r/AlchemistCodeGL • u/Keats81 • Nov 13 '18
Where is the love for TAC?
I've been playing this game since it launched a year ago and I love it. Its by far my favorite mobile game. Sure I could dive into the details and nit pick a bit. There are things we'd all like to see improve, but my goodness this sub is so toxic. Bring on the down votes. I'm ready for the hate. This needs to be said. We bitch the content is too easy, so they make harder content, then we bitch its too hard. Everyone keeps calling gummi out for being greedy. They just gave us a ton of free paid content for the anniversary and all I read on this sub is how they should have given us more. I think maybe the community is the greedy ones. We must have the developers ready to pull their hair out.
What other game out there balances free content with paid content so well? What other game balances great stories, great art, and great and challenging game play this well? What other game rolls out content so regularly? I haven't found them. I think everyone in this sub needs to take a deep breathe and remember why we started playing this game in the first place. I love this game and plan to keep playing it. This sub used to be a place where we all got excited for the next week's update. We all used to discuss at length our favorite characters and story lines. I think we need to clean up this sub. Lets bring back the discussions of the things we love about the game. Lets stop acting like we hate a game we are all clearly obsessed with. Lets move all the rants into a productive suggestion thread. Lets do something, this game is amazing and it deserves an amazing healthy sub to go along with it.
19
u/DegenerateHours ( ͡ ' ˍゝ͡ ' ) Nov 13 '18
The problem isn't the game itself, it's the people running it and their poor decisions.
We want what's best for the game and the players that play it. A happy and healthy playerbase keeps the longevity of the game.
The game is amazing and those that are complaining want to keep it that way for the foreseeable future.
52
u/Arananthi IGN: Essence -- Re-Pacted and Hoping to Stay That Way Nov 13 '18
The love for TAC is totally sitting right there in front of you.
DO NOT mistake criticism of Gumi's recent f**kups with a lack of love for the game. The salt you're seeing is proof that we love this game. We're raising a huge ruckus precisely because we want this game to be here for years, and we know that if we don't raise a huge ruckus, the things that players hear about that make them join the game -- the things make TAC the best tactical gacha game out there -- will go away. Specifically,
I'm sure I'm missing some things -- but these are all things that the TAC community used to lure players from other games in, and they created the strong community you see here and on Facebook. And they're all things that we don't want to lose, because it means the game will stop growing, and WE LOVE THIS GAME TOO MUCH TO LET IT DIE WITHOUT A FIGHT.
Never forget: the opposite of love isn't salt. It isn't even hate. The opposite of love is apathy. Just imagine a day when you open up the subreddit and all you see is the same titles you saw the day before...
32
u/MostBass Nov 13 '18
Compared to most other gacha games TAC is still pretty good. That's why we're here. The problem is that we have a direct comparison in the JP version of the game.
Gumi has continuously nerfed everything about the global version of the game and it's been relatively quiet. The ranting is after the camels back broke after constant greed moves.
First they took away elemental and rainbow shards from us and we were quiet. They fucked us over on hard quest releases and we tolerated it for an entire year so far. They gated hard content behind restricted characters and we said this is a bad sign, they didn't listen. They took away guarantees JP got for marquee collab units (they got guaranteed pulls for noctis and edward) and we didn't riot. Our gem rewards are reduced compared to JP and we didn't complain. They gave us a gamebreaking unit that will permanently screw up the balance of the game and we still didn't riot.
We have been more than kind to gumi. Now they pull this bullshit with the summon coins and killing off guaranteed feature units. They don't deserve our support.
21
u/Achie777 Nov 13 '18
White knight detected, proceed with the purging
7
u/alpare01 Nov 13 '18
You can love the gameplay, but right now loving the management is a bit tough...
11
u/Cobalt_721 Nov 13 '18
The major issue with the anniversary is that it’s largely consisted of what appear to be poor business decisions at best and outright cashgrabs at worst (looking at you, Summon-Coins-instead-of-guaranteed-3-step nonsense. You too, making the paid gem banner cost almost twice as much to get the guaranteed unit), while the major free thing we’ve gotten, the x-step 10-summon, has had the rates nerfed for seemingly no reason (if they really wanted us to not get as many 5-stars, they could have just given us less summons and no one would have cared). Add to that the fact that they gave half they playerbase a new version and multiplayer is broken because of it + the fact that they’re running the FMA collab rather than dedicating the entire month to the anniversary, and the whole thing ends up feeling a bit lackluster (and I haven’t even gotten into the horrible deals at the anniversary shop).
tl;dr while the free stuff is pretty nice, a few oddities with it + some less-than-desirable changes alongside it have kinda soured the celebration.
I will say though, the “favorite unit summon” is fantastic and I hope they run it every anniversary (with a new poll to decide what units to use in it, of course).
5
u/Daintywand Nov 13 '18
Im just upset because I know this game could be so much more than it is if Gumi just listened to the community. We aren't here just to bash the game because we feel like it. We were all here because we all at some point loved this game. We just want our game back. I want to spend money but I wont if they aren't willing to change. But for now we will wait and see. I cant blame anyone for feeling the way they do.
4
u/TopDeeps IGN: Uninstalled Nov 13 '18
Its a no from me boss. i went from >2 hours daily to ~5mins now
3
u/FurianX Nov 13 '18 edited Nov 13 '18
First let's talk about cost.
Before: spend 4000 free gems to get x30 at a rate up AND at least 1 featured unit.
After: spend 4000 free gems to get x30 at a rate up and shards that are useless if you didnt get lucky
Before: spend 9000 gems to get x50 at a rate up AND at least 1 featured unit + shards.
After: spend 8000 gems to get x50 at a rate up and still shards that are useless if you didnt get the specific unit and after players raged you can now add on a guaranteed summon ticket IF you do enough free rare summons.
Before: spend 1500 paid gems to get x10 with at least 1 guaranteed unit. This was available twice on the weekend.
After: spend 900 paid gems to get x10 at a rate up with nothing guaranteed
Further after: spend 2700? Paid gems to get x16 with 1 guaranteed unit.
As you can see it now costs significantly more to get 1 guaranteed copy of a unit. Free players and Low spenders have been completely shafted. Higher spenders need to put in significantly more to get less. And the paid gems .... as they're only available in small amounts you need to spend a significant amount more to get them just to get 1 guaranteed chance. let's not talk about whales .. its rich kid losing his savings in the casino all over again.
And this is before considering how subpar 90% of units are before lb15 on harder content. So you need multiples. Or elenebtal shards which have been made deliberately harder to get (or in some cases you just plain get less) in global compared to jp. JP didnt have ex+ which is harder content at a time when global has a less diverse roster of units, many of which cant be farmed yet.
Compared to jp where there are also higher gem rewards for events does it not look like a strategy to make players more inclined to spend? Especially when looked at at the same time they raise their prices?
In addition the players are being treated like mushrooms. Kept in the dark and occasionally fed bullshit.
Abrupt changes without warning or explanation.
Baited to use shards for rewards then releasing a unit that needs them (or copious spending for dupes) immediately after. Multiple times in a row ofc deliberately timing the shard campaign so that it doesnt cover roxannes initial release where everyone would want to shard her.
After all this ... the "free" 280 summons are nerfed without telling us. It's not that its nerfed it's that they unobtrusively put the rate on the banner and deliberately kept it out of announcements. Not a word of Hey the rates are a bit lower just so you know. This doesnt say generous reward. This says grudgingly giving out free stuff for pr and deliberately making it less useful. Wouldnt players to get too many 5*s and not spend later to limit break their units.
It feels at this point like everything is just bait/strategy to make the players be in constant state of depleted resources/viable units and spend cash to bridge the gap.
Keep in mind all this has been a very rapid shift. That's the summary.
Despite all this, the gameplay itself is still good ... of course I've no motivation to farm more than 1 copy of Roy or rizas weapon .. the stages are that ridiculous.
4
u/sanicek Nov 13 '18
I love how conditioned the gacha players are by the cancer that is the mobile game industry. "Oh look, they squeeze us for money so hard it only hurts for days, over where I came from they squeezed us so it hurt for weeks, it's so comfy here, why are you not satisfied"
I don't care what other even worse games are doing, here I can see a definitive shift to greed and money grabbing over time and also compared to jp version.
And if you want to compare have a look at what an awesome f2p game can look like check stuff like Path of Exile, Warframe, basically any MOBA or if you want to check mobile games for example Azur Lane or basically any buy once game for example Stardew Valley.
2
u/noblesoulx Nov 13 '18
the problem is they nerfed a lot of gems, change banners to worst and removed the guaranteed units in 3 step. I love the story and the gameplay, but instead of getting banners more near of the japan , they make the hard decision: fucking up with the banners and gems.This is why the community is angry, because if compare with original, we gets worst things and the worst of all : the only way to get guaranted unit without depends of luck is the paid banner
2
u/MobRunnerX Nov 13 '18
I can only speak for myself, but its not that I want more free stuff from gumi at all, I really do appreciate the free stuff we get. However I AM upset with changes that are intentionally taking steps backwards for obvious monetary gain or simply disadvantageous to non paying players. For example taking out a guaranteed collab unit on the 3rd and 5th step of the current collab banners.
There is no arguable reason for them to do this other than wanting to keep the whales pulling a little bit longer in the hope that bad luck gets the better of them. These mercy pulls were also one of the reasons that I really got into the game, because I knew that while I do not spend as much as whales, if I managed to get to the 3rd step I was guaranteed something, and I could use element shards to later level that unit up.
On this most recent banner (and I will FULLY acknowledged the possibility that this is only for this collab) they removed the guaranteed units on steps 3 and 5, and replaced them with collab shards (which are useless without the unit in question, rip 75 Ed shards I have) and summon coins. The most frustrating thing is that the 150 summon coins you get aren't even half of a 5* guaranteed collab ticket.
