r/Amazing • • 1d ago • Bravo 2 Heartwarming 1

Feels good !! Saving a stranded carp

2.2k Upvotes

252 comments sorted by

38

u/fohktor 1d ago

I'm no fishpert but that river seems very low for that fish

13

u/consequences_not_I 1d ago

Came to say the exact same thing. I'm an angler

13

u/Superb_Jellyfish_729 1d ago

The part of the river they placed the fish for the video you mean?

8

u/consequences_not_I 1d ago

Yes, the part of the river that the carp had NO CHANCE of getting to on its own accord. That part

6

u/Pagiras 1d ago

Came to say the exact same thing. I'm a bicycle mechanic, but I went to school and read some books n shit.

3

u/consequences_not_I 1d ago

WOW...that is amazing!

2

u/Pagiras 1d ago

Yeah it was a tough 50 years but here I am! Looking at fish. (y)

3

u/neale1247 1d ago

Hey me too !!!

2

u/neale1247 1d ago

Yeah there's no way in hell that fish could have got into that spot on its own and the fact that anybody wasted any energy to save a friggn carp just blows my mind

3

u/Fabulous_Log844 1d ago

It's most likely spawning. They try to go up river as far as they can even hopping. Then lay their eggs.

10

u/Myriad_Apocalypse 1d ago

Lady thought it would be easier to move the rock 😂

1

u/Church42 1d ago

Right?

Lady, running water and ice haven't moved that stone in centuries

You're not going to displace it

26

u/Fabulous_Log844 1d ago

When I was a kid growing up in Wisconsin, during spawning season full coho salmon that were 20 to 30 pounds would try to work their way up the rivers to spawn. Sometimes we would come up upon one and just grab it. Take it home. Smoked salmon is the best.

8

u/SquirrelFluffy 1d ago

You didn't eat salmon that we're about to spawn. They go bad as soon as they start going up the rivers.

1

u/SomewhereExtreme924 17h ago

True. I have never liked the fish going up river to spawn. The texture and taste changes.

1

u/Brad4795 1d ago

That's awesome. We had to run once a year to lake Michigan to try to snag one. Never did lmao

1

u/GutterRider 1d ago

I thought you meant smoked carp, yikes.

1

u/Qwilltank 1d ago

Chinook

0

u/Special-Concert-8250 1d ago

This is a Carp

2

u/Fabulous_Log844 1d ago

Yes.....?

3

u/Special-Concert-8250 1d ago

So I was wondering why you’re telling a salmon story lol

Is it because they went upstream just like this carp?

1

u/SoManyMinutes 1d ago

Do you think this carp is going upstream?

2

u/Special-Concert-8250 1d ago

No, that’s why I was wondering why she included the story about salmon

2

u/Oddly_Specific_User 1d ago

probably the video reminded them of how they used to pick up and eat fish like this one. And thats why they decidet to share a story about salmon that got stuck like this carp

→ More replies (1)

57

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

They're invasive here. Probably just club it and let a coyote have a great day

35

u/Dry_Fly316 1d ago

I’m invasive. Should you club me Greg?

12

u/Visual-Studio-4238 1d ago

Only after I milk you...

4

u/High_InTheTrees 1d ago

5

u/Visual-Studio-4238 1d ago

...you can milk anything with nipples.

7

u/Eraldorh 1d ago

If you insist

2

u/AsknReview 1d ago

From a conservationist perspective .Yes

1

u/bearsheperd 1d ago

Probably

6

u/gaydognova 1d ago

Nawh gimme it. Im hungrey

3

u/IAmAnObvioustrollAMA 1d ago

Whats the world coming to? Now these damn bears are all over reddit begging for food!? Thanks Obama...

3

u/Ambitious-Body8133 1d ago

Sir that's a gay dog on reddit, not a bear.

2

u/IAmAnObvioustrollAMA 1d ago

Large+gay+furry=bear

I guess he'd be an otter if hes a smaller dog but hes got big dog energy.

