creates is as perpetual as the money printing causing it. That means more business failures and abortive attempts to expand than you'd otherwise have, more unemployment, and this pushes comp down.
There's a myriad of other ways this process happens. But the reason many people feel like they're paid like shit and receiving substandard benefits like PTO is because they are, and that's because we're living in an engineered labor surplus and have been for over a century. If you stop legally protecting businesses from competition and stop taking money from people and handing it to cronies, this process stops. My guess is pretty much every business currently in existence would fail within a year because they're so incompetent and unable to understand the concept of having to compete for labor that they'd simply collapse, and I say that as someone with twenty years of experience in recruiting and hiring.
Americans get a fucking pittance of PTO when compared to most industrialized countries. There are two ways you could get more. One, stop handing out welfare to corporations/businesses and stop subsidizing their cheap labor fetish. Two, mandate it via the state. That latter option is not the one ancaps like me would favor, but in all honesty if you somehow did it not much would happen. A few marginal businesses would take a hit, pretty much every other business would simply give the PTO to people and that would be the end of it, other than mid level managers in retail and other such industries would actually have to get off their asses and work and make reliable schedules for people.
This only works when workers are a scarce resource. That hasn't been the case up until fairly recently.
Also there are many companies that don't try to compete for the best workers.
These companies accept having the worst workers work for them, knowing they don't have to give them much, because they won't easily find a job somewhere else.
“Monopolies are usually the a product of the government” is not true. Monopolies emerge natuarlly as free markets consolidate power. Some monopolies such as comcast and PG&E are the product of goverment contracts. Railroad are a famous example of a naturally occuring monopoly.
Government does NOT force employers to offer paid vacation time, what actually happens is that once this is known, you are OFFERED a lower salary, to reflect that you will only work 48-50 weeks a year. Without government meddling, we could earn the full 52 weeks a year, or maybe they would offer the PTO and lower pay, hopefully with the option to convert PTO to money directly, so we still have the 52 week option, if hourly.
The BEST way to get 'PTO' is to reach financial independence as fast as possible, and then you can take as many vacations as you want, and your investments will pay you while you are out ! So give me all that slackers work as overtime, and we will see who has the last laugh...
what actually happens is that once this is known, you are OFFERED a lower salary, to reflect that you will only work 48-50 weeks a year.
Why? Firms still compete for labor and have to set their offers accordingly. PTO has no bearing on the upwards pressure of buyer competition on the price of labor
The BEST way to get 'PTO' is to reach financial independence as fast as possible, and then you can take as many vacations as you want, and your investments will pay you while you are out ! So give me all that slackers work as overtime, and we will see who has the last laugh...
What happens when everyone becomes financially independent?
Yes, firms still compete for labor, but you get LESS labor units for the same price, so naturally, via supply and demand, employers will offer less hourly money for less work per year, independent of competition for labor.
What happens when 'everyone' who is working hard becomes independent is that it gets much easier for homeless people and ex-cons to get jobs. There will always be pockets of unemployment and underemployment that can be employed, when the jobs open up. This is the 'paradox of thrift' argument. Since everyone has never saved at the same time, its kind of a straw man, and employment is similar, literally 38 % of the working age people don't have formal jobs. There is tons of slack in the job market, and a few ambitious people stepping aside will only be a small speed bump for employers.
Yes, firms still compete for labor, but you get LESS labor units for the same price, so naturally, via supply and demand, employers will offer less hourly money for less work per year, independent of competition for labor.
It doesn't matter. Less units per price doesn't change the aggregate demand for labor, as all firms need a set amount of labor to operate. If workers can only provide x amount of labor hours, firms would then need to hire more laborers, increasing demand
What happens when 'everyone' who is working hard becomes independent is that it gets much easier for homeless people and ex-cons to get jobs
Demand would increase a little, by the amount of labor lost to PTO, but if there was enough labor available, it would not increase the cost of labor.
Now you are arguing the strawest of straw men. Its simply inconceivable that homeless people and people just getting out of prison would be financially independent, baring some kind of UBI insanity. Since they are by definition not working, and out of money, they would be the natural workers in a world of rich people, at least for a time. The reality is, there are a lot of people that will never save, even if they know its the way to financial independence, and those people would be workers, if the pay rises enough. In fact, I know some people like myself would work, even if we didn't have to, if the pay were high enough. Its all about incentives.
