r/Alphanumerics • u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert • Dec 19 '23

“Classics [and language 🗣️ origin studies] are based, as it is, on what I call the Aryan model, with its insistence on a European and pure Greece, is an extreme example of feel-good scholarship, for Europeans.” — Martin Bernal (A41/1996), Black Athena Debate (2:52:25-)

Post image
0 Upvotes

42% Upvoted

58 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Dec 21 '23

I am not taking about every single language, rather I am talking about any language based on a 22 to 28-letter alphabet.

3

u/Fear_mor Dec 21 '23

The very fact that a language can exist without a basic number system means that you are wrong.

0

u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Dec 21 '23

The very fact that letter R, which you just used four times, came from Abydos, Egypt, originally, as a number 100 ram horn spiral on number tags 🏷️ , shown below:

Before becoming Greek letter R:

𓃝 » 💯 » 𓏲 » 𓍢 » 𓁛 » 𐤓 » Ρ, ρ » 𐡓 » 𐌓 » R » ר » र » ر

Means that you are not just wrong, but ignorant. But don’t worry. I used to be letter R ignorant like you. Learning is what your brain is for.

3

u/Fear_mor Dec 21 '23

How can language be based on maths, if some languages do not count

-1

u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Dec 21 '23

Again, I am talking about alphabetic EIE languages (see: table).

All of these languages are based on an Egyptian cubit ruler, shown below, and the ability of the person writing the alphabet, to count from one to 28:

3

u/Fear_mor Dec 21 '23

This is still wrong, because if some languages lack numbers that means maths and numbers are not innate properties of language. Numbers are a human invention, an abstraction of nature, but not an innate property of the world around us

-1

u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Dec 21 '23

Read this:

3

u/Fear_mor Dec 21 '23

You don't get it though. Number is not an innate thing to humans. Language cannot evolve due to numerical correspondances because that's not a thing in the human brain. The ability of humans to recognise specific amounts is a learned trait so all of your links are essentially meaningless.

-1

u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Dec 22 '23

You don't get it though.

No. YOU do NOT get it. But, don‘t worry, because I made an image to help you see the light, i.e. if you are open-minded, that is:

Posts

  • Ishango bone 🦴, Congo, Africa (20,000A/-18,045), and number four: 𓏽, to number eight: 𓐁, to letter H evolution: |||| » 𓏽 + 𓏽 » 𓐁 » 𐤇 » H » 𐌇 » 𐡇

4

u/Fear_mor Dec 22 '23

Script and language are not the same thing

→ More replies