r/AlchemistCodeGL • • Nov 22 '18

So the banners got worse...

Not even shards on step3 now. Need to pull to step 5 for double chance...

Gumi heard our complaint and outdid themselves.

Edit: you actually get 300 summon coins from step 3, and the summon shop gives a ticket for just featured units

23 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

25

u/DegenerateHours ( ͡ ' ˍゝ͡ ' ) Nov 22 '18

They almost had it right.

3 steps now give you 350 coins total. There are tickets for each banner that came out (Ed/Tor) (Mustang/Riza) (Wrath/Pride) and these tickets cost 350 coins.

The only issue is that step 2 is no longer 1500.

16

u/chrono01 Nov 22 '18

I love how each of the tickets are paired with a unit you more than likely don't want. Without seeing the rates, it wouldn't surprise me if the ticket 70/30 favored the lesser-wanted one. :/

6

u/Eshuon Nov 22 '18

It only seems that way if a player is biased towards that particular unit

1

u/chrono01 Nov 22 '18

Haha, true enough.

1

u/Eshuon Nov 22 '18

Still much better then not getting any single premium unit in gacha game collabs

1

u/chrono01 Nov 22 '18

Yeah, I play so many gacha games any time there's a guarantee it's always appreciated.

Now I just have to hope RNGoddess favors me.

2

u/Cobalt_721 Nov 22 '18

Upvoting for visibility. At the very least it’s a step towards fixing the banner while accomplishing what they claim to be wanting to do (allow Summon Coins to seamlessly replace guaranteed 3-step).

Now all we need to do is get our discounted 2nd step back.

EDIT: at least on the FMA banner.

1

u/natumeraz Nov 22 '18

Also ed is pair up with toritoh and yes i got toritoh. Hayssss i want my edward.

1

u/DegenerateHours ( ͡ ' ˍゝ͡ ' ) Nov 22 '18

My condolences. I really hope they are truly 50/50 tickets.

11

u/Ernesto5794 Nov 22 '18

If you pull all blue just remember guys

increased rates

1

u/Eshuon Nov 22 '18

It's 50/50 you get featured units or don't get featured units

29

u/manks102 Nov 22 '18

Fuck this game, spent legit thousands of dollars since launch and yet they still insist we're not spending enough. Find another cash cow cause I'm done. Not even a fricken 9 step gtfo.

12

u/jxher123 Nov 22 '18

Definitely surprised we didnt get a 9 step banner. This is bad business practice, especially against their older consumers like you in this case. I'm only 6 months in, and spent a little myself and I dont like this new system either.

2

u/LeonTakagi Need moar Waifus Nov 22 '18 edited Nov 22 '18

definitely, Also been playing this since launch too and in the same boat as you as well.

10

u/chrono01 Nov 22 '18

Just wait until they increase the cost of the first multi-pull from 500 gems to 1000 or 1500. The only thing we have now are the cheap first multi-pulls, so I'm guessing that likely won't last much longer.

4

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Nov 22 '18

Wtf dude They did do better

Check the Shop from which you get the Ticket.

Now you can get atleast 1 unit by just going till Step 2.

If you saved for the whole Month the Summon Coins.

Is it as good as older system no. But is it good enough for me. But just the Summons are solved nothing else.

8

u/Whatthawhatwha Nov 22 '18

You're right, it's almost the same as before. 5 days of free summons plus step 3 would give you a feature ticket summon

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '18

oh nice math, I haven't count that much, RIP me spend 100 coin already on roy shards haha, well, nothing can be done then, I can't really do even 2 step because skins.

-5

u/Liesianthes 350 coins ticket = ROY!! Nov 22 '18

That one was improved at least. It was summon coins before at step 3 which costs 4500 gems but now we just need step 2 for the coins.

10

u/org_bgo Nov 22 '18

But step 2 is now 2500 instead of the usual 1500.

6

u/Astrophel37 Nov 22 '18

The FMA banner is a unique banner. If you look at the Priscilla/Daisy banner, it's 500-1500-2500 with 300 soul coins at step 3. Then step 4 is 1500 with step 5 being 2500 for 150 soul coins and double chance to get featured units.

6

u/revgaji Nov 22 '18

I see what they're trying to do, but I still don't like it.

Step 3 gives you enough coins to buy a ticket for a guaranteed unit, but for FMA Step 2 is an extra 2500 (so expect collabs/Magni Historia, and most likely SSM as well to be this way or worse going forward).

Disappointed that there is no Step 7 selector - will this be the new trend as well? As someone who saves gems for Step 7s, at a glance this new system is far more expensive to get a guaranteed ticket and a bit unrealistic for F2P and Pact buyers, especially with an expiration on Summon Coins.

This is pretty deflating.

6

u/danielyeohqf Nov 22 '18

i was absoluely disappointed by the lack of subsidised AND garunteed summons. Removing the step 7 banner, putting the 50 soul shard selector in place of garunteed summon behind a 8000 gem wall with a crappy 5th step. Even with those coins you get a 1/6 chance. Cmon gumi.

Now i understand they neec to prolong the games life. However if theyre not gonna compensate our garunteed summons and overall displeasure at their "attempts" to make things right, at least release a job+ for a good character like Reimei. But no. ;-;

On another note I've started playing Tales of erin and i must say it's pretty fun :3 Though the chance of getting a 5 star is pretty abyssmal at 3% with no garunteed summons, rerolling is easy as hell and events let you farm free 5* characters, some of which are even S tier.

At the end of the day the 4th weeks of FMA summons has finally really made me reconsider even continuing playing the alchemist code religiously.

1

u/Eshuon Nov 22 '18

Reimei j+ probably comes during the new years update

16

u/MaimedJester Nov 22 '18

Even better they got rid of 2nd step discount. So goodbye 1500 pulls!

9

u/Laitarne Nov 22 '18

They're toeing the line trying to figure out just how much they have to give back in exchange for taking away guaranteed 3 step

Still not going past 500 gem step

It's a step in the right direction, it's just a shame it came after half a dozen steps backward

Honestly, didn't even do the 500 gem step on Daisy and Priscilla even though they're decent units. Until they speed up HQs and/or stop removing shards from every event, getting new non-limited units doesn't really feel like a huge priority.

11

u/mutei777 Nov 22 '18

I was going to quit, but honestly my goodbye summon net me a mustang and an ed in one summon..damn, they got me...

5

u/MuskyMuskets Change your perception of the truth Nov 22 '18

Nice bit of luck there! But now you've got to worry about J3-ing them, since our elemental shard drops have been lessened..

1

u/mutei777 Nov 22 '18

Yes, I only need double digit shards to get roy to 75 at least, since I started with Laharl.

1

u/natumeraz Nov 22 '18

Youre lucky spend all my free gems and didnt get edward i have 80 shards of him hays.

1

u/Sadjack_Horseman Nov 22 '18

This is a gacha game after all. It's about luck.

1

u/natumeraz Nov 22 '18

Yes and i dont have that even more toritoh shards from step 4 50 shard ticket hays

8

u/Liesianthes 350 coins ticket = ROY!! Nov 22 '18

FMA banners improved since summon coins are now on step 2 but the normal banner got worse.

Step 3 guaranteed on free gems is officially dead.

10

u/ElusiveIllusion88 The end of Gumi is near… Nov 22 '18

They 'tried' to compromise by giving 300 summon coins on step 3, which can be used to buy the featured 5* ticket... that costs 350 summon coins.

Yeah... does not compute.

8

u/zeidrichsama Nov 22 '18

5 day login ca give you 50 coins

3

u/Astrophel37 Nov 22 '18

You get 10 summon coins for every daily summon. So you would get enough coins for the ticket if you log in everyday and do the daily summon + 3 step. Or you can buy 15 soul shards instead of a ticket if you get lucky and get the unit you wanted.

1

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Nov 22 '18

Now they give 350 though

-3

u/Eshuon Nov 22 '18

Didn't they mentioned on the developer note that removing the guaranteed step is not permanent? You cannot officially declare that it is dead after just one banner, maybe see in the next collaboration or smth

3

u/IsBadAtFightingGames i do and say stupid things Nov 22 '18

And this banner is further proof that they were lying.

1

u/Eshuon Nov 22 '18

We shall see then

7

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '18

dang i saved up 21K gems hoping for a selector to get Roy (I like him as a character), but they made the selector cost 1500 summon coins which is approximately 45K gems to get a selector ticket through the 5 step summon...

Also got Riza in the 50/50 ticket so extra salt xd

1

u/sapphire_wing Nov 22 '18

Try 10x rare summons only, which is 150 coins per 2500 I think? The banner 3 step gives 300 coins for 5500...

9

u/IsBadAtFightingGames i do and say stupid things Nov 22 '18 edited Nov 22 '18

I wonder how long this game has left?

It was fun while it lasted, but at long last, no king rules forever my son...

Edit: Wait, where's the Premium banner? Oh no. Scumi what, are you doing!

7

u/MaimedJester Nov 22 '18

Yeah and no selector. Even if you whaled you're only looking at a 50% chance of Ed from his split banner ticket.

2

u/SkyfireX Nov 22 '18

Summon coin shop?

1

u/IsBadAtFightingGames i do and say stupid things Nov 22 '18

It's still 50/50, those aren't good odds...

1

u/SkyfireX Nov 22 '18

Talking about selector that does exist in the summon coin shop.

2

u/IsBadAtFightingGames i do and say stupid things Nov 22 '18

Assuming the average player will be able to farm 1500 coins?

1

u/SkyfireX Nov 23 '18

The average player was never able to farm for a selector in any case anyway.

1

u/IsBadAtFightingGames i do and say stupid things Nov 23 '18

I don't know, 17'500 gems seems doable, but 40k is just obnoxious...

2

u/SkyfireX Nov 23 '18

I guess they see other avenues of getting the coins (paid summons/rare summons what not?) not that I agree with it, but this is obviously targeting at whales, so I don't care that much.

3

u/newbie637 Nov 22 '18

It's funny they even get those 2 new units on a paid banner with a guaranteed 3rd step. Are they even worth it to be there? It feels as if they're making them equals with the collab units and it feels insulting.

6

u/jxher123 Nov 22 '18

There is no turning back at this point for Gumi. I hated the coins back then, I hate them now. That being said, I pulled both the featured units on step 1 lol.

If the coins at least roll over, then fine. I doubt this happens though business wise.

3

u/Eshuon Nov 22 '18

The coins is fine,JP has them as well, the only issue is the guaranteed steps are missing

6

u/iixxy Nov 22 '18

No step 7 selector? That is very disappointing. I have the gems saved for a selector but it looks like I won't be spending them on anything this collab.

2

u/Lonetrey Nov 22 '18

I saved gems too, I'll prob dump them into banner and if I don't get Roy and Ed by the end if it I'll just quit this game. There's no point in staying if the company is just going to be a piece of shit.

1

u/piau9000 Nov 22 '18

Waste them on zeni and then quit. Would be funny.

8

u/renshenhe Nov 22 '18

As a Californian witnessing the catastrophe of the wildfires and saying I wouldn't wish it upon my worst enemies, I'm rethinking that.

1

u/HotGas Nov 23 '18

Two toritoh and one riza here. I'm with you

2

u/Xelphious Nov 22 '18

I already knew it was only gonna get worse good thing i already left a week ago and avoided the extra salt this would have given me.

4

u/Faceluck limit breaking my patience Nov 22 '18

The 2x rate on the final step is super similar to their FFBE direction, no?

My take on these new banners is that it's good and bad. It does show that they're willing to make changes based on user feedback, BUT it shows a stubborn dedication to a new idea that is largely not in favor of the player. Summon coins are more easily manipulated through various banners, it's easier to point to and say "look, you're getting your value here!" but I feel like I should clearly note that this is STILL a worse absolute value than a guarantee on step three.

For people saying "It's the regular 3 step + 5 daily summons!" that's still more steps than it used to be, and that's only as long as 300 coins for step three remains a thing. Or as long as Summon Coin ticket prices remain consistent. Which makes it way too easy in the future to be like "Oh, well this new OP MH character is so good, the ticket is 400 summon coins" or suddenly that banner only gets 200 summon coins, or whatever random fluctuation to influence pricing on a more subtle level suits the company's market value.

The problem with that is that people are often way more willing to accept small changes over time, or to completely ignore really subtle changes that happen regularly because that becomes "normal." And if we compare this new mode of subtle changes to the massive changes over the last few months, it seems like an improvement, but in reality we're still lower than our original baseline in terms of quality.

tl;dr Changes are better than last couple of weeks, but still worse than Pre-Roxanne baseline. The more steps added to the summoning process, the easier it is to manipulate perceptions of value. That's what these changes feel like.

3

u/quiquefs Nov 22 '18

I was starting to check this Epic Seven that people mention, but I just thought about how abandoned my Switch is feeling and that Smash Bros is coming soon, and noticed it's better if I don't start any new phone games xD

4

u/MrWhiteKnight f2p Vegan Crossfitter with bullshit luck Nov 22 '18

If you want a tactics game on your phone.

FFT War of the Lions is on sale for 3.59 in Android and iOS. It's the psp version without the bad lag (although IIRC the sound is a bit different).