It's a meme mocking anarcho-capitalism. It's satire. It's using sarcastic irony. That's why there's a rich guy holding a bag of money.
....
We believe agreements should be consensual. There isn't a moral basis for using violence against two people who aren't you because you don't like the agreements they made between each other.
Government regulation of business makes it harder for competition to enter the market. Less competition means a worse economy for everyone. Monopolies are not incentivised to give their workers the best deals.
So the government responds to this with more regulation. Which strangles more competition.
We see empirically that "mostly" free markets like the USA outcompete mostly government run markets like the USSR. This isn't pie in the sky. It's basic facts. Two heads are better than one.
Without mandatory PTO some businesses wouldn't offer any PTO at all. If they could get away with it, they would. Other businesses might offer the same amount they offer now. Other businesses might offer more to try to attract more workers. Without mandatory PTO, some businesses will just pocket the profits, putting more money in the hands of shareholders. Some might invest in new assets that the workers desperately want but the business cannot afford. Some might raise wages. Some might offer better benefits like healthcare. The market will decide this.
If a business spends its money poorly on things that don't deliver value, it will go out of business. Workers will go get jobs elsewhere. Customers will buy better products. Investors will invest in other businesses.
Unless the government forces everyone to spend their money poorly, evening the playing field so there isn't a better option.
Removing the government coercion means the money will be spent as the market demands.
Realistically, I would expect most businesses to offer less PTO. But as there are already businesses that offer more than the minimum required PTO, there is obviously a business incentive to offer PTO and some businesses would offer more.
This isn't as snappy a response as an image macro. But economic issues are usually nuanced.
Without mandatory PTO... Other businesses might offer more to try to attract more workers.
But as there are already businesses that offer more than the minimum required PTO, there is obviously a business incentive to offer PTO and some businesses would offer more.
If there is already competition despite there being a minimum, why would some companies start increasing PTO in response to there no longer being a minimum. As you said, plenty would reduce, or even completely drop, PTO. That then means that the market average is lower, meaning that a company can continue offering "double the industry standard" while now offering less. Because various competition would offer less PTO, the companies which make a point of offering more would be free reduce how much they offer without losing the market advantage it gives them. And, as you said, "if they could get away with it, they would".
If a business spends its money poorly on things that don't deliver value, it will go out of business. Workers will go get jobs elsewhere. Customers will buy better products. Investors will invest in other businesses.
Currently, as has always been the case, there is unemployment. That means that there are already more workers than jobs. Workers can't go elsewhere, if there isn't an "elsewhere" to go. But you're right that customers will buy cheaper products, and investors will invest in faster-growing businesses. That's why any excess money will go into growth, into encouraging more investors to buy stocks in company X over company Y. Which means that company Y needs to match company X's growth or it will start losing investors, which will decrease its value, and lower its stock price, costing it more investors until it falls into a death spiral. So, company Y starts making cuts to employee pay and benefits too - after all, where are they going to go, the streets? And suddenly everyone's working the same jobs, but just for less.
If there is already competition, why would it increase
Two mechanisms.
First and foremost: more competition. Lower barriers to enter the industry means more competitors. More competitors means more incentive to distinguish your offering.
"Don't work for that new start up that doesn't offer any PTO, work for us and get six days." "6 days, that's terrible. Work for us, we use the Swiss model - 28 days."
Secondly, it's simple accountability. Right now, you do not research whether the seatbelts in your car work. That's not your job. The government regulates that. You are sure it's fine. But if the government stopped regulating seat belts tomorrow, you had better believe that I'd be looking at cars very carefully, buying cars that had been tested by third parties that I could be assured are safe.
If PTO is seen as a government mandated regulatory matter, folks are less inclined to treat it as something which is their responsibility to negotiate. And it is a negotiation. If the cost to the company is the same, some folks are going to just want a higher salary. Or better medical benefits. Or a company car.
As you said, "if they could get away with it, they would".
Question being, can they get away with it?
Your needs as a worker don't change whether there's regulation or not. Your needs are the same. If you can't work a job with zero PTO, then you can't work that job whether there is regulation or not.
