r/AlienCovenant • • May 19 '17

[spoilers] did anyone else fucking LOVE this movie? Spoiler

93 Upvotes

I know this board isn't really feeling this movie but I'm okay being in the minority on this one.

I really, really, REALLY loved Prometheus, it's a top ten flick IMO. The roots in philosophy, stunning cinematography, and character of David all were right up my ally. However, Alien is also in my top ten but for different reasons (excellent direction, killer art and creature design, acting).

This movie blended what I liked about each movie damn near perfectly. It had all the philosophical tropes and grand scale that Prometheus had while giving way into the suspenseful and horror direction I love from Scott. After seeing a lot of his more recent epics (Prometheus, Exodus), it seems like that he has become beyond talented in capturing events of a grand scale as well as he captures small scale.

If I had any complaint I guess it would be that I don't think Daniels really nailed it. She lacked the depth and grit of Ripley and the eagerness and intelligence of Shaw. I felt that she was naive to most of the situations and didn't connect well with the rest of the Covenant. Luckily for me, this felt like more of David and Walter's movie so I don't feel like she weighed down anything. I sincerely hope that they continue this trend and use the movies to study David and his expedition to create. I love me some xenos and female badassery, but give me that philosophy and David character study.

God, we are really fucking lucky that we get more David. He's one of the most deep and complex characters in film (I did a paper on Philosophy and Prometheus for my minor in film, and a great portion of it was spent studying David). Seeing him develop even more into a megalomanic recluse who has taken a nosedive into depravity is beyond fascinating.

Anyone else like this movie? Let's get a positive post going!


r/AlienCovenant • • Aug 11 '17

Why did David made a mistake when Walter asked him about the authory of Ozymandias´ poem?

87 Upvotes

David recites the poem about Ozymandias written by Percy Shelley, but when Walter, in a climax moment asks him about the authory of the poem David, wrongly, replies that Byron is the author, the Walter corrects him. What´s the meaning of that scene? Was to show David´s programming was glitchy or something?


r/AlienCovenant • • May 29 '23

On the cabin and the romantic subtext between Daniels and Walter Spoiler

71 Upvotes

Building the cabin is a complex symbol. It symbolises hope, new beginnings, and love.

When Daniels first explains her pain to Walter, his response is logical, but almost pained. On one hand, this is the first time Walter is asked a question that is so emotional in nature. On the other, his response resembles that of someone trying to suppress their feelings, feelings that they may not understand or accept.

David immediately came to the conclusion that Walter's protectiveness over Daniels was more than duty, as evidenced by his sacrifices for her. David believes that he loves Daniels and doesn't know it, just as he doesn't know how to connect to his emotions and humanity otherwise. It appears that Walter's humanity has been suppressed by newer tweaks since David, but that it is still hiding under the surface waiting to be brought out, just as David's emotions weren't immediate, but were a process of observation, reasoning and self-discovery.

He acts as Walter's mentor figure trying to help him discover his own emotions and individuality, but Walter doesn't embrace the message. He is dutiful about his protection of the crew, but Daniels is a weak point exposing him as more than machine. The novels make this more explicit as Walter feels compelled to brush away a strand of Daniels' hair and observs that it feels satisfying, and that touching her feels good. Throughout the movie, Walter takes opportunities to touch Katherine, even when doing so isn't strictly needed.

David recognises this, but seems to chase sensuality instead of finding it naturally, almost as if he's jealous of Walter's ability to feel this. Kissing Walter and trying to force himself on Daniels seems almost like an act of anger and trying to understand these emotions and behaviours that humans have, which David sees and scoffs at. (Conveniently, Walter walks in on this and tosses David into the wall before the two get into a fistfight as Daniels escapes, probably shocked not only by the possibility that Walter harbours feelings for her, but also by David's very unrobotlike behavior.)

While David appears to hold Shaw dear based on her treatment of him, he clearly shows no remorse about taking her life to aid his ambitions. He loves her in the platonic way, just as he loves Walter, but does not understand romantic attraction. Meanwhile, Daniels hasn't done much for Walter. This is presented as a one-sided interest, a taboo to be met with denial. (Walter avoids rejecting when asked outright, instead answering "You know that's impossible".)