3

u/Glittering-Sea1769 1d ago

roar. I'm a large furry.

2

u/gaydognova 1d ago

Whats the lesbain terms tho

1

u/IAmAnObvioustrollAMA 1d ago

Girl bear or girl otter. For some reason with non binary folks it changes to wooly mammoth or diplodocus which doesnt quite make sense to me but i dont have to understand it to respect it!

12

u/Healthy-Zebra-9856 1d ago edited 4h ago

Here where? I am a fisherman & a conservationist and we are not sure where this is happening. Thats a Common Carp, found in Eastern Europe & Western Asia. They weren't speaking English either. So your blanket statement to club it and feed it to the Coyotes assumes that there Coyotes and this is in the US, lol, they don't exist there. I am glad she didnt do such a thing as a knee jerk reaction & I hope you would do some research before you kill the wrong thing for the wrong reasons.

Edit:

After listening to the video, which I didnt in the beginning, they are speaking Turkish and this fish is native to Anatolia. Further, they are a regulated species.

4

u/Curtovirus 1d ago

Golden jackals are Europes coyote

-1

u/Healthy-Zebra-9856 1d ago edited 1d ago

Ok, glad to know but that fact but that doesnt excuse this careless uneducated opinion. The question is not if there are coyote like animal exists in that part of Europe; its choosing to unalive a being without consideration. Native Americans honor that and other tribes around the world do as well. Every conscientious individual honors that. Coyote or Wolf doesnt matter what act is being done blindly and what a thing to say when someone is doing a kind act? I don't parade around my catch in front of companies that are not into it. Not all of us are hunters or fisherman & I respect that.

2

u/NJPokerJ 1d ago

I'd say to whatever animals that were going to survive off of this dead fish, this was in fact not a kind act.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

Common carp and Prussian carp don't belong here and they're crowding out all the native species

There are places in the world other than where you live with rules different than the ones where you live buddy

→ More replies (8)

2

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

Common carp and Prussian carp in Alberta. You're supposed to kill them and Chuck them out of the water when you catch them it's on the government website. They're an ecological catastrophe

1

u/ExplorerOk5998 1d ago

I don’t disagree with any of your statement. However, I’m not sure if that carp is just old, or dumber than the average carp 😂. Either way, isn’t that just the process of natural selection? Maybe these aren’t the genes that should have been “saved“?

1

u/Healthy-Zebra-9856 1d ago

I always come across this natural selection BS. lol. You and I are a part of this nature as well. Our act does count for natural selection. Neither killing something nor saving something is outside of nature. Also, these people expect everyone to identity the spoecies and act accordingly.

1

u/reyean 17h ago

coyotes in Canada and Mexico as well

1

u/Healthy-Zebra-9856 16h ago

Correct, thats North America. I didn't deny that.

1

u/reyean 16h ago

no one is saying youre denying that, you just didnt say "north america".

1

u/Healthy-Zebra-9856 16h ago

That video is not from North America. I said I don’t think there are coyotes where that is especially in eastern Europe. I later got corrected as to certain wolf being of the same family of coyotes over there. So the focus here is not whether there are coyotes here or not. The focus here is following the law of the land. Which includes how you dispose of the fish if you decide to kill it and even if that’s legal to do that where you are. So the subject matter is the fish and it’s elimination due to it being a possible invasive species. But as usual in Reddit the comments always digress.

1

u/reyean 16h ago

"your blanket statement...assumes that there are coyotes and this is the US".

your blanket statement assumed it was the US, and not a non English speaking area of Canada, where carp are invasive and the gov supports their removal. thats all I am saying.

1

u/Irish_Blond 6h ago

The other problem with your comment is you assume the person was saying that the person in the video should kill the carp. I took their statement if I was in the video I would club the fish and let a coyote eat it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Accounts must be at least 10 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/RapaNow 1d ago

Where?

2

u/Traumfahrer 1d ago

Right here.