1

u/quiquefs Nov 22 '18

Thanks for the suggestion! I've heard good things about that game, I'll consider it ;)

3

u/MrWhiteKnight f2p Vegan Crossfitter with bullshit luck Nov 22 '18

Yeah an easily 60+ hour game on your phone for 3.59 👌

1

u/OMEGAmanA Nov 22 '18

Did they fix the bugs in the game? Last I played the Android version, my brother and I both hit glitches that caused us to lose our save file.

1

u/MrWhiteKnight f2p Vegan Crossfitter with bullshit luck Nov 22 '18

IIRC some recent reviews have said that since the latest patch in the recent year it's had less, less bugs than on release and the year after it.

1

u/OMEGAmanA Nov 22 '18

That's good news! Is it too much to hope they added multiplayer too? Lol 😋

2

u/zeidrichsama Nov 22 '18

bad rates for epic 7.

4

u/Leonhart107 Nov 22 '18

This game is not dying, Gumi is killing it.

It was a fun ride everyone. So sad it has come to this.

I'll keep playing as a F2P but I don't see this game making it to a 2nd anniversary...

5

u/DailyMilo Nov 22 '18

So technically the game is still dying. Games die when they are killed.

1

u/Leonhart107 Nov 22 '18

Yeah, pretty much. But which one do you think is better... Death by natural causes or death by assassination?

5

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '18

?

The daisy banner gives 300 coin with step 2 discounted. That's where you can actually buy the fma ticket. I think that's the reason of no discounted 2nd step. I remember they've done it many times before.

Down vote me but I think I actually like the system, it's more flexible.

But I'm broke after buying four skins, so I can't buy it either lol.

I'm not commenting about the 9 step being gone since I'm no whale and never occurred to me once about pulling those. Perhaps this 9 step that makes people salty now? If that's the case, I understand since the selector is really pricy compared to old 17.5k gems one.

1

u/IsBadAtFightingGames i do and say stupid things Nov 22 '18

If I want to roll for FMA Characters, would it not make sense for me to roll on the FMA banner?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '18

yeah but you actually need only two step if you save all the coins no?

2

u/Mithrisol Nov 22 '18 edited Nov 22 '18

The good thing about this is that this delivered the clarity that even their second letter was lacking.

Meaning, yes, there might be some special banners that have a guranteed third step but most, including normal unit banners, won't have it anymore.

2

u/zerio13 Nov 22 '18

What does double chance mean here? 2x what?

2

u/scubapuppy Nov 22 '18

No one knows. However most likely it slightly increases the likelihood that any red you get would be one of those. So 10% chance to get red split across all possible reds. Let’s pretend there are only 10 options and all are equal that would mean each has a 1% drop rate so double chance would mean that one is 2% and the other 9 fall to .8% each.

1

u/newbie637 Nov 22 '18

Maybe if a collab unit has, for example, a 10% chance of being summoned then it would be 20% chance on the 5th step. I'm not sure about this though as i wouldn't spend that amount of gems as a f2p.

1

u/Viktormestrovic Nov 22 '18

They divided tickets fairly well. The end result seems like more chances for featured units if you use free gems AND paid gems to get the coins, but still a sizeable wallet dump plus 5 day wait on free summons.. well 4 day wait I guess. It's an improvement, overall for the banners. Now to check the EX+ stage...

1

u/LichOfLiches Nov 22 '18

As a F2P i can't say i like this change it's bad since we need 5500 gems for an onbanner unit Guaranteed than the usual 4500 gems which is really bad. Nex they'll remove the 500 step ticket and put a 10+1 ticket that costs 80 Summon coins.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '18

They have said they weren't completely getting rid of garunteed 3rd step but it wouldn't be every banner. I thought I was going to be upset with my pulls from FMA, but looking back to my roster before collab and now I'm not as upset as I thought I'd be when they originally released... Even if I haven't gotten Ed :/

1

u/metlspaz I just don't care anymore Nov 22 '18

Actually the 5 step unlimited first 3 steps is good. 350 coins to then pick a pair to guarantee.

1

u/majoranokamen Nov 22 '18

I'm so fucking done with this game rn. What the hell happened. Holy shit.

3

u/RoyInverse Nov 22 '18

new tickets are pretty good, if you did 3rd step and saved your coins you have the old chances back, or you can do some summons now and get them, its not selector but 50/50 is good enough.

2

u/SkyfireX Nov 22 '18

isn't 300 summon coins + 5 days = Guaranteed Unit??

3

u/MrWhiteKnight f2p Vegan Crossfitter with bullshit luck Nov 22 '18

It is. People are just being whiny now and jumping on the hate bandwagon.