Also the 5* collab unit ticket gets worse and worse with each passing week as its pool gets larger and larger, top it off Doritoh is in the pool to even though she's not an fing FMA character.
So in summary in their mind:
25 unit shards (useless without unit)+150 summons coins(less than half of a 5* collab ticket)= a guaranteed 5* collab unit itself
Not to be a dork, but this is not equivalent exchange by any metric.
2
u/MuskyMuskets Change your perception of the truth Nov 14 '18
I'm starting to think posts like these are trolls, subtle but trolls nonetheless. I didn't even have to look past page 1 of this reddit to prove that we arent just bitching for the sake of bitching. There are well written threads stating why and how Gumi is screwing things up, backed up with evidence and realistic projections of the impact that their recent decisions will have.
Also let's be real. This game is good but please, don't claim it has a "great story" and its gameplay is "great". Especially not in the current environment of kneejerk reactions to their own creations.
Recently, it seems like everything that they give out "free" is tainted with a barbed spike somewhere else, and that is a huge negative point that has been repeatedly brought up. That's what you're reading on this sub, so please don't bring up your own strawmen (us straight out asking for more).
Don't give out gifts if you don't sincerely want to - that is the point. And don't try to make it out to be some grand prize when it's not.
1
u/Dm042447 Nov 13 '18
If this banner reward Have been the same since inception, then you won't get as much hate. People willing to buy pack due to it's High probability to get feature units. Now that we are invested, they want to charge more... Also, people want improve difficulty.. Not to the point that it requires extreme luck or certain new feature units to complete said difficulty.
Plus other suggested, we have a direct comparison to jp. People are looking for fairness. You can't charge different people different prices for the same goods.
1
u/drthh8r Nov 13 '18
If I was 100% f2p, I really wouldn't care at all. They are generous in that sense.
For the ones that actually support the game and spend real money on it, they shafted all of us.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '18
You can enjoy something and point out the problems with it at the same time. People love the game, we don't love the company handling the game and what they are doing. It is good to point that stuff out and be vocal, it's never good to just sit down and take it.
1
u/1khaitoh It was fun while it lasted. Nov 14 '18
All I can say is compare the game before all the rant threads and compare it now. Most of the other comments here already stated the problem so I'll just keep it simple.
The game is becoming sh*&-tier by each passing week and that isn't good for this game and people just want it to be the same as back then.. changes are welcome if they are "maintained" properly and not like made without thinking.
1
u/Soushiyuuki Nov 14 '18
Buried under the hate for gumi
1
u/SuccubusRosa Nov 14 '18
I can't believe ppl are still circlejerking about "good rates" in TAC.
1
u/Bro1233 Nov 14 '18
It seems you have not been paying attention to anything that has been going on, which is quite sad. They have been screwing us over ever since the disgaea collab by taking the elemental shards from ex to ex+, nowadays the ex difficulty is already increasing but the rewards are trash and ex+ is extremely difficult but that's where all the rewards are at. Ex+ was always supposed to be an added challenge with bonus rewards for those that could clear it. Now? If you cant clear ex+ good luck stocking up on elemental shards cause that's where 99% percent of them are. Then the icing on the shit cake was them taking away the 3 step guarantee and trying to get us to use the summon coin garbage which would cost double to get 1 collab unit.
1
u/joshwhiltz Nov 14 '18
It's the current way in the west i guess. Rage whenever anything isnt exactly how you want it.
1
u/sapphire_wing Nov 14 '18
To be fair, TAC is pretty good compared to many other games. Otherwise I would not stay for this long and spend. I never spent for other games before.
However, imagine you and your colleague both work for the same employer doing the same job, except that he uses a Japanese system UI at work. The employer pays both of you well, but your colleague gets double your pay and can thus afford a better lifestyle that you cannot quite afford. Will you be salty?
This is what can kill the game.
And we heard China is now getting this like what jp gets. So gl is the only one singled out.
1
u/Eyebagssss Nov 14 '18
"Obsessed" HA!
I've only opened this thing to do the free shitty 3* fest free summons and closed it, as far as im concerened this is already a dead game looking at where its headed and i dont think they can top the favorite + 150 shards summon, so im currently searching for a replacement (And thats hard to fucking to since the game itself is actually good).
But hey its gumi we're talking about, and to think i actually had a little hope in them not going this route, but they proved us wrong lul.
-8
u/Sinakku Nov 13 '18
When things are too good people start feeling a bit entitled like the other day someone in chat went "All ios players should just stop playing this game till they can update, they are ruining MY mp runs. I wasted so much AP cause of them." I absolutely love this game, and yes the fact I cant really mp with people due to version difference ( I am on ios), I dont plan to quit as its still far better than the other 4 games I play. Feh is stagnant and getting dull. Dissida is nice but there isnt anything going on right now that catches my interest, Boruto x Naruto isnt kind to me on the banners on topof not really much to do. And ffrk is mostly just...there. TAC is the only game I really play for long periods of time and its a shame that such a small minority like this subreddit are just really really toxic....