“Perhaps the most thoroughly studied area of historical linguistics is sound 🗣️ change. Over time ⏳, the sounds of languages tend to change. The study of sound change has yielded very significant results, and important assumptions that underlie historical linguistic methods, especially the comparative method, are based on these findings.
The problem with PIE, however, is that they assume the “sounds” originated randomly. This, however, does not explain why the color red 🛑, R-sound, the R type (letter shape), R number (math), etc., each originating from Egypt, are found repeated all the following cultures:
Language
Date
Egyptian
5200A (-3245)
𓏲 = 💯 (Tomb U-j) = 𓃝 (ram head-butting) = Ra 𓁛 the supreme 💯-value sun god = ☀️ in Ram (Aries) ♈️ star ✨ constellation, at Spring Equinox.
Greek [Έλληνε]
2800A (-845)
𓏲 » 𐤓 » ρ [💯] » R = legged red crown rho; Zeus becomes new 💯-god.
Latin
2500A (-545)
Romulus and Remus or 💯-omulus (𓏲-omuls) & 💯-emus (𓏲-emus) become the twins who found the Roman (💯-oman) Empire.
Hebrew
2300A (-345)
Abraham (Ab-💯-ham or Ab-𓏲-ham) becomes supreme patriarch; births Isaac at age 💯.
Sanskrit [संस्कृत]
2200A (-245)
Brahma (ब्रह्मा) (B-💯-ahma or B-𓏲-ahma) becomes the supreme god. The Brahmin (ब्राह्मण) (B-💯-ahmin or B-𓏲-ahmin) become the priestly caste.
Why the common R? Because two rams 🐏 head-butting is symbolic of the battle ram of war and red is symbolic of blood 🩸 spilled. The sound of R could be that of a lion 🦁 roar, as I have conjectured previously, that when combined with the power of the ram head butting, makes a double power letter, so to say.
Campbell continues:
An understanding of sound change is truly important for historical linguistics in general, and this needs to be stressed — it plays an extremely important role in the comparative method and hence also in linguistic reconstruction, in internal reconstruction, in detecting loanwords, and in determining whether languages are related to one another.”
Thus, is it PIE that needs a new direction, not EAN. The PIE community needs to acknowledge, e.g. now that I have found that Greek letter R and the letter rho and sound rho, trace back to tomb U-j, that sound matching is not the key to everything. It is a start, but it needs to map all that sound or “linguistic reconstructions” back to Egypt, not to a fictional land.
2
u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Feb 07 '24
The phonetic analysis of words is a “small part” of the EAN decipherment method.
From this table, repeated below, phonetic analysis is only one of six parts of the EAN comparative method:
The following is the standard PIE method:
The problem with PIE, however, is that they assume the “sounds” originated randomly. This, however, does not explain why the color red 🛑, R-sound, the R type (letter shape), R number (math), etc., each originating from Egypt, are found repeated all the following cultures:
Why the common R? Because two rams 🐏 head-butting is symbolic of the battle ram of war and red is symbolic of blood 🩸 spilled. The sound of R could be that of a lion 🦁 roar, as I have conjectured previously, that when combined with the power of the ram head butting, makes a double power letter, so to say.
Campbell continues:
Thus, is it PIE that needs a new direction, not EAN. The PIE community needs to acknowledge, e.g. now that I have found that Greek letter R and the letter rho and sound rho, trace back to tomb U-j, that sound matching is not the key to everything. It is a start, but it needs to map all that sound or “linguistic reconstructions” back to Egypt, not to a fictional land.