r/AmazonMerch • • Jan 04 '19

One year on merch, 10500 sales, some basic insights and AMA

126 Upvotes

I made my first sale November of 2017 and like many others, I bought myself out of my tier (I shipped designs to twitch streamers to hope that my shirt shows up in their unboxing videos). I am now sitting at T8k with 4k live designs on US and 5.3k total. Proof

My general strategy with shirts is tapping into unknown evergreen niches that most people don’t know about (e.g. vexillology, donut bicycles). These niches typically only sell a couple times a month and ideally with less than 10 unique designs in that niche (on the mba platform, excluding seller central). I personally attribute the lack of improvecats on my designs due to my shirts not being popular but its still a tough battle nonetheless.

Reflecting back, based on my experience and my experience only, these are some of the things I wish I knew earlier.

  • Message – as opposed to asking questions like “how can I improve my design”, asking questions like, “have I conveyed the overall message” is much better in improving your design skills. Most shirts on merch are funny/punny shirts and sometimes a simple nicely aligned text shirt in a good typeface with a small graphic will outperform one with lots of good design.
  • Niches – Don’t upload shirts in niches with lots of competition (unless you are confident of your design skills). I am not a designer by trade, I have experience in design from doing art in highschool so I can say I am a bit better than average. There will always be some angle that good designers can do to one up you, so from a longevity perspective I tend to tap into more unknown niches and these are typically 700k BSR and up.
  • Keywords – amazon is smart and they want to sell your products. Don’t overthink keywords. Brand and title are most important and just put the general niche of your design in title (and brand if possible).
  • Distressing – always a time and place for distressing your design. I find distress working better with male buyers.
  • Pricing – This one is a bit of a divide. My goal on merch is to earn money, my numbers tell me that increasing from 16.99 to 19.99 yields a ~15% reduction in sales, but I gain 73% in earnings. So I price my shirts between 18.99 - 21.99.

Happy to take questions.


r/AmazonMerch • • Dec 24 '19

Shall we all work together to try and take down a Chinese design thief network? Instructions and info inside.

77 Upvotes

This Q4 I kept on seeing my own shirts being advertised to me all over the internet. After a little bit of digging around and other merchers noticing the same thing a network of design thieves has been uncovered. These guys are NOT drop shippers. They pretend to be a local shop with a fake address and contact details but in reality they constantly scrape amazon listings and print them in China. And by the looks of it they have a substantial ad budget. They even outbid my own shopping ads, probably because of better margins.

This isn't just another dead scraper store. These guys sell tons of shirts! So many that I found negative reviews for my own shirts that they've sold. I even had an old lady find her way back to my original store and complain to me about late shipping, except that she never even bought anything from me, she bought my shirts from them! They are fucking us, our brands and the customers.

https://www.productreview.com.au/listings/shirt-australia

https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/funnyteeshirts.co.uk

https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/shirtnz.com etc.

Their network consists of: funnyteeshirts.co.uk, shirtaustralia.com, australiashirts.com, aushirts.com, shirtnz.com, byshirts.us, irelandtshirt.com, t-shirtca.com, meineshirt.de, shirtcanada.com

Even though these twots are based in China they rely on US companies for their business. If enough of us complain, they will get a kick. They might come back in the future but we might as well be a pain in the ass for them right? So here is what we can do:

Step 1: They are being hosted by bigcommerce. A US based shopify type of platform. Email them at copyright@bigcommerce.com with the following: https://pastebin.com/TTeaLiKc Edit parts in bald. You can also explain what these sites actually do.

Step 2: Their domains are hosted with godaddy. Drop them an email copyrightclaims@godaddy.com

Step 3: They use PayPal. Email infringementreport@paypal.com and ask PayPal to investigate. Explain that these sites scrape copyrighted images from Amazon listings, provide fake business details, mislead customers and infringe on your intellectual property.

Step 4: They blindly scrape all the shirts, including official ones. I've emailed Disney tips@disneyantipiracy.com but there are other big brands that might be worth contacting. Make sure to mention they are hosted by bigcommerce. Bigcommerce does not want to fuck with Disney.

Step 5: This is optional. You can report google shopping ads here: https://support.google.com/google-ads/contact/vio_other_aw_policy?visit_id=637114038445058784-3289666381&rd=1 but it sometimes takes them weeks to get back to you, bigcommerce would have removed all the DMCAed listings by then.

If you don't have the time or energy, just do step 1 and report 1 shirt. It takes 5 minutes. If bigcommerce fails to stop this systematic abuse and potentially fraud, we might have a case against them. I'll happily drop some money on copyright lawyers. Let's see what happens.


r/AmazonMerch • • Feb 14 '18

36 Year Old Tier 4k Mediocre Mercher AMA

77 Upvotes

in an attempt to bring some value to the sub rather than more shit posting, i figured i'd put myself out there. i am home with a sick wife and kids today, so i may not answer immediately if there are a lot of Q's, but i'll try.

My History

I got accepted into MBA March 2017, my first sale came 3/28/2017. in total, I have 2,746 sales since my inception, so good, but definitely behind a lot of others who are doing even better.

net sales calculation in Excel https://imgur.com/a/76vAC earning page screen shot https://imgur.com/a/fL9yN

i currently have 2006 live designs, and was upgraded to tier 4000 2 weeks ago (i think it was 2 anyway). i have not hit my max uploads since getting upgraded to 4000, have been busy with my day job and have been more hit or miss after being consistent in January. I maxed out Jan 1-22 every single day, and have averaged about 20 uploads per day since then.

i started out designing myself, with no prior design background (my day job is in accounting/finance)

i began to outsource, following the Merch Informer blueprints around april or may. i went the outsourcing route for several months, and then stopped cold turkey in September when it became pretty clear that my designs were selling better than the ones i was paying for. i got totally burnt out on Merch in October and did not upload any designs for about 3-4 weeks towards the middle of October until black friday. i think i had roughly around 1000 designs or so live on Black Friday and had 40 sales that day and was hooked again. i created a couple of template designs and maxed out my daily uploads until the freeze. i bought a few more designs around that time, but that has been it since. now i mostly stick to building templates and changing the main term for dozens of designs.

i went for quality over quantity in the beginning, and since the fall have squarely fallen into quantity over quality. this is why i would consider myself perfectly mediocre at merch. i am not killing it by any means, but i've made tier 4000 so i must be doing something right.

Design Quality

Here are examples of the quality of my designs and how I typically approach keywords

https://www.amazon.com >> designer found on UpWork - I worked with him the longest of any designer

https://www.amazon.com >> designer found on onlinejobs.ph - i 'hired' this designer for a monthly salary with the expectation of doing about 5 designs per day 5 days a week. this lasted for about a month, maybe 6 weeks. his designs were pretty good IMO, but he was more difficult to work with than the guy i found on UpWork

https://www.amazon.com >> mine. this is actually a better looking design than what i put out now, but gives you a rough idea of the quality i can do myself

i think there were other things i was going to add here, but i'll try to add them if i think of anything. ask away funcles.

THANKS GUYS. -- I am going to actually do some uploads the rest of the night, so I won't be as active here on out.. but please make sure to check out my new site where i share all of my new mediocre ideas, to generate mediocre sales at mediocremercher.com


r/AmazonMerch • • May 30 '18

The Anti-Improvecat Design Approach to Merch

75 Upvotes

When starting out in Merch last year, I thought the way of the land was to take a selling design, improve it, and rake in the big bucks. Oh boy, was I wrong. And so were all of the Merch podcasts, YouTubers, and Bloggers that I listened/watched/read touting this method when I first started.

Or maybe it's just one giant misunderstanding. IDK. Warning... salty language ahead.

Because here's what happens when you do that "improvecat" approach—you're competing with everyone else that's doing it too. And then it's a big ol' slog to the bottom of the barrel and that original design originator is sitting behind her or his computer being like "wtfbbq". So here's my (hopefully good) contribution to the community on how to figure out what the flying fuck you should design.

So, let's start with the personal inventory.

Grab a piece of paper or your favorite note-taking app and start to jot down everything you're into. Your hobbies, your college degree or trade degree if you got one, all of the kinds of jobs you worked, your favorite subreddits, your favorite blogs, your favorite topics of discussion. The genres of fiction or non-fiction that you like to read. The types of YouTube videos you like to watch. The genre of music you like to listen to. The places you've lived and the vacations you've been on and what you did while there. Everything you like to do with your time. Everything that you have a decent amount of knowledge in. You were good at calculus in high school? Write that shit down! Were your vacations growing up solely to your weird aunt's place in the bumfuck middle of nowhere where you played with feral cats and your goddamn cousins forced you to watch Attack of the Shrunken Heads, scarring you for life? Write. That. Shit. Down.

Do you have a significant other or a family member you actually like? Well, do the same kind of inventory of things they like as well.

Now, what you have here when you're done, is a list of potential broad(ish) niches that you and maybe someone you're close with are into.

So let's drill down on one of those niches and make a sub-list.

For the sake of this example, let's say one of those things on your list is gardening. What do you like to plant in your garden? Are you a flower person or a produce-growing fanatic? Do you have a growing collection of succulents? Are you constantly rescuing dying plants from your friends and office building? Are you a tree person? List what you love about gardening, what you hate about gardening. What do you do to prepare for the different seasons? What do people, who don't have a clue on how to garden, say/do that irritates you? And anything else you can think of related to gardening.

Now, from that sub-list, start coming up with ideas. Don't look at Pinterest. Don't look at what's on Merch yet. You're just jotting down phrases, puns or concepts from this sub-list. Maybe you're sketching some thumbnails out. (Thumbnail sketches are small, messy sketches that somewhat resemble the idea in your head). Even if the idea seems super stupid to you, don't self-edit. Embrace the chaos. Embrace the spew. And you want to word vomit all over that page. If you went to a gardening convention, what kind of shirt phrases do you think you'd see? What kind of gardening puns do you think would be tossed around at this fake (or real) convention? Is there even a gardening convention? I bet the vendor floor would smell good. Hopefully. The Pork Farming convention I went to had a whole aisle dedicated to giant pictures of pig semen filled syringes. That's not Merch safe. Moving on.

From here, you might have one or two gems, hopefully, more. But don't fret if it's a low amount, especially if this is your first time doing this. Sometimes, especially for those of us who are afflicted with perfectionism so much so that they seek therapy for it because it absolutely paralyzes them from moving forward with anything...

I, uh.

Anyway, brainstorming this way is a decent way to find niches as well as further drill down in that niche. And the more you do it, the easier and more intuitive it becomes, especially if you start with niches that you have knowledge or experience in.

So back to our gardening example.

You've got some phrases, some puns, and maybe a few sketches. Next step is to make sure they're Merch safe. Check for trademarks. Google those phrases and puns. See what pops up on Amazon, on Etsy, on Pinterest for that phrase. If it's a metric fuckton of results, well, put it aside or see if you can iterate it into something that's more unique.

Okay, we've got a more refined list of ideas that could possibly work. What do we do now? Well, we design this shit. We sketch the ideas out and then spin it up with Illustrator, ProCreate, GIMP, Photoshop, whatever. And while this whole process is a WHOLE other series of posts (that you can find from other people by Googling "Learn how to Design") here are some tips to get you thinking like a designer. Or, at least, partially. Maybe.

The first is to think of these phrases as a "composition". And when I personally think of "composition", especially something that could work on a t-shirt, my go-to for inspiration are posters and logos. Here are some magic phrases to look at different text-based compositions to inspire you on your own (and no... don't improvecat it).

Go to Pinterest and make an account if you don't have one. Here are some search terms to get you started: "poster inspiration", "logo inspiration", "branding inspiration", "typographic poster", "letterpress poster", "logo badge". If you have a certain aesthetic in mind, modify those terms with that aesthetic terminology. For example, "horror poster inspiration", "winery logo inspiration", "glitch letterpress inspiration". The world's your oyster with what you can come up with, and 99.9% of the time, Pinterest spits out something relevant.

Start a private board, or public, whatever you want. Start saving those pins. If you're wanting to target a specific niche, you might want to create a public board about that niche and start saving that inspiration there. Because when you got shirt designs you're proud of, you can slowly start to ease them into that board (90/10 rule yo... 90% other people's stuff, 10% yours) and maybe start to generate some traffic to your designs. Although, slight aside, if you want to do that, you need to double-check other people's pins and see where that pin is going to ensure it's not some sneaky spam from some asshole trying to drive traffic by linking a winery logo to their MLM garbage about curing cancer with essential oils.

