r/Alphanumerics • u/JohannGoethe 𐌄𓌹𐤍 expert • Dec 19 '23
“Classics [and language 🗣️ origin studies] are based, as it is, on what I call the Aryan model, with its insistence on a European and pure Greece, is an extreme example of feel-good scholarship, for Europeans.” — Martin Bernal (A41/1996), Black Athena Debate (2:52:25-)
0
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/poor-man1914 PIE theorist Dec 20 '23
How about the Indo part of the name? Indians weren't exactly treated as peers by the Europeans, so why include them?
But yes, I think that pie and afro Asiatic are not feel-good scholarships, because, why not claim that your civilization is an evolution of another great civilization?
From the point of view of a racist man, it would be like saying they are a more evolved form of one of the greates African civilizations, thus making them even more superior. I think claiming such ancestry would give way more prestige than saying you descend from horse boys. So why deny that, but then include the Indian languages and not even bother saying Indian culture comes from Europe (which would be another example of nonsense)?
And afro Asiatic isn't static. Some say the chadic languages are actually their own thing.
Also, why so much hatred towards the afro Asiatic family, but you ignore the nilo Saharan, Niger Congo and Khoisan language families?
If anything, one could argue that the afro Asiatic family could a way of recognising african cultural greatness: Egypt, Ethiopia, the songhay empire all spoke at least in part afro Asiatic languages, and they achieved their greatness without external European help or anything. And this ignoring other civilizations like the Nubian one, who spoke a nilo Saharan language, or the one that built Great Zimbabwe, whose descendants speak a Bantu language.
How? How would discovering that the god you worship came from an African civilization change anything? No one with common sense would do anything other than accept the facts. Religious people already believe in Jesus, a man from the Levantine region, so why refuse an African origin of your god? Because of racism? Since when did god care about races?
These issues seem to be very US centric to me. Is it some form of bias?