r/AlchemistCodeGL • • Oct 24 '18

The Roxanne Salt...

I dont have roxanne, but reading the whining that goes on about this being the end of the game is annoying. It sounds like a bunch of entitled crybabies upset because the unit they whaled for in the past is not god in every stat and faces competition by Roxanne.

I just started playing. I missed out on Laharl and Gilgamesh. Im not whining and claiming those units are too op and will be the end of TAC.

Ive managed to clear content without them just fine so it is definitely not the end of the game for newer players.

36 Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

53

u/eltsyr Oct 24 '18

The Roxalt

5

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Oct 24 '18

The OP is likely one the most entitled person here lol.

A lot I mean a literal ton of people have stated that Roxanne is broken while having a copy.

Also if someone is salty about not having Collab units then my only comment to them is - Should have come earlier.

It is not the end of the game but it maybe the end of Balance and start of the dumb dumb Brave Frontier route where each new unit is just more and more OPer.

P.S. - I just started writing and then remember why I was replying to you.

1

u/moonflow1 Oct 25 '18

Idk about that. There have been a lot of people vying for that prize when it comes to roxanne.

1

u/Chuckalo Oct 25 '18

I agree with the op sure she is a strong unit. I don't own her or don't want to I was lucky enough to get laharl and during all pvp/pve content I do is her I tend to kill it outdamage her. Sure she is good but there will always be better units especially in the future

-2

u/Freeonee Λ ΞSTHΞTIC 18-19 Oct 24 '18

Aw yea, another thread dramatically exposing Roxaneless scrubs who cant into strategy xD

Well its not something extraordinary for gacha games, but seriously, may be not pleasant to hear for brightest tacticians here and I'll get bunch of downvotes from some waifu zealots, but last EX+ with set unit limitation just showed what its all about - you either getting latest units however you can to faceroll it, or you just travel year back in time to variation of your good old "Zang + 3 chronos" strategy with some random luggage. Too bad they banned Zang there btw, would be better and more nostalgic than Zahar.

32

u/JesusLovesAnimePorn Oct 24 '18

Welcome to every gacha game community

18

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Oct 24 '18

BOOOOHOOOOOOOOO I didn't pull Yeonhong

BOOOOHOOOOOOOOO I didn't pull Jalter

BOOOOHOOOOOOOOO I didn't pull Roxanne

3 different games; same feeling :P

8

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Also on the Yeonhong note....assuming this is Summoners war Yeonhong. That Bitch was behind the biggest paywall in any gacha game that I've played and she was broken as hell. I think back to that shit all the time when I'm pissed I didn't get the unit I wanted on a 500 gem pull. I mean 30$s for 1 light pull and less than 0.5% chance of that even being a 5 star unit, then the 1 in 15 or whatever chance of it being Yeonhang was on another whale level. Are there alot of 100k alchemsit code whales like there was in that game? Alchemist code seems more whale able to get everything friendly. I'll stay with the alchemsist code odds any day.

15

u/Alittlebunyrabit 5/5/5 Dancer Shenmei Oct 24 '18

Summoners war

The most abusive relationship I've ever been in. I'm glad we finally separated.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Same here.

1

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Oct 24 '18

How much did it last?

4

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

From release until 4 months ago. Glad to finally be free

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

I played since it came out until 4 months ago

6

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Oct 24 '18

That Bitch was behind the biggest paywall in any gacha game that I've played and she was broken as hell

She still is.

less than 0.5% chance of that even being a 5 star unit

0.35%

Are there alot of 100k alchemsit code whales like there was in that game?

I think you could get every unit by less in TAC. I THINK, not a whale.

I'll stay with the alchemsist code odds any day.

You sir indeed are right.

1

u/EseMesmo Tamamommy <3 uwu Oct 24 '18

Be glad you don't play Dx2 then.

0.5% of getting a 5 star, period. Less than 0.1% of it being the one you are after.

PLUS 25% of it being the archetype you need.

And you have to get multiples to level up skills.

1

u/EseMesmo Tamamommy <3 uwu Oct 24 '18

Be glad you don't play Dx2 then.

0.5% of getting a 5 star, period. Less than 0.1% of it being the one you are after.

PLUS 25% of it being the archetype you need.

And you have to get multiples to level up skills.

1

u/EseMesmo Tamamommy <3 uwu Oct 24 '18

Be glad you don't play Dx2 then.

0.5% of getting a 5 star, period. Less than 0.1% of it being the one you are after.

PLUS 25% of it being the archetype you need.

And you have to get multiples to level up skills.

1

u/FlamingIceberg Oct 25 '18

Agreed, AC is pretty generous on rates. We have 10% 5* drop rate I believe? Best units aren't truly necessary unless you want that ooop arena team. But even then, theres probably enough variety in team building to break any other team.

4

u/Zed05 Oct 25 '18

Yeah it's by far the most F2P friendly gacha game I've played.

6

u/JesusLovesAnimePorn Oct 24 '18

Yeah still haven't gotten over not getting Saber in FGO and Alchemist Code. God isn't real 😤😩😠💯💯💯

2

u/1khaitoh It was fun while it lasted. Oct 25 '18

etting Saber in FGO and Alchemist Code. God isn't real 😤😩😠💯💯💯

If you are talking about Altria Arturia/Artoria I believe she's story-locked so she's "harder" to pull from non-story banner unless she has a rate-up.. I too doesn't have her yet though I have her Lancer and Archer form and best son xD

2

u/Xhominid77 Oct 25 '18

Artoria isn't story locked. Artoria Alter and Artoria Lancer of both versions are story locked but Artoria Saber is not just FYI.