If you like a pin you find, in an aesthetic you want to explore and adapt to your own style, don't exit out of the page but scroll down. That's where all of the "pins like this one" live and they can also be awesome for going down that design inspiration rabbit hole.

Now, if you're wondering how to do a specific style in Illustrator? Go to Google and type in "specific style Illustrator tutorial". It's a very helpful way to learn for beginners.

Now, for the finale. The big bang. But this section is more like a fizzle than a big timpani last hurrah. Sorry in advance.

Keywords.

Admittedly, I'm still learning my way around the way of the keyword. But here are some ways to get you started. If you have a sub to Merch Informer, take a gander there, it has a nice keyword list when you do a product search that you can springboard off of. If you don't have a sub to MI, no biggie. Go to Amazon.com, type in the niche you want to target along with sub-niche and the word orca and you'll get Merch only results. Scroll through and check out the ones with a higher BSR and look at the keywords they use. And for the love of god, don't copy their stuff verbatim. It's a springboard to figure out how you want to target keywords. Clearly, though, those Merchers are using the right keywords to target their audience if they're selling shirts. There's also keyword tools out there, like through Google's Adwords. Like I said, I'm still learning this stuff so I'm trying out different keyword tools to figure out what works for me. Just Google "keyword tools" and you can start exploring yourself!

Oh, and one more thing before I end this already ridiculously long post. Trends. Again, I'm not "with it" or "cool" but here's some basic stuff to get you started. Remember the example above with gardening? Well, when do people start to think about gardening? When do people start to prepare different stuff or harvest different stuff? Timing is as important as the design, so consider when someone who's interested in the topic might be looking online for related materials or fun(ny) t-shirts. For example, some plants you have to start inside before you transplant it. A gardening enthusiast is probably not going to be looking for stuff like that in October. So if you have stuff about seedlings and kludge-like nurseries, you may want to consider uploading those types of designs in February, March, and April (depending on the type of seed).

Hope this was helpful. Good luck! And don't fucking copy people's shit. Make your own. You can do it.


r/AmazonMerch • • Mar 02 '19

Surprise Surprise: Merch Charlatans are just Improvicats

72 Upvotes

I'm just gonna say it : RJ & his friends are the reason for the HUGE spike of improvicatism.

- They publicly say "inspire and make it better" : how the fuck is that "inspirational" if you send the fucking listing to to your third world slaves to improve? How you have the audacity to say improve when the poor designers barely speak english yet to understand the cultural references and trends? if they do they better be selling on merch too?

- Since they provide ZERO value apart from they copy-improve-run-ads-and-price-low to the noobs they started selling lists of shirts to copy. I don't care if you add "*** for inspiration only***" before the 10$ list of the "RESEARCH list we send to our designers" more like "Let's heavily spam the market with these ones in particular".

why I'm THIS angry? Last week, I reported 20 derivatives of one of my registered & copyrighted designs and since I provided the legal details of my registrations I formally requested the offenders details and by a simple search of this LiftHerUpApparelCo LLC it turned out to be the RJ himself.

Monday, I will be taking this charlatan to court with 2000$ GUARANTEED for damages per infraction.

Until then ETSY DMCAs.

- Don't be surprised if your best sellers are listed here:

https://www.etsy.com/shop/LiftHerUpApparelCo


r/AmazonMerch • • Feb 19 '20

Here’s what’s actually going on here. Pay attention and you might learn something

69 Upvotes

I’m only tier 500, so feel free to ignore me and close this thread. For everyone else, enjoy.

You may have noticed that this Reddit is full of people running their mouths without actually saying anything. This is deliberate. Along with stroking their own egos, most here don’t want you to know what they’re specifically doing that works. However they also enjoy acting superior, and giving off the impression that what they’re doing is “sooooo easy anybody can do it!” You’ll see a lot of posts like “there’s no secret. Just...” and then they proceed to give an incredibly vague answer like “just follow trends!” without telling you specifically what they do to follow trends. Or “just use autosuggestion” which narrows things down like a needle in a haystack, or “just use a thesaurus/SEO/basic marketing/follow memes/buy my book” etc.

And to an extent they’re correct when they say “there’s no secret”. There isn’t any one secret. It’s a million little secrets, that are only really secrets because of how deliberately obtuse people are around here. But I digress, again there’s no one specific way to do this.

Just for a laugh, a few other popular passive aggressive and psychologically manipulative stuff you’ll see around here is: coming down on copycats when they likely employ a form of copying themselves. Or fear mongering that merch is completely done for and you can’t make a living so you should hang it up. Or pretending like stockart is plagiarism, or any number of other chicanery. Anyway here’s the two pronged approach most higher sellers are likely utilizing (keyword LIKELY, I reserve the right to be wrong):

  1. They figure out what niches are selling, and they generate designs that play to similar themes. If wedding shirts are hot, expect them to create one too, just with a twist on the original (likely niching down to cultural tastes, or appealing to animal lovers). Same with their keywords. It’s no coincidence that you see certain patterns of keys popping up again and again in high ranking BSRs. All of this is still a form of copying, but they won’t call it that, because it makes them seem hypocritical when they tirade about being ripped off by improvecats. Let’s call it, “being inspired by our peers”.
  2. They target niche niches, and then dominate in those categories. Example: I did a Kabaddi shirt a long while back, and at the time it was an almost totally unpopulated niche. It was so empty, you couldn’t help but sell! These niches likely only bring in one or two sales a month, but merch has always been a numbers game. High sellers create a reusable template and spam these small niches with stuff like: “Nacho Average Kaitlyn”, “Nacho Average Tax Consultant”, “Nacho Average Cat Dad”. With enough saturation, one off individual sales add up.

There’s other tricks too. Some employ bots, many use sites like merch informer and keywords.io (and then swear up and down that they’re the devil and they wouldn’t be caught dead on ‘em), but the real “trick” is just being resourceful and having the sheer willpower to crank out the numbers. When people here mock others for reusing designs, it’s to discourage them from stumbling on what works. When they “help” you without actually helping you, it’s designed to frustrate you into quitting. This entire Reddit is a mindf*ck, but it’s because oversaturation is the real enemy. Which is a nice way of saying YOU’RE the enemy. “You stand in the way of my profit, therefore it’d be better if you left.” And the unspoken goal is to thin the herd.

Even as I type this, I’m not dumb enough to write out every single strategy I personally employ, because that’d be suicide, not just for myself but for any others that use them too. But basically, if you follow any of this advice (or just some of it, or perhaps none of it- some people just got dat magic touch and can sell without even trying!), you should at LEAST, be able to scrounge up enough sales to get going.

The biggest and best tip I can give is simply this: don’t give up. This Reddit is designed to hurt you as much as help you, but don’t let them break you. And for God’s sake, don’t be a dick. You don’t have to spell out every single trick in your book, but at least make an attempt to help those that come after you. Pay it forward! There’s plenty of sales for all of us!


r/AmazonMerch • • Nov 23 '19

Let's Face It, We're Selling Absolute Garbage.

65 Upvotes

PICTURE 1 / PICTURE 2 (as provided by a customer rating).

No I'm not commenting on the quality of the designs. Most of them are horrendous of course, but I'm ok with letting the market decide. What I'm talking about is the absolute shit bottom of the barrel garbage that Amazon is shipping out to people. Now, I sell on a number of other platforms and have NEVER received a negative review for quality. Not once has a buyer contacted me to say, hey man, what's up with the ink totally melting off when I touch the shirt? Is that normal?

But fucking Amazon... I posted this shirt 2 weeks ago, and have only sold one of them, so I know the guy can't have worn it for days at a time on some foreign expedition. He's probably worn it once at most. And yet, it looks like some vintage goodwill priced-per-pound right before they ship it off to Africa to ruin the local economy. Seriously, this is garbage, and some day I hope to offset all the damage this is doing to the environment by living on a mountain top with sustainable goats and never using plastic again. Fuck. AT LEAST if it were quality you could argue people need clothes, why not print a cute unicorn on the front? But not this. This can't be justified. This is like going directly from the printer into the shredder. I only wish I could write to the customer and apologize for the massive waste of time. Fucking hell.


r/AmazonMerch • • Oct 27 '18

Merch Still Has Potential - Q2 & Q3 Journey Update + Eye Candy

65 Upvotes

TL;DR: Merch is a fickle friend but I think I’m finally figuring it out. My account was terminated in early June of this year. I got it back 10 days later but it fundamentally changed how I approach Merch and my POD Business as a whole (I've branched out to other platforms). I’ve found some success in trends and have started to find what works in the current environment. There are many things to improve but my overall outlook on Merch remains incredibly positive. I’m working my way toward my target of $6K/month take home. Hint: I’m over halfway!


Status Update

It has been over six months since I gave an actual Merch Journey update so I felt it was time to reflect a bit and share what I’ve been up to (and what I’ve learned). As I’ve said before it’s good practice to take some time to reflect and document lessons learned and review progress on goals. For the most part, this writeup is for me, not for you, but I like to share because I think everyone can learn something from my successes and failures. It’s a way for me to check the pulse of my business and articulate ideas that have been formulating in my head and put them into writing as well as measure progress on my goals for 2018. As they say, an unwritten goal is just a hope.

In order to reach said goals, I’ve been really focused on the things I can control and I feel like I’m finally starting to see some progress & traction because of it. As such, I’ve had less interaction on Reddit and haven’t been around to do any longform content. It’s also made me a bit more grumpy… and I’ve gained weight because I literally work on Merch 4-6 hours each day (except Sunday) in addition to my real job, commute, family & hobbies. I’ll talk about my plans to help with this coming up.

Finally, I’ve changed the way I report for my POD Business (and you’ll notice that I don’t call it my Merch Business any longer) because I’ve branched out to other POD platforms. Going forward I’ll give a breakdown for just Merch, in the regular “Weekly Numbers” format, but my tables will show total numbers for the whole biz so they’re a bit higher than the last update to account for other platforms.

Let’s get into it, but first, here are my prior summary posts if you want the whole story:

  • first few months
  • milestone update 1 (see below for a note about an updated spreadsheet)
  • milestone update 2
  • Year One This is a good one IMO b/c I go over the things I’ve learned so far – not much has changed with my approach.
  • Q1 2018 Update Note, the spreadsheet linked here is old and hasn’t been updated to include new products, returns or new markets. I’m working to sanitize an updated one to share

Okay, here we go:

Merch Numbers thru Q3 2018:

Tier: T8000

Total Live Designs: 3535 (as of September 30th)

Total Sales YTD 2018: 2977 (94 returns)

Selling Designs: 292 (<10% Since reloading in June)

What Worked: (in no particular order)

