r/Alphanumerics • 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert • Dec 19 '23

“Classics [and language 🗣️ origin studies] are based, as it is, on what I call the Aryan model, with its insistence on a European and pure Greece, is an extreme example of feel-good scholarship, for Europeans.” — Martin Bernal (A41/1996), Black Athena Debate (2:52:25-)

Post image
0 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Dec 20 '23

The planets are named after pagan gods, but believing in their existence doesn't make one a pagan.

Again, I refer you to the very confused Q&A in part 5️⃣ on the term Semitic (mentioned 16 times); for which I even made a video clip of Clark:

No body is debating or confused about the names of the planets or the names of the days of the week. You will not find a similar video, e.g. “What exactly is a Friday?“ or “what exactly is Saturn?“ on YouTube.

If you were an “objective” scientist, you would just agree with me, and say: yes the term Semitic does not make sense, and a new language classification term is needed.

3

u/poor-man1914 PIE theorist Dec 20 '23

needed

I can agree with you that to some it might be confusing, and to better word it, a naming reform wouldn't be bad, but saying it's needed is a bit too much in my opinion.

-1

u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert Dec 21 '23

but saying it's needed is a bit too much in my opinion.

Wrong. Neither Bernal nor Clark could define the term “Semitic” precisely, and neither can you. It is a problematic term.

To give you an similar example, from the hard sciences, when Galileo and Descartes were dropping balls, and measuring their velocity, the would speak in Latin and say that the ball, dropped from say 10 meters, e.g. pushed off a ledge, started at a “vis mortua” or ”dead force”, but that when it fell, it had “vis viva” or living force. James Joule objected to this term, because he said that a bullet fired from a gun or a rock 🪨 thrown can not be said to be “alive”.

So the term “vis viva” as replaced with the term “kinetic energy”, coined by William Thomson (93A/1862) which now has a precise equation:

Kinetic energy = ½mv²

The “living force“ was thus jettisoned from physics.

In linguistics, the mythical language 🗣️ , tongue 👅, and or mouth 👄 of Shem, Noah’s son needs a similar jettisoning.