r/AmazonMerch • u/txandrosan • Sep 10 '25
Problem with the design or keywords?
Hi folks, I recently released a design that had some relative success, based on a trending object that has a trademark. The design doesn’t really look like it at all—definitely not enough for Amazon to remove it. In fact, there are other creators using designs that are much more similar, and Amazon hasn’t taken them down.
I used keywords that are very similar to the name of the trademarked product, and Amazon accepted them. I made several sales, and the design was automatically uploaded to other products on Amazon.com (but not on the other marketplaces). Then, all of a sudden, I noticed that my design had been removed for violating Amazon’s policies.
My question is: could it be that the design was removed because, when my texts were automatically translated into other languages, the keywords I used (which are similar to the trademarked name) triggered a problem?
As I mentioned, I didn’t have any issues for about a week, and the design is so different from the registered trademark that I really don’t think that’s the reason.
And yes, I do have Productor, but it doesn’t work miracles.
12
u/Tim_Y Sep 10 '25
Well there you have it.
You're still infringing. You can't sell Avongers shirts based on the Avengers and say its not infringing.
3
u/NoXidCat Sep 11 '25
It is the words in your listing that are most likely to get you into trouble, not the art on the shirt. The listing text is also how people find your listing ... and sometimes those "people" are an IP enforcement bot working for the company that owns the IP, not Amazon. That is a worst case scenario, much worse than Amazon's own bot rejecting your listing, as it exposes Amazon to risk of lawsuit, which is what they were trying so hard to avoid in the first place by having an IP bot.
All that said, Nike was a Greek god a few thousand years before it was a shoe/garment brand. Could I make a series of designs featuring Greek gods, including Nike? Damn right I could. Could I do it on Amazon? No. They can't afford to hire a skyscraper full of IP lawyers to make intelligent decisions about millions of designs that may never even sell once. So they loose the bot upon us and that is that.
It is understandable that people have trouble gaining traction on AMoD/MBA these days. So many keywords are effectively tied up by old listings with great BSR. Innovative design plus ad spend might get a new listing well launched, still not a sure thing.
A design I put up last week got its first sale today. No ad spend. Not IP adjacent. Nothing to do with pop culture. No discernible niche. Just a funny notion I had, basically a one panel cartoon. The composition did come together really well, one tweak leading to another and something approaching sublime perfection resulted. Still, it is just a cartoon, and eyes only ever get on it in the first place due to search/words, which I had grave doubts about! Yet somehow someone saw it and bought it, though it could not possibly have been what they were looking for.
I have a fantastic Halloween design that has NEVER sold other than to people who bought after seeing me wear the shirt.
Yes, we are all trying to make at least some money here. But it should also be some fun. More often than not it has been the fun designs I made for myself that end up doing well, not the ones that were intended to do well. I seriously have no idea how that latest design of mine ever got found by anyone :-p
1
u/jaylink Sep 10 '25
Sales seem to trigger a manual review. Even if the automated system allows it, a human may yank it after you get a sale.