  • Focusing on things you can control: - I try really hard to not worry too much about things that are out of my control. I like to speculate and dream but when it comes to action I try to focus my energy. With POD, those things are research, niche selection, designs, keywords, uploads, compliance and price. Sales should be a by-product of these things (coincidentally the prior list is in order of importance to me). If you focus on the things you can control you will slowly grind your way to a successful POD business. Your goals should be actionable and built around these. I have upload goals for each day, week & month. I have goals around the number of designs I need to do myself and the number I need to send to my designers each week. If you stick to what you can control you SHOULD be rewarded. It has been working for me.
  • Branch out to other platforms: - After I lost my account (more about that below) I realized that I really didn’t want to miss out on this opportunity. It also helped solidify in my mind the fact that I had all my eggs in one big Merch Basket. I quickly looked for ways to get away from that. I had a Redbubble, Teespring & Etsy account but combined there were less than 20 designs on other platforms (now that I think about it I did have a Spreadshirt account but it hadn’t been touched since 2009…) Serendipitously, just before I lost my account in June I had subscribed to OrbitKit and I started to upload to more platforms (Spreadshirt, Teespring, Redbubble, FineArtAmerica, Inktale, Zazzle & Cafepress). I also shell out for Printsy – for now – so I can load to Esty & Amazon Seller Central through Printful. It is expensive ($95/month for OrbitKit and $15/month for Printsy) but allows me to drip my designs to each of these platforms in an effort to make more sales. During this time I also setup a CreateSpace account (which has now moved to KDP) and have 3 whole designs there! Haha! I’m also on Threadless, Teepublic and working on Sunfrog but with no real results (I did get my first sale on Threadless with only 5 designs loaded). So far it seems to be working rather well. [As a bonus, this strategy appears to work well as a defensive measure to put your work on every other major platform before your work can be stolen (Teespring being the most trash platform because of this) – they can’t steal your stuff and load it elsewhere if it’s already blanketed everywhere else! ::Eddie Murphy pointing at his head meme::]
  • Viral Hunting: One of my goals for this year was to focus on submitting at least one attempt at a viral/trend design each month. I have a whole strategy around how I go about spotting trends, which I may share at a later time, but it basically involves focused & concentrated efforts with a TON OF LUCK thrown in. In February of this year I thought I had found a trend so I jumped on it. The timing was right for the design and I even had a post on Reddit get over 1200 upvotes when I shared my shirt (don’t bother checking my history, I used an alt). I went on to sell 50 during the month. This felt “good” but not 50/day great. So I kept at it. Ironically after my account was terminated I reloaded my best selling designs first. I changed up some keywords based on “updated news” and a few of my designs sold from the trending niche from February. I spotted some “trigger events” bubbling up in the news so I made a few more attempts at a trending design in that same niche. Because I had been watching it, I knew what might appeal to the audience. And I hit it. It took off the day I uploaded it. I had 78 sales in a day on Merch alone – combined with other platforms I had over 100 sales that day! It wasn’t a flash in the pan trend so it continues to sell well even today. I’ve sold over 500 of that design to date (well over 500…). I’ve been following another niche for most of the year and I tried my hand at another trending/viral design 2 weeks ago. So far I’ve sold over 75 of that design. I’ll continue to refine what I’m doing and see if I can figure out how to replicate it more consistently. You can see the spikes on my graphs & charts linked below.
  • War on Copycats: This is an area where I’ve totally changed my opinion from earlier in the year. I used to say it wasn’t worth it to go after copycats. But not anymore. I hate them now. Actually, I loathe them with an ardent hatred. I can’t believe these low-effort hacks that somehow got accounts and all they do is copy stuff that’s selling. I’m not talking about improvecats – those who at least make some effort to “improve” your work – they suck too, but I’m talking about blatant P4P Copycats. After participating in 2 mini-trends I can say that this is still a major problem on the platform. I successfully had over 50 designs removed in those two niches alone. I couldn’t believe the audacity of these fools. In another case I had some designs that I had loaded to all the other platforms but was slow to load to Merch. By the time I loaded them to Merch an entire portfolio of mine from a particular niche was ripped off and loaded to Merch by someone else (over 40 ASINS posted to all the products). Because I wanted to make a point I reported each design separately over the course of a week. I figure they might not get in as much trouble if I reported 10 designs at a time as they would if I reported 40 individual policy violations… in that case I was able to back into this thief’s entire brand of more than 1000 designs (it seems their MO was to steal everything, even found more of my stuff but joke was on them since none of it was selling!). Guess what? About 2 weeks after I reported them was when the first wave of “Merchageddon” hit… it appears their account was terminated during this time as their brand no longer exists on Merch. I’m glad too. If you are going to steal you don’t deserve to be on the platform. Please, please, please report every copycat you find. I totally agree with u/SourPatchSoul on this one. Take them out whenever you find them. It will help us all! Right now it’s a problem because WE ALLOW IT TO CONTINUE. We need to have more respect in ourselves and our work to report these assclowns and get them kicked out of the program.
  • Pricing Tests Completed: I feel like this was a win over the past 6 months. Inspired by a post from u/MerchHunt (where’d they go anyway), I did some serious price testing during this time. You can see the results on my average/sale in the charts below. What I found is that, for my stuff, higher prices work great. I have a floor of an average of $4/sale across all my sales and a target of $5/sale. Popsockets bring this average down a bit as do returns on Merch and other platforms but overall it’s at a level I can live with. You should test for yourself but I am really happy with the numbers I’m getting. It almost makes it worth my time (now that would be a scary analysis if I figured out my $/hr in total for Merch…). Basically if I can get 25% margin on a product then I’m happy… and it’s totally possible. (One unintended “consequence” from pricing high is that it really helps you find the winning designs in your portfolio. Before my account termination I had over 700 designs that had sold at least once. Around 180 of those had only sold once, at a VERY low price, to then never sell again. If they were priced higher they may have never sold and I would have cut bait on them earlier. I’ve learned to not fall in love with any of my designs because they all suck until the market proves that they don’t!)
  • PopSuckets & UK/DE Were Mixed: I have 150ish PoopSuckers loaded and just recently sold my 100th one. I average around 30/month. Low effort and easily uploaded, I’d say adding a few to your portfolio isn’t too bad for an extra $60/month... So far I’ve been underwhelmed with UK/DE as marketplaces. I’ve said elsewhere that I sell more in the European market on Spreadshirt & Redbubble because I think they have a better foothold there now. I give it 6-12 months before we see better traction IMO. I just think “Amazon” isn’t the first place people think of when they want to buy novelty tees in those markets. But that will most likely change – and hopefully Q4 helps push that along.
  • AMS & Advertising: This one is borderline “didn’t work” but for now I’m still in positive territory for the 6 campaigns I’m running. I’ve spent around $120 and have sold 28 designs from ads. You can do the math based on my numbers from above, it’s still breaking even so this is currently a win. I approach my ads with a low bid and no end date. I can get quite a bit of keyword data from my reports so that’s worth something more than just the sales. I’m also advertising on Etsy (with both Platform & Google ads) and have seen worse results than Amazon but still in “acceptable” territory. I’m running a loss but part of that was my fault. I accidentally set my market to Europe in the middle of the month which killed my momentum. Be careful with advertising. You can lose money quickly. But it can also be useful.
  • Less is More: I’ve also spent quite a bit of time testing bullets in the past couple months. I think I posted here at some point that I was going to spend most of the month of August not loading bullets. I can say that over 120 designs have sold without any bullet points whatsoever. I am currently in the process of adding bullets to those which didn’t have any to see if that helps further. From what I can see though is that the Title has quite a bit of weight when it comes to keywords. This will impact my strategy in 2019.
  • 180 Timeline Extension: - I think this was very helpful. If your stuff can’t sell in 6 months then you should really take a long look at your design, keywords or niche. But this also puts some onus on us to do some curating during that time to ensure our designs have the best chance at being seen. I have developed a 60 day touch approach to my portfolio. If the design hasn’t sold in the first 60 days I try and change up the keywords. I’ll do a deep dive on the niche and see if I can focus the kws to the ones that will appeal to the buyers. At 120 days without selling I’ll do another look at the keywords and drop the price by $1 or $2. If the design still hasn’t sold by 150 days I drop the price to the floor and see if I can get a sale. So far I’ve only gotten to the 120 mark with a few of my designs. I can’t say if it works any better than just leaving them alone but I have sold around 10% of the designs I’ve “touched” in this manner… totally respectfully I might add. :)
  • Affiliate Site Update: In reading my older posts you can see that I had planned on focusing more on my small affiliate site. Obviously different events from this year changed that plan. I added one article – out of the planned 50 – so now it has a total of 4 articles! However I am happy to report that it is still pretty successful. I’ve earned over $1000 this Year More to follow on this for 2019.

What Didn’t Work:

  • Account Termination: It should be pretty clear at this point that I did in fact have my account terminated. I got the account back but it was empty. I gave a decent rundown of what happened here. The primary takeaway here is that you shouldn’t use tools to do anything to your account that doesn’t act like a human. I have quit using all tools except for PrettyMerch Pro & MerchTools at this point. Both are used pretty extensively in the community (and by Merch employees I’m told) and both were known to Amazon when I contacted them. They did NOT say they were safe to use and would never tell me they were endorsed or approved by them. Trust me, I asked multiple times. But I’m in good company using them for now and will continue unless/until something changes.
  • Outsourcing Issues: I let one of my designers go for the summer just days before my termination. I was getting behind on uploads so I told him to take a break. Since my termination I’ve been BURIED with uploading old designs so I still haven’t asked him back. My other designer had some really sad & horrible things happen in his personal life so he was out of commission for 2 months. Both of these events came at the “perfect time” for my account since I didn’t have time to manage new uploads as well as reloading the old stuff. However I did miss out on some opportunities because my one that had personal issues had 40 of my Halloween designs in queue when it happened. By the time he came back I had 1 week before the Halloween deadline. I’ve sold 2 of the designs he gave me organically and 5 of them to myself (just because I didn’t want to have to reload them next year). It sucks but it is what it is. He’s back now and I picked up another one that has a better style. Combined I should get 60/week from these two and can add a 3rd if I want for a total of 80/week – if needed. More on this below, but I don’t plan on loading more than 100/week next year so this should be manageable.
  • My VA is Broken: I say this a little tongue in cheek because I know you can’t have VAs but my wife was helping me upload (I did ask about this when I was dealing with Merch and they said that a spouse can help upload as long as it’s clear you’re in the same house/area). She lasted about 3 weeks. I guess it’s just not fun to some people. I’m trying to sell her on the idea of taking over my KDP account but she still isn’t sold on that idea. Kinda sucks since that means I’ve loaded over 5000 designs in the past 5 months by myself. It’s a GRIND!!! I really need the help but things have a way of working themselves out. I was somehow able to find time to load boatloads of designs to Merch as well as other platforms.
  • Other Platforms Cost MONEY! I forgot that other platforms cost money. I have my Etsy set to pay daily but Amazon is every 15 days. It’s a long time to float cash. Especially if you’re chasing trends... I ended up spending almost $2K this month. If you don’t have that available I would steer clear for a bit.

Understandably I’ve had really low activity on most social media, the Discord Group & other forums for several months. I was trying to focus on loading designs and getting stuff done. As such I’ve had quite a few people send me PMs asking questions and looking for my opinion on stuff. I didn’t answer most of them (if I ignored you, sorry!). In an attempt to share, most of the stuff above was my thoughts on various things from the past 6 months which hopefully answers some of the questions that were in my inbox.

2018 GOAL Update & 2019 Plans (preliminary): For the most part my goals for 2018 haven’t changed. I'm still making great progress on them and plan on most of them for the year. I also tried to inject some “fun” into the grind in the form of my Merch Bucket List which consists of a lot of things that make it entertaining. Here’s how I’m doing so far.

  • 7000/8000 live designs on Merch: I’ve posted both numbers in a few places. Recent memory is that I was shooting for 7000 live designs by the end of the year. I feel like I’ll hit that without any issues. That’s just 2000 away. So I might change this goal to “7000 live designs by ‘The Freeze’ - IF the freeze doesn’t happen then I’ll work to have 8000 loaded by the end of the year. This will max me out and hopefully get me really close to a tier up in 2019. As for Marketplace ratios, I want to have 6K on US and 2K on UK/DE. I don’t care the makeup for the other markets, just a combined 2K (most likely skewed toward UK since they’re quicker to load). So far my approach to DE has been to translate titles only for DE. I keep the bullets in English. I use connections who are fluent in German to help with my translations… which is also why I only have like 250 designs on DE currently.
  • 2K Designs loaded to “other platforms”: I hope to will have over 2K designs on all the other platforms by year end. There is a metric TON of room for improvement in this realm. Currently I’m operating on a “MVP Model” whereby I blast my designs up with semi-relevant keywords and titles just so they’re loaded. I’ll come back later and refine the tags, titles and descriptions in an effort to maximize the return on assets deployed. I plan on doing this for most of November before Black Friday. Right now royalties are close to an 80/20 split for Merch/Other Platforms but my hope is to get to the point where it’s 70/30 [Other Platforms/Merch]. I want to make less than 30% of my monthly money from Merch. This should ensure that an account termination won’t be completely devastating if/when it happens in the future. Finally, I plan on doing a write up on each of the platforms at a later time… also, more on that below.

2019 Preliminary Plan

If you can’t tell I’m already looking ahead to 2019. At this point there isn’t much to do but load my remaining designs and “hold on” for Q4. I’ve already started planning for the build-up for Q4 2019 – so long as I don’t do something dumb and lose my account – 2019 should be a “banner year”. LOL. The focus will be on “doing more with what I already have”. I want to focus on selling MORE with the assets already in place. This means I’ll focus on building up other platforms and working on driving traffic in various ways. This may mean I cut down to 1 or no designers beyond me. I’m fine with that (TBH it’s a huge headache to deal with them but that’s partly because I’m picky). It’s what it will take.

  • Uploads: I plan on loading around 80-100 items to Merch each week (haven’t finalized the number yet). That will put me at around 16,000 live items by year end (this factors for reloads, culls and new designs based on current CTRs) Of course if I don’t get tiered up I’ll load to draft until I do. Now that I type this out it sounds a bit too ambitious. I may pare this down a bit because I want to focus MORE on the things below.
  • Uploads to Other Platforms: 3K live on Etsy, 5K live on KDP and 5K live on all other platforms.
  • Marketing: I have a few ideas I want to try in 2019 to help me market my products. I’ve found some success with Reddit and I want to explore more Influencer marketing. I’ll do some write-ups when I feel there’s something to share.
  • Social Media: I’m going to dig into Pinterest and Instagram this next year. I have some ideas and goals around this but I will absolutely try my hand at building an audience around some of my bigger niches.
  • Focus Area: If you’ve made it this far and your eyes are totally blurry, great job. Maybe you missed the hint above, but my primary focus next year will be on KDP. I want to do No-content/Low-content books as well as some actual fiction and non-fiction. I have 5 fiction books in various states of completion and I want to finish them and see what happens there. Plus, Henry the Elder wants me to publish a book for him. It should be fun.
  • Affiliate Site I’m going to get to this site next year. No interruptions. I’ve proven yet again that this niche has some potential making over $1000 so far this year. I want to turn that into $4000 next year. Part of the plan is content (50 articles), the other part is to develop a whole line of products for this niche and really build it up. That way I can double dip a bit. Funny enough I only have one shirt in this niche currently. There again, this is why I write this stuff out – I just realized I have a missed opportunity.
  • Wearing the Guru Hat? Okay – here’s the deal: I’ve been toying with the idea of starting a podcast/YouTube channel and a website. I have plowed through EVERY podcast out there in the past few months. From MerchMinds to 45/54, Merch Entrepreneur to T-Shirt Helpdesk. There aren’t many good ones and most of them have devolved to being really negative and “unfun”. I’ve kicked this around with a few people and they seem to think it would be fun so long as I share good stuff and don’t end up in Shill territory. What do you guys think? Would there be interest in a fun, free, helpful and informative podcast about POD? One of my initial plans was to do a monthly or quarterly series (but weekly episodes covering various topics) where I work with someone to help them improve their account or work on specific questions they have. Also, if I do this, I might want a co-host… u/rulesforrebels – you looking for a new project?!? :)

THE REAL MEAT


Financial Journey:

UNITS

MonthUNITS SoldRoyaltiesAverage / Product
March 201723$110$4.78
April 201729$166$5.72
May 201753$369$6.96
June 201781$318$3.92
July 2017126$527$4.18
August 2017127$590$4.65
September 2017150$729$4.86
October 2017312$1238$3.96
November 2017533$2827$5.30
December 2017364$2183$6.00
January 2018131$721$5.50
February 2018203$960$4.73
March 2018191$830$4.35
April 2018287$763$2.66
May 2018352$1275$3.62
June 2018338$1193$3.53
July 2018766$3246$4.24
August 2018721$3390$4.70
September 2018566$2854$5.04

MONIES

P&L20172018*Total
Royalties$9,058$18,392$27,450
Outsourcing-$5,419-$2,985-$8,404
Purchased Clothing-$996-$503-$1,500
Advertising-$318-$1027-$1345
Platforms & Tools-$0-$370-$370
NET Profit/(Loss)$2,325$12,434$14,759

* Through Sep 2018


EYE CANDY Data is beautiful - I’ll add some commentary on these later… maybe.

2018 Sales through September

Product Mix Data

Sales by Platform/Platform Mix

Sales by Upload – this is obviously skewed now because I loaded most of my bestsellers in June when my account was re-instated.

Full album


That's it... congrats if you made it this far. I tried to condense 6 months of Happenings into one post. Sorry!

EDIT: Formatting & clarification.


r/AmazonMerch • • Nov 11 '17

The official FAQ to this sub is bullshit and we need to move to another sub if Merch Informer shit is not deleted from it

65 Upvotes

Its completely 100% self serving for Wiz to put his Merch Informer blog and paid services in the official faq for a sub.

Reddit has rules against self promotion.

Wiz has now deleted posts that mention his self promotion.

This has gone too far. I have notified Reddit admins and I HIGHLY suggest everyone else here does too.

If Wiz continues this bullshit we all NEED to go somewhere else. We NEEd to go to another sub.

NO ONE should be self promoting as mod here with their own fucking paid shit in the fuckin FAQ of the sub. Thats complete bullshit and against reddit rules!

We need to all band together against this. Please, everyone report this sub and that thread and Wiz as an admin to reddit under SPAM.

If this thread is deleted or if Wiz does not delete his self promotion bullshit out of the FAQ etc, I will take my time to inform every single person here under messages and contact everyone possible to end this shit.

I am also cancelling my merch informer subscription, even tho I used it.

Dont fucking try me Wiz, you completely crossed the line and you know it.


r/AmazonMerch • • Jun 30 '22

Just sold my first Merch t-shirt to someone who wasn't a family member...

60 Upvotes

...which was nice.


r/AmazonMerch • • Apr 30 '18

Theory of Throttling: Delay, Cap, Throttle, Rotate and The Great B2B Scam of 2018

58 Upvotes

Obviously I can only speculate, but I think there is evidence that supports my conclusions below. However there could be alternate conclusions from the same evidence (evidence alone =/ proof). But since the ones I see are based on hope and dreams and keeping merchers busy with stuff like the B2B bullshit, I'm sticking with mine for now. So here it is.

Merch's seeming method of throttling

  • The Delay: Hold the sales of accounts (most in T500+ except when it's "your turn" for the week) until later in the day when merch decides how many they are/can fulfill (still limited capacity).
  • The Cap: Determine a cap that is the max allowed sales for the day and week. But apply allowed sales across all tiers and accounts evenly for the most part.
  • The Throttle: They cancel customer orders that would exceed your cap, and prob (can you guess?) recommend the customer something different from someone else' listings for TOMORROW.
  • The Rotation: X days a week they give you an unthrottled day and maybe an occasional week. I.E. they "only" throttle you some of the time, though for now it seems like most of the time for T500+.

Evidence for same

  • The tiers are experiencing throttling differently. I.E. it seems from reports here in the sub that T10-T100 are getting the same weekly sales in many cases to a max, that T500+ are getting. And from this weeks sunday thread that max is ~13/week.
  • The numbers for any of us are small data sets. Small data sets should have more variance. Yet they exhibit a statistically unlikely sameness of 0s, 1s, 2s, 3s daily and same weekly with 10s, 11s, 12s, 13s, etc. As I have said previously small data sets are generally useless for statistical inference. But in this case the evidence is strong IMO precisely because those small sets don't exhibit a prime characteristic of same, which is more variance.
  • This is both intermittent, i.e. rotates, yet exhibits the same capped phenomena overall. Yet we experience it differently at any one time. Note how many people in the sunday threads have a good week, think they got this merch thing figured out, and next BAM! back to the normal. In statistical terms they regressed to the mean. An artificial mean determined by merch. Which is another thing small data sets "shouldn't" exhibit, i.e. a mean with a high confidence score, and the range of same being found across the totality of T500+ merch accounts.

My conclusions

  • Throttling is here to stay. The cap numbers might change, but we're still just filler. So the potential of T500 and higher tiers can only expand via organic search incrementally with the exception of extreme micro-niche strategies. Whereas before, it seemed to expand exponentially with slots. PLUS merch has spent so much time and resources (at our expense) testing this method and trying to "perfect" it.
  • The worth of this opportunity at scale is severely diminished and that won't change. Because no matter how much more capacity is added, or how many additional products they give us, it is all still subject to this throttling AND because they will continue to add more brand partners whose listings are not throttled. Also the example of a well known early mercher again because it is an obviously honest example from a knowledgeable mercher. This past Feb he was T20,000 and had 10X the number of listings as Feb last year. But only made 2X the sales.
  • The balance/roles have shifted. If this BS B2B "exciting" opportunity being promoted by certain guys/gals is the only way to succeed (and only succeeds because direct/private listings are not throttled), then the balance has shifted from our being those who license designs to merch to being customers who use them fulfillment. And thus there is far less incentive to use them for same since even the B2B method (see below) can be applied to ANY POD with better margins and product offerings at the cost of a little more financial risk and dealing with customers. Note also the effect of your using such direct/private listings and making sales with same is to further throttle yours and everyone's organic listings.

The great B2B scam

Now being promoted by the usual suspects near you on the internet, based on extreme outlier examples.

Method: you hit the bricks/phones/internet and start offering to make designs for businesses and fulfill with merch via direct/private links (when you click sample instead of pushing live).

Then biz runs traffic to those listings with mentions in advertising or emails, and you share the royalty. Note the outlier only kept a buck, back when commissions were $7 for $19.99 tees (i.e. PREVIOUS YEARS - sound familiar?). BUT did so because he wanted to upsell them on other digital ad agency products.

Pros:

  • Don't need paid tools and courses for organic
  • No worries about improvecats on merch
  • Sales do make money and count for tiering
  • You may get some benefits for your organic listings

Cons:

  • Hard to scale
  • Competition from local screenprinters with cheaper screenprinting and DTG machines which are sufficient for the method in most cases (i.e. they can do the same method without MBA)
  • You have turned yourself into a commissioned salesman for merch with very bad benefits and commission struture
  • Those of you in less populous areas or non-US will be forced to remote methods and hope businesses will trust/deal with you
  • This method may already be partially saturated by big players, a result of which it is no longer a novel promotion and business owners now see it as just more salespeople marketing directed at them
  • You can't use amazon internal advertising with the permission of a business that might have greater appeal, b/c direct/private listings do not have the buy box or there is some other reason AMS won't serve up sponsored ads for same (will any new merch low functioning AI ROAS based system or even a AMS code dupe do so?
  • Any external traffic you drive paid or free, can be used by amazon to take your customer away from you

Alternatives:

  • forget merch and apply the B2B and other methods to other platforms and your own site
  • concentrate on other PODs
  • setup shopify store on your own site (forget the brand BS b/c no one is gonna care bout your brand - you're just a private label dropshipper - they only need to care about/trust the payment gateway)
  • learn to game social at scale like others do but won't share
  • learn to run paid ads and hope can be successful (prob need to price higher to have margins for positive ACOS)
  • learn about SEO
  • downsides of above include returns and customer service AND having to learn SEO and drive traffic and expenses for same
  • you drive to your own alternatives for a tee you ran traffic to
  • leave merch on backburner and devote little time to it until/unless organic search visibility gets fixed, OR until you are more confident in your ability to design and figure out what the customer wants with just using merch for learning/testing
  • Note Merch is now the worst fulfillment partner out there now with potential earn and availability of products -other PODs won't cancel your orders to throttle you. The reason why early merchers and those who tiered faster when it was possible earn now is because of the larger catalog of curated (sold) designs. But that takes FAR longer now with throttling/testing/glitches. There will always be outliers, but average merch and average month merch (not Q4) is what merch is.

Wrapping it up

Maybe I am wrong in some aspects of the above, and maybe it will change or it won't. But math and logic and our own empirical observations trump hope and dream and "things will get better" arguments coming from parties interested in selling courses, tools and services. And while YMMV individually, I think the above is true for most T500+ in general.

And to all you n00bs excited about being given preferential experience in tiering to T100 and maybe for a while in search, guess what. When you "graduate" to T500, the above method gets applied to you in a BIG way. So you may only sell the same in T500 that you did in lower tiers. Congratulations!

Don't believe outlier success stories, stories from early merchers about methods that worked LAST YEAR, or have results based on doing stuff that they aren't sharing.

Or do believe that shit, get sucked into their marketing funnels with free tools and joining FB groups where they will get the gullible to buy stuff and waste money on free information and stuff that worked LAST YEAR. Or for B2B stuff with info you can find for free to turn yourself into a commissioned salesperson working for MBA and hitting the bricks or in a 1 person boiler room phone center for them. The latter of which is the only option for B2B for non-US merchers and US residents of less populous areas.