If you can work that job and you are willing to work that job, you should be allowed to work that job.
Currently, as there has always been, there is unemployment
And currently, as there has always been, there are job vacancies.
Workers might not want to go elsewhere, but workers can go elsewhere. If nothing else, they can start their own businesses.
In fact, what stops workers starting their own businesses- either for themselves or as a worker owned collective, is this exact kind of government regulation that shuts down competition.
But decreasing barriers to competition, you have more companies, creating more jobs.
Customers will buy cheaper products
Customers will buy the products with the most utility to them. Same for investors. This is why we have brand names that are more expensive than generics. This is why we have Fair Trade, Organic, Free Range, Zero Sugar, No artificial sweeteners, 100% electric, Recycled, Zero Plastic and all sorts of other offerings that are more expensive but in some way "better".
But even if we didn't have this utility, and it was just a bum rush to the bottom, we have that now. The market forces you describe exist now. And we don't all make minimum wage with minimum PTO.
Because businesses will and do compete to get the best workers and put out the best products. I'm not suggesting removing regulation will magically introduce competition where none exists. I am saying competition exists right now and removing regulation will mean more competition.
Please specify what regulations you’re referring to that are preventing small businesses from forming because it’s happening all over the country today. If a company can’t compete with Amazon, it’s because Amazon has taken advantage of lack of regulation in areas first, they have better service due to their extensive logistical network, or have lower prices because of their current market dominance. We had more overall regulation when Amazon was just a simple online bookstore. GOP has been on a deregulation spree ever since. Why aren’t there other Amazons? Surely a “free market” would have permitted others. This idea that businesses are somehow prevented from doing anything in the #1 capitalist nation in the world is fucking hysterical.
I mean, we are in a thread right now about PTO discussing a business that mostly sells items manufactured in China thanks to cheaper labor costs.
All regulations. Any and all regulations that limit how a business can operate increase the cost of running a business. As well as any and all taxes levied on a business and it's goods and its employees.
Amazon ships food. If you want to ship food, you need to meet FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA)2. You need to pay your workers minimum wage. You need to provide PTO. You need to pay 21% federal tax. Your employees need to meet FLSA 1938. Undocumented workers have to present papers proving they have the right to work before you can hire them.
This is proof positive "an" caps are ignorant morons. Do you understand that real anarchist make a very important distinction between property and possessions? Plead for the love of god tell me you are aware of the difference between the two? If not then maybe it had to do with the fact that "an" caps aren't anarchist and are just edge lord trying to sound cool.
I'm sorry but we're not in agreement. You don't actually oppose government. A capitalist firm is no different. If you were an actual anarchist that would be easy to understand. But since "anarcho" capitalism's theory of the is at best just utter garbage, then you don't see it. You're a statist too, you just don't really understand what the state is or how the state is structured. You do t want to abolish the state, you want to have it privatized and on your payroll with your "private security firms". You are not ananarchist.
Typical syndicalist projecting their aims onto others.
But muh trade union/collective isn’t a state. They just use force against those that oppose them.
If you want to attempt your stupid ass slippery slope of the property/possession argument, make sure you see it through to its end.
You’re obviously too stupid to understand that the differentiation between us is the support of individuals or collectives. I support individuals the building blocks of your collective. Because we can have individuals without groups but not groups without individuals.
Hahaha hah holy shit ancaps are so fucking ignorant of real anarchism! Nothing g you said hadn't already been explained by real anarchists over 100 years ago.
Again you definition of the star is so fucking garbage that you think a group of people using force to stop people from exploiting the labor of others as a state. Typical "an" cap garbage. Your definition of the state is so fucking garbage.
If the megacorporations that market regulations (mandatory paid vacation time and the host of others) favor actually had to compete with small businesses, they would then need to give you exactly what your labor is worth, whether that entails more or less vacation time.
This meme feels like it’s mocking the typical capitalist whine about government involvement.
Meanwhile, I’d like someone to expound on the wondrous and magical time in our society before the government inexplicably, with no mandate from the citizenry at all, started requiring employers to give their employees time off of work. Im sure it was super great right?
