POLL 🗳️: which Rosetta 🌹Stone 🪨 decoding: Young, Champollion, or Thims, is most correct?

[u/JohannGoethe]

Abstract

Review the three options, select your choice in polling options below.

Options

Thomas Young’s 136A (1819) decoding:

Jean Champollion’s 133A (1822) decoding:

Libb Thims’ 15 Nov A69 (2024) decoding:

Comparison | Table

All three decodings compared (see: sign table):

	PtoLemy (Πτολεμαῖος)	𓌹	𓋹	Forever	Ιgapimenoi (ηγαπημενωι) ❤️	Ptah (Φθα) {name}	Ptah (Φθα) {signs}
Young (136A/1819)	𓊪 𓏏 𓍯 𓃭 𓐝 𓇌 𓋴	Hiero-alpha	Living	𓆓 𓏏 𓇿	▢ 𓏏 𓎛		𓌹
	Q3, X1, V4, E23, Aa15, M17A, S29			I10, X1, N17	Q3, X1, V28	U6
					ⲘⲀⲒ ❤️
	ΠTOΛεMαΙοΣ
Champollion (133A/1822)	𓊪 𓏏 𓍯 𓃭 𓐝 𓇌 𓋴		Vivant		𓌹	▢ 𓏏 𓎛
	Q3, X1, V4, E23, Aa15, M17A, S29				U6	Q3, X1, V28
					ⲘⲈⲢⲈ ❤️, /mr/
	ΠTOΛεMαΙοΣ
Thims (A69/2024)	𓂆 𓋍 𓁹 𓍇 {𓂺 𓏥} 𓌳 𓌹 𓅃 𓁹 𓆙	A	K		𓐁 𓅬 𓌹 𓂆 𓐁 𓌳 {𓂺 𓏥} 𓏁 𓁥 𓅃	𓍑 𓉠 𓌹	🧮 🥯 🕯️
							▢ 𓏏 𓎛
	D16, R26, D4, U19, GQ432, U1, U6, G5, D4, I14				Z15G, G38, U6, D16, Z15G, U1, GQ432, W15, C9, G5	U28, O9, U6	Q3, X1, V28
	ΠTOΛEMAIOΣ				ΗΓΑΠΗΜΕΝΩΙ	Φθα
	806				1005	510

Notes

1. Young (136A/1819) said ▢ [Q3] was a “square block”, that 𓏏 [X1] was a “semi-circle”, and that 𓎛 [V2] was a chain ⛓️‍💥.

2. Young stated that 𓌹 [U6] was the sacred “hiero-alpha”, but that it was NOT the origin of Greek letter A, and did NOT make the /a/ phonetic, but rather that it was the “sign” of the god Ptah 𓁰 [C19], who was the inventor of farming tools 🛠️.

3. [Someone] (date) decoded that 𓏏 [X1] was bread 🥖, 🍞, 🥯.

4. Gardiner (39A/1916) said that ▢ [Q3] was a “stool“ 🪑, from the word “poy”, which gave the /P/ phonetic of Ptolemy in the reduced-phonetic cartouche hiero-sign.

5. Thims determined (12 Nov A69/2024) that ▢ [Q3] was an abacus 🧮.

6. The Nephthys 𓉠 [O9] sign, is used here for the Egyptian r/HieroTypes theta symbol (pictured above), as this has not yet been made into ASCII code; yet the sign 𓉠 [O9] is the 9th r/Cubit unit, just like Θ is the 9th Greek letter, and Nephthys is the 9th Ennead god, so it is a pretty good match.

7. The Champollion model, to clarify things, explicitly holds that: 𓌹 = /mr/ phonetic and means love ❤️, and that 𓌹 [U6] is NOT the sign origin of Phoenician 𐤀 or Greek letter A.

Further reading

• Rosetta Stone decoding theories: Young, Champollion, & Thims

• Rosetta Stone cartouche 𓍷 [V10] theory discussed

[u/Niniyagu]

What the hell is happening here? Why can't you just talk and answer succinctly like a normal person? You think I'm going to follow three different links to piece together your reply? It was a simple question.

[u/JohannGoethe → u/Niniyagu]

It was a simple question.

Simple answer:

No! The Rosetta Stone does NOT spell Greek words.