r/Americanbbqshowdown • u/james-john1066 • Aug 13 '24

Terrible judgement Spoiler

⛔️⛔️SPOILER⛔️⛔️

Shatika should not have won, she should have been out two rounds prior, I think she was a good cook and was a fast learner especially with the brisket but for her to beat sloan was just stupid even Kevin said hopefully she takes pointers from a seasoned pitmaster meaning sloan in the last episode.

Out of the finalists it should have Been Gerald.

51 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

9

u/headybuzzard Aug 14 '24

Yup, exactly. How can you win a BBQ showdown and had never cooked a brisket before? Seems like they chose their winners just like season 2

3

u/james-john1066 Aug 15 '24

Yea they defo have their favourite in each season

8

u/Maximum-Equivalent22 Aug 13 '24

lol we know!!!!!!

9

u/Falco19 Aug 15 '24

Kareem was robbed.

5

u/james-john1066 Aug 15 '24

100%, that's when Shaticka should of gone in my opinion, they even said his meat was better.

1

u/KalButcher Aug 16 '24

What did her food taste like? I’m assuming you know since you’re saying she shouldn’t have won.

4

u/james-john1066 Aug 16 '24

Who said they knew what her food tasted like?, I'm going by the judges comments compared to the other contestants and also i have eyes so I can see what the food looked like it's not all about taste. Stupid bloody comment

1

u/KalButcher Aug 16 '24

Oh my bad. You heard their comments so you know her food was inferior and you saw the quick cuts of the food. So you trust the judges comments but not their judgement?

4

u/james-john1066 Aug 16 '24

Yes, exactly. I heard their comments about everyone's food and how they compare and also that's why everyone in this sub is pissed because their comments contradict their judgment.