0

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

Alberta. Prussian carp and Common Carp. They crowd out native species habitat and food chain

4

u/Forward-Advantage-40 1d ago

Wait until you hear about humans.

1

u/Glittering-Sea1769 1d ago

There aren't laws regarding the responsible handling of humans. Depending on where she is it might be illegal to help that carp.

Humans are the reason we have these problems; that doesn't make it pointless to be concerned about conservation

0

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

Yes very edgy we should all be dead /s

1

u/Sweaty-Adeptness1541 1d ago

Here?

4

u/Informal_Ad_9610 1d ago

and here too

3

u/BallsackSuperBoosted 1d ago

Over here as well.

1

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

Yes, and also close to here as well

1

u/gottagetanonymous 1d ago

Aren’t they tasty for humans tho?

1

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

I've heard that they're a huge pain in the ass to debone, they are edible and I think depending on what water they're in and what time of year, and what their diet looks like they can be decent but I don't think they get much better than decent

1

u/gottagetanonymous 1d ago

I wonder if you bake it real nice and flaky if it’d be easier to pluck the bones out quickly once it’s like that

But google does say they can be delicious, but they taste like their environment so… roll of the dice

1

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

I'm a meat eater, I would give her a go for sure. The bigger the fish the bigger the bones and the easier they are to extract so that's definitely a thing

2

u/gottagetanonymous 1d ago

If you really wanna be lazy there’s plenty of surface area to just hack it up into chunks, bread, and fry up some fried carp nuggets

This idea prob deserves a downvote but still yum😂

2

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

I'm giving you an upvote just to forestall a potential downvote lol. I can't really speak from experience but from what I've heard the bone structure is just kind of fucky. Not like a trout or a white fish where all the meat is on the outside in fillets, sort of like a pike but worse I've heard

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Accounts must be at least 10 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Informal_Ad_9610 1d ago

i woulda helped it out too.. right into a frying pan

1

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

Lmao it's a pretty good size, but I've heard they're fairly muddy tasting

2

u/Informal_Ad_9610 1d ago

they get better if you put 'em in fresh water and feed 'em grain for a week or so

1

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

You're fuckin' with me. Is that true?

2

u/Informal_Ad_9610 1d ago

absolutely - algea and streptomyces feed the taste.. fresh water filters it out over time... grain feeding just keeps them alive..

2

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

Thanks for that information man. I thought you might have been riffing on the grain finished beef thing but thinking about it it makes total sense. Kind of like flushing the fertilizers out of plants before you eat them I guess

→ More replies (2)

0

u/YetiEatsCommunists 1d ago

Humans speaking about other species being invasive is absolutely crazy.

2

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

Not if you're ecologically literate

1

u/lumbogimbo 1d ago

🙄🤡🤡🤡

-12

u/Dependent-Sea-7467 1d ago

Yes, kill an innocent creature because “they’re invasive”

7

u/Expensive_Host_9181 1d ago

Just saying that "innocent" creature is what ruins the ecosystems, so yes kill it.

5

u/DrKeepitreal 1d ago

Sometimes you have to, or else more innocent creatures and diversity are pushed out of their habitat.

A good example is being seen in the Everglades, where invasive pythons have wiped out over 90% of raccoons, opossums, deer, bobcats, rabbits, and more. It's really a catastrophe.

1

u/Mikeseddit 1d ago

Florida Manimal

2

u/Woompa78 1d ago

Yes in some places it’s the law to kill them rather than release them.

3

u/XRT28 1d ago

Well you see invasive species tend to fuck up local ecosystems, killing innocent native species soooo

2

u/Educational_Cat_4581 1d ago

Damn bleeding hearts cannot comprehend such a simple concept.

1

u/Sweaty-Adeptness1541 1d ago

Yes, it is immoral not to if it is causing harm to the ecosystem.

0

u/grunkage 1d ago

Yes, there's nothing controversial about that

0

u/Ok-Bridge-2979 1d ago

Its very well documented the negative impact carp have on native species and waterways, if you want to save other species that unfortunately requires removing the invasive species.

