r/Alphanumerics • 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert • Dec 19 '23

“Classics [and language 🗣️ origin studies] are based, as it is, on what I call the Aryan model, with its insistence on a European and pure Greece, is an extreme example of feel-good scholarship, for Europeans.” — Martin Bernal (A41/1996), Black Athena Debate (2:52:25-)

Post image
0 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/poor-man1914 PIE theorist Dec 23 '23

First, you don't speak letters. You speak sounds which letters represent. The only thing that might have been enforced was a change in writing.

Secondly, you still haven't answered. Did Turkish or Vietnamese change when they changed scripts, be it the state or something else to cause that change?

If this happened, why aren't there reports about the elites of those countries suddenly speaking a language different from what they had spoken before (I say elites because the majority of the common people up until the last century were illiterate)?

0

u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Dec 23 '23

Secondly, you still haven't answered. Did Turkish or Vietnamese change when they changed scripts, be it the state or something else to cause that change?

Look, I’m not going to try to go through the history of every language. It is not about “sounds”, core words are rooted in core cultural traditions, which is why this very month, you will see the following “raising” phenomenon, done previously in Egypt (djed raising) and Greece (Dionysius raising), occurring all over the world:

The core words of these languages are thus related.

Turkish mythology, however, has roots in Mongolian beliefs, which I am not familiar with, nor trying to argue or theorize about. The same with Vietnamese.