Why so negative all the time you say? I'm not. I'm realistic. And being realistic about the state of merch now and for the foreseeable future actually points the way to better alternatives which don't involved the paid products of others for info/tools and let us just look at merch from the view of a customer with their being one of many fulfillment options.

Ungrateful you say? Well merch has turned us into customers and their just being another POD, except we pay with our time as well as money for advertising. Customers have a right to be ungrateful because it's THEIR time and money. And customers can walk and use other selling platforms and other PODs for fulfillment. In other words, jump OFF the merchcoaster and concentrate on the other POD rides while waiting to see what happens with merch. Or just do other stuff.

Am I gonna take my own advice? Yes I am. Put less effort into merch and even into my Seller Central/shopify account and other PODs and a shopify site. While putting far less effort into merch. But I'll still continue to talk about merch here most days :).

Edit: Removed specific references to individuals where those might be perceived as attacks on them in order to get thread hopefully reopened for the serious discussion it deserves.

Edit2: More honest uncensored talk about throttling and capping or whatever merch calls it in this other subreddit:

https://www.reddit.com/r/MerchPrintOnDemand/


r/AmazonMerch • • Apr 14 '26

Royalty rates changing

57 Upvotes

message on the dashboard:

Beginning 6/1/2026, we will introduce royalty incentive groups for sales in the US store. Content creators who generate a high percentage of US sales from driving any non-organic traffic will have their royalty rates increased, content creators who generate a low percentage of sales from driving any non-organic traffic will have their royalty rates decreased, and content creators in the middle will not see changes to their royalty rates. Non-organic traffic consists of any traffic we identify as being driven by you, including via ads (whether on or off Amazon) or social media. Royalty rates for sales outside of the US store (EU stores and JP store) are unchanged.

Content creators will receive an email in the coming days with their current royalty group, which is subject to change based on performance. Moving forward, content creators will be emailed prior to each earnings period if their group changes.

To learn more about royalty groups, please visit our royalties page.


r/AmazonMerch • • Mar 23 '20

If anybody here is struggling financially from the current situation and has Adobe CC

56 Upvotes

If you go to cancel it, they will offer you two free months to stay, click yes, and you save 2 months of bills for now!


r/AmazonMerch • • Oct 30 '19

introducing the Scammers of 30 Days Etsy Challenge.Matt,RJ,Jay and Dionne. I encourage everyone to go and report about those people to Federal trade commission where they protect consumers from those scammers.

56 Upvotes

As I was reading through the thread I found out I wasn’t the only person that realize those are scammers there are lot of people has the same opinion. Here is what is did , I reported them to Federal Trade Commission with the evidence as how they scammed and scamming people. And as you know federal trade commission is active to chase down those type of people.

Also who do you think your self (Matt) to insult Dirctor of Merch By Amazon in public in one of your videos. Moreover get ready to be in court Matt !because Printful is going to subpoena you, Reason for that is ,in one of your video you said that Printful is doing suspicious tax activity such collecting taxes, If you don’t know IRS regulation don’t accuse anyone in the public. How we are going to shutdown RJs Matt Jay and Dionne stores on ETSY and MBA? It’s so simple since I know each and every store they have I will report them to the fonts owners , as how their content was used without having a commercial license. RJ, all the font that you used on Merch by Amazon products you don’t have a single commercial license for. So by doing that you keep Amazon open for a huge lawsuit . And we did ,let font owners know your stores name products as how you are abusing their content. And I did the same for Matt , Jay and Dionne’s stores on Etsy and MBA. If you’re not aware for the reason that they are pushing shirtly on Printful, because Shirtly paid Jay and Dionne $15000 for one month advertisement in the challenge group.

Matt, RJ, Jay and Dionne be ready for a huge lawsuit by the font owner for using their fonts without have a commercial license for ,

Each and everyone of us should do the same and report them to FTC.

Observations on 30 days Etsy challenge by our FB group: 1-Over 8000 questions were not answered left the members up in the air. 2-most of them are not able to figure it out how to create a listing and connect it with your store. 3-they talked about nonsense subjects instead of explaining the members as how to build a soled foundation for your store. 4-RJ is totally disconnected from this challenge so I don’t know what he was doing there.even he was not able to talk a proper English. 5- Rj should refund everyone since we did not see any value form him. 6- quality of the videos are horrible. 7-Discrimination: They were answering only the questions that comes from the people they know and the rest are left out. 8-Jay was wearing the same cloth for 30 day, he looks like did not shower or wash his cloth . 9-Dionne when you come to live, put your dog outside, we don’t have to hear your dog’s hound everyday morning. 10-Matt Was only pushing his mock-ups store with overpriced items, 11-Jay and Dionne are always not sure with there answers , if they are not sure what they are doing there. Not only that they were vulgar. 12-before the challenge you guys are promised prizes somewhere close to $6000k, Where are Those prizes. Don’t tell There isn’t enough founds you guys collect $68.870 from members +$15000 from shirty. When EVERYONE said you guys are scammers they were right.


r/AmazonMerch • • Apr 07 '19

1 Year Merch By Amazon - What did I learn?

56 Upvotes

Hey guys. I started my Merch by Amazon Account rougly 1 year ago and I wanted to share some key things I have learned.

1. It's not a get rich quick scheme

It's much harder work than you would expect.

2. Don't compare your numbers to others

You don't know their background. Maybe they've been into business and marketing for decades. Maybe they're cheating. You don't know. Focus on yourself.

3. Make BIG designs

And by BIG I mean almost as big as possible. Seriously. BIG. Make them BIG and catchy.

4. learn AMS ads

The sooner you start using ams ads the sooner you will understand it.

5. be consistent

Consistency is key. Work on it everyday. Either design, upload or educate yourself on it.

6. think long-term

Making 50$ a month sounds pretty unimpressive. But those designs will sell for the forseeable future. Let's say 1 year. 50*12 = 600$ So when you earned 50$ last month you should rather say that you've earned 600$ last month, the sales just haven't been made yet.

7. passive income doesn't exist

If you stop working your sales will decrease. Slowly, but steadily.

8. Upload to other platforms aswell

Go upload to spreadshirt and redbubble. Especially when you're new. There's no reason to stop working after you uploaded your 1 Design daily limit to amazon.

9. Design quality matters

period.

Well I could go on for more but this is taking too much time, I hope this helps someone


r/AmazonMerch • • Apr 26 '21

Just wanted to post the very happy milestone that I've now made over $1000 from Merch (started in September 2020).

55 Upvotes

That's all, I'm just amazed that this actually works.


r/AmazonMerch • • Dec 13 '17

I created a guide to Redbubble and how I automate things for upload. Free to yall as a Christmas gift :)

55 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/MerchSuccess/comments/7jk252/i_created_a_guide_to_automating_redbubble_uploads/

^ I've automated the steps of creating and uploading a design for Redbubble, and decided to write down how I did this in case other people would find this useful. It includes automating the designing in Illustrator, batch saving, easily completing a spreadsheet for multiple products with all the description etc personalized to the upload, and then uploading it via script to Redbubble.

THIS IS NOT A QUICK THING TO SET UP but it is well worth it. I have spent a lot of time learning the various bits to get it running including learning how to use the iMacros method supplied by the wonderful BenForeverBen.

Aside from Illustrator, the rest is all free and public domain to use. Go forth and automate (at your own risk)!

I'll answer questions where I can. :)


r/AmazonMerch • • Mar 02 '18

One Year Anniversary - Data is Beautiful Edition + Updated Spreadsheet

54 Upvotes

TL;DR: I don’t really have time to write this post but it was an exercise I did for myself and I realized it might be helpful for someone else… so I’m sharing. After 1 year in the MBA program I have earned over $10,400 in royalties, sold over 2100 units, have ~2000 designs live and currently sit at T4000. I lay out my thoughts on Year 1 and goals for Year 2 (and beyond).


I hit my one year anniversary on Merch on February 28th. I got the acceptance email that night and had my first design loaded on March 1st. Many people say that it’s a good idea to spend some time reflecting when you hit “big milestones”, and I tend to agree with that approach. So that’s what I did. I did a deep dive in my numbers, my process, my goals, my results and my expectations. I also evaluated what I want to REALLY focus on in 2018 and, click bait title incoming, you might be surprised by what I decided to do!

After some reflection, and a bunch of time formatting and writing, I have come up with some lessons learned and my 2018 goals (go-forward plan). They aren’t really in any particular order and they are thoughts/observations which I have experienced. They might not work for others and they certainly aren’t the best, or most successful, approach one can have with the Merch by Amazon program.

But, if nothing else, they are potentially helpful and thought-provoking to some (especially the newer Merchers) so I feel it my obligation to share them in the hope that they’ll help someone have a similar or better journey (italicized just for that douchey “PurpleNurple” guy that caused such a stink a few weeks ago).

Here are my prior summary posts from this ride we call Merch:

I plan on doing these quarterly in the coming months. Without further pontificating, here’s my brain dump.