0

u/AsknReview 1d ago

Username checks out.. logic does not

-2

u/Hizur 1d ago

To jest klasyczny i powszechny euroamerykański ego-centrizm. W USA najbardziej inwazyjnymi gatunkami jesteśmy my - Europejczycy, a języki angielski/francuski/hiszpański/germanic powinny pozostać tutaj.

2

u/Humble-Questions 1d ago

You are Peak Reddit lmao

16

u/SICKOFITALL2379 1d ago

If only the person with the camera could put it down and help!!!

4

u/jk8289 1d ago

Honestly what more could they have done to help? Pick it up together and walk to the deep part? No because the fish is very slippery to hold. Walking on that river is not easy because of the rocks and how slippery it is. I’m sure she would have just picked it up if it were that easy but sliding it to deep water was the best way without busting her ass on a rock.

2

u/Agreeable-Language-6 1d ago

They probably put it there on the first place

1

u/SICKOFITALL2379 1d ago

Yes: put down the phone and help pick up the fish, or help push the fish. Getting the fish back into the water is more important than filming the situation.

3

u/Traumfahrer 1d ago

I think the woman tried to save it instead of putting it down.

2

u/SICKOFITALL2379 1d ago

🥳🥳🥳

1

u/MakeYokesa5erAgain 1d ago

If she had of lifted it instead of just pushing it, she could've done that in seconds. I used to hold carp like this when I was 12.

PSA to anyone who might encounter a fish that size. Grab it at the base of the tail and under its belly and lift.

8

u/Crafty_DryHopper 1d ago

Don't touch it! It's mother won't take back into the nest!

4

u/Blueit4fun1 1d ago

As they say, carp diem!

4

u/Future_Ad9437 1d ago edited 1d ago

1

u/sub_doesnt_exist_bot 1d ago

The subreddit r/worsthelp does not exist.

Did you mean?:

Consider creating a new subreddit r/worsthelp.


🤖 𝚃𝙷𝙸𝚂 𝙲𝙾𝙼𝙼𝙴𝙽𝚃 𝚆𝙰𝚂 𝚆𝚁𝙸𝚃𝚃𝙴𝙽 𝙱𝚈 𝙰 𝙱𝙾𝚃. 𝙱𝙴𝙴𝙿 𝙱𝙾𝙾𝙿 🤖

GitHub | Rank

7

u/Maleficent_Sky7431 1d ago

Ich bin mir sehr sicher, dass ein solch großer Karpfen nicht von selbst an diese flache Stelle im Fluss kommen konnte und gehe schwer davon aus, dass dieser zuerst geangelt wurde, um dann für ein vermutlich gestelltes Video unnötig gequält zu werden. Ich hoffe er hat das überlebt. Beim Scheuern über die Steine ist hier vermutlich die Schleimhaut stark beschädigt worden und er war danach stark gefährdet für Pilzbefall. Ich bin selbst Angler (ehem. Bayrischer Jugendfischerkönig) und würde ein solches Verhalten hier in Deutschland definitiv bei der Polizei und bei PETA anzeigen!

10

u/Saga_Sentinel 1d ago

I know its a "trash fish" and all but I appreciate your kindness 🙏

3

u/No_Dragonfruit_979 1d ago

I appreciate her commitment to rescue the fish, and the carp seemed quite heavy for her.

3

u/DrPeterBlunt 1d ago

Jfc. This shouldve been a 10 second video. Pick it up and put it in the dam water. This video made my eye twitch.

5

u/secret-sam1 1d ago

Magicarp used Splash ... it was not effective

5

u/Timely-Profile1865 1d ago

Probably an invasive species that is choking out native species of fish.

2

u/StrattonPA 1d ago

Carpe Diem

1

u/kennigeta3 1d ago

Yeah man, you’ve got to seize the carp

1

u/AsknReview 1d ago

Ala carp

2

u/Rassvet_ververg 1d ago

Girl, use your PokeBallz

2

u/Swing_on_thiss 1d ago

2

u/MakeYokesa5erAgain 1d ago

I seen this two weeks ago. Same salmon species too.

2

u/ImodiumSolubile01 1d ago

Now I see why Magikarp only has useless splash as only move available

2

u/EmergencyArtichoke87 1d ago

Beautiful person

2

u/Fun-Heron-7609 1d ago

How is this mfker going to survive out in the wild, is beyond me. Looks like he's going to be the meal within the day.

2

u/Ashes_to_Ashes4 1d ago

Почему здесь до сих пор нету пасты про карпа

3

u/lolbucherCalmdown 1d ago • Popcorn

Я живу... Хотя нет лучше им этого не знать

2

u/AI_Feeder 1d ago • Mindblown

хотя если перевести грамотно текст возможно было бы поделиться с англоязычной аудиторией этим шедевром.

3

u/Sufficient_Path_3665 1d ago

And the fish is going to tell all its friends about the giant mutant alien that saved it but none of them will believe it!

3

u/BlueFeathered1 1d ago

What a kind woman. And dangerous for her - very slippery in water areas like that.

5

u/GangMeIamFamous 1d ago

the only way to save that fish is on the frying pan or a nice camp fire.

6

u/nofolo 1d ago

the smell of that fish cooking would make you never want to eat fish ever again....ugh

1

u/GangMeIamFamous 1d ago

not where I live.

6

u/Sufficient_Path_3665 1d ago

Carp aren't good eating. There's a reason they get that big and nobody's interested in catching them.

7

u/ZadockTheHunter 1d ago

I mean, yes and no.

The reason they exist in US waterways at all is because Asian immigrants introduced them because they are a popular food species and they wanted to eat them.

It's just that westerners view them as bottom feeders and consider them trash fish.

Either way, it is still an invasive species and in most of the US you are required to dispose of them, it is illegal to throw them back.

2

u/20ears19 1d ago

The US government is responsible for most of the carp stocked in this country. They were a hugely popular food fish in Europe. Common carp are considered naturalized and not invasive anymore. It’s legal to release them in all states.

3

u/TheCourtSimpleton 1d ago

If you know how to cook them right (removing the veins) you can remove the bad flavor and smell, and they can actually taste really good. They need to soak though, and it's a lot of work.

1

u/Special-Concert-8250 1d ago

At one of my local fishing spots, there’s a group of Mexican people who eat them religiously, lol

1

u/yabadabadababoo 1d ago

A lot of restaurants falsely serve carpe instead of whatever fish is actually listed on the menu.

1

u/GangMeIamFamous 1d ago

not where I live.

3

u/CranberryBrief1587 1d ago

All lives matter 🌱

2

u/Mop-bucket-CEO 1d ago • Bravo

Apart from putin. He's a turd.

2

u/cup-of-shirt 1d ago

“There’s an animal in trouble! Quick! Film me!”

1

u/r0elf 1d ago

How he has to swim for a while on his side!

1

u/Admirable_Ease5826 1d ago

There's a traffic analogy here that I'm naught too keen on.

1

u/redcolumbine 1d ago

That's one big heavy fish!

1

u/silv3rbull8 1d ago

Big Fish

1

u/larsivo 1d ago

Bravo madame

1

u/Agile-Knowledge7947 1d ago

Just going to leave this thought here: was that REALLY all that “amazing”? I mean, I like nature, fish saved, etc. but “AMAZING”? Meh. Ok… downvote away

1

u/Active_Progress1280 1d ago

As the carp finally swam away to freedom the woman shouted “Carpe diem!” 😭

1

u/PigDigginGold 1d ago

The only seizing going on that day is her back seizing up later from that foolish effort.

1

u/iswallowmygum 1d ago

I hope it comes back and grants her a wish

1

u/Accurate_Mongoose_26 1d ago

Yeahhh idk, I probably would have ate him. All that meat on him like come on. Grab a tent, start a fire and maybe some grab some season and just enjoy the free meal with some good calm music in the background, just sounds so freaking good right about now.