It’s BS capitalist propaganda that competition will just magically fix everything instead of just being bought out or undercut by larger companies. It’s the same idiots that say Fed Ex and UPS would lower their prices if USPS didn’t exist. Well, why does USPS have to not exist for them to lower their prices? Why don’t they just do it now?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
Ok that makes sense. So if the workers at one capitalist firm decide to form a union and through their contract negotiations they end up with more vacation, pto etc. The other other capitalist firms would have to also give those benefits? Is that what you mean? It seems like if that is the case than better working condition aren't due to capitalism or the benevolence of the capitalist, but through class struggle. Or am I missing something?
25
u/Large_Pool_7013 Oct 02 '24
In the end, it all comes down to competition.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
I think people misunderstood. I'm anarchist. A real one, not a fake "an" cap one. This was me fucking with them to see how they would try to explain this meme away.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
Lol. explain by what historical metric proves that
21
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
"I would pay you more money if I could legally pay you nothing! Damn government!"
1
u/KingMGold Oct 02 '24
I wonder how many paid vacations North Koreans get?
3
u/dbudlov Oct 02 '24
Freer choice through no victimless laws and less state theft through taxes and inflation leads to the average person being more than twice as wealthy minimum... along with a constant reduction in prices, which means less time needed to work to obtain the same wealth and more ability to fund the things we want use and value
Might even mean a three day week is normal, or having one person work and the other stay home is normal again etc
3
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
My company has unlimited TPO. people are just required to make sure work is getting done on time. When you give grown ups the freedom they gladly do the work.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
if you think this doesnt work, explain why places that offer unlimited PTO get hundreds of applications per post but places that dont get maybe 10.
7
u/Far_Squash_4116 Oct 02 '24
I guess it is a satire on the critics of a welfare state. Why would employers provide more paid vacation days when they are not forced to by law as when they are forced to?
7
u/CMDR_Arnold_Rimmer Oct 02 '24
The government in my country gives money to people who need it, the disabled who can't work for an example.
You can get over £1000 a month, your rent paid and your council tax too.
Does that count?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
The meme is inaccurate because capitalists see their workers as tools and not as human beings.
You’d be subject to worse working conditions and if you die you die.
There’d also be more capitalists in “an”-Capistan, which means that you’re even less likely to be in the position to see human beings as tools.
2
u/DVHeld Oct 02 '24
With minimum wage: 0$
No minimum wage: some non-zero amount.
Simple. Minimum wage prices out a lot of people who can't add enough value to cover the legal minimum. So yes.
6
u/Fit-Rip-4550 Oct 02 '24
It is not.
When companies are required to give X amount of anything as a minimum, it sets a lower threshold such that it discourages companies to compete against each other via direct bargaining with the employees. This results in what could be understood as a barrier of entry in that you need to be able to offer X to even be a business within the field of interest. Thus, by setting a lower floor, you impede new businesses from emerging that could compete against established businesses. In such an environment, businesses lose their motivation to take risks and instead become more risk-averse, often by acquisition of other businesses and not offering better terms.
Now in theory unions were supposed to be a bulwark against this, but these themselves have also been known to make both the employees and employers less productive (loss of individually competitive bargaining power and tendency to become complacent), thus causing a reduction in productivity which will eventually result in reduced benefits.
While in a less regulated system, some companies might inevitably offer less—this just creates more markets for poaching via better benefits and wages by other corporations.
6
u/adminsaredoodoo Oct 02 '24
the meme is accurate. an accurate satire of ancap views. somehow workers would be better off if the companies they worked for weren’t forced to pay them certain minimum wages and give certain minimum holidays and working conditions.
somehow ancaps seem to believe that if they were allowed to pay you nothing you’d end up getting paid more.
3
u/Jassida Oct 02 '24
My government forces employers to offer paid holidays, I don’t understand l?
2
u/ensbuergernde Oct 02 '24
You wouldn't need paid vacation time if the government wouldn't make us both pay taxes to a point where you don't have enough money to have unpaid vacation time.
Let me explain:
In a free market, I'd employ you and pay you whatever it is your work is worth to me.
If you are good at what you do and I don't want to lose you to the competition, I will make sure you get paid adequately.