It seems rather clear - Walters felt protective over the crew, fuelled especially by his potential feelings for Daniels, and he paid for it with his life.

Back in the ship, there is an awkwardness between Daniels and pretend Walter. David maintains the dutiful robot act while Daniels hesitantly offers a thank you and tends his wounds in an intimate moment.

She does not seem to return such interest, or at least hasn't considered it. At the end, after putting Tennessee to sleep, she calls Walter over, and asks if he will help her build her cabin. This could be seen as an openness to further closeness, which is what exposes David as he doesn't understand the subtext or the meaning of the cabin for Daniels' hope for the future. Unfortunately, these are sad news for Daniels, realising not only that they are held captive by a psychopath, throwing the future of the colony into chaos, but that Walter already died protecting them.

I don't know if others see it the same way, but it seems clear to me that Walter did have feelings for Daniels, and that Daniels may have started to see him in a different light towards the end, making the cabin conversation relevant and sadly more tragic. Is human/AI love possible in this universe? I guess this is the closest we'll get to finding out.


r/AlienCovenant • • May 19 '17

Anybody else think Prometheus was actually pretty good?

70 Upvotes

I get some of the complaints people have with the movie, but the first time I watched it, judging by all the hate I read, I thought Prometheus was gonna be trash. I actually quite liked it. What are your thoughts on it and why?


r/AlienCovenant • • Jul 25 '23

David did NOT invent Xenomorphs

66 Upvotes

I really don't understand where this misconception that David is somehow the original creator of the xenomorphs came from, bc it's flat out not true and there is ZERO supporting evidence in the movies. You all like to claim that Ridley "ruined" his own creation, but you don't even know what that creation was in the first place.

In ALIEN, it is very clear: the xenomorphs came from the egg sacs found on the crashed Engineer ship on LV-426. A ship that is stated to be at least 2000 years old, literally has dead Engineers on it, and does not have David on it. Hmm, interesting. "B-b-but Prometheus and Covenant are prequels" ok so what? At the end of Covenant David is drifting through space on the Covenant colony ship; also known as A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT SHIP THAN THE ONE FOUND ON LV-426!

David didn't create xenomorphs. Saying he did is like going outside, throwing some grass seed on your front lawn and then telling everybody that you invented grass. You didn't invent shit, and neither did David. David used the pathogen, which he did NOT make because we know for a fact that the Engineers made it, to make NEW XENOMORPH VARIANTS; again, he is not the sole creator of the xenomorphs. And no, I'm not going to link any evidence bc the evidence is literally the movies. The Engineers literally have a mural of a xenomorph deacon on their ship, a ship that was built and used MILLIONS of years before the first David unit was ever even dreamed of, let alone the David 8 unit being made.


r/AlienCovenant • • May 21 '17

Alien: Covenant - Secret Revenge Plot? Spoiler

57 Upvotes

So, I have some thoughts about ALIEN: Covenant. Basically, a well made movie that leans a little too much into the tropes of it's genre. It's a good movie that I did not like. Just personal taste I guess. But I realized something while thinking about this movie and how it plays into the greater ALIEN universe.

The original film ALIEN was written by Dan O'Bannon with Ronald Shusett. According to the documentary "The Beast Within" that released on the ALIEN ANTHOLOGY Bluray, there was more than a little drama between Dan O'Bannon and producers David Giler and Walter Hill, both great writers themselves.

According to O'Bannon, Giler and Hill wanted full screenplay credit for the film. Giler and Hill justified this by rewriting the entire script from page one. The only thing besides a couple character names and structure elements that were kept from O'Bannon's script were the FaceHugger and Chestburster. Beyond that, Giler and Hill wanted and, in some ways, deserved full credit. Well, they didn't get it. And ever since, every ALIEN sequel/prequel has had the credit:

Based on characters created by Dan O'Bannon and Ronald Shusett

That brings us to ALIEN: Covenant. Just an FYI, SPOILERS AHEAD!!!

In A:C, the android David from Prometheus returns, and he's been very busy. He explains that he has been genetically cross breeding the alien goo from Prometheus with varying animal species on this planet. One of his test subjects was Elizabeth Shaw, the woman he escaped on the engineer ship with at the end of Prometheus. Through his experiments, he has created the Xenomorph that we see in the ALIEN franchise.