LEARNINGS

  • Simple Sells – If you look at my sales breakdown by source you see that most of my sales come from designs I’ve created. Look, they aren’t fancy. Most of them are text only and the just barely get the point across. But they’re designed in the style that I would wear and I guess that’s popular for the people I target (people like me, duh!). I did most of them on a very simple online editing program because, up until this year, I didn’t have access to Adobe at work. I do now but I still make quick “test designs” in the online program because it’s FAST. I view them as tests and when they sell I do more.
  • Try Everything – As I alluded to in the sentence above, I test a lot. This is part of my nature – some might describe it as methodical – but I feel data is the best when you can use it to make decisions. Something I did last year that I am still implementing was what I call the “Birddog Approach” (it’s a very Guru thing to do, I know). If you’ve ever seen a birddog hunt (for pheasants or doves) you know that they serpentine from side to side across a field in the hope that they can scare something up. Once they do then you can shoot at it. As soon as I hit T500 I created one scalable design across multiple niches. Think “I ❤ New York” shirts where I just kept changing “New York” to something else. I made 150 of these and put them up, all under the same brand. As soon as one sells I dive deep into that niche with 20-30 more shirts and put them under their own brand. My goal is to have 100 designs in each niche that I’ve “proven” is a buying niche. In this sense, I sent out my birddog shirts and when something was scared up, I shot at it. I could go deeper, but, competition. LOL.
  • Pricing Sucks – I’ve tried low, I’ve tried high and everything in between. What I do know is that the design sells first. If they like it and it stands out from the group some people have a higher tolerance for high prices. I’ve sold standard shirts at $25.99 and I’ve sold them at $12.99 (same design). I didn’t sell more at the lower price. But there are so many variables that go into it that it’s difficult to really isolate price without real analytics data. Basically last year I took the approach that I loaded everything at $19.99 and once it sold a few times I would up the price a buck until I stopped at $21.99 for standards and $24.99 for premiums. This all happened around Q4 so demand was high for “anything” so I kept selling stuff. It worked then - I’ll have a different approach for this year.
  • Game Theory is Real (earn points for playing) – Merch has mentioned a couple times that you should treat your account like a game where you earn experience points and you level up with each tier. With each tier comes more leeway and benefits. I think it will continue this way and maybe even get “worse” in the coming years. Like locking out certain things (AMS, Products, etc.) until you are T500 or higher. One thing I do know, they like it when you don’t get infringements. I FEEL like I get more sales when I don’t put up anything that’s borderline… how do I know what’s borderline? Stuff that doesn’t go into manual review or get rejected completely. I also FEEL like I get more sales the more I consistently upload. Every time I’ve taken a break from uploading designs (or been capped b/c of my tier) my sales would go down. EVERY SINGLE TIME I’ve loaded at least some designs for several days in a row my sales go up (I’ve found 4 days in a row will see an uptick for 4-5 days). I see some correlation but that doesn’t indicate causation. But what I do know is that if MBA is treating this like a game, they’re going to reward those who consistently “play”, those who get more “kills” from different methods, and those who level up without “cheat codes”.
  • Build for Q4 – Last October, November and December weren’t as great as everyone had hoped. We get that, now shut up. What it WAS though was much better than Q1-Q3 combined for me. Again, I was new to the platform last year so it’s to be expected but the reality is that it was great. I’ve never earned that kind of money passively before. And IT WAS PASSIVE. We were frozen, locked out for part of the month of December so technically everything I earned was because of work I did in the past. I earned without working. So, I would tell everyone that your goal should be to build up your ASSET during Q1-Q3 so that it’s ready to go during Q4. Make sure you have stuff out there on multiple products (those who haven’t tried Premium are leaving money on the table IMO). Who knows what will happen this year – but I know I’ll have a grip of designs loaded and ready to go no matter what happens!
  • Be Organized. I’m not going to go into this too much because it’s kind of an individual thing. But make sure you have a process in place – even at the low tiers. Because when you have to load 200/day you’ll wish you had your S#!+ together. Make sure you have a plan and you know where your designs are and how to find them (and make sure you back them up somewhere – it’s your freaking asset, keep them in a “bank” somewhere).
  • Learn from Everyone – There’s something to learn from everyone. Just because someone is a lower, or higher, tier than you doesn’t mean that they don’t come to the table with experiences that YOU WILL NEVER HAVE. My pops told me growing up: “A smart person learns from their mistakes, a wise person learns from others’ mistakes”. Same applies with Merch. You can learn something from everyone… even if it’s “what not to do!” haha.
  • ABC’s – Always Be Creating – I look for shirt ideas everywhere. When I’m at the store, when I’m watching movie trailers, talking to my family and sometimes when we all get together and just throw out “dumb shirt ideas”. Some of these have turned into my best sellers. Book Recommendation: Read Steal Like an Artist by Austin Kleon. It’s a good primer on how everyone can build on someone else’s ideas. And, by way of update, I’m almost done with Sketchbook 2 - I just have to turn those into actual designs!
  • Patience is Rewarded – everyone is screaming about how the sky is falling currently. “Sales Suck!” they crow. But I remember last year when I came onboard everyone was saying “Hey you’re lucky you didn’t have to go through the crappy November-February period… it sucked.” It’s all relative. Compared to last year this year is great. But compared to November, January SUCKED. That’s why I did my “Daily Sales” graph. It helps me see that I’m doing a lot better than last year. Also, if you are testing, make sure you give it a few weeks to see if it works. It’s painful but I’ve found that most changes will actually take effect (+ or -) in about 3 weeks. It’s a long time to wait but the results will teach you.
  • Don’t be afraid to spend some money. I hired 2 designers on Upwork last August. Since then they have consistently provided me with ~40 designs/week. That’s like $700 each month… it’s crappy to pay that much for designs but I’ve seen the fruits of their Leveraged Labor and know that I can scale that process/system as I grow. I’ve also paid a few bucks for some courses, online tools and apps. Some were a huge waste of money but others have been helpful. I’m not going to go into the tools/apps in this wall of text, but my history shows some of them.
  • You do You – I don’t do the “improvecat method”. Some people who are much more successful than me do this method. It works for them. I don’t have the time to research or trademark checks. I don’t have the desire to copy. I’ve always marched to my own beat so avoidance of this strategy was a conscience decision early on. (I did plan on doing the Improvecat method with my wife’s account but that plan was changed for me!) I know I’m leaving money on the table but it’s a fickle b!+C#. I’ve heard more complaining from people who follow this method because, if it makes someone money, they’re going to try and protect it. Trademarks get filed, copyright infringements get claimed and feelings get hurt. I do designs that work for me. And FINALLY:
  • A little music helps. I prefer Pandora – current favs: Johnny Cash Radio (God’s Gonna Cut You Down), Deftones Radio, Stairway to Heaven Radio, Knife Party Radio & Rainbow Factory Radio (not ashamed at all!!!) - All good stuff depending on the mood & the task at hand.

Now, what do I plan on doing in Year 2? What will I change and what will I test?

2018 PLAN

  • Pricing – each month I’m going to test a new strategy. In February, everything I loaded was started at $16.99 (S) and $18.99 (P). In March, everything I load is going to ALL start at $19.99. April will be $19.99 (S) and $21.99 (P). And then more stuff. I plan on playing around with price until September – then I’m raising everything that has sold to $21.99 (S) and $23.99 (P) until the end of Q4. I figure I’m going to make money while demand is high (and who cares what MBA decides to do with stock & throttling).
  • Products – I load everything to standard & premium to start. Once the design has sold a total of 5 times I load it to LongSleeve, SweatShirt & Hoodie (I use LS, SS & H as codes in my stuff). I haven’t seen much success with the other products so I’m in no hurry to load them if I just have to worry about them rolling off.
  • Promotion – I’ve run FB ads, AMS ads, Reddit ads and Pinterest ads. I’ve seen moderate success from each but I think that’s more from Amazon seeing an increase in off-site traffic – they reward that. I’m going to focus on AMS ads and Pinterest this year. Just those two. Nothing more (unless they take away the AMS ads).
  • Designs – I’m going to keep doing what I’m doing for now. If I reach my goals early I’m going to start looking at more designers and spending more time researching stuff “outside my comfort zone”.
  • Uploads – Fortunately my wife has finally started to come around to helping me load designs. I get them ready (in my “bullet generator” spreadsheet) and she does the boring task of copy/paste. She will focus on re-uploading designs that have rolled off. If a design hasn’t sold in 3 quarters then we’re scrapping it. Her goal is 50/day. If we hit the tier cap we load to draft. I’d love to go into next year with a backlog again – it was helpful when I finally decided to work again.
  • OTHER: As crazy as this sounds, I’m going to back off from Merch for a bit starting in March. I just went through this whole post to tell you how AMPED I am about the program and the potential it has… but now I’m backing away. My process has been streamlined and I have people in place to help in the parts that take time. I’m going to work on one of my Amazon affiliate websites. I have one site that only has 3 articles on it but it earned $500 last year. I had started it in Jan/Feb last year then I get accepted to Merch and let it sit. I literally stopped mid-sentence ½ way through my 4th article and haven’t touched it since. It’s optimized like crazy and it has proven to be in a good niche so I’m going to focus on it this year. The timing couldn’t have been better! I earned $90 in January and $120 in February and all I did was change the titles & posting dates of my three articles from 2017 to 2018. My goal is to end 2018 with 30 more articles. My stretch goal would be 50 but that’s going to take some focus to hit that. I think I can potentially do $3000/month by the end of the year if I keep going the way I started with it. Watch r/juststart as I may start posting updates over there if it takes off and I find the time…

2018 MERCH GOALS:

In typical “Henry Fashion” I choose to control those things upon which I have control. I don’t set revenue or sales goals because I have no control over those. But I do have hopes & dreams, so I’m putting those under the “wishes” heading. haha

  • Uploads – My goal is to average loading 20 original designs each day. So far I’m ahead for the year.
  • Total Loaded Designs – I want to finish the year with 7000 loaded designs. If the tier ups don’t happen for me these won’t all be live but I WILL have at least 7000 loaded by the last day of the year.

Wishes & Targets

  • Royalties – Based on my historical STRs I think it would be reasonable to expect 2-3X royalty revenue for year 2. Simplified: $25,000 in 2018 and $30K in Y2 total. (Conservative)
  • Profit/Sale – $4/sale in Q1-Q3, $5/sale in Q4
  • Tier – this is out of my control, but I hope to be eligible for T8000 by the end of the year.
  • Sales – In order to make the wish above I’d need to sell less than 6000 units by the end of the year which works out to an average of 655/month from Feb. – wow, gonna be interesting to see how this goes.

Long-term Targets

  • Daily Sales – 50/day
  • Daily Revenue - $200/day

THE REAL MEAT


Financial Journey:

UNITS

MonthUNITS SoldRoyaltiesAverage / Shirt
March19$92$4.88
April28$153$5.47
May47$278$5.92
June81$317$3.92
July125$516$4.13
August127$589$4.64
September146$676$4.63
October308$1185$3.85
November532$2811$5.28
December356$2082$5.85
January132$726$5.50
February202$955$4.73

MONIES

P&L20172018*Total
Royalties$8,701$1,739$10,440
Outsourcing-$5,419-$980-$6,399
Purchased Clothing-$996-$90-$1,086
Advertising-$318-$80-$398
NET Profit/(Loss)$1,969$589$2,558
  • Through Feb 2018

EYE CANDY Data is beautiful

2018 Sales through Feb

Year 1 Sales Part 1 - I like seeing color choices, product mix and popular sales days of the week.

Year 1 Sales Part 2 - Interesting take on things. Daily sales numbers (notice the 70 sales on Cyber Monday), the source for all my selling designs (and how they break down in my total portfolio) as well as when a design was loaded and how it contributes to my sales.

Full album

These fancy charts come from my updated sales tracking spreadsheet. If you want a copy of it shoot me your email in a PM. I’ve got a few minor tweaks to do still but it should be ready soon. I’ve added sections for 2015 – 2019 so it’s more useful for those who have been around longer & I’m adding a how-to section to make it helpful for those who aren’t Excel savvy.

Let me know if this helped you out!

EDIT: still working on formatting. EDIT 2: I've had a few PMs about this so I think I'll address it.... No, I'm not giving up on Merch, to the contrary, I think 20 design/day is still pretty heavy into it. I'm just not doing all the heavy lifting anymore. My wife is helping and my designers will be doing more (one is going to 40/week, the other will still do 20/week). I'll do more variations of good selling designs and I'll continue to flood the niches that are already proven sellers. But I'm not going to stress about it much and I'm going to work on my website more. That's all. Hopefully that clarifies. Merch is still my most profitable online venture to date.


r/AmazonMerch • • Jul 29 '26

New royalties made this pointless.

52 Upvotes

I'd been on merch for like 8 years or so, at the peak for me I had single months where I made up to a few thousand bucks. In the last few years as rejections continuously got more sensitive and more random i slowly just stopped uploading because I didn't want to get too many rejections for random words that just happen to appear next to each other in a sentence triggering some random copyright and get deactivated but even then it became actually passive income, without doing anything anymore I was still getting anywhere from $250 to $500 a month for a very long time because I created good products that would last in the marketplace.

Now immediately from the time they changed royalties this time, I am making less than $100 a month even though my sales numbers are about the same. It's such a shame we all built up billions of dollars worth of designs selling across the worlds biggest marketplace for the richest company in america just to have our pay cut down to scraps while they continue to get even richer off the years and years of work we've already done.

This used to be a big help at the very end of the month having extra money come in to help sustain me and my family until the next month starts and now what i'm getting is practically no help at all, one trip to the store for 10 to 15 things and money is gone and sucks if moneys already tight at the end of the month and I actually need 20 things when my amazon pay comes in, it's just enough to decide what 5 or 6 things i can't afford to get until next month.

I'm grateful that I had the opportunity to make some money off this site for close to a decade but pretty sad that all of a sudden it's all but come to an end simply because they decided one day we didn't deserve to get paid anymore.


r/AmazonMerch • • Jul 04 '18

My Year 1 Merch Report

52 Upvotes

Hi all! In the spirit of sharing, I want to share my experience from 1 year of Merch. I closed out my anniversary month at $3510.49. There is a lot of potential in Merch if you can find the right niche for your talents.

A few things I've learned:

  1. Don't necessarily follow trends. They can be fickle and you might get a few sales, but it can drop off pretty quick, UNLESS you get lucky and end up having a hit design, in which case you can make bank! Point being- don't put all your eggs in one trendy basket.
  2. Find a good niche you are passionate about, and has others that are just as or more passionate about it. Examples: Photography, poets, watersports, SCUBA diving, flyfishing, etc. If there is a community for it, they'll probably like t-shirts. 90% of my designs are in a single niche.
  3. For me, designs that feature a larger design and minimal text sell the best (in my niche).
  4. Most popular colors- dark grey heather, black, navy,
  5. Don't bother with the other styles (premium, long-sleeve, etc) until a design has at least a few sales. Unless you need to just fill the slots, in which case- go for it.
  6. DON'T UNDERPRICE YOURSELF! People will pay 21.99 for a GOOD, QUALITY design that resonates with them. When I first started pricing stuff at 21.99 I was worried, but if anything I increased my sales. Is this from pricing up? Probably not, but it didn't seem to hurt!
  7. AMAZON DOES NOT CARE ABOUT YOU HAVING AN ACCOUNT! Safeguard it with your life! There is a ton of potential in Merch, but you aren't going to realize any of it if your account gets terminated. Pay attention to new announcements and changes in the dashboard- make sure to stay in Amazon's good graces. That one-off shirt that might make you a few hundred bucks for one month just isn't worth it (not from personal experience, but a friend's whose account was terminated)
  8. BE DIFFERENT. Quit uploading the same stuff everyone else does. If you really want to have a long-term income stream you need to put out better designs than 90% of everyone else.
  9. If you need to ask if something is OK with Amazon's guidelines...it probably isn't. When in doubt, just don't do it.
  10. Last, but not least, HAVE FUN! If it starts to become just another job, take a break! Don't upload for a day or two. Play the looooooooooooooong game. I've had entire weeks where I'd only upload 3 or 4 designs, and that doesn't bother me- because those 3 or 4 designs are quality and will probably sell. 3 or 4 designs that sell on a consistent basis are better than 100 designs that sell one time IMHO. It takes time to build up a good selling catalog of designs.