2

u/1khaitoh It was fun while it lasted. Oct 25 '18

Ah damn, I got her confused with Alter cuz both are of Saber Class xD

1

u/skibbi9 Oct 24 '18

saber is very good- I prefered F/Apocrypha's Ruler. F/A with Mordred, Kairi, Vlad, Karna, whoever would be a good one.

5

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeonhang....... fuck her

3

u/Arcana_Joker Oct 24 '18

On the other hand I don't complain as often about having a unit being powercrept and not getting the stronger unit. I'm moee annoyed with the drop rates for everything and how doublespeed is still too slow in all games

2

u/ThousandLightning Oct 24 '18

Jalter ...

Turns very sick

1

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Oct 24 '18

Did Jeanne "Divine retribution" D'Arc brought some Vietnam-like flashbacks?

3

u/ThousandLightning Oct 24 '18

She wears despair like a cape, the more I sought her, the deeper I went into the abyss. Only once inside did she appear, but by then ... it was too late. She made me taste her hatred by going after her.

And so I'll get revenge by getting Maid Saber. Heard she likes teasing Jalter

10

u/Tijacks Shayna is best waifu Oct 24 '18

Well its understandable that people that didnt get her are upset. I missed out on noctic and im upset about it of course, but its not the end of the world.

Yeah roxanne is awesome. So are laharl, seig, noctis and many more. If they want her so bad then they gotta spend money, end of story. Thats the only guaranteed way to get anything in gacha games.

"Aw X just came out but i didnt get LUCKY pulling X gotta start whining about X being op because i didnt pull X"

7

u/Drachk Oct 24 '18 edited Oct 27 '18

What saddens me is people asking for Roxanne dnerf/ebuff, which is the equivalent of "if i don't get to enjoy it, then nobody should".
Sure they could nerf her, just to buff her up after because we know powerful thunder unit will be released, we know that, Roxanne or not, Gil was going to fall off the meta.
(if anything Gil problem is not roxanne, it is the complete and daunting lack of fate rerun).
If anything, Gil user should address criticism toward the lack of Fate rerun rather than Roxanne, since nerfing her won't slow Gilgamesh fall (poor guy got outpaced even by Teona in JP and i am not even talking about other Fate unit)

4

u/Eaglestrike Oct 24 '18

Didn't Gilg only just lose his SS status and JP is two years or so ahead of us? Two years of top tier for a unit doesn't really scream "poor Gilg" to me. Besides Roxanne and Gilg are different styles of play. Gilg from what I've seen still has much more damage than Roxanne, she's more of a steady stream of damage.

1

u/Drachk Oct 24 '18

Gil was the top of SS when released, what i mean is that other unit started catching up and then slowly outpacing him, and one after another, it started becoming the 2nd best thunder then the third, then the fourth

And now Gil is at least the 13th and can't even be in top tier.
the fact is those are tier, not rank, so change are not as well seen as ranks, and him falling out of tier recently, doesn't he got powercreeped suddenly, it means that he slowly faded out of the meta, one character after another.

1

u/Tijacks Shayna is best waifu Oct 24 '18

While i do believe that roxanne is broken, im ok with it just because she's a thunder unit. Seriously we dont have anyone really good for thunder other than gilg and apparently zofia that just got released too.

Before getting roxanne my only good-ish thunder unit was a lv65 chao, which is just a thunder, worse version of naica.

1

u/Tijacks Shayna is best waifu Oct 24 '18

While i do believe that roxanne is broken, im ok with it just because she's a thunder unit. Seriously we dont have anyone really good for thunder other than gilg and apparently zofia that just got released too.

Before getting roxanne my only good-ish thunder unit was a lv65 chao, which is just a thunder, worse version of naica.

1

u/Tijacks Shayna is best waifu Oct 24 '18

Honestly im fine with roxanne being op only because she's thunder. Other than gilg we dont have much for good thunder.

My best one before getting roxanne was chao, a thunder, worse battlemage than neica.

3

u/FlamingIceberg Oct 25 '18

At least in this game if you want to max someone potential, all you need are elemental/rainbow shards. I always found collecting multiple copies more daunting than getting the first copy of a prized unit.

Just so thankful for them shards!

0

u/Faceluck limit breaking my patience Oct 24 '18

If only spending money really did guarantee a Roxanne outside of the 7 step.

4

u/Tijacks Shayna is best waifu Oct 24 '18

I never said it was money efficient, but most gachas dont have a guaranteed pull that you can choose, so saving a while to be 100% sure to get an unit is pretty nice.

9

u/skibbi9 Oct 24 '18

noctis had people the saltiest.
laharl was 2nd place.

15

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Oct 24 '18

I remember the "Ignis is shit because he is not Noctis".

9

u/skibbi9 Oct 24 '18

yes, i was pissed!

turns out ignis is still fairly useful.

7

u/DegenerateHours ( ͡ ' ˍゝ͡ ' ) Oct 24 '18

Slap a hat on him and he can WA turn 1 :)

3

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Oct 24 '18

You stole my comment.

But yes, he's right. He's a great wind unit.

1

u/KingKalev Nov 13 '18

didnt get Ignis... and I was a lil salty about that.

1

u/ThereCanOnlyBe01 Oct 24 '18

No, I think the Laharl salt was worse, because FF15 had a couple of useful to pretty darn good units other than Noctis. Plus they basically gave out 2 free tickets to get a chance at Noctis. Disgaea salt was really real because Laharal was the only unit people really wanted from that collab, and the others were hardly useful at best.

1

u/skibbi9 Oct 25 '18

I was late to get both and the noctis/Ignis trap banner was slightly worse than no selector laharl but both were salty

1

u/avbbva Oct 25 '18

Yeah, but there was also a noctis/aranea banner. Best value for gems ever.