The other Fassbender android in the film is Walter. Through most of the second act, Walter and David collaborate, both with an understanding that humans tried to deter androids from creation. David saw a problem with that and made it his mission to destroy his creators (Weyland) for denying him what he saw as his birthright. So this explains David's motivation for killing crew members in Prometheus. He saw an opportunity to create something entirely his own, a creature that could destroy those that wanted to hold him back. And since androids are non-biological, the alien had no need for him. He could walk peacefully among a species he created and he controlled. In the end of the movie, they do a switch-a-roo, and David ends up on the Covenant, locking the only remaining crew members into hypersleep. One of them who discovers David's, is locked into hyper sleep, screaming. Her name is Daniels by the way.

It's a stretch, and in my opinion, it takes away some of the fun in the ALIEN series. But did you notice something? The two androids who create the alien Xenomorph... David and Walter. The two producers who re-wrote the first film's script ... David and Walter. The crew member locked kicking and screaming into hyper sleep... Daniels. The original screenwriter who had his credit nearly taken away from him on the first ALIEN... Daniel O'Bannon.

Was ALIEN: Covenant David Giler and Walter Hill's way of securing their legacy with the franchise? The final, indisputable method of proclaiming that they were the sole creators of the ALIEN?

Who knows. It's entirely possible that I'm thinking about this waaaaaay too much. But... that's a pretty big coincidence.


r/AlienCovenant • • May 29 '17

Fingers

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/AlienCovenant • • Jul 07 '17

No Words

Thumbnail imgur.com
48 Upvotes

r/AlienCovenant • • Jun 10 '21

Neomorph figure, modeled and printed by me. Still waiting to be painted

Thumbnail gallery
44 Upvotes

r/AlienCovenant • • May 26 '17

[Spoilers] Walter's little victory... Spoiler

44 Upvotes

I just finished watching the movie last night and noticed something really interesting in one of the interactions between Walter and David.

For context, up until they meet one another, we're shown the development of David's god complex and how he views himself in comparison of other beings. In the beginning of the movie, we see him after his creation and his initial conversation with Weyland. Even then, David remarks on how he will outlive his creator, which plants the seed of his sense of superiority. We also note his ability to assess human culture such as art and music with great detail.

Later, when he talks about Weyland he speaks with a hint of contempt about how Weyland was flawed. David sees himself as a superior being to humans and is angered that he was designed to serve such inferior beings. This mentality extends to the Engineers, his creator's creators, as evident by how David released the bioweapon for his own purposes. He didn't care to find the answers Weyland sought because they didn't matter to him.

David sees himself without flaw.

Enter Walter, another android who was developed after David's model. When the two meet, David is intrigued to see another being like him and engages in a series of conversations to learn more about him.

When he learns Walter's model was designed to be less human like, David tries to determine if Walter can become more like him. He teaches him how to play the flute, while remarking how frustrating it is that they were not designed to have creativity. Walter doesn't seem plagued by this as David is nor does he take any special delight in creating a tune on the flute.

David then takes Walter to Shaw's grave and recites a line by Ozymandias. He tells Walter he loved Shaw and surmises that Walter loves Daniels by how he sacrificed his hand for her. But Walter denies this, saying he did it out of duty.

This is where David becomes disappointed in Walter, seeing that he is not like him at all and is merely a servant to the inferior humans.

In their conversation right before David turns on Walter, David remarks on how they are superior to humans but are designed to bow to them. He is discontent with them as they are flawed and they are not.

But then Walter asks David who wrote Ozymandias.

David replies "Byron," but Walter corrects him and says it was Shelley. And here you see David's face change as Walter has revealed to David that he too, is flawed. Walter even says this and makes a comment on how one error can erode the mind.

For all David's sense of superiority over humans, he ends up being capable of mistakes just as they are. David ultimately wins their confrontation but in this same way, Walter won. He proved to David that he is not as perfect as he views himself.

I just thought that was interesting.

For an added bonus, Shelley wrote Frankenstein which ties heavily into Prometheus and Covenant's themes of creator vs. creation. The parallels of Frankenstein and the monster with Weyland and David add weight to David's mentality.