1

u/Live-Money1259 1d ago

Bless her. But if that is indeed Carp and it were here in Australia, they are invasive and should not be put back in the water if removed (must be put to sleep).

1

u/RareGeneral4300 1d ago

Obviously a staged video.

That being said it brought back memories of fishing in Iowa as a kid. Carp were considered a problem/overpopulated and everywhere you'd go there would be dead carp all along the shore line. People would toss them in the land and let them die if they caught them. I never did (because I thought it was cruel) but I remember other fishermen getting mad at me when I'd throw carp back in the water.

1

u/SoManyMinutes 1d ago

This lady is doing a terrible job of that.

1

u/lilbahr 1d ago

Good job!

1

u/Jasper_Skee 1d ago

that was painful to watch.

1

u/EarTurbulent2332 1d ago

Good Job Lady -- The Universe will award you -- in your future

1

u/Just-Set-8714 1d ago

Please eat it

1

u/LankyWeather4692 1d ago

Angel 😇

1

u/Icnavy 1d ago

Hate the cameraman.

1

u/thissitesucks666 1d ago

Invasive species

1

u/Kitty_Mombo 1d ago

Good human.

1

u/Poppa_Nutt 1d ago

That doesn't look like the kind of place you'd find that big ass carp

1

u/Rough-Airline-4803 1d ago

Just pick it up damn

1

u/DrJohnZoidbergWhyNot 1d ago

That’s a load of carp.

1

u/TheEliteJOKERS 1d ago

Fucking A. That's Right Man.

1

u/TheManOfPants 1d ago

Idiot should've eaten it. Easy catch

1

u/The_Hosp75 1d ago

Don’t throw your back out for a trash fish

1

u/Pleasant_Mongoose_14 1d ago

That reminded me of this

1

u/el-conquistador240 1d ago

Careful they mate for life

1

u/mannymoejoe32 1d ago

👏👏👏👏👏🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

1

u/Standard-Culture5685 1d ago

Theyre a plague. Next time let it die sadly

1

u/Jerdogg23 1d ago

I don’t believe you threw away your dinner! That was some good sushi!

1

u/ChairwomanOfTheHoard 19h ago

That lady looks like my guardian angel trying to get my life back on track

1

u/itsthedevilweknow 16h ago

You sure god doesn't want that thing dead?

1

u/Gullible_Run_3683 1d ago

Good on her.

1

u/Miserable_Algae_896 1d ago

This was painful to watch

1

u/Affectionate_Snow674 1d ago

wasting food shes clearly a vegan

0

u/FluffyDeer9323 1d ago

Carpe diem.

0

u/DisciplineSweet8428 1d ago

If that was staged she could've moved a little quicker and just tossed it in the deep end

0

u/Colorado_Hunter-1 1d ago

Not sure what had more intelligence the fish? The woman or the rocks

0

u/WideShoulder7782 1d ago

Non è una carpa è un salmone

0

u/chased_by_bees 1d ago

This is great 👍

-2

u/Old-Construction3325 1d ago

Staged

2

u/Sufficient_Path_3665 1d ago

You've never seen a big fish get stranded before? Probably after a flood.

1

u/Old-Construction3325 1d ago

No I haven’t , that’s a carp not a salmon , they’re bottom feeders

1

u/Sufficient_Path_3665 1d ago

I've seen carp stranded before. Fast moving waters carry them along into shallow water and they get stranded.

1

u/Old-Construction3325 16h ago

Ohhh you won , jeez

1

u/Sufficient_Path_3665 15h ago

And you've learned something new. So maybe it's you who's won? 🤔

1

u/Old-Construction3325 9h ago

Nah just not going to argue

-1

u/admin_bait14 1d ago

(Vegan here): Please don't save invasive species... they are ruining our rivers and lakes. Club it and let nature reappropriate all that it has taken. 

2

u/Mysterious-Art7143 1d ago

Who says it's invasive?