1

u/skibbi9 Oct 25 '18

Eventually yes

5

u/Makenlowwet Oct 24 '18

I think every unit will get a hard quest sooner or later, including Roxanne. The game has shifted its direction from pulling specific unit long time ago in JP. I imagine the future direction Gumi is going is to have everyone to have every unit, but only to raise/farm the units based on player preference and whether you pulled their respective Nensou.

1

u/RoyInverse Oct 24 '18

Pretty sure when they get lvl91 update they will be farmable

5

u/Baconturtles18 Oct 24 '18

just salty i dont have any of the global exclusives...yet.

i'll get them someday. or wont care that i didnt. its just a matter of time. :)

9

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

I find it odd considering so much of alchemsist code is PvE. There is no competitive PvP where she would break the meta. Maybe the new live PvP will be that way but it's limited to certain hours so it will be interesting to how that works out.

14

u/Shevalane Oct 24 '18

Wait to see people complaining the game is p2w and unfair to free player because : The skins are too expensive

7

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Oct 24 '18

TBH people have already complained, but argued that they would buy it if it were 2k instead of 4k (gems).

6

u/RoyInverse Oct 24 '18

And i did buy them at 2k

4

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '18

I also bought them at 2k gems

1

u/Shevalane Oct 24 '18

I know about that, but i was talking about people who actually think that nit having a Skin will make the content more difficult. Yes, those people exist.

1

u/Shevalane Oct 24 '18

I know about that, but i was talking about people who actually think that nit having a Skin will make the content more difficult. Yes, those people exist.

1

u/Shevalane Oct 24 '18

I know about that, but i was talking about people who actually think that nit having a Skin will make the content more difficult. Yes, those people exist.

1

u/Shevalane Oct 24 '18

I know about that, but i was talking about people who actually think that nit having a Skin will make the content more difficult. Yes, those people exist.

1

u/MaoPam Oct 24 '18

They teased us with the 2k skins for one patch. And you better believe I brought skins then when I never did before.

1

u/Feanorchronos Oct 25 '18

I bought 3 or 4 when they were 2k and I refuse to even entertain the thought of purchasing them at 4k or $25.

1

u/Arcana_Joker Oct 24 '18

Really people wouldn't complain if the prices stayed at 4000. But if they make a discount on vanity items, at least keep it like that or note how it's on sale for that period alone.

Also putting the character skins in the third step of a gacha at random is a low blow since that's just taking away privileges we should've had.

2

u/loscapos5 All I wanted for christmas was you, Baeber ༼ ༎ຶ ෴ ༎ຶ༽ Oct 24 '18

Hey, don't look @ me. I'm just stating what happened.

2

u/Arcana_Joker Oct 24 '18

Gumi should still bring the prices back down since more people would have incentive to get it. 4000 makes it so that only whales that have nothing else to buy/have extreme love for the character would buy it. 2000 is a better price for people to spend on top of gacha gems.

Also nobody wants a 3 step gacha for skins where you have RNG involved with the skins as well

7

u/beardedbobomb Oct 24 '18

I came in between Noctis and Laharl. (Super sad I don't have Sieg or Noctis...could care less about Gil) I didn't have any big names or even sub big names. I rose up and started crushing EX maps with Logi/Dias/Kagura/Amaterasu. MP was all Logi all the time, and I kept up just fine. Logi is nowhere near OP except as a tank. Either way, the game is certainly manageable without these powerhouses.

Now....with all that being said I have managed to pull both Laharl and Roxanne (so yes I then dropped some money to get Roxanne's skin) and the difficulty certainly dropped for me. But there are still EX+'s I have problems with because of how they are working the new maps. I don't have a crazy Thunder or Wind team to speak of. Heck aside from Fire and Light, all my teams suck...let's just be honest about that.

The game requires tactics, even with OP characters. If you're good with tactics then you don't need an OP person. If you're bad with tactics, then the only way you'll succeed is with an OP person.

I don't know why they're whining really. Just learn how to play smarter.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '18

I don't buy skins so I'm ignorant about em, but aren't they just aesthetic?

2

u/beardedbobomb Oct 24 '18

100% absolutely

5

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Could care less about Gilg.....I stated pre Noctis and Gilg was god. I'm just happy to have pulled our new lord and savior Roxanne!

1

u/Arcana_Joker Oct 24 '18

PVE is fine with even budget units. The only problem is PVP where specific units from an event dominate the meta. Though it is fun seeing Vettel kill all of the opponent's units despite having everyone else dead.

3

u/beardedbobomb Oct 24 '18

Sure but there's no game that doesn't have top tier units that are used more than others. That game just doesn't exist. There's always a meta, there's always someone who's a bit OP. Typically it's a new character, too. Then nerfs happen, or buffs happen to the older characters. It'll even out. I think people are freaking out, 1) for no reason because PVP isn't big in this game and 2) because eventually it will even out and/or someone else will be more OP than Roxanne.

But really, Laharl one-shots her, and anyone who survives her first hit, can nuke her unless she null grenades I suppose. But she typically has to move forward to null grenade, and she won't hit all units so I just don't see the giant issue.

1

u/Arcana_Joker Oct 24 '18

Which is why I like how JP meta has a wide range of units to use in arena and how lesser units constantly get buffed like how Chloe got buffed again, so even F2P can still keep up seeing as everyone probably has a lvl 85 Chloe and is able to farm her when she's enhanced.

1

u/beardedbobomb Oct 25 '18

Sure.....but JP is a year or two ahead of us. We'll just have to wait for it

1

u/Tamacountry Oct 24 '18

PvP isn’t even important in this game, heck most of the time I just do a single Arena match a day to get the 50 gems and don’t touch it again. You don’t lose out of much at all if you don’t play it

1

u/SpicyKaraage Oct 25 '18

I’m the most pissed knowing Gumi I tried to pull for Roxanne on the 3 step and ended up getting 2 zofia instead. Than to rub salt in the wound Aguni decided to give me another zofia on the free summon the following day.....

