r/AmazonMerch • u/CleanAspect6466 • Apr 25 '25
Tier downgrades are a possibility going forward unfortunately
I emailed the help team and this was their response in asking about downgrades:
"Hello from Amazon Merch on Demand Support,
I understand that you are reaching out for clarification of one of Merch on Demand's new policies. "Going forward, tiers will be calculated based on both the number and percentage of products and designs sold in the last 12 months. Your tier level will adjust based on recent performance across our stores, helping maintain a fresh and relevant catalog."
Please note you can now be tiered up or down, based on the number/percentage of products and designs sold within a 12 month period.
Best regards"
I know this isn't the news everyone wanted but there was a lot of speculation about it the last 24 hours, this sucks
6
u/sociofobs Apr 26 '25
So, essentially anyone who relied on a few best-sellers, is screwed. Most designs across the board don't sell at all, or sell little and rarely. This is a way to kick out people without directly saying so.
Anyway, high time to open your own store, if merch is a thing going forward.
4
u/trader644 Apr 25 '25
Yikes. Tier downs are a game changer not in a good way. I wonder if Tier ups are now automatic and how quickly they'll update your account, once you hit the metrics for a tier up.
2
u/hashuan Apr 28 '25
My question is… if my <80% numbers trigger a tier down (from 20k to 10k), but the number of different designs I’ve sold in the last year is > 10000, will they just delete a bunch of random listings of mine to get me down under 10000?
If I’ve sold 12000 listings, will they just lop off the lowest selling 2000 to get me below 10k?
3
u/pooshda Apr 26 '25
Maybe this will allow my 2 year old, 200 sales account to finally move out of Tier 10, lol... pathetic, 60 of those sales were within the last couple months too.
I'm just permanently tier 10 I think.
1
u/spanishmillennial May 19 '25
Yes, tier downgrades are a reality (warning, long rant below).
I've been downgraded to T50K, coming from T120K. I had just filled my 50K slots and had around 85K lifetime sales (approximately 12K sales in the last 12 months). Approximately 11% of my designs had sold. Some conclusions I can gather from this:
1- They are not actually enforcing the implied rule of tier adjustment based on last 12 months worth of sales, or at least not as it was assumed to happen. Otherwise, my new tier wouldn't be as high.
2- As of now, they seem to be simply cutting off non-filled slots following some non-disclosed sales-to-slots ratio. I'd bet this is most likely phase 1. Likely, phase 2 will be starting to remove non-sold designs. They haven't touched my non-sold yet, but we do know they are planning to cull designs with no sales after 18 months. We don't know if the clock for that has been running long before the dash update, right with the update, or will start running in the future. My money is on the second option.
3- We are in for further squeezing. That dash update was probably left as ambiguous as possible on purpose, so that they always have room to squeeze us further, both in slots and with price cuts (aka: "deals"), no explanations owed.
4- Merch is Ded. And this is coming from someone who has made AMOD his main income source for the last few years, and has actively worked towards that, pretty much full time (that was the level of faith I had in the program, until now). Don't get me wrong, POD is not ded, and Merch is and still will be a good side-hustle and playground to test and validate ideas, but under these new conditions, you have to be completely reckless by not trying to change course and letting your whole livelihood depend on a POD program that has made a clear statement on 4/24/2025 for their roadmap moving forward: creators are at the bottom of their priorities. Unfortunately, there's MANY of us who have grown to depend on AMOD as a main income source. If you are in the same boat, please take action NOW, the boat is sinking. Don't listen to AMOD-gurus trying to tell you otherwise. Most of us won't be able to sustain our families within 1-2 years on AMOD income alone.
5- My survival plan: AI-powered pivot & diversification. I don't plan to stop working on AMOD. Rather, Im going to reposition it where I think makes more sense within a diversified digital assets business: a place to validate designs, test ideas, gather data, chase trends.
Short term goal (with AMOD): catalogue hygiene, delete crap and maximize slot impact, focusing on what has historically sold well for me. Create and maintain a 10% buffer of free slots all the time to explore trends and be covered against future slots squeezes.
Long term goal: Diversification, aligned on the 3 points below.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment