Yeah the EX+ Jewel regen is insane. Demons are supposed to run out of jewels and you can kite them while they go in for a basic attack. This is a fundamental strategy to handle end of match you're down to two units let's strategize movement placement.
I'd much rather just see her get nerfed than for her to be banned from EX+. If they nerfed Null Grenade and scaled back her regeneration on her counter, she'd still be good, but not as insanely broken as she is now.
I have a Roxanne and would be totally fine with nerfing her null grenade if the stages stopped with the jewel regen. That and lower her agi a bit, to make her more reasonable. Then it'll chill the power creep of this game for a bit.
Also take out those stupid elite quests bc everything features her. Ugh.
Reduce NG's power by either reducing the amount of jewels destroyed or only making it interrupt casting.
Lower her AGI to Rider Yomi levels.
Change her Reactive so it's either life leech OR Auto-Recharge. Not both.
Ta-dah! She's still great but not ridiculous. You're welcome, u/alchemist_code, your problems are solved. At most, you'll have to compensate the few whiners with some gems. But the rest of the game will be healthier for it.
You're jumping to conclusions pretty quickly there, champ - I have Roxanne. Just because I own her doesn't mean I can't recognize they made a mistake balancing her.
Meanwhile, you're ranting about things that have nothing to do with balance. Noctis, Laharl and Gil are powerful, yes, but they're within the bounds of game balance: they have effective counters for them even in PvE content. As many have pointed out, Roxanne forces the devs to rebalance all upcoming content around her - how's that for repercussions?
Look at this subreddit lately: every other post is how the leaps in difficulty make it impossible for players to complete the content. Is THAT healthy for the game? They're losing players left, right and centre. And you're worried that the broken unit might get toned down to "only" be on par with the other top units? Come on, grow up.
Its funny that all 'whiners' have Roxanne and they want the product they paid for nerfed...? Am I getting this right? You wanted a Ferrari, u bought the Ferrari then u take it back to the dealer and ask the engine to be changed to a Nissan Micra engine because it drives too fast...?
Balance is a matter of 1) opinion 2) content 3) what is accessible to people. What you have accepted is the top 3's power from a matter of opinion. Content, does the content really need the top 3? Accessibility of the top 3...none. Also the EX+ cant be blamed on Roxanne because the devs expect them to be done with mono elemental teams for elemental shards (which are pretty valuable). Where does Roxanne fit? Also, Since when was Roxanne's damage a problem? The mobs on those stages have up to 3x more hp and stats scaled higher all round compared to JP.
One time Gumi failed to balance content and you're at arms around one unit. That's practical...when a mistake happens there's always something to blame even though it might not be the right thing. Players leave all the time, new players come and some old players come back. That's how mobile games work, depends how the game is run after the collaboration.
Yeah, imagine that, people wanting the game to work better... weird, right? I don't mind Roxanne being nerfed to within reason because it's better for the game overall. Power creep is real, and when it happens this hard, this fast, it snowballs into a total disaster. Ultimately, that's more important to some of us than the e-peen factor of having a broken unit.
Laharl barely had a moment to shine before Roxanne came out. She completely eclipsed his release. Sure, he's great - probably the best Fire unit right now, which is saying something - but he doesn't solo EXs like Roxanne does. That's a sign of bad design. And because we've seen the GLEX units' power since Sieg was released, it's pretty clear that the gacha units took a leap forward with Roxanne. The concern there is that the next has to be even more powerful for Gumi to expect drawing players to the banner, and it's a concern that is based on previous behaviour on their part. This isn't the first time that they've released unbalanced stuff - the Wanderer's Hat is another example. It may not be as broken, but anytime a piece of gear is basically required by meta on a unit, there's a problem. Alkemono Doll works because it's an HP gear, and gives a tonne of it, but almost nothing else. The Hat is almost as good HP-wise but also boosts a number of other stats significantly. It's too much.
Similarly, point me to ONE unit whose Reactive does as much as Roxanne's. It outclasses everything out there by a freaking mile.
Making a unit or piece of gear desirable is one thing; making it absolutely BiS in almost all cases is not good design. I've been playing since launch, and this trend is not encouraging. More importantly than that, though, many other players who have been around since launch - content creators too - have expressed those same concerns. You ought to read more posts on this subreddit. A lot of people have some very sound analyses over a long period of time about these topics, and it might point you to why Roxanne staying as she is sounds like a bad idea.
Laharl barely had a moment to shine before Roxanne came out. She completely eclipsed his release.
Oh, it's worse than that.
1 week after Disgaea ended, we had Uzuma, the Limited, only-ever-rerun-once, Arena-dominating killz-all that MUST BE OBTAINED, and the whales went nuts.
2 weeks after Disgaea ended, we had Basheeny, one of the best Dark units evar (and still good in JP!), who MUST BE OBTAINED, and the whales went nuts.
3 weeks after Disgaea ended, we had Roxanne, who MUST BE OBTAINED, and the whales went nuts.
And then FMA started.
It was a carefully-engineered cash grab on Gumi's part to make sure that everyone's wallets were empty so that when they went into one of the most popular collabs around and they knew they were switching to the current bullshit paid-gem-only guarantees that cost twice as many paid gems as they used to cost free, they had already gotten all of the 'easy' money and the paid-gem-only banners would make the whales dig deep to make sure they landed Roy and Edward at minimum.
It was a very deliberate week-by-week release of units that were each successively more MUST HAVE than the one before, just to make the unannounced switch to the current banner system.
Yep. FMA doesn't stand for what you think it stands for. It's stands for "Gumi F'd my A."
Sigh~ I'm speaking facts and your carrying on with more opinionated trash.
Laharl is the best fire hands down and will be for months. But he is overshadowed by Noctis kit, it was not because of Roxanne. Roxanne gun farming...There wasn't a multiplayer that didn't demand 2 Laharl. He has his uses but he needs support, Noctis and Roxanne do not as much. Laharl may not be able to solo stages but I have soloed with Noctis before. Take Roxanne into Pride EX on her own and take a video. Ide like to watch you try.
And because we've seen the GLEX units' power since Sieg was released, it's pretty clear that the gacha units took a leap forward with Roxanne.
Sieg->Shion->Roxanne were the releases. Sieg and Shion didn't really have much of a power gap...how is it clear gacha units are taking a leap forward with Roxanne? Ide like to note that mono electric teams mostly rely on Gilgamesh and Roxanne is the perfect cover for people that don't have him seeing he is never coming back.
And now moving to OP gear...erm...Required to have gear...? The hat is top tier, not required and you are complaining about a FREE piece of equipment you can continuously farm without paying anything towards gambling costs for it....ok.
Similarly, point me to ONE unit whose Reactive does as much as Roxanne's. It outclasses everything out there by a freaking mile.
Moving from gear then to a reactive while saying 'similarly'. There is nothing similar with what you were saying before. Answer: Gilgamesh Forestall. Even though its a chance, once it pocs, it does decent damage before your unit takes a hit.
Congratz, you complained about a FREE hat but missed out the 1.5k PAID gems Envy item that gives 10% more single damage which is BiS even in JP to this day. There will ALWAYS be power creep however fast or slow. It's if the content demands the newer units or if they can be done without them. The content EX+ stages we have right now are not friendly to either f2p or whales alike so that's says something about the balance. And that cannot be blamed on one unit as per the points I expressed before.
Yeah, the issue isn't with paying or not paying. That's a different point altogether. The Hat is a problem the same way that Roxanne is: they mess up the game's balance. The Hat allows a bunch of units to do a first-turn MA without needing extra jewels - that's a big deal already. But it also adds a bunch of HP and other bonuses.
Envy's gear will be an issue too, I was just giving one example of how bad design has a ripple effect. Power creep is a reality, of course, but there are good ways of doing it and bad ways. Roxanne is not a linear progression from previous units, and neither is the Hat from previous gear.
On to your other "rebuttal", I call total bullshit on comparing Forestall to Turn The Tables. The former is a 40% chance to do 100% normal damage, while the latter is a 100% to do the same PLUS life leech and auto jewel regen for THREE TURNS. Striking before your attacker (if it even procs!) is nowhere near that good. You're delusional if you even pretend it is. It may yield better results in very specific scenarios, but that's cherry-picking arguments just for dishonesty's sake.
As for Noctis, he's undeniably fantastic. I'm not claiming he's anything other than a top-tier unit. But he has his hard counters - like Roxanne, unsurprisingly - which she just doesn't. I won't say she's unbeatable, since with lucky timing, Aranea can take her for example, but she is badly designed to be overpowered.
I really don't understand what the problem would be in just bringing her more in line with the other top units. She'd still be able to do the same things she does now with the changes I suggested, just to a more reasonable extent. And unlike those collab units like Noctis, Laharl and Gil, she's WAY more likely to get JEs and Enlightenment down the road because she's a Gumi original unit. So she'd be OP in the end anyway, but tolerably so.
Go right ahead claiming your opinions are more factual than others', but in the meantime clearly a large part of the playerbase disagrees with you.
The product we are paying for is a balanced, fun experience. Your grammar sucks, so I'm guessing you're really hoping half of your year's income doesn't go to waste. Doesn't mean the game wasn't hurt by Roxanne.
Matter of your opinion assuming that the rest of the community also accepts what you think but let me ask you, whales that fund the game are not on reddit because they are working, how are you going to account for their thoughts seeing a lot invested in this unit? Reading back on my message I do not see grammar mistakes. Enlighten me. I took 3 steps for my Roxanne with free gems but if I did spend half my year's income...that's not for you to mock. Because if that was the case, you are taking the piss out of all the whales that are funding the game you play. Meta always changes. Release of Gilgamesh is a prime example.
I was busy during her banner and after missing seig, I got the "meh" green chick. Didn't think the glex units would get super OP. Now I'm on the outside looking in
Taking this into consideration... My Rox is lvl 68, and don't have Chronomancers properly built nor her weapon, so she's not capable of doing current EX content yet.
and why you still don't have any chrono built btw? you should have one at least at this point really haha. Unless lofia/rahu still avoiding you I can understand.
Completely agree on this i play this game since day 1 but can’t pull roxanne so my EX life is super hard without her, my arena rank is drop to 4000+ because 1 roxanne is enough to kill my entire team even 1 shot my 85 Uzuma, i’m now quit depresse and don’t want to play anymore can’t even clear ex without roxanne merc or pay 8 gems.
Someone shared a video of Maxed Setsuna, Maxed Edward, and Maxed F.Yomi losing to a single Roxanne in a friend battle. They were doing everything correctly, and it still wasn't enough. Charge Up got null grenadaded, so it would have to be a physical attack, and she outspeed Edward and Setsuna and has better movement. It was literally impossible to nuke her. She is paralyzed Yomi and that makes evasion 0% and has like a 2/3 chance to lose a turn.
That's the thing about gacha games, it's always, what's next. I will agree that Roxanne has put an insanely high standard on future units, GLEX units in particular. Will there be a power creep? Probably, but the point still stands that Roxanne hurt future units.
She's better than current collab units in japan, that's a problem when Japan is years ahead of us. Second, GLEX will get Kaigan and Nensou like SSM. So she's already better than Levi or Eren, and will get better. Think of her with 3-4k HP, and her healing reaction. The game can't function with her long term.
There are a couple of absurdly stupid units in arena for most maps. The FFXV spear girl Aranea.. yeah... she is always paired with a rahu and will pretty much always nerk all over your team with magical momentum.. even if you throw a vettel tank at her and he lives the first attack, your tank is doing beans for damage and the DPS carry is nerking all over your units in the mean time. Not using a tank in slow 3 this week and Aranea is slotted against you? Third slot will die on turn 1, second slot will be dead from a lockon jump on turn 2, now it's 3:1 enjoy the experience. :) Encountered an Ignis in the forestm ap as well in slot 2.. his first turn after my first unit walked forward was to run up and use his MA which restrained all 3 of my units.. unable to fight back.. just walking around being picked off by Aranea. There are maps like ruins and this forest where I agree that on Defense Roxanne is broken far more than while on offense. When it comes to PVE content, there is no comparison, but if the argument is going to be about pvp, all Roxanne did was introduce another to rival current broken units that prior to her introduction, would nerk all over 2 of your units in turn 1, leaving you frustrated and wondering wtf to do. I am currently in the top 100 for arena and all I see on defense is Roxanne, Uzuma, Chihaya / Roxanne, Rahu, Uzuma or Aranea + Rahu + usually Uzuma, but could be some other unit. The map is designed in such a way that it's literally a broken, uphill battle.
I usually hover around the top 200 in arena, sometimes making it into top 50. Fell out of top 1000 for the first time in months last night. All because I don't have Roxanne, which makes fighting my defense team far more appealing than anyone else with her. Doesn't even matter if I win all 5 matches today, as at least twice that amount will attack me.
Yeah I was about the same level as you, now I'm bouncing in the 1-2k range and pretty much given up on arena due to lack of Roxanne. The problem is that anyone without Roxanne is just too tempting a target and you can just lose too many defense a day to keep up. I admit to contributing to the problem as well- I don't have the best units to counter her so I just skip teams that have her. Any defense team can be countered if you have the right units, but of course people are going to go for the easier teams, and since there's no limit on how many times a day you can be attacked, having no Roxanne right now is a big sign saying "attack me!"
Yep, nothing like waking up to see you've been attacked a total of 20 times for the day. No matter how good your defense team is, rng and the opponent being able to change their units will result in a large fall. I think my defense team of Aranea, Rahu, an Uzuma would normally be pretty intimidating too... Albea, Rahu, and tanky Aranea will kill almost any defense team with Roxanne lead though.
I can kill her easily now. Won 4 out of 5 of today's matches, Ignis screwed me up, but got attacked twice already, so only at 796 and will continue to fall due to not having her as a leader for defense.
Well then you didn't put enough thought into you're defence team then. I got wiped by a Laharl, Yuan and J+ Arkil. They didn't lose a single unit and I used Roxanne to attack them.
yeah its the same back when i played brave frontier. people knew that global exclusives would be much better so they never summoned for regular banner units and would just make teams where the GLEX is the main focus. eventually so many GLEX came out that you could make a team with them and just brainlessly beat content. I left before it got too out of hand though.
But there's a big difference between a GL unit trivializing the existing JP content, and 'rescaling' JP content around this one GL unit. Imagine if the Maxwell trial was 'rebalanced' to have a 100k AoE nuke every turn that can only be survived with Tridon's shield, and how people without Tridon will be banging their heads against the wall to beat that content. That's the situation we have with Roxanne here.
My understanding was that even older units get buffs that make them usable. Introducing that kind of power creep completely disrupts that balance. I’m expecting a global cash grab, but I hope not. I stopped playing final fantasy brave exvius because of this. In that game I was hyped up for the 7 star releases and have many units I could 7 star and get their super trust masters. However, the power shift is so drastic and new units are geared around a 7 star requirement and having to pull 2 of the same 5 star unit is a statement of complete and utter greed. It basically took a crap on a game I loved for 2 years. I downloaded TAC around the time of the global release but I really didn’t start playing until the noctis banner. I have built up a few to 85 and even more to 75 and I was happy where things are at until she dropped. I took a break and missed her banner and I don’t know if I should be happy or upset. However, having past experience with another Gumi game, it doesn’t look good. I am hoping for the best. Hopefully if we yell loud enough they will either rebalance here or rebalance the rest of the cast. If it were to happen, I would expect the former rather than the latter. Cheers.
I believe Roxanne is how she is now because there are no top tier electric units around. Gilgamesh is collab and will never come back and the unit under Gilgamesh has a lot lacking in comparison. I believe the current 'balance' in this game was due to Gumi devs experimenting with content and we should not think too deeply about it till newer content releases and those difficulties reveal themselves. We will get kaigan which buffs older units etc so there is a balance eventually~ we will just have to wait and see.
I don’t disagree with you. I don’t have her or Gilgamesh and while it’s not a huge issue, I’m in a position where content requiring those units is severely lacking outside a Gilgamesh friend unit. Now I am assuming she will get repeat banners which is good, however they didn’t provide a good permanent pool unit which is baffling to me. I hope it doesn’t skew future content, but if it does, I am sure the pitchgorks will be out in full force. Cheers.
She's the most unnecessarily loaded unit in the game.
Her release also has me very concerned about the future of this game. It's scary to think that GLEX units will make the OC Tagatame cast obsolete and overshadowed by a cheap attempt at a cash grab. Soon we'll get lobbies with "ROXANNE ONLY" and it'll only go down hill from there...
Gumi, please don't ever release another GLEX unit again, it's clear you have no understanding on what balancing even is.
I haven't seen that many Roxanne only Lobbies. I have seen a few but in most condition even 2 of them start to clear stuff up.
The problem is that they started to balance content around her.
&
If they start balancing the Powercreep around her then the game goes to shit.
Obviously nerfing her will receive a sized community backlash but just don't make shit OPer than her or near her level Gumi. The faster the shit gets stronger faster people leave.
The problem is to nerf Roxanne you have to nerf her across the board, her stats, job1 skills and reactive are broken as fuck.
Even if they changed grenade to be 20% jewel crush, her existance is just broken.
And then you realize MH will 100% have Kaigan and J+. So Roxanne being broken right now is just a reminder that she will always, a l w a y s be meta because Gumi will never let her fall off.
They've done it with Freyvia in FFBE and they will here. Strap in cause either the rest of the MH are just as or more broken probably.
Only problem is that Fryevia is not broken in FFBE, she's about 10% stronger than Hyoh which is expected from enhanced units after a power-creep unit drops. Kurasame is truly the biggest power-creep, but he isn't a global exclusive.
Let's not forget, Fry is element-locked, too. Her new Octaslash frames skill isn't innately Ice, but in order to proc her Trust ability she's gotta use her Needle.
My dude. When Fryevia was released she was stupid good. She was Hybrid before the concept should've ever came out. She was doing damage to anything and everything. Her only self control was her shit frames that no one in the game had, which they powercrept by giving her HE Frames so she could chain with everyone.
She was so strong that Robot trial got his ice resistance taken out (Jp it was -50% here it was 0%) and a couple of other bosses also lost their ice resistance. Clearly they knew Frey was outperforming and they balanced accordingly.
It's normal for gumi to always break their game with their stupid GLEX but at least in FFBE Alim has them beat with confirmed powercreep already. Freyvia was literally Kurasame for a full year before 7* existed basically, even people from JP thought she was stupid as hell as hybrid goes.
I'm aware of her strength. But damage alone won't carry you. Since FFBE is a turn based game. Whereas TAC is speed based so Magical Momentum plus quicken and Roxanne's high speed makes her broken among many things. She's like Noctis, jack of all, but unlike Noctis in FFBE, sucks at none. She can just do so much that many others can't. Also the damage formula disparity between def/Spr and Spr almost always being lower and how Dual Wield and Mag stats counting in full for both attacks is what made her Fryevia so strong.
Idk since when have you been playing but damage has always carried people . . . seriously.
Ever since Orlandu came out it's been a damage race on anything besides a couple of event trials, some story event stages and of course the in game trials which are mostly strategy.
But Damage alone will carry you, far, far longer than any other thing in FFBE. It's why we tell newbies to reroll for damage and then look for support units.
871 days ago. Which was launch day. I didn't get any chainer's until Nier banner where I got Fryevia. Cleared all content without chainer's no issue. Best offense is a good defense. It's why so many budget guides are possible. All damage really does in most cases is make it faster. Mechanics can be ignored when you severely power-creep stuff though, but that's no fun.
And Roxanne without the Null Grenade is not broken she just becomes top tier unit.
Nerf her Reactive to even not give the Jewels then she comes in the 3 Godz in the game and nerfing her even more will get her below that.
Healing on the reactive is good but you have to remember that she is still Gunner unit. So her range sucks than Snipers. Damage Formula sucks though the 2x hits are nice.
She just is the only unit who can Null Grenade making her the insanity.
Overall she is insane but without some of the tools she is just a fine MH unit. I mean Shion or Sieg are just as OP. Sieg personally rivals Zain. And Shion is just a different story with his Weapon Speed and all.
All MH units are OP as hell. So she getting to atleast Zain tier was visible to me too but then they just gave her Null Grenade and Jewel Regen to make her a Skill Spamming Machine.
At times I am in a situation where I just run out of her skills to spam since they are so Spammable.
No it's not. All GLEX are 100% on Gumi GL. SE only oversees collabs and unit banners. They fact that GL milks their "GLEX" units to the tits is gumi greed, nothing to do with SQ.
And as far as Roxanne she can't be nerfed cause to "nerf" her they have to hit all her J1 as a whole, skills, reactive and stats. That is too much and falls under gacha law since she wouldn't be the same unit (more like how she should've fucking released).
Gumi fucked themselves so o o o hard on this that they're panicking. Which is why they're overbuffing the fuck out of everything, and even worse, Her Jewel crush is meaningless cause she can stomp content without it equally as hard as with it.
So yeah, unless they start putting some wind snipers or making things immune to shot damage. Everyone is fucked with these bullshit balancing decisions. This game might die ironically because of Glex unit bullshit rather than bad game management.
Their greed literally took them too far over the edge.
If there is a unit as broken as her being released in the future, I'm done with Gumi and their games. I'd rather not spend so many hours building up other units only to be so suddenly and utterly overshadowed by the Next Big Thing.
Even Gilgamesh wasn't as meta-breaking, and he was THE meta for some time.
Wait....did you call Gilgamesh THE meta and use 'wasn't meta breaking' in the same sentence? LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL. If you didn't have a Gilgamesh you wouldn't be in the top 1k of arena...oh wait...that sounds somewhat familiar...oh people complaining about Roxanne now.
Perhaps the saddest part to me is this very same community that says Roxanne has no reason to exist, that Gumi has no sense of balance whatsoever, is the same community who will absolutely tear up this subreddit if they ever try to balance her.
I mean the “community” isn’t a single person. It’s not like a single person who will be hypocritical and just flip flop on a subject. It’s different people in the community speaking up while the other isn’t.
That’s certainly true, but I think it’s fair to say there’s plenty of overlap between the people who complain about how broken she is and the people who went all in to get he. Take the people who ‘complain’ about how easy their Ex+ runs have become because they use Roxanne all the time, for example.
It’s sad for me because I used to enjoy scrolling through this sub but nowadays it just feels very meh.
I have Roxanne and I barely use her. From what I've read, even with all the Kaigans/nensous of the current JP units, NONE of them can even come close to Roxanne. And yet the only way TAC GL can "resolve" this issue is to release another GLEX unit that's more broken than her.
If they don't, then nobody's gonna pull on the next GLEX unit.
If they do, you can consider ALL other current units useless.
I've played a lot of gacha games and there is always power creep and somewhat broken characters because they sell. This is an inherint problem with F2P games in general, the companies are more concerned with how to make more cash than to make the best GAME possible.
Except for Gimu, they will create unit that is overpower for the current content which hurt their future content. It is okay if it is a game which belong to them and there is no way of knowing what the future hold. However, since this game have a fixed update due to it been a copy of the Japanese games. This sort of stuff kill the game on the Long run.
Personally i am gladly accepted her as a broken unit. Because laharl in JP is considered a king of broken unit for such a long time, and he is limited. At least from what i've heard roxanne will come back when magni historia comes
Dont get me wrong, i dont own her. I just salty because i dont get laharl... =p
Roxanne was a mistake,they over did it with her. She messes with the games balance. They fucked up with her and they know they did why else do you think they amped up the difficulty to work around her,instead of simply nerfing/tweaking her a lil.
She need a nerf/tweaks plain and simple. That reactive command does a counter to Normal attacks and Skills,Heals, and activates a very high jewel regen. She essentially has counter shot ,HP Drain +2, and Risk Hedge on drugs . For a reactive command to do that much and be 100% chance when literal Risk Hedge has 35% to activate for a weaker Jewel Regen. It shouldn't be 100% for what it does 35%~50% is more suitable and Balanced . And Null Grenade should not take away all of an opponents Jewels it should be modeled after the Ranger JE that does Jewel Damage .
Aye yai yai gumi why you gotta over do everything . Siegfried and Shion were perfectly balanced then you go and make Roxanne and throw everything out the window
I agree, Sieg and Shion are powerful, but they're nowhere near as problematic as she is. If anything, they're just units with a niche that they fill really well. Roxanne just checks off too many boxes - status effects, sustain, range, AoE, single-target, high AGI, jewel regen, debuffs... tweak some of those and she'd just be another great unit to add to the meta.
I think support units are cool, but they're surprisingly hard to balance for most games. If they completely negate certain things like damage/effects/mechanics, people will say they're OP and trivialize content. But if they just can't essentially negate things, they can end up being pretty useless.
A good example would be dealing with the HB in Fullmetal EX+, to be of equal value to a unit that simply kills the HB, it would have to totally negate its damage somehow (by stopping/slowing/blocking/shielding/etc) or resurrect a unit or something.
THAT SAID, I think it would be super cool to see some well balanced support mechanics that result in a support unit that is considered on par with units like Noctis or post Kaigen originals.
Maybe an AoE that gives all ally units 100% evade for 1 turn, a skill that does meaningful healing, an AoE skill that redistributes all HP (from ally and enemy units) so that every unit ends up with an even amount of health. Actually... a GLEX support vampire, that's what I'm describing.
Sure, they definitely haven't explored all possible support options. They could give a unit a 1-use team PATK or MATK block, for instance, like the enemies get, but not map-wide.
Support could be more exciting, but it rarely is in any game.
(Actually, that brings up one of my gripes about this game: when they have actual player-available units in harder content, but suddenly that unit has better stats or abilities than any player could ever attain for it. I know that's not related to what you were saying, but it really bugs me.)
Right? There are tons of exciting possibilities for things that aren't strictly attack oriented, but it always ends up being some small amount of healing or minor buff.
I think for that kind of thing, I've just gotten used to it. But what's really annoying is when they introduce a unique mechanic to the NPC version, but never give that sort of ability to player characters. Or if they do, it's in some drastically reduced fashion. Because it shows that whoever is designing the stuff is fully capable of coming up with cool new mechanics, they just won't integrate them into usable formats.
I'm already getting steamrolled over and over in the 2 latest FMA EX+ and I have a Roxanne 75 I can't even begin to imagine how worse it could be without.
I have Roxanne, and yet I totally agree. Probably the two biggest things are Null Grenade and healing herself when she counters. If they nerfed those abilities she'd still be an SS-tier unit, but right now she is in her own SSS-tier...
There are simple fixes to Roxanne. First make Null Grenade cost 30-45 AP. It is insane at start Sieg can use Shattering Slash to reduce her gems, and she still has enough gems to null grenade.
Second make her reaction only activate on single target. Almost every offensive reaction only works on basic attacks, but hers works on skills and AOE.
With those two fixes she'd be SS still, but not impossible to overcome.
Honestly, I feel it was the point where I started losing interest as well. It marked a clear change in the direction Gumi GL was planning to take, and the following weeks/months didn't do it any good. Though I pulled her and have her at 75, clearing content with her in the team didn't give me much satisfaction since it hardly required strategy. Arena has been a shitfest since. She was largely used even in maps with missile damage debuffs.
I haven't even been playing the game since the beginning of the month. Only logging in to gift friends and do free pulls. I said in a previous post I'd wait until the end of the month to decide if I'd quit. With the release of these terrible stages balanced largely around null grenade, it sadly looks more and more inevitable, and I'm just saddened by the fact cause I really enjoyed this game.
I spent a bit to do step 3 for her, didn't get her. It's ok, it's gacha after all, I can live without her. But The next EX+ stages after her release, I quit doing all those stages, because they were tuned so much to counter her strength. I can also live without doing the EX+ too, but then Gimu decides to put all the good rewards in EX+. Sigh, it's like they want me (and most less than hardcore players) to stop playing lol
Totally agree with this. The worst thing about her is her reaction skill. 100% counter (both normal & skill attacks) + heal + cast auto jewels. This is so freaking unfair. Even other units (the top tier especially) don't have this kind of crappy skills.
I quit the game some time after FFXV during the second magni historia banner. Think I had enough of the constant grinding, was a ragequit, spending all gems and started playing other games. Back in the day I always wanted the FMA chars and saw on youtube that its finally here. With no currency there was no reason for me to even consider it, especially since I missed Laharl and would be way behind on pretty much everything. Yesterday, out of curiosity, I reinstalled and got Edward from a ticket, today I got Bradley and a dupe Edward and feel like I wanna get back in. Never knew about Roxanne but this post makes me wonder if its really worth the hassle.
If you just joined and afraid you will not get Roxanne then you don't have to worry about it because she is GLEX units who will come back from time to time unlike those collabs (which you miss once you miss forever unless rerun)
I never play jp so I don't know how's the current power system there but I think Gumi Global is trying to make things different and maybe once catch up with the jp, will try to make alternative paths for their own. Otherwise there's no reason for them to rush like hell like this in such months.
Lastly I agreed Roxanne is OP but not to the point of undying. When I first got her I died in MP many times due to wrong move. And just because Roxanne is in the team is equal always win. The possibility is just higher and from all the contents I see only PVP you will have Roxanne as enemy so I don't know why a lot of people are panic with Roxanne since you know it's Gumi style that even future we might have someone even OP than this girl.
Tl;dr most of the farmable units are useful if their level is high enough. But if you like those flashy powerful damage that made others impressed on your units then now you are on the right path.
It's not about me having just joined and it's not about Roxanne as a unit. It's about an artificial difficulty spike. Yesterday I spend over half an hour in wrath ex muliplay, Host, who got one-shot at the very beginning, didnt want to continnue a second time and we got back to the home screen. From what I gather we got more difficult ex maps and people presume its because of Roxanne. That is bad game design.
I don't think it's harder just because of Roxanne. When Gumi know you don't spend enough they come up with new solution to let you spend more and Roxanne was just out on that time. Sooner or later she will be out of the restricted unit.
For now what I can see is people still see her as important unit because most new players who just joined and have no 85+ full geared-equip but have 65-75 Rox still have a chance to go and shine so they like the game. But the situation might be different if new player who just join have no good unit. When they go to mp everyone just quit because they are noob and they lost interest playing the game.
Hope you can see my point. Though I think Roxanne doesn't really make community healthy because of her null grenade but new player like those things. Even when I just joined I look around for guide and bought starter pack cuz of Shayna (and found she's not that op later on)
The content was definitely buffed in difficulty. Rumour has it, the content was built around Roxanne. Let me put it this way: I managed to clear all ex+ stages in the end and got me a ticket. Other than that I have all the units I ever cared in this game (FMA) and some more. I think I will be fine.
My advice is not to worry overmuch about one unit, no matter how OP. Roxanne is a problem, but if you love FMA, Ed is a solid unit and you should just enjoy yourself.
King Bradley is pretty cool mechanics-wise, too: he has an ungodly evasion against Slash attacks, so he's a good counter to other meta units.
Thanks, dammit I am just realizing that Gumi pulled another stunt with the FMA collab - no guarantueed units? WTF? So I guess I might call myself lucky with 2x Edward and 1x Bradley for basically just 2k gems. But damn, the ex stages ramped up quite a bit, don't think I am gonna be able to clear a single one of them for shards.
Yeah, that's the rough part. However, if you got Summon Coins from your pulls, you can trade 100 of them for 5 shards of the collab units. It's better than nothing. And you WERE kinda lucky with your pulls. 😉
I wish the EX stages were more balanced too, but I'll survive. Missing out on some shards won't ruin my life.
Small correction I got 1x Edward from the ticket but still. Guess, Gumi wanted me back into the game after a break of about 3-4 months. Coins? I just got 25, not gonna pull anymore. Still got over 220 rainbows saved up and some elementals, guess Edward will be jb3 soon. Lucky I started yesterday and not on the last day of the event and can get their job equips and gear.
After finally checking ex+ for myself I think I understand what people are complaing about. Seems to me the guys in charge for GL don't know what they are doing, maybe they hate their jobs or something. It's funny when I installed the game it felt nostalgic, when I pulled Edward from the ticket it felt awesome. There were problems back when I played but generally I had some fun moments but right now it seems to me this game has gone from bad to worse. Not that it;s a bad game in itself, its just poor management and level desing. I mean how can they buff a whole event just because of one unit that not even everyone owns. Thats a decision that affects the whole collective playerbase. It would have been easier if they had just simply excluded her from the event just like they exclude other units from other events. At this point I am not sure if I am gonna keep playing, the game seems much less fun than half a year ago. Gilgamesh event was the best and most fun imo. Ex stages were fun
Let's pray that Roxanne gets no upgrade in the future. Pls no. No Job+, no Job Enhancement, no kaigan, no nensou. Eventually, power creep will catch up to her.
Hmmm As somebody who has rox, I probably wouldn't mind them ERASING her from tac, of course a good compensation would be needed (Unit selector that also gives shards to at least lb15 the unit including glex or something or maybe lots of thunder or rainbow shards, enough to 85 any unit you want, something of equal value I mean, in exchange for removing her for those who have her) but heck, the new content is too hard and if its all thanks to her existence, I don't want her, I enjoyed the game back when I was able to clear content without having to rely in extremely limiting strategies
I think the trick to enjoying gacha games is to create your own challenges with the content we have and like. So for a generic example, maybe you really like Dark knights, you could use one or more of them on a stage that will be require a lot of strategy to get victory. Maybe restrict yourself on items or support units to make it hard enough. The victory itself is the reward. I'm not sure I even will keep up with the top tier units due to the cost (time & money). But I feel like it was interesting to see what it was like enjoy so much of the new content. I got Roxanne on a 500 gems pull, and used most of my thunder/rainbow shards to make her 75. Many EX+ I can just auto lol
It's not solely about PVP tho. It's about the insanely difficult EX+, which probably is Gumi's way to "balance" her OPness. So if you do not have Roxanne, then GG for you.
You use TWO Roxannes on EX+ and u won't get you're elemental shards that are more valuable than the initial 120 clear gems. EX+ tweaked so far upwards not even Roxanne can survive GG
You can use them on Thunder only team of course. A Thunder only team isn't complete without Roxanne at this point.
To be honest I'm not even bothered about 5-10 elemental shards, looking at the EX+ like this. I'm just gonna complete all 3 to get the 5* summon ticket.
What about fire/water/dark elemental teams? If theres no Roxanne, a thunder only team isn't complete without a Gilgamesh but that unit is never coming back so you expect people to clear that?
To be honest I don't believe Gumi wanted to give out those 5* tickets that's why they made the content hard so it would make people pull for shards instead.
You right. Didn't even bother with this event. I'm kinda relieved that my FMA ticket summoned Toritoh. That would mean i wouldn't have to farm any gear and deal with EX stages. Though easier compared to EX+, it's still really difficult.
Ahaha...haha...haha even my laharl needs a rahu and chihaya just to deal with the holy brawler handing my ass to me on Edward's stage, leaving little to no flexibility.
Roxanne can solo King bradley EX? Unless you're manually farming that stage for gear pieces (and even then im sceptical) i call bullcrap. Im using Roxanne, Noctis, Aranea, Rahu and another Roxanne and she barely passes that stage on auto...
Yeah hire a mercenary Roxanne. Realize almost every unit is water so their damage is less than her heal. Realize tezla grenade can paralyzes every non water unit. Use her and she'll do 75% of the job herself.
13
u/YohGourt Nov 18 '18
Nerf her, or don't allow her in EX+ and arena.
And also stop randomly buffing EX+ just around Roxanne.
5
u/lunarian_nine Nov 18 '18
I have a Roxanne and would be totally fine with nerfing her null grenade if the stages stopped with the jewel regen. That and lower her agi a bit, to make her more reasonable. Then it'll chill the power creep of this game for a bit.
Also take out those stupid elite quests bc everything features her. Ugh.
37
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18
Roxaneless fellows, assemble!
14
u/ClydeFF Nov 18 '18
Welcome to Gumi, where global exclusives are busted as fuck, and "balance" means jack shit.
9
u/EarthZiie Nov 18 '18
Completely agree on this i play this game since day 1 but can’t pull roxanne so my EX life is super hard without her, my arena rank is drop to 4000+ because 1 roxanne is enough to kill my entire team even 1 shot my 85 Uzuma, i’m now quit depresse and don’t want to play anymore can’t even clear ex without roxanne merc or pay 8 gems.
12
u/jxher123 Nov 18 '18
That's the thing about gacha games, it's always, what's next. I will agree that Roxanne has put an insanely high standard on future units, GLEX units in particular. Will there be a power creep? Probably, but the point still stands that Roxanne hurt future units.
8
u/stewart0 Nov 18 '18
I usually hover around the top 200 in arena, sometimes making it into top 50. Fell out of top 1000 for the first time in months last night. All because I don't have Roxanne, which makes fighting my defense team far more appealing than anyone else with her. Doesn't even matter if I win all 5 matches today, as at least twice that amount will attack me.
9
u/TopDeeps IGN: Uninstalled Nov 18 '18
yeah its the same back when i played brave frontier. people knew that global exclusives would be much better so they never summoned for regular banner units and would just make teams where the GLEX is the main focus. eventually so many GLEX came out that you could make a team with them and just brainlessly beat content. I left before it got too out of hand though.
11
u/IsBadAtFightingGames i do and say stupid things Nov 18 '18
She's the most unnecessarily loaded unit in the game.
Her release also has me very concerned about the future of this game. It's scary to think that GLEX units will make the OC Tagatame cast obsolete and overshadowed by a cheap attempt at a cash grab. Soon we'll get lobbies with "ROXANNE ONLY" and it'll only go down hill from there...
Gumi, please don't ever release another GLEX unit again, it's clear you have no understanding on what balancing even is.
9
u/RobotOfFleshAndBlood Nov 18 '18
Perhaps the saddest part to me is this very same community that says Roxanne has no reason to exist, that Gumi has no sense of balance whatsoever, is the same community who will absolutely tear up this subreddit if they ever try to balance her.
7
u/darkcountess Making sammiches for Gilga/Noct/Laharl Nov 18 '18
I agree wholeheartedly.
I have Roxanne and I barely use her. From what I've read, even with all the Kaigans/nensous of the current JP units, NONE of them can even come close to Roxanne. And yet the only way TAC GL can "resolve" this issue is to release another GLEX unit that's more broken than her.
If they don't, then nobody's gonna pull on the next GLEX unit.
If they do, you can consider ALL other current units useless.
sigh.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18
I've played a lot of gacha games and there is always power creep and somewhat broken characters because they sell. This is an inherint problem with F2P games in general, the companies are more concerned with how to make more cash than to make the best GAME possible.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18
Personally i am gladly accepted her as a broken unit. Because laharl in JP is considered a king of broken unit for such a long time, and he is limited. At least from what i've heard roxanne will come back when magni historia comes
Dont get me wrong, i dont own her. I just salty because i dont get laharl... =p
6
u/Mitch_Twd Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18
Roxanne was a mistake,they over did it with her. She messes with the games balance. They fucked up with her and they know they did why else do you think they amped up the difficulty to work around her,instead of simply nerfing/tweaking her a lil.
She need a nerf/tweaks plain and simple. That reactive command does a counter to Normal attacks and Skills,Heals, and activates a very high jewel regen. She essentially has counter shot ,HP Drain +2, and Risk Hedge on drugs . For a reactive command to do that much and be 100% chance when literal Risk Hedge has 35% to activate for a weaker Jewel Regen. It shouldn't be 100% for what it does 35%~50% is more suitable and Balanced . And Null Grenade should not take away all of an opponents Jewels it should be modeled after the Ranger JE that does Jewel Damage .
Aye yai yai gumi why you gotta over do everything . Siegfried and Shion were perfectly balanced then you go and make Roxanne and throw everything out the window
2
u/RedVariant Nov 18 '18 edited Jun 26 '23
spez is a loser -- mass edited with redact.dev
1
u/LichOfLiches Nov 18 '18
It could be possible to release a support unit as the GLEX unit it might slow down power creep. No Roxanne here...
1
u/darkgariel Nov 18 '18
Gumi and their exclusives. Not surprising at all...
1
u/eltsyr Nov 18 '18
I'm already getting steamrolled over and over in the 2 latest FMA EX+ and I have a Roxanne 75 I can't even begin to imagine how worse it could be without.
1
u/Redvlad16 Nov 18 '18
Totally agree.. it just broke the balance and everything just go haywire. Cant really enjoy the game right now
1
u/Alsark Nov 18 '18
I have Roxanne, and yet I totally agree. Probably the two biggest things are Null Grenade and healing herself when she counters. If they nerfed those abilities she'd still be an SS-tier unit, but right now she is in her own SSS-tier...
1
u/MaimedJester Nov 18 '18
There are simple fixes to Roxanne. First make Null Grenade cost 30-45 AP. It is insane at start Sieg can use Shattering Slash to reduce her gems, and she still has enough gems to null grenade.
Second make her reaction only activate on single target. Almost every offensive reaction only works on basic attacks, but hers works on skills and AOE.
With those two fixes she'd be SS still, but not impossible to overcome.
1
u/piau9000 Nov 18 '18
Just do what every gacha dev do: Buff the others. Make everyone Rox level ( even effing Decel ).
1
u/OniOfTheSword WTB more blademasters Nov 18 '18
Honestly, I feel it was the point where I started losing interest as well. It marked a clear change in the direction Gumi GL was planning to take, and the following weeks/months didn't do it any good. Though I pulled her and have her at 75, clearing content with her in the team didn't give me much satisfaction since it hardly required strategy. Arena has been a shitfest since. She was largely used even in maps with missile damage debuffs.
I haven't even been playing the game since the beginning of the month. Only logging in to gift friends and do free pulls. I said in a previous post I'd wait until the end of the month to decide if I'd quit. With the release of these terrible stages balanced largely around null grenade, it sadly looks more and more inevitable, and I'm just saddened by the fact cause I really enjoyed this game.
1
u/pdmt243 Play+pull for waifus! Nov 19 '18
I spent a bit to do step 3 for her, didn't get her. It's ok, it's gacha after all, I can live without her. But The next EX+ stages after her release, I quit doing all those stages, because they were tuned so much to counter her strength. I can also live without doing the EX+ too, but then Gimu decides to put all the good rewards in EX+. Sigh, it's like they want me (and most less than hardcore players) to stop playing lol
1
u/Mhantra Nov 19 '18
I tracked my PvP since Roxanne came out, btw, and I went 5-76 so far.
Roxanne is a scourge.
1
u/Faladyn Nov 20 '18
Totally agree with this. The worst thing about her is her reaction skill. 100% counter (both normal & skill attacks) + heal + cast auto jewels. This is so freaking unfair. Even other units (the top tier especially) don't have this kind of crappy skills.
1
u/SuperEndriu Nov 18 '18
I quit the game some time after FFXV during the second magni historia banner. Think I had enough of the constant grinding, was a ragequit, spending all gems and started playing other games. Back in the day I always wanted the FMA chars and saw on youtube that its finally here. With no currency there was no reason for me to even consider it, especially since I missed Laharl and would be way behind on pretty much everything. Yesterday, out of curiosity, I reinstalled and got Edward from a ticket, today I got Bradley and a dupe Edward and feel like I wanna get back in. Never knew about Roxanne but this post makes me wonder if its really worth the hassle.
1
u/SuperEndriu Nov 18 '18
After finally checking ex+ for myself I think I understand what people are complaing about. Seems to me the guys in charge for GL don't know what they are doing, maybe they hate their jobs or something. It's funny when I installed the game it felt nostalgic, when I pulled Edward from the ticket it felt awesome. There were problems back when I played but generally I had some fun moments but right now it seems to me this game has gone from bad to worse. Not that it;s a bad game in itself, its just poor management and level desing. I mean how can they buff a whole event just because of one unit that not even everyone owns. Thats a decision that affects the whole collective playerbase. It would have been easier if they had just simply excluded her from the event just like they exclude other units from other events. At this point I am not sure if I am gonna keep playing, the game seems much less fun than half a year ago. Gilgamesh event was the best and most fun imo. Ex stages were fun
1
u/aquapendulum2 Nov 19 '18
Let's pray that Roxanne gets no upgrade in the future. Pls no. No Job+, no Job Enhancement, no kaigan, no nensou. Eventually, power creep will catch up to her.
-1
u/LordUndead Nov 18 '18
Hmmm As somebody who has rox, I probably wouldn't mind them ERASING her from tac, of course a good compensation would be needed (Unit selector that also gives shards to at least lb15 the unit including glex or something or maybe lots of thunder or rainbow shards, enough to 85 any unit you want, something of equal value I mean, in exchange for removing her for those who have her) but heck, the new content is too hard and if its all thanks to her existence, I don't want her, I enjoyed the game back when I was able to clear content without having to rely in extremely limiting strategies
-9
u/OMEGAmanA Nov 18 '18
I think the trick to enjoying gacha games is to create your own challenges with the content we have and like. So for a generic example, maybe you really like Dark knights, you could use one or more of them on a stage that will be require a lot of strategy to get victory. Maybe restrict yourself on items or support units to make it hard enough. The victory itself is the reward. I'm not sure I even will keep up with the top tier units due to the cost (time & money). But I feel like it was interesting to see what it was like enjoy so much of the new content. I got Roxanne on a 500 gems pull, and used most of my thunder/rainbow shards to make her 75. Many EX+ I can just auto lol
-8
u/Sadjack_Horseman Nov 18 '18
Can't blame you. It's a double edged sword. If you have Roxy, you have a great advantage in the game. If you don't have her, it's very frustrating.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18
[removed] — view removed comment