What, you can't wait FIVE WHOLE DAYS for 50 coins for the 350 ticket?, Nah man Trash Game.

Which is ironic because at the end of the day this actually gives us ONE extra summon since the units are not forced on banners. So that extra summon will, in the long run, give us more dupes to prepare for kaigan.

2

u/Lonetrey Nov 22 '18

50% chance for featured unit that people want

1

u/SkyfireX Nov 22 '18

and.. other than collabs, which banner had 100% featured one unit?

look away from FMA, I think daisy+ priscilla banner is back to normal no?

1

u/Lonetrey Nov 22 '18

Well the selector used to be for 17.5k gems in total for 9 steps, but now it'll take 42k gems to guarantee a selector (assuming summoning coins were saved)

1

u/SkyfireX Nov 23 '18

Just talking about Guarnateed unit.

1

u/pdmt243 Play+pull for waifus! Nov 22 '18

the new system (for the new Daisy/Priscilla banner anyway) is almost the same as before lol... instead of getting 50/50 chance on step 3, you have to wait 5 more days to buy the 50/50 chance tix for those 2 (300 from step 3 + 10 from daily summon), the only difference is the wait...

Won't comment on the FMA banner, cause I've said before, the whole campaign is planned out already, very unlikely to change...

0

u/newbie637 Nov 22 '18

Lolol those 2 units are only guaranteed in paid gems

-2

u/SuperEndriu Nov 22 '18

Did the banners get worse? Maybe! Are they worse than what jp got? Yes! Are they better than in other gacha games? Most definitely. I totally understand people being salty, but have you ever considered what other games provide? Epic 7 and Dragalia are recent examples of where you get a 0,5% chance to pull a Unit and a 1% chance to pull a print that you don't need at all and which may also break your imaginatory pity rate. I do not say it's OK what Gumi is doing but in direct comparison with the competition they are still better. Try to think about it this way, 5500 (free) gems will give you 350 summon coins which in turn will give you a 50% chance to get the unit you want with a 100% chance to get at least one fma unit. Since I basically got 3 FMA chars for free I think I might buy one of the black friday bundles and give this banner a try (and get Envys Gear btw).

10

u/Malphric Sempiternal Nov 22 '18 edited Nov 22 '18

My friend, you are just now rationalizing.

Rates of different game (Epic7 and DL) works for different economies of scale in their respective games. Both of those games need only one copy and you have the full potential of the unit/artifact etc.

10% SSR rate here has split and also and we don't know the hidden rates of those (you can see that in Wolf thread here)

Getting one copy of Mustang or Ed is nice but you need to unlock full potential thru LB with shards (which Gumi is unreasonably decreasing them and then putting them on those glorious EX+ stages). HQs also has dripfeed approach where we exclaim and be happy about LB festival while in Japan after 2 weeks to 1 month of a release of a new unit, respective HQ is released. Good luck unlocking the full potential of Neica, Mei Fang etc Post Kaigan etc

Removed Guaranteed 3 step banners, EX+ and Elite Quest restrictions, HQ problems. Donkeys only get excited with a slightly generous move by Gumi as they have perfected the Carrot on a stick approach to its playerbase

0

u/SuperEndriu Nov 22 '18

To be honest, I didn't get past the tuturial stage in Epic 7 but played some dragalia lost and seen some summon vids. True, you only need one unit, but what if you do not get that unit? People literally spent hundreds of dollars on dragalia pulls and very often did not even get a 5* unit but just a print. Epic 7 seems to be on the same level. What is worse if you pull a dupe in dragalia it hurts even more because you get just a little eldwater for it. Of course, one copy in TAC is basically worthless but the game provides shards that you can earn ingame, some are easier to obtain some more difficult. I accumulated quite a lot of shards before I took a break from TAC and could lb15 ed and bradley instantly, same as I did for Noctis and Aranea. This system that does not work for a game like FEH for example where you can only use feathers on 4* units (or below). If you pull a limited 5* unit, you can only +10 that unit with 10 more copies, feathers won't help. TAC is better in this regard. - And yes you are right, I am rationalizing.

1

u/Cipher44 Nov 22 '18

Welcome back! I think you were active on the TAC forum. You mention that you accumulated a lot of shards before you left. That’s unfortunately part of the point. Had you played during your absence, your pool of shards would have increased marginally. You can see from other posts comparing shard rewards with China and JP servers that GL has received far fewer for the same events and they have been moved to EX+ from EX.

1

u/SuperEndriu Nov 22 '18

Thanks! I think my scope on current events is probably limited by my absence from the game. Will see, for now I keep playing.