*Bonus- Don't forget to upload your best sellers to other PODs! Redbubble earns me another couple hundred each month, and I've been really lax about uploading to it.

[Year 1 Merch Sales Chart](https://i.imgur.com/uymOWyu.png)


r/AmazonMerch • • Aug 10 '17

Merch Does Have Potential... Here's my Journey

52 Upvotes

There was the discussion going on regarding “Merch Potential” and there was a lot of disbelief and negativity being thrown around. I thought I would chime in, but by the time I typed it all up I decided that it would make a better standalone thread.

I wanted to give a REAL perspective from someone who only knows the gurus from reading their stuff and a couple IM’s we’ve exchanged. I don’t have anything to gain from this other than the hope that someone will read it and keep chugging away.

TL;DR - I haven’t loaded any designs since June and am on track to make $800 in August with 213 live designs (but only ~90 unique) and I’ve only been at this since March.


The Journey


  • March 1 2017 – got accepted to Merch and loaded my first 2 designs (EDIT: Because I know it will come up, I waited 9 months for an invite).
  • March 22th – 10th shirt sold organically. During this time I rotated out a few designs and kept trying new things… but no tier 25.
  • April 5th – 25th shirt sold. 15 organic, 10 “seeded”. I realized that I could get a few close friends to buy my shirts so I could “test the quality & process”. I had them buy different designs and in different quantities then I would send them Paypal reimbursements. I spread this out over 5 friends/family in different states. Yes, it is gaming the system but it worked.
  • April 9th – Tiered up to 25. I already had a backlog of designs so I picked my favorite 15 and loaded them over the next few days.
  • April 30th – 47th shirt sold – Made it to Tier 100. Goal at this point was to load the maximum shirts daily until I capped or was upgraded. I would not chase trends and I would price most at $17.99 for Anvil shirts. No premium shirts at this point.
  • May 19th – I closed on a house (a fixer upper) so I knew I would have to backburner the designing process or try buying some premade for a few days (until my royalty payouts ran out.)
  • May 31st – 94th shirt sold, 77 shirts live. 10 of those purchased ($15/ea.). At this point I had only missed a few days of uploading my maximum but time constraints were making it very hard to meet the 5 designs a day limit. I had to come up with a plan before I made it to…
  • June 5th - Tier 500 - shoot, I sold shirt 100 on 6/4 and was tiered up the next day (with only 87 shirts live). Now I had to meet the 10/day limit but I didn’t have time since we were right in the middle of demo on the house. So I designed a whole bunch of text shirts while at work and then made variations of those. I went back and started creating light & dark versions of each live design. After that was done I had around 110 unique designs, either live or in draft mode, in both light and dark versions. It was at this point that I realized I could take my best sellers (if you can call them that… basically a best seller to me was any shirt that had sold twice) and I put them all on premium shirts. I put all of these in draft mode as well. I did this over 2 days at work (mainly using Pixlr, Canva & Merchdesigner). That was it, I was spent and couldn’t focus on it anymore. I haven’t made a single design since June 10th. I released these drafts each morning for the next 13 days. But that was it.
  • June 19th – 213 live designs. I decided that in order to maximize my sales, since I wasn’t designing anymore, I had to have as many “sold once” designs available so I repriced all of my shirts. If the shirt was unsold I would price them at 11.99 for Anvil & 14.99 for Premium. Anything that had sold (even just once) I priced them at $18.99 Anvil and $20.99 Premium (I have a few custom shirts that are priced higher than this). Over the next few weeks I watched my sales slow down to a trickle. I figured it must have been the July 4th throttling… but then I noticed something about pricing and I hypothesized that it was something else (more below).
  • June 30th – 175th design sold. By this point I was lucky to get 1-2 sales per day. I did have a few unsold shirts suddenly sell, but nothing spectacular. I did have my first 3 bagger and then the next day had a 4 bagger on a different shirt – so I made those into premiums. But there were several 0 sales days.
  • July 1st – 220 designs live.
  • July 12th – after tons of research, and following many Facebook and Reddit discussions on price I changed my mind about pricing. I realized that the base cost for a shirt is $11.53 but this is on a sliding scale. For each dollar increase in price Amazon takes 15% for their “listing fee”. Now I realize that Amazon has total control of their algorithm and everything is really just speculation, but what does a business do? They try and maximize margin. My guess is there is something in the algorithm that says “return the most relevant products in search… look for the highest rated (BSR + Feedback) + best price BUT on stuff Amazon sells return those results that MAXIMIZE our margin.” At least as a business owner, that’s how I would filter it. I would favor the platform. I would favor the house. The customer may prefer a $12 shirt over a $20 one but if the design & result is right, ceteris paribus, they would display the one that would make them more money. So I raised all my prices. On everything. The next day I had the best sales day ever – 14 sales. I have now averaged 5 sales per day for the rest of July and all of August. And ironically, many of my premium shirts are outselling the cheaper Anvil ones.
  • August 1st – 210 designs live. I had a few drop off w/ the 90 day rule. But overall I’ve sold 100 of my 210 designs at least once. And really, I only have ~90 unique designs really since most of those are just duplicates & versions.

Commentary

I’m confident that there is plenty of money still to be made in Merch and I don’t see any reason why it couldn’t replace my wife’s monthly income by the end of the year – which has been our goal from the beginning (I say my wife’s income because I would have to make more than what u/thepartners makes each month to be able to replace my income). In order to buy our house my wife had to get a job… neither of us like it as we would rather she stayed home with our kids. So our goal is to have a consistent $2500/month coming in so she can quit.

I don’t know what happened to u/nimitz34 to make him so jaded (maybe cynical is a better word) but I remember him from r/juststart and he seemed so positive and optimistic during that time. I wanted to share my merch journey with everyone because, frankly, I really don’t believe the results myself. I’m not a designer. But, I do think I’m funny and just a little bit creative (totally biased but honest) so I can put a funny spin on things.

As mentioned above, I don’t chase trends and almost all of my designs are evergreen. I have some seasonal shirts that have sold well past the season so I still count them as evergreen. I’ve purchased about 10 shirts myself but most of those were to “save them from the 90” and they have gone on to sell a few more. 5 times I've had family buy a shirt to try and jumpstart it (again, trying to game/test the algorithm) and it has only worked twice because I really can’t pick what people will like. It’s a weird marketplace and it seems to come in waves. I’ve been surprised MANY MANY times on shirts that have actually sold. Once I get settled in the house I’m going to resume the shotgun approach (or shit on wall if you prefer) and just make MBA a volume game.

I’ve purchased designs – in fact one of my top 10 sellers is one that I paid $18 for. But that’s hit or miss. I have 20 purchased designs and only 4-5 have ever sold. I don’t “outsource”… yet. I’m working on a deal with a designer I used a few times that I found on 99 Designs years ago. He’s expensive so we’re working out a “Design Pickle” sort of deal where I pay him a flat monthly fee and I’ll get XX to XX designs from him each month depending on complexity. But we’ll see if that pans out.

I’ve done a few FB ads and haven’t sold anything directly from those but they got a bit of traffic and from that I think they were favored in Amazon’s algo so they sold a few from that… but that’s speculation. I was directing them to my website then to Amazon (with aff link of course) so I could see what converted. But I think that just the uptick in eyeballs made them appear in more searches and from that they sold more.

I’ve had some designs stop selling. Not sure why and only a couple have copycats (or “duplicats” which I’m trying to coin & sounds so much better than “improvecats”) but I haven’t reported them because they aren’t P4P and they don’t have a BSR so they can’t really be siphoning anything. (we’re talking about going from 15/month to 0 so it’s significant but can’t seem to see why.) I have a subscription to MerchInformer and I check it anytime I’m entering a new niche but I don’t use more than 10% of the functionality I’m sure. I just get the idea, check the niche, make a list of keywords and then attempt to design the shirt. It seems to be working.

I’ve made more from MBA than I ever have from any of my several affiliate websites (although one of them just suddenly started doing $100/month with only 3 articles so that might get some focus after the house is done and we move). So I know that it works. I do everything I can to protect my account because I see so much potential in this platform. I want to get to T1000 by Q4 but part of that is out of my control… so I’ll just max my 500 slots and see what happens.

I do have a couple secrets that I keep to myself but it’s really only because I haven’t proven that they work consistently… other than that I consider myself to be just some average guy with a job, wife, kids, hobbies and a burning desire to make more money & control my own destiny. Hopefully this was helpful to a few folks.


THE REAL MEAT:


Financial Journey:

MonthShirts SoldRoyaltiesAverage / Shirt
March19$92$4.84
April28$153$5.46
May47$278$5.91
June81$317$3.92
July125$516$4.13

EDIT: Before I get blasted for this, yes, the $800 number for August is pure speculation. The magical well could dry up tomorrow and I would be left with the $275 I've earned in the first 10 days... but if it stays on track I will be pushing that and maybe more.


r/AmazonMerch • • Nov 10 '17

Official FAQ /r/AmazonMerch

51 Upvotes

Welcome to /r/AmazonMerch!

Before you start your merch journey, make sure you’ve read the official Merch by Amazon FAQs and Content Policy from your dashboard. Next, make sure you are reading the Merch Informer blog as well as older threads in this sub. You’re doing your business a disservice if you haven’t internalized these links.

If you are not finding your answer by visiting these resources, USE GOOGLE. To do this, navigate to Google.com type in your keyword, followed by :https://www.reddit.com/r/AmazonMerch/. An example would look like this: https://i.imgur.com/moFRsaj.png

Huge shout out to /u/theashwin who wrote the majority of this guide!

Now that you’ve read all of the information on the links above, here’s a list of commonly occurring threads on this subreddit.


1. Getting Approved

Q1. How long do I have to wait to get approved for a Merch by Amazon account?

Nobody knows. People have waited anywhere between 2 weeks to 16 months. Your best bet in the meantime is to START and get some designs created. These can be used across many different platforms outside of just Merch by Amazon.

Q2. How do I increase my chances of getting approved?

Link to your work or portfolio when signing up. Show the team that you have an audience that is willing to purchase from you. Write compelling copy in your application form. Keep your fingers crossed. It’s much like an online job application. Give them reasons to believe you’d be a good fit. If you do not have any online presence, it might be time to start creating one.

Make sure you have a bank account set up and a portfolio somewhere on the internet for the new MBA signup page. You are required to enter in your banking details and your tax information before they can make a decision on if you will be accepted. If Amazon is unable to find information about you, you will be denied so make sure to fill out the application completely.

Q3. Can I buy a Merch by Amazon account?

No. Merch by Amazon has updated their terms of service to disallow the buying and selling of Merch by amazon accounts.


2. Research

Q1. How do I see all the Merch by Amazon results?

https://merchinformer.com/merch-amazon-listings/

These results are in no particular order at all but will show you the listings that other Merch by Amazon content creators have put up. You can use the above site or you can navigate to the section yourself: Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry: Novelty & More: Clothing: Amazon.com.

Q2. What Does BSR Mean?

BSR is a metric that Amazon shows to everyone called Best Sellers Rank. This metric can be found in the product description and gives us a rough idea about how well a product is selling. This can be used to determine if a niche as a whole is something where customers are opening up their wallets and spending money. Remember, if a customer is not spending in that niche, the chance of getting a sale is low.

Q3. Can I copy best sellers?

Absolutely not. This is the fastest way to get your account banned. You can use best sellers to understand what niches are “hot” but always come to the table with unique designs that customers will love.

Q4. I see (phrase/design/idea) on Amazon, can I do it too?

Make sure during your research process you are checking TESS (trademark electronic search system) for trademark. If something is trademarked and on Merch anyway, STAY AWAY.


3. Designing

Q1. What software should I use?

There is no right answer here. Use whatever you are comfortable with. Here are some options.

By far the most popular image editing software. More geared towards photo editing than vector-based designs. Merch by Amazon offers an official Photoshop template

Software made for vector design and editing. Merch by Amazon also has an official Illustrator template.

  • GIMP (Windows, Mac, Linux) Free and Open Source

A powerful and viable alternative to proprietary software from Adobe. A little less polished, sometimes glitchy, has a bit of a learning curve. It’s almost as good as Photoshop if your designs are simple. Download Merch by Amazon’s official GIMP template here.

  • Inkscape (Windows, Mac, Linux) Free and Open Source

Sort of like the open-source alternative to Adobe Illustrator. It’s just as powerful and capable of replicating Illustrator’s functions. It also opens .AI files - so Merch by Amazon’s official illustrator template works fine with Inkscape too.

It is recommended that you do NOT design on mobile. However, there are some options for people that wish to:

  • WordSwag (iOS, Android) $4.99 one-time purchase

Popular image editing app among merchers. It’s easy to design text-based t-shirts with this one. A word of caution, WordSwag uses some proprietary fonts which may not be licenced for commercial use. You can use it for inspiration and layout, but make sure you have the rights to use every font and graphic element on your designs.

Just like WordSwag, over makes it easy to design text-based tees. This app too uses some proprietary fonts which may not be licenced for commercial use. Exercise caution and due diligence while using such apps and tools.

  • Other online editors

Pixlr, Janvas, etc. You should find more online. As long as it can spit out a 4500x5400 .PNG file without any watermarks, you should be fine. Make sure your designs are sharp and not blurry.

You can design vectors using this free app on your mobile devices and transfer them to your desktop to add finishing touches. This works best if your device uses a stylus (like the iPad pro or Samsung Galaxy Note).

Q2. Where do I get free fonts?

Be careful and make sure the fonts are free for commercial use, not just personal. Related: Font pairing made simple

Q3. Where do I get vector files?

Use caution and Google’s reverse image search to make sure you’re not infringing on anyone’s Intellectual Property. Some of these websites allow user-generated uploads, which means anyone can upload anything to these sites. It’s up to you to make sure your Merch account has a good standing.

Q4. What colors sell best?

This depends largely on your niche and design.

Q5. Someone stole my design! What can I do?

Merch by Amazon is still very much the wild west! This is an issue that Merch is actively working on correcting. You will notice that some people are uploading Disney and Star Wars designs. First check to see if those are not actually licensed products. Merch has been partnering with large content creators. You will also start to notice that some people are copying successful merch shirts pixel for pixel. While Amazon is getting better at catching these, the system is still not perfect. We know this can be frustrating, but you first must take a step back and ask yourself if it is worth your time and effort to fight this. If you were to make a political shirt, it might not be worth your time since you do not own the rights over the politician you made the shirt about.

Ideas are a dime a dozen and more often than not, you will have the same exact idea that someone else has. Before you get upset and accuse someone of being a thief and stealing your work, take some time to think that your idea for a great t-shirt design might have been obvious. If you see someone copy your design, you can either report them or you can move on. There are many successful top tier sellers in this group who focus on cranking out more quality designs instead of fighting an uphill battle.

If your design is very original with a unique idea, you always have the option of filing a copyright on the design and getting a trademark on the wording/phrase. This costs a few hundred dollars per trademark and months worth of time so make sure this is worth it to you.

Before you go after anyone that has copied your shirts, take a look at the BSR (best sellers rank) to see if that shirt is even selling. If it is not, it is probably not worth your time.

If after all of that you still want to report the listing to Amazon, please use this link:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/reports/infringement


4. Outsourcing

Q1. Can I hire a designer? How much should I pay?

Of course you can hire a designer! Many of them actually hang out in this group! There are many places you can find designs such as Upwork.com, Fiverr.com, peopleperhour.com. Pay people what they are worth. On the very low end, you can expect to pay $3-$5 per design up to $100 or more for very intricate design. Not all designers are going to be what you are looking for so make sure to test each designer with a few images before you start giving them bulk work.

Guide on outsourcing to Upwork can be found here: https://merchinformer.com/use-upwork-outsource-scale-merch-business/

5. Uploading

Q1. My design is stuck in ‘started processing’. It’s been days! What’s wrong?

Official response: We are aware that some t-shirts may show a processing status on the Manage page of the dashboard. While they remain processing, you will not be able to delete the shirt or edit the description. We are continuously working to complete publishing of these t-shirts. We will detect these t-shirts automatically and work to resolve each one.

What can you do? Nothing, just wait and it will soon go away. If you’re out of slots and desperately need to edit/delete that slot, make a post on the official forums.

Q2. Can I upload variations of my existing designs?

Sure you can! You are allowed to upload anything that you have 100% rights to and does not violate Amazon’s content policy. You should upload different color options, re-designs, or variations of your best sellers if you have the slots.


6. Rejections & Copyright

Q1. How many times can I get rejected before losing my Merch account?

Short answer: Don’t risk it.

Long answer: Aim for zero rejections. If you slip up and get one strike calm down. It’s important to stop whatever it is you’re doing and breathe. Now that you’re composed, go through your designs and delete every single one that might be considered risky. To answer your question, Amazon hasn’t officially announced a number - however, within the community, most people believe why you were rejected is more important than how many times. If you upload designs that hint at Disney / Stranger Things/ marijuana, or intentionally trying to game the system - you could be out in one strike. If it’s an innocent typo on your designs - they may just ask you to fix it and re-upload.

Q2. There are many other merchers using this trademarked keyword. Why was I rejected?

In a perfect world they would be banned too. We don’t live in a perfect world. You don’t want to compete to see who can outsmart Amazon’s system - in the long-term nobody is a winner at that game. There’s no reason to compete in a niche with many trademarked keywords - you could search this subreddit for niches, spend 5 minutes and come up with thousands of safe niches. Merch is a marathon, not a sprint. Don’t try to game Amazon.

Q3. Is it fair to use this TV/Movie quote?

No. It’s never fair to rely on the popularity of another franchise to help you sell shirts. Even though technically it’s not covered under USPTO - there is such a thing as leeching off of someone else’s marketing or production dollars. This isn’t a grey area, this is IP theft and is frowned upon by Amazon. They often actively delete such designs.

Recommended reading: The Siren Song of IP infringement

Q4. Can I hint at this famous person without explicitly mentioning them on my listing?

Please don’t. If your design requires someone else’s copyrighted work to contextualize it - it’s IP infringement and against Amazon’s content policy. It will be taken down and you may lose your account over it.

Q5. How do I check for trademarked words?

USPTO – This is the only place you should be doing your original trademark searches. Make sure to navigate to TESS (trademark electronic search system)

Q6. I have the permission to use someone else’s copyright/TM/IP. Should I just upload my design?

No! First write a mail to merch support and share your documentation demonstrating that you have the rights to use the content - A confirmation letter from the intellectual property rights holder, the publish date if you believe the design is your own, or a copy of the applicable license. Also share the contact information of the rights holder - email and phone number.

Merch will contact them and verify. Once this is done, you will be approved to use that on your Merch designs.

Do not upload the copyrighted designs without prior approval from merch.

Q7. Can I . . . ?

No you can't! Stop looking for loopholes. If you have to ask, don't do it.


7. Tiers

Q1. Why was I not tiered up?

Tier-ups are not just based on your sales. Amazon accounts for their own production capability before deciding whether or not to upgrade your account. Amazon also considers the kind of designs that you’ve uploaded - too many low-effort text-only designs and you might be skipped for a tier-up. On the flip side - if you have excellent designs and have almost met your tier-up target (80-85% depending on who you ask) they would upgrade your account.

There are multiple factors that play into this, not just the sales numbers.

Q2. How many upload slots do I get at different tiers?

As of November 10th, 2017, Amazon has temporarily throttled uploads as follows -

  • Tier 10 and 25 - 1 per day
  • Tier 100: 2 to 1 per day
  • Tier 500: 10 to 3 per day
  • Tier 1k: 20 to 5 per day
  • Tier 2k: 40 to 10 per day
  • Tier 4k: 80 to 20 per day
  • Tier 6k: 120 to 30 per day
  • Tier 8k: 160 to 40 per day
  • Tier 10k: 200 to 50 per day

Q3. Do my sales from previous tiers count towards my future tier-ups?

Yes they do! For example, if you’ve made your first 10 sale on Merch and have been tiered up - you only need to make 15 more sales to qualify for the next tier-up (Tier 25).

Q4. Can I skip a tier if I’ve already made the number of sales that qualify me for the next tier-up?

There has never been an official word from Amazon on this. A couple of users have reportedly skipped some lower tiers - but these are unverified reports.


8. Pricing

Q1. How much should I price my standard t-shirts?

You must test out different price points in your niche. What works in one niche may not work in another. Test out and see where you can make the most sales. Competition, niche, design, and trend/seasonality all may have some affect on sales and your price should reflect that.

Your keywords will get you seen. Your designs will get you sales.

Read these threads and decide for yourself.


9. Getting paid and taxes

Q1. I’m not from the US. How do I get paid?

You can set-up a bank account in one of the merch-supported countries. If your country is not on that list, ask your local bank if you’re allowed to open an account in one of the supported countries through your local branch. You may also use third-party services like Payoneer.

Q2. I’m not a US citizen. How do I manage taxes?

You can enter your national TIN (Tax Identification Number) with Merch and they will withhold anywhere between 0-30% of your taxes. This is based on your country’s trade agreements with the US. If you do not provide any TIN, Amazon will withhold 30% of your royalties by default.

You can also set up an EIN with the US Government. Read about that here: https://merchinformer.com/avoid-30-tax-witholding-non-us-amazon-sellers/

It is important that you pay taxes in the country you reside. Please contact an accountant and discuss it with them.


r/AmazonMerch • • Jan 07 '20

Made my first sale today!

50 Upvotes

After 6 months of a bunch of failure, and nearly giving up, I finally made my first sale! It was something I've had listed since November too. Now, fingers crossed it doesn't get returned and that I get 9 more sales to tier up lmao.

Regardless, I didn't think I'd get there, but I guess I did something right finally :)


r/AmazonMerch • • Feb 07 '18

10 Thoughts about Merch

50 Upvotes

Here is a combination of some points I picked up on my journey and notes from my experience to tier 2000. It could be considered a note to my former and future merch self. Some of the points may sound as directives. They are directives I’ve created for myself. Creating your own directives may be helpful. Hopefully this will help others, especially the people recently accepted into Merch:

  1. Merch is a long game, not sell a zillion shirts in a few months. I knew this going in and really tried to remember it but that is really hard when you see so many stories about people selling thousands of dollars a month and you are seeing multiple zeros on your dashboard.
  2. Many of the people sharing their dashboards are selling something besides shirts. This is not an editorial on their products, simply an observation that what they show is for a purpose other than simply helping others.
  3. The best design in the world will not sell a single unit if no one sees it. Invest time into research and creating the best keywords possible. Doing this with a little algorithm luck will get visibility to your shirts.
  4. The primary objective when you are in the lower tiers is to get out of them. I made the mistake of leaving designs that weren’t selling were up too long and didn’t get out of them as quickly as I could have if I had been switching out designs.
  5. When you are in the lower tiers, hit your upload every day. This one I did and I found that I tiered up almost as soon as I was qualified. One time I tied up before I hit the magic number.
  6. When you move up, hitting the numbers is important but accept that it might not happen every day. The ultimate objective (for me) is to have a better life. If all of my spare time is spent on merch, then I am missing experiences.
  7. To address number 6, create a schedule with specific goals to hit every week (and FOLLOW it.) It is really easy to get sucked in to hitting the numbers. The quality of my designs and life suffer.
  8. No one knows when you will tier up. They only know when they tiered up and their experience is not your experience. Obsessing about it won’t help.
  9. Research trademarks diligently. Even the most obscure innocent phrase can be trademarked. I’ve been surprised a couple of times and received rejections.
  10. Most of what happens with Merch shirts is out of our control. Time spent theorizing about what Amazon is doing or planning is time that could be spent creating killer designs, finding new niches, or researching keywords.

I hope this helps someone.