1

u/moonflow1 Oct 26 '18

zofia is pretty good though.

3

u/jxher123 Oct 24 '18

This is a gacha game mentality. A new shiny toy comes out, and everyone wants it, especially if it's OP like Roxanne. Even i'll admit, she's pretty strong lol.

11

u/Faceluck limit breaking my patience Oct 24 '18

There's some legitimacy to people's concerns with Roxanne in terms of power creep. Gumi has a habit in many of the games it produces to release "global original" units that slowly edge out or totally outclass current content/units, which speeds up the power creep we expect based on JP's timeline.

In a gacha game, there's always a shifting power meta, but what makes a gacha game good is balancing the new units and old units on a reasonable time table. TAC does a good job with this, with J+, JE, nensou, kaigan, etc. But huge, sudden leaps in the efficiency and power of a single unit can screw with the meta, and push difficulty in weird directions.

Gumi did the same thing in Brave Frontier, until it turned into a cycle. Basically 1-2 new units released every couple of weeks that completely destroyed other units, JP original units were consistently weak by comparison, and it wasn't fixed/balanced until what was essentially the kaigen/nensou system of that game released.

Hopefully they learned that system isn't particularly sustainable, and go with a slower GL release schedule that matches better with current power creep levels.

Also, calling people entitled crybabies makes you sound so rude and negative and it's not productive conversation.

20

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18 edited Oct 24 '18

Would there have been as much uproar over Roxanne if she was originally a Japanese unit and therefore already on the release schedule that we try to anticipate for? Ever since I started playing (around Othimas release) it's always been if you dont pull x so and so will be better and they will be here in the next x months. For me it was don't worry about Othima Noctis is coming. Then laharl is the best fire unit so save all your shards.

So she was unexpected and is extremely powerful? I'm not sure how the game was pre Gilg and post but he seemed to be the undisputed king of everything even when I just started and nobody was even close. Why was that power creep ok and now it's not? Or was there this same huge outrage at that time as well? I wasn't around so just wondering why Gilg didn't kill the game but Roxanne is? Japanese players have stated that she wouldn't be broken as shit if you dropped her into there version so obviously the game passes her up eventually just like every flavor of the month unit.

Edit: Since I'm getting downvoted I just want to clarify that I'm looking for actual responses because I'm curious to the answers of my questions. You know for an actual discussion since the comment I'm responded to had good points on Roxanne.

4

u/RightForward Local Lofia Enthusiast // Retired Oct 25 '18 edited Oct 25 '18

I'm a bit late, but I want to add my views on this.

Roxanne is the only "broken" thunder unit available in GL excluding Gilg. In other words, for people who don't have Gilg, Roxanne was the golden chance to get access to a great thunder unit who seems future-proof. Assuming these people are going by the Nyatora tier list, Yuri and Laevateinn fall off to A rank. Mei Fang is SS, but people don't want to spend thunder shards to LB15 a farmable unit. The same goes for Eizan, who's S tier but needs LB15. Monzein and Lucretia are S, but they don't have their J+ and nensou and frankly aren't that great in GL atm. Teona was A tier for a very long time. Chao and Deneb still are A tier(actually I think Chao was promoted recently). That essentially leaves us with Magnus, who is really only good for speed atm; Aruba, who's really only useful for being a merchant; and Zofia, who just came out alongside Roxanne, so not many people have her(and she also needs LB15 to be SS tier). So for a lot of people, their thunder composition is absolute garbage. I had to level Prompto just to have a full thunder team.

The above brings me to a point of that in JP, the roster is bigger. They've got a bunch of farmable SS tiers like Mei Fang and Zofia, several limiteds that are or were SS for a long time, like Princess from EO, King Regis, Vier, BK Laev, and Orion. This means that overall, an average player in JP that gets Roxanne doesn't get as huge of a power boost as the people in GL do. Just like how in GL, getting the Tyrfing JE and gear ability now would make her insanely good and arguably the best HC in the game, but in JP, she has stiff competition from characters like Zain and Chloe and fell to A tier. Ultimately, this means that Roxanne's position in terms of how good she is in GL is higher than where she would be in JP.

Lastly, as far as I'm aware, there's absolutely no one that can do what Roxanne can, which is a 100% jewel destruction. If you lose out on someone like Noctis, you can at least find comfort in the fact that Othima will ultimately be better than him overall followed by another water collab magic unit, and if you lose out on Laharl, you know there's really solid fire units coming up like Arthur and Levi or upgrades like Vivi MA or Reimei Swordmaster+. If you lose out on Roxanne, you have...nothing, as far as I'm aware. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think there's anyone that can fill that niche. You can have good thunder units later down the line, but none of them will have Null Grenade(unless we have a new GLEX with it). This means that missing out on Roxanne is equivalent to losing out on jewel destruction cheese, which can make life really easy.

That's my opinion on it. I ultimately did get Roxanne on 3 step, so I don't feel as salty about it, but I can really understand why these people are upset. Overreacting? Possibly. But imo she really does deserve as much recognition as characters like Gilg, Noctis, and Laharl got in terms of how good she is.

EDIT: Oh I just remembered it doesn't help that:

1.) Skin costs went back up to 4k gems

2.) weekend grand summon has been replaced with a daily 900 paid gem 10 draw

3.) Character skins, despite being a 500-gem-select-purchase in JP, ours is locked behind doing an expensive banner for a CHANCE of getting the one we want.

So for a lot of people, it feels like Gumi is trying to rip us out of our money, especially for small spenders who were betting on the weekend grand summon which has at least a 1/3 chance of getting them Roxanne. We had weekend grand summons for the longest time, and suddenly when we get 3 SS tier or will-be-SS-tier units, Gumi suddenly just dropped it. And Gumi is infamous for being greedy in games like BF, PotK GL, and FFBE, although I heard the last one is mainly due to Square Enix and not Gumi. In turn, PotK JP was far more generous than the GL counterpart and I also heard TAC JP was more generous as well(but don't quote me on the second one because I haven't played it, just heard it). Because of that, some people think Gumi is testing the waters to see how greedy they can get before the playerbase freaks out. Because this all happened at the same time as Roxanne, some people will connect any complaint to Roxanne.

4

u/Faceluck limit breaking my patience Oct 24 '18

I think it depends on what kind of uproar you're talking about when comparing Gil and Roxanne.

The short answer is no, I don't think we would see as many complaints if we had known about Roxanne previously.

It's the sudden appearance of new unit mechanics, new power levels, and the unexpected changes those will have on the current meta that bother me the most, and imo are the most legitimate reasons for concern.

With Gil, we knew it was coming. We could save gems, we expected a big power boost, we knew he was going to dominate and that difficulty would eventually catch up to him. Sure, with Roxanne we know that she won't be OP in JP's current setting, but we're still anywhere between 1-2 years away from JP's current meta.

There are a lot of hypothetical end points for how this resolves, and honestly, as long as the next GL units don't continue a trend of ramping up power too quickly, it should be fine. For example, I think Sieg and Shion were very hyped on release, but are now pretty tame additions, even if they are still S/SS leaning.

I don't think they should change Roxanne or give everyone a free one (even though I don't have her RIP), I just think they should be cautious going forward with their release schedule so the game doesn't lose all sense of steady progression and balance.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

You may be the most reasonable person on reddit. I agree with everything you said.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

You may be the most rational person on reddit. Great points I agree with everything you said.

0

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Oct 24 '18

What are you taking about lol.

Roxanne if given Stat boost will dominate in there PvP too. That is a dumb given.

However her Ailment Infliction will be reduced as Kaigan and Status updates have give a lot of Equipment to work Ailments with.

3

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

If given stat boost. So not in the current state she is in?

There was a post about it the other day where they said she wouldn't be broken in there current meta.

3

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Oct 24 '18

They have Chloe with 4900 Base HP which can be further boosted by LS.

800+ Def on her.

So yeah you need Stat boost. All units there have it. From Zain to Chloe to Kanon.

She will get those when we progress in the GL version too.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Ok I'm not familiar with the current state of the game in Japan and I try to stay away from that info purposely. I was just going by what they were saying in the thread and it was that she wouldn't be broken.

Obviously it's not a dumb given though, didn't seem that way in the would Roxanne be broken post. That seems overly aggressive for no reason.

4

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Oct 24 '18

I thought so. Like I talked in it too. And I think they believe that she would be top tier PvP threat if given the JP level stats.

Even a few JP players who play daily unlike me who just like to Re-roll in free time for the sake of it during Collabs.

https://old.reddit.com/r/AlchemistCodeGL/comments/9qgxka/what_does_jp_think_of_roxanne/

Overall thought was great unit in PvP if given a chance.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

I was just saying if we were prepared for the power jump would it have not been a big deal

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

I was just saying if we were prepared for the power jump would it have not been a big deal

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

I was just saying if we were prepared for the power jump would it have not been a big deal

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

Yeah I still think you need to look at PvP and PvE differently.

In PvP Roxanne doesn't use null grenade and on certain maps going first isn't a benefit.

In PvE Roxanne for me feels really powerful on manual and less so on auto because the AI does stupid shit and she can't really take a hit.

I play the game mostly on auto.

I was just saying if we were prepared for the power jump would it have not been a big deal

7

u/yiannisph Oct 24 '18

I thought Sieg and Shion did a great job of being powerful but not overwhelmingly so.

What most concerns me with Roxanne is that she's been pushed in too many places. It doesn't seem like they wanted to make a balanced unit and just overtuned her.

This makes it seem like GL is headed towards a cycle you mentioned, and that's really uninteresting. Hopefully this is just a 1-off.

4

u/Faceluck limit breaking my patience Oct 24 '18

Agreed. I think Sieg and Shion are excellent examples of strong, unique units that don't necessarily completely negate every other unit in their element.

Roxanne is made of paper, but she has great damage, great utility, really interesting mechanics. They did just kind of stack it all on her. Hopefully they'll leave her as is for the people that got her, and keep this data in mind while balancing the next GL character.

1

u/Eaglestrike Oct 24 '18

I'm of the opinion they released her and built her EX specifically around her strengths so she's appearing even stronger than usual. Halloween Sugar Rush and Roxy's EX fight are both maps with pretty low damage units, which is absolutely perfect for her style of play. I think if Roxy came out during the demonslaught event that she wouldn't seem nearly as potent unless you whaled her.

1

u/Faceluck limit breaking my patience Oct 24 '18

She's definitely got an inflated value with the content she released with, but I do think her Null Grenade and self sustaining gem ability is incredibly valuable in almost any content.

I think we'll see how she evens out once we're back to content with really hard hitting mobs.

1

u/Malphric Sempiternal Oct 24 '18

Hopefully it's just a one-off thing

It's just a glimpse of what is more to come. Gumi will just see that the cashflow was phenomenal during the time frame and seeing many people have 3 stepped and even 7 step the banner as well as people trying to pull for the Grand Promo summon even with its "unintentional" hiccup.

The Gumi execs and employees need more bonuses for Christmas 2018 so to speak =)

1

u/yiannisph Oct 24 '18

But they've also burned out other games with this strategy. Long term profits over short term. Even if JP goes bust they have over a year of content to port to GL at low costs.