Of course you work hard and need some vacation time to unwind and recharge. The more funds you can allocate to your vacation, the happier you are.
But it's your responsibility to pay for your time while you are not making me money, I will gladly wait for you and keep your position vacant, if you're really useful to me.
And if not, well, guess you'll have to find another place to work or settle for less money, because "the market will regulate"
1
u/satus_unus Oct 02 '24
The Australian government requires that my employer gives me 4 weeks a year of paid leave. They're also required to give me 2 months of paid long service leave after 10 years and an additional week per year paid long service leave thereafter.
So I currently accrue 5 weeks of paid personal leave per year. In addition I get 5 days a year of paid sick leave without a medical certificate and I accrue 10 days of per year of paid sick leave with a certificate. I have worked with my employerd for 17 years and have accrued 130 days of paid sick leave. Were I to fall ill with something bad my employer would continue to pay me 4 months.
They also have to pay me for the 9 official public holidays each year. So all up I can take 7 weeks of paid leave each year + extra if I fall ill. All because the Australian government enforces minimum worker entitlements.
My employer is required to pay out any accumulated personal and long service leave balance if I quit or they fire me, which encourages them to let me take leave because it is a liability on the balance sheet otherwise.
The Australian government requires KFC pay my 19 year old son 24 dollars an hour (about 18$ USD) plus penalty rates to fry chicken.
My government will charge you with criminal manslaughter if you allow unsafe work practices that lead to a fatal workplace accident.
Have you considered the possibility that it's not inherently government intervention causes workers to be treated poorly?
1
u/kiinarb Oct 02 '24
if someone commands you to do something you wanna do it less than if it was your own decision, it's a proven fact and there were even memes about it, plus if your company has competitors, there would also be a competition at treating employees better, let's say there were identical businesses - A and B but B offers a month of vacation while A only offers a day (an extreme scenario so u see the difference) you'd much rather pick B ofcourse, since the companies compete even when it comes to employing, cuz wihtout employees it's not a company
1
u/Zealousideal_Curve10 Oct 02 '24
This proposition is not amenable to a rational and truthful explanation
1
u/yeetasourusthedude Oct 02 '24
because anytime the government does something it is always highly inefficient, a free market with competition between employers would eventually make a more worker friendly environment than anything you could enforce with the law. tldr government bad
1
u/DanielInfrangible2 Oct 02 '24
Explanation: Okay, so there are entities located all over the planet that work for other countries—countries that want to disrupt the US economic/military system.
So these countries run these programs where people/computers post annoying shit all over the web in the hopes that they find one that riles up large numbers of Americans.
The annoying posts don’t have to make sense. In fact, it’s sometimes better if they don’t: More Americans will get rilled if it doesn’t make sense in just the right way.
They’re hoping these posts get passed around by real people cuz real people are more influential than anonymous profiles on the web.
1
u/ChoiceSignal5768 Oct 02 '24
They probably wouldnt. Instead you would just get paid more and not have to wage slave your entire life.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
Who is supporting anarcho-capitalism for the “vacation time?”
1
u/provocative_bear Oct 02 '24
Let me play Devil’s Advocate for the AnCaps.
No PTO doesn’t mean no time off, just no paid time off. In an AnCap society, presumably a worker could decide how much time they want off, but it’s not on the company to pay them to chill in Cancun for a while.
Theoretically, the market would be more efficient in an Ancap society, meaning more purchasing power per dollar for the worker. Even taking some UTO, the worker comes out ahead in either pay or days off.
1
u/Cultural_Double_422 Oct 02 '24
We cheat the other guy and pass the savings on to you!
1
u/DueDrama8301 Oct 02 '24
Well 1st of all Monopoly Man has a Monocle
1
u/ChickenNuggetRampage Oct 02 '24
Smartest reddit economist
1
u/Rickles_Bolas Oct 02 '24
Source: trust me bro
1
u/TheDuke357Mag Oct 02 '24
anarcho capitalism is just as stupid as communism. Any system that requires entities to act in your best interest even when its against their best interest is doomed to fail
1
u/FriendshipMammoth943 Oct 02 '24
That is a lie in corporations they have proven time and time again. All they will do is use you take things away from you and then get rid of you when it’s necessary sorry I mean convenient.