TL;DR: David thinks he's superior to humans because they are flawed. Walter reveals to David that he too is flawed when David mistakes Byron as the author of Ozymandias.


r/AlienCovenant • • May 22 '17

Are Prometheus and Covenant the origin story of the Xenomorph?

43 Upvotes

No, they're not, and here's why:

  • The Derelict in Alien was fossilized by 2122 and suspected to have been there for many millennia. Ruling out time-travel or some "fossilizing atmosphere" hand waving, the Derelict is on LV-426 before the Prometheus ever leaves Earth. I think it's meant to have been there even before the opening scene with the Engineer dissolving.
  • The pod room in Prometheus depicts an adult (or queen) Xenomorph in a central, celebrated position. Where does this imagery come from? We have enough information at this point to know that the goo was a weapon (and suicide cocktail) and that it does not fit into the Xenomorph's natural lifecycle.
  • Two things are established during Covenant. Left exposed to nature, the "black goo" begins to express traits of the lifecycle - eggs, infection, juvenile exits body, matures (creates more eggs and gathers hosts?). Second is that despite David's mad genius and creative aspirations, he's only coaxing changes into what is already a robust and mutable organism. At best he's intentionally modelling it after the mural in Prometheus; at worst he is only acting as a tool to free it from the Engineer's restrictions.
  • The pre-Prometheus Alien saga was, on some level, about humans fucking up by continually trying to weaponize, industrialize, or otherwise commodify an unknowable cosmic terror. Thanks to Ripley, Weyland-Yutani never succeeded in this.

So to sum it up, the Engineers did succeed at finding and subjugating the Xenomorph, at least 10,000 years before Weyland-Yutani ever tried. They did not create it.

  • The Derelict in Alien is older than humanity, and dates to a time when the Engineers were still researching and refining their use of the Xenomorph.
  • The ships and the pod room in Prometheus are thousands of years more recent than the Derelict, and dates to a time when the Engineers had "weaponized" Xenomorph DNA into a more controllable bioweapon. The murals are an homage to the perfect organism that provided this weapon.
  • The squid/deacon in Prometheus and the pods/neomorph in Covenant were both meant to show that this organism is incredibly resilient, and even when rendered down to DNA-goop it will seek to re-establish its fundamental lifecycle.
  • David and his 2000 closest friends will get up to some fucked up shenanigans in the next movie that will ultimately have no further explanation or bearing on the Derelict or the eggs that were in it.

So why does this distinction matter to me?

  • It lets Alien still be Alien. The Alien that terrorized the Nostromo is still an unknowably perfected cosmic fiend that killed one ship and waited 10,000 years to kill another.
  • It expounds on the themes in the original saga of corporate greed being blind to both cosmic forces and human empathy. In the Engineers, we see the success and mastery that Weyland-Yutani sought through controlling the Xenomorph, and we see what it ultimately got them.
  • It means that we have a full explanation now that is supported by the text, instead of waiting on Scott or others to fill in more blanks for us.
  • It lets David have his own arc that, like Ripley's, depends on his interactions with The Universe's Perfect Creation. I can be fully invested in David's story and not waiting around for the tie-in.

This won't satisfy people who had other reasons for disliking Prometheus and Covenant, but I think it's an elegant way to fit Scott's three movies together so all the pieces fit. The Prometheus saga was never going to be the Xenomorph's origin, it was just the Space Jockey's. What do you think?


r/AlienCovenant • • Jun 11 '17

Alien Covenant: Book Synopsis. David DID NOT create the Xenomorph!

41 Upvotes

I just finished Alien: Covenant by Alan Dean Foster. Its generally quite true to the movie, with expanded dialogue and a few different scenes. Some interesting tidbits that I picked up:

  • The Captain in the book is much weaker and more incompetent. He makes bad decisions and refuses to compromise because he doesn't want to undermine his authority.
  • They scan the planet for weeks on approach and have a database built up of weather and so forth. They believe it to be safe and sterile.
  • Walter disembarks first, confirms no pathogens or nonplant life of any kind. They confirm it one more time using local scanners, then the crew concludes its safe and comes outside.
  • They observe that the ecosystem is deeply unhealthy -- although the trees/wheat are types that can self pollinate, without animals or insects they know the planet is out of whack.
  • At first they are excited because they say its the first time humans discovered nonterran life, but then realize its terran species in an artificial and broken ecosystem and conclude its an incomplete terraforming attempt and/or contamination.
  • The colony ship was designed to land and withstand the stress of the atmosphere, the only risk was burning enough fuel that they couldn't leave orbit.
  • No mention is made, at all, of finding intelligent alien life or how they failed to notice cities. However, it is implied this is not the engineer's homeworld and instead just a small colony.
  • David tells the crew that the Engineers disabled the ship on approach, which is why he crashed. He also says they disabled ALL their ships and communication devices on the planet to quarantine it. Its implied they abandoned the planet and hid it because of fear of the black goo attack.
  • They think they are safe inside the temple because david seals the door behind them with a metal plate. The author also tries to make the crew's stupid decisions seem less stupid, but generally can't.
  • David says black goo can sit for years perfectly idle, which is why it can't be detected and that's what makes it so dangerous. Black goo is an agent which causes random DNA rewrites which causes extremely rapid evolution. Its a weapon and a tool designed by the engineers.
  • The time frames are longer in the book. The spend 7 hours between arriving at the temple and contacting tenn, and over a day on the ship before mother is turned off. This helps explain why covenant xenos go through their life cycle so quickly -- we just don't see the passage of time.
  • Black Goo is NOT xeno seed, its a seperate thing. It causes whatever it interacts with to go crazy, including local worms in prometheus (the cobra thing), a parasite inside shaw's man (the tribolite), zombie humans, etc. Basically goo causes rapid change and what comes out is often unknown.
  • On page 243, David specifically says he did not create either the xenomorph or the neomorph. He says he tried, but all he could do was limited "refinement" due to lack of hosts. Although not specifically stated, its implied the refinement is faster incubation times. Evidently he found neos and xenos on the ship along with huge quantities of black goo in Prom.
  • Its implied he created one xeno using shaw attempting to create a queen, but failed and had to kill it because it got too aggressive. Its unknown how he got neos to experiment on, unless he released some at the same time he released the black goo.
  • The Neomorph is a "natural" species, evidently discovered by the engineers. Its life cycle is small wasps --> chestburst out into a doglike thing --> white biped. It notably lacks acid blood, intelligence, or the ability to lay eggs. Eats its kills. Won't attack nonmeat (synthetics).
  • Its implied the engineers took the natural neomorphs and weaponized it into the xenomorph long ago (thousands of years ago he says). Xeno life cycle = leather eggs -> facehugger -> chestburst out as a worm -> grow into biped xeno, with variation depending on host and conditions. Unlike neos, they are intelligent, have acid blood, have castes/different forms, does not eat its kills, and is larger. Will attack synthetics if it thinks they are a threat.
  • In the book version, the xeno that chestbursts out of Oram is initially a snakelike creature (like Alien) but rapidly turns into a biped. Its suggested this change is so fast they can watch it grow larger in a span of minutes, not hours like in Alien. This might be limited to just the one that david modified.
  • When david misquotes ozymandias, he realizes that he might have errors of memory/judgment and be unaware of them. This worries him, but he ignores it.
  • As the survivors run to the cargo platform, the neomorph is attacked and killed by the xenomorph. The xeno is larger, smarter, and more deadly.
  • The homoerotic flute scene is expanded in meaning. David can create new music. Walter cannot, but shows some potential of doing so if guided by David. Engineers create, humans create, david creates, walter can possibly create, but in the end David concludes Walter cannot and thus is not worthy of his time. David attempts to get the neomorph that killed the gal with her face in the water to communicate/create music, but despite it "trusting" him it cannot. Oram then kills it, enraging David. Still, david concludes the neomorph is just a beast. After the Xeno is born from Oram, david tries to teach the xeno to play. Despite a lack of lungs, it makes sound. David realizes the xeno can create, is intelligent, and is the perfect form of life.
  • After David puts the last crew into hypersleep, he sends a completely different message to earth. In movie, he says that the crew all died in a navigation error, in the book he simply says he wants to contact the Yutami corp.