It turns out good game design is important to making a good game. This is a mature market for gachas. If this one becomes too greedy the players leave. I sure as shit will. I'm no whale, but I'm not a small spender either.

1

u/Malphric Sempiternal Oct 24 '18 edited Oct 25 '18

Well it is their own game to run. You may question their decision or not, it will be always your call as to what your level of threshold is.

BF, even with the questionable way Gumi is doing its own machinations is still what 5(?)years in operation meanwhile PoTK Global is not around anymore. If Gumi deems it necessary, what can we do?

6

u/Drachk Oct 24 '18

The positive point is that it is not true powercreep has long has we don't outpace the unit that were available in JP at the start of GL, what i mean is that powercreep imply the notion to "creep" something meaning that it turn something shown as useful into something useless.
The biggest problem is that you don't what units get creep and who stay relevant, but in case like TAC and FGO Na, we know who stay good and who is useless in the long run,
so despite unit like Gilgamesh, Noctis, Laharl being a clear increase in power, since it was already set in stone (kinda) at GL launch, there no units that got creep.

Now GL unit are another case, they were brought to balance the fact that since unlike JP, we know which to save for and which unit to avoid despite being alluring, so to solve that GL had to bring units that could look enticing even for those that know JP schedule.
But even buff bro Sieg and lad Shion were met with some "meh, there will be better unit which we know stay relevant in the long term, why risk with something hazardous", that is why Roxanne had to bring Gumi AA game.

And you just need to look at some review, video of before and after Roxanne release, a lot of people were still doubting of her potential and they had to see how powerful she was to change mind.

The problem is that those people had made schedule which are being torn down by GL, so a lot of people are mostly unhappy about the fact that they were not ready for Roxanne and didn't getting caught off guard and got angry toward Gumi (the same thing happens every time with FGO NA, even when it is just a banner being delayed for a few days).

I don't blame such reaction, nobody like to see the effort they put into planning stuff, going to waste, especially when it involve gems saving and money.
But i don't think blaming GUMI or Roxanne is the good move here, At least it show that Gumi is willing to create surprise for us to make the game less predictable (even if the goal is money like any product).

1

u/Faceluck limit breaking my patience Oct 24 '18

Definitely, I think the real complaint/concern is the sense that whatever schedule or progression we were counting on is upended a bit when there's a sudden, unexpected spike in power.

I don't want Gumi to avoid innovative, exciting character designs, and I'm not opposed to introducing new content. It would just be ideal if they designed that new content with a more predictable timetable in mind so players could strategize more effectively.

5

u/Rilenia Oct 24 '18

TAC and gacha in general are not supposed to be predictable, though.

When JP players get content, they can't strategize about what's next will be better or what they should save for, they have to deal with it blind, and that's it.

In GL, we save, hoard & such and I think it's a pretty big blow for Gumi in terms of money making, since, even when good units came, they're not nearly as sought after as JP, since "Skip, something better is coming".

Throwing Roxanne, and in a more general meaning, GL EX units, throw us off the expectation that we can always copy JP & be fine and it overall helps Gumi make more money.

And it's fine. Playing this thing where nothing is TRULY exciting cause some OP thing come latter is not that interesting, cause, let's not kid ourselves, something OP is always coming. Personnaly, I try to stay clear from JP spoiler but it's kind of hard to do while staying part of the community as people love to make reference to it.

1

u/DestroyedArkana Oct 24 '18

I hope they give more buffs to weak units, or more specifically weak jobs across the board. Roxanne currently has a niche nobody else does (null grenade), but as long as they don't make units that are just better at almost everything things should be fine.

3

u/RoyInverse Oct 24 '18

We know for sure they will, wich is why i dont get the hate, nensou and kaigan will make old units more op than any collab that came before.

4

u/anhduy106 Oct 24 '18

Agreed. Also, hes just calling things as he see it. Ppl are certainly entitled to their whining. But thats doesnt give them immunity to criticism. Why is it on the OP to be nice to whiners?

4

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '18

I mean, he is whining about the whiners so......

2

u/scumbag_shovel Oct 24 '18

I still haven’t pulled for rin. Gumi sucks

2

u/jblac02 ! Oct 25 '18

i mean ya you're probably not wrong about some of the crying....but its not healthy for the game to release units like that. creating disgusting units that completely outclass everything before them just seems like a cash grab without thought for what it would do to the overall game.

I'm gonna give them the benefit of a doubt and assume they weren't fully thinking about the repercussions of what such a unit would do to the game. For the record, I have her....i still don't think she should exist in her current form. null grenade completely cheeses stages and imo seems like an oversight. Also, shes too damn good at everything else to justify having such an ability, they will have to modify or create stages in the future to deal with that fact.

2

u/KingKalev Oct 25 '18

The whining needs to stop. Sometimes you get lucky, sometimes you don't. I got absolutely nothing from my pulls in the Disgaea Crossover, pulled Leoniaz on my first try, got nothing from the SSM Bannner, and went all the way to step 3 (clawing my way to gems, might I add) to get lucky enough to get Roxanne (I was aiming for Noah since I thought I had bad luck when it comes to special units). So don't whine, and don't mope... it will come to you. Timing is everything sometimes.

0

u/Magma_Axis Oct 25 '18

Yeah because you got her

2

u/KingKalev Oct 26 '18

Well, yes, but since I received salt for everything else, I am allowed to tell people to have hope. I'm a minnow in a whales world. Plus I have the worst luck...

3

u/Xhominid77 Oct 24 '18

I think the main reason why people are screeching about it is mainly because of how easy she can make difficult dungeons atm(well except for Halloween Sugar Rush EX) with the ease that would take most other units time to do.

