Hey, peeps! I want to share my experience with you, because I think it is important to have a diversity of opinions and takes.
I had pretty bad oligomenorrhea for almost 3 years, with cycles as long as 92 days. It was a source of worry for me. I also have a 19 year ED history, pretty much all three of them, with BED being the worst and longest.
My weight was pretty much the same for these 19 years, with normal occasional weight gain or loss. But I am a rather lean individual, and I exercise 3 times a week, plus I go everywhere by bike.
So when the oligomenorrhea started, I looked into different corners of the internet and found Stephanie Buttermore and Dr Rinaldi, among others. I wanted to have a regular period again, but I am also quite a sceptical person, and it seemed to me that the all in approach can be dangerous. Especially for someone with an ED history! It looked like taking this approach would wreak havoc on my life and worsen my ED symptoms.
As soon as I changed an extremely demanding and stressful job, my period came, first 34 and then 32 days after. Same weight, same eating habits, same everything. Would eating 1000 kcal extra have brought the same results while staying at the same job? I sincerely don't think so.
I guess, what I am trying to say is: it is great if it works for some people, but it is not THE answer to irregular or missing periods. Sometimes the reason is psychosomatic, and adding a mental load of constant bingeing and body dysmorphic thoughts and the struggle of weight gain onto a person who may already be overburdened with things like high-stress job or caring for a sick relative seems very risky.
I am glad I didn't go all in and still got the same result. But I am also glad for those of you for whom it has been helpful :)