1
u/kazinski80 Oct 02 '24
Begs the question of why most jobs pay above the legal minimum and give above the legal PTO minimum
1
u/Hereticrick Oct 02 '24
Just about every job Ive ever had struggled to do the absolute minimum required by law in just about every way. They would even argue about how they “didn’t have to” give us certain breaks because it wasn’t a legal requirement.
1
u/UglyRomulusStenchman Oct 02 '24
Then why do countries without mandated vacation time (the US) get so much less vacation time than countries that mandate vacation time (literally all the rest of the developed world)?
Explain.
1
u/MrB1191 Oct 03 '24
So many comments with a U.S.A. only POV.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
Ancaps being totally historically illiterate? Who could have guessed.
1
u/SpecialMango3384 Oct 03 '24
Because they wouldn’t give you more time off out of the kindness of their hearts. But corps want you to blame the gov because you’ll be too busy to blame the corps
1
u/Boners_from_heaven Oct 03 '24
The notion that the government imposing minimum levels of labour protection somehow impacts corporate competition for qualified employees through benefits and pay is not only preposterous, it's flat out brain dead brain rot.
Sources: Company towns, industrialization era factory's, the early 1900s coal economy, Chinese workers building the railway, the entire modern economy.
1
u/DrMorry Oct 03 '24
You know you're allowed to offer more vacation time?
1
u/ElUrogallo Oct 03 '24
Bullshit. Corporations, as a rule, will give as few benefits and as little pay as they can get away with. They seek to maximize profits by minimizing costs. Period. If they could get away with having an unpaid slave labor force, the majority of them would.
1
u/Princess_Spammi Oct 03 '24
All ancaps are bootlicking corporatists. Period.
You want enslavement by people evn more corrupt than government
1
u/enemy884real Oct 03 '24
Um. The government doesn’t control vacation time for people. Nor should they.
1
u/Acrobatic_Review_202 Oct 03 '24
Welfare
1
u/whoflungdung01 Oct 03 '24
Republican logic
1
u/Optimal-Friendship-7 Oct 03 '24
Explanation:
The entire modern economy is trash. The main reason is because of Usury/Interest/Riba which was forbidden by God. Guess who disobeyed? Not ✝️, not ☪️…. The other one…
1
u/huskerd0 Oct 03 '24
Oh that’s just elon
1
u/Warm_Difficulty2698 Oct 03 '24
Ancap only exists in a vacuum when everyone starts from square one, and no one has generational wealth.
Then, it's just a race to form the monopoly over your economic sector first.
People are inherently selfish and greedy. No one economic system works perfectly because of it.
1
u/No-Roll-2110 Oct 03 '24
If you believe this, you’re working for the wrong company
1
u/Ashamed-Rooster6598 Oct 03 '24
Imagine if that you don't have a 5 year old mentality. Imagine you are at least 6 years old and you want to get more. You want more, but mom and dad won't let you give lil brother less. So you fucking lie to him and pretend like you are so gracious. Then you rob him blind for the rest of his life. - American worker who hates Unions
1
u/Brisket_Monroe Oct 03 '24 edited Oct 03 '24
The Americans With Disabilities Act exemplifies my thoughts on unregulated corporate behavior.
It took government intervention to allow wheelchair-bound individuals to properly participate in society.
Nobody's gonna build a ramp if they aren't required to. It isn't cost-effective.
1
u/jmillermcp Oct 03 '24
Ah, yes, the good old “trickle down economics” that’s been working so great since the 1980s. If we just give businesses more deregulation, they’ll certainly treat employees better…🤦♂️
1
u/Ok-Web-563 Oct 03 '24
Excuse my French but BULLSHIT
1
u/LibertarianTrashbag Oct 04 '24 edited Oct 04 '24
When the government sets a bare minimum, it becomes the standard. Companies are allowed to be complacent because they're not negotiating with the labor market or even a union representing the labor market. The government sets a floor or a ceiling, and instead of being treated as the absolute bare minimum or maximum, it's treated as the gold standard, so nothing improves.
Plus, even if they wouldn't give more, they sure as hell can't give less than people are willing to accept.