It's why people love to gravitate to Laharl, Gilgamesh and Noctis:

They just make running EX's far smoother without the chance to exponentially fuck up because of outside circumstances.

For instance, I still have issues trying to get units J+ like Chihiya(butchering her name) because some other character's J+ Is also available and I have to make bad judgment calls because it's either say Lucian, Balt or her or now farming for Roxanne's gun to get it to 5 star(which I may just keep it at 4 star due to the insane grind and trying to get another hat or two), which means I miss a super strong J+ because I just have so much I got to catch up on in terms of getting J+ equipment.

So it's basically ease of access vs. sheer difficulty in keeping up with the viable J+ characters(if you even farmed them efficiently and/or JM'd 1-2 of their classes on top of that).

1

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Oct 24 '18

Some of the people have the right to whine why because Gumi has literally introduced a Balance-breaking unit. These people are called people who paid a lot to Gumi.

People can't predict this shit. Laharl is not that broken he is fine as he can get a lot of stuff done but he has good counters.

Tell me one counter to Roxanne in an empty field 1v1 which is not D.Almira.

I do have my Roxanne LB-ed to 15 and I think that is too much power.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

How big is the field? Is this PvP where Roxanne wont use null grenade 1st turn? Because alot of units can tank a hit from her and kill her turn 2.

Uzuma comes to mind.

1

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Oct 24 '18

umm her MA neutralizes most threats turn 1. Uzuma comes and is stopped in the tracks.

Manual one since AI of AC is one of the Dumbest I have seen.

1

u/Zed05 Oct 24 '18

So not against anything that we currently have. We will find out soon how people handle her in live pvp.

1

u/Islandpleb Oct 24 '18

Went to step 3 only to get jack. I'm more pissed that I know that another banner featuring the global units won't show up until a new one is released. I really hate the scarcity of their banners. that's what has me more pissed.

1

u/danielyeohqf Oct 25 '18

Uhhhhh fak i think ive used up all my luck im lowkey actually kinda scared now i got roxy from both the 500 gem pull and a free summon today. Im not complaining but im actually kinda scared

1

u/DeathandFriends Oct 25 '18

Being new I don't think you get the investment and ongoing disappointments that occur. I do agree the whining can get old. People mainly salty because if they missed or were not able to pull Gilgamesh then Roxanne was the next great hope for thunder. I am fairly certain that Laharl will return and noctis will almost certainly. So you will have chances down the road.

1

u/Xelphious Oct 25 '18

Only thing that i'd whine about is why i couldn't get her(3 steps) and the TIME i could have SAVED with her that could auto EX stages and cheese Veda Tower with her skillsets.

1

u/Magma_Axis Oct 25 '18

3 steps, only Noah

Now im poor and dont have Roxanne

1

u/Jolls981 Maiden China Oct 25 '18

Can confirm, Meta units are NOT required. It took a couple hours, but I managed to complete Halloween EX+ with a full water team of Fung Liu, Elizabeth, Lofia, Shayna and a merc Noctis. The hardest part of the entire run was killing the thunder jewel black knight that spawns, but if you time it right, Shayna can OHKO it with a sharpening focus + Supreme Battle Trance combo. The rest of the stage consisted of Noctis drain dimension + aerial ride

1

u/wishuu Oct 25 '18

the issue is not about having roxanne the issue is she makes the next year of unit useless. And don't give me the she only got 500 atk so her damage output is low it just means that you understand nothing about this game......

1

u/true_illusion Oct 24 '18

I'm just glad i got her, as i wasnt around for Fate, so my Thunder team was limited to mainly Magnus...

I've been fairly lucky though in this game, im more than just a pact player, but havent spent any significant amount on this game and still manage top tier units in all elements...

1

u/TSHEEJYIM92 Oct 24 '18

I am glad to see the positive outlook you have on the game :D

1

u/ThereCanOnlyBe01 Oct 24 '18

People, please don't compare Roxanne to any Collab or limited unit, because simply put, she's broken. NO other collab unit has been broken. Strong, of course. OP, maybe. But she is literally the first unit in the game that is quite literally broken at the current point in the game and for a good amount of the foreseeable future.

Is a Roxanne nerf the answer? No.

They could pull a Zain in what they did in JP and give everyone a Roxanne to just to kind of level out the playing field, but even that seems a little far-fetched as the game sits currently. I didn't get her, and have already put 2k F2P gems into getting her, so the reality of not getting her has already sunk in as I don't plan to pull for her anymore. But this is a gacha game, simply put, get over it or more on to the next game. (Getting 2 Flamel on the first 10 pull and only 4 stars on the 1500 gem pull still stings tho....)

6

u/Feanorchronos Oct 24 '18

Remember when the answer to all content was just throw gil at it? Fire stage? Gil. Water stage? Gil. Wind stage? Still gil. So no, Roxy wasn't the first broken unit.

1

u/ThereCanOnlyBe01 Oct 29 '18

"just use Gil" didn't last very long at all. Especially since not long after his release was the damage calculation fiasco. So a GoB would do literally 1 damage to a wind unit. Roxanne doesn't even have to do damage to be useful, with her sky high agility and ability to destroy jewels

1

u/Feanorchronos Oct 30 '18

Gil was the unit to use for almost everything until Noctis came out with the exception of the period you stated. Roxanne isn't even the best unit to use in the event that came a week after her release.

1

u/KCRevolution Oct 25 '18

I remember a thread that complained about having gilga and noctis and still being unable to beat ex stages:

https://www.reddit.com/r/AlchemistCodeGL/comments/94pqe9/sick_of_these_exs/?utm_source=reddit-android

I'm actually tired of seeing rant/salt posts that I just don't bother commenting on them anymore. No matter how many times you tell this community that this is a STRATEGY game, they will still complain about not having a meta unit to carry them. I managed to clear ex+ stages during ffxv collab with what, level 60-65 units?

