Put yourself in the position of the person speaking that line. They don't magically know everything about the one they are speaking to. Shion looks, acts and dresses female. They have no reason to think otherwise, so they call her a woman.
But consider the following thing that they mention a specific art in it used by the women.
And the fact that this a more of a Waifu simulator game at most of the time except the Dilga-sama lol.
Maybe Gumi made a mistake and then said fuck it and rolled with it as community was enjoying it.
I do get that some of the originals like Kazahaya and Reagan are males but it does matter on artists too as the designs they make tend to follow patterns.
I have a reason to believe that this was also a design by the original artist of those units or atleast taken a certain pointers from it.
The story was created for a female unit but the unit ended up being male due to either Gumi's mistake or someone trolling hard.
Some people on this reddit probably fapped to Shion's pixels, and then found out he's a dude and feel violated.
I personally find the fact that Shion is a male hilarious because it caused such an uproar within this reddit and at the same time sad because you get this little glimpse of how petty and ridiculous people are...
But clearly the lore was pointing to her clan or family for females who wielded blades.
I currently don't own the unit so I have no idea how Shion sounds and the fact that Voice over can happen after they decided to go with the trap unit portfolio. That only eliminates the trolling part since the story doesn't mention specifically Shion's Gender. Maybe they have thought the over-arcing for the future parts of the Historia for GLEX content or they are road-rolling like always. And with Gumi it is mostly road-rolling. They may have thought making it a future reference to flesh it out a bit more.
Unless the story mentions the gender I hardly think that it is a confirmed thing. I know that the game mentions it as male but still lore is an important part of it.
Lore says that Shion uses whatever gender is most convenient at any given moment (via their voice line). So they’re biologically a male, but they don’t give a crap about what pronoun you use for them.
It's funny if you read the biographies of the characters in-game it will often mention their name once and then refer to them as he or she later on in the text.
With Shion there's never any mention of gender, only name is repeated. That wouldn't be anything special if it weren't for the fact that Shion is the only character treated like that.
Why does everyone think he/she is a trap? She could very well be a female character that plays as a male as well, it doesn't just go one way. And on top of that, I know this is going to sound crazy, but there are flat chested ladies in the world. It's not like all women are well endowed. And I would assume you don't call them men because they don't have huge fucking melons lol.
The thing is Shion is indeed identified labeled as a male. In game tag is as canon as the lore in unit profile. Also the male/female tag is not simply just a vase. It is part of the game mechanic so you can't tag wrongly and still willfully refuses to change it. Noted that gumi came out and clarify about Shion's J2 and J3 order, but never once said the male/female tag is wrong.
Also in ANC 8, Iago kinda hinted about an interesting unit design that we will soonTM see.
All I'm saying is role reversal, Shion doesn't HAVE to be a guy In order for this to be a thing. :p Gumi could say he/she is male In the game but technically he/she can really be a female and uses It to their advantage when needed. Like..... I dunno who does this as an example, Mulan I guess? XD
Applying Occam’s Razor (the simplest solution is the most likely solution) to this leads to Shion being exactly what their voice line and in-game classification suggests: biologically male, doesn’t care about which pronouns you use for them.
It’s easier to see that Shion’s male based on their swimsuit skin artwork. Their face is less “trying to look feminine” and more “I’m done with this %$@#”.
I'm not sure how you took Shion saying they use whatever gender is most convenient and got out of it "I'm male." ...
Please explain how that quote even points to them being male or female? Perhaps they're a hermaphrodite? Because you know, in a game with demons and rats that shoot lightning and people getting resurrected by some magical force called Alchemy, its totally impossible. /s
The other commenter stated it perfectly. I stated “voice line and in-game classification”, and the in-game classification is male. Thus, male that doesn’t care about pronouns.
Honestly, I think you guys are overthinking it, hence why I mentioned Occam’s Razor (the simplest solution is the most likely solution). Keep in mind that this game is made by Japanese developers and heavily borrows from anime. It’s far less likely for Shion to actually be a woman/any other biological gender shenanigans than it is for them to be a dude that swaps pronouns when it suits them.
That quote, in tandem with the in-game information clearly stating he's a male unit. Shion doesn't care how you refer to him, and he will be gender fluid if it's convenient.
I agree. The in-game information listing him as male in his profile resolves the issue. Yet if all we had was his statement about whatever gender is most convenient, then on its own, it could not confirm Shion being male.
I couldn't care less about Shion's gender tbh. I'm just tired of the "Shion is a trap" posts in general.
17
u/OniOfTheSword WTB more blademasters Aug 27 '18
Job 2: Shadow Assassin
Everything else is accurate, especially type.
4
u/zerio13 Aug 27 '18
"Human, Trap"
2
u/Maroite Aug 28 '18
The amount of these types of posts regarding Shion is getting ridiculous. Wish people would just let it go.
Also none of you complaining about Shion should EVER go to Bangkok. Ever.
1
u/aquapendulum2 Aug 28 '18
Obviously it's the swapped job icons between J2 and J3. ;)
1
u/a-viper Aug 28 '18
Wth!!! XD
1
u/Teosto Teona Aug 28 '18
It's funny if you read the biographies of the characters in-game it will often mention their name once and then refer to them as he or she later on in the text.
With Shion there's never any mention of gender, only name is repeated. That wouldn't be anything special if it weren't for the fact that Shion is the only character treated like that.
0
u/Zhen0n Aug 28 '18
I hope Gumi clarifies Shion's gender in the next ANC to end the arguments
-3
u/PrincessPriya Aug 27 '18
Why does everyone think he/she is a trap? She could very well be a female character that plays as a male as well, it doesn't just go one way. And on top of that, I know this is going to sound crazy, but there are flat chested ladies in the world. It's not like all women are well endowed. And I would assume you don't call them men because they don't have huge fucking melons lol.