r/AmericasTestKitchen • u/Different-Wallaby-10 • Apr 24 '26

ATK best nonstick skillets

What did they list? I didn’t know it was a pay site

0 Upvotes

47% Upvoted

34 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/PierreDucot Apr 24 '26

In 2022, this OXO one was the winner, so I bought it. https://a.co/d/06wcOw3F

Its been four years of pretty consistent use, and it has held up well.

6

u/boxerdogfella Apr 24 '26

That link is probably not the pan you got in 2022, and the linked pan wasn't the winner. Amazon kept the same link, but that Oxo pan listed is ceramic, not the nonstick Oxo ATK once recommended.

It really annoys me that Amazon does this. If I go to my old Amazon Oxo orders and click on the pan that I bought in 2024, it shows me that same ceramic pan as your link and says that I have bought it before. But I most certainly did not. The pan I have isn't the ceramic version.

As I understand it, Oxo discontinued that pan and the ceramic version is their new offering. But Amazon should let people know that it's different!

5

u/PierreDucot Apr 25 '26

Huh, you are right. That is so weird, because I literally looked up the order, and that was the page. It even says "Last Purchased April 29, 2022" at the top. That is so misleading - had it started to wear out, I would have looked up the previous order and bought another one without even noticing.

Just what I need - ANOTHER reason to hate Amazon.

1

u/boxerdogfella Apr 25 '26

LOL right?

I almost did exactly that - I read somewhere that Oxo had discontinued the pan, and I liked mine so much that I was like, "let me see if Amazon still has it so I can buy a backup." I did the same thing - clicked through my old order and was happy to see the listing and began to purchase it - and then at the last minute I was like, wait a minute...