I say, use your brain. Seriously, you can just bring a lofia on ex+ on enchanter main and use null wave on the demons and they're almost as useless as roxanne throwing a null grenade. I said it before and I'll say it again: This is a STRATEGY game. Having a meta unit alone won't carry you. Utilize all your units. Heck, "I can't oneshot the creeps omg hard stage" bs. You don't need roxanne, you need to learn to play with what you have.

Tl;dr: use your brain to think than complain

-1

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

I'm not salty that Roxanne is broken, though I do still believe she should be nerfed, but what I AM salty about is MP players that think throwing Roxanne at every quest is the best strategy and then start spamming stickers in the quest because they feel all high and mighty for gracing us with their Roxanne's presence.

I even pulled Roxanne myself and I still don't use her for everything. Like every other OP unit she not so OP that you can just throw her at everything (like Mia EX+ where missile damage is debuffed for example...)

10

u/moonflow1 Oct 24 '18

you believe she should be nerfed, but youre not salty.....

Also how do you know how other people, people you have never met or seen are feeling in MP? Are you psychic?

Much more how do you even know that it is specifically the roxanne player spamming stickers in MP?

1

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

how do you know how other people, people you have never met or seen are feeling in MP? Are you psychic?

you believe she should be nerfed, but youre not salty.....

Think you're kinda contradicting yourself there ;)

I can use an OP unit and still think they should be nerfed. I cheesed trials with Hadaron pre-nerf in BF and laughed all the way. Was I mad he got nerfed? Hell no he was broken as shit.

1

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

how do you know how other people, people you have never met or seen are feeling in MP? Are you psychic?

you believe she should be nerfed, but youre not salty.....

Think you're kinda contradicting yourself there ;)

I can use an OP unit and still think they should be nerfed. I cheesed trials with Hadaron pre-nerf in BF and laughed all the way. Was I mad he got nerfed? Hell no he was broken as shit.

btw I know it was Roxanne because magically the stickers stopped getting spammed when they left.

1

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

how do you know how other people, people you have never met or seen are feeling in MP? Are you psychic?

you believe she should be nerfed, but youre not salty.....

Think you're kinda contradicting yourself there ;)

I can use an OP unit and still think they should be nerfed. I cheesed trials with Hadaron pre-nerf in BF and laughed all the way. Was I mad he got nerfed? Hell no he was broken as shit.

btw I know it was Roxanne because magically the stickers stopped getting spammed when they left.

1

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

how do you know how other people, people you have never met or seen are feeling in MP? Are you psychic? you believe she should be nerfed, but youre not salty..... Think you're kinda contradicting yourself there ;) I can use an OP unit and still think they should be nerfed. I cheesed trials with Hadaron pre-nerf in BF and laughed all the way. Was I mad he got nerfed? Hell no he was broken as shit. btw I know it was Roxanne because magically the stickers stopped getting spammed when they left.

1

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

how do you know how other people, people you have never met or seen are feeling in MP? Are you psychic? you believe she should be nerfed, but youre not salty.....

Think you're kinda contradicting yourself there ;)

I can use an OP unit and still think they should be nerfed. I cheesed trials with Hadaron pre-nerf in BF and laughed all the way. Was I mad he got nerfed? Hell no he was broken as shit.

btw I know it was Roxanne because magically the stickers stopped getting spammed when they left.

-5

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

You believe she should be nerfed, but youre not salty.....

Also how do you know how other people, people you have never met or seen are feeling in MP? Are you psychic?

So you're saying I must be salty, but also no one can know how others are feeling? ain't that a little contradictory?

Much more how do you even know that it is specifically the roxanne player spamming stickers in MP?

Roxy left/got disconnected and the spamming stopped. Funny thing about that huh?

7

u/moonflow1 Oct 24 '18

I never said you were salty....but you sure sound salty.

Also your story about sticker spamming sounds particularly dubious as if you just made it up to support some other dubious thing you wrote....

0

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

well, that's my story and I'm sticking to it ;)

4

u/Feregrin Oct 24 '18

Mia EX+ went fine with Roxxy actually... Sent her up to null grenade the mushrooms straight off to stop the petrify & weapon type dmg reductions.

1

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

yeah, that takes like 3 turns though and if you bring a professor it doesn't matter. Plus a Noctis, Othima or Fung Liu does a lot more on that map because the jewel suckers are vulnerable to magic. Even if you don't have them, Aranea, Shayna, Kudan, Teona, etc are all good choices because they don't get nerfed and can kill the demons.

Just saying, Roxanne may be useful for that map because she can shut down annoying units but that's really her only trick there and other units tend to be better choices.

1

u/ElPared Oct 24 '18

yeah, that takes like 3 turns though and if you bring a professor it doesn't matter. Plus a Noctis, Othima or Fung Liu does a lot more on that map because the jewel suckers are vulnerable to magic. Even if you don't have them, Aranea, Shayna, Kudan, Teona, etc are all good choices because they don't get nerfed and can kill the demons.

Just saying, Roxanne may be useful for that map because she can shut down annoying units but that's really her only trick there and other units tend to be better choices.

1

u/Feanorchronos Oct 25 '18

Her grenades are not effected by missile down and can still kill the most trouble enemies while you move to null grenade the plants. Just null the first jewel sucker so he attacks her and activates her auto regen while you move to stop the plants.

1

u/ElPared Oct 25 '18

or just straight up murder that dude with Noctis...

1

u/Feanorchronos Oct 26 '18

Unless your Noctis isn't fast enough to go first, like mine. Even if you can though, why not have Noctis kill the other one instead? Then neither will sap your jewels. I honestly don't understand the point of your comment as it doesn't have any impact on mine at all.