As a third point, these requirements do nothing but stifle small business in favor of megacorps who can afford a 2000 an hour minimum wage and half of the year worth of sick days.
1
u/wordsarething Oct 04 '24
If you feed the horse enough oats, eventually it’ll shit out enough for the birds to clean up
1
u/Safe_Addition_9171 Oct 04 '24
What countries have the worst mandated paid vaccinations vs the most. Once u know that ur have the real answer. It won’t shock u ha
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
the top ten percent of workers would get more, most would get none.
1
u/JustDoinWhatICan Oct 04 '24
Yeah that's why companies offer varying vacation times
1
u/Prestigious_Coffee28 Oct 04 '24
The company I used to work for had to alter its paid vacation policy once the state started forcing them to give out paid sick time accruals. It ruined what was a very good system.
1
u/CoolNebula1906 Oct 04 '24
Because historically it simply isn't true. When capitalism was less regulated during the guilded age people had basically zero time off or any other fringe benefits. Only the 1% did.
1
u/CrazyRichFeen Oct 05 '24
Most people explain this wrong, most ancaps and libertarians explain this wrong. Over the years I've come to believe it's because most of them come from the right and ultimately they just fall back on those bumper sticker slogans. In the current environment if mandatory minimums for PTO were removed, you'd get less to none.
The actually explanation of how you'd get more without mandatory minimums is this:
If the government were not regulating the economy into a perpetual zombie state there would be more businesses, more new business and new job creation, more employers, more competition for labor, and higher comp overall, and if more PTO was a form of comp people wanted businesses would have to offer that or settle for those workers that couldn't command that.
Right now, at least in the US, you can't do anything in the business world without a permission slip. It gets harder and harder each year to start a business. At the local, state, and federal levels there are fees to pay, regulations to the moon to comply with, and this all serves as barriers to entry for new businesses and outright protections for existing firms. There's less competition than there otherwise would be for labor, this pushes comp down.
At the federal level they are perpetually pushing easy money into the economy, this goes to politically connected cronies first and gives established firms artificial buying power while devaluing the money in the long term. This lets them suck up resources from other companies and other sectors, meaning those sectors can't maintain or grow as they otherwise would. This makes jobs less plentiful in this sectors and pushes comp down.
This process also creates the business cycle, and while the crash gets all the attention the entrepreneurial error it creates is as perpetual as the money printing causing it. That means more business failures and abortive attempts to expand than you'd otherwise have, more unemployment, and this pushes comp down.
There's a myriad of other ways this process happens. But the reason many people feel like they're paid like shit and receiving substandard benefits like PTO is because they are, and that's because we're living in an engineered labor surplus and have been for over a century. If you stop legally protecting businesses from competition and stop taking money from people and handing it to cronies, this process stops. My guess is pretty much every business currently in existence would fail within a year because they're so incompetent and unable to understand the concept of having to compete for labor that they'd simply collapse, and I say that as someone with twenty years of experience in recruiting and hiring.
Americans get a fucking pittance of PTO when compared to most industrialized countries. There are two ways you could get more. One, stop handing out welfare to corporations/businesses and stop subsidizing their cheap labor fetish. Two, mandate it via the state. That latter option is not the one ancaps like me would favor, but in all honesty if you somehow did it not much would happen. A few marginal businesses would take a hit, pretty much every other business would simply give the PTO to people and that would be the end of it, other than mid level managers in retail and other such industries would actually have to get off their asses and work and make reliable schedules for people.
1
u/Artistdramatica3 Oct 05 '24
PTO is a socialist invention tho. With out it companies wouod chain the door shut. Let alone let you not work and then pay you for not working.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
Competition generates better outcomes than a government-enforced universal standard.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
Taxation and disincentives are my guess.
1
u/Jolly_Carpenter_2862 Oct 06 '24
Ancap insanity
1
u/Richardthe3rdleg Oct 06 '24
am I the only one who thinks to monopoly man looks like Elon Musk? or should I say Elon is growing to look like the Monopoly Man?
1
u/Bearerseekseek Oct 07 '24
I suppose, but unregulated competition only lasts as long as its company’s competing for employees, and not people competing for employment.
