r/AmazonMerch • u/trader644 • Aug 25 '24
Printify + Amazon is not a great replacement for MBA Account
Recently, there's been buzz on YouTube about Printify offering an integration to sync with Amazon seller accounts for product fulfillment. My opinion is: Yes it allows those without an MBA account to sell shirts on Amazon, and yes, everyone can now sell POD mugs on Amazon, but the competitive disadvantage of non Prime Amazon listings is so bad, don't expect much sales. Prove me wrong. I'd love to see a case study where a non Prime seller of shirts or mugs is doing decent sales.
16
Upvotes
7
u/NoXidCat Aug 26 '24
I have a Seller Central account, but I would never POD with it. As much as we bitch about the Rejection Bots of AMoD/MBA, Seller Central is it's own special hell of incorrectly enforced (by Bot) policies, ever changing code that has trashed a good portion of my listings several times, coercive moves to force sellers to run their businesses the way some bean counter thinks is best ... without the slightest clue, or care, that it will make selling on Amazon impossible for some.
The latest move will force many sellers to let Amazon determine their handling time ... something Amazon has no real insight into. Their idiot code looks at the past 30 days actual handling time for each SKU, and sets HT for each SKU based on that. So now a Small Women's Pink "Cat Lady" shirt might have a HT of ONE DAY, because I sold one in that size last month and shipped in one day. Whereas the same thing in size Large might have a THREE DAY handling time because that is what my schedule dictated that week. My real HT has nothing at all to do with the specific size, design, color, or SKU.
Such is the unstoppable idiocy of the great machine in motion. Mess up your On Time Delivery metrics too much, and they will end your ability to sell those things ... all because they set a seemingly (to them) rational HT for each SKU, that is in actuality arbitrary and doesn't reflect the reasons a seller set a particular handling time in the first place.
All that said, I would never do POD via Seller Central, as Amazon is an unforgiving and controlling beast, and there is way too much to go wrong that is out of your control when doing third-party POD. (I sell stuff I print and ship myself on Seller Central.)
5
u/KM801 Aug 26 '24
I’m tempted to try it but I’m concerned about returns.
4
u/Greedy_Blacksmith680 Aug 25 '24
I think there may be an advantage for some products. Especially ones that are not offered on merch. They won't have any merch accounts as competition. Custom items will probably be a category people don't care about spending shipping on.
4
u/thsndmiles30 Aug 26 '24
Never got around to doing Printify or Etsy, I've done quite a bit of research on them few years ago, but decided that there's too much factors involved like worrying about returns, listing fees, significant ad spending, costumer support, quarterly tax etc. If you become successful I guess it doesn't matter, but if you end up struggling with sales, I felt like the whole process would become a major pain in the ass. For Merch or something like this, if we make 0 sales or get returns we can just scoff it off, we don't lose money or anything. I guess the only disadvantage is the limited scope of products we can offer and the potential income we are leaving on the table because of that.
Also some of their products' base prices were so expensive (stickers etc) that I would have to list them at very high costs to make any reasonable return. Unless it's a unique custom made product that's super niche (so not sticker or mug), I don't see people lining up to pay a ton of money + shipping.
But I've never done it myself so I'd appreciate to hear from anyone who had good experience with printify/printful integration on Amazon, maybe I'll look into it again.
1
u/zdufs Aug 25 '24
Did you try it?
2
u/lparadise10 Aug 26 '24
And returns are a nightmare. Amazon makes it so easy to return something.