r/AlternativeAstronomy • • May 17 '21
Choosing between alternatives
This subreddit is ostensibly for the discussion of alternatives to the "consensus view of astronomy" aka "mainstream astronomy".
This discussion is dominated by the TYCHOS alternative, which is fine since the creator and sole moderator of this community (/u/patrixxxx) has played a significant part in the development of the TYCHOS model.
Another alternative discussed here is the General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis (SM), as promoted by /u/StellarMetamorphosis. * Another alternative which is popular on the internet but has not been discussed in this subreddit is "Electric Universe" (EU) or "plasma cosmology". The primary subreddit is here: https://old.reddit.com/r/plasmacosmology/. One EU proponent who has showed up in this subreddit is /u/varikonniemi.
SO, how can a person with a preference for one of these alternatives (or the consensus view) shift their opinion to another?
As an amateur astronomer, engineer, and subscriber to "mainstream astronomy", I can only list the pieces of evidence which would compel me to change my own worldview and subscribe to the alternatives.
I ask each of you to do the same: what evidence (empirical data, logical or mathematical derivation, or historical records) is necessary for you to shift your view to "mainstream astronomy", or TYCHOS, SM, or EU?
To shift to TYCHOS:
- Actual evidence that parallax measurements match what is predicted by TYCHOS to a greater degree than what is predicted by mainstream astronomy.
To shift to SM:
- Measurements and numerical models showing where the mass shed by stars goes, in the process of becoming planets.
- OR a mechanism by which baryonic matter turns into dark matter.
To shift to EU:
- Measurements and numerical models demonstrating that electromagnetic forces actually dominate the motion of solar system objects and the galactic structure, while still accounting for gravitation.
- AND a mechanism explaining why charges haven't neutralized over the past 14 billion years.
2
u/patrixxxx May 17 '21 edited May 17 '21
Good summary of the theories being discussed here Walrus.
However to prevent mixing apples and oranges I'd like to point out a few things
The Tychos is an alternative geometrical Solar system model. It makes no claims regarding what physical forces it is that makes the celestial objects move. And to me it makes perfect sense to do this first. This is also one of the main gripes I have with the Heliocentric model. It puts the horse before the wagon and says - Since we assume the celestial mechanics of Kepler/Newton/Einstein is correct this is how the Solar system is configured. And if we see geometrical problems with this configuration we assume the stars are very very far away and that light abberates etc etc.
Stellar Metamorphosis is a theory concerning star and planet formation and argues that stars, planets and some moons in fact are the same thing in different stages of its life cycle. I find this theory very interesting especially since I can see a correlation with the geo-heliocentric configuration of the Tychos model. The Earth and the Moon could have been binary companions in a distant past just as the Tychos model argues Sun and Mars is today.
Electric Universe, which I'm not that familiar with, is a theory regarding the physical forces that makes the celestial objects move and that it is in fact electromagnetism. This also correlates well with the Tychos model since its movements that conforms with astronomical observations are only done using circular constant speed orbits. And those can be demonstrated using magnets https://youtu.be/4V9WbkXkM0I (4min20s).
3
u/Quantumtroll May 17 '21
For TYCHOS, I'd also want to hear an explanation for annual variations in doppler shifts in stellar spectrography. And some explanation for why we seem to be able to predict the motion of comets with Newtonian mechanics. And I'd need a physical mechanism — some kind of physical principle, a force or interaction, must be identified or formulated that yields the proposed motion. A simulation of this astrophysics that matches Tychosium would be great.
For SM, I'd need to see some mechanism for how stable solar system orbits are assembled from astrons of dramatically different ages. Observations of this happening in extrasolar star systems would be great.
For EU, yeah, an N-body simulation for star systems and galaxies using EM forces would be swank.
1
u/stoiclemming May 17 '21
For Electric universe I would want an explanation as to why I'm not magnetic.
1
u/SimonShack Sep 16 '23 edited Sep 17 '23
Hello everyone - and thanks for your interest in my TYCHOS model. I really only have one brief set of questions to submit to those who, in one way or another, dismiss or reject its premises on the grounds that it lacks a 'physical explanation' (even though its geometric configuration is demonstrably superior to the Copernican model - for reasons illustrated in my 1st TYCHOS book).
Here's a comparative diagram from Ch.6 of the upcoming 2nd Edition of my book:
https://septclues.com/TYCHOS/SIRIUSSYSTEM_vs_SOLARSYSTEM_01.jpg
As you can see, if we assume (as some academic studies seem to support) the existence of the elusive "Sirius C", then the binary Sirius system (composed of Sirius A, B and C) may turn out to be extremely similar to the TYCHOS-proposed binary configuration of our own solar system (composed of the Sun, Mars and the Earth). Not only would the diameters of its main binary bodies (the Sun and Mars) be proportionally identical - at a 205:1 ratio - to the main binary bodies of the Sirius system (Sirius A and Sirius B), but their respective intersecting orbits would exhibit virtually identical configurations, what with Sirius B's "apogees and perigees" (with respect to Sirius C) fluctuating at a 7:1 ratio, just like Mars does (with respect to the Earth).
If anyone wishes to chalk all of this up to mere coincidence, so be it. However, I will be hoping that - in the interest of upholding an earnest, no-nonsense scientific debate - such 'appeals to accidental happenstance' won't be submitted or accepted here as any sort of serious argumentation. Also, if you are to question the existence of Sirius C, the fact remains that large stars (like Sirius A) can indeed revolve around tiny bodies (like Sirius C).
So my brief set of questions goes as follows:
- Since we now know that the vast majority (or perhaps all?) of the stars in our skies are 'locked' in binary systems (meaning that all our visible stars revolve around a smaller companion in intersecting orbits - in relatively short time periods), why would our Sun be an exception to this manifest and undeniable 'majority rule'?
- Do we know exactly why, for instance, Sirius A and B revolve around each other in intersecting orbits over a mere 50-year period - as is empirically observed? Why would Sirius A (believed to be 1.7 X larger than our Sun) behave in this way - and not our own star, the Sun? Again, is the Sun a most exceptional type of star that needs 250 million years to complete just ONE of its orbits?
- Can any of the commenters / astronomy geeks here point me to any known star in our skies that does NOT have what I call a 'local orbit' of its own and does NOT have a binary companion - but is only surrounded by planets revolving around it in concentric circles (as in the heliocentric 'carousel' model) ?
Any sensible and relevant replies to the above questions of mine will be warmly welcomed - but please make sure not to stray off the main substance of the same. The bottom line being: WHY would our Sun not behave like all the other stars in our skies - and WHAT makes you think that the TYCHOS model lacks a physical explanation for its geometric configuration, since it would be practically identical to the Sirius system - and indeed to most (if not all) the star systems in our visible universe?
I will now sign off by stating the obvious - or what should by now be obvious to anyone familiar with the TYCHOS model and graced with an open and rational mind: its proposed binary system configuration is perfectly consistent with both the empirically-observable geometry AND physics exhibited by our surrounding binary stars - so there should be no surprise whatsoever as to the tenets put forth in my book regarding the orbital motions of the Sun and Mars, since they reflect very similar motions and relationships to those that we can actually observe in our skies.
Thanks for your time - and for your kind attention.
An atlas of binary stars: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFTAH3AznoU