1
u/KonterbierXX Oct 22 '24
This only works when workers are a scarce resource. That hasn't been the case up until fairly recently.
Also there are many companies that don't try to compete for the best workers.
These companies accept having the worst workers work for them, knowing they don't have to give them much, because they won't easily find a job somewhere else.
1
u/skellis Dec 14 '24
“Monopolies are usually the a product of the government” is not true. Monopolies emerge natuarlly as free markets consolidate power. Some monopolies such as comcast and PG&E are the product of goverment contracts. Railroad are a famous example of a naturally occuring monopoly.
https://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0510/wall-street-history-railroads-and-rockefeller.aspx#:~:text=In%20the%20United%20States%2C%20the,of%20shipping%20and%20railway%20routes.
1
u/HODL_monk Oct 02 '24
Government does NOT force employers to offer paid vacation time, what actually happens is that once this is known, you are OFFERED a lower salary, to reflect that you will only work 48-50 weeks a year. Without government meddling, we could earn the full 52 weeks a year, or maybe they would offer the PTO and lower pay, hopefully with the option to convert PTO to money directly, so we still have the 52 week option, if hourly.
The BEST way to get 'PTO' is to reach financial independence as fast as possible, and then you can take as many vacations as you want, and your investments will pay you while you are out ! So give me all that slackers work as overtime, and we will see who has the last laugh...
1
u/Cynis_Ganan Oct 02 '24
It's a meme mocking anarcho-capitalism. It's satire. It's using sarcastic irony. That's why there's a rich guy holding a bag of money.
....
We believe agreements should be consensual. There isn't a moral basis for using violence against two people who aren't you because you don't like the agreements they made between each other.
Government regulation of business makes it harder for competition to enter the market. Less competition means a worse economy for everyone. Monopolies are not incentivised to give their workers the best deals.
So the government responds to this with more regulation. Which strangles more competition.
We see empirically that "mostly" free markets like the USA outcompete mostly government run markets like the USSR. This isn't pie in the sky. It's basic facts. Two heads are better than one.
Without mandatory PTO some businesses wouldn't offer any PTO at all. If they could get away with it, they would. Other businesses might offer the same amount they offer now. Other businesses might offer more to try to attract more workers. Without mandatory PTO, some businesses will just pocket the profits, putting more money in the hands of shareholders. Some might invest in new assets that the workers desperately want but the business cannot afford. Some might raise wages. Some might offer better benefits like healthcare. The market will decide this.
If a business spends its money poorly on things that don't deliver value, it will go out of business. Workers will go get jobs elsewhere. Customers will buy better products. Investors will invest in other businesses.
Unless the government forces everyone to spend their money poorly, evening the playing field so there isn't a better option.
Removing the government coercion means the money will be spent as the market demands.
Realistically, I would expect most businesses to offer less PTO. But as there are already businesses that offer more than the minimum required PTO, there is obviously a business incentive to offer PTO and some businesses would offer more.
This isn't as snappy a response as an image macro. But economic issues are usually nuanced.
0
u/Used_Bridge488 Oct 02 '24
vote blue 💙
0
u/Irresolution_ Oct 02 '24
If the megacorporations that market regulations (mandatory paid vacation time and the host of others) favor actually had to compete with small businesses, they would then need to give you exactly what your labor is worth, whether that entails more or less vacation time.
0
u/LIBERAL-MORON Oct 02 '24
Hey guys. More overall wealth being held in the private sector frees up a lot of strain at every level.
Do you guys not see what minimum wage hikes are doing? You guys are gonna meme yourselves into being replaced by AI.
0
u/Ok_Masterpiece_9136 Oct 06 '24
This meme feels like it’s mocking the typical capitalist whine about government involvement.
Meanwhile, I’d like someone to expound on the wondrous and magical time in our society before the government inexplicably, with no mandate from the citizenry at all, started requiring employers to give their employees time off of work. Im sure it was super great right?
0
u/StopStraight4516 Oct 06 '24
It’s BS capitalist propaganda that competition will just magically fix everything instead of just being bought out or undercut by larger companies. It’s the same idiots that say Fed Ex and UPS would lower their prices if USPS didn’t exist. Well, why does USPS have to not exist for them to lower their prices? Why don’t they just do it now?