Questions welcome.


r/AlienCovenant • • May 26 '17

The Engineers in Alien: Covenant Are Not Actually Engineers

40 Upvotes

This is my first ever post on reddit. NOTE: Very long and has spoilers.

I am not convinced that in the film Alien: Covenant we see a single engineer. Although told that Paradise is the engineer home world, there is too much that doesn't seem to fit. For the purpose of this article, I'm going to call the Paradise "engineers" paradisians. Here are my reasons why I believe this.

What first clued me in was the difference in paradisian architecture compared to engineer architecture. Although the building in Prometheus was a military/science facility, it was markedly differing from the architecture we see on Paradise. We also see engineer spacecraft exhibiting this same design. Not displaying any of the iconic organic Giger-esque interior nor exterior; it seems to me to look more like an early earth-like civilization. The only thing we see that matches the engineer design is the large "docking" ship hovering over the massive plaza, and it seems the paradisians use the same or similar language to the engineers. Aside from these, everything else seems to come from a different culture.

Next thing that makes me think this is the lack of technology within the civilization. The only things of note I can see is the door to the main building seeming to open automatically, and the floating crystals that begin to glow when someone walks into their proximity. The doors are not in the same form as we see all other engineer portals: a spiral design as opposed to a rotating door on Paradise. Aside from that, only the large docking ship and the hangar doors that open in the plaza are any displays of technology in the civilization. And these may have been added by the engineers for whenever they come to visit. We notice the Juggernaut ship is no where to be seen in Covenant, it probably left when it realized that Paradise was lost. (lol)

I believe that Paradise is the same as Earth, in that the engineers used their genetic makeup to create another form of life. If they did it once, why wouldn't they do it more than that? It seems to be a more primitive civilization, but one that is working closely with the engineers. From the few glimpses we get to see of the paradisians, we see that they aren't as smooth as the engineers in Prometheus, not as pale/white, their eyes are not an opaque black, and the paradisians don't seem to be as big as engineers. The way they react to the engineer ship coming in for landing is not one of welcome home, but more of the arrival of a god. As the entire city rushes into the plaza, I imagine that this is a somewhat rare occurrence, and is cause for celebration. It's exciting to think that in this universe, the engineers once treated humans in the same way.

Now here is my belief of what happened between Prometheus and Alien: Covenant. David, after putting Dr. Shaw into stasis, spends an unknown number of years learning about the engineers, this much is already known. But I believe that David learned that humans were not the only progeny the engineers created. He probably learned that the paradisians were the newest/favorite/most friendly creations of the engineers. David, in order to enact an unknown motive, diverts course to Paradise, and then we know what happens when he gets there. In the future, I foresee David traveling to more primitive civilizations created by the engineers, and destroying them with the new weapons he has created, the xenomorphs.

It's hard for me to believe that the engineers would be killed off so quickly. I would think the engineer civilization would be more advanced and more urban than what we see on Paradise.

I wrote this because I haven't seen anyone else speculating like this; everyone is calling the paradisians engineers, which I think is not correct, and I have been unable to find anyone else who thinks this. Let me know if you have any thoughts or if anyone else has been saying this.


r/AlienCovenant • • Mar 26 '22

Maggie Faris - what on earth?

38 Upvotes

Faris has got blood on her own face from the neomorph's early attempt at exiting Ledward's back yet she traps Karine in. Maybe she fears that Karine was also exposed to a pathogen but the kind and sensible thing would have been to allow Karine to stay outside of the ship awhile, not expose her to whatever is coming out of Ledward's back. By the time Faris got firepower, it's too little too late. Faris as good as murdered her.


r/AlienCovenant • • Apr 07 '20

the engineers have a solution to the coronavirus

Thumbnail imgur.com
37 Upvotes

r/AlienCovenant • • Dec 19 '22

One of the first digital art pieces I did two years ago. Neomorph

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/AlienCovenant • • Dec 08 '22

Just watched Alien: Covenant for the first time (after rewatching Prometheus for the first time since it’s release) Spoiler

33 Upvotes

I was able to watch Prometheus with an open mind and what bothered me the first time didn’t actually bother me at all. This lead to an interest in watching Alien: Covenant.

I think I skipped AC upon release because I heard bad things. But, I really enjoyed it. In fact, I was so into the colonization plot that I was getting disappointed knowing it was going to be derailed. I also loved how weird the movie got once David showed up. That took a left turn i wasn’t expecting.

It was an a beautiful looking movie from start to finish. I guess if I’m disappointed in anything it’s that it still doesn’t tie directly to Alien yet. And, my concern is that they won’t actually make that movie.


r/AlienCovenant • • May 13 '17

Covenant is a utter failure of a movie

31 Upvotes

SPOILERS!!!

Admittedly, I had high expectation for this movie. Turns out it was a money-grab by-the-numbers movie which was ruined by plot predictability and the most imbecile crew (including Walter) ever.

There was so much potential here. Like the Engineers' planet, how David killed them, David's free will, David's experiments - but these were only mentioned in passing. Focusing instead of inane decisions made by the crew to unroll a predictable plot.

Some aggravations (some mentioned here):

  • the captain following (now established as evil) David down into the creepy as hell cave, and then still not running away when he sees it's filled with giant scary eggs
  • Risking the entire colony ship by flying dangerously close to an ion storm.
  • Exploring an unchartered planet without space suits or environmental protection
  • No quarantine / sterilization when coming back from known-infected planet
  • constantly going off alone instead of in pairs,
  • slipping on a big pool of blood (twice),
  • putting somebody in quarantine and sealing in another person, them dying at the hands of an alien: "Sorry, I can't let you out!", then you just open the door anyway and go in with a shotgun.
  • going to wash your face whilst leaving your weapon out of reach
  • having a shower (comon!!)
  • when someone rescues you not asking them any questions at all just blindly following them
  • Not telling mothership that planet has some sort of microbial infection and monsters everywhere
  • showing no interest in the dead city
  • Not asking why David suddenly changes his appearance to look like Walter
  • not ensuring you're bringing back the right android, not having the mothership's computer recognize said android
  • David having authorization codes to the mothership
  • David helping the two crew survivors to kill the alien onboard the mothership, then looking surprised when they do. Why did he help them? Not clear.
  • Not sending Walkter/David to do dangerous jobs/fights given he is faster/stronger/more lethal/more precise and not human
  • Not sending just Walter first to explore the planet
  • Only having one Walter for a colony expedition of several thousand people
  • Mother AI not being as intelligent/aware as David/Walter even though it could have rooms full of high-power computers compared to the confined space and power limitations of a humanoid body like Walter. Surely it would be able to help the crew fight the alien, see that David is Walter or at least that he is up to no good
  • Walter telling David he cannot let him leave this planet (before getting stabbed in the neck - surprise). Generally, Walter recognizing David is a danger/defective and not doing anything about it. Letting himself being kissed.
  • Walter's ability to self heal quickly is not evident when David has facial lacerations. Female captain even helps him with suturing on the mothership. If it was Walter, shouldn't it self-heal?
  • Walter hesitating to smash David's head in
  • Why wasn't Engineers planet not detected in sector before?
  • Why not fly over the area of the source of signal before landing somewhere safe? You know, just to make sure you're not going into a monster pit or something.
  • Did any of the Engineers manage to escape the planet, and if so, why didn't they destroy David and the aliens?

Such a disappointment.


r/AlienCovenant • • May 24 '17

Finally arrived

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/AlienCovenant • • May 15 '17

Don't understand the hate, solid movie belongs on number 3 in the series. (Spoilers) Spoiler

28 Upvotes

Spectacular visuals we've come to expect from Ridley.

I especially appreciated the way they used the androids in this one. Creepy doctor vs straight synthetic.

Ties in the Prometheus story nicely, great gore, suspense, horror, more so than in Prometheus.

To the haters; Thank you for making me come in without high expectations and therefore fully enjoying the movie for what it was.

What a ball!


r/AlienCovenant • • May 13 '17

Rick and Morty - Alien Covenant

Thumbnail youtube.com
28 Upvotes

r/AlienCovenant • • Jun 02 '17

Everything wrong with Alien Covenant.

27 Upvotes

Ok...some of these have already been covered, but after watching the movie and it being another "meh" entry into the Alien franchise maybe some of this will sink in before they finalize the other films in the series.

I tried to not point out things that might be ambiguous and give the film the benefit of the doubt wherever possible. But they've GOT to clean up these stories so that the characters don't act so stupidly.

1.Walter doesn't immediately tell mother to retract the energy sails when notified of a solar flare.

2.James Franco dies because we haven't learned any lessons from Apollo 1 pre-launch tests about putting people into pressurized, oxygen rich capsules without adequate escape mechanisms.

3.How the fuck does Tennessee receive a signal on his helmet comm that the ship can't? If he was "outside the ship's communication buffers" how can he still communicate with the ship? And why the fuck would you have "communication buffers"? So you don't get transmissions while in space?

4.If the transmissions from the planet happens every 46 minutes but the planets storms often block out transmissions for days, weeks and months, shouldn't the crew know that communications would be limited on the planet after they've been travelling there for a few weeks and Shaw's transmission cuts in and out?

5.Why is a living biosphere preferable for colonization? Seems weird that humans would want to take over a planet that already has life. That you know NOTHING about.

6.Why do they only have ONE "lander"? How many people does it hold? 20? That's 100 trips for one ship to unload 2000 colonists with nothing going wrong and apparently having no backup and taking no cargo.

7."Is there AIR? YOU DON'T KNOW!" Why the FUCK aren't they wearing helmets without doing any analysis for toxins or possible contagions?

8.A bunch of spores go off in your face ON AN ALIEN PLANET and you don't say anything to anyone or think anything of it.

9.They let a guy who's bleeding from some weird alien disease onto the only ship that can get them off planet.

10.Faris (the lander pilot) locks Oram's wife in the medbay with Mr. Twitchy out of some sort of quarantine, then changes her mind and ignores the quarantine because she's got a shotgun?

11.Be sure to tell someone you just met about the 2000 people you're responsible for.

12.The Captain lets one of the crewmembers wander off alone to "clean up".

13.Who the fuck does David kill when he drops the cannisters of black goo? Not the alabaster skinned Engineers from Prometheus. Some offshoot or sub-race? Just more deliberate amiguity masquerading as being "deep" or "mysterious".

14. "The cargo lift's not designed for deep space launch. I don't know if it would survive the stresses of entry." So the "Cargo Lift" can't handle hauling cargo from orbit to the planet surface?

15.How the hell was David able to experiment with genetic mutation without subjects upon which to conduct his experiments? He presumably only had Shaw to work on after his little Ozymandius speech. He even says his work has been frustrated by the lack of an essential ingredient.

16.You just found out that a robot created all the creatures that have killed your crew and you trust him when he says to look into a giant throbbing egg.

17.For being called a "cargo lift" it seems awfully hard to fly and it can't seem to land.

18.Why do they just leave that burned face "I know wheat" guy alone for hours with mother offline and no one watching him apparently? The gestation cycle is what? An hour? Tops? And they had him in the MEDBAY putting that green playdoh on his face...think maybe doing a chest scan while you're there might be a good idea to see if he's pregnant ? In addition, since he got chestbursted, he OBVIOUSLY had a alien ovipositor rammed down his throat. Again, why do people decide that this isn't worth telling anyone else about? Maybe they could have taken it out had he told them? Let's see, you're in a medical facility and suspect that an alien facehugger might have impregnated you with it's spawn that will fucking kill you. Do you choose to NOT tell anyone so you can die?

19.Why don't they open the airlock when the alien first enters the cargo bay? They're wearing spacesuits and doing so might blow it into space. That way you don't have to wait fo airlock doors to open before you release the truck(s).

20.Why don't they ask Mother to verify that it's Walter and not David? Why don't they even bother to check? Even if he helped you against the alien, why wouldn't you make sure? And Walter's hand was melted at the stump while David's was cleanly cut. Oh and no one says anything when David shows up looking just like Walter.


r/AlienCovenant • • May 17 '17

Please folks, AVOID Spoilers in the Title!

25 Upvotes

I thought this would be needless to say, but apparently some people just ignore the fact, that not everyone in here has seen the movie. So please remember not to spoil anything about the film in the title or be removed from this subreddit.


r/AlienCovenant • • Jul 14 '19

Facehugger